Ultrasound Evaluation of Flap Thickness, Ablation Depth, and Corneal Edema After Laser in situ Keratomileusis

The Impact of Flap Creation Methods for Sub-Bowman's Keratomileusis (SBK) on the Central Thickness of Bowman's Layer

Purpose

To determine the impact of flap creation methods for sub-Bowman’s keratomileusis (SBK) on central Bowman’s layer thickness.

Methods

SBK flaps were made by Moria microkeratome for 20 subjects and by femtosecond (FEMTO) laser for 21 subjects. Corneal sublayer thicknesses were measured by ultra-high resolution optical coherence tomography before SBK and at 1 day, 1 week, 2 weeks, and 1 month afterwards. Each subject was imaged twice on each visit. Thicknesses of central epithelium, Bowman’s layer, flap, and total cornea were calculated using a custom-made automated image processing algorithm. The repeatability of sublayer thickness measurements was tested by the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) and by the coefficient of repeatability (CoR) at 1 week post-SBK.

Results

ICCs of the Moria and FEMTO groups were ≥0.959 and ≥0.961 respectively for all sublayer measurements. The segmentation CoRs were less than 6.78% and 5.63% respectively. For both groups, microdistortions were present in the epithelium and Bowman’s layer after SKB. The flap thickness of the Moria group was 9.8 μm (95% confidence interval: 4.8 – 14.8μm) thinner than the FEMTO group one day after SBK (independent samples t-test, P < 0.05). Bowman’s layer became thicker by 1.6 ± 1.1 μm and 1.7 ± 1.6 μm one day post-SBK for the Moria and FEMTO groups (repeated ANOVA, P < 0.05) and then remained stable. Corneal and sublayer thickness were similar between the two groups.

Conclusions

Central Bowman’s layer thickness increased 1 day post-SBK. Flap creation by Moria microkeratome and femtosecond laser did not have significantly different impacts on Bowman’s layer thickness following SBK.

Trial Registration

Chinese Clinical Trial Registry (ChiCTR) NO: ChiCTR-OCH-14004525

Role of optical coherence tomography on corneal surface laser ablation

This paper focuses on reviewing the roles of optical coherence tomography (OCT) on corneal surface laser ablation procedures. OCT is an optical imaging modality that uses low-coherence interferometry to provide noninvasive cross-sectional imaging of tissue microstructure in vivo. There are two types of OCTs, each with transverse and axial spatial resolutions of a few micrometers: the time-domain and the fourier-domain OCTs. Both have been increasingly used by refractive surgeons and have specific advantages. Which of the current imaging instruments is a better choice depends on the specific application. In laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK) and in excimer laser phototherapeutic keratectomy (PTK), OCT can be used to assess corneal characteristics and guide treatment decisions. OCT accurately measures central corneal thickness, evaluates the regularity of LASIK flaps, and quantifies flap and residual stromal bed thickness. When evaluating the ablation depth accuracy by subtracting preoperative from postoperative measurements, OCT pachymetry correlates well with laser ablation settings. In addition, OCT can be used to provide precise information on the morphology and depth of corneal pathologic abnormalities, such as corneal degenerations, dystrophies, and opacities, correlating with histopathologic findings.

Repeatability of intraoperative central corneal and residual stromal thickness measurement using a handheld ultrasound pachymeter

PURPOSE

To determine and compare the repeatability of intraoperative central corneal thickness (CCT) and residual stromal bed thickness measurements using a handheld ultrasound (US) pachymeter.

SETTING

London Vision Clinic, London, United Kingdom.

DESIGN

Comparative evaluation of a diagnostic test or technology.

METHODS

This study comprised eyes that had laser in situ keratomileusis retreatment by flap lift in which handheld US pachymetry (Corneo-Gage Plus 50 MHz) had been performed intraoperatively. In each case, 5 consecutive measurements were obtained centrally immediately before and after the flap was lifted. The within-eye repeatability was calculated as the standard deviation of the 5 repeated measurements for the CCT measurements and the central residual stromal thickness (RST) measurements.

RESULTS

The study evaluated 134 eyes (79 patients). The mean CCT was 467 μm ± 40 (SD) (range 393 to 577 μm). The repeatability of CCT measurements was 6.83 μm, the coefficient of repeatability was 13.40 μm, and the coefficient of variation (CoV) was 1.46%. The mean central RST was 335 ± 46 μm (range 259 to 465 μm). The repeatability of central RST measurements was 4.91 μm, the coefficient of repeatability was 9.62 μm, and the CoV was 1.46%.

CONCLUSION

The repeatability of intraoperative handheld US pachymetry was similar between measurements of CCT and measurements of central RST; the CoV was 1.46% in both cases.

Comparison of residual stromal bed thickness measurement among very high-frequency digital ultrasound, intraoperative handheld ultrasound, and optical coherence tomography

PURPOSE

To compare residual stromal thickness (RST) measurement by three methods: very high-frequency digital ultrasound (VHFDU), intraoperative handheld ultrasound (US), and optical coherence tomography (OCT).

METHODS

This was a retrospective analysis of 93 eyes (55 patients) that underwent LASIK retreatment by flap lift where VHFDU and OCT measurements were obtained before the retreatment and intraoperative US RST measurement was performed after lifting the flap. Corneal vertex RST measurements for intraoperative US and OCT were compared with the VHFDU measurement. Linear regression and Bland-Altman analysis were performed.

RESULTS

Mean corneal vertex RST was 327±53 μm for VHFDU, 338±54 μm for intraoperative US, and 326±43 μm for OCT. Mean difference between VHFDU and intraoperative US was 11±11 μm (range: -12 to 46 μm). Mean difference between VHFDU and OCT was -2±23 μm (range: -53 to 57 μm). The coefficient of determination (R(2)) was 0.96 between VHFDU and intraoperative US and 0.82 between VHFDU and OCT. Intraoperative US was on average 11 μm thicker than VHFDU independent of RST value. Optical coherence tomography was on average thicker than VHFDU for low RST values (250 to 300 μm) and thinner than VHFDU for high RST values (>350 μm). The RST was thicker than VHFDU by >10 μm in 50% and >20 μm in 21% of eyes measured with intraoperative US and by >10 μm in 32% and >20 μm in 18% of eyes measured with OCT.

CONCLUSIONS

Residual stromal thickness measured by both intraoperative US and OCT was thicker than VHFDU in a significant number of eyes, which could have resulted in retreatment being performed in an eye with insufficient RST.

Corneal ablation depth readout of the MEL 80 excimer laser compared to Artemis three-dimensional very high-frequency digital ultrasound stromal measurements

PURPOSE

To evaluate the accuracy of the ablation depth readout for the MEL 80 excimer laser (Carl Zeiss Meditec).

METHODS

Artemis 1 very high-frequency digital ultrasound measurements were obtained before and at least 3 months after LASIK in 121 eyes (65 patients). The Artemis-measured ablation depth was calculated as the maximum difference in stromal thickness before and after treatment. Laser in situ keratomileusis was performed using the MEL 80 excimer laser and the Hansatome microkeratome (Bausch & Lomb). The Aberration Smart Ablation profile was used in 56 eyes and the Tissue Saving Ablation profile was used in 65 eyes. All ablations were centered on the corneal vertex. Comparative statistics and linear regression analysis were performed between the laser readout ablation depth and Artemis-measured ablation depth.

RESULTS

The mean maximum myopic meridian was -6.66±2.40 diopters (D) (range: -1.50 to -10.00 D) for Aberration Smart Ablation-treated eyes and -6.50±2.56 D (range: -1.34 to -11.50 D) for Tissue Saving Ablation-treated eyes. The MEL 80 readout was found to overestimate the Artemis-measured ablation depth by 20±12 μm for Aberration Smart Ablation and by 21±12 μm for Tissue Saving Ablation profiles.

CONCLUSIONS

The accuracy of ablation depth measurement was improved by using the Artemis stromal thickness profile measurements before and after surgery to exclude epithelial changes. The MEL 80 readout was found to overestimate the achieved ablation depth. The linear regression equations could be used by MEL 80 users to adjust the ablation depth for predicted residual stromal thickness calculations without increasing the risk of ectasia due to excessive keratectomy depth as long as a suitable flap thickness bias is included.

Pentacam Scheimpflug evaluation of corneal volume after LASIK

PURPOSE

To assess the change in corneal volume and laser ablation volume over time after LASIK using a rotating Scheimpflug camera.

METHODS

Twenty-six patients (49 eyes) underwent LASIK. Pentacam Scheimpflug measurements were performed pre- and postoperatively at 1, 3, 7, 15, and 30 days. Central corneal thickness, total corneal volume (10-mm diameter), and partial corneal volumes (3, 5, and 7 mm) based on the apex of the cornea, were measured. Main outcome measures were differences between pre- and postoperative volume measurements of total and partial corneal regions, volume changes over time postoperatively, and comparison between laser ablation volume and corneal volume.

RESULTS

A strong linear relationship was noted between spherical equivalent refraction and laser ablation volume (r = -0.931, P < .0001). Furthermore, 30 days after LASIK, a strong linear relationship was noted between planned thickness and achieved thickness (r = 0.9457, P < .001). Corneal volumes for 3-, 5-, and 7-mm diameter regions significantly decreased over time postoperatively (one-way analysis of variance, P < .05).

CONCLUSIONS

Alterations in corneal volume correlated with laser ablation volume when the diameter of the region considered was 3, 5, or 7 mm from the corneal apex.

Measurement of LASIK flap thickness with anterior segment optical coherence tomography

PURPOSE

To assess the interobserver variability and agreement of anterior segment optical coherence tomography (OCT) in the measurement of LASIK flap thickness, and to compare the results with intraoperative ultrasound pachymetry measurements.

METHODS

Thirty-nine eyes of 20 consecutive patients undergoing LASIK with the XP microkeratome (Bausch & Lomb) and ALLEGRETTO Eye-Q laser system (WaveLight Inc) had corneal flap thickness measured with SP-100 ultrasound (Tomey Corp) intraoperatively and with OCT (Visante; Carl Zeiss Meditec Inc) postoperatively. Interobserver assessment was performed by comparing the flap thickness measurements obtained from the same scan by 2 masked, independent observers. Agreement of OCT scan was determined by assessment of 2 different scans of the same eye by the same observer.

RESULTS

Mean (+/- standard deviation) flap thickness measured by ultrasound, OCT scan 1 (OCT 1-1) and scan 2 (OCT 1-2) assessed by observer 1, and OCT scan 1 (OCT 2-1) and scan 2 (OCT 2-2) assessed by observer 2 were 112.79+/-19.71, 124.69+/-17.02, 127.59+/-17.32, 130.59+/-20.34, and 133.74+/-19.70 microm, respectively. No statistically significant difference among the interobserver measurements was seen. The difference between OCT and ultrasound measurements by observers 1 and 2 was statistically significant (P<.01). Correlation among all measurements was statistically significant. Good agreement among the OCT scans was noted.

CONCLUSIONS

Optical coherence tomography showed good correlation among measurements and observers for different OCT measurements in the assessment of corneal flap thickness after LASIK. However, OCT significantly overestimated flap thickness when compared to ultrasound despite a good correlation between these two modalities. Optical coherence tomography measurements should not be substituted for standad ultrasound measurements at the present time.

Assessment of Eye Bank–Prepared Posterior Lamellar Corneal Tissue for Endothelial Keratoplasty

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate eye bank-prepared tissue for Descemet's stripping automated endothelial keratoplasty (DSAEK).

DESIGN

Experimental study and retrospective case series.

PARTICIPANTS

Seventeen human donor corneas and 4 recipient patients undergoing DSAEK surgery.

METHODS

Corneal-scleral discs were obtained. Specular microscopy and pachymetry were performed. A designated Tissue Banks International technician used a microkeratome to prepare a flap. Posterior bed thickness was measured. The sectioned tissue was stored, and at 24 and 48 hours, pachymetry was repeated. At 48 hours, specular microscopy was repeated, and endothelial cell viability was assessed with trypan blue. Descemet's stripping automated endothelial keratoplasty was performed in 4 patients using eye bank-prepared posterior lamellar tissue.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Corneal tissue was assessed with the following parameters: corneal thickness measured with ultrasonic pachymetry, cell density counts measured with a keratoanalyzer, and cell viability as observed with trypan blue exclusion. Patient outcomes were measured by changes in visual acuity (VA) and the presence of a clear graft.

RESULTS

Donor corneal pachymetry before sectioning averaged 599+/-52 microm. Immediately after sectioning with a microkeratome set at a depth of 300 microm, mean posterior bed thickness was 328+/-95 microm. Thus, the mean cutting depth achieved by the microkeratome when set at 300 micrometers averaged 271+/-83 microm. After storage for 24 hours, the posterior beds measured 352 microm, an average swelling of 24 (7%) microm (P = 0.14). After 48 hours, the posterior beds measured 382 microm, an average swelling of 54 (16%) microm (P = 0.02). Cell counts 48 hours after sectioning decreased by an average of 11% (P = 0.10). Endothelial cell staining confirmed improvement in postsectioning morphology and survival with increased technician experience. All 4 patients receiving eye bank-prepared DSAEK tissue showed uncomplicated postoperative results, with improvement in VA.

CONCLUSIONS

The microkeratome cutting depth was moderately accurate. Pachymetry, cell density, and cell viability of sectioned tissue after 48 hours in storage were encouraging overall. Initial clinical results of eye bank-prepared DSAEK tissue showed uncomplicated postoperative courses and improved VA. Additional studies are needed to follow the long-term outcomes in the recipients of these tissues.

The safety of 250 microm residual stromal bed in preventing keratectasia after laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK)

To determine if the residual corneal stromal bed of 250 microm is enough to prevent iatrogenic keratectasia in laser in situ keratomileusis (LASIK), we studied 958 patients who underwent LASIK from April 2000 to October 2003 retrospectively. The estimated probabilities of the residual stromal bed, that was less than 250 microm, were calculated using the published flap thickness data of Moria C&B microkeratome. Then we calculated the ratio of the real incidence of keratectasia to the expected the percentage of the patients with less than 250 microm residual stromal bed in our study. Using the LASIK flap thickness data of Miranda, Kezirian and Nagy, the expected probabilities that the residual stroma would be less than 250 microm were 8.8%, 4.3% and 1.5% of the 1,916 eyes respectively, while keratectasia developed in both eyes (0.1%) of 1 patient in our study. The estimated ratio of the keratectatic eyes to eyes with less than 250 microm stromal bed were 1.2-6.9%. Compared to the number of eyes with residual stromal thickness less than 250 microm, the incidence of keratectasia was relatively low. The residual stromal bed thickness of more than 250 microm may possibly be safe, but further observations for long period are necessary.

Online optical coherence pachymetry to evaluate intraoperative ablation parameters in LASIK

PURPOSE

The ablation of corneal tissue with the excimer laser can be variable and can lead to miscorrections. The purpose of this study was to evaluate intraoperative ablation parameters during laser-assisted in-situ keratomileusis (LASIK) with online optical coherence pachymetry (OCP).

METHODS

In a prospective, nonrandomized, comparative clinical study, the ablation parameters were continuously assessed intraoperatively with online OCP (Heidelberg Engineering, Lübeck, Germany) in 45 myopic and 10 hyperopic LASIK treatments. The central intraoperative ablation values were compared with the calculated values of the excimer laser (ESIRIS, Schwind, Germany) and the postoperative refraction. The ablation process and the ablation rate in mum per layer, time, and dioptric correction were evaluated in myopic corrections.

RESULTS

In myopic LASIK treatments, a linear ablation process was measured with a mean correlation coefficient of -0.968 +/- 0.04. The intraoperative ablation rate was, on average, 0.59 +/- 0.17 microm per layer, 1.45 +/- 0.48 microm per second, and 24.63 +/- 7.81 microm per corrected diopter. These values were 28.7% to 29.6% higher (P < 0.001) than the calculated values. There was a significant correlation (P < 0.001) for the ablation rate per layer (r = 0.823), per second (r = 0.869), and corrected diopter (r = 0.892), but no correlation (r = 0.21, P = 0.239) between the measured linear ablation process and the postoperative refraction. During hyperopic LASIK treatments, without ablation of the corneal center, there was a significant decrease (P = 0.005) of the stromal thickness by 18.34 +/- 14.13 microm, which corresponded to a mean corneal dehydration rate of 0.27 microm per second.

CONCLUSIONS

Online OCP allowed a clinical evaluation of intraoperative ablation parameters in LASIK. Further studies are needed to assess a possible active control of the excimer laser ablation from these continuous values, which could possibly improve current ablation nomograms.

Probability Model of the Inaccuracy of Residual Stromal Thickness Prediction to Reduce the Risk of Ectasia After LASIK Part I: Quantifying Individual Risk

PURPOSE

To measure the imprecision of microkeratome cuts, preoperative corneal pachymetry, and laser ablation depth and develop a statistical model to describe the probability of the residual stromal bed thickness (RST) after myopic LASIK being significantly thinner than predicted.

METHODS

Preoperative corneal thickness, flap thickness, ablation depth, and RST were measured in 36 eyes by a prototype three-dimensional very high-frequency (VHF) 50 MHz digital ultrasound scanning device (<1.2 microm precision), precursor to the commercially available Artemis 2. All eyes had undergone LASIK with the Moria LSK-One microkeratome and the NIDEK EC-5000 excimer laser. Based on the statistically combined uncertainty (standard deviation) and bias (accuracy to intended value) of corneal thickness measurement, flap thickness, and ablation depth, a continuous probability function was devised describing the chance of obtaining an actual RST less than a specified "cut-off". The model was applied using the data collected from the cohort of eyes. The model was also applied using published flap thickness statistics on a series of microkeratomes.

RESULTS

Precision (standard deviation) was 0.74 microm for VHF digital ultrasound measurement of pachymetry, 30.3 microm for Moria LSK-One flap thickness, and 11.2 microm for NIDEK EC-5000 ablation depth. Assuming negligible laser ablation depth bias, the model found the probability that the actual RST will be <200 pmicromgiven a target RST of 250 microm is 7.56% with the Moria LSK-One. The model applied to published flap statistics revealed a range of probabilities of leaving <200 microm given a target RST of 250 microm from <0.01% to 33.6%.

CONCLUSIONS

The choice of microkeratome, laser, and pachymeter has a significant impact on the variation of the depth of keratectomy and thus on the risk of ectasia. This model together with high-precision microkeratomes, preoperative pachymetry, and knowledge of laser ablation precision would enable surgeons to determine the specific imprecision of RST prediction for individual LASIK cases and minimize the risk of ectasia.

Probability Model of the Inaccuracy of Residual Stromal Thickness Prediction to Reduce the Risk of Ectasia After LASIK Part II: Quantifying Population Risk

PURPOSE

To derive a statistical model to estimate the rate of excessive keratectomy depth below a selected cut-off residual stromal thickness (RST) given a minimum target RST and specific Clinical Protocol; apply the model to estimate the RST below which ectasia appears likely to occur and back-calculate the safe minimum target RST that should be used given a specific Clinical Protocol.

METHODS

Myopia and corneal thickness distribution were modeled for a population of 5212 eyes that underwent LASIK. The probability distribution of predicted target RST error (Part I) was used to calculate the rate of excessive keratectomy depth for this series. All treatments were performed using the same Clinical Protocol; one surgeon, Moria LSK-One microkeratome, NIDEK EC-5000 excimer laser, Orbscan pachymetry, and a minimum target RST of 250 microm--the Vancouver Clinical Protocol. The model estimated the RST below which ectasia appears likely to occur and back-calculated the safe minimum target RST. These values were recalculated for a series of microkeratomes using published flap thickness statistics as well as for the Clinical Protocol of one of the authors-the London Clinical Protocol.

RESULTS

In the series of 5212 eyes, 6 (0.12%) cases of ectasia occurred. The model predicted an RST of 191 microm for ectasia to occur and that a minimum target RST of 329 microm would have reduced the -rate of ectasia to 1: 1,000,000 for the Vancouver Clinical Protocol. The model predicted that the choice of microkeratome varied the rate of ectasia between 0.01 and 11,623 eyes per million and the safe minimum target RST between 220 and 361 microm. The model predicted the rate of ectasia would have been 0.000003: 1,000,000 had the London Clinical Protocol been used for the Vancouver case series.

CONCLUSIONS

There appears to be no universally safe minimum target RST to assess suitability for LASIK largely due to the disparity in accuracy and reproducibility of microkeratome flap thickness. This model may be used as a tool to evaluate the risk of ectasia due to excessive keratectomy depth and help determine the minimum target RST given a particular Clinical Protocol.

Spatial Distribution of Keratan Sulfate in the Rabbit Cornea Following Photorefractive Keratectomy

PURPOSE

To examine the keratan sulfate content of the stroma and to assess its correlation with the healing process (epithelialization and keratocyte density) after photorefractive keratectomy (PRK).

METHODS

Using an Aesculap Meditec MEL 70(G-scan) excimer laser, -6.0 diopters (6.0-mm diameter, 82 microm photoablation depth), PRK was carried out on the right eye of 32 New Zealand pigmented rabbits. After enucleation (at days 1, 4, 7, 14, and 28 and months 2, 3, and 7; sub-groups of 4 animals), fluorescent immunohistochemistry was performed on sections from the central comea using monoclonal mouse anti-keratan-sulfate antibody, immunohistochemistry with proliferative cell nuclear antigen antibody, and hematoxylin-eosin histology. The left, untreated eyes served as controls. Cellular morphology and spatial distribution of keratan sulfate were recorded, stromal thickness measured, and keratocyte density calculated.

RESULTS

Keratan sulfate was found on the surface of migrating epithelial cells in the early stage (from days 1 to 7). In the stroma, three phases were noted. (Phase 1) Day 1 to 14, intense granular fluorescence appeared in the anterior stroma with hypocellularity. (Phase 2) Month 1 to 2, newly synthesized lamellar keratan sulfate restored the repopulating anterior stroma. Endothelial cells became keratan sulfate positive, while in the posterior stroma, lamellar-form keratan sulfate increased from week 1 and peaked at month 1 (100% increase). (Phase 3) Month 2 to 7, remodeling and deposition of keratan sulfate was noted, which was produced in phase 2.

CONCLUSIONS

Keratan sulfate was found in the epithelium, stroma, and endothelium. By controlling the interlamellar spacing, keratan sulfate plays a role in postoperative edema, remodeling of the corneal stroma, and simultaneous regulation of inflammation after PRK.