The expression of deafferentation dysesthesias reduced by dorsal root entry zone lesions in the rat

Electrical stimulation of dorsal root entry zone attenuates wide-dynamic-range neuronal activity in rats

OBJECTIVES

Recent clinical studies suggest that neurostimulation at the dorsal root entry zone (DREZ) may alleviate neuropathic pain. However, the mechanisms of action for this therapeutic effect are unclear. Here, we examined whether DREZ stimulation inhibits spinal wide-dynamic-range (WDR) neuronal activity in nerve-injured rats.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We conducted in vivo extracellular single-unit recordings of WDR neurons in rats after an L5 spinal nerve ligation (SNL) or sham surgery. We set bipolar electrical stimulation (50 Hz, 0.2 msec, 5 min) of the DREZ at the intensity that activated only Aα/β-fibers by measuring the lowest current at which DREZ stimulation evoked a peak antidromic sciatic Aα/β-compound action potential without inducing an Aδ/C-compound action potential (i.e., Ab1).

RESULTS

The elevated spontaneous activity rate of WDR neurons in SNL rats (n = 25; data combined from post-SNL groups at days 14-16 [n = 15] and days 45-75 [n = 10]) was significantly decreased from the prestimulation level (p < 0.01) at 0-15 min and 30-45 min post-stimulation. In both sham-operated (n = 8) and nerve-injured rats, DREZ stimulation attenuated the C-component, but not the A-component, of the WDR neuronal response to graded intracutaneous electrical stimuli (0.1-10 mA, 2 msec) applied to the skin receptive field. Further, DREZ stimulation blocked windup (a form of brief neuronal sensitization) to repetitive noxious stimuli (0.5 Hz) at 0-15 min in all groups (p < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Attenuation of WDR neuronal activity may contribute to DREZ stimulation-induced analgesia. This finding supports the notion that DREZ may be a useful target for neuromodulatory control of pain.

Deafferentation Pain Resulting from Cervical Posterior Rhizotomy is Alleviated by Chromaffin Cell Transplants into the Rat Spinal Subarachnoid Space

OBJECTIVE

Deafferentation pain is common after posttraumatic brachial plexus avulsion in humans. Alleviation of such pain is poorly achieved by most therapeutic interventions; the only efficient neurosurgical procedure currently available is lesioning of the dorsal root entry zone. Previous work has demonstrated that adrenal medullary transplants into the lumbar spinal subarachnoid space can alleviate neuropathic pain behavior resulting from peripheral nerve or spinal cord injury. The purpose of this study was to evaluate the potential effects of adrenal medullary transplants on brachial plexus deafferentation pain.

METHODS

The cervical posterior rhizotomy model was selected as an upper segmental deafferentation model because it mimics the pathological situation after traumatic brachial plexus avulsion in humans. Animals underwent a right posterior cervical rhizotomy extending from C5 to T1 and received either adrenal medullary transplants or control striated muscle transplants into the cervical subarachnoid space. The clinical evolution was evaluated daily for self-directed behaviors indicative of ongoing pain, including onset, dermatomal extent, and severity.

RESULTS

In animals with muscle control transplants, self-directed behaviors appeared in 83.3% of the group, with a mean delay between rhizotomy and onset of self-directed behaviors of 8 days. In contrast, only 30.8% of the animals implanted with chromaffin cells exhibited any signs of self-directed behaviors, and these had a mean onset delay of 14 days.

CONCLUSION

The suppression of self-directed behaviors by adrenal medullary transplants is similar to that observed after dorsal root entry zone lesioning and suggests that this approach may offer a nonablative alternative in the management of deafferentation pain resulting from dorsal root avulsion.

Trigeminal nucleus caudalis dorsal root entry zone radiofrequency thermocoagulation for invalidating facial pain

INTRODUCTION

Facial pain syndromes occasionally result in desperate clinical settings completely unresponsive to any known therapy. Trigeminal nucleus caudalis dorsal root entry zone (DREZ) lesion is reported to be of benefit in such cases. In 1982 Nashold performed the first DREZ caudalis lesion in a patient with anaesthesia dolorosa.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

From 1994 to 2002 we have performed six DREZ caudalis lesions on five patients with extremely invalidating facial pain resistant to multiple pharmacological and surgical therapies. Pain was secondary to previous craniofacial surgery in all but one case. Pain presented as anaesthesia dolorosa or atypical facial pain so severe as to interfere with personal hygiene and even to prevent patients from oral feeding. A midline suboccipital approach was used and radiofrequency lesions (at the trigeminal nucleus caudalis in the cervicomedullary junction) were made at 1-mm intervals, 75 (o)C for 15 seconds each along the ipsilateral posterolateral sulcus from the cervical DREZ up to the obex.

RESULTS

Pain relief was complete and permanent in two patients. Three patients experienced significant improvement but pain recurred in two (weeks to a few months after the procedure). No patient's pain was made worse. A patient with persistent postoperative nasolabial pain was re-operated on (improving again but ultimately remaining unchanged). Air venous embolism related to the sitting position (3 patients) during surgery and bradycardia due to manipulation in medulla (2 patients) occurred during some of the procedures without any cardiovascular or neurological repercussion. Postoperative complications included mild and transient ataxia and monoparesia (3 patients).

DISCUSSION

Facial pain secondary to craniofacial surgery is known to be among the least responsive to treatment and a true challenge for pain clinicians. Actual indications for this procedure, operative technical details and the results of our series compared to previous reports are reviewed.

CONCLUSION

Trigeminal nucleus caudalis radiofrequency thermocoagulation is an effective neurosurgical procedure for the treatment of chronically debilitating and desperate facial pain syndromes with acceptable morbidity.

Clinical and electrophysiological expression of deafferentation pain alleviated by dorsal root entry zone lesions in rats

OBJECT

The aims of this study were to construct an animal model of deafferentation of the spinal cord by brachial plexus avulsion and to analyze the effects of subsequent dorsal root entry zone (DREZ) lesions in this model. To this end, the authors measured the clinical and electrophysiological effects of total deafferentation of the cervical dorsal horn in rats and evaluated the clinical efficacy of cervical DREZ lesioning.

METHODS

Forty-three Sprague-Dawley rats were subjected to total deafferentation of the right cervical dorsal horn by performing a posterior rhizotomy from C-5 to T-1. The clinical effects of this deafferentation, namely self-directed mutilations consisting of scraping and/or ulceration of the forelimb skin or even autotomy of some forelimb digits, were then evaluated. As soon as some of these clinical signs of pain appeared, the authors performed a microsurgical DREZ rhizotomy ([MDR], microincision along the deafferented DREZ and dorsal horn). Before and after MDR, single-unit recordings were obtained in the deafferented dorsal horn and in the contralateral (healthy) side. The mean frequency of spontaneous discharge from the deafferented dorsal horn neurons was significantly higher than that from the healthy side (36.4 Hz compared with 17.9 Hz, p = 0.03). After deafferentation, 81.4% of the rats developed clinical signs corresponding to pain following posterior rhizotomy. Among these animals, scraping was observed in 85.7% of cases, ulceration (associated with edema) in 37.1%, and autotomy in 8.5%. These signs appeared a mean 5.7 weeks (range 1-12 weeks) after deafferentation. Thirteen rats benefited from an MDR; nine (69%) experienced a complete cure, that is, a total resolution of scraping or ulceration (a mean 4.6 weeks after MDR). In contrast, only one of 11 sham-operated animals showed signs of spontaneous recovery (p = 0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

These results emphasize the role of the spinal dorsal horn in the genesis of deafferentation pain and suggest that dorsal horn deafferentation by cervical posterior rhizotomy in the rat provides a reliable model of chronic pain due to brachial plexus avulsion and its suppression by MDR.

Treatment of Refractory Pain after Brachial Plexus Avulsion with Dorsal Root Entry Zone Lesions

OBJECTIVE

Significant numbers of patients experience intractable pain after brachial plexus root avulsions. Medications and surgical procedures such as amputation of the limb are often not successful in pain treatment.

METHODS

Forty-seven patients with intractable pain after traumatic cervical root avulsions were treated with dorsal root entry zone coagulation between 1980 and 1998. The dorsal root entry zone coagulation procedure was performed 4 months to 12 years after the trauma, and patients were monitored for up to 18 years (average follow-up period, 14 yr).

RESULTS

Immediately after surgery, 75% of patients experienced significant pain reduction; this value was reduced to 63% during long-term follow-up monitoring. Nine patients experienced major complications, including subdural hematomas (n = 2) and motor weakness of the lower limb (n = 7). Improved coagulation electrodes with thermistors that could produce smaller and more-accurate lesion sizes, which were introduced in 1989, significantly reduced the number of complications.

CONCLUSION

Central deafferentation pain that persists and becomes intractable among patients with traumatic cervical root avulsions has been difficult to treat in the past. Long-term follow-up monitoring of patients who underwent the dorsal root entry zone coagulation procedure in the cervical cord indicated that long-lasting satisfactory relief is possible for the majority of individuals, with acceptable morbidity rates.

Correlation between autotomy-behavior and current theories of neuropathic pain

The past 10 years have brought several new experimental models with which to study chronic neuropathic pain in animals. Consequently, our knowledge about the mechanisms subserving neuropathic pain in humans has improved. However, the first animal model that was used for studying this type of chronic pain was the autotomy-model which can still be considered as a useful tool for pain studies. The present review assesses some of the similarities and differences between autotomy-model and more recent models of experimental traumatic mononeuropathy. In addition, it considers some of the similarities between the results obtained in clinical studies and in autotomy studies.