Microbiologique Microfilm™ EBEc - a Rapid Method for the Simultaneous Enumeration of Enterobacteriaceae and Escherichia coli

BACKGROUND

The Enterobacteriaceae and generic Escherichia coli are routinely enumerated in foods as part of product release criteria, or in the case of swabs, for environmental monitoring.

OBJECTIVE

Microbiologique Microfilm™ EBEc is intended to provide a rapid and easy-to-use method for simultaneous enumeration of Enterobacteriaceae and E. coli on foods and environmental surfaces. Methods: This study evaluated the performance of Microfilm™ EBEc against ISO methods (ISO 21528-2:2017 for Enterobacteriaceae and ISO 16649-2: 2001 for E. coli) in 20 food matrixes and two environmental surfaces. Inclusivity, exclusivity, lot-to-lot reproducibility, ruggedness and stability studies were also performed on Microfilm™ EBEc.

RESULTS

No significant differences and high correlation coefficients (R2) were observed between the Microfilm™ EBEc and the corresponding ISO methods in spiked food matrixes and environmental samples. Inclusivity studies showed expected results for all the E. coli and Enterobacteriaceae strains tested. In terms of exclusivity testing, all the strains tested failed to grow on Microfilm™ EBEc. A lot-to-lot study showed no significant differences in mean difference (log10) counts among the three lots of the Microfilm™ EBEc. Ruggedness studies showed no significant differences in mean difference (log10) counts at varying incubation temperatures and times. Stability studies on the Microfilm™ EBEc showed that it is stable at 2-25°C for 12 months, and at 45°C for 6 weeks.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of this study indicate that the Microfilm™ EBEc is equivalent to the corresponding ISO methods for enumeration of Enterobacteriaceae and E. coli. Highlights: Microfilm™ EBEc offers a convenient and relatively fast test method for simultaneous enumeration of Enterobacteriaceae and E. coli in 24 h and has an advantage over the corresponding ISO methods that require two assays on the same sample for enumeration of Enterobacteriaceae and E. coli Gram-negative indicator groups.

Comparison of the quantitative dry culture methods with both conventional media and most probable number method for the enumeration of coliforms and Escherichia coli/coliforms in food

Sanita-kun™ CC (coliform count) and EC (Escherichia coli/coliform count), sheet quantitative culture systems which can avoid chromogenic interference by lactase in food, were evaluated in comparison with conventional methods for these bacteria. Based on the results of inclusivity and exclusivity studies using 77 micro-organisms, sensitivity and specificity of both Sanita-kun™ met the criteria for ISO 16140. Both media were compared with deoxycholate agar, violet red bile agar, Merck Chromocult™ coliform agar (CCA), 3M Petrifilm™ CC and EC (PEC) and 3-tube MPN, as reference methods, in 100 naturally contaminated food samples. The correlation coefficients of both Sanita-kun™ for coliform detection were more than 0·95 for all comparisons. For E. coli detection, Sanita-kun™ EC was compared with CCA, PEC and MPN in 100 artificially contaminated food samples. The correlation coefficients for E. coli detection of Sanita-kun™ EC were more than 0·95 for all comparisons. There were no significant differences in all comparisons when conducting a one-way analysis of variance (anova). Both Sanita-kun™ significantly inhibited colour interference by lactase when inhibition of enzymatic staining was assessed using 40 natural cheese samples spiked with coliform. Our results demonstrated Sanita-kun™ CC and EC are suitable alternatives for the enumeration of coliforms and E. coli/coliforms, respectively, in a variety of foods, and specifically in fermented foods.

SIGNIFICANCE AND IMPACT OF THE STUDY

Current chromogenic media for coliforms and Escherichia coli/coliforms have enzymatic coloration due to breaking down of chromogenic substrates by food lactase. The novel sheet culture media which have film layer to avoid coloration by food lactase have been developed for enumeration of coliforms and E. coli/coliforms respectively. In this study, we demonstrated these media had comparable performance with reference methods and less interference by food lactase. These media have a possibility not only to be useful alternatives but also to contribute for accurate enumeration of these bacteria in a variety of foods, and specifically in fermented foods.

Evaluation of the petrifilm plate method for the enumeration of aerobic microorganisms and coliforms in retailed meat samples

This study was designed to compare the effectiveness and applicability of the Petrifilm plate method with the Association of Official Analytical Chemists' (AOAC) standard aerobic count method and violet red bile agar method for meat products. The comparison was carried out using 303 meat samples collected from various retailers: 110 pork samples, 87 chicken samples, and 107 beef samples. In the comparison of the correlation coefficient (R) between the conventional method and the Petrifilm plate method by a linear regression analysis, the correlation coefficient in total microorganisms was 0.99, 0.95, and 0.94 in pork, beef, and chicken samples, respectively. The correlation coefficient in coliform count was 0.83, 0.96, and 0.81 in pork, beef, and chicken samples, respectively. Based on the high correlation in the total microorganism count, it might be possible to replace the conventional methods with the Petrifilm plate method. For coliform counts, the Petrifilm plate method also showed a generally high correlation coefficient, except for pork samples, which are more subject to contamination. The Petrifilm plate method was simpler and less time-consuming in sample preparation and, in procedures, faster than the conventional method. These results suggested that the 3M Petrifilm plate method could replace the conventional methods in the analysis of microorganism contamination measurement in meat products.