Dynamic Modeling of Streptococcus pneumoniae Competence Provides Regulatory Mechanistic Insights Into Its Tight Temporal Regulation

Pneumococcal competence is a populational health sensor driving multilevel heterogeneity in response to antibiotics

Competence for natural transformation is a central driver of genetic diversity in bacteria. In the human pathogen Streptococcus pneumoniae, competence exhibits a populational character mediated by the stress-induced ComABCDE quorum-sensing (QS) system. Here, we explore how this cell-to-cell communication mechanism proceeds and the functional properties acquired by competent cells grown under lethal stress. We show that populational competence development depends on self-induced cells stochastically emerging in response to stresses, including antibiotics. Competence then propagates through the population from a low threshold density of self-induced cells, defining a biphasic Self-Induction and Propagation (SI&P) QS mechanism. We also reveal that a competent population displays either increased sensitivity or improved tolerance to lethal doses of antibiotics, dependent in the latter case on the competence-induced ComM division inhibitor. Remarkably, these surviving competent cells also display an altered transformation potential. Thus, the unveiled SI&P QS mechanism shapes pneumococcal competence as a health sensor of the clonal population, promoting a bet-hedging strategy that both responds to and drives cells towards heterogeneity.

Evolutionary innovation through transcription factor rewiring in microbes is shaped by levels of transcription factor activity, expression, and existing connectivity

The survival of a population during environmental shifts depends on whether the rate of phenotypic adaptation keeps up with the rate of changing conditions. A common way to achieve this is via change to gene regulatory network (GRN) connections-known as rewiring-that facilitate novel interactions and innovation of transcription factors. To understand the success of rapidly adapting organisms, we therefore need to determine the rules that create and constrain opportunities for GRN rewiring. Here, using an experimental microbial model system with the soil bacterium Pseudomonas fluorescens, we reveal a hierarchy among transcription factors that are rewired to rescue lost function, with alternative rewiring pathways only unmasked after the preferred pathway is eliminated. We identify 3 key properties-high activation, high expression, and preexisting low-level affinity for novel target genes-that facilitate transcription factor innovation. Ease of acquiring these properties is constrained by preexisting GRN architecture, which was overcome in our experimental system by both targeted and global network alterations. This work reveals the key properties that determine transcription factor evolvability, and as such, the evolution of GRNs.

Fever-like temperature bursts promote competence development via an HtrA-dependent pathway in Streptococcus pneumoniae

Streptococcus pneumoniae (the pneumococcus) is well known for its ability to develop competence for natural DNA transformation. Competence development is regulated by an autocatalytic loop driven by variations in the basal level of transcription of the comCDE and comAB operons. These genes are part of the early gene regulon that controls expression of the late competence genes known to encode the apparatus of transformation. Several stressful conditions are known to promote competence development, although the induction pathways are remain poorly understood. Here we demonstrate that transient temperature elevation induces an immediate increase in the basal expression level of the comCDE operon and early genes that, in turn, stimulates its full induction, including that of the late competence regulon. This thermal regulation depends on the HtrA chaperone/protease and its proteolytic activity. We find that other competence induction stimulus, like norfloxacin, is not conveyed by the HtrA-dependent pathway. This finding strongly suggests that competence can be induced by at least two independent pathways and thus reinforces the view that competence is a general stress response system in the pneumococcus.

Transcription factor expression levels and environmental signals constrain transcription factor innovation

Evolutionary innovation of transcription factors frequently drives phenotypic diversification and adaptation to environmental change. Transcription factors can gain or lose connections to target genes, resulting in novel regulatory responses and phenotypes. However the frequency of functional adaptation varies between different regulators, even when they are closely related. To identify factors influencing propensity for innovation, we utilise a Pseudomonas fluorescens SBW25 strain rendered incapable of flagellar mediated motility in soft-agar plates via deletion of the flagellar master regulator (fleQ ). This bacterium can evolve to rescue flagellar motility via gene regulatory network rewiring of an alternative transcription factor to rescue activity of FleQ. Previously, we have identified two members (out of 22) of the RpoN-dependent enhancer binding protein (RpoN-EBP) family of transcription factors (NtrC and PFLU1132) that are capable of innovating in this way. These two transcription factors rescue motility repeatably and reliably in a strict hierarchy – with NtrC the only route in a ∆fleQ background, and PFLU1132 the only route in a ∆fleQ ∆ntrC background. However, why other members in the same transcription factor family have not been observed to rescue flagellar activity is unclear. Previous work shows that protein homology cannot explain this pattern within the protein family (RpoN-EBPs), and mutations in strains that rescued motility suggested high levels of transcription factor expression and activation drive innovation. We predict that mutations that increase expression of the transcription factor are vital to unlock evolutionary potential for innovation. Here, we construct titratable expression mutant lines for 11 of the RpoN-EBPs in P. fluorescens . We show that in five additional RpoN-EBPs (FleR, HbcR, GcsR, DctD, AauR and PFLU2209), high expression levels result in different mutations conferring motility rescue, suggesting alternative rewiring pathways. Our results indicate that expression levels (and not protein homology) of RpoN-EBPs are a key constraining factor in determining evolutionary potential for innovation. This suggests that transcription factors that can achieve high expression through few mutational changes, or transcription factors that are active in the selective environment, are more likely to innovate and contribute to adaptive gene regulatory network evolution.

comCDE (Competence) Operon Is Regulated by CcpA in Streptococcus pneumoniae D39

Natural transformation plays an important role in the formation of drug-resistant bacteria. Exploring the regulatory mechanism of natural transformation can aid the discovery of new antibacterial targets and reduce the emergence of drug-resistant bacteria. Competence is a prerequisite of natural transformation in Streptococcus pneumoniae, in which comCDE operon is the core regulator of competence. To date, only ComE has been shown to directly regulate comCDE transcription. In this study, a transcriptional regulator, the catabolite control protein A (CcpA), was identified that directly regulated comCDE transcription. We confirmed that CcpA binds to the cis-acting catabolite response elements (cre) in the comCDE promoter region to regulate comCDE transcription and transformation. Moreover, CcpA can coregulate comCDE transcription with phosphorylated and dephosphorylated ComE. Regulation of comCDE transcription and transformation by CcpA was also affected by carbon source signals. Together, these insights demonstrate the versatility of CcpA and provide a theoretical basis for reducing the emergence of drug-resistant bacteria. IMPORTANCE Streptococcus pneumoniae is a major cause of bacterial infections in humans, such as pneumonia, bacteremia, meningitis, otitis media, and sinusitis. Like most streptococci, S. pneumoniae is naturally competent and employs this ability to augment its adaptive evolution. The current study illustrates CcpA, a carbon catabolite regulator, can participate in the competence process by regulating comCDE transcription, and this process is regulated by different carbon source signals. These hidden abilities are likely critical for adaptation and colonization in the environment.

Airway proteolytic control of pneumococcal competence

Streptococcus pneumoniae is an opportunistic pathogen that colonizes the upper respiratory tract asymptomatically and, upon invasion, can lead to severe diseases including otitis media, sinusitis, meningitis, bacteremia, and pneumonia. One of the first lines of defense against pneumococcal invasive disease is inflammation, including the recruitment of neutrophils to the site of infection. The invasive pneumococcus can be cleared through the action of serine proteases generated by neutrophils. It is less clear how serine proteases impact non-invasive pneumococcal colonization, which is the key first step to invasion and transmission. One significant aspect of pneumococcal biology and adaptation in the respiratory tract is its natural competence, which is triggered by a small peptide CSP. In this study, we investigate if serine proteases are capable of degrading CSP and the impact this has on pneumococcal competence. We found that CSP has several potential sites for trypsin-like serine protease degradation and that there were preferential cleavage sites recognized by the proteases. Digestion of CSP with two different trypsin-like serine proteases dramatically reduced competence in a dose-dependent manner. Incubation of CSP with mouse lung homogenate also reduced recombination frequency of the pneumococcus. These ex vivo experiments suggested that serine proteases in the lower respiratory tract reduce pneumococcal competence. This was subsequently confirmed measuring in vivo recombination frequencies after induction of protease production via poly (I:C) stimulation and via co-infection with influenza A virus, which dramatically lowered recombination events. These data shed light on a new mechanism by which the host can modulate pneumococcal behavior and genetic exchange via direct degradation of the competence signaling peptide.

Investigating the Streptococcus sinensis competence regulon through a combination of transcriptome analysis and phenotypic evaluation

Streptococcus sinensis is a recently identified member of the Mitis group of streptococci. This species has been associated with infective endocarditis; however its mechanisms of pathogenesis and virulence are not fully understood. This study aimed to investigate the influence of the competence-stimulating peptide (CSP) and the competence regulon quorum-sensing circuitry (ComABCDE) on subsequent gene transcription and expression, as well as resultant phenotypes. In this study we confirmed the native CSP identity, ascertained when endogenous CSP was produced and completed a transcriptome-wide analysis of all genes following CSP exposure. RNA sequencing analysis revealed the upregulation of genes known to be associated with competence, biofilm formation and virulence. As such, a variety of phenotypic assays were utilized to assess the correlation between increased mRNA expression and potential phenotype response, ultimately gaining insight into the effects of CSP on both gene expression and developed phenotypes. The results indicated that the addition of exogenous CSP aided in competence development and successful transformation, yielding an average transformation efficiency comparable to that of other Mitis group streptococci. Additional studies are needed to further delineate the effects of CSP exposure on biofilm formation and virulence. Overall, this study provides novel information regarding S. sinensis and provides a substantial foundation on which this species and its role in disease pathogenesis can be further investigated.

Gene Expression Regulation in Airway Pathogens: Importance for Otitis Media

Otitis media (OM) is an inflammatory disorder in the middle ear. It is mainly caused by viruses or bacteria associated with the airways. Streptococcus pneumoniae, Haemophilus influenzae and Moraxella catarrhalis are the three main pathogens in infection-related OM, especially in younger children. In this review, we will focus upon the multifaceted gene regulation mechanisms that are well-orchestrated in S. pneumoniae, H. influenzae, and M. catarrhalis during the course of infection in the middle ear either in experimental OM or in clinical settings. The sophisticated findings from the past 10 years on how the othopathogens govern their virulence phenotypes for survival and host adaptation via phase variation- and quorum sensing-dependent gene regulation, will be systematically discussed. Comprehensive understanding of gene expression regulation mechanisms employed by pathogens during the onset of OM may provide new insights for the design of a new generation of antimicrobial agents in the fight against bacterial pathogens while combating the serious emergence of antimicrobial resistance.

Tight Interplay between Replication Stress and Competence Induction in Streptococcus pneumoniae

Cells respond to genome damage by inducing restorative programs, typified by the SOS response of Escherichia coli. Streptococcus pneumoniae (the pneumococcus), with no equivalent to the SOS system, induces the genetic program of competence in response to many types of stress, including genotoxic drugs. The pneumococcal competence regulon is controlled by the origin-proximal, auto-inducible comCDE operon. It was previously proposed that replication stress induces competence through continued initiation of replication in cells with arrested forks, thereby increasing the relative comCDE gene dosage and expression and accelerating the onset of competence. We have further investigated competence induction by genome stress. We find that absence of RecA recombinase stimulates competence induction, in contrast to SOS response, and that double-strand break repair (RexB) and gap repair (RecO, RecR) initiation effectors confer a similar effect, implying that recombinational repair removes competence induction signals. Failure of replication forks provoked by titrating PolC polymerase with the base analogue HPUra, over-supplying DnaA initiator, or under-supplying DnaE polymerase or DnaC helicase stimulated competence induction. This induction was not correlated with concurrent changes in origin-proximal gene dosage. Our results point to arrested and unrepaired replication forks, rather than increased comCDE dosage, as a basic trigger of pneumococcal competence.

The alternative sigma factor σX mediates competence shut-off at the cell pole in Streptococcus pneumoniae

Competence is a widespread bacterial differentiation program driving antibiotic resistance and virulence in many pathogens. Here, we studied the spatiotemporal localization dynamics of the key regulators that master the two intertwined and transient transcription waves defining competence in Streptococcus pneumoniae. The first wave relies on the stress-inducible phosphorelay between ComD and ComE proteins, and the second on the alternative sigma factor σ^X, which directs the expression of the DprA protein that turns off competence through interaction with phosphorylated ComE. We found that ComD, σ^X and DprA stably co-localize at one pole in competent cells, with σ^X physically conveying DprA next to ComD. Through this polar DprA targeting function, σ^X mediates the timely shut-off of the pneumococcal competence cycle, preserving cell fitness. Altogether, this study unveils an unprecedented role for a transcription σ factor in spatially coordinating the negative feedback loop of its own genetic circuit.

Asian Sand Dust Particles Increased Pneumococcal Biofilm Formation in vitro and Colonization in Human Middle Ear Epithelial Cells and Rat Middle Ear Mucosa

INTRODUCTION

Air pollutants such as Asian sand dust (ASD) and Streptococcus pneumoniae are risk factors for otitis media (OM). In this study, we evaluate the role of ASD in pneumococcal in vitro biofilm growth and colonization on human middle ear epithelium cells (HMEECs) and rat middle ear using the rat OM model.

METHODS

S. pneumoniae D39 in vitro biofilm growth in the presence of ASD (50-300 μg/ml) was evaluated in metal ion-free BHI medium using CV-microplate assay, colony-forming unit (cfu) counts, resazurin staining, scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and confocal microscopy (CF). Biofilm gene expression analysis was performed using real-time RT-PCR. The effects of ASD or S. pneumoniae individually or on co-treatment on HMEECs were evaluated by detecting HMEEC viability, apoptosis, and reactive oxygen species (ROS) production. In vivo colonization of S. pneumoniae in the presence of ASD was evaluated using the rat OM model, and RNA-Seq was used to evaluate the alterations in gene expression in rat middle ear mucosa.

RESULTS

S. pneumoniae biofilm growth was significantly (P < 0.05) elevated in the presence of ASD. SEM and CF analysis revealed thick and organized pneumococcal biofilms in the presence of ASD (300 μg/ml). However, in the absence of ASD, bacteria were unable to form organized biofilms, the cell size was smaller than normal, and long chain-like structures were formed. Biofilms grown in the presence of ASD showed elevated expression levels of genes involved in biofilm formation (luxS), competence (comA, comB, ciaR), and toxin production (lytA and ply). Prior exposure of HMEECs to ASD, followed by treatment for pneumococci, significantly (P < 0.05) decreased cell viability and increased apoptosis, and ROS production. In vivo experiment results showed significantly (P < 0.05) more than 65% increased bacteria colonization in rat middle ear mucosa in the presence of ASD. The apoptosis, cell death, DNA repair, inflammation and immune response were differentially regulated in three treatments; however, number of genes expressed in co-treatments was higher than single treatment. In co-treatment, antimicrobial protein/peptide-related genes (S100A family, Np4, DEFB family, and RATNP-3B) and OM-related genes (CYLD, SMAD, FBXO11, and CD14) were down regulated, and inflammatory cytokines and interleukins, such as IL1β, and TNF-related gene expression were elevated.

CONCLUSION

ASD presence increased the generation of pneumococcal biofilms and colonization.

Streptococcus pneumoniae Elaborates Persistent and Prolonged Competent State during Pneumonia-Derived Sepsis

The competence regulon of pneumococcus regulates both genetic transformation and virulence. However, competence induction during host infection has not been examined. By using the serotype 2 strain D39, we transcriptionally fused the firefly luciferase (luc) to competence-specific genes and spatiotemporally monitored the competence development in a mouse model of pneumonia-derived sepsis. In contrast to the universally reported short transient burst of competent state in vitro, the naturally developed competent state was prolonged and persistent during pneumonia-derived sepsis. The competent state began at approximately 20 h postinfection (hpi) and facilitated systemic invasion and sepsis development and progressed in different manners. In some mice, acute pneumonia quickly led to sepsis and death, accompanied by increasing intensity of the competence signal. In the remaining mice, pneumonia lasted longer, with the competence signal decreasing at first but increasing as the infection became septic. The concentration of pneumococcal inoculum (1 × 10⁶ to 1 × 10⁸ CFU/mouse) and postinfection lung bacterial burden did not appreciably impact the kinetics of competence induction. Exogenously provided competence stimulating peptide 1 (CSP1) failed to modulate the onset kinetics of competence development in vivo The competence shutoff regulator DprA was highly expressed during pneumonia-derived sepsis but failed to turn off the competent state in mice. Competent D39 bacteria propagated the competence signal through cell-to-cell contact rather than the classically described quorum-sensing mechanism. Finally, clinical pneumococcal strains of different serotypes were also able to develop natural competence during pneumonia-derived sepsis.

Bacterial Second Messenger Cyclic di-AMP Modulates the Competence State in Streptococcus pneumoniae

Streptococcus pneumoniae (the pneumococcus) is a naturally competent organism that causes diseases such as pneumonia, otitis media, and bacteremia. The essential bacterial second messenger cyclic di-AMP (c-di-AMP) is an emerging player in the stress responses of many pathogens. In S. pneumoniae, c-di-AMP is produced by a diadenylate cyclase, CdaA, and cleaved by phosphodiesterases Pde1 and Pde2. c-di-AMP binds a transporter of K+ (Trk) family protein, CabP, which subsequently halts K+ uptake via the transporter TrkH. Recently, it was reported that Pde1 and Pde2 are essential for pneumococcal virulence in mouse models of disease. To elucidate c-di-AMP-mediated transcription that may lead to changes in pathogenesis, we compared the transcriptomes of wild-type (WT) and Δpde1 Δpde2 strains by transcriptome sequencing (RNA-Seq) analysis. Notably, we found that many competence-associated genes are significantly upregulated in the Δpde1 Δpde2 strain compared to the WT. These genes play a role in DNA uptake, recombination, and autolysis. Competence is induced by a quorum-sensing mechanism initiated by the secreted factor competence-stimulating peptide (CSP). Surprisingly, the Δpde1 Δpde2 strain exhibited reduced transformation efficiency compared to WT bacteria, which was c-di-AMP dependent. Transformation efficiency was also directly related to the [K+] in the medium, suggesting a link between c-di-AMP function and the pneumococcal competence state. We found that a strain that possesses a V76G variation in CdaA produced less c-di-AMP and was highly susceptible to CSP. Deletion of cabP and trkH restored the growth of these bacteria in medium with CSP. Overall, our study demonstrates a novel role for c-di-AMP in the competence program of S. pneumoniaeIMPORTANCE Genetic competence in bacteria leads to horizontal gene transfer, which can ultimately affect antibiotic resistance, adaptation to stress conditions, and virulence. While the mechanisms of pneumococcal competence signaling cascades have been well characterized, the molecular mechanism behind competence regulation is not fully understood. The bacterial second messenger c-di-AMP has previously been shown to play a role in bacterial physiology and pathogenesis. In this study, we provide compelling evidence for the interplay between c-di-AMP and the pneumococcal competence state. These findings not only attribute a new biological function to this dinucleotide as a regulator of competence, transformation, and survival under stress conditions in pneumococci but also provide new insights into how pneumococcal competence is modulated.

DprA-Dependent Exit from the Competent State Regulates Multifaceted Streptococcus pneumoniae Virulence

Streptococcus pneumoniae (pneumococcus) causes multiple infectious diseases. The pneumococcal competence system facilitates genetic transformation, spreads antibiotic resistance, and contributes to virulence. DNA-processing protein A (DprA) regulates the exit of pneumococcus from the competent state. Previously, we have shown that DprA is important in both bacteremia and pneumonia infections. Here, we examined the mechanisms of virulence attenuation in a ΔdprA mutant. Compared to the parental wild-type D39, the ΔdprA mutant enters the competent state when exposed to lower concentrations of the competence-stimulating peptide CSP1. The ΔdprA mutant overexpresses ComM, which delays cell separation after division. Additionally, the ΔdprA mutant overexpresses allolytic factors LytA, CbpD, and CibAB and is more susceptible to detergent-triggered lysis. Disabling of the competent-state-specific induction of ComM and allolytic factors compensated for the virulence loss in the ΔdprA mutant, suggesting that overexpression of these factors contributes to virulence attenuation. Finally, the ΔdprA mutant fails to downregulate the expression of multiple competence-regulated genes, leading to the excessive energy consumption. Collectively, these results indicate that an inability to properly exit the competent state disrupts multiple cellular processes that cause virulence attenuation in the ΔdprA mutant.

Competence beyond Genes: Filling in the Details of the Pneumococcal Competence Transcriptome by a Systems Approach

DNA uptake by natural competence is a central process underlying the genetic plasticity, biology, and virulence of the human respiratory opportunistic pathogen Streptococcus pneumoniae A study reported in this issue (J. Slager, R. Aprianto, and J.-W. Veening, J. Bacteriol. 201:e00780-18, https://doi.org/10.1128/JB.00780-18) combined deep-genome annotation and high-resolution transcriptome analyses to considerably extend the previous model of temporal regulation of competence at the operon and component gene levels. That extended study also provides a playbook for updating, refining, and extending genomic data sets and making them publicly available.

Refining the Pneumococcal Competence Regulon by RNA Sequencing

Streptococcus pneumoniae is an opportunistic human pathogen responsible for over a million deaths every year. Although both vaccination programs and antibiotic therapies have been effective in prevention and treatment of pneumococcal infections, respectively, the sustainability of these solutions is uncertain. The pneumococcal genome is highly flexible, leading to vaccine escape and antibiotic resistance. This flexibility is predominantly facilitated by competence, a state allowing the cell to take up and integrate exogenous DNA. Thus, it is essential to obtain a detailed overview of gene expression during competence. This is stressed by the fact that administration of several classes of antibiotics can lead to competence. Previous studies on the competence regulon were performed with microarray technology and were limited to an incomplete set of known genes. Using RNA sequencing combined with an up-to-date genome annotation, we provide an updated overview of competence-regulated genes.

Competence for genetic transformation allows the opportunistic human pathogen Streptococcus pneumoniae to take up exogenous DNA for incorporation into its own genome. This ability may account for the extraordinary genomic plasticity of this bacterium, leading to antigenic variation, vaccine escape, and the spread of antibiotic resistance. The competence system has been thoroughly studied, and its regulation is well understood. Additionally, over the last decade, several stress factors have been shown to trigger the competent state, leading to the activation of several stress response regulons. The arrival of next-generation sequencing techniques allowed us to update the competence regulon, the latest report on which still depended on DNA microarray technology. Enabled by the availability of an up-to-date genome annotation, including transcript boundaries, we assayed time-dependent expression of all annotated features in response to competence induction, were able to identify the affected promoters, and produced a more complete overview of the various regulons activated during the competence state. We show that 4% of all annotated genes are under direct control of competence regulators ComE and ComX, while the expression of a total of up to 17% of all genes is affected, either directly or indirectly. Among the affected genes are various small RNAs with an as-yet-unknown function. Besides the ComE and ComX regulons, we were also able to refine the CiaR, VraR (LiaR), and BlpR regulons, underlining the strength of combining transcriptome sequencing (RNA-seq) with a well-annotated genome.

IMPORTANCEStreptococcus pneumoniae is an opportunistic human pathogen responsible for over a million deaths every year. Although both vaccination programs and antibiotic therapies have been effective in prevention and treatment of pneumococcal infections, respectively, the sustainability of these solutions is uncertain. The pneumococcal genome is highly flexible, leading to vaccine escape and antibiotic resistance. This flexibility is predominantly facilitated by competence, a state allowing the cell to take up and integrate exogenous DNA. Thus, it is essential to obtain a detailed overview of gene expression during competence. This is stressed by the fact that administration of several classes of antibiotics can lead to competence. Previous studies on the competence regulon were performed with microarray technology and were limited to an incomplete set of known genes. Using RNA sequencing combined with an up-to-date genome annotation, we provide an updated overview of competence-regulated genes.