Structural characterization of the D290V mutation site in hnRNPA2 low-complexity-domain polymers

A simple method for mapping the location of cross-β-forming regions within protein domains of low sequence complexity

Protein domains of low sequence complexity are unable to fold into stable, three-dimensional structures. In test tube studies, these unusual polypeptide regions can self-associate in a manner causing phase separation from aqueous solution. This form of protein:protein interaction has been implicated in numerous examples of dynamic morphological organization within eukaryotic cells. In several cases, the basis for low complexity domain (LCD) self-association and phase separation has been traced to the formation of labile cross-β structures. The primary energetic force favoring formation of these transient and reversible structures is enabled by polypeptide backbone interactions. Short, contiguous networks of peptide backbone amino groups and carbonyl oxygens are zippered together intermolecularly by hydrogen bonding as described by Linus Pauling seven decades ago. Here, we describe a simple, molecular biological method useful for the identification of localized, self-associating regions within larger protein domains of low sequence complexity.

Conformations of a low-complexity protein in homogeneous and phase-separated frozen solutions

Solutions of the intrinsically disordered, low-complexity domain of the FUS protein (FUS-LC) undergo liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) below a temperature TLLPS. To investigate whether local conformational distributions are detectably different in the homogeneous (i.e., single-phase) and phase-separated states of FUS-LC, we performed solid-state NMR (ssNMR) measurements on solutions that were frozen on submillisecond timescales after equilibration at temperatures well above (50°C) or well below (4°C) TLLPS. Measurements were performed at 25 K with signal enhancements from dynamic nuclear polarization. Crosspeak patterns in two-dimensional ssNMR spectra of rapidly frozen solutions in which FUS-LC was uniformly 15N,13C labeled were found to be nearly identical for the two states. Similar results were obtained for solutions in which FUS-LC was labeled only at Thr, Tyr, and Gly residues, as well as solutions of a FUS construct in which five specific residues were labeled by ligation of synthetic and recombinant fragments. These experiments show that local conformational distributions are nearly the same in the homogeneous and phase-separated solutions, despite the much greater protein concentrations and more abundant intermolecular interactions within phase-separated, protein-rich "droplets." Comparison of the experimental results with simulations of the sensitivity of two-dimensional ssNMR crosspeaks to changes in populations of β strand-like conformations suggests that changes in conformational distributions are no larger than 5-10%.

Mutations in human prion-like domains: pathogenic but not always amyloidogenic

Heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoproteins (hnRNPs) are multifunctional proteins with integral roles in RNA metabolism and the regulation of alternative splicing. These proteins typically contain prion-like domains of low complexity (PrLDs or LCDs) that govern their assembly into either functional or pathological amyloid fibrils. To date, over 60 mutations targeting the LCDs of hnRNPs have been identified and associated with a spectrum of neurodegenerative diseases including amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), frontotemporal dementia (FTD), and Alzheimer's disease (AD). The cryo-EM structures of pathological and functional fibrils formed by different hnRNPs have been recently elucidated, including those of hnRNPA1, hnRNPA2, hnRNPDL-2, TDP-43, and FUS. In this review, we discuss the structural features of these amyloid assemblies, placing particular emphasis on scrutinizing the impact of prevalent disease-associated mutations mapping within their LCDs. By performing systematic energy calculations, we reveal a prevailing trend of destabilizing effects induced by these mutations in the amyloid structure, challenging the traditionally assumed correlation between pathogenicity and amyloidogenic propensity. Understanding the molecular basis of this discrepancy might provide insights for developing targeted therapeutic strategies to combat hnRNP-associated diseases.

Conformations of a Low-Complexity Protein in Homogeneous and Phase-Separated Frozen Solutions

Solutions of the intrinsically disordered, low-complexity domain of the FUS protein (FUS-LC) undergo liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) below temperatures TLLPS in the 20-40° C range. To investigate whether local conformational distributions are detectably different in the homogeneous and phase-separated states of FUS-LC, we performed solid state nuclear magnetic resonance (ssNMR) measurements on solutions that were frozen on sub-millisecond time scales after equilibration at temperatures well above (50° C) or well below (4° C) TLLPS. Measurements were performed at 25 K with signal enhancements from dynamic nuclear polarization. Crosspeak patterns in two-dimensional (2D) ssNMR spectra of rapidly frozen solutions in which FUS-LC was uniformly 15N,13C-labeled were found to be nearly identical for the two states. Similar results were obtained for solutions in which FUS-LC was labeled only at Thr, Tyr, and Gly residues, as well as solutions of a FUS construct in which five specific residues were labeled by ligation of synthetic and recombinant fragments. These experiments show that local conformational distributions are nearly the same in the homogeneous and phase-separated solutions, despite the much greater protein concentrations and more abundant intermolecular interactions within phase-separated, protein-rich "droplets". Comparison of the experimental results with simulations of the sensitivity of 2D crosspeak patterns to an enhanced population of β-strand-like conformations suggests that changes in conformational distributions are no larger than 5-10%.

Statement of Significance

Liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) in solutions of proteins with intrinsically disordered domains has attracted recent attention because of its relevance to multiple biological processes and its inherent interest from the standpoint of protein biophysics. The high protein concentrations and abundant intermolecular interactions within protein-rich, phase-separated "droplets" suggests that conformational distributions of intrinsically disordered proteins may differ in homogeneous and phase-separated solutions. To investigate whether detectable differences exist, we performed experiments on the low-complexity domain of the FUS protein (FUS-LC) in which FUS-LC solutions were first equilibrated at temperatures well above or well below their LLPS transition temperatures, then rapidly frozen and examined at very low temperatures by solid state nuclear magnetic resonance (ssNMR) spectroscopy. The ssNMR data for homogeneous and phase-separated frozen solutions of FUS-LC were found to be nearly identical, showing that LLPS is not accompanied by substantial changes in the local conformational distributions of this intrinsically disordered protein.

An evolutionarily conserved mechanism controls reversible amyloids of pyruvate kinase via pH-sensing regions

Amyloids are known as irreversible aggregates associated with neurodegenerative diseases. However, recent evidence shows that a subset of amyloids can form reversibly and fulfill essential cellular functions. Yet, the molecular mechanisms regulating functional amyloids and distinguishing them from pathological aggregates remain unclear. Here, we investigate the conserved principles of amyloid reversibility by studying the essential metabolic enzyme pyruvate kinase (PK) in yeast and human cells. We demonstrate that yeast PK (Cdc19) and human PK (PKM2) form reversible amyloids through a pH-sensitive amyloid core. Stress-induced cytosolic acidification promotes aggregation via protonation of specific glutamate (yeast) or histidine (human) residues within the amyloid core. Mutations mimicking protonation cause constitutive PK aggregation, while non-protonatable PK mutants remain soluble even upon stress. Physiological PK aggregation is coupled to metabolic rewiring and glycolysis arrest, causing severe growth defects when misregulated. Our work thus identifies an evolutionarily conserved, potentially widespread mechanism regulating functional amyloids during stress.

Amyloids, amorphous aggregates and assemblies of peptides - Assessing aggregation

Amyloid and amorphous aggregates represent the two major categories of aggregates associated with diseases, and although exhibiting distinct features, researchers often treat them as equivalent, which demonstrates the need for more thorough characterization. Here, we compare amyloid and amorphous aggregates based on their biochemical properties, kinetics, and morphological features. To further decipher this issue, we propose the use of peptide self-assemblies as minimalistic models for understanding the aggregation process. Peptide building blocks are significantly smaller than proteins that participate in aggregation, however, they make a plausible means to bridge the gap in discerning the aggregation process at the more complex, protein level. Additionally, we explore the potential use of peptide-inspired models to research the liquid-liquid phase separation as a feasible mechanism preceding amyloid formation. Connecting these concepts can help clarify our understanding of aggregation-related disorders and potentially provide novel drug targets to impede and reverse these serious illnesses.

Protein domains of low sequence complexity-dark matter of the proteome

This perspective begins with a speculative consideration of the properties of the earliest proteins to appear during evolution. What did these primitive proteins look like, and how were they of benefit to early forms of life? I proceed to hypothesize that primitive proteins have been preserved through evolution and now serve diverse functions important to the dynamics of cell morphology and biological regulation. The primitive nature of these modern proteins is easy to spot. They are composed of a limited subset of the 20 amino acids used by traditionally evolved proteins and thus are of low sequence complexity. This chemical simplicity limits protein domains of low sequence complexity to forming only a crude and labile type of protein structure currently hidden from the computational powers of machine learning. I conclude by hypothesizing that this structural weakness represents the underlying virtue of proteins that, at least for the moment, constitute the dark matter of the proteome.

Cryo-EM structures of the D290V mutant of the hnRNPA2 low-complexity domain suggests how D290V affects phase separation and aggregation

Heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein A2 (hnRNPA2) is a human ribonucleoprotein that transports RNA to designated locations for translation via its ability to phase separate. Its mutated form, D290V, is implicated in multisystem proteinopathy known to afflict two families, mainly with myopathy and Paget's disease of bone. Here, we investigate this mutant form of hnRNPA2 by determining cryo-EM structures of the recombinant D290V low complexity domain. We find that the mutant form of hnRNPA2 differs from the WT fibrils in four ways. In contrast to the WT fibrils, the PY-nuclear localization signals in the fibril cores of all three mutant polymorphs are less accessible to chaperones. Also, the mutant fibrils are more stable than WT fibrils as judged by phase separation, thermal stability, and energetic calculations. Similar to other pathogenic amyloids, the mutant fibrils are polymorphic. Thus, these structures offer evidence to explain how a D-to-V missense mutation diverts the assembly of reversible, functional amyloid-like fibrils into the assembly of pathogenic amyloid, and may shed light on analogous conversions occurring in other ribonucleoproteins that lead to neurological diseases such as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis and frontotemporal dementia.

[Biological phase separation in neuromuscular diseases]

Biological phase separation refers to the liquid-liquid phase separation of biomolecules such as proteins in cells. Phase separation is driven by low-complexity domains of phase-separating proteins and strictly controlled by regulatory factors. Phase separation has also been found to be disrupted by genetic abnormalities. Abnormal aggregates of causative proteins accumulate in many neuromuscular diseases. In recent years, it has become clear that phase separating proteins are associated with neuromuscular diseases, and that abnormalities in the regulation of phase separation leads to the formation of aggregates. Gains in our knowledge of biological phase separation is gradually elucidating the pathogenesis of neuromuscular diseases.

Oxidative regulation of TDP-43 self-association by a β-to-α conformational switch

An evolutionarily conserved region of the TDP-43 low-complexity domain (LCD) twenty residues in length can adopt either an α-helical or β-strand conformation. When in the latter conformation, TDP-43 self-associates via the formation of a labile, cross-β structure. Self-association can be monitored via the formation of phase-separated protein droplets. Exposure of droplets to hydrogen peroxide leads to oxidation of conserved methionine residues distributed throughout the LCD. Oxidation disassembles the cross-β structure, thus eliminating both self-association and phase separation. Here, we demonstrate that this process reciprocally enables formation of α-helical structure in precisely the same region formerly functioning to facilitate β-strand-mediated self-association. We further observe that the α-helical conformation allows interaction with a lipid-like detergent and that exposure to lipids enhances the β-to-α conformational switch. We hypothesize that regulation of this oxidative switch will prove to be important to the control of localized translation within vertebrate cells. The experimental observations reported herein were heavily reliant on studies of 1,6-hexanediol, a chemical agent that selectively dissolves labile structures formed via the self-association of protein domains of low sequence complexity. This aliphatic alcohol is shown to exert its dissociative activity primarily via hydrogen-bonding interactions with carbonyl oxygen atoms of the polypeptide backbone. Such observations underscore the central importance of backbone-mediated protein:protein interactions that facilitate the self-association and phase separation of LCDs.

Dissecting how ALS-associated D290V mutation enhances pathogenic aggregation of hnRNPA2286-291 peptides: Dynamics and conformational ensembles

The aggregation of RNA binding proteins, including hnRNPA1/2, TDP-43 and FUS, is heavily implicated in causing or increasing disease risk for a series of neurodegenerative diseases such as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). A recent experimental study demonstrated that an ALS-related D290V mutation in the low complexity domain (LCD) of hnRNPA2 can enhance the aggregation propensity of wild type (WT) hnRNPA2_286-291 peptide. However, the underlying molecular mechanisms remain elusive. Herein, we investigated effects of D290V mutation on aggregation dynamics of hnRNPA2_286-291 peptide and the conformational ensemble of hnRNPA2_286-291 oligomers by performing all-atom molecular dynamic and replica-exchange molecular dynamic simulations. Our simulations demonstrate that D290V mutation greatly reduces the dynamics of hnRNPA2_286-291 peptide and that D290V oligomers possess higher compactness and β-sheet content than WT, indicative of mutation-enhanced aggregation capability. Specifically, D290V mutation strengthens inter-peptide hydrophobic, main-chain hydrogen bonding and side-chain aromatic stacking interactions. Those interactions collectively lead to the enhancement of aggregation capability of hnRNPA2_286-291 peptides. Overall, our study provides insights into the dynamics and thermodynamic mechanisms underlying D290V-induced disease-causing aggregation of hnRNPA2_286-291, which could contribute to better understanding of the transitions from reversible condensates to irreversible pathogenic aggregates of hnRNPA2 LCD in ALS-related diseases.

Single-molecule techniques to visualize and to characterize liquid-liquid phase separation and phase transition

Biomolecules forming membraneless structures via liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) is a common event in living cells. Some liquid-like condensates can convert into solid-like aggregations, and such a phase transition process is related to some neurodegenerative diseases. Liquid-like condensates and solid-like aggregations usually exhibit distinctive fluidity and are commonly distinguished via their morphology and dynamic properties identified through ensemble methods. Emerging single-molecule techniques are a group of highly sensitive techniques, which can offer further mechanistic insights into LLPS and phase transition at the molecular level. Here, we summarize the working principles of several commonly used single-molecule techniques and demonstrate their unique power in manipulating LLPS, examining mechanical properties at the nanoscale, and monitoring dynamic and thermodynamic properties at the molecular level. Thus, single-molecule techniques are unique tools to characterize LLPS and liquid-to-solid phase transition under close-to-physiological conditions.

Liquid Droplet Aging and Seeded Fibril Formation of the Cytotoxic Granule Associated RNA Binding Protein TIA1 Low Complexity Domain

Protein domains biased toward a few amino acid types are vital for the formation of biomolecular condensates in living cells. These membraneless compartments are formed by molecules exhibiting a range of molecular motions and structural order. Missense mutations increase condensate persistence lifetimes or structural order, properties that are thought to underlie pathological protein aggregation. In the context of stress granules associated with neurodegenerative diseases, this process involves the rigidification of protein liquid droplets into β-strand rich protein fibrils. Here, we characterize the molecular mechanism underlying the rigidification of liquid droplets for the low complexity domain of the Cytotoxic granule associated RNA binding protein TIA1 (TIA1) stress granule protein and the influence of a disease mutation linked to neurodegenerative diseases. A seeding procedure and solid state nuclear magnetic resonance measurements show that the low complexity domain converges on a β-strand rich fibril conformation composed of 21% of the sequence. Additional solid state nuclear magnetic resonance measurements and difference spectroscopy show that aged liquid droplets of wild type and a proline-to-leucine mutant low complexity domain are composed of fibril assemblies that are conformationally heterogeneous and structurally distinct from the seeded fibril preparation. Regarding low complexity domains, our data support the functional template-driven formation of conformationally homogeneous structures, that rigidification of liquid droplets into conformationally heterogenous structures promotes pathological interactions, and that the effect of disease mutations is more nuanced than increasing thermodynamic stability or increasing β-strand structure content.

Protein interactions: anything new?

How do proteins interact in the cellular environment? Which interactions stabilize liquid-liquid phase separated condensates? Are the concepts, which have been developed for specific protein complexes also applicable to higher-order assemblies? Recent discoveries prompt for a universal framework for protein interactions, which can be applied across the scales of protein communities. Here, we discuss how our views on protein interactions have evolved from rigid structures to conformational ensembles of proteins and discuss the open problems, in particular related to biomolecular condensates. Protein interactions have evolved to follow changes in the cellular environment, which manifests in multiple modes of interactions between the same partners. Such cellular context-dependence requires multiplicity of binding modes (MBM) by sampling multiple minima of the interaction energy landscape. We demonstrate that the energy landscape framework of protein folding can be applied to explain this phenomenon, opening a perspective toward a physics-based, universal model for cellular protein behaviors.

Emerging Implications of Phase Separation in Cancer

In eukaryotic cells, biological activities are executed in distinct cellular compartments or organelles. Canonical organelles with membrane-bound structures are well understood. Cells also inherently contain versatile membrane-less organelles (MLOs) that feature liquid or gel-like bodies. A biophysical process termed liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) elucidates how MLOs form through dynamic biomolecule assembly. LLPS-related molecules often have multivalency, which is essential for low-affinity inter- or intra-molecule interactions to trigger phase separation. Accumulating evidence shows that LLPS concentrates and organizes desired molecules or segregates unneeded molecules in cells. Thus, MLOs have tunable functional specificity in response to environmental stimuli and metabolic processes. Aberrant LLPS is widely associated with several hallmarks of cancer, including sustained proliferative signaling, growth suppressor evasion, cell death resistance, telomere maintenance, DNA damage repair, etc. Insights into the molecular mechanisms of LLPS provide new insights into cancer therapeutics. Here, the current understanding of the emerging concepts of LLPS and its involvement in cancer are comprehensively reviewed.

Protein condensation diseases: therapeutic opportunities

Condensed states of proteins, including liquid-like membraneless organelles and solid-like aggregates, contribute in fundamental ways to the organisation and function of the cell. Perturbations of these states can lead to a variety of diseases through mechanisms that we are now beginning to understand. We define protein condensation diseases as conditions caused by the disruption of the normal behaviour of the condensed states of proteins. We analyze the problem of the identification of targets for pharmacological interventions for these diseases and explore opportunities for the regulation of the formation and organisation of aberrant condensed states of proteins.

In this review, the authors define protein condensation diseases as conditions caused by aberrant liquid-like or solid-like states of proteins, and describe opportunities for therapeutic interventions to restore the normal phase behaviour of proteins. The review accompanies the related collection of articles published in Nature Communications focusing on possible therapeutic approaches involving liquid-liquid phase separation.

ALS mutations in the TIA-1 prion-like domain trigger highly condensed pathogenic structures

T cell intracellular antigen-1 (TIA-1) plays a central role in stress granule (SG) formation by self-assembly via the prion-like domain (PLD). In the TIA-1 PLD, amino acid mutations associated with neurodegenerative diseases, such as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) or Welander distal myopathy (WDM), have been identified. However, how these mutations affect PLD self-assembly properties has remained elusive. In this study, we uncovered the implicit pathogenic structures caused by the mutations. NMR analysis indicated that the dynamic structures of the PLD are synergistically determined by the physicochemical properties of amino acids in units of five residues. Molecular dynamics simulations and three-dimensional electron crystallography, together with biochemical assays, revealed that the WDM mutation E384K attenuated the sticky properties, whereas the ALS mutations P362L and A381T enhanced the self-assembly by inducing β-sheet interactions and highly condensed assembly, respectively. These results suggest that the P362L and A381T mutations increase the likelihood of irreversible amyloid fibrillization after phase-separated droplet formation, and this process may lead to pathogenicity.

Mutations linked to neurological disease enhance self-association of low-complexity protein sequences

Protein domains of low sequence complexity do not fold into stable, three-dimensional structures. Nevertheless, proteins with these sequences assist in many aspects of cell organization, including assembly of nuclear and cytoplasmic structures not surrounded by membranes. The dynamic nature of these cellular assemblies is caused by the ability of low-complexity domains (LCDs) to transiently self-associate through labile, cross-β structures. Mechanistic studies useful for the study of LCD self-association have evolved over the past decade in the form of simple assays of phase separation. Here, we have used such assays to demonstrate that the interactions responsible for LCD self-association can be dictated by labile protein structures poised close to equilibrium between the folded and unfolded states. Furthermore, missense mutations causing Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease, frontotemporal dementia, and Alzheimer's disease manifest their pathophysiology in vitro and in cultured cell systems by enhancing the stability of otherwise labile molecular structures formed upon LCD self-association.

Bioinformatic identification of previously unrecognized amyloidogenic proteins

Low-complexity domains (LCDs) of proteins have been shown to self-associate, and pathogenic mutations within these domains often drive the proteins into amyloid aggregation associated with disease. These domains may be especially susceptible to amyloidogenic mutations because they are commonly intrinsically disordered and function in self-association. The question therefore arises whether a search for pathogenic mutations in LCDs of the human proteome can lead to identification of other proteins associated with amyloid disease. Here, we take a computational approach to identify documented pathogenic mutations within LCDs that may favor amyloid formation. Using this approach, we identify numerous known amyloidogenic mutations, including several such mutations within proteins previously unidentified as amyloidogenic. Among the latter group, we focus on two mutations within the TRK-fused gene protein (TFG), known to play roles in protein secretion and innate immunity, which are associated with two different peripheral neuropathies. We show that both mutations increase the propensity of TFG to form amyloid fibrils. We therefore conclude that TFG is a novel amyloid protein and propose that the diseases associated with its mutant forms may be amyloidoses.

Solid-State NMR: Methods for Biological Solids

In the last two decades, solid-state nuclear magnetic resonance (ssNMR) spectroscopy has transformed from a spectroscopic technique investigating small molecules and industrial polymers to a potent tool decrypting structure and underlying dynamics of complex biological systems, such as membrane proteins, fibrils, and assemblies, in near-physiological environments and temperatures. This transformation can be ascribed to improvements in hardware design, sample preparation, pulsed methods, isotope labeling strategies, resolution, and sensitivity. The fundamental engagement between nuclear spins and radio-frequency pulses in the presence of a strong static magnetic field is identical between solution and ssNMR, but the experimental procedures vastly differ because of the absence of molecular tumbling in solids. This review discusses routinely employed state-of-the-art static and MAS pulsed NMR methods relevant for biological samples with rotational correlation times exceeding 100's of nanoseconds. Recent developments in signal filtering approaches, proton methodologies, and multiple acquisition techniques to boost sensitivity and speed up data acquisition at fast MAS are also discussed. Several examples of protein structures (globular, membrane, fibrils, and assemblies) solved with ssNMR spectroscopy have been considered. We also discuss integrated approaches to structurally characterize challenging biological systems and some newly emanating subdisciplines in ssNMR spectroscopy.

Identifying amyloid-related diseases by mapping mutations in low-complexity protein domains to pathologies

Proteins including FUS, hnRNPA2, and TDP-43 reversibly aggregate into amyloid-like fibrils through interactions of their low-complexity domains (LCDs). Mutations in LCDs can promote irreversible amyloid aggregation and disease. We introduce a computational approach to identify mutations in LCDs of disease-associated proteins predicted to increase propensity for amyloid aggregation. We identify several disease-related mutations in the intermediate filament protein keratin-8 (KRT8). Atomic structures of wild-type and mutant KRT8 segments confirm the transition to a pleated strand capable of amyloid formation. Biochemical analysis reveals KRT8 forms amyloid aggregates, and the identified mutations promote aggregation. Aggregated KRT8 is found in Mallory-Denk bodies, observed in hepatocytes of livers with alcoholic steatohepatitis (ASH). We demonstrate that ethanol promotes KRT8 aggregation, and KRT8 amyloids co-crystallize with alcohol. Lastly, KRT8 aggregation can be seeded by liver extract from people with ASH, consistent with the amyloid nature of KRT8 aggregates and the classification of ASH as an amyloid-related condition.

How do protein domains of low sequence complexity work?

This review covers research findings reported over the past decade concerning the ability of low complexity (LC) domains to self-associate in a manner leading to their phase separation from aqueous solution. We focus our message upon the reductionist use of two forms of phase separation as biochemical assays to study how LC domains might function in living cells. Cells and their varied compartments represent extreme examples of material condensates. Over the past half century, biochemists, structural biologists, and molecular biologists have resolved the mechanisms driving innumerable forms of macromolecular condensation. In contrast, we remain largely ignorant as to how 10%-20% of our proteins actually work to assist in cell organization. This enigmatic 10%-20% of the proteome corresponds to gibberish-like LC sequences. We contend that many of these LC sequences move in and out of a structurally ordered, self-associated state as a means of offering a combination of organizational specificity and dynamic pliability to living cells. Finally, we speculate that ancient proteins may have behaved similarly, helping to condense, organize, and protect RNA early during evolution.

The low-complexity domain of the FUS RNA binding protein self-assembles via the mutually exclusive use of two distinct cross-β cores

Single amino acid changes causative of neurologic disease often map to the cross-β forming regions of low-complexity (LC) domains. All such mutations studied to date lead to enhanced avidity of cross-β interactions. The LC domain of the fused in sarcoma (FUS) RNA binding protein contains three different regions that are capable of forming labile cross-β interactions. Here we describe the perplexing effect of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS)-causing mutations localized to the LC domain of FUS to substantially weaken its ability to form one of its three cross-β interactions. An understanding of how these mutations abet uncontrolled polymerization of the FUS LC domain may represent an important clue as to how LC domains achieve their proper biological function.

The low-complexity (LC) domain of the fused in sarcoma (FUS) RNA binding protein self-associates in a manner causing phase separation from an aqueous environment. Incubation of the FUS LC domain under physiologically normal conditions of salt and pH leads to rapid formation of liquid-like droplets that mature into a gel-like state. Both examples of phase separation have enabled reductionist biochemical assays allowing discovery of an N-terminal region of 57 residues that assembles into a labile, cross-β structure. Here we provide evidence of a nonoverlapping, C-terminal region of the FUS LC domain that also forms specific cross-β interactions. We propose that biologic function of the FUS LC domain may operate via the mutually exclusive use of these N- and C-terminal cross-β cores. Neurodegenerative disease–causing mutations in the FUS LC domain are shown to imbalance the two cross-β cores, offering an unanticipated concept of LC domain function and dysfunction.

Sequence Determinants of the Aggregation of Proteins Within Condensates Generated by Liquid-liquid Phase Separation

The transition between the native and amyloid states of proteins can proceed via a deposition pathway via oligomeric intermediates or via a condensation pathway involving liquid droplet intermediates generated through liquid-liquid phase separation. While several computational methods are available to perform sequence-based predictions of the propensity of proteins to aggregate via the deposition pathway, much less is known about the physico-chemical principles that underlie aggregation within condensates. Here we investigate the sequence determinants of aggregation via the condensation pathway, and identify three relevant features: droplet-promoting propensity, aggregation-promoting propensity and multimodal interactions quantified by the binding mode entropy. By using this approach, we show that it is possible to predict aggregation-promoting mutations in droplet-forming proteins associated with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS). This analysis provides insights into the amino acid code for the conversion of proteins between liquid-like and solid-like condensates.

Transiently structured head domains control intermediate filament assembly

Assembly of intermediate filaments (IFs) is reliant upon amino-terminal head domains. These head domains are of low sequence complexity and are assumed to function in the absence of structural order. Herein, we provide evidence that the head domains of the desmin and neurofilament light (NFL) IF proteins self-associate via the formation of labile but structurally specific cross-β interaction. Disease-causing mutations in the head domains of both proteins cause enhanced cross-β interactions. By assembling desmin and NFL IFs bearing isotopically labeled head domains, we provide evidence of structural order in properly assembled biological filaments. We propose that these observations on IF head domains may be instructive to the function of low complexity domains operative in other aspects of cell biology.

Low complexity (LC) head domains 92 and 108 residues in length are, respectively, required for assembly of neurofilament light (NFL) and desmin intermediate filaments (IFs). As studied in isolation, these IF head domains interconvert between states of conformational disorder and labile, β-strand–enriched polymers. Solid-state NMR (ss-NMR) spectroscopic studies of NFL and desmin head domain polymers reveal spectral patterns consistent with structural order. A combination of intein chemistry and segmental isotope labeling allowed preparation of fully assembled NFL and desmin IFs that could also be studied by ss-NMR. Assembled IFs revealed spectra overlapping with those observed for β-strand–enriched polymers formed from the isolated NFL and desmin head domains. Phosphorylation and disease-causing mutations reciprocally alter NFL and desmin head domain self-association yet commonly impede IF assembly. These observations show how facultative structural assembly of LC domains via labile, β-strand–enriched self-interactions may broadly influence cell morphology.

O-Linked-N-Acetylglucosaminylation of the RNA-Binding Protein EWS N-Terminal Low Complexity Region Reduces Phase Separation and Enhances Condensate Dynamics

Many membraneless organelles are thought to be biomolecular condensates formed by phase separation of proteins and other biopolymers. Post-translational modifications (PTMs) can impact protein phase separation behavior, although for many PTMs this aspect of their function is unknown. O-linked β-D-N-acetylglucosaminylation (O-GlcNAcylation) is an abundant form of intracellular glycosylation whose roles in regulating biomolecular condensate assembly and dynamics have not been delineated. Using an in vitro approach, we found that O-GlcNAcylation reduces the phase separation propensity of the EWS N-terminal low complexity region (LCR_N) under different conditions, including in the presence of the arginine- and glycine-rich RNA-binding domains (RBD). O-GlcNAcylation enhances fluorescence recovery after photobleaching (FRAP) within EWS LCR_N condensates and causes the droplets to exhibit more liquid-like relaxation following fusion. Following extended incubation times, EWS LCR_N+RBD condensates exhibit diminished FRAP, indicating a loss of fluidity, while condensates containing the O-GlcNAcylated LCR_N do not. In HeLa cells, EWS is less O-GlcNAcylated following OGT knockdown, which correlates with its increased accumulation in a filter retardation assay. Relative to the human proteome, O-GlcNAcylated proteins are enriched with regions that are predicted to phase separate, suggesting a general role of O-GlcNAcylation in regulation of biomolecular condensates.

A Time-Resolved Diffusion Technique for Detection of the Conformational Changes and Molecular Assembly/Disassembly Processes of Biomolecules

Biological liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) is driven by dynamic and multivalent interactions, which involves conformational changes and intermolecular assembly/disassembly processes of various biomolecules. To understand the molecular mechanisms of LLPS, kinetic measurements of the intra- and intermolecular reactions are essential. In this review, a time-resolved diffusion technique which has a potential to detect molecular events associated with LLPS is presented. This technique can detect changes in protein conformation and intermolecular interaction (oligomer formation, protein-DNA interaction, and protein-lipid interaction) in time domain, which are difficult to obtain by other methods. After the principle and methods for signal analyses are described in detail, studies on photoreactive molecules (intermolecular interaction between light sensor proteins and its target DNA) and a non-photoreactive molecule (binding and folding reaction of α-synuclein upon mixing with SDS micelle) are presented as typical examples of applications of this unique technique.

Molecular structure of a prevalent amyloid-β fibril polymorph from Alzheimer's disease brain tissue

Amyloid-β (Aβ) fibrils exhibit self-propagating, molecular-level polymorphisms that may contribute to variations in clinical and pathological characteristics of Alzheimer's disease (AD). We report the molecular structure of a specific fibril polymorph, formed by 40-residue Aβ peptides (Aβ40), that is derived from cortical tissue of an AD patient by seeded fibril growth. The structure is determined from cryogenic electron microscopy (cryoEM) images, supplemented by mass-per-length (MPL) measurements and solid-state NMR (ssNMR) data. Previous ssNMR studies with multiple AD patients had identified this polymorph as the most prevalent brain-derived Aβ40 fibril polymorph from typical AD patients. The structure, which has 2.8-Å resolution according to standard criteria, differs qualitatively from all previously described Aβ fibril structures, both in its molecular conformations and its organization of cross-β subunits. Unique features include twofold screw symmetry about the fibril growth axis, despite an MPL value that indicates three Aβ40 molecules per 4.8-Å β-sheet spacing, a four-layered architecture, and fully extended conformations for molecules in the central two cross-β layers. The cryoEM density, ssNMR data, and MPL data are consistent with β-hairpin conformations for molecules in the outer cross-β layers. Knowledge of this brain-derived fibril structure may contribute to the development of structure-specific amyloid imaging agents and aggregation inhibitors with greater diagnostic and therapeutic utility.

Identification of the Rigid Core for Aged Liquid Droplets of an RNA-Binding Protein Low Complexity Domain

The biomolecular condensation of proteins with low complexity sequences plays a functional role in RNA metabolism and a pathogenic role in neurodegenerative diseases. The formation of dynamic liquid droplets brings biomolecules together to achieve complex cellular functions. The rigidification of liquid droplets into β-strand-rich hydrogel structures composed of protein fibrils is thought to be purely pathological in nature. However, low complexity sequences often harbor multiple fibril-prone regions with delicately balanced functional and pathological interactions. Here, we investigate the maturation of liquid droplets formed by the low complexity domain of the TAR DNA-binding protein 43 (TDP-43). Solid state nuclear magnetic resonance measurements on the aged liquid droplets identify residues 365-400 as the structured core, which are squarely outside the region between residues 311-360 thought to be most important for pathological fibril formation and aggregation. The results of this study suggest that multiple segments of this low complexity domain are prone to form fibrils and that stabilization of β-strand-rich structure in one segment precludes the other region from adopting a rigid fibril structure.

Current Understanding of the Structure, Stability and Dynamic Properties of Amyloid Fibrils

Amyloid fibrils are supramolecular protein assemblies represented by a cross-β structure and fibrous morphology, whose structural architecture has been previously investigated. While amyloid fibrils are basically a main-chain-dominated structure consisting of a backbone of hydrogen bonds, side-chain interactions also play an important role in determining their detailed structures and physicochemical properties. In amyloid fibrils comprising short peptide segments, a steric zipper where a pair of β-sheets with side chains interdigitate tightly is found as a fundamental motif. In amyloid fibrils comprising longer polypeptides, each polypeptide chain folds into a planar structure composed of several β-strands linked by turns or loops, and the steric zippers are formed locally to stabilize the structure. Multiple segments capable of forming steric zippers are contained within a single protein molecule in many cases, and polymorphism appears as a result of the diverse regions and counterparts of the steric zippers. Furthermore, the β-solenoid structure, where the polypeptide chain folds in a solenoid shape with side chains packed inside, is recognized as another important amyloid motif. While side-chain interactions are primarily achieved by non-polar residues in disease-related amyloid fibrils, the participation of hydrophilic and charged residues is prominent in functional amyloids, which often leads to spatiotemporally controlled fibrillation, high reversibility, and the formation of labile amyloids with kinked backbone topology. Achieving precise control of the side-chain interactions within amyloid structures will open up a new horizon for designing useful amyloid-based nanomaterials.

The nuclear localization sequence mediates hnRNPA1 amyloid fibril formation revealed by cryoEM structure

Human heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein A1 (hnRNPA1) serves as a key regulating protein in RNA metabolism. Malfunction of hnRNPA1 in nucleo-cytoplasmic transport or dynamic phase separation leads to abnormal amyloid aggregation and neurodegeneration. The low complexity (LC) domain of hnRNPA1 drives both dynamic phase separation and amyloid aggregation. Here, we use cryo-electron microscopy to determine the amyloid fibril structure formed by hnRNPA1 LC domain. Remarkably, the structure reveals that the nuclear localization sequence of hnRNPA1 (termed PY-NLS), which is initially known to mediate the nucleo-cytoplamic transport of hnRNPA1 through binding with karyopherin-β2 (Kapβ2), represents the major component of the fibril core. The residues that contribute to the binding of PY-NLS with Kapβ2 also exert key molecular interactions to stabilize the fibril structure. Notably, hnRNPA1 mutations found in familial amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) and multisystem proteinopathoy (MSP) are all involved in the fibril core and contribute to fibril stability. Our work illuminates structural understandings of the pathological amyloid aggregation of hnRNPA1 and the amyloid disaggregase activity of Kapβ2, and highlights the multiple roles of PY-NLS in hnRNPA1 homeostasis.

Heterogeneous nuclear ribonucleoprotein A1 (hnRNPA1) shuttles between the nucleus and cytoplasm to regulate gene expression and RNA metabolism and its low complexity (LC) C-terminal domain facilitates liquid–liquid phase separation and amyloid aggregation. Here, the authors present the cryo-EM structure of amyloid fibrils formed by the hnRNPA1 LC domain, which reveals that the hnRNPA1 nuclear localization sequence forms the fibril core, and they discuss how ALS-causing mutations affect fibril stability.

Dynamic structural order of a low-complexity domain facilitates assembly of intermediate filaments

The main point of our manuscript is focused on the structure of the low-complexity (LC) domain of the Tm1-I/C intermediate filament protein in the context of assembled intermediate filaments. We found that the LC tail domain of Tm1-I/C exists in precisely the same cross-β conformation within its proper biologic assembly as it does in labile, amyloid-like polymers made from the tail domain alone. This science represents a conceptually distinct advance that may form the cornerstone understanding of how the thousands of LC domains expressed in eukaryotic cells operate in a mechanistic sense, and stands in conflict with previous research claiming that LC domains function in the absence of molecular structure.

The coiled-coil domains of intermediate filament (IF) proteins are flanked by regions of low sequence complexity. Whereas IF coiled-coil domains assume dimeric and tetrameric conformations on their own, maturation of eight tetramers into cylindrical IFs is dependent on either “head” or “tail” domains of low sequence complexity. Here we confirm that the tail domain required for assembly of Drosophila Tm1-I/C IFs functions by forming labile cross-β interactions. These interactions are seen in polymers made from the tail domain alone, as well as in assembled IFs formed by the intact Tm1-I/C protein. The ability to visualize such interactions in situ within the context of a discrete cellular assembly lends support to the concept that equivalent interactions may be used in organizing other dynamic aspects of cell morphology.

CryoEM structure of the low-complexity domain of hnRNPA2 and its conversion to pathogenic amyloid

hnRNPA2 is a human ribonucleoprotein (RNP) involved in RNA metabolism. It forms fibrils both under cellular stress and in mutated form in neurodegenerative conditions. Previous work established that the C-terminal low-complexity domain (LCD) of hnRNPA2 fibrillizes under stress, and missense mutations in this domain are found in the disease multisystem proteinopathy (MSP). However, little is known at the atomic level about the hnRNPA2 LCD structure that is involved in those processes and how disease mutations cause structural change. Here we present the cryo-electron microscopy (cryoEM) structure of the hnRNPA2 LCD fibril core and demonstrate its capability to form a reversible hydrogel in vitro containing amyloid-like fibrils. Whereas these fibrils, like pathogenic amyloid, are formed from protein chains stacked into β-sheets by backbone hydrogen bonds, they display distinct structural differences: the chains are kinked, enabling non-covalent cross-linking of fibrils and disfavoring formation of pathogenic steric zippers. Both reversibility and energetic calculations suggest these fibrils are less stable than pathogenic amyloid. Moreover, the crystal structure of the disease-mutation-containing segment (D290V) of hnRNPA2 suggests that the replacement fundamentally alters the fibril structure to a more stable energetic state. These findings illuminate how molecular interactions promote protein fibril networks and how mutation can transform fibril structure from functional to a pathogenic form.

Karyopherins and condensates

Several aggregation-prone RNA-binding proteins, including FUS, EWS, TAF15, hnRNP A1, hnRNP A2, and TDP-43, are mutated in neurodegenerative diseases. The nuclear-cytoplasmic distribution of these proteins is controlled by proteins in the karyopherin family of nuclear transport factors (Kaps). Recent studies have shown that Kaps not only transport these proteins but also inhibit their self-association/aggregation, acting as molecular chaperones. This chaperone activity is impaired for disease-causing mutants of the RNA-binding proteins. Here, we review physical data on the mechanisms of self-association of several disease-associated RNA-binding proteins, through liquid-liquid phase separation and amyloid fiber formation. In each case, we relate these data to biophysical, biochemical, and cell biological data on the inhibition of self-association by Kaps. Our analyses suggest that Kaps may be effective chaperones because they contain large surfaces with diverse physical properties that enable them to engage multiple different regions of their cargo proteins, blocking self-association.

Liquid-Liquid Phase Separation and Its Mechanistic Role in Pathological Protein Aggregation

Liquid-liquid phase separation (LLPS) of proteins underlies the formation of membrane-less organelles. While it has been recognized for some time that these organelles are of key importance for normal cellular functions, a growing number of recent observations indicate that LLPS may also play a role in disease. In particular, numerous proteins that form toxic aggregates in neurodegenerative diseases, such as amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, frontotemporal lobar degeneration, and Alzheimer's disease, were found to be highly prone to phase separation, suggesting that there might be a strong link between LLPS and the pathogenic process in these disorders. This review aims to assess the molecular basis of this link through exploration of the intermolecular interactions that underlie LLPS and aggregation and the underlying mechanisms facilitating maturation of liquid droplets into more stable assemblies, including so-called labile fibrils, hydrogels, and pathological amyloids. Recent insights into the structural basis of labile fibrils and potential mechanisms by which these relatively unstable structures could transition into more stable pathogenic amyloids are also discussed. Finally, this review explores how the environment of liquid droplets could modulate protein aggregation by altering kinetics of protein self-association, affecting folding of protein monomers, or changing aggregation pathways.

Structural Diversity of Amyloid Fibrils and Advances in Their Structure Determination

Protein amyloid fibrils are originally identified as pathological entities in a variety of neurodegenerative diseases such as Alzheimer's disease and Parkinson's disease. Recent studies have revealed that amyloid fibrils also serve as functional protein assemblies to fulfill a wide range of biological functions. Deciphering the molecular basis underlying the assembly of amyloid fibrils is essential for understanding their biological and pathological functions. Here, we summarize recent advances in the atomic structure determination of amyloid fibrils formed by both amyloidogenic peptides and full-length proteins. Furthermore, we demonstrate the diversity of amyloid fibrils, with a primary focus on the reversible fibrils, in sequence composition, self-assembled architecture, and physiochemical and pathological properties. Finally, we raise questions that will be answered by the future study of amyloid fibril structure.

hnRNPDL Phase Separation Is Regulated by Alternative Splicing and Disease-Causing Mutations Accelerate Its Aggregation

Prion-like proteins form multivalent assemblies and phase separate into membraneless organelles. Heterogeneous ribonucleoprotein D-like (hnRNPDL) is a RNA-processing prion-like protein with three alternative splicing (AS) isoforms, which lack none, one, or both of its two disordered domains. It has been suggested that AS might regulate the assembly properties of RNA-processing proteins by controlling the incorporation of multivalent disordered regions in the isoforms. This, in turn, would modulate their activity in the downstream splicing program. Here, we demonstrate that AS controls the phase separation of hnRNPDL, as well as the size and dynamics of its nuclear complexes, its nucleus-cytoplasm shuttling, and amyloidogenicity. Mutation of the highly conserved D378 in the disordered C-terminal prion-like domain of hnRNPDL causes limb-girdle muscular dystrophy 1G. We show that D378H/N disease mutations impact hnRNPDL assembly properties, accelerating aggregation and dramatically reducing the protein solubility in the muscle of Drosophila, suggesting a genetic loss-of-function mechanism for this muscular disorder.

Side Chain Hydrogen-Bonding Interactions within Amyloid-like Fibrils Formed by the Low-Complexity Domain of FUS: Evidence from Solid State Nuclear Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopy

In aqueous solutions, the 214-residue low-complexity domain of the FUS protein (FUS-LC) is known to undergo liquid-liquid phase separation and also to self-assemble into amyloid-like fibrils. In previous work based on solid state nuclear magnetic resonance (ssNMR) methods, a structural model for the FUS-LC fibril core was developed, showing that residues 39-95 form the fibril core. Unlike fibrils formed by amyloid-β peptides, α-synuclein, and other amyloid-forming proteins, the FUS-LC core is largely devoid of purely hydrophobic amino acid side chains. Instead, the core-forming segment contains numerous hydroxyl-bearing residues, including 18 serines, six threonines, and eight tyrosines, suggesting that the FUS-LC fibril structure may be stabilized in part by inter-residue hydrogen bonds among side chain hydroxyl groups. Here we describe ssNMR measurements, performed on ²H,¹⁵N,¹³C-labeled FUS-LC fibrils, that provide new information about the interactions of hydroxyl-bearing residues with one another and with water. The ssNMR data support the involvement of specific serine, threonine, and tyrosine residues in hydrogen-bonding interactions. The data also reveal differences in hydrogen exchange rates with water for different side chain hydroxyl groups, providing information about solvent exposure and penetration of water into the FUS-LC fibril core.

Molecular structure in biomolecular condensates

Evidence accumulated over the past decade provides support for liquid-liquid phase separation as the mechanism underlying the formation of biomolecular condensates, which include not only 'membraneless' organelles such as nucleoli and RNA granules, but additional assemblies involved in transcription, translation and signaling. Understanding the molecular mechanisms of condensate function requires knowledge of the structures of their constituents. Current knowledge suggests that structures formed via multivalent domain-motif interactions remain largely unchanged within condensates. Two different viewpoints exist regarding structures of disordered low-complexity domains within condensates; one argues that low-complexity domains remain largely disordered in condensates and their multivalency is encoded in short motifs called 'stickers', while the other argues that the sequences form cross-β structures resembling amyloid fibrils. We review these viewpoints and highlight outstanding questions that will inform structure-function relationships for biomolecular condensates.

Structural basis for reversible amyloids of hnRNPA1 elucidates their role in stress granule assembly

Subcellular membrane-less organelles consist of proteins with low complexity domains. Many of them, such as hnRNPA1, can assemble into both a polydisperse liquid phase and an ordered solid phase of amyloid fibril. The former mirrors biological granule assembly, while the latter is usually associated with neurodegenerative disease. Here, we observe a reversible amyloid formation of hnRNPA1 that synchronizes with liquid–liquid phase separation, regulates the fluidity and mobility of the liquid-like droplets, and facilitates the recruitment of hnRNPA1 into stress granules. We identify the reversible amyloid-forming cores of hnRNPA1 (named hnRACs). The atomic structures of hnRACs reveal a distinct feature of stacking Asp residues, which contributes to fibril reversibility and explains the irreversible pathological fibril formation caused by the Asp mutations identified in familial ALS. Our work characterizes the structural diversity and heterogeneity of reversible amyloid fibrils and illuminates the biological function of reversible amyloid formation in protein phase separation.

Low complexity (LC) domains can drive the formation of both amyloid fibrils and protein droplets. Here, the authors identify reversible amyloid cores from the LC of hnRNPA1, based on which they elucidate the structural basis of reversible fibrillation and its interplay with hnRNPA1 droplet formation.

Therapeutic Dissolution of Aberrant Phases by Nuclear-Import Receptors

Nuclear-import receptors (NIRs) bind nuclear-localization signals (NLSs) of protein cargo in the cytoplasm and transport them into the nucleus. Here, we review advances establishing that NIRs also function in the cytoplasm to prevent and reverse functional and aberrant phase transitions of their cargo, including neurodegenerative disease-linked RNA-binding proteins (RBPs) with prion-like domains, such as TDP-43, FUS, hnRNPA1, and hnRNPA2. NIRs selectively extract cargo from condensed liquid phases thereby regulating functional phase separation. Consequently, NIRs sculpt cytoplasmic membraneless organelles and regulate cellular organization beyond their canonical role in nuclear import. Elevating NIR expression dissolves cytoplasmic RBP aggregates, restores functional RBPs to the nucleus, and rescues disease-linked RBP toxicity. Thus, NIRs could be leveraged therapeutically to restore RBP homeostasis and mitigate neurodegeneration.