Distribution, Evolution, Catalytic Mechanism, and Physiological Functions of the Flavin-Based Electron-Bifurcating NADH-Dependent Reduced Ferredoxin: NADP+ Oxidoreductase

Structures and Electron Transport Paths in the Four Families of Flavin-Based Electron Bifurcation Enzymes

Oxidoreductases facilitating electron transfer between molecules are pivotal in metabolic pathways. Flavin-based electron bifurcation (FBEB), a recently discovered energy coupling mechanism in oxidoreductases, enables the reversible division of electron pairs into two acceptors, bridging exergonic and otherwise unfeasible endergonic reactions. This chapter explores the four distinct FBEB complex families and highlights a decade of structural insights into FBEB complexes. In this chapter, we discuss the architecture, electron transfer routes, and conformational changes across all FBEB families, revealing the structural foundation that facilitate these remarkable functions.

Molecular architecture and electron transfer pathway of the Stn family transhydrogenase

The challenge of endergonic reduction of NADP+ using NADH is overcome by ferredoxin-dependent transhydrogenases that employ electron bifurcation for electron carrier adjustments in the ancient Wood-Ljungdahl pathway. Recently, an electron-bifurcating transhydrogenase with subunit compositions distinct from the well-characterized Nfn-type transhydrogenase was described: the Stn complex. Here, we present the single-particle cryo-EM structure of the Stn family transhydrogenase from the acetogenic bacterium Sporomusa ovata and functionally dissect its electron transfer pathway. Stn forms a tetramer consisting of functional heterotrimeric StnABC complexes. Our findings demonstrate that the StnAB subunits assume the structural and functional role of a bifurcating module, homologous to the HydBC core of the electron-bifurcating HydABC complex. Moreover, StnC contains a NuoG-like domain and a GltD-like NADPH binding domain that resembles the NfnB subunit of the NfnAB complex. However, in contrast to NfnB, StnC lost the ability to bifurcate electrons. Structural comparison allows us to describe how the same fold on one hand evolved bifurcation activity on its own while on the other hand combined with an associated bifurcating module, exemplifying modular evolution in anaerobic metabolism to produce activities critical for survival at the thermodynamic limit of life.

Nitrogen Fixation and Ammonium Assimilation Pathway Expression of Geobacter sulfurreducens Changes in Response to the Anode Potential in Microbial Electrochemical Cells

Nitrogen gas (N2) fixation in the anode-respiring bacterium Geobacter sulfurreducens occurs through complex, multistep processes. Optimizing ammonium (NH4+) production from this bacterium in microbial electrochemical technologies (METs) requires an understanding of how those processes are regulated in response to electrical driving forces. In this study, we quantified gene expression levels (via RNA sequencing) of G. sulfurreducens growing on anodes fixed at two different potentials (-0.15 V and +0.15 V versus standard hydrogen electrode). The anode potential had a significant impact on the expression levels of N2 fixation genes. At -0.15 V, the expression of nitrogenase genes, such as nifH, nifD, and nifK, significantly increased relative to that at +0.15 V, as well as genes associated with NH4+ uptake and transformation, such as glutamine and glutamate synthetases. Metabolite analysis confirmed that both of these organic compounds were present in significantly higher intracellular concentrations at -0.15 V. N2 fixation rates (estimated using the acetylene reduction assay and normalized to total protein) were significantly larger at -0.15 V. Genes expressing flavin-based electron bifurcation complexes, such as electron-transferring flavoproteins (EtfAB) and the NADH-dependent ferredoxin:NADP reductase (NfnAB), were also significantly upregulated at -0.15 V, suggesting that these mechanisms may be involved in N2 fixation at that potential. Our results show that in energy-constrained situations (i.e., low anode potential), the cells increase per-cell respiration and N2 fixation rates. We hypothesize that at -0.15 V, they increase N2 fixation activity to help maintain redox homeostasis, and they leverage electron bifurcation as a strategy to optimize energy generation and use. IMPORTANCE Biological nitrogen fixation coupled with ammonium recovery provides a sustainable alternative to the carbon-, water-, and energy-intensive Haber-Bosch process. Aerobic biological nitrogen fixation technologies are hindered by oxygen gas inhibition of the nitrogenase enzyme. Electrically driving biological nitrogen fixation in anaerobic microbial electrochemical technologies overcomes this challenge. Using Geobacter sulfurreducens as a model exoelectrogenic diazotroph, we show that the anode potential in microbial electrochemical technologies has a significant impact on nitrogen gas fixation rates, ammonium assimilation pathways, and expression of genes associated with nitrogen gas fixation. These findings have important implications for understanding regulatory pathways of nitrogen gas fixation and will help identify target genes and operational strategies to enhance ammonium production in microbial electrochemical technologies.

Evidence for a Putative Isoprene Reductase in Acetobacterium wieringae

Recent discoveries of isoprene-metabolizing microorganisms suggest they might play an important role in the global isoprene budget. Under anoxic conditions, isoprene can be used as an electron acceptor and is reduced to methylbutene. This study describes the proteogenomic profiling of an isoprene-reducing bacterial culture to identify organisms and genes responsible for the isoprene hydrogenation reaction. A metagenome-assembled genome (MAG) of the most abundant (89% relative abundance) lineage in the enrichment, Acetobacterium wieringae, was obtained. Comparative proteogenomics and reverse transcription-PCR (RT-PCR) identified a putative five-gene operon from the A. wieringae MAG upregulated during isoprene reduction. The operon encodes a putative oxidoreductase, three pleiotropic nickel chaperones (2 × HypA, HypB), and one 4Fe-4S ferredoxin. The oxidoreductase is proposed as the putative isoprene reductase with a binding site for NADH, flavin adenine dinucleotide (FAD), two pairs of canonical [4Fe-4S] clusters, and a putative iron-sulfur cluster site in a Cys₆-bonding environment. Well-studied Acetobacterium strains, such as A. woodii DSM 1030, A. wieringae DSM 1911, or A. malicum DSM 4132, do not encode the isoprene-regulated operon but encode, like many other bacteria, a homolog of the putative isoprene reductase (~47 to 49% amino acid sequence identity). Uncharacterized homologs of the putative isoprene reductase are observed across the Firmicutes, Spirochaetes, Tenericutes, Actinobacteria, Chloroflexi, Bacteroidetes, and Proteobacteria, suggesting the ability of biohydrogenation of unfunctionalized conjugated doubled bonds in other unsaturated hydrocarbons. IMPORTANCE Isoprene was recently shown to act as an electron acceptor for a homoacetogenic bacterium. The focus of this study is the molecular basis for isoprene reduction. By comparing a genome from our isoprene-reducing enrichment culture, dominated by Acetobacterium wieringae, with genomes of other Acetobacterium lineages that do not reduce isoprene, we shortlisted candidate genes for isoprene reduction. Using comparative proteogenomics and reverse transcription-PCR we have identified a putative five-gene operon encoding an oxidoreductase referred to as putative isoprene reductase.

Evolving a New Electron Transfer Pathway for Nitrogen Fixation Uncovers an Electron Bifurcating-Like Enzyme Involved in Anaerobic Aromatic Compound Degradation

Nitrogenase is the key enzyme involved in nitrogen fixation and uses low potential electrons delivered by ferredoxin (Fd) or flavodoxin (Fld) to reduce dinitrogen gas (N₂) to produce ammonia, generating hydrogen gas (H₂) as an obligate product of this activity. Although the phototrophic alphaproteobacterium Rhodopseudomonas palustris encodes multiple proteins that can reduce Fd, the FixABCX complex is the only one shown to support nitrogen fixation, and R. palustris Fix^- mutants grow poorly under nitrogen-fixing conditions. To investigate how native electron transfer chains (ETCs) can be redirected toward nitrogen fixation, we leveraged the strong selective pressure of nitrogen limitation to isolate a suppressor of an R. palustris ΔfixC strain that grows under nitrogen-fixing conditions. We found two mutations were required to restore growth under nitrogen-fixing conditions in the absence of functional FixABCX. One mutation was in the gene encoding the primary Fd involved in nitrogen fixation, fer1, and the other mutation was in aadN, which encodes a homolog of NAD⁺-dependent Fd:NADPH oxidoreductase (Nfn). We present evidence that AadN plays a role in electron transfer to benzoyl coenzyme A reductase, the key enzyme involved in anaerobic aromatic compound degradation. Our data support a model where the ETC for anaerobic aromatic compound degradation was repurposed to support nitrogen fixation in the ΔfixC suppressor strain. IMPORTANCE There is increasing evidence that protein electron carriers like Fd evolved to form specific partnerships with select electron donors and acceptors to keep native electron transfer pathways insulated from one another. This makes it challenging to integrate a Fd-dependent pathway such as biological nitrogen fixation into non-nitrogen-fixing organisms and provide the high-energy reducing power needed to fix nitrogen. Here, we show that amino acid substitutions in an electron donor for anaerobic aromatic compound degradation and an Fd involved in nitrogen fixation enabled electron transfer to nitrogenase. This study provides a model system to understand electron transfer chain specificity and how new electron transfer pathways can be evolved for biotechnologically valuable pathways like nitrogen fixation.

Purine catabolism by enterobacteria

Purines are abundant among organic nitrogen sources and have high nitrogen content. Accordingly, microorganisms have evolved different pathways to catabolize purines and their metabolic products such as allantoin. Enterobacteria from the genera Escherichia, Klebsiella and Salmonella have three such pathways. First, the HPX pathway, found in the genus Klebsiella and very close relatives, catabolizes purines during aerobic growth, extracting all four nitrogen atoms in the process. This pathway includes several known or predicted enzymes not previously observed in other purine catabolic pathways. Second, the ALL pathway, found in strains from all three species, catabolizes allantoin during anaerobic growth in a branched pathway that also includes glyoxylate assimilation. This allantoin fermentation pathway originally was characterized in a gram-positive bacterium, and therefore is widespread. Third, the XDH pathway, found in strains from Escherichia and Klebsiella spp., at present is ill-defined but likely includes enzymes to catabolize purines during anaerobic growth. Critically, this pathway may include an enzyme system for anaerobic urate catabolism, a phenomenon not previously described. Documenting such a pathway would overturn the long-held assumption that urate catabolism requires oxygen. Overall, this broad capability for purine catabolism during either aerobic or anaerobic growth suggests that purines and their metabolites contribute to enterobacterial fitness in a variety of environments.

Looking for the mechanism of arsenate respiration of Fusibacter sp. strain 3D3, independent of ArrAB

The literature has reported the isolation of arsenate-dependent growing microorganisms which lack a canonical homolog for respiratory arsenate reductase, ArrAB. We recently isolated an arsenate-dependent growing bacterium from volcanic arsenic-bearing environments in Northern Chile, Fusibacter sp. strain 3D3 (Fas) and studied the arsenic metabolism in this Gram-positive isolate. Features of Fas deduced from genome analysis and comparative analysis with other arsenate-reducing microorganisms revealed the lack of ArrAB coding genes and the occurrence of two arsC genes encoding for putative cytoplasmic arsenate reductases named ArsC-1 and ArsC-2. Interestingly, ArsC-1 and ArsC-2 belong to the thioredoxin-coupled family (because of the redox-active disulfide protein used as reductant), but they conferred differential arsenate resistance to the E. coli WC3110 ΔarsC strain. PCR experiments confirmed the absence of arrAB genes and results obtained using uncouplers revealed that Fas growth is linked to the proton gradient. In addition, Fas harbors ferredoxin-NAD⁺ oxidoreductase (Rnf) and electron transfer flavoprotein (etf) coding genes. These are key molecular markers of a recently discovered flavin-based electron bifurcation mechanism involved in energy conservation, mainly in anaerobic metabolisms regulated by the cellular redox state and mostly associated with cytoplasmic enzyme complexes. At least three electron-bifurcating flavoenzyme complexes were evidenced in Fas, some of them shared in conserved genomic regions by other members of the Fusibacter genus. These physiological and genomic findings permit us to hypothesize the existence of an uncharacterized arsenate-dependent growth metabolism regulated by the cellular redox state in the Fusibacter genus.

Site-Differentiated Iron–Sulfur Cluster Ligation Affects Flavin-Based Electron Bifurcation Activity

Electron bifurcation is an elegant mechanism of biological energy conversion that effectively couples three different physiologically relevant substrates. As such, enzymes that perform this function often play critical roles in modulating cellular redox metabolism. One such enzyme is NADH-dependent reduced-ferredoxin: NADP⁺ oxidoreductase (NfnSL), which couples the thermodynamically favorable reduction of NAD⁺ to drive the unfavorable reduction of ferredoxin from NADPH. The interaction of NfnSL with its substrates is constrained to strict stoichiometric conditions, which ensures minimal energy losses from non-productive intramolecular electron transfer reactions. However, the determinants for this are not well understood. One curious feature of NfnSL is that both initial acceptors of bifurcated electrons are unique iron–sulfur (FeS) clusters containing one non-cysteinyl ligand each. The biochemical impact and mechanistic roles of site-differentiated FeS ligands are enigmatic, despite their incidence in many redox active enzymes. Herein, we describe the biochemical study of wild-type NfnSL and a variant in which one of the site-differentiated ligands has been replaced with a cysteine. Results of dye-based steady-state kinetics experiments, substrate-binding measurements, biochemical activity assays, and assessments of electron distribution across the enzyme indicate that this site-differentiated ligand in NfnSL plays a role in maintaining fidelity of the coordinated reactions performed by the two electron transfer pathways. Given the commonality of these cofactors, our findings have broad implications beyond electron bifurcation and mechanistic biochemistry and may inform on means of modulating the redox balance of the cell for targeted metabolic engineering approaches.

Molecular characterization of the missing electron pathways for butanol synthesis in Clostridium acetobutylicum

Clostridium acetobutylicum is a promising biocatalyst for the renewable production of n-butanol. Several metabolic strategies have already been developed to increase butanol yields, most often based on carbon pathway redirection. However, it has previously demonstrated that the activities of both ferredoxin-NADP⁺ reductase and ferredoxin-NAD⁺ reductase, whose encoding genes remain unknown, are necessary to produce the NADPH and the extra NADH needed for butanol synthesis under solventogenic conditions. Here, we purify, identify and partially characterize the proteins responsible for both activities and demonstrate the involvement of the identified enzymes in butanol synthesis through a reverse genetic approach. We further demonstrate the yield of butanol formation is limited by the level of expression of CA_C0764, the ferredoxin-NADP⁺ reductase encoding gene and the bcd operon, encoding a ferredoxin-NAD⁺ reductase. The integration of these enzymes into metabolic engineering strategies introduces opportunities for developing a homobutanologenic C. acetobutylicum strain.

Ferredoxin-NAD(P) + oxidoreductases are important enzymes for redox balancing in n-butanol production by Clostridium acetobutylicum, but the encoding genes remain unknown. Here, the authors identify the long sought-after genes and increase n-butanol production by optimizing the levels of the two enzymes.

Customized exogenous ferredoxin functions as an efficient electron carrier

Ferredoxin (Fdx) is regarded as the main electron carrier in biological electron transfer and acts as an electron donor in metabolic pathways of many organisms. Here, we screened a self-sufficient P450-derived reductase PRF with promising production yield of 9OHAD (9α-hydroxy4-androstene-3,17-dione) from AD, and further proved the importance of [2Fe-2S] clusters of ferredoxin-oxidoreductase in transferring electrons in steroidal conversion. The results of truncated Fdx domain in all oxidoreductases and mutagenesis data elucidated the indispensable role of [2Fe-2S] clusters in the electron transfer process. By adding the independent plant-type Fdx to the reaction system, the AD (4-androstene-3,17-dione) conversion rate have been significantly improved. A novel efficient electron transfer pathway of PRF + Fdx + KshA (KshA, Rieske-type oxygenase of 3-ketosteroid-9-hydroxylase) in the reaction system rather than KshAB complex system was proposed based on analysis of protein-protein interactions and redox potential measurement. Adding free Fdx created a new conduit for electrons to travel from reductase to oxygenase. This electron transfer pathway provides new insight for the development of efficient exogenous Fdx as an electron carrier.

Renewable fatty acid ester production in Clostridium

Bioproduction of renewable chemicals is considered as an urgent solution for fossil energy crisis. However, despite tremendous efforts, it is still challenging to generate microbial strains that can produce target biochemical to high levels. Here, we report an example of biosynthesis of high-value and easy-recoverable derivatives built upon natural microbial pathways, leading to improvement in bioproduction efficiency. By leveraging pathways in solventogenic clostridia for co-producing acyl-CoAs, acids and alcohols as precursors, through rational screening for host strains and enzymes, systematic metabolic engineering-including elimination of putative prophages, we develop strains that can produce 20.3 g/L butyl acetate and 1.6 g/L butyl butyrate. Techno-economic analysis results suggest the economic competitiveness of our developed bioprocess. Our principles of selecting the most appropriate host for specific bioproduction and engineering microbial chassis to produce high-value and easy-separable end products may be applicable to other bioprocesses.

Esters can be used as fuels and specialty chemicals for food flavoring, cosmetic and pharmaceutical industries. Here, the authors systematically engineer clostridia, including discovery and deletion of prophages to increase strain stability, for the production of butyl acetate and butyl butyrate from corn stover at low cost.

Iron-sulfur flavoenzymes: the added value of making the most ancient redox cofactors and the versatile flavins work together

Iron-sulfur (Fe-S) flavoproteins form a broad and growing class of complex, multi-domain and often multi-subunit proteins coupling the most ancient cofactors (the Fe-S clusters) and the most versatile coenzymes (the flavin coenzymes, FMN and FAD). These enzymes catalyse oxidoreduction reactions usually acting as switches between donors of electron pairs and acceptors of single electrons, and vice versa. Through selected examples, the enzymes' structure−function relationships with respect to rate and directionality of the electron transfer steps, the role of the apoprotein and its dynamics in modulating the electron transfer process will be discussed.

Identifying and Engineering Bottlenecks of Autotrophic Isobutanol Formation in Recombinant C. ljungdahlii by Systemic Analysis

Clostridium ljungdahlii (C. ljungdahlii, CLJU) is natively endowed producing acetic acid, 2,3-butandiol, and ethanol consuming gas mixtures of CO2, CO, and H2 (syngas). Here, we present the syngas-based isobutanol formation using C. ljungdahlii harboring the recombinant amplification of the "Ehrlich" pathway that converts intracellular KIV to isobutanol. Autotrophic isobutanol production was studied analyzing two different strains in 3-L gassed and stirred bioreactors. Physiological characterization was thoroughly applied together with metabolic profiling and flux balance analysis. Thereof, KIV and pyruvate supply were identified as key "bottlenecking" precursors limiting preliminary isobutanol formation in CLJU[KAIA] to 0.02 g L-1. Additional blocking of valine synthesis in CLJU[KAIA]:ilvE increased isobutanol production by factor 6.5 finally reaching 0.13 g L-1. Future metabolic engineering should focus on debottlenecking NADPH availability, whereas NADH supply is already equilibrated in the current generation of strains.

Flavins in the electron bifurcation process

The discovery of a new energy-coupling mechanism termed flavin-based electron bifurcation (FBEB) in 2008 revealed a novel field of application for flavins in biology. The key component is the bifurcating flavin endowed with strongly inverted one-electron reduction potentials (FAD/FAD•^- ≪ FAD•^-/FADH^-) that cooperatively transfers in its reduced state one low and one high-energy electron into different directions and thereby drives an endergonic with an exergonic reduction reaction. As energy splitting at the bifurcating flavin apparently implicates one-electron chemistry, the FBEB machinery has to incorporate prior to and behind the central bifurcating flavin 2e-to-1e and 1e-to-2e switches, frequently also flavins, for oxidizing variable medium-potential two-electron donating substrates and for reducing high-potential two-electron accepting substrates. The one-electron carriers ferredoxin or flavodoxin serve as low-potential (high-energy) electron acceptors, which power endergonic processes almost exclusively in obligate anaerobic microorganisms to increase the efficiency of their energy metabolism. In this review, we outline the global organization of FBEB enzymes, the functions of the flavins therein and the surrounding of the isoalloxazine rings by which their reduction potentials are specifically adjusted in a finely tuned energy landscape.

The role of thermodynamic features on the functional activity of electron bifurcating enzymes

Electron bifurcation is a biological mechanism to drive a thermodynamically unfavorable redox reaction through direct coupling with an exergonic reaction. This process allows microorganisms to generate high energy reducing equivalents in order to sustain life and is often found in anaerobic metabolism, where the energy economy of the cell is poor. Recent work has revealed details of the redox energy landscapes for a variety of electron bifurcating enzymes, greatly expanding the understanding of how energy is transformed by this unique mechanism. Here we highlight the plasticity of these emerging landscapes, what is known regarding their mechanistic underpinnings, and provide a context for interpreting their biochemical activity within the physiological framework. We conclude with an outlook for propelling the field toward an integrative understanding of the impact of electron bifurcation.

Rational Design of Fe2 (μ-PR2 )2 (L)6 Coordination Compounds Featuring Tailored Potential Inversion

It was recently discovered that some redox proteins can thermodynamically and spatially split two incoming electrons towards different pathways, resulting in the one-electron reduction of two different substrates, featuring reduction potential respectively higher and lower than the parent reductant. This energy conversion process, referred to as electron bifurcation, is relevant not only from a biochemical perspective, but also for the ground-breaking applications that electron-bifurcating molecular devices could have in the field of energy conversion. Natural electron-bifurcating systems contain a two-electron redox centre featuring potential inversion (PI), i. e. with second reduction easier than the first. With the aim of revealing key factors to tailor the span between first and second redox potentials, we performed a systematic density functional study of a 26-molecule set of models with the general formula Fe₂ (μ-PR₂ )₂ (L)₆ . It turned out that specific features such as i) a Fe-Fe antibonding character of the LUMO, ii) presence of electron-donor groups and iii) low steric congestion in the Fe's coordination sphere, are key ingredients for PI. In particular, the synergic effects of i)-iii) can lead to a span between first and second redox potentials larger than 700 mV. More generally, the "molecular recipes" herein described are expected to inspire the synthesis of Fe₂ P₂ systems with tailored PI, of primary relevance to the design of electron-bifurcating molecular devices.

The Sporomusa type Nfn is a novel type of electron-bifurcating transhydrogenase that links the redox pools in acetogenic bacteria

Flavin-based electron bifurcation is a long hidden mechanism of energetic coupling present mainly in anaerobic bacteria and archaea that suffer from energy limitations in their environment. Electron bifurcation saves precious cellular ATP and enables lithotrophic life of acetate-forming (acetogenic) bacteria that grow on H₂ + CO₂ by the only pathway that combines CO₂ fixation with ATP synthesis, the Wood–Ljungdahl pathway. The energy barrier for the endergonic reduction of NADP⁺, an electron carrier in the Wood–Ljungdahl pathway, with NADH as reductant is overcome by an electron-bifurcating, ferredoxin-dependent transhydrogenase (Nfn) but many acetogens lack nfn genes. We have purified a ferredoxin-dependent NADH:NADP⁺ oxidoreductase from Sporomusa ovata, characterized the enzyme biochemically and identified the encoding genes. These studies led to the identification of a novel, Sporomusa type Nfn (Stn), built from existing modules of enzymes such as the soluble [Fe–Fe] hydrogenase, that is widespread in acetogens and other anaerobic bacteria.

Electron bifurcation: progress and grand challenges

Electron bifurcation moves electrons from a two-electron donor to reduce two spatially separated one-electron acceptors.