Effects of lipid chain length and unsaturation on bicelles stability. A phosphorus NMR study

Morphological control and modern applications of bicelles

Bicellar systems have become popularized as their rich morphology can be applied in biochemistry, physical chemistry, and drug delivery technology. To the biochemical field, bicelles are powerful model membranes for the study of transmembrane protein behavior, membrane transport, and environmental interactions with the cell. Their morphological responses to environmental changes reveal a profound fundamental understanding of physical chemistry related to the principle of self-assembly. Recently, they have also drawn significant attention as theranostic nanocarriers in biopharmaceutical and diagnostic research due to their superior cellular uptake compared to liposomes. It is evident that applications are becoming broader, demanding to understand how the bicelle will form and behave in various environments. To consolidate current works on the bicelle's modern applications, this review will discuss various effects of composition and environmental conditions on the morphology, phase behavior, and stability. Furthermore, various applications such as payload entrapment and polymerization templating are presented to demonstrate their versatility and chemical nature.

Effects of lipid saturation on bicelle to vesicle transition of a binary phospholipid mixture: a molecular dynamics simulation study

Controlling the transition from lipid bicelles to vesicles is essential for producing engineered vesicles. We perform coarse-grained molecular dynamics (CGMD) simulations of unsaturated/saturated lipid mixtures to clarify the effects of lipid unsaturation on vesiculation at the molecular scale. The results demonstrate that vesiculation depends on the concentration of unsaturated lipids and the degree of unsaturation. The probability of vesiculation increases linearly with the apparent unsaturated lipid concentration at a low degree of unsaturation. Higher degrees of unsaturation lead to phase segregation within the binary bicelles, reducing the probability of vesiculation. A comparison between CGMD simulations and the conventional theory of vesiculation shows that the theoretical predictions of binary lipid systems must explicitly include phase segregation effects. Furthermore, simulations with biased lipid distributions reveal that vesiculation is facilitated by the preconcentration of unsaturated lipids in the core region of the bicelle but is then temporally limited as the unsaturated lipids move to the bicelle edges. These findings advance theoretical and experimental studies on binary lipid systems and promote the development of tailor-made vesicles.

Fragmentation of DMPC Membranes by a Wedge-Shaped Amphiphilic Cyclodextrin into Bicellar-like Aggregates

Small bilayer lipid aggregates such as bicelles provide useful isotropic or anisotropic membrane mimetics for structural studies of biological membranes. We have shown previously by deuterium NMR that a wedge-shaped amphiphilic derivative of trimethyl βcyclodextrin anchored in deuterated DMPC-d27 bilayers through a lauryl acyl chain (TrimβMLC) is able to induce magnetic orientation and fragmentation of the multilamellar membranes. The fragmentation process fully detailed in the present paper is observed with 20% cyclodextrin derivative below 37 °C, where pure TrimβMLC self-assembles in water into large giant micellar structures. After deconvolution of a broad composite ²H NMR isotropic component, we propose a model where the DMPC membranes are progressively disrupted by TrimβMLC into small and large micellar aggregates depending whether they are extracted from the outer or inner layers of the liposomes. Below the fluid-to-gel transition of pure DMPC-d27 membranes (T_c = 21.5 °C), the micellar aggregates vanish progressively until complete extinction at 13 °C, with a probable release of pure TrimβMLC micelles leaving lipid bilayers in the gel phase doped with only a small amount of the cyclodextrin derivative. Bilayer fragmentation between T_c and 13 °C was also observed with 10% and 5% of TrimβMLC, with NMR spectra suggesting possible interactions of micellar aggregates with fluid-like lipids of the P_β' ripple phase. No membrane orientation and fragmentation was detected with unsaturated POPC membranes, which are able to accommodate the insertion of TrimβMLC without important perturbation. The data are discussed in relation to the formation of possible DMPC bicellar aggregates such as those known to occur after insertion of dihexanoylphosphatidylcholine (DHPC). These bicelles are in particular associated with similar deuterium NMR spectra exhibiting identical composite isotropic components which were never characterized before.

Not just a fluidifying effect: omega-3 phospholipids induce formation of non-lamellar structures in biomembranes

Polyunsaturated omega-3 fatty acid docosahexaenoic acid (DHA) is found in very high concentrations in a few peculiar tissues, suggesting that it must have a specialized role. DHA was proposed to affect the function of the cell membrane and related proteins through an indirect mechanism of action, based on the DHA-phospholipid effects on the lipid bilayer structure. In this respect, most studies have focused on its influence on lipid-rafts, somehow neglecting the analysis of effects on liquid disordered phases that constitute most of the cell membranes, by reporting in these cases only a general fluidifying effect. In this study, by combining neutron reflectivity, cryo-transmission electron microscopy, small angle neutron scattering, dynamic light scattering and electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy, we characterize liquid disordered bilayers formed by the naturally abundant 1-palmitoyl-2-oleoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine and different contents of a di-DHA glycero-phosphocholine, 22:6-22:6PC, from both a molecular/microscopic and supramolecular/mesoscopic viewpoint. We show that, below a threshold concentration of about 40% molar percent, incorporation of 22:6-22:6PC in the membrane increases the lipid dynamics slightly but sufficiently to promote the membrane deformation and increase of multilamellarity. Notably, beyond this threshold, 22:6-22:6PC disfavours the formation of lamellar phases, leading to a phase separation consisting mostly of small spherical particles that coexist with a minority portion of a lipid blob with water-filled cavities. Concurrently, from a molecular viewpoint, the polyunsaturated acyl chains tend to fold and expose the termini to the aqueous medium. We propose that this peculiar tendency is a key feature of the DHA-phospholipids making them able to modulate the local morphology of biomembranes.

Bicelles and nanodiscs for biophysical chemistry

Membrane nanoobjects are very important tools to study biomembrane properties. Two types are described herein: Bicelles and Nanodiscs. Bicelles are obtained by thorough water mixing of long chain and short chain lipids and may take the form of membranous discs of 10-50 nm. Temperature-composition-hydration diagrams have been established for Phosphatidylcholines and show limited domains of existence. Bicelles can be doped with charged lipids, surfactants or with cholesterol and offer a wide variety of membranous platforms for structural biology. Internal dynamics as measured by solid-state NMR is very similar to that of liposomes in their fluid phase. Because of the magnetic susceptibility anisotropy of the lipid chains, discs may be aligned along or perpendicular to the magnetic field. They may serve as weak orienting media to provide distance information in determining the 3D structure of soluble proteins. In different conditions they show strong orienting properties which may be used to study the 3D structure, topology and dynamics of membrane proteins. Lipid Bicelles with biphenyl chains or doped with lanthanides show long lasting remnant orientation after removing the magnetic field due to smectic-like properties. An alternative to pure lipid Bicelles is provided by nanodiscs where the half torus composed by short chain lipids is replaced by proteins. This renders the nano-objects less fragile as they can be used to stabilize membrane protein assemblies to be studied by electron microscopy. Internal dynamics is again similar to liposomes except that the phase transition is abolished, possibly due to lateral constrain imposed by the toroidal proteins limiting the disc size. Advantages and drawbacks of both nanoplatforms are discussed.

Measuring Lipid Transfer Protein Activity Using Bicelle-Dilution Model Membranes

In vitro assessment of lipid intermembrane transfer activity by cellular proteins typically involves measurement of either radiolabeled or fluorescently labeled lipid trafficking between vesicle model membranes. Use of bilayer vesicles in lipid transfer assays usually comes with inherent challenges because of complexities associated with the preparation of vesicles and their rather short "shelf life". Such issues necessitate the laborious task of fresh vesicle preparation to achieve lipid transfer assays of high quality, precision, and reproducibility. To overcome these limitations, we have assessed model membrane generation by bicelle dilution for monitoring the transfer rates and specificity of various BODIPY-labeled sphingolipids by different glycolipid transfer protein (GLTP) superfamily members using a sensitive fluorescence resonance energy transfer approach. Robust, protein-selective sphingolipid transfer is observed using donor and acceptor model membranes generated by dilution of 0.5 q-value mixtures. The sphingolipid transfer rates are comparable to those observed between small bilayer vesicles produced by sonication or ethanol injection. Among the notable advantages of using bicelle-generated model membranes are (i) easy and straightforward preparation by means that avoid lipid fluorophore degradation and (ii) long "shelf life" after production (≥6 days) and resilience to freeze-thaw storage. The bicelle-dilution-based assay is sufficiently robust, sensitive, and stable for application, not only to purified LTPs but also for LTP activity detection in crude cytosolic fractions of cell homogenates.

Characterizing the Supported Lipid Membrane Formation from Cholesterol-Rich Bicelles

Supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) are simplified model membrane systems that mimic the fundamental properties of biological cell membranes and allow the surface-sensitive tools to be used in numerous sensing applications. SLBs can be prepared by various methods including vesicle fusion, solvent-assisted lipid bilayer (SALB), and bicelle adsorption and are generally composed of phospholipids. Incorporating other biologically relevant molecules, such as cholesterol (Chol), into SLBs has been reported with the vesicle fusion and SALB methods, whereas it remains unexplored with the bicelle absorption method. Herein, using the quartz crystal microbalance-dissipation (QCM-D) and fluorescence microscopy techniques, we explored the possibility of forming SLBs from Chol-containing bicelles and discovered that Chol-enriched SLBs can be fabricated with bicelles. We also compared the Chol-enriched SLB formation of the bicelle method to that of vesicle fusion and SALB and discussed how the differences in lipid assembly properties can cause the differences in the adsorption kinetics and final results of SLB formation. Collectively, our findings demonstrate that the vesicle fusion method is least favorable for forming Chol-enriched SLBs, whereas the SALB and bicelle methods are more favorable, highlighting the need to consider the application requirements when choosing a suitable method for the formation of Chol-enriched SLBs.

Influence of NaCl Concentration on Bicelle-Mediated SLB Formation

The deposition of two-dimensional bicellar disks on hydrophilic surfaces is an emerging approach to fabricate supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) that requires minimal sample preparation, works at low lipid concentrations, and yields high-quality SLBs. While basic operating steps in the fabrication protocol mimic aspects of the conventional vesicle fusion method, lipid bicelles and vesicles have distinct architectural properties, and understanding how experimental parameters affect the efficiency of bicelle-mediated SLB formation remains to be investigated. Herein, using the quartz crystal microbalance-dissipation and localized surface plasmon resonance techniques, we investigated the effect of bulk NaCl concentration on bicelle-mediated SLB formation on silicon dioxide surfaces. For comparison, similar experiments were conducted with vesicles as well. In both cases, SLB formation was observed to occur rapidly provided that the NaCl concentration was sufficiently high (>50 mM). Under such conditions, the effect of NaCl concentration on SLB formation was minor in the case of bicelles and significant in the case of vesicles where it is expected to be related primarily to osmotic pressure. At lower NaCl concentrations, bicelles also formed SLBs but slowly, whereas adsorbed vesicles remained intact. These findings were complemented by time-lapsed fluorescence microscopy imaging and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching measurements that corroborated bicelle-mediated SLB formation across the range of tested NaCl concentrations. The results are discussed by comparing the architectural properties of bicelles and vesicles along with theoretical analysis of the corresponding adsorption kinetics.

Understanding How Membrane Surface Charge Influences Lipid Bicelle Adsorption onto Oxide Surfaces

The adsorption of two-dimensional bicellar disks onto solid supports is an emerging fabrication technique to form supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) that is efficient and requires minimal sample preparation. To date, nearly all relevant studies have focused on zwitterionic lipid compositions and silica-based surfaces, and extending the scope of investigation to other lipid compositions and surfaces would improve our understanding of application possibilities and underpinning formation processes. Herein, using the quartz crystal microbalance-dissipation technique, we systematically investigated the adsorption of charged lipid bicelles onto silicon dioxide, titanium oxide, and aluminum oxide surfaces. Depending on the lipid composition and substrate, we observed different adsorption pathways, including (i) SLB formation via one- or two-step adsorption kinetics, (ii) monotonic adsorption without SLB formation, and (iii) negligible adsorption. On each substrate, SLB formation could be achieved with particular lipid compositions, whereas the trend in adsorption pathways varied according to the substrate and could be controlled by adjusting the bicelle?substrate interaction strength. To rationalize these findings, we discuss how electrostatic and hydration forces affect bicelle?substrate interactions on different oxide surfaces. Collectively, our findings demonstrate the broad utility of lipid bicelles for SLB formation while revealing physicochemical insights into the role of interfacial forces in controlling bicelle adsorption pathways.

Effects of Ergothioneine-Rich Mushroom Extract on the Oxidative Stability of Astaxanthin in Liposomes

Ergothioneine-rich crude extracts of Pleurotus cornucopiae were used as a source of antioxidative components to control the effects of lipid oxidation in astaxanthin-containing liposomes. This study aimed to elucidate the interactions of liposomal astaxanthin and lipids with ergothioneine-rich mushroom extract (ME) under radical oxidation-induced conditions to provide a better understanding of the agricultural and postharvest applications of this strategy. Azo compounds (2,2'-azobis(2-methylpropionamidine) dihydrochloride and 2,2'-azobis(2,4-dimethylvaleronitrile) were used as hydrophilic and lipophilic radical initiators, respectively. Results of this study demonstrate that the presence of ME significantly delayed the oxidative degradation of astaxanthin and controlled the progress of lipid oxidation in a liposomal system. The lipid hydroperoxide formation was significantly suppressed, while polyunsaturated fatty acids were protected from degradation. In addition, Crude ME also demonstrated more potent DPPH radical scavenging activities and EC₅₀ than the equimolar concentrations of ergothioneine alone, which suggested the presence of additional compounds with antioxidative properties.

Effects of Amphipathic Polypeptides on Membrane Organization Inferred from Studies Using Bicellar Lipid Mixtures

SP-B_63-78, a lung surfactant protein fragment, and magainin 2, an antimicrobial peptide, are amphipathic peptides with the same overall charge but different biological functions. Deuterium nuclear magnetic resonance has been used to compare the interactions of these peptides with dispersions of 1,2-dimyristoyl- sn-glycero-3-phophocholine (DMPC)/1,2-dihexanoyl- sn-glycero-3-phophocholine (DHPC) (4:1) and DMPC/1,2-dimyristoyl- sn-glycero-3-phopho-(1'-rac-glycerol) (DMPG)/DHPC (3:1:1), two mixtures of long-chain and short-chain lipids that display bicellar behavior. This study exploited the sensitivity of a bicellar system structural organization to factors that modify partitioning of their lipid components between different environments. In small bicelle particles formed at low temperatures, short-chain components preferentially occupy curved rim environments around bilayer disks of the long-chain components. Changes in chain order and lipid mixing, on heating, can drive transitions to more extended assemblies including a magnetically orientable phase at intermediate temperature. In this work, neither peptide had a substantial effect on the behavior of the zwitterionic DMPC/DHPC mixture. For bicellar mixtures containing the anionic lipid DMPG, the peptide SP-B_63-78 lowered the temperature at which magnetically orientable particles coalesced into more extended lamellar structures. SP-B_63-78 did not promote partitioning of the zwitterionic and anionic long-chain lipid components into different environments. Magainin 2, on the other hand, was found to promote separation of the anionic lipid, DMPG, and the zwitterionic lipid, DMPC, into different environments for temperatures above 34 °C. The contrast between the effects of these two peptides on the lipid mixtures studied appears to be consistent with their functional roles in biological systems.

NMR Spectroscopy Approach to Study the Structure, Orientation, and Mechanism of the Multidrug Exporter EmrE

Multidrug exporters are a class of membrane proteins that remove antibiotics from the cytoplasm of bacteria and in the process confer multidrug resistance to the organism. This chapter outlines the sample preparation and optimization of oriented solid-state NMR experiments applied to the study of structure and dynamics for the model transporter EmrE from the small multidrug resistance (SMR) family.

Contrast-Matched Isotropic Bicelles: A Versatile Tool to Specifically Probe the Solution Structure of Peripheral Membrane Proteins Using SANS

Obtaining structural information on integral or peripheral membrane proteins is currently arduous due to the difficulty of their solubilization, purification, and crystallization (for X-ray crystallography (XRC) application). To overcome this challenge, bicelles are known to be a versatile tool for high-resolution structure determination, especially when using solution and/or solid state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and, to a lesser extent, XRC. For proteins not compatible with these high-resolution methods, small-angle X-ray and neutron scattering (SAXS and SANS, respectively) are powerful alternatives to obtain structural information directly in solution. In particular, the SANS-based approach is a unique technique to obtain low-resolution structures of proteins in interactions with partners by contrast-matching the signal coming from the latter. In the present study, isotropic bicelles are used as a membrane mimic model for SANS-based structural studies of bound peripheral membrane proteins. We emphasize that the SANS signal coming from the deuterated isotropic bicelles can be contrast-matched in 100% D₂O-based buffer, allowing us to separately and specifically focus on the signal coming from the protein in interaction with membrane lipids. We applied this method to the DYS-R11-15 protein, a fragment of the central domain of human dystrophin known to interact with lipids, and we were able to recover the signal from the protein alone. This approach gives rise to new perspectives to determine the solution structure of peripheral membrane proteins interacting with lipid membranes and might be extended to integral membrane proteins.

Optimizing the Formation of Supported Lipid Bilayers from Bicellar Mixtures

Supported lipid bilayers (SLBs) are widely studied model membrane platforms that are compatible with various surface-sensitive measurement techniques. SLBs are typically formed on silica-based materials, and there are numerous possible fabrication routes involving either bottom-up molecular self-assembly or vesicle adsorption and rupture. In between these two classes of fabrication strategies lies an emerging approach based on depositing quasi-two-dimensional lamellar, bicellar disks composed of a mixture of long-chain and short-chain phospholipids to promote the formation of SLBs. This approach takes advantage of the thermodynamic preference of long-chain phospholipids to form planar SLBs, whereas short-chain phospholipids have brief residence times. Although a few studies have shown that SLBs can be formed on silica-based materials from bicellar mixtures, outstanding questions remain about the self-assembly mechanism as well as the influence of the total phospholipid concentration, ratio of the two phospholipids (termed the "q-ratio"), and process of sample preparation. Herein, we address these questions through comprehensive quartz crystal microbalance-dissipation, fluorescence microscopy, and fluorescence recovery after photobleaching experiments. Our findings identify that optimal SLB formation occurs at lower total concentrations of phospholipids than previously used as short-chain phospholipids behave like membrane-destabilizing detergents at higher concentrations. Using lower phospholipid concentrations, we also discovered that the formation of SLBs proceeds through a two-step mechanism involving a critical coverage of bicellar disks akin to vesicle fusion. In addition, the results indicate that at least one cycle of freeze-thaw-vortexing is useful during the sample preparation process to produce SLBs. Taken together, the findings in this work identify optimal routes for fabricating SLBs from bicellar mixtures and reveal mechanistic details about the bicelle-mediated SLB formation process, which will aid further exploration of bicellar mixtures as tools for model membrane fabrication.

Characterization of fast-tumbling isotropic bicelles by PFG diffusion NMR

Small isotropic bicelles are versatile membrane mimetics, which, in contrast to micelles, provide a lipid bilayer and are at the same time suitable for solution-state NMR studies. The lipid composition of the bilayer is flexible allowing for incorporation of various head groups and acyl chain types. In bicelles, lipids are solubilized by detergents, which are localized in the rim of the disk-shaped lipid bilayer. Bicelles have been characterized by a broad array of biophysical methods, pulsed-field gradient NMR (PFG NMR) being one of them. PFG NMR can readily be used to measure diffusion coefficients of macromolecules. It is thus employed to characterize bicelle size and morphology. Even more importantly, PFG NMR can be used to study the degree of protein association to membranes. Here, we present the advances that have been made in producing small, fast-tumbling isotropic bicelles from a variety of lipids and detergents, together with insights on the morphology of such mixtures gained from PFG NMR. Furthermore, we review approaches to study protein-membrane interaction by PFG NMR. Copyright © 2015 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Magnetically Oriented Bicelles with Monoalkylphosphocholines: Versatile Membrane Mimetics for Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Applications

Bicelles (bilayered micelles) are model membranes used in the study of peptide structure and membrane interactions. They are traditionally made of long- and short-chain phospholipids, usually dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (D14PC) and dihexanoyl-PC (D6PC). They are attractive membrane mimetics because their composition and planar surface are similar to the native membrane environment. In this work, to improve the solubilization of membrane proteins and allow their study in bicellar systems, D6PC was replaced by detergents from the monoalkylphosphocholine (MAPCHO) family, of which dodecylphosphocholine (12PC) is known for its ability to solubilize membrane proteins. More specifically 12PC, tetradecyl- (14PC), and hexadecyl-PC (16PC) have been employed. To verify the possibility of making bicelles with different hydrophobic thicknesses to better accommodate membrane proteins, D14PC was also replaced by phospholipids with different alkyl chain lengths: dilauroyl-PC (D12PC), dipalmitoyl-PC (D16PC), distearoyl-PC (D18PC), and diarachidoyl-PC (D20PC). Results obtained by ³¹P solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) and isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) at several lipid-to-detergent molar ratios (q) and temperatures indicate that these new MAPCHO bicelles can be formed under a variety of conditions. The quality of their alignment is similar to that of classical bicelles, and the low critical micelle concentration (CMC) of the surfactants and their miscibility with phospholipids are likely to be advantageous for the reconstitution of membrane proteins.

Effect of an Anionic Lipid on the Barotropic Behavior of a Ternary Bicellar Mixture

Dispersions of lipid mixtures comprising long- and short-chain phospholipids (bicellar mixtures) can form small isotropically reorienting particles (bilayered micelles), magnetically orientable stuctures, or unorientable lamellar structures. Application of hydrostatic pressure can also induce interdigitation of the long-chain lipid components. In this work, variable-pressure ²H NMR was used to study the effect of head group charge on the barotropic behavior of bicellar mixtures. Observations at pressures up to 152 MPa and temperatures up to 64 °C were combined with earlier observations at lower pressure and lower temperature to obtain a pressure-temperature phase diagram for DMPC-d₅₄/DMPG/DHPC (3:1:1). In this phase diagram, a region corresponding to small, isotropically reorienting particles at lower temperature and higher pressure is separated from a region corresponding to unorientable lamellar organization, at higher temperature and lower pressure, by a band in which the magnetically orientable phase is stable below ∼100 MPa and in which an interdigitated gel phase is stable above ∼120 MPa. From ∼46 to ∼52 °C, the dispersion transforms directly from the unorientable lamellar to isotropically reorienting particle phases upon isothermal pressurization. The extent to which this behavior reflects the presence of anionic lipid in the long-chain fraction of this mixture is illustrated by comparison with spectral series obtained during isothermal pressurization of DMPC-d₅₄/DHPC (4:1) and DMPC-d₅₄/DMPG/DHPC (2.7:1.3:1) at selected temperatures. These observations show how electrostatic interactions at a bilayer surface can affect the balance between hydrophobic and hydrophilic interactions that is reflected by a dispersion's barotropic phase behavior.

Investigation of the curvature induction and membrane localization of the influenza virus M2 protein using static and off-magic-angle spinning solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance of oriented bicelles

A wide variety of membrane proteins induce membrane curvature for function; thus, it is important to develop new methods to simultaneously determine membrane curvature and protein binding sites in membranes with multiple curvatures. We introduce solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) methods based on magnetically oriented bicelles and off-magic-angle spinning (OMAS) to measure membrane curvature and the binding site of proteins in mixed-curvature membranes. We demonstrate these methods on the influenza virus M2 protein, which not only acts as a proton channel but also mediates virus assembly and membrane scission. An M2 peptide encompassing the transmembrane (TM) domain and an amphipathic helix, M2(21-61), was studied and compared with the TM peptide (M2TM). Static (31)P NMR spectra of magnetically oriented 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC)/1,2-dihexanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DHPC) bicelles exhibit a temperature-independent isotropic chemical shift in the presence of M2(21-61) but not M2TM, indicating that the amphipathic helix confers the ability to generate a high-curvature phase. Two-dimensional (2D) (31)P spectra indicate that this high-curvature phase is associated with the DHPC bicelle edges, suggestive of the structure of budding viruses from the host cell. (31)P- and (13)C-detected (1)H relaxation times of the lipids indicate that the majority of M2(21-61) is bound to the high-curvature phase. Using OMAS experiments, we resolved the (31)P signals of lipids with identical headgroups based on their distinct chemical shift anisotropies. On the basis of this resolution, 2D (1)H-(31)P correlation spectra show that the amide protons in M2(21-61) correlate with the DMPC but not DHPC (31)P signal of the bicelle, indicating that a small percentage of M2(21-61) partitions into the planar region of the bicelles. These results show that the amphipathic helix induces high membrane curvature and localizes the protein to this phase, in good agreement with the membrane scission function of the protein. These bicelle-based relaxation and OMAS solid-state NMR techniques are generally applicable to curvature-inducing membrane proteins such as those involved in membrane trafficking, membrane fusion, and cell division.

Temperature-resistant bicelles for structural studies by solid-state NMR spectroscopy

Three-dimensional structure determination of membrane proteins is important to fully understand their biological functions. However, obtaining a high-resolution structure has been a major challenge mainly due to the difficulties in retaining the native folding and function of membrane proteins outside of the cellular membrane environment. These challenges are acute if the protein contains a large soluble domain, as it needs bulk water unlike the transmembrane domains of an integral membrane protein. For structural studies on such proteins either by nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy or X-ray crystallography, bicelles have been demonstrated to be superior to conventional micelles, yet their temperature restrictions attributed to their thermal instabilities are a major disadvantage. Here, we report an approach to overcome this drawback through searching for an optimum combination of bicellar compositions. We demonstrate that bicelles composed of 1,2-didecanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DDPC) and 1,2-diheptanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholin (DHepPC), without utilizing additional stabilizing chemicals, are quite stable and are resistant to temperature variations. These temperature-resistant bicelles have a robust bicellar phase and magnetic alignment over a broad range of temperatures, between -15 and 80 °C, retain the native structure of a membrane protein, and increase the sensitivity of solid-state NMR experiments performed at low temperatures. Advantages of two-dimensional separated-local field (SLF) solid-state NMR experiments at a low temperature are demonstrated on magnetically aligned bicelles containing an electron carrier membrane protein, cytochrome b5. Morphological information on different DDPC-based bicellar compositions, varying q ratio/size, and hydration levels obtained from (31)P NMR experiments in this study is also beneficial for a variety of biophysical and spectroscopic techniques, including solution NMR and magic-angle-spinning (MAS) NMR for a wide range of temperatures.

Membrane interactions in small fast-tumbling bicelles as studied by 31P NMR

Small fast-tumbling bicelles are ideal for studies of membrane interactions at molecular level; they allow analysis of lipid properties using solution-state NMR. In the present study we used 31P NMR relaxation to obtain detailed information on lipid head-group dynamics. We explored the effect of two topologically different membrane-interacting peptides on bicelles containing either dimyristoylphosphocholine (DMPC), or a mixture of DMPC and dimyristoylphosphoglycerol (DMPG), and dihexanoylphosphocholine (DHPC). KALP21 is a model transmembrane peptide, designed to span a DMPC bilayer and dynorphin B is a membrane surface active neuropeptide. KALP21 causes significant increase in bicelle size, as evidenced by both dynamic light scattering and 31P T2 relaxation measurements. The effect of dynorphin B on bicelle size is more modest, although significant effects on T2 relaxation are observed at higher temperatures. A comparison of 31P T1 values for the lipids with and without the peptides showed that dynorphin B has a greater effect on lipid head-group dynamics than KALP21, especially at elevated temperatures. From the field-dependence of T1 relaxation data, a correlation time describing the overall lipid motion was derived. Results indicate that the positively charged dynorphin B decreases the mobility of the lipid molecules--in particular for the negatively charged DMPG--while KALP21 has a more modest influence. Our results demonstrate that while a transmembrane peptide has severe effects on overall bilayer properties, the surface bound peptide has a more dramatic effect in reducing lipid head-group mobility. These observations may be of general importance for understanding peptide-membrane interactions.

Stability of bicelles: a simulation study

Aqueous mixtures of long-tailed lipids (e.g., dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine - DMPC) and detergents can sometimes form membrane disks called bicelles. Bicelles have found applications as an embedding medium for membrane proteins in the context of NMR studies and protein crystallization. However, the parameters that determine the thermodynamic stability of bicelles are not well understood. Here we report a coarse-grained simulation study of the relationship between lipid-aggregate morphology and the composition and temperature of the surfactant mixture. In agreement with experiments, we find that bicellar mixtures are destabilized at higher temperatures and detergents are present at membrane edges as well as in flat membranes with a strong preference for the edges. In addition, our results suggest that the free-energy difference between bicelles and the perforated lamellar phase is typically very small for molecules without intrinsic curvature and charge. Cone shaped surfactant molecules tend to favor the formation of bicelles; however, none of the systems that we have studied provide unambiguous evidence for the existence of thermodynamically stable bicelles in mixtures of uncharged lipids with long and short tails. We speculate that small changes in the properties of the system (charge, dopants) may make bicelles thermodynamically stable.

Impact of bilayer lipid composition on the structure and topology of the transmembrane amyloid precursor C99 protein

C99 (also known as β-CTF) is the 99 residue transmembrane C-terminal domain (residues 672–770) of the amyloid precursor protein and is the immediate precursor of the amyloid-β (Aβ) polypeptides. To test the dependence of the C99 structure on the composition of the host model membranes, NMR studies of C99 were conducted both in anionic lyso-myristoylphosphatidylglycerol (LMPG) micelles and in a series of five zwitterionic bicelle compositions involving phosphatidylcholine and sphingomyelin in which the acyl chain lengths of these lipid components varied from 14 to 24 carbons. Some of these mixtures are reported for the first time in this work and should be of broad utility in membrane protein research. The site-specific backbone ¹⁵N and ¹H chemical shifts for C99 in LMPG and in all five bicelle mixtures were seen to be remarkably similar, indicating little dependence of the backbone structure of C99 on the composition of the host model membrane. However, the length of the transmembrane span was seen to vary in a manner that alters the positioning of the γ-secretase cleavage sites with respect to the center of the bilayer. This observation may contribute to the known dependency of the Aβ42-to-Aβ40 production ratio on both membrane thickness and the length of the C99 transmembrane domain.

Bicelles exhibiting magnetic alignment for a broader range of temperatures: a solid-state NMR study

Bicelles are increasingly used as model membranes to suitably mimic the biological cell membrane for biophysical and biochemical studies by a variety of techniques including NMR and X-ray crystallography. Recent NMR studies have successfully utilized bicelles for atomic-resolution structural and dynamic studies of antimicrobial peptides, amyloid peptides, and membrane-bound proteins. Though bicelles composed with several different types of lipids and detergents have been reported, the NMR requirement of magnetic alignment of bicelles limits the temperature range in which they can be used and subsequently their composition. Because of this restriction, low-temperature experiments desirable for heat-sensitive membrane proteins have not been conducted because bicelles could not be aligned. In this study, we characterize the magnetic alignment of bicelles with various compositions for a broad range of temperatures using (31)P static NMR spectroscopy in search of temperature-resistant bicelles. Our systematic investigation identified a temperature range of magnetic alignment for bicelles composed of 4:1 DLPC:DHexPC, 4:1:0.2 DLPC:DHexPC:cholesterol, 4:1:0.13 DLPC:DHexPC:CTAB, 4:1:0.13:0.2 DLPC:DHexPC:CTAB:cholesterol, and 4:1:0.4 DLPC:DHexPC:cholesterol-3-sulfate. The amount of cholesterol-3-sulfate used was based on mole percent and was varied in order to determine the optimal amount. Our results indicate that the presence of 75 wt % or more water is essential to achieve maximum magnetic alignment, while the presence of cholesterol and cholesterol-3-sulfate stabilizes the alignment at extreme temperatures and the positively charged CTAB avoids the mixing of bicelles. We believe that the use of magnetically aligned 4:1:0.4 DLPC:DHexPC:cholesterol-3-sulfate bicelles at as low as -15 °C would pave avenues to study the structure, dynamics, and membrane orientation of heat-sensitive proteins such as cytochrome P450 and could also be useful to investigate protein-protein interactions in a membrane environment.

Probing the transmembrane structure and topology of microsomal cytochrome-p450 by solid-state NMR on temperature-resistant bicelles

Though the importance of high-resolution structure and dynamics of membrane proteins has been well recognized, optimizing sample conditions to retain the native-like folding and function of membrane proteins for Nuclear Magnetic Resonance (NMR) or X-ray measurements has been a major challenge. While bicelles have been shown to stabilize the function of membrane proteins and are increasingly utilized as model membranes, the loss of their magnetic-alignment at low temperatures makes them unsuitable to study heat-sensitive membrane proteins like cytochrome-P450 and protein-protein complexes. In this study, we report temperature resistant bicelles that can magnetically-align for a broad range of temperatures and demonstrate their advantages in the structural studies of full-length microsomal cytochrome-P450 and cytochrome-b5 by solid-state NMR spectroscopy. Our results reveal that the N-terminal region of rabbit cytochromeP4502B4, that is usually cleaved off to obtain crystal structures, is helical and has a transmembrane orientation with ~17° tilt from the lipid bilayer normal.

Response to hydrostatic pressure of bicellar dispersions containing an anionic lipid: pressure-induced interdigitation

Bicellar dispersions of chain perdeuterated 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DMPC-d54), 1,2-dimyristoyl-sn-glycero-3-phospho-(1'-rac-glycerol) (DMPG), and 1,2-dihexanoyl-sn-glycero-3-phosphocholine (DHPC), with molar ratios of 3:1:1, were studied using variable-pressure (2)H NMR spectroscopy at hydrostatic pressures up to 125 MPa. Upon warming of the dispersions, spectra at ambient pressure indicated a progressive coalescence from small bilayered disks undergoing isotropic reorientation to more extended micellar structures in which spectra indicated anisotropic reorientation and, under some conditions, magnetic orientation and finally to randomly oriented lamellae or multilamellar vesicles. Temperatures for the onsets of anisotropic reorientation and random lamellar orientation increased with pressure at rates of 0.22 and 0.15 °C/MPa, respectively. In the 3.5-T magnetic field used for this work, magnetic orientation within the intermediate phase was not observed at 83 MPa or higher pressures. Comparison of spectra obtained at fixed pressure showed significant asymmetry between behaviors upon warming and cooling. For samples of DMPC-d54/DMPG/DHPC (3:1:1), but not DMPC-d54/DHPC (4:1), a persistent interdigitated phase was formed after repeated cooling from high temperature at 83 MPa. This is likely a metastable phase and might reflect kinetic trapping of the short-chain lipid component, DHPC, in a nonequilibrium spatial distribution as temperature is lowered at high pressure. Bicellar dispersions typically behave differently upon warming and cooling, and these observations could provide some insight into the observed behaviors in such systems. This work also suggests the possibility of trapping bicellar dispersions in persistent nonequilibrium morphologies.

Interaction of the C-terminal peptide of pulmonary surfactant protein B (SP-B) with a bicellar lipid mixture containing anionic lipid

The hydrophobic lung surfactant SP-B is essential for respiration. SP-B promotes spreading and adsorption of surfactant at the alveolar air-water interface and may facilitate connections between the surface layer and underlying lamellar reservoirs of surfactant material. SP-B_63–78 is a cationic and amphipathic helical peptide containing the C-terminal helix of SP-B. ²H NMR has been used to examine the effect of SP-B_63–78 on the phase behavior and dynamics of bicellar lipid dispersions containing the longer chain phospholipids DMPC-d₅₄ and DMPG and the shorter chain lipid DHPC mixed with a 3∶1∶1 molar ratio. Below the gel-to-liquid crystal phase transition temperature of the longer chain components, bicellar mixtures form small, rapidly reorienting disk-like particles with shorter chain lipid components predominantly found around the highly curved particle edges. With increasing temperature, the particles coalesce into larger magnetically-oriented structures and then into more extended lamellar phases. The susceptibility of bicellar particles to coalescence and large scale reorganization makes them an interesting platform in which to study peptide-induced interactions between lipid assemblies. SP-B_63–78 is found to lower the temperature at which the orientable phase transforms to the more extended lamellar phase. The peptide also changes the spectrum of motions contributing to quadrupole echo decay in the lamellar phase. The way in which the peptide alters interactions between bilayered micelle structures may provide some insight into some aspects of the role of full-length SP-B in maintaining a functional surfactant layer in lungs.

Solution NMR studies of cell-penetrating peptides in model membrane systems

Cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) are a class of short, often cationic peptides that have the capability to translocate across cellular membranes, and although the translocation most likely involves several pathways, they interact directly with membranes, as well as with model bilayers. Most CPPs attain a three-dimensional structure when interacting with bilayers, while they are more or less unstructured in aqueous solution. To understand the relationship between structure and the effect that CPPs have on membranes it is of great importance to investigate CPPs at atomic resolution in a suitable membrane model. Moreover, the location in bilayers is likely to be correlated with the translocation mechanism. Solution-state NMR offers a unique possibility to investigate structure, dynamics and location of proteins and peptides in bilayers. This review focuses on solution NMR as a tool for investigating CPP-lipid interactions. Structural propensities and cell-penetrating capabilities can be derived from a combination of CPP solution structures and studies of the effect that the peptides have on bilayers and the localization in a bilayer.

Effect of divalent cations on DMPC/DHPC bicelle formation and alignment

Many important classes of biomolecules require divalent cations for optimal activity, making these ions essential for biologically relevant structural studies. Bicelle mixtures composed of short-chain and long-chain lipids are often used in solution- and solid-state NMR structure determination; however, the phase diagrams of these useful orienting media and membrane mimetics are sensitive to other solution components. Therefore, we have investigated the effect of varying concentrations of four divalent cations, Ca(2+), Mg(2+), Zn(2+), and Cd(2+), on cholesterol sulfate-stabilized DMPC/DHPC bicelles. We found that low concentrations of all the divalent ions are tolerated with minimal perturbation. At higher concentrations Zn(2+) and Cd(2+) disrupt the magnetically aligned phase while Ca(2+) and Mg(2+) produce more strongly oriented phases. This result indicates that divalent cations are not only required to maintain the biological activity of proteins and nucleic acids; they may also be used to manipulate the behavior of the magnetically aligned phase.

Bicelles: lipid nanostructured platforms with potential dermal applications

Bicelles emerge as promising membrane models, and because of their attractive combination of lipid composition, small size and morphological versatility, they become new targets in skin research. Bicelles are able to modify skin biophysical parameters and modulate the skin's barrier function, acting to enhance drug penetration. Because of their nanostructured assemblies, bicelles have the ability to penetrate through the narrow intercellular spaces of the stratum corneum of the skin to reinforce its lipid lamellae. The bicelle structure also allows for the incorporation of different molecules that can be carried through the skin layers. All of these characteristics can be modulated by varying the lipid composition and experimental conditions. The remarkable versatility of bicelles is their most important characteristic, which makes their use possible in various fields. This system represents a platform for dermal applications. In this review, an overview of the main properties of bicelles and their effects on the skin are presented.

Bicelles at low concentrations

Bilayered detergent-lipid assemblies known as bicelles have been widely used as model membranes in structural biological studies and are being explored for wider applications, including pharmaceutical use. Most studies to date have involved the use of concentrated bicelle mixtures, such that little is known about the capacity of bicellar mixtures to be diluted without unwanted transitions to nonisotropic phases. Here, different detergent/lipid mixtures have been explored, leading to the identification of two different families of bicelles for which it is possible to lower the total amphiphile (detergent + lipid) concentration to <1% (w/v) while retaining isotropic assemblies. These include a novel family of bicelles based on mixtures of 6-cyclohexyl-1-hexylphosphocholine (Cyclofos-6) and the lipid dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC). Bicelles formed by these mixtures can be diluted to <0.5% and also have attractive biochemical properties. However, a caveat of our results is that the diffusion coefficients measured for the lipid component of the different bicelles tested were seen to be dependent on sample history, even though all samples were optically transparent. This suggests that the phase behavior of bicelles at low lipid-to-detergent ratios may be more complex than previously appreciated.

Temperature driven annealing of perforations in bicellar model membranes

Bicellar model membranes composed of 1,2-dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) and 1,2-dihexanoylphosphatidylcholine (DHPC), with a DMPC/DHPC molar ratio of 5, and doped with the negatively charged lipid 1,2-dimyristoylphosphatidylglycerol (DMPG), at DMPG/DMPC molar ratios of 0.02 or 0.1, were examined using small angle neutron scattering (SANS), (31)P NMR, and (1)H pulsed field gradient (PFG) diffusion NMR with the goal of understanding temperature effects on the DHPC-dependent perforations in these self-assembled membrane mimetics. Over the temperature range studied via SANS (300-330 K), these bicellar lipid mixtures exhibited a well-ordered lamellar phase. The interlamellar spacing d increased with increasing temperature, in direct contrast to the decrease in d observed upon increasing temperature with otherwise identical lipid mixtures lacking DHPC. (31)P NMR measurements on magnetically aligned bicellar mixtures of identical composition indicated a progressive migration of DHPC from regions of high curvature into planar regions with increasing temperature, and in accord with the "mixed bicelle model" (Triba, M. N.; Warschawski, D. E.; Devaux, P. E. Biophys. J.2005, 88, 1887-1901). Parallel PFG diffusion NMR measurements of transbilayer water diffusion, where the observed diffusion is dependent on the fractional surface area of lamellar perforations, showed that transbilayer water diffusion decreased with increasing temperature. A model is proposed consistent with the SANS, (31)P NMR, and PFG diffusion NMR data, wherein increasing temperature drives the progressive migration of DHPC out of high-curvature regions, consequently decreasing the fractional volume of lamellar perforations, so that water occupying these perforations redistributes into the interlamellar volume, thereby increasing the interlamellar spacing.

Thermal stabilization of DMPC/DHPC bicelles by addition of cholesterol sulfate

Doping DMPC/DHPC bicelles with cholesterol sulfate broadens the temperature range over which stable alignment occurs, forming an aligned phase at lower temperatures even with high lipid concentrations. Cholesterol sulfate appears to combine the advantages of cholesterol with those of charged amphiphiles, stabilizing the aligned phase and preventing precipitation. This allows NMR data for RDC and CSA protein structure constraints to be acquired at or below room temperature, an obvious advantage for solid-state and solution studies of heat-sensitive proteins.

Application of bicellar systems on skin: diffusion and molecular organization effects

The effect of bicelles formed by dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine (DPPC)/dihexanoylphosphatidylcholine (DHPC) on stratum corneum (SC) lipids was studied by attenuated total reflectance-Fourier transform infrared (ATR-FTIR) spectroscopy at different temperatures. Analysis of the lipid organization in terms of chain conformational order and lateral packing shows that the use of bicelles hampers the fluidification of SC lipids with temperature and leads to a lateral packing corresponding to a stable hexagonal phase. Grazing incidence small- and wide-angle X-ray scattering (GISAXS and GIWAXS) techniques confirm these results and give evidence of higher lamellar order after treatment with these bicelles. Additionally, the effects of DPPC/DHPC and dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC)/DHPC bicelles at different SC depths were compared. The combination of ATR-FTIR spectroscopy and the tape-stripping method was very useful for this purpose.

Novel type of bicellar disks from a mixture of DMPC and DMPE-DTPA with complexed lanthanides

We report on the formation of bicelles from a mixture of dimyristoylphosphatidylcholine (DMPC) and the chelator-lipid dimyristoylphosphatidylethanolamine-diethylenetriaminepentaacetate (DMPE-DTPA) with complexed lanthanides, either thulium (Tm(3+)) or lanthanum (La(3+)). The two phospholipids used have the same acyl-chain length but differ in headgroup size and chemical structure. The total lipid concentration was 15 mM, and the molar ratio of DMPC to DMPE-DTPA was 4:1. The system was studied with small angle neutron scattering (SANS) in a magnetic field, cryo-transmission electron microscopy (cryo-TEM), and (31)P NMR spectroscopy. We found that, after appropriate preparation steps, that is, extrusion through a polycarbonate membrane followed by a cooling step, monodisperse small unilamellar disks (flat cylinders called bicelles) are formed. They have a radius of 20 nm and a bilayer thickness of about 4 nm and are stable in the investigated temperature range of 2.5-30 degrees C. Fitting of SANS data with a form factor for partly aligned flat cylinders shows that the bicelles are slightly orientable in a magnetic field of 8 T if DMPE-DTPA is complexed with Tm(3+).

A reconstitution protocol for the in vitro folded human G protein-coupled Y2 receptor into lipid environment

Although highly resolved crystal structures of G protein-coupled receptors have become available within the last decade, the need for studying these molecules in their natural membrane environment, where the molecules are rather dynamic, has been widely appreciated. Solid-state NMR spectroscopy is an excellent method to study structure and dynamics of membrane proteins in their native lipid environment. We developed a reconstitution protocol for the uniformly (15)N labeled Y(2) receptor into a bicelle-like lipid structure with high yields suitable for NMR studies. Milligram quantities of target protein were expressed in Escherichia coli using an optimized fermentation process in defined medium yielding in over 10mg/L medium of purified Y(2) receptor solubilized in SDS micelles. The structural integrity of the receptor molecules was strongly increased through refolding and subsequent reconstitution into phospholipid membranes. Specific ligand binding to the integrated receptor was determined using radioligand affinity assay. Further, by NMR measurement a dispersion of the (15)N signals comparable to native rhodopsin was shown. The efficiency of the reconstitution could also be inferred from the fact that reasonable (13)C NMR spectra at natural abundance could be acquired.