Comparison of ligand-induced conformational changes and domain closure mechanisms, between prokaryotic and eukaryotic dehydroquinate synthases

Dehydroquinate synthase (DHQS) is a potential target for the development of novel broad-spectrum antimicrobial drugs, active against both prokaryotes and lower eukaryotes. Structures have been reported for Aspergillus nidulans DHQS (AnDHQS) in complexes with a range of ligands. Analysis of these AnDHQS structures showed that a large-scale domain movement occurs during the normal catalytic cycle, with a complex series of structural elements propagating substrate binding-induced conformational changes away from the active site to distal locations. Compared to corresponding fungal enzymes, DHQS from bacterial species are both mono-functional and significantly smaller. We have therefore determined the structure of Staphylococcus aureus DHQS (SaDHQS) in five liganded states, allowing comparison of ligand-induced conformational changes and mechanisms of domain closure between fungal and bacterial enzymes. This comparative analysis shows that substrate binding initiates a large-scale domain closure in both species' DHQS and that the active site stereochemistry, of the catalytically competent closed-form enzyme thus produced, is also highly conserved. However, comparison of AnDHQS and SaDHQS open-form structures, and analysis of the putative dynamic processes by which the transition to the closed-form states are made, shows a far lower degree of similarity, indicating a significant structural divergence. As a result, both the nature of the propagation of conformational change and the mechanical systems involved in this propagation are quite different between the DHQSs from the two species.

High-resolution structures reveal details of domain closure and "half-of-sites-reactivity" in Escherichia coli aspartate beta-semialdehyde dehydrogenase

Two high-resolution structures have been determined for Eschericia coli aspartate beta-semialdehyde dehydrogenase (ecASADH), an enzyme of the aspartate biosynthetic pathway, which is a potential target for novel antimicrobial drugs. Both ASADH structures were of the open form and were refined to 1.95 A and 1.6 A resolution, allowing a more detailed comparison with the closed form of the enzyme than previously possible. A more complex scheme for domain closure is apparent with the subunit being split into two further sub-domains with relative motions about three hinge axes. Analysis of hinge data and torsion-angle difference plots is combined to allow the proposal of a detailed structural mechanism for ecASADH domain closure. Additionally, asymmetric distortions of individual subunits are identified, which form the basis for the previously reported "half-of-the-sites reactivity" (HOSR). A putative explanation of this arrangement is also presented, suggesting the HOSR system may provide a means for ecASADH to offset the energy required to remobilise flexible loops at the end of the reaction cycle, and hence avoid falling into an energy minimum.

Structure of the `open' form ofAspergillus nidulans3-dehydroquinate synthase at 1.7 Å resolution from crystals grown following enzyme turnover

Crystallization of Aspergillus nidulans 3-dehydroquinate synthase (DHQS), following turnover of the enzyme by addition of the substrate DAHP, gave a new crystal form (form J). Although the crystals have dimensions of only 50 x 20 x 5 micro m, they are well ordered, diffracting to 1.7 A. The space group is C222(1), with unit-cell parameters a = 90.0, b = 103.7, c = 177.4 A. Structure determination and refinement to R = 0.19 (R(free) = 0.25) shows the DHQS is in the 'open' form with the substrate site unoccupied but with some loop regions perturbed. Previous crystals of open-form DHQS only diffracted to 2.5 A resolution. The use of enzyme turnover may be applicable in other systems in attempts to improve crystal quality.

Twists and turns: a tale of two shikimate-pathway enzymes

We are studying two enzymes from the shikimate pathway, dehydroquinate synthase (DHQS) and 5-enolpyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase (EPSPS). Both enzymes have been the subject of numerous studies to elucidate their reaction mechanisms. Crystal structures of DHQS and EPSPS in the presence and absence of substrates, cofactors and/or inhibitors are now available. These structures reveal movements of domains, rearrangements of loops and changes in side-chain positions necessary for the formation of a catalytically competent active site. The potential for using complementary small-angle X-ray scattering (SAXS) studies to confirm the presence of these structural differences in solution has also been explored. Comparative analysis of crystal structures, in the presence and absence of ligands, has revealed structural features critical for substrate-binding and catalysis. We have also analysed these structures by generating GRID energy maps to detect favourable binding sites. The combination of X-ray crystallography, SAXS and computational techniques provides an enhanced analysis of structural features important for the function of these complex enzymes.

Ligand-induced conformational changes and a mechanism for domain closure in Aspergillus nidulans dehydroquinate synthase

In order to investigate systematically substrate and cofactor-induced conformational changes in the enzyme dehydroquinate synthase (DHQS), eight structures representing a series of differently liganded states have been determined in a total of six crystal forms. DHQS in the absence of the substrate analogue carbaphosphonate, either unliganded or in the presence of NAD or ADP, is in an open form where a relative rotation of 11-13 degrees between N and C-terminal domains occurs. Analysis of torsion angle difference plots between sets of structures reveals eight rearrangements that appear relevant to domain closure and a further six related to crystal packing. Overlapping 21 different copies of the individual N and C-terminal DHQS domains further reveals a series of pivot points about which these movements occur and illustrates the way in which widely separated secondary structure elements are mechanically inter-linked to form "composite elements", which propagate structural changes across large distances. This analysis has provided insight into the basis of DHQS ligand-initiated domain closure and gives rise to the proposal of an ordered sequence of events involving substrate binding, and local rearrangements within the active site that are propagated to the hinge regions, leading to closure of the active-site cleft.

Expression, purification and crystallization of Aspergillus nidulans NmrA, a negative regulatory protein involved in nitrogen-metabolite repression

The NmrA repressor protein of Aspergillus nidulans was overproduced in Escherichia coli and purified to homogeneity. Gel-exclusion chromatography showed that NmrA was monomeric in solution under the buffer conditions used. The protein was crystallized in three forms, belonging to trigonal, monoclinic and hexagonal space groups. Two of these crystal forms (A and B) diffract to high resolution and thus appear suitable for structure determination. Crystal form A belongs to space group P3((1))21, with unit-cell parameters a = b = 76.8, c = 104.9 A. Crystal form B belongs to space group C2, with unit-cell parameters a = 148.8, b = 64.3, c = 110.2 A, beta = 121.8 degrees.

Identification of many crystal forms of Aspergillus nidulans dehydroquinate synthase

Extensive crystallization trials of Aspergillus nidulans dehydroquinate synthase, a potential novel target for antimicrobial drugs, in complexes with different ligands have resulted in the identification of nine crystal forms. Crystals of unliganded DHQS, binary complexes with either the substrate analogue, carbaphosphonate or the cofactor NADH, as well as the ternary DHQS-carbaphosphonate-cofactor complex, were obtained. The ternary complex crystallizes from ammonium sulfate and CoCl(2) in space group P2(1)2(1)2, with unit-cell parameters a = 133.8, b = 86.6, c = 74.9 A. The binary carbaphosphonate complex crystallizes from PEG 6000 in space group P2(1)2(1)2(1), with a = 70.0, b = 64.0, c = 197.6 A, and the binary cofactor complex crystallizes from PEG 3350 and sodium potassium tartrate in space group P2(1), with a = 83.7, b = 70.4, c = 144.3 A, beta = 89.2 degrees. DHQS in the absence of ligands crystallizes in space group P2(1), with a = 41.0, b = 68.9, c = 137.7 A, beta = 94.8 degrees. Each of these crystal forms are suitable for high-resolution structure determination. Structures of a range of DHQS-ligand complexes will be of value in the structure-based design of novel antimicrobial drugs.

Identification of domains responsible for signal recognition and transduction within the QUTR transcription repressor protein

QUTR (qutR-encoded transcription-repressing protein) is a multi-domain repressor protein active in the signal-transduction pathway that regulates transcription of the quinic acid utilization (qut) gene cluster in Aspergillus nidulans. In the presence of quinate, production of mRNA from the eight genes of the qut pathway is stimulated by the activator protein QUTA (qutA-encoded transcription-activating protein). Mutations in the qutR gene alter QUTR function such that the transcription of the qut gene cluster is permanently on (constitutive phenotype) or is insensitive to the presence of quinate (super-repressed phenotype). These mutant phenotypes imply that the QUTR protein plays a key role in signal recognition and transduction, and we have used deletion analysis to determine which regions of the QUTR protein are involved in these functions. We show that the QUTR protein recognizes and binds to the QUTA protein in vitro and that the N-terminal 88 amino acids of QUTR are sufficient to inactivate QUTA function in vivo. Deletion analysis and domain-swap experiments imply that the two C-terminal domains of QUTR are mainly involved in signal recognition.

Mechanistic studies on type I and type II dehydroquinase with (6R)- and (6S)-6-fluoro-3-dehydroquinic acids

(6R)- and (6S)-6-Fluoro-3-dehydroquinic acids are shown to be substrates for type I and type II dehydroquinases. Their differential reactivity provides insight into details of the reaction mechanism and enables a novel enzyme-substrate imine to be trapped on the type I enzyme.

The two types of 3-dehydroquinase have distinct structures but catalyze the same overall reaction

The structures of enzymes catalyzing the reactions in central metabolic pathways are generally well conserved as are their catalytic mechanisms. The two types of 3-dehydroquinate dehydratase (DHQase) are therefore most unusual since they are unrelated at the sequence level and they utilize completely different mechanisms to catalyze the same overall reaction. The type I enzymes catalyze a cis-dehydration of 3-dehydroquinate via a covalent imine intermediate, while the type II enzymes catalyze a trans-dehydration via an enolate intermediate. Here we report the three-dimensional structures of a representative member of each type of biosynthetic DHQase. Both enzymes function as part of the shikimate pathway, which is essential in microorganisms and plants for the biosynthesis of aromatic compounds including folate, ubiquinone and the aromatic amino acids. An explanation for the presence of two different enzymes catalyzing the same reaction is presented. The absence of the shikimate pathway in animals makes it an attractive target for antimicrobial agents. The availability of these two structures opens the way for the design of highly specific enzyme inhibitors with potential importance as selective therapeutic agents.

The folding and assembly of the dodecameric type II dehydroquinases

The dodecameric type II dehydroquinases (DHQases) have an unusual quaternary structure in which four trimeric units are arranged with cubic 23 symmetry. The unfolding and refolding behaviour of the enzymes from Streptomyces coelicolor and Mycobacterium tuberculosis have been studied. Gel-permeation studies show that, at low concentrations (0.5 M) of guanidinium chloride (GdmCl), both enzymes dissociate into trimeric units, with little or no change in the secondary or tertiary structure and with a 15% loss (S. coelicolor) or a 55% increase (M. tuberculosis) in activity. At higher concentrations of GdmCl, both enzymes undergo sharp unfolding transitions over narrow ranges of the denaturant concentration, consistent with co-operative unfolding of the subunits. When the concentration of GdmCl is lowered by dilution from 6 M to 0.55 M, the enzyme from S. coelicolor refolds in an efficient manner to form trimeric units, with more than 75% regain of activity. Using a similar approach the M. tuberculosis enzyme regains less than 35% activity. From the time courses of the changes in CD, fluorescence and activity of the S. coelicolor enzyme, an outline model for the refolding of the enzyme has been proposed. The model involves a rapid refolding event in which approximately half the secondary structure is regained. A slower folding process follows within the monomer, resulting in acquisition of the full secondary structure. The major changes in fluorescence occur in a second-order process which involves the association of two folded monomers. Regain of activity is dependent on a further associative event, showing that the minimum active unit must be at least trimeric. Reassembly of the dodecameric S. coelicolor enzyme and essentially complete regain of activity can be accomplished if the denatured enzyme is dialysed extensively to remove GdmCl. These results are discussed in terms of the recently solved X-ray structures of type II DHQases from these sources.

The slow step of folding of Staphylococcus aureus PC1 beta-lactamase involves the collapse of a surface loop rate limited by the trans to cis isomerization of a non-proline peptide bond

We wished to test the hypothesis that the non proline cis to trans isomerization of the peptide bond at position 167 in the S. aureus beta-lactamase PC1 exerts a significant controlling effect on the folding pathway of this enzyme. The previous data presented in support of this hypothesis could not rule out the effect of factors unrelated to non-proline cis/trans isomerization. We have used the plasmid pET9d to direct soluble overproduction of the S. aureus beta-lactamase PC1 and a site-directed mutant (Ile 167 to Pro) in Escherichia coli. Following purification the proteins were subjected to a comparative analysis of the kinetics of unfolding and refolding using the techniques of near- and far-UV circular dichroism spectroscopy and fluorescence spectroscopy in conjunction with "double-jump" experiments. Results show that the fully-unfolded I167P mutant enzyme retains 20% of molecules in a fast-refolding form and that slower-refolding molecules fold faster than the recombinant wild-type enzyme. The final stage of folding involves folding of the omega-loop into a conformation essential for enzymatic activity. In support of the original hypothesis, the folding of this omega-loop is rate limited by the isomerization of the Glu 166-Ile 167 peptide bond.

Structure of dehydroquinate synthase reveals an active site capable of multistep catalysis

Dehydroquinate synthase (DHQS) has long been regarded as a catalytic marvel because of its ability to perform several consecutive chemical reactions in one active site. There has been considerable debate as to whether DHQS is actively involved in all these steps, or whether several steps occur spontaneously, making DHQS a spectator in its own mechanism. DHQS performs the second step in the shikimate pathway, which is required for the synthesis of aromatic compounds in bacteria, microbial eukaryotes and plants. This enzyme is a potential target for new antifungal and antibacterial drugs as the shikimate pathway is absent from mammals and DHQS is required for pathogen virulence. Here we report the crystal structure of DHQS, which has several unexpected features, including a previously unobserved mode for NAD+-binding and an active-site organization that is surprisingly similar to that of alcohol dehydrogenase, in a new protein fold. The structure reveals interactions between the active site and a substrate-analogue inhibitor, which indicate how DHQS can perform multistep catalysis without the formation of unwanted by-products.

Deletion of the N-terminal region of the AREA protein is correlated with a derepressed phenotype with respect to nitrogen metabolite repression

The entire areA gene and a truncated version lacking the sequence encoding the N-terminal 389 amino acids were expressed from the qutE promoter and terminator in an Aspergillus nidulans strain with the endogenous areA gene deleted. This expression system was used to decouple the effects of transcription regulation and mRNA stability mediated by the native promoter and terminator from any posttranslational modulation of AREA activity. Both the full-length AREA protein and the truncated form were able to function in the deletion strain, conferring the ability to use alternate nitrogen sources. Transformants containing the entire areA gene had a repressible phenotype with respect to nitrogen metabolite repression, whereas those containing the truncated form of the areA gene had a derepressed phenotype. The truncated areA gene was expressed in an A. nidulans strain containing a normally regulated wild-type areA gene, and transformants displayed a quinate-inducible nitrogen metabolite derepressed phenotype. Northern blot analysis of transformed strains showed that areA-specific mRNAs of the expected sizes were being produced. The truncated AREA protein was overproduced in Escherichia coli as a fusion protein and purified to homogeneity by a single-step immobilized metal affinity chromatography, and the purified protein was shown to bind specifically to the niaD promoter. Revised sequences of the 5' region of the areA gene and the entire meaB gene are reported.

Analysis of the effect of an electric-field profile on the gain bandwidth product of avalanche photodetectors

We investigate the effect of the electric-field profile on the gain-bandwidth product of avalanche photodetectors with separate absorption and multiplication. We show that for a given multiplication layer thickness the electric-field profile plays an important role in determining the gain-bandwidth product. The calculation results show that an increasing triangular electric-field profile yields a larger gain-bandwidth product than most other profiles for Si/InGaAs avalanche photodetectors.

Evidence from kinetic isotope studies for an enolate intermediate in the mechanism of type II dehydroquinases

Substrate isotope studies, solvent isotope studies, proton in-ventories and studies of Vmax and Km as a function of pH suggest an E1CB (V. E. Anderson (1991) in Enzyme Mechanisms for Isotope Effects (Cook, P. F., ed.), pp. 389–417, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL) mechanism via an enolate intermediate for type II dehydroquinases involved in biosynthetic or catabolic pathways.

Conformational changes and the role of metals in the mechanism of type II dehydroquinase from Aspergillus nidulans

We have investigated the involvement of metal ions and conformational changes in the elimination reaction catalysed by type II dehydroquinase from Aspergillus nidulans. Mechanistic comparisons between dehydroquinases and aldolases raised the possibility that, by analogy with type II aldolases, type II dehydroquinases may require bivalent metal ions for activity. This hypothesis was tested by a combination of metal analysis, effects of metal chelators and denaturation/renaturation experiments, all of which failed to show any evidence that type II dehydroquinases are metal-dependent dehydratases. Analysis of native and refolded enzyme by electron microscopy showed that the dodecameric type II enzyme from A. nidulans adopts a ring-like structure similar to that of glutamine synthase, suggesting an arrangement of two hexameric rings stacked on top of one another. Evidence for a ligand-induced conformational change came from both chemical modification and proteolysis experiments. Inactivation data with the arginine-specific reagent phenylglyoxal indicated that, at pH 7.5, two arginine residues are modified: one modification displays affinity-labelling kinetics and has a 1:1 stoichiometry, while the other displays simple bimolecular kinetics and a stoichiometry of 2:1. The labelling at the affinity site is markedly enhanced by the addition of ligand, implying that this active-site residue is further exposed to modification by phenylglyoxal as a result of a ligand-induced conformational change. A combination of proteolysis and electrospray MS experiments identified the site of affinity labelling as Arg-19. The highly conserved N-terminal region encompassing Arg-19 of type II dehydroquinase was found to be particularly susceptible to proteolytic cleavage Limited digestion with proteinase K inactivates the enzyme, although the type II oligomeric structure is retained, and ligand binding partially protects against this inactivation.

Control of metabolic flux through the quinate pathway in Aspergillus nidulans

The quinic acid ulitization (qut) pathway in Aspergillus nidulans is a dispensable carbon utilization pathway that catabolizes quinate to protocatechuate via dehydroquinate and dehydroshikimate(DHS). At the usual in vitro growth pH of 6.5, quinate enters the mycelium by means of a specific permease and is converted into PCA by the sequential action of the enzymes quinate dehydrogenase, 3-dehydroquinase and DHS dehydratase. The extent of control on metabolic flux exerted by the permease and the three pathway enzymes was investigated by applying the techniques of Metabolic Control Analysis. The flux control coefficients for each of the three quinate pathway enzymes were determined empirically, and the flux control coefficient of the quinate permease was inferred by use of the summation theorem. There measurements implied that, under the standard growth conditions used, the values for the flux control coefficients of the components of the quinate pathway were: quinate permease, 0.43; quinate dehydrogenase, 0.36; dehydroquinase, 0.18; DHS dehydratase, <0,03. Attempts to partially decouple quinate permease from the control over flux by measuring flux at pH 3.5 (when a significant percentage of the soluble quinate is protonated and able to enter the mycelium without the aid of a permease) led to an increase of approx. 50% in the flux control coefficient for dehydroquinase. Taken together with the fact that A. nidulans has a very efficient pH homeostasis mechanism, these experiments are consistent with the view that quinate permease exerts a high degree of control over pathway flux under the standard laboratory growth conditions at pH 6.5. The enzymes quinate dehydrogenase and 3-dehydroquinase have previously been overproduced in Escherichia coli, and protocols for their purification published. The remaining qut pathway enzyme DHS dehydratase was overproduced in E. coli and a purification protocol established. The purified DHS dehydratase was shown to have a K(m) of 530 microM for its substrate DHS and a requirement for bivalent metal cations that could be fulfilled by Mg(2+), Mn(2+) or Zn(2+). All three qut pathway enzymes were purified in bulk and their elasticity coefficients with respect to the three quinate pathway intermediates were derived over a range of concentrations in a core tricine/NaOH buffer, augmented with necessary cofactors and bivalent cations as appropriate. Using these empirically determined relative values, in conjunction with the connectivity theorem, the relative ratios of the flux control coefficients for the various quinate pathway enzymes, and how this control shifts between them, was determined over a range of possible metabolic concentrations. These calculations, although clearly subject to caveates about the relationswhip between kinetic measurements in vitro and the situation in vivo, were able to successfully predict the hiearchy of control observed under the standard laboratory growth conditions. The calculations imply that the hierarchy of control exerted by the quinate pathway enzymes is stable and relatively insensitive to changing metabolite concentrations in the ranges most likely to correspond to those found in vivo. The effects of substituting the type I 3-dehydroquinases from Salmonella typhi and the A. nidulans AROM protein (a pentadomain protein catalysing the conversion of 3-deoxy-D-arabinoheptulosonic acid 7-phosphate into 5-enolpyruvylshikimate 3 phosphate), and the Mycobacterium tuberculosis type II 3-dehydroquinase, in the quinate pathway were investigated and found to have an effect. In the case of S. typhi and A. nidulans, overproduction of heterologous dehydroquinase led to a diminuation of pathway flux caused by a lowering of in vivo quinate dehydrogenase levels increased above those of the wild type. We speculate that these changes in qu

Comparative analysis of the QUTR transcription repressor protein and the three C-terminal domains of the pentafunctional AROM enzyme

The AROM protein is a pentadomain protein catalysing steps two to six in the prechorismate section of the shikimate pathway in microbial eukaryotes. On the basis of amino acid sequence alignments and the properties of mutants unable to utilize quinic acid as a carbon source, the AROM protein has been proposed to be homologous throughout its length with the proteins regulating transcription of the genes necessary for quinate catabolism. The QUTR transcription repressor protein has been proposed to be homologous with the three C-terminal domains of the AROM protein and one-fifth of the penultimate N-terminal domain. We report here the results of experiments designed to overproduce the QUTR and AROM proteins and their constituent domains in Escherichia coli, the purpose being to facilitate domain purification and (in the case of AROM), complementation of E. coli aro- mutations in order to probe the degree to which individual domains are stable and functional. The 3-dehydroquinate dehydratase domain of the AROM protein and the 3-dehydroquinate dehydratase-like domain of the QUTR spectroscopy and fluorescence emission spectroscopy. The CD spectra were found to be virtually superimposable. The fluorescence emission spectra of both domains had the signal from the tryptophan residues almost completely quenched, giving a tyrosine-dominated spectrum for both the AROM- and QUTR-derived domains. This unexpected observation was demonstrated to be due to a highly unusual environment provided by the tertiary structure, as addition of the denaturant guanidine hydrochloride gave a typical tryptophan-dominated spectrum for both domains. The spectroscopy experiments had the potential to refute the biologically-based proposal for a common origin for the AROM and QUTR proteins; however, the combined biophysical data are consistent with the hypothesis. We have previously reported that the AROM dehydroquinate synthase and 3-dehydroquinate dehydratase are stable and functional as individual domains, but that the 5-enol-pyruvylshikimate-3-phosphate synthase is only active as part of the complete AROM protein or as a bi-domain fragment with dehydroquinate synthase. Here we report that the aromA gene (encoding the AROM protein) of Aspergillus nidulans contains a 53 nt intron in the extreme C-terminus of the shikimate dehydrogenase domain. This finding accounts for the previously reported observation that the AROM protein was unable to complement aroE- (lacking shikimate dehydrogenase) mutations in E. coli. When the intron is removed the correctly translated AROM protein is able to complement the E. coli aroE- mutation. An AROM-derived shikimate dehydrogenase domain is, however, non-functional, but function is restored in a bi-domain protein with e-dehydroquinate dehydratase. This interaction is not entirely specific, as substitution of the 3-dehydroquinate dehydratase domain with the glutathione S-transferase protein partially restores enzyme activity. Similarly an AROM-derived shikimate kinase domain is non-functional, but is functional as part of the complete AROM protein, or as a bi-domain protein with 3-dehydroquinate dehydratase.