Structural correlates of an anticarcinoma antibody: identification of specificity-determining residues (SDRs) and development of a minimally immunogenic antibody variant by retention of SDRs only

A novel complement-fixing IgM antibody targeting GPC1 as a useful immunotherapeutic strategy for the treatment of pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma

BACKGROUND

Pancreatic ductal adenocarcinoma (PDAC) is one of the most aggressive cancers with a very low survival rate at 5 years. The use of chemotherapeutic agents results in only modest prolongation of survival and is generally associated with the occurrence of toxicity effects. Antibody-based immunotherapy has been proposed for the treatment of PDAC, but its efficacy has so far proved limited. The proteoglycan glypican-1 (GPC1) may be a useful immunotherapeutic target because it is highly expressed on the surface of PDAC cells, whereas it is not expressed or is expressed at very low levels in benign neoplastic lesions, chronic pancreatitis, and normal adult tissues. Here, we developed and characterized a specific mouse IgM antibody (AT101) targeting GPC1.

METHODS

We developed a mouse monoclonal antibody of the IgM class directed against an epitope of GPC1 in close proximity to the cell membrane. For this purpose, a 46 amino acid long peptide of the C-terminal region was used to immunize mice by an in-vivo electroporation protocol followed by serum titer and hybridoma formation.

RESULTS

The ability of AT101 to bind the GPC1 protein was demonstrated by ELISA, and by flow cytometry and immunofluorescence analysis in the GPC1-expressing "PDAC-like" BXPC3 cell line. In-vivo experiments in the BXPC3 xenograft model showed that AT101 was able to bind GPC1 on the cell surface and accumulate in the BXPC3 tumor masses. Ex-vivo analyses of BXPC3 tumor masses showed that AT101 was able to recruit immunological effectors (complement system components, NK cells, macrophages) to the tumor site and damage PDAC tumor tissue. In-vivo treatment with AT101 reduced tumor growth and prolonged survival of mice with BXPC3 tumor (p < 0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

These results indicate that AT101, an IgM specific for an epitope of GPC1 close to PDAC cell surface, is a promising immunotherapeutic agent for GPC1-expressing PDAC, being able to selectively activate the complement system and recruit effector cells in the tumor microenvironment, thus allowing to reduce tumor mass growth and improve survival in treated mice.

Application of germline antibody features to vaccine development, antibody discovery, antibody optimization and disease diagnosis

Although the efficacy and commercial success of vaccines and therapeutic antibodies have been tremendous, designing and discovering new drug candidates remains a labor-, time- and cost-intensive endeavor with high risks. The main challenges of vaccine development are inducing a strong immune response in broad populations and providing effective prevention against a group of highly variable pathogens. Meanwhile, antibody discovery faces several great obstacles, especially the blindness in antibody screening and the unpredictability of the developability and druggability of antibody drugs. These challenges are largely due to poorly understanding of germline antibodies and the antibody responses to pathogen invasions. Thanks to the recent developments in high-throughput sequencing and structural biology, we have gained insight into the germline immunoglobulin (Ig) genes and germline antibodies and then the germline antibody features associated with antigens and disease manifestation. In this review, we firstly outline the broad associations between germline antibodies and antigens. Moreover, we comprehensively review the recent applications of antigen-specific germline antibody features, physicochemical properties-associated germline antibody features, and disease manifestation-associated germline antibody features on vaccine development, antibody discovery, antibody optimization, and disease diagnosis. Lastly, we discuss the bottlenecks and perspectives of current and potential applications of germline antibody features in the biotechnology field.

A comprehensive comparison between camelid nanobodies and single chain variable fragments

By the emergence of recombinant DNA technology, many antibody fragments have been developed devoid of undesired properties of natural immunoglobulins. Among them, camelid heavy-chain variable domains (VHHs) and single-chain variable fragments (scFvs) are the most favored ones. While scFv is used widely in various applications, camelid antibodies (VHHs) can serve as an alternative because of their superior chemical and physical properties such as higher solubility, stability, smaller size, and lower production cost. Here, these two counterparts are compared in structure and properties to identify which one is more suitable for each of their various therapeutic, diagnosis, and research applications.

Optimization of therapeutic antibodies

In this review, we have summarized the current landscape of therapeutic antibody optimization for successful development. By engineering antibodies with display technology, computer-aided design and site mutagenesis, various properties of the therapeutic antibody candidates can be improved with the purpose of enhancing their safety, efficacy and developability. These properties include antigen binding affinity and specificity, biological efficacy, pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics, immunogenicity and physicochemical developability features. A best-in-class strategy may require the optimization of all these properties to generate a good therapeutic antibody.

Humanization and Simultaneous Optimization of Monoclonal Antibody

Antibody humanization is an essential technology for reducing the potential risk of immunogenicity associated with animal-derived antibodies and has been applied to a majority of the therapeutic antibodies on the market. For developing an antibody molecule as a pharmaceutical at the current biotechnology level, however, other properties also have to be considered in parallel with humanization in antibody generation and optimization. This section describes the critical properties of therapeutic antibodies that should be sufficiently qualified, including immunogenicity, binding affinity, physicochemical stability, expression in host cells and pharmacokinetics, and the basic methodologies of antibody engineering involved. By simultaneously optimizing the antibody molecule in light of these properties, it should prove possible to shorten the research and development period necessary to identify a highly qualified clinical candidate and consequently accelerate the start of the clinical trial.

Andre M, Svenson K, Morris C, Tchistiakova L. Beyond CDR-grafting: Structure-guided humanization of framework and CDR regions of an anti-myostatin antibody

Antibodies are an important class of biotherapeutics that offer specificity to their antigen, long half-life, effector function interaction and good manufacturability. The immunogenicity of non-human-derived antibodies, which can be a major limitation to development, has been partially overcome by humanization through complementarity-determining region (CDR) grafting onto human acceptor frameworks. The retention of foreign content in the CDR regions, however, is still a potential immunogenic liability. Here, we describe the humanization of an anti-myostatin antibody utilizing a 2-step process of traditional CDR-grafting onto a human acceptor framework, followed by a structure-guided approach to further reduce the murine content of CDR-grafted antibodies. To accomplish this, we solved the co-crystal structures of myostatin with the chimeric (Protein Databank (PDB) id 5F3B) and CDR-grafted anti-myostatin antibody (PDB id 5F3H), allowing us to computationally predict the structurally important CDR residues as well as those making significant contacts with the antigen. Structure-based rational design enabled further germlining of the CDR-grafted antibody, reducing the murine content of the antibody without affecting antigen binding. The overall "humanness" was increased for both the light and heavy chain variable regions.

Antibody humanization methods for development of therapeutic applications

Recombinant antibody technologies are rapidly becoming available and showing considerable clinical success. However, the immunogenicity of murine-derived monoclonal antibodies is restrictive in cancer immunotherapy. Humanized antibodies can overcome these problems and are considered to be a promising alternative therapeutic agent. There are several approaches for antibody humanization. In this article we review various methods used in the antibody humanization process.

Humanization and simultaneous optimization of monoclonal antibody

Antibody humanization is an essential technology for reducing the potential risk of immunogenicity associated with animal-derived antibodies and has been applied to a majority of the therapeutic antibodies on the market. For developing an antibody molecule as a pharmaceutical at the current biotechnology level, however, other properties also have to be considered in parallel with humanization in antibody generation and optimization. This section describes the critical properties of therapeutic antibodies that should be sufficiently qualified, including immunogenicity, binding affinity, physiochemical stability, expression in host cells and pharmacokinetics, and the basic methodologies of antibody engineering involved. By simultaneously optimizing the antibody molecule in the light of these properties, it should prove possible to shorten the research and development period necessary to identify a highly qualified clinical candidate and consequently accelerate the start of the clinical trial.

New engineered antibodies against prions

A number of recently developed and approved therapeutic agents based on highly specific and potent antibodies have shown the potential of antibody therapy. As the next step, antibody-based therapeutics will be bioengineered in a way that they not only bind pathogenic targets but also address other issues, including drug targeting and delivery. For antibodies that are expected to act within brain tissue, like those that are directed against the pathogenic prion protein isoform, one of the major obstacles is the blood-brain barrier which prevents efficient transfer of the antibody, even of the engineered single-chain variants. We recently demonstrated that a specific prion-specific antibody construct which was injected into the murine tail vein can be efficiently transported into brain tissue. The novelty of the work was in that the cell penetrating peptide was used as a linker connecting both specificity-determining domains of the antibody peptide, thus eliminating the need for the standard flexible linker, composed of an arrangement of three consecutive (Gly 4Ser) repeats. This paves the road toward improved bioengineered antibody variants that target brain antigens.

Humanization and characterization of an anti-ricin neutralization monoclonal antibody

Ricin is regarded as a high terrorist risk for the public due to its high toxicity and ease of production. Currently, there is no therapeutic or vaccine available against ricin. D9, a murine monoclonal antibody developed previously in our laboratory, can strongly neutralize ricin and is therefore a good candidate for humanization. Humanization of D9 variable regions was achieved by a complementarity-determining region grafting approach. The humanized D9 (hD9) variable regions were further grafted onto human heavy and light chain constant regions to assemble the complete antibody gene. A foot-and-mouth-disease virus-derived 2A self-processing sequence was introduced between heavy and light chain DNA sequences to cleave the recombinant protein into a functional full-length antibody molecule from a single open reading frame driven by a single promoter in an adenoviral vector. After expression in mammalian cells and purification, the hD9 was demonstrated to have equimolar expression of the full-length antibody heavy and light chains. More importantly, the hD9 exhibited high affinity to ricin with K_D of 1.63 nM, comparable to its parental murine D9 (2.55 nM). In a mouse model, intraperitoneal (i.p.) administration of hD9, at a low dose of 5 µg per mouse, 4 hours after the i.p. challenge with 5×LD50 ricin was found to rescue 100% of the mice. In addition, administered 6 hours post-challenge, hD9 could still rescue 50% of the mice. The hD9 has the potential to be used for prophylactic or therapeutic purposes against ricin poisoning.

Molecular engineering of antibodies for therapeutic and diagnostic purposes

During the past ten years, monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) have taken center stage in the field of targeted therapy and diagnosis. This increased interest in mAbs is due to their binding accuracy (affinity and specificity) together with the original molecular and structural rules that govern interactions with their cognate antigen. In addition, the effector properties of antibodies constitute a second major advantage associated with their clinical use. The development of molecular and structural engineering and more recently of in vitro evolution of antibodies has opened up new perspectives in the de novo design of antibodies more adapted to clinical and diagnostic use. Thus, efforts are regularly made by researchers to improve or modulate antibody recognition properties, to adapt their pharmacokinetics, engineer their stability, and control their immunogenicity. This review presents the latest molecular engineering results on mAbs with therapeutic and diagnostic applications.

Leveraging SBDD in protein therapeutic development: antibody engineering

Antibodies make up the largest, growing segment of protein therapeutics in the pharmaceutical and biotechnology industries. The development or engineering of therapeutic antibodies is based to a large extent on our knowledge of antibody structure and requires sophisticated methods that continue to evolve. In this chapter, after a review of what is known about the structure and functional properties of antibodies, the current, state-of-the-art antibody engineering methods are described. These methods include antibody humanization, antigen-affinity optimization, Fc engineering for modulated effector function and extended half-life, and engineering for improved stability and biophysical properties. X-ray crystallographic structures of antibody fragments and their complexes can play a critical role in guiding and, in some cases, accelerating these processes. These approaches represent guidelines for developing antibody therapeutics with the desired affinity, effector function, and biophysical properties.

Humanization by CDR grafting and specificity-determining residue grafting

Humanized antibodies are constructed by CDR grafting, while retaining those murine framework residues that influence the antigen-binding activity. To reduce the immunogenicity of CDR-grafted humanized antibodies, the murine content in the CDR-grafted humanized antibodies is minimized through SDR grafting. Within each CDR, there are more variable positions that are directly involved in the interaction with antigen, i.e., specificity-determining residues (SDRs), whereas there are more conserved residues that maintain the conformations of CDRs loops. SDRs may be identified from the 3D structure of the antigen-antibody complex and/or the mutational analysis of the CDRs. An SDR-grafted humanized antibody is constructed by grafting the SDRs and the residues maintaining the conformations of the CDRs onto human template, and its immunogenic potential is evaluated by measuring the reactivity to the sera from patients who had been immunized with the parental antibody.

Engineering the variable region of therapeutic IgG antibodies

Since the first generation of humanized IgG1 antibodies reached the market in the late 1990s, IgG antibody molecules have been extensively engineered. The success of antibody therapeutics has introduced severe competition in developing novel therapeutic monoclonal antibodies, especially for promising or clinically validated targets. Such competition has led researchers to generate so-called second or third generation antibodies with clinical differentiation utilizing various engineering and optimization technologies. Parent IgG antibodies can be engineered to have improved antigen binding properties, effector functions, pharmacokinetics, pharmaceutical properties and safety issues. Although the primary role of the antibody variable region is to bind to the antigen, it is also the main source of antibody diversity and its sequence affects various properties important for developing antibody therapeutics. Here we review recent research activity in variable region engineering to generate superior antibody therapeutics.

Engineering fully human monoclonal antibodies from murine variable regions

Fully human monoclonal antibodies (mAbs) derived from transgenic mice or human antibody libraries are the current state of the art for reducing the immunogenicity risk of antibody drugs. Here, we describe a novel method for generating fully human mAbs from nonhuman variable regions using information from the human germline repertoire. Central to our strategy is the rational engineering of residues within and proximal to CDRs and the V(H)/V(L) interface by iteratively exploring substitutions to the closest human germline sequences using semi-automated computational methods. Starting from the parent murine variable regions of three currently marketed mAbs targeting CD25, vascular endothelial growth factor, and tumor necrosis factor alpha, we have generated fully human antibodies with 59, 46, and 45 substitutions, respectively, compared to the parent murine sequences. A large number of these substitutions were in the CDRs, which are typically avoided in humanization methods. Antigen affinities of the fully human variants were comparable to the chimeric mAbs in each case. Furthermore, in vitro functional characterization indicated that all retain potency of the chimeric mAbs and have comparable activity to their respective marketed drugs daclizumab, bevacizumab, and infliximab. Based on local and global sequence identity, the sequences of our engineered mAbs are indistinguishable from those of fully human mAbs isolated from transgenic mice or human antibody libraries. This work establishes a simple rational engineering methodology for generating fully human antibody therapeutics from murine mAbs produced from standard hybridoma technology.

Engineering antibodies for clinical applications

Molecular engineering has contributed immensely to the clinical success of antibodies in recent years. The modular structure of antibodies has permitted their modification in numerous ways, to meet various clinical requirements. With the help of antibody engineering, it has been possible to modify the molecular size, pharmacokinetics, immunogenicity, binding affinity, specificity and effector function of antibodies. In addition, fusion proteins of antibodies with various proteins and peptides have yielded targeted biological modifiers, toxins and imaging agents. This review focuses on the recent trends in antibody engineering for improving their clinical utility.

Ribosome display for improved biotherapeutic molecules

Ribosome display presents an innovative in vitro technology for the rapid isolation and evolution of high-affinity peptides or proteins. Displayed proteins are bound to and recovered from target molecules in multiple rounds of selection in order to enrich for specific binding proteins. No transformation step is necessary, which could lead to a loss of library diversity. A cycle of display and selection can be performed in one day, enabling the existing gene repertoire to be rapidly scanned. Proteins isolated from the panning rounds can be further modified through random or directed molecular evolution for affinity maturation, as well as selected for characteristics such as protein stability, folding and functional activity. Recently, the field of display technologies has become more prominent due to the generation of new scaffolds for ribosome display, isolation of high-affinity human antibodies by phage display, and their implementation in the discovery of novel protein-protein interactions. Applications for this technology extend into the broad field of antibody engineering, proteomics, and synthetic enzymes for diagnostics and therapeutics in cancer, autoimmune and infectious diseases, neurodegenerative diseases and inflammatory disorders. This review highlights the role of ribosome display in drug discovery, discusses advantages and disadvantages of the system, and attempts to predict the future impact of ribosome display technology on the development of novel engineered biopharmaceutical products for biological therapies.

Construction, affinity maturation, and biological characterization of an anti-tumor-associated glycoprotein-72 humanized antibody

The tumor-associated glycoprotein (TAG)-72 is expressed in the majority of human adenocarcinomas but is rarely expressed in most normal tissues, which makes it a potential target for the diagnosis and therapy of a variety of human cancers. Here we describe the construction, affinity maturation, and biological characterization of an anti-TAG-72 humanized antibody with minimum potential immunogenicity. The humanized antibody was constructed by grafting only the specificity-determining residues (SDRs) within the complementarity-determining regions (CDRs) onto homologous human immunoglobulin germ line segments while retaining two mouse heavy chain framework residues that support the conformation of the CDRs. The resulting humanized antibody (AKA) showed only about 2-fold lower affinity compared with the original murine monoclonal antibody CC49 and 27-fold lower reactivity to patient serum compared with the humanized antibody HuCC49 that was constructed by CDR grafting. The affinity of AKA was improved by random mutagenesis of the heavy chain CDR3 (HCDR3). The highest affinity variant (3E8) showed 22-fold higher affinity compared with AKA and retained the original epitope specificity. Mutational analysis of the HCDR3 residues revealed that the replacement of Asn(97) by isoleucine or valine was critical for the affinity maturation. The 3E8 labeled with (125)I or (131)I showed efficient tumor targeting or therapeutic effects, respectively, in athymic mice with human colon carcinoma xenografts, suggesting that 3E8 may be beneficial for the diagnosis and therapy of tumors expressing TAG-72.

Anticorps humanisés en thérapeutique

Since 1997, nine humanized antibodies received the approval of the FDA to be used as drugs for the treatment of various diseases including transplant rejections, metastatic breast and colon cancers, leukaemia, non-Hodgkin lymphomas, allergic conditions or multiple sclerosis. This review describes techniques used to engineer these antibodies and presents the recent evolutions of these techniques : SDRs grafting or << abbreviated >> CDRs grafting. Based on the illustrative examples of several antibodies, Mylotarg, Herceptin or Xolair, the therapeutic effectiveness of humanized antibodies are underlined and, with the example of Tysabri, the sometimes dramatic adverse effects associated with their clinical use is stressed. In a second part, this review presents some future and realistic avenues to improve the effectiveness of the humanized antibodies, to decrease their immunogenicity and to reduce their cost.

SDR grafting--a new approach to antibody humanization

A major impediment to the clinical utility of the murine monoclonal antibodies is their potential to elicit human anti-murine antibody (HAMA) response in patients. To circumvent this problem, murine antibodies have been genetically manipulated to progressively replace their murine content with the amino acid residues present in their human counterparts. To that end, murine antibodies have been humanized by grafting their complementarity determining regions (CDRs) onto the variable light (V(L)) and variable heavy (V(H)) frameworks of human immunoglobulin molecules, while retaining those murine framework residues deemed essential for the integrity of the antigen-combining site. However, the xenogeneic CDRs of the humanized antibodies may evoke anti-idiotypic (anti-Id) response in patients. To minimize the anti-Id response, a procedure to humanize xenogeneic antibodies has been described that is based on grafting, onto the human frameworks, only the specificity determining residues (SDRs), the CDR residues that are most crucial in the antibody-ligand interaction. The SDRs are identified through the help of the database of the three-dimensional structures of the antigen-antibody complexes of known structures or by mutational analysis of the antibody-combining site. An alternative approach to humanization, which involves retention of more CDR residues, is based on grafting of the 'abbreviated' CDRs, the stretches of CDR residues that include all the SDRs. A procedure to assess the reactivity of the humanized antibody to sera from patients who had been administered the murine antibody has also been described.

Controlling complement resistance in cancer by using human monoclonal antibodies that neutralize complement-regulatory proteins CD55 and CD59

Expression of the complement-regulatory proteins (CRP) CD46, CD55 and CD59 represents a strategy used by tumor cells to evade complement-dependent cell cytoxicity stimulated by monoclonal antibodies. We have isolated two single-chain variable fragments (scFv) to CD55 and CD59 from a human phage-display library and from these scFv we have produced two miniantibodies (MB), MB-55 (against CD55) and MB-59 (against CD59), containing the human hinge-CH2-CH3 domains of IgG1. The specificity of the two MB for the corresponding CRP was assessed by ELISA using purified CD46, CD55 and CD59. MB-55 and MB-59 neutralized the inhibitory activity of CD55 and CD59, respectively, restoring the complement-mediated lysis of sheep and guinea pig erythrocytes that was otherwise inhibited by the two CRP. FACS analysis revealed binding of MB-55 and MB-59 to the lymphoma cell line Karpas 422. The two MB induced a two-fold increase in the complement-dependent killing of these cells stimulated by Rituximab, a chimeric anti-CD20 monoclonal antibody. Transfection of HEK293T cells with vectors encoding MB-55 or MB-59 markedly reduced the expression of CD55 and CD59. We conclude that the human antibodies MB-55 and MB-59 may represent a therapeutic tool to increase the complement-dependent killing activity of Rituximab in the treatment of non-Hodgkin's lymphoma.

The structure of an antitumor C(H)2-domain-deleted humanized antibody

C(H)2-domain-deleted CC49 (HuCC49DeltaCH2), a recombinant humanized antibody that recognizes the TAG-72 antigen expressed on a variety of human carcinomas, is secreted from cultured cells as a mixture of two homodimeric isoforms. Isoform A contains two covalent interchain disulfide bonds at heavy chain positions 239 and 242, while isoform B fails to develop any interchain disulfide bonds but has 239-242 intrachain disulfide bonds instead. Form A is currently in preclinical development as a therapeutic agent for treating colorectal carcinoma, though form B shows equal efficacy. HuCC49DeltaCH2 form B can be crystallized from sodium formate only in the presence of detergents. X-ray diffraction data were collected on a single cryo-cooled crystal grown with Triton X-100 and the structure was solved by molecular replacement. The model has refined to R=0.246 (R(free)=0.297) for 2.8A data. The antibodies pack in the crystal around crystallographic 2-fold axes as tetramers with approximate 222 symmetry. Atomic force microscopy studies show that this tetrameric structure is the crystal building block and also exists free in the mother liquor. The tetramer is composed of two rings, back-to-back, with a thickness of approximately 83A. Each ring is composed of two antibodies with the complementarity-determining regions (CDR) of the two Fabs of one antibody interacting with the CDR regions of the second antibody in a head-to-head fashion. These rings are approximately 167A long and 112A wide. The C(H)3 domain is inverted with respect to the Fabs when compared to the usual orientation found in conventional antibodies. The polypeptides joining the C(H)3 domains to the Fab portions of the antibody are not seen and are almost certainly disordered. The antigen combining site of HuCC49DeltaCH2 is very similar, but not identical, in topology and charge distribution to that of antibody B72.3, which binds a similar epitope on TAG-72. The combining site consists of a deep cleft, heavily lined with aromatic amino acid side-chains but bounded by numerous charged groups.

Minimizing the Immunogenicity of Antibodies for Clinical Application

The clinical utility of murine monoclonal antibodies has been greatly limited by the human anti-murine antibody responses they effect in patients. To make them less immunogenic, murine antibodies have been genetically engineered to progressively replace their murine content with that of their human counterparts. This review describes the genetic approaches that have been used to humanize murine antibodies, including the generation of mouse-human chimeric antibodies, veneering of the mouse variable regions, and the grafting of murine complementarity-determining regions (CDRs) onto the variable light (VL) and variable heavy (VH) frameworks of human immunoglobulin molecules, while retaining only those murine framework residues deemed essential for the integrity of the antigen-binding site. To minimize the anti-idiotypic responses that could still be evoked by the murine CDRs in humanized antibodies, two approaches have also been described. These are based on grafting onto the human frameworks the 'abbreviated' CDRs or only the specificity-determining residues (SDRs), the CDR residues that are involved in antigen interaction. The SDRs are identified through the help of the database of three-dimensional structures of antibody:antigen complexes or by mutational analysis of the antibody-combining site. In addition, we also describe the use of in vitro affinity maturation to enhance the binding affinity of humanized antibodies, as well as the manipulation of framework residues to maximize their human content and minimize their immunogenic potential.

SDR grafting of a murine antibody using multiple human germline templates to minimize its immunogenicity

The humanization of mAbs by complementarity-determining region (CDR)-grafting has become a standard procedure to improve the clinical utility of xenogeneic Abs by reducing human anti-murine Ab (HAMA) responses elicited in patients. However, CDR-grafted humanized Abs may still evoke anti-V region responses when administered in patients. To minimize anti-V region responses, the Ab may be humanized by grafting onto the human templates only the specificity-determining residues (SDRs), the residues that are essential for the surface complementarity of the Ab and its ligand. Typically, humanization of an Ab, whether by CDR or SDR grafting, involves the use of a single human template for the entire VL or VH domain of an Ab. We hypothesized, however, that the homology between the human template sequences and mAb to be humanized may be maximized by using templates from multiple human germline sequences corresponding to the different segments of the variable domain. This could be more advantageous in reducing the potential immunogenicity of the humanized Ab. This report describes the SDR grafting of the murine anti-carcinoembryonic antigen (CEA) mAb COL-1 using three different human germline V-kappa sequences as templates for the VL CDRs and another human template for the VL frameworks. In competition RIAs, the SDR-grafted COL-1 (HuCOL-1SDR) completely inhibited the binding of radiolabeled murine COL-1 (mCOL-1) to CEA, and showed that its binding affinity is comparable to that of the CDR-grafted Ab (HuCOL-1). The HuCOL-1SDR showed similar binding reactivity to the CEA expressed on the surface of a tumor cell line as the HuCOL-1. More importantly, compared to HuCOL-1 and the "abbreviated" CDR-grafted Ab, HuCOL-1SDR showed lower reactivity to patients' sera carrying anti-V region Abs to mCOL-1. HuCOL-1SDR, which shows a lower sera reactivity than that of the parental Abs while retaining its Ag-binding property, is a potentially useful clinical reagent. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first time a VL or VH domain of an Ab has been humanized by grafting the SDRs onto a human template comprised of several Ab sequences. We have shown that humanization of an Ab can be optimized using multiple human templates for a single variable domain of an Ab. This approach maximizes the homology between the target Ab and the human templates in both the frameworks and the CDRs by choosing as the template the human sequence that displays the highest local sequence identity to the frameworks and to each of the CDRs of the target Ab.

Recombinant antibodies for the diagnosis and treatment of cancer

The advent of recombinant antibody technology led to an enormous revival in the use of antibodies as diagnostic and therapeutic tools for fighting cancer. This review provides a brief historical sketch of the development of recombinant antibodies for the diagnosis and immunotherapy of cancer and summarizes the most significant clinical data for the best established reagents to date. It also discusses clinically relevant aspects of the use of recombinant antibodies in cancer patients.

Humanization of the anti-CD18 antibody 6.7: an unexpected effect of a framework residue in binding to antigen

Humanization of monoclonal antibodies by complementary determinant region (CDR)-grafting has become a standard procedure to improve the clinical usage of animal antibodies. However, antibody humanization may result in loss of activity that has been attributed to structural constraints in the framework structure. In this paper, we report the complete humanization of the 6.7 anti-human CD18 monoclonal antibody in a scFv form. We used a germline-based approach to design a humanized VL gene fragment and expressed it together with a previously described humanized VH. The designed humanized VL has only 14 mutations compared to the closest human germline sequence. The resulting humanized scFv maintained the binding capacity and specificity to human CD18 expressed on the cell surface of peripheral blood mononuclear cells (PBMC), and showed the same pattern of staining T-lymphocytes sub-populations, in comparison to the original monoclonal antibody. We observed an unexpected effect of a conserved mouse-human framework position (L37) that hinders the binding of the humanized scFv to antigen. This paper reveals a new framework residue that interferes with paratope and antigen binding and also reinforces the germline approach as a successful strategy to humanize antibodies.

Rational design and engineering of therapeutic proteins

An increasing number of engineered protein therapeutics are currently being developed, tested in clinical trials and marketed for use. Many of these proteins arose out of hit-and-miss efforts to discover specific mutations, fusion partners or chemical modifications that confer desired properties. Through these efforts, several useful strategies have emerged for rational optimization of therapeutic candidates. The controlled manipulation of the physical, chemical and biological properties of proteins enabled by structure-based simulation is now being used to refine established rational engineering approaches and to advance new strategies. These methods provide clear, hypothesis-driven routes to solve problems that plague many proteins and to create novel mechanisms of action. We anticipate that rational protein engineering will shape the field of protein therapeutics dramatically by improving existing products and enabling the development of novel therapeutic agents.

Surface plasmon resonance-based competition assay to assess the sera reactivity of variants of humanized antibodies

While clinical trials are the only way to evaluate the immunogenicity, in patients, of murine or genetically engineered humanized variants of a potentially therapeutic or diagnostic monoclonal antibody (MAb), ethical and logistical considerations of clinical trials do not permit the evaluation of variants of a given MAb that are generated to minimize its immunogenicity. The most promising variant could be identified by comparing the reactivities of the parental antibody (Ab) and its variants to the sera of patients containing anti-variable region (anti-VR) Abs to the administered parental Ab. We have developed a surface plasmon resonance (SPR) biosensor-based assay to monitor the binding of the sera anti-VR Abs to the parental Ab and the inhibition of this binding by the variants. SPR biosensors allow the real-time detection and monitoring of the binding between an immobilized protein and its soluble ligand without the need for prior purification and labeling of the mobile analyte. This new assay requires no radiolabeling, is relatively less time-consuming, and uses only small amounts of serum (5-20 microl of diluted serum) through a new microfluidic sample handling technique. To validate the assay, we have tested the relative reactivities of the CDR-grafted anti-carcinoma Ab, HuCC49, and its two variants, designated V5 and V10, to the sera of patients who were earlier administered radiolabeled murine CC49 in a clinical trial. A comparison of IC(50)s (the concentrations of the competitor Abs required for 50% inhibition of the binding of sera to immobilized HuCC49) showed that V5 and V10 were less reactive than HuCC49 to the three patients' sera tested. We have also demonstrated, for the first time, the specific detection and comparison of relative amounts of anti-VR Abs present in the sera of different patients without prior removal of anti-murine Fc Abs and/or circulating antigen. This may facilitate the rapid screening, for the presence of anti-VR Abs, of the sera of patients undergoing clinical trials.

Grafting of "abbreviated" complementarity-determining regions containing specificity-determining residues essential for ligand contact to engineer a less immunogenic humanized monoclonal antibody

Murine mAb COL-1 reacts with carcinoembryonic Ag (CEA), expressed on a wide range of human carcinomas. In preclinical studies in animals and clinical trials in patients, murine COL-1 showed excellent tumor localization. To circumvent the problem of immunogenicity of the murine Ab in patients, a humanized COL-1 (HuCOL-1) was generated by grafting the complementarity-determining regions (CDRs) of COL-1 onto the frameworks of the variable light and variable heavy regions of human mAbs. To minimize anti-V region responses, a variant of HuCOL-1 was generated by grafting onto the human frameworks only the "abbreviated" CDRs, the stretches of CDR residues that contain the specificity-determining residues that are essential for the surface complementarity of the Ab and its ligand. In competition RIAs, the recombinant variant completely inhibited the binding of radiolabeled murine and humanized COL-1 to CEA. The HuCOL-1 and its variant showed no difference in their binding ability to the CEA expressed on the surface of a CEA-transduced tumor cell line. Compared with HuCOL-1, the HuCOL-1 variant showed lower reactivity to patients' sera carrying anti-V region Abs to COL-1. The final variant of the HuCOL-1, which retains its Ag-binding reactivity and shows significantly lower serum reactivity than that of the parental Ab, can serve as a prototype for the development of a potentially useful clinical reagent.

Rationales, evidence, and design considerations for fractionated radioimmunotherapy

Although fractionation can be used in a discrete radiobiologic sense, herein it is generally used in the broader context of administration of multiple, rather than single, doses of radionuclide for radioimmunotherapy (RIT) or other targeted radionuclide therapies. Fractionation is a strategy for overcoming heterogeneity of monoclonal antibody (MAb) distribution in the tumor and the consequent nonuniformity of tumor radiation doses. Additional advantages of fractionated RIT are the ability to 1) provide patient-specific radionuclide and radiation dosing, 2) control toxicity by titration of the individual patient, 3) reduce toxicity, 4) increase the maximum tolerated dose (MTD) for many patients, 5) increase tumor radiation dose and efficacy, and 6) prolong tumor response by permitting treatment over time. However, fractionated RIT has logistic and economic implications. Preclinical and clinical data substantiate the advantages of fractionated RIT, although the radiobiology for conventional external beam radiotherapy does not provide a straightforward rationale for RIT unless fractionation leads to more uniform distribution of radiation dose throughout the tumor. Preclinical data have shown that toxicity and mortality can be reduced while efficacy is increased, thereby providing inferential evidence of greater uniformity of radiation dose. Direct evidence of superior dosimetry and tumor activity distribution has also been found. Clinical data have shown that toxicity can be better controlled and reduced and the MTD extended for many patients. It is clear that fractionated RIT can only fulfill its potential if the effects of critical issues, such as the number and amount of radionuclide doses, the radionuclide physical and effective half-life, and the dose interval, are better characterized.

Effects of humanization and gene shuffling on immunogenicity and antigen binding of anti-TAG-72 single-chain Fvs

One major constraint in the clinical application of murine monoclonal antibodies (MAbs) is the development of a human antimurine antibody response. The immunogenicity of MAbs can be minimized by replacing nonhuman regions with corresponding human sequences. The studies reported in our article were undertaken to analyze the immunoreactivity and the immunogenicity of the CC49 single-chain antibody fragments (scFvs): (i) an scFv construct comprised of mouse CC49 VL and VH (m/m scFv), (ii) a light chain shuffled scFv with human VL (Hum4 VL) and mouse CC49 VH (h/m scFv), and (iii) a humanized scFv assembled from Hum4 VL and CC49 VH complementary determining regions (CDRs) grafted onto a VH framework of MAb 21/28' CL (h/CDR scFv). The CC49 scFvs competed for an antigen binding site with CC49 IgG in a similar fashion in a competition radioimmunoassay and were able to inhibit the binding of CC49 IgG to the antigen completely. The immunogenicity of CC49 scFvs was tested using sera with antiidiotypic antibodies to MAb CC49 obtained from patients treated by CC49 IgG in clinical trials. All tested sera exhibited the highest reactivity to the m/m scFv. However, the sera demonstrated differential reactivities to h/CDR scFv and h/m scFv. Replacement of the mouse chain in h/m scFv and h/CDR scFv decreased or completely averted serum reactivity. Our studies compared for the first time the antigen binding and immunogenicity of different scFv constructs containing the mouse, CDR grafted or human variable chains. These results indicate that the humanized CC49 scFv is potentially an important agent for imaging and therapeutic applications with TAG-72-positive tumors.

Reduced antibody response to streptavidin through site-directed mutagenesis

Streptavidin provides an effective receptor for biotinylated tumoricidal molecules, including radionuclides, when conjugated to an antitumor antibody and administered systemically. Ideally, one would like to administer this bacterial protein to patients repeatedly, so as to maximize the antitumor effect without eliciting an immune response. Therefore, we attempted to reduce the antigenicity of streptavidin by mutating surface residues capable of forming high energy ionic or hydrophobic interactions. A crystallographic image of streptavidin was examined to identify residues with solvent-exposed side chains and residues critical to streptavidin's structure or function, and to define loops. Mutations were incorporated cumulatively into the protein sequence. Mutants were screened for tetramer formation, biotin dissociation, and reduced immunoreactivity with pooled patient sera. Patient antisera recognized one minor continuous epitope with binding locus at residue E101 and one major discontinuous epitope involving amino acid residues E51 and Y83. Mutation of residues E51, Y83, R53, and E116 reduced reactivity with patient sera to <10% that of streptavidin, but these mutations were no less antigenic in rabbits. Mutant 37, with 10 amino acid substitutions, was only 20% as antigenic as streptavidin. Rabbits immunized with either streptavidin or mutant 37 failed to recognize the alternative antigen. Biotin dissociated from mutant 37 four to five times faster than from streptavidin. Residues were identified with previously undescribed impact on biotin binding and protein folding. Thus, substitution of charged, aromatic, or large hydrophobic residues on the surface of streptavidin with smaller neutral residues reduced the molecule's ability to elicit an immune response in rabbits.

Ribosome display and affinity maturation: from antibodies to single V-domains and steps towards cancer therapeutics

Protein affinity maturation using molecular evolution techniques to produce high-affinity binding proteins is an important step in the generation of reagents for cancer diagnosis and treatment. Currently, the most commonly used molecular evolution processes involve mutation of a single gene into complex gene repertoires followed by selection from a display library. Fd-bacteriophage are the most popular display vectors, but are limited in their capacity for library presentation, speed of processing and mutation frequency. Recently, the potential of ribosome display for directed molecular evolution was recognised and developed into a rapid and simple affinity selection strategy using ribosome complexes to display antibody fragments (scFv). Ribosome display and selection has the potential to generate and display large libraries more representative of the theoretical optima for naïve repertoires (10(14)). Even more important is the application of ribosome display for the affinity maturation of individual proteins by rapid mutation and selection cycles. These display strategies can apply to other members of the immunoglobulin superfamily; for example single V-domains which have an important application in providing specific targeting to either novel or refractory cancer markers. We discuss the application of ribosome display and selection in conjunction with variable domain (CTLA-4) libraries as the first step towards this objective and review affinity maturation strategies for in vitro ribosome display systems.

Recombinant antibodies: a novel approach to cancer diagnosis and therapy

Recombinant antibodies and their fragments currently represent over 30% of all biological proteins undergoing clinical trials for diagnosis and therapy. These reagents dominate the cancer-targeting field, as highlighted by the recent approval of the first engineered therapeutic antibodies by the Food and Drugs Administration (FDA). Last year, important advances have been made in the design, selection and production of recombinant antibodies. The natural immune repertoire and somatic cell affinity maturation has been superseded by large antibody display libraries and rapid molecular evolution strategies. These novel libraries and selection methods have enabled the rapid isolation of high-affinity cancer targeting and antiviral antibodies, the latter capable of redirecting viruses for gene therapy applications. In alternative strategies for cancer diagnosis and therapy, recombinant antibody fragments have been fused to radioisotopes, drugs, toxins, enzymes and biosensor surfaces. Antibody-directed cancer pre-targeting followed by prodrug activation (ADEPT) has proved a most promising therapeutic strategy. Multi-specific antibodies have been effective for cytotoxic T-cell recruitment and antibody-fusion proteins have delivered enhanced immunotherapeutic and vaccination strategies. The new millennium is indeed an exciting time for the design, selection and formulation of a range of new antibody-based products for cancer diagnosis and therapy.