Appearance of microglial cells in the postnatal rat retina

Neuroprotective Effects of FGF2 and Minocycline in Two Animal Models of Inherited Retinal Degeneration

Purpose

The purpose of this study was to study the effect of minocycline and several neurotrophic factors, alone or in combination, on photoreceptor survival and macro/microglial reactivity in two rat models of retinal degeneration.

Methods

P23H-1 (rhodopsin mutation), Royal College of Surgeon (RCS, pigment epithelium malfunction), and age-matched control rats (Sprague-Dawley and Pievald Viro Glaxo, respectively) were divided into three groups that received at P10 for P23H-1 rats or P33 for RCS rats: (1) one intravitreal injection (IVI) of one of the following neurotrophic factors: ciliary neurotrophic factor (CNTF), pigment epithelium-derived factor (PEDF), or basic fibroblast growth factor (FGF2); (2) daily intraperitoneal administration of minocycline; or (3) a combination of IVI of FGF2 and intraperitoneal minocycline. All animals were processed 12 days after treatment initiation. Retinal microglial cells and cone photoreceptors were immunodetected and analyzed qualitatively in cross sections. The numbers of microglial cells in the different retinal layers and number of nuclei rows in the outer nuclear layer (ONL) were quantified.

Results

IVI of CNTF, PEDF, or FGF2 improved the morphology of the photoreceptors outer segment, but only FGF2 rescued a significant number of photoreceptors. None of the trophic factors had qualitative or quantitative effects on microglial cells. Minocycline treatment reduced activation and migration of microglia and produced a significant rescue of photoreceptors. Combined treatment with minocycline and FGF2 had higher neuroprotective effects than each of the treatments alone.

Conclusions

In two animal models of photoreceptor degeneration with different etiologies, minocycline reduces microglial activation and migration, and FGF2 and minocycline increase photoreceptor survival. The combination of FGF2 and minocycline show greater neuroprotective effects than their isolated effects.

Retinal microglia - A key player in healthy and diseased retina

Microglia, the resident immune cells of the brain and retina, are constantly engaged in the surveillance of their surrounding neural tissue. During embryonic development they infiltrate the retinal tissues and participate in the phagocytosis of redundant neurons. The contribution of microglia in maintaining the purposeful and functional histo-architecture of the adult retina is indispensable. Within the retinal microenvironment, robust microglial activation is elicited by subtle changes caused by extrinsic and intrinsic factors. When there is a disturbance in the cell-cell communication between microglia and other retinal cells, for example in retinal injury, the activated microglia can manifest actions that can be detrimental. This is evidenced by activated microglia secreting inflammatory mediators that can further aggravate the retinal injury. Microglial activation as a harbinger of a variety of retinal diseases is well documented by many studies. In addition, a change in the microglial phenotype which may be associated with aging, may predispose the retina to age-related diseases. In light of the above, the focus of this review is to highlight the role played by microglia in the healthy and diseased retina, based on findings of our own work and from that of others.

Repopulating retinal microglia restore endogenous organization and function under CX3CL1-CX3CR1 regulation

Microglia have been discovered to undergo repopulation following ablation. However, the functionality of repopulated microglia and the mechanisms regulating microglia repopulation are unknown. We examined microglial homeostasis in the adult mouse retina, a specialized neural compartment containing regular arrays of microglia in discrete synaptic laminae that can be directly visualized. Using in vivo imaging and cell-fate mapping techniques, we discovered that repopulation originated from residual microglia proliferating in the central inner retina that subsequently spread by centrifugal migration to fully recapitulate pre-existing microglial distributions and morphologies. Repopulating cells fully restored microglial functions including constitutive "surveying" process movements, behavioral and physiological responses to retinal injury, and maintenance of synaptic structure and function. Microglial repopulation was regulated by CX3CL1-CX3CR1 signaling, slowing in CX3CR1 deficiency and accelerating with exogenous CX3CL1 administration. Microglial homeostasis following perturbation can fully recover microglial organization and function under the regulation of chemokine signaling between neurons and microglia.

Early Events in Retinal Degeneration Caused by Rhodopsin Mutation or Pigment Epithelium Malfunction: Differences and Similarities

To study the course of photoreceptor cell death and macro and microglial reactivity in two rat models of retinal degeneration with different etiologies. Retinas from P23H-1 (rhodopsin mutation) and Royal College of Surgeon (RCS, pigment epithelium malfunction) rats and age-matched control animals (Sprague-Dawley and Pievald Viro Glaxo, respectively) were cross-sectioned at different postnatal ages (from P10 to P60) and rhodopsin, L/M- and S-opsin, ionized calcium-binding adapter molecule 1 (Iba1), glial fibrillary acid protein (GFAP), and proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA) proteins were immunodetected. Photoreceptor nuclei rows and microglial cells in the different retinal layers were quantified. Photoreceptor degeneration starts earlier and progresses quicker in P23H-1 than in RCS rats. In both models, microglial cell activation occurs simultaneously with the initiation of photoreceptor death while GFAP over-expression starts later. As degeneration progresses, the numbers of microglial cells increase in the retina, but decreasing in the inner retina and increasing in the outer retina, more markedly in RCS rats. Interestingly, and in contrast with healthy animals, microglial cells reach the outer nuclei and outer segment layers. The higher number of microglial cells in dystrophic retinas cannot be fully accounted by intraretinal migration and PCNA immunodetection revealed microglial proliferation in both models but more importantly in RCS rats. The etiology of retinal degeneration determines the initiation and pattern of photoreceptor cell death and simultaneously there is microglial activation and migration, while the macroglial response is delayed. The actions of microglial cells in the degeneration cannot be explained only in the basis of photoreceptor death because they participate more actively in the RCS model. Thus, the retinal degeneration caused by pigment epithelium malfunction is more inflammatory and would probably respond better to interventions by inhibiting microglial cells.

Involvement of the CD200 receptor complex in microglia activation in experimental glaucoma

The interaction of the myeloid restricted molecule CD200R with its widely expressed ligand CD200 is involved in the down-regulation of microglia activation. In the present study, we examined the involvement of CD200R in microglia activation in experimental ocular hypertension to determine the role of microglia activation in retinal ganglion cell (RGC) death, the key pathological event in glaucoma. Experimental glaucoma was induced in adult Brown Norway rats by sclerosis of the episcleral veins with the injection of hypertonic saline. Immunohistochemical methods were used to determine the involvement of microglia using GFAP, CD45, OX42 and OX41 and the involvement of CD200 and CD200R in the optic nerve head. Our data demonstrate the increased presence of microglia within the optic nerve head during ocular hypertension, identified by positive staining with OX42 and OX41. The peak of microglia correlates with peak in RGC death at days 20-27 (T3) post OHT induction. In addition, CD200 and CD200R positive cells were increased in ocular hypertensive eyes. Increased expression of CD200 was detected in the early phase (days 1-7; T1) of OHT and decreased over time, whilst the expression of CD200R was detected in the middle phase (days 20-27; T3) of OHT, correlating with the increase in microglia markers. Changes in the expression of CD200R/CD200 occur early in experimental glaucoma and precede the peak in microglia infiltration and RGC death, suggesting that CD200R-positive microglia play an important role in the initiation of RGC death during OHT, indicating a potential area for therapeutic intervention in treating glaucoma.

Microglial cells in the retina of Carassius auratus: effects of optic nerve crush

To study the morphology and distribution of the retinal microglial cells of the goldfish retina in normal conditions and after optic nerve crush, we have used the nucleoside diphosphatase (NDPase) technique, applied to whole-mounts or sections, for light and electron microscopy. In normal retinas, two populations of NDPase-positive cells were identified: compact cells associated with the retinal vessels on the vitreal surface of the retina and microglial cells in various retinal layers. The microglial cells had a bipolar or multipolar morphology. Bipolar cells were observed in the nerve fibre layer, and multipolar cells were visualised in the ganglion cell layer (GCL), inner plexiform layer (IPL), and outer plexiform layer. The highest densities of multipolar cells were observed in the IPL layer, where they adopted a regular mosaic-like arrangement in which the occasional spaces were occupied by cells of the GCL. After optic nerve crush, we observed an increase in the number of compact cells associated with the vessels and changes in NDPase activity, morphology, and distribution of the retinal microglial cells. These cells showed an increase in NDPase activity in all retinal layers from day 1 to day 15 after axotomy, and retraction of their processes from day 1 to day 7. In addition, the densities of microglial cells increased in the GCL between 2 and 15 days after axotomy, and decreased in the IPL by day 4 after axotomy. These microglial changes resemble those observed in other regenerating and nonregenerating neuronal systems and may reflect a general response of microglia directed to help the regeneration process.

Circumferential migration of ameboid microglia in the margin of the developing quail retina

Central-to-peripheral migration of QH1-positive microglial precursors occurs in the vitrealmost part of the developing quail retina. This study shows that some QH1-positive ameboid cells with morphological features of migrating cells are already present in the margin of the retina before microglial precursors migrating centrally to peripherally arrive in this zone. Because the earlier cells are oriented parallel to the ora serrata, we deduce that some microglial cells migrate circumferentially in the margin of the retina, whereas other microglial precursors migrate from central to peripheral zones. Microglial cells that migrate circumferentially are first seen on embryonic day 6 (E6) and advance in a temporal-to-dorsal-to-nasal direction from the temporoventral quadrant of the retina. When cells migrating centrally to peripherally reach the retinal margin, they meet those migrating circumferentially. From E6 on, some QH1-positive dendritic cells in the ciliary body bear processes that penetrate the retina, where they are oriented circumferentially. These observations suggest that microglial cells that migrate circumferentially in the retinal margin share a common origin with dendritic cells of the ciliary body. Therefore, microglial cells of the quail retina appear to make up a heterogeneous population, with some cells originating from the pecten/optic nerve head area and others from the ciliary body.

Colonisation of the developing human brain and spinal cord by microglia: a review

Microglia are the immune effector cells of the nervous system. The prevailing view is that microglia are derived from circulating precursors in the blood, which originate from the bone-marrow. Colonisation of the central nervous system (CNS) by microglia is an orchestrated response during human fetal development related to the maturation of the nervous system. It coincides with vascularisation, formation of radial glia, neuronal migration and myelination primarily in the 4th-5th months and beyond. Microglial influx generally conforms to a route following white matter tracts to gray areas. We have observed that colonisation of the spinal cord begins around 9 weeks, with the major influx and distribution of microglia commencing around 16 weeks. In the cerebrum, colonisation is in progress during the second trimester, and ramified microglial forms are widely distributed within the intermediate zone by the first half of intra-uterine life (20-22 weeks). A distinct pattern of migration occurs along radial glia, white matter tracts and vasculature. The distribution of these cells is likely to be co-ordinated by spatially and temporally regulated, anatomical expression of chemokines including RANTES and MCP-1 in the cortex; by ICAM-2 and PECAM on radiating cerebral vessels and on capillaries within the germinal layer, and apoptotic cell death overlying this region. The phenotype and functional characteristics of fetal microglia are also outlined in this review. The need for specific cellular interactions and targeting is greater within the central nervous system than in other tissues. In this respect, microglia may additionally contribute towards CNS histogenesis.

Development of microglial topography in human retina

The development of microglial topography in wholemounts of human retina has been examined in the age range 10-25 weeks gestation (WG) using histochemistry and immunohistochemistry for CD45 and major histocompatibility complex class II antigens. Microglia were present in three planes corresponding to the developing nerve fibre layer/ganglion cell layer, the inner plexiform layer and the outer plexiform layer. Distribution patterns of cells through the retinal thickness and across the retinal surface area varied with gestational age. Microglia were elongated in superficial retina, large and ramified in the middle plane, and small, rounded and less ramified in deep retina. Intensely labeled, rounded profiles seen at the pars caeca of the ciliary processes, the retinal margin and at the optic disc may represent precursors of some retinal microglia. At 10 WG, the highest densities of microglia were present in middle and deep retina in the far periphery and at the retinal margin, with few superficial microglia evident centrally at the optic disc. At 14 WG, high densities of microglia were apparent superficially at the optic disc; microglia of middle and deep retina were distributed at more central locations although continuing to concentrate in the retinal periphery. Microglia appear to migrate into the developing human retina from two mains sources, the retinal margin and the optic disc, most likely originating from the blood vessels of the ciliary body and iris, and the retinal vasculature, respectively. The data suggest that the development of microglial topography occurs in two phases, an early phase occurring prior to vascularization, and a late phase associated with the development of the retinal vasculature.

Ontogeny and cellular expression of MHC and leucocyte antigens in human retina

We have investigated the ontogeny of MHC class I, class II, CD45, and macrophage antigens in whole mounts of normal human fetal retina at 10-25 weeks gestation (WG) using monoclonal antibodies and immunogold histochemistry. MHC class I antigens were expressed on retinal vascular endothelial cells and provided a useful marker of vessel organization from 14-25 WG. Microglial cells expressed immunoreactivity to MHC class I, class II, and CD45 antigens from 10 WG (pre-vascularization) and macrophage S22 (Mac S22) antigen from 14 WG (post-vascularization), although none of the antigens tested were detected on neuronal or macroglial elements. Microglia expressing MHC, CD45, and macrophage antigens occurred in both ramified and rounded forms with no close correlation being observed between morphology and antigenicity. The numbers of immunoreactive cells labeled with each of the four markers increased steadily throughout gestation in all specimens studied. Equivalent numbers of microglia expressed MHC class I, class II, and CD45 antigens in retinae at similar gestational ages; however, our data indicate that microglia expressing Mac S22 antigen comprise approximately 40% or less of the population of MHC and CD45-immunoreactive cells during development. Topographical analyses suggest that MHC class I, class II, and CD45-positive microglia enter the retina from both the peripheral retinal margin and the optic disc from at least 10 WG; Mac S22-positive cells appear in association with the development of the retinal vasculature and enter the retina via the optic disc after 14 WG.

Origin of microglia in the quail retina: central-to-peripheral and vitreal-to-scleral migration of microglial precursors during development

The origin, migration, and differentiation of microglial precursors in the avascular quail retina during embryonic and posthatching development were examined in this study. Microglial precursors and developing microglia were immunocytochemically labeled with QH1 antibody in retinal whole mounts and sections. The retina was free of QH1+ macrophages at embryonic day 5 (E5). Ameboid QH1+ macrophages from the pecten entered the retina from E7 on. These macrophages spread from central to peripheral areas in the retina by migrating on the endfeet of the Müller cells and reached the periphery of the retina at E12. While earlier macrophages were migrating along the inner limiting membrane, other macrophages continued to enter the retina from the pecten until hatching (E16). From E9 on, macrophages were seen to colonize progressively more scleral retinal layers as development advanced. Macrophages first appeared in the ganglion cell layer at E9, in the inner plexiform layer at E12, and in the outer plexiform layer at E14. Therefore, it seems that macrophages first migrated tangentially along the inner retinal surface and then migrated from vitreal to scleral levels to gain access to the plexiform layers, where they differentiated into ramified microglia. Macrophages appeared to differentiate shortly after arrival in the plexiform layers, as poorly ramified QH1+ cells were seen as early as E12 in the inner plexiform layer and at E14 in the outer plexiform layer. Radial migration of macrophages toward the outer plexiform layer continued until posthatching day 3, after which retinal microglia showed an adult distribution pattern. We also observed numerous vitreal macrophages intimately adhered to the surface of the pecten during embryonic development, when macrophages migrated into the retina. These vitreal macrophages were not seen from hatching onwards, when no further macrophages entered the retina.

Microglia in the avian retina: immunocytochemical demonstration in the adult quail

Immunocytochemical techniques were used in conjunction with the QH1 antibody to study the morphological characteristics and distribution of microglia in the avascular retina of an avian species (the quail). The majority of microglial cells appeared in the outer and inner plexiform layers throughout the entire retina, whereas a few microglial cells in the nerve fiber layer were seen only in the central zone of the retina, near the optic nerve head. In the outer plexiform layer, microglial cells were star-shaped, with processes that ramified profusely in the horizontal plane. Fine process tips extended outward radially, insinuating themselves among the photoreceptors. A regular mosaic-like arrangement of microglial cells was evident in the outer plexiform layer, with no overlapping between adjacent cell territories. Microglial cells in the inner plexiform layer ramified through the entire width of this layer, showing radial and horizontal processes. Microglia in the inner plexiform layer also tended to be regularly distributed in a mosaic-like fashion, although there was slight overlapping between adjacent cell territories. Microglia density in this layer was approximately twice that in the outer plexiform layer. This pattern of microglial distribution was similar to that described in vascular retinae of several species of mammals, a finding that suggest that blood vessels are not responsible for the final locations of microglia in the adult retina, and that microglial precursors must migrate through long distances before they reach their precise destination.

Brain macrophages: evaluation of microglia and their functions

There is now evidence approaching, if not having already surpassed, overwhelming in support of microglial cells as macrophages. Consistent with this cellular identity, they appear to arise from monocytes in developing brain where amoeboid microglia function in removing cell death-associated debris and in regulating gliogenesis. In normal adult tissue, ramified microglial cells with down-regulated macrophage functional properties may serve a constitutive role in cleansing the extracellular fluid. Under all conditions of brain injury, microglia appear to activate and convert into active macrophages. Activated and reactive microglia participate in inflammation, removal of cellular debris and wound-healing, the latter through regulation of gliosis in scar formation and a potential contribution to neural regeneration and neovascularization. In the activated state, microglia also express MHC's and, thus, may function in antigen presentation and lymphocyte activation for CNS immune responses. As uniquely adapted tissue resident macrophages within the CNS, microglia serve a variety of functional roles over the lifespan of this tissue. These cells may therefore be involved in or contribute to some disease states; such has been indicated in multiple sclerosis and AIDS dementia complex.

Antibodies to human leucocyte antigens indicate subpopulations of microglia in human retina

Monoclonal antibodies to human leucocyte antigens, including anti-CD45 and anti-CD68, have been used to describe microglia in flatmounts of normal adult human retina for the first time. Anti-CD45 (the leucocyte common antigen) intensely labeled large numbers of cells in a regular distribution across the retina; anti-CD68 and anti-macrophage antibodies labeled fewer cells with distinctive morphologies, suggesting the presence of subpopulations of microglia in the human retina expressing leucocyte antigens.

Macrophages, microglial cells, and HLA-DR antigens in fetal and infant brain

Immunohistochemical reactions for macrophages, microglia, and HLA-DR antigens were tested on frozen sections of necropsy brain tissue from 20 fetuses and infants ranging in age from 18 weeks' gestation to 8 months post term. No primary central nervous system disease was present but there were four cases of sudden infant death syndrome (SIDS). Macrophages were detected in all the samples studied and were located in the germinal matrix zone, in perivascular spaces throughout the brain, and in the leptomeninges and subependymal layer. Well differentiated microglia were present in all cases examined after 35 weeks' gestation and less well ramified forms were seen at earlier stages of gestation. HLA-DR antigens were detected on a small number of macrophages, chiefly in a perivascular location, in all but three cases. The fewest reactive cells and the weakest reactions occurred in the youngest fetuses. One case of SIDS showed increased foci of microglia in perivascular white matter: this case and one other case of SIDS were the only cases with well ramified microglia that expressed HLA-DR antigens. These findings may be relevant to an understanding of local immune responses in fetal brain infections, including human immunodeficiency virus infection.

Macrophage-like cells in the presumptive optic pathways in the floor of the diencephalon of the chick embryo

In the suboptic necrotic centres (SONCs) of the chick embryo diencephalon floor, large numbers of cells die in Hamburger and Hamilton's (HH) developmental stages 14-23. Until recently, it was thought that in these centres, the fragments of dead cells were phagocytosed exclusively by neighboring healthy cells but not by specialized macrophages. We now report morphological evidence of macrophage-like cells within the SONCs of the chick embryo. The distinctive features of these cells are their more or less spherical shape, a nucleus with a thin band of heterochromatin just beneath the nuclear envelope, and cytoplasm showing abundant digestive vacuoles and mitochondria with an electron-lucent matrix. These cells are capable of undergoing mitosis, and selectively stain with the histochemical technique for acid phosphatase. The macrophage-like cells are rare in SONCs in stages HH14-20 and become much more abundant in developmental stages just before the disappearance of these necrotic centres, suggesting that they phagocytose debris from the last cells to die in the SONCs. Acid phosphatase-positive mesenchymal cells with morphological features similar to those of macrophage-like cells are seen in intimate relationship with the basal surface of the SONCs in places where the basal lamina is sometimes missing. These observations suggest that macrophage-like cells in the SONCs arise from the underlying mesenchyme. Free macrophage-like cells with mitotic capacity are also seen in the ventricular lumen adjacent to the apical surface of the diencephalon floor in zones related to the presumptive optic pathways. These cells phagocytose cell debris shed from both the SONCs and from the partially disorganized areas in the neuroepithelium. In these latter we have identified mesenchymal cells with morphological features similar to the macrophage-like cells in the process of traversing the neuroepithelium from the mesenchymal compartment toward the ventricular lumen, thus suggesting that the intraventricular macrophage-like cells arise from the mesenchyme underlying the diencephalon floor.

Development of microglia in the albino rabbit retina

In this study the development of ameboid microglia and resting microglia in the retina of the albino rabbit has been examined by means of a lectin derived from Griffonia simplicifolia. Ameboid microglia are present in the retina as early as E12, when the optic fissure is in the process of closure, and appear to be concentrated initially at the vitreal surface. At E14 many ameboid microglia can be seen to extend processes to the ventricular surface of the cytoblast layer, but in subsequent ages these cells are rare and ameboid microglia are largely confined to the ganglion cell layer, inner plexiform layer, and occasionally the developing inner nuclear layer. By adult life, mature (or resting) microglia are confined to the inner plexiform and ganglion cell layers. Numbers of microglia increase steadily throughout fetal life from a mean of 400 at E14, the earliest age quantified, to a peak of 28,600 at E30. There is a small postnatal drop in numbers to 17,150 at P9. Microglia could only be labelled faintly in animals older than P11, but analysis of two adult (P130) retinas with adequate labelling suggested that numbers rise to a value of about 23,800 at this age. Ameboid microglia thus appear in the retina 11 days prior to the onset of axon loss in the optic nerve (about E23) and 14 days prior to the beginning of the period of reduction of retinal ganglion cell numbers (about E26). The present findings indicate that while some microglial precursors may enter the retina in response to debris generated during the natural retinal ganglion cell death period, most enter the retina well before this period. Also, microglia present a uniform density distribution with apparently regular spacing as early as E16, so the uniform regular distribution cannot simply be the consequence of regularly distributed pyknotic figures as previously suggested.

The appearance and distribution of microglia in the developing retina of the rat

We have examined the development of microglia in the rat retina, using a peroxidase-conjugated lectin derived from Griffonia simplicifolia. Retinas were studied from animals aged from E(embryonic day)12, just after the invagination of the optic cup and prior to the closure of the optic fissure, to adulthood. The lectin also proved a sensitive label for the endothelial cells of the developing retina. Our results provide some support for the view that microglia are derived from the monocyte-macrophage series of blood cells. At E12, most labeled cells were found at the vitreal surface, suggesting that they had come from the hyaloid circulation, while some had entered the retina and appeared to be migrating towards its ventricular surface. From E14 to early postnatal ages, most labeled cells had processes and resembled the amoeboid microglial cells described in silver carbonate staining studies (Ling, 1982). The number of labeled cells rose from about 700 to E14 to a peak of about 27,000 at P(postnatal day)7, and fell to about 19,600 by P12. As early as E16, a regularity was apparent in the distribution of microglial cells over the surface of the retina, the cells tending to avoid each other. Microglial cells are found throughout the thickness of the very young retina, but as the layers of the retina differentiate, they are increasingly restricted to the inner half of the retina. Our findings indicate that microglia enter the retina well before the period of neuronal death, making it unlikely that they invade the retina solely in response to cell death. Our results confirm however that, once in the retina, microglia become associated with, and appear to phagocytose, the pyknotic debris which appears during the period of neuronal death. They also become closely associated with the retinal vasculature. In the adult, the intensity of the labeling of microglia was much reduced. Those cells which were labeled appeared more differentiated, resembling the "resting microglia" described in earlier studies.