Searching for DNA Damage: Insights From Single Molecule Analysis

FSHing for DNA Damage: Key Features of MutY Detection of 8-Oxoguanine:Adenine Mismatches

Base excision repair (BER) enzymes are genomic superheroes that stealthily and accurately identify and remove chemically modified DNA bases. DNA base modifications erode the informational content of DNA and underlie many disease phenotypes, most conspicuously, cancer. The "OG" of oxidative base damage, 8-oxo-7,8-dihydroguanine (OG), is particularly insidious due to its miscoding ability that leads to the formation of rare, pro-mutagenic OG:A mismatches. Thwarting mutagenesis relies on the capture of OG:A mismatches prior to DNA replication and removal of the mis-inserted adenine by MutY glycosylases to initiate BER. The threat of OG and the importance of its repair are underscored by the association between inherited dysfunctional variants of the MutY human homologue (MUTYH) and colorectal cancer, known as MUTYH-associated polyposis (MAP). Our functional studies of the two founder MUTYH variants revealed that both have compromised activity and a reduced affinity for OG:A mismatches. Indeed, these studies underscored the challenge of the recognition of OG:A mismatches that are only subtly structurally different than T:A base pairs. Since the original discovery of MAP, many MUTYH variants have been reported, with most considered to be "variants of uncertain significance." To reveal features associated with damage recognition and adenine excision by MutY and MUTYH, we have developed a multipronged chemical biology approach combining enzyme kinetics, X-ray crystallography, single-molecule visualization, and cellular repair assays. In this review, we highlight recent work in our laboratory where we defined MutY structure-activity relationship (SAR) studies using synthetic analogs of OG and A in cellular and in vitro assays. Our studies revealed the 2-amino group of OG as the key distinguishing feature of OG:A mismatches. Indeed, the unique position of the 2-amino group in the major groove of OGsyn:Aanti mismatches provides a means for its rapid detection among a large excess of highly abundant and structurally similar canonical base pairs. Furthermore, site-directed mutagenesis and structural analysis showed that a conserved C-terminal domain β-hairpin "FSH'' loop is critical for OG recognition with the "His" serving as the lesion detector. Notably, MUTYH variants located within and near the FSH loop have been associated with different forms of cancer. Uncovering the role(s) of this loop in lesion recognition provided a detailed understanding of the search and repair process of MutY. Such insights are also useful to identify mutational hotspots and pathogenic variants, which may improve the ability of physicians to diagnose the likelihood of disease onset and prognosis. The critical importance of the "FSH" loop in lesion detection suggests that it may serve as a unique locus for targeting probes or inhibitors of MutY/MUTYH to provide new chemical biology tools and avenues for therapeutic development.

Single-molecule analysis of purified proteins and nuclear extracts: Insights from 8-oxoguanine glycosylase 1

By observing one molecule at a time, single-molecule studies can offer detailed insights about biomolecular processes including on rates, off rates, and diffusivity of molecules on strands of DNA. A recent technological advance (Single-molecule Analysis of DNA-binding proteins from Nuclear Extracts, SMADNE) has lowered the barrier to entry for single-molecule studies, and single-molecule dynamics can now be determined directly out of nuclear extracts, providing information in an intermediate environment between purified proteins in isolation and the heterogeneity of a nucleus. To compare and contrast the single-molecule DNA binding dynamics in nuclear extracts versus purified proteins, combined optical tweezers and fluorescence microscopy experiments were performed with purified GFP-tagged 8-oxoguanine glycosylase 1 (OGG1), purified GFP-OGG1 spiked into nuclear extracts, and nuclear extracts from human cells overexpressing GFP-OGG1. We observed differences in undamaged DNA binding during DNA damage search in each of the three conditions. Purified GFP-OGG1 engaged undamaged DNA for a weighted average lifetime of 5.7 s and 21% of these events underwent DNA diffusion after binding. However, unlike other glycosylases studied by SMADNE, OGG1 does not bind non-damaged DNA efficiently in nuclear extracts. In contrast, GFP-OGG1 binding dynamics on DNA substrates containing oxidative damage were relatively similar in all three conditions, with the weighted average binding lifetimes varying from 2.2 s in nuclear extracts to 7.8 s with purified GFP-OGG1 in isolation. Finally, we compared the purified protein and nuclear extract approaches for a catalytically dead OGG1 variant (GFP-OGG1-K249Q). This variant greatly increased the binding lifetime for oxidative DNA damage, with the weighted average lifetime for GFP-OGG1-249Q in nuclear extracts at 15.4 s vs 10.7 s for the purified protein. SMADNE will provide a new window of observation into the behavior of nucleic acid binding proteins only accessible by biophysicists trained in protein purification and protein labeling.

Single-molecule analysis of purified proteins and nuclear extracts: insights from 8-oxoguanine glycosylase 1

By observing one molecule at a time, single-molecule studies can offer detailed insights about biomolecular processes including on rates, off rates, and diffusivity of molecules on strands of DNA. A recent technological advance (Single-molecule Analysis of DNA-binding proteins from Nuclear Extracts, SMADNE) has lowered the barrier to entry for single-molecule studies, and single-molecule dynamics can now be determined directly out of nuclear extracts, providing information in an intermediate environment between purified proteins in isolation and the heterogeneity of a nucleus. To compare and contrast the single-molecule DNA binding dynamics in nuclear extracts versus purified proteins, combined optical tweezers and fluorescence microscopy experiments were performed with purified GFP-tagged 8-oxoguanine glycosylase 1 (OGG1), purified GFP-OGG1 spiked into nuclear extracts, and nuclear extracts from human cells overexpressing GFP-OGG1. We observed differences in undamaged DNA binding during DNA damage search in each of the three conditions. Purified GFP-OGG1 engaged undamaged DNA for a weighted average lifetime of 5.7 s and 21% of these events underwent DNA diffusion after binding. However, unlike other glycosylases studied by SMADNE, OGG1 does not bind non-damaged DNA efficiently in nuclear extracts. In contrast, GFP-OGG1 binding dynamics on DNA substrates containing oxidative damage were relatively similar in all three conditions, with the weighted average binding lifetimes varying from 2.2 s in nuclear extracts to 7.8 s with purified GFP-OGG1 in isolation. Finally, we compared the purified protein and nuclear extract approaches for a catalytically dead OGG1 variant (GFP-OGG1-K249Q). This variant greatly increased the binding lifetime for oxidative DNA damage, with the weighted average lifetime for GFP-OGG1-249Q in nuclear extracts at 15.4 s vs 10.7 s for the purified protein. SMADNE will provide a new window of observation into the behavior of nucleic acid binding proteins only accessible by biophysicists trained in protein purification and protein labeling.

Spatio-temporal dynamics of the DNA glycosylase OGG1 in finding and processing 8-oxoguanine

OGG1 is the DNA glycosylase responsible for the removal of the oxidative lesion 8-oxoguanine (8-oxoG) from DNA. The recognition of this lesion by OGG1 is a complex process that involves scanning the DNA for the presence of 8-oxoG, followed by recognition and lesion removal. Structural data have shown that OGG1 evolves through different stages of conformation onto the DNA, corresponding to elementary steps of the 8-oxoG recognition and extrusion from the double helix. Single-molecule studies of OGG1 on naked DNA have shown that OGG1 slides in persistent contact with the DNA, displaying different binding states probably corresponding to the different conformation stages. However, in cells, the DNA is not naked and OGG1 has to navigate into a complex and highly crowded environment within the nucleus. To ensure rapid detection of 8-oxoG, OGG1 alternates between 3D diffusion and sliding along the DNA. This process is regulated by the local chromatin state but also by protein co-factors that could facilitate the detection of oxidized lesions. We will review here the different methods that have been used over the last years to better understand how OGG1 detects and process 8-oxoG lesions.

Identification of key residues of the DNA glycosylase OGG1 controlling efficient DNA sampling and recruitment to oxidized bases in living cells

The DNA-glycosylase OGG1 oversees the detection and clearance of the 7,8-dihydro-8-oxoguanine (8-oxoG), which is the most frequent form of oxidized base in the genome. This lesion is deeply buried within the double-helix and its detection requires careful inspection of the bases by OGG1 via a mechanism that remains only partially understood. By analyzing OGG1 dynamics in the nucleus of living human cells, we demonstrate that the glycosylase constantly samples the DNA by rapidly alternating between diffusion within the nucleoplasm and short transits on the DNA. This sampling process, that we find to be tightly regulated by the conserved residue G245, is crucial for the rapid recruitment of OGG1 at oxidative lesions induced by laser micro-irradiation. Furthermore, we show that residues Y203, N149 and N150, while being all involved in early stages of 8-oxoG probing by OGG1 based on previous structural data, differentially regulate the sampling of the DNA and recruitment to oxidative lesions.

Single-molecule analysis of DNA-binding proteins from nuclear extracts (SMADNE)

Single-molecule characterization of protein-DNA dynamics provides unprecedented mechanistic details about numerous nuclear processes. Here, we describe a new method that rapidly generates single-molecule information with fluorescently tagged proteins isolated from nuclear extracts of human cells. We demonstrated the wide applicability of this novel technique on undamaged DNA and three forms of DNA damage using seven native DNA repair proteins and two structural variants, including: poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase (PARP1), heterodimeric ultraviolet-damaged DNA-binding protein (UV-DDB), and 8-oxoguanine glycosylase 1 (OGG1). We found that PARP1 binding to DNA nicks is altered by tension, and that UV-DDB did not act as an obligate heterodimer of DDB1 and DDB2 on UV-irradiated DNA. UV-DDB bound to UV photoproducts with an average lifetime of 39 seconds (corrected for photobleaching, τc), whereas binding lifetimes to 8-oxoG adducts were < 1 second. Catalytically inactive OGG1 variant K249Q bound oxidative damage 23-fold longer than WT OGG1, at 47 and 2.0 s, respectively. By measuring three fluorescent colors simultaneously, we also characterized the assembly and disassembly kinetics of UV-DDB and OGG1 complexes on DNA. Hence, the SMADNE technique represents a novel, scalable, and universal method to obtain single-molecule mechanistic insights into key protein-DNA interactions in an environment containing physiologically-relevant nuclear proteins.

Searching for New Z-DNA/Z-RNA Binding Proteins Based on Structural Similarity to Experimentally Validated Zα Domain

Z-DNA and Z-RNA are functionally important left-handed structures of nucleic acids, which play a significant role in several molecular and biological processes including DNA replication, gene expression regulation and viral nucleic acid sensing. Most proteins that have been proven to interact with Z-DNA/Z-RNA contain the so-called Zα domain, which is structurally well conserved. To date, only eight proteins with Zα domain have been described within a few organisms (including human, mouse, Danio rerio, Trypanosoma brucei and some viruses). Therefore, this paper aimed to search for new Z-DNA/Z-RNA binding proteins in the complete PDB structures database and from the AlphaFold2 protein models. A structure-based similarity search found 14 proteins with highly similar Zα domain structure in experimentally-defined proteins and 185 proteins with a putative Zα domain using the AlphaFold2 models. Structure-based alignment and molecular docking confirmed high functional conservation of amino acids involved in Z-DNA/Z-RNA, suggesting that Z-DNA/Z-RNA recognition may play an important role in a variety of cellular processes.

Reactive Oxygen Species in the Adverse Outcome Pathway Framework: Toward Creation of Harmonized Consensus Key Events

Reactive oxygen species (ROS) and reactive nitrogen species (RNS) are formed as a result of natural cellular processes, intracellular signaling, or as adverse responses associated with diseases or exposure to oxidizing chemical and non-chemical stressors. The action of ROS and RNS, collectively referred to as reactive oxygen and nitrogen species (RONS), has recently become highly relevant in a number of adverse outcome pathways (AOPs) that capture, organize, evaluate and portray causal relationships pertinent to adversity or disease progression. RONS can potentially act as a key event (KE) in the cascade of responses leading to an adverse outcome (AO) within such AOPs, but are also known to modulate responses of events along the AOP continuum without being an AOP event itself. A substantial discussion has therefore been undertaken in a series of workshops named "Mystery or ROS" to elucidate the role of RONS in disease and adverse effects associated with exposure to stressors such as nanoparticles, chemical, and ionizing and non-ionizing radiation. This review introduces the background for RONS production, reflects on the direct and indirect effects of RONS, addresses the diversity of terminology used in different fields of research, and provides guidance for developing a harmonized approach for defining a common event terminology within the AOP developer community.