Germline Sequencing Improves Tumor-Only Sequencing Interpretation in a Precision Genomic Study of Patients With Pediatric Solid Tumor

PURPOSE

Molecular tumor profiling is becoming a routine part of clinical cancer care, typically involving tumor-only panel testing without matched germline. We hypothesized that integrated germline sequencing could improve clinical interpretation and enhance the identification of germline variants with significant hereditary risks.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Tumors from pediatric patients with high-risk, extracranial solid malignancies were sequenced with a targeted panel of cancer-associated genes. Later, germline DNA was analyzed for a subset of these genes. We performed a post hoc analysis to identify how an integrated analysis of tumor and germline data would improve clinical interpretation.

RESULTS

One hundred sixty participants with both tumor-only and germline sequencing reports were eligible for this analysis. Germline sequencing identified 38 pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants among 35 (22%) patients. Twenty-five (66%) of these were included in the tumor sequencing report. The remaining germline pathogenic or likely pathogenic variants were single-nucleotide variants filtered out of tumor-only analysis because of population frequency or copy-number variation masked by additional copy-number changes in the tumor. In tumor-only sequencing, 308 of 434 (71%) single-nucleotide variants reported were present in the germline, including 31% with suggested clinical utility. Finally, we provide further evidence that the variant allele fraction from tumor-only sequencing is insufficient to differentiate somatic from germline events.

CONCLUSION

A paired approach to analyzing tumor and germline sequencing data would be expected to improve the efficiency and accuracy of distinguishing somatic mutations and germline variants, thereby facilitating the process of variant curation and therapeutic interpretation for somatic reports, as well as the identification of variants associated with germline cancer predisposition.

MYOD1 c.365G>T, p.L122R Variant Detection by Droplet Digital PCR (ddPCR)

Introduction/Objective

Rhabomyosarcomas (RMS) are a group of skeletal muscle tumors that include embryonal, alveolar, pleomorphic, spindle cell/sclerosing subtypes (SC/SRMS). Spindle cell RMS occurs in both adult and pediatric populations, and is associated with either more aggressive or better clinical outcomes respectively. A recurrent hotspot variant in MYOD1, p.L122R (NM_002478.4 c.365G>T), has been described in SC/SRMS. The classification of this diagnosis is evolving, with VGLL2 and NCOA2 fusions defining the diagnosis in young children, and MYOD1 p.L122R defining the diagnosis in older children. The MYOD1 p.L122R variant seems to be associated with more aggressive disease, and may be increasingly used in risk stratification with intensification of treatment.

Methods/Case Report

A digital droplet PCR (ddPCR) assay was used to detect the MYOD1 p.L122R in DNA samples with RMS. Patients and controls were coded as positive or negative, and tested for association with clinical features and outcome.

Results (if a Case Study enter NA)

Known-positive cohort of samples was limited by the extreme rarity of this tumor. “Known-positive” status was established by confirmation of the variant with an external clinically-validated assay. The six known positive samples were assessed by ddPCR for the presence of MYOD1 L122R. The L122R variant was detected in all six variants for a sensitivity of 100%. DNA and/or TNA obtained from known wild-type FFPE and frozen material was assessed, for a total of nine unique samples (1 synthetic, 8 patient-derived). All 9 samples were wild- type, with no positive droplets detected, for a specificity of 100%.

Conclusion

Our MYOD1 c.365G>T, p.L122R variant detection by droplet digital PCR (ddPCR) assay is a robust, reproducible, specific and sensitive method to detect the MYOD1 hotspot mutation.

Assessment of BCOR Internal Tandem Duplications in Pediatric Cancers by Targeted RNA Sequencing

Alterations in the BCOR gene, including internal tandem duplications (ITDs) of exon 15 have emerged as important oncogenic changes that define several diagnostic entities. In pediatric cancers, BCOR ITDs have recurrently been described in clear cell sarcoma of kidney (CCSK), primitive myxoid mesenchymal tumor of infancy (PMMTI), and central nervous system high-grade neuroepithelial tumor with BCOR ITD in exon 15 (HGNET-BCOR ITDex15). In adults, BCOR ITDs are also reported in endometrial and other sarcomas. The utility of multiplex targeted RNA sequencing for the identification of BCOR ITD in pediatric cancers was investigated. All available archival cases of CCSK, PMMTI, and HGNET-BCOR ITDex15 were collected. Each case underwent anchored multiplex PCR library preparation with a custom-designed panel, with BCOR targeted for both fusions and ITDs. BCOR ITD was detected in all cases across three histologic subtypes using the RNA panel, with no other fusions identified in any of the cases. All BCOR ITDs occurred in the final exon, within 16 codons from the stop sequence. Multiplex targeted RNA sequencing from formalin-fixed, paraffin-embedded tissue is successful at identifying BCOR internal tandem duplications. This analysis supports the use of anchored multiplex PCR targeted RNA next-generation sequencing panels for identification of BCOR ITDs in pediatric tumors. The use of post-analytic algorithms to improve the detection of BCOR ITD using DNA panels was also explored.

Molecular Alterations in Pediatric Solid Tumors

Pediatric tumors can be divided into hematologic malignancies, central nervous system tumors, and extracranial solid tumors of bone, soft tissue, or other organ systems. Molecular alterations that impact diagnosis, prognosis, treatment, and familial cancer risk have been described in many pediatric solid tumors. In addition to providing a concise summary of clinically relevant molecular alterations in extracranial pediatric solid tumors, this review discusses conventional and next-generation sequencing-based molecular techniques, relevant tumor predisposition syndromes, and the increasing integration of molecular data into the practice of diagnostic pathology for children with solid tumors.

A Curriculum for Genomic Education of Molecular Genetic Pathology Fellows: A Report of the Association for Molecular Pathology Training and Education Committee

Molecular genetic pathology (MGP) is a subspecialty of pathology and medical genetics and genomics. Genomic testing, which we define as that which generates large data sets and interrogates large segments of the genome in a single assay, is increasingly recognized as essential for optimal patient care through precision medicine. The most common genomic testing technologies in clinical laboratories are next-generation sequencing and microarray. It is essential to train in these methods and to consider the data generated in the context of the diagnosis, medical history, and other clinical findings of individual patients. Accordingly, updating the MGP fellowship curriculum to include genomics is timely, important, and challenging. At the completion of training, an MGP fellow should be capable of independently interpreting and signing out results of a wide range of genomic assays and, given the appropriate context and institutional support, of developing and validating new assays in compliance with applicable regulations. The Genomics Task Force of the MGP Program Directors, a working group of the Association for Molecular Pathology Training and Education Committee, has developed a genomics curriculum framework and recommendations specific to the MGP fellowship. These recommendations are presented for consideration and implementation by MGP fellowship programs with the understanding that MGP programs exist in a diversity of clinical practice environments with a spectrum of available resources.

Abstract 210: Advancing knowledgebase representation of pediatric cancer variants through ClinGen/CIViC collaboration

Childhood cancers are driven by unique profiles of somatic genetic alterations, with a significant contribution from predisposing germline variants. Understanding the genomic landscape of pediatric cancers is complicated by their rarity, the heterogeneity of variation within a given disease, and the complex forms of structural variation they contain. Variants in childhood disease may differ from those in adult versions of the same cancer type, or may have different clinical significance. Currently, pediatric variants are underrepresented in cancer variant databases, and an urgent need exists for their publicly available expert curation. To address this, the Pediatric Cancer Taskforce (PCT) was formed within the Clinical Genome Resource (ClinGen) Somatic Cancer Clinical Domain Working Group (CDWG) (https://www.clinicalgenome.org/working-groups/somatic/). The PCT is a multi-institutional group of 39 members with broad experience in childhood cancer and variant curation, whose work consists of standardization and classification of genetic variants in pediatric cancers. The CIViC knowledgebase (www.civicdb.org) is a freely available resource for Clinical Interpretation of Variants in Cancer, which leverages public curation and expert moderation to address the problem of annotating the large volume of clinically actionable cancer variants. PCT curators work together with PCT expert members and the CIViC team on variant curation, and have submitted over 230 Evidence Items and over 10 Assertions to CIViC. To further address issues specific to pediatric curation, the PCT is working with CIViC to develop new pediatric-specific CIViC features and modifications of the data model that will aid in pediatric curation. A pediatric user interface, as well as representation of large scale structural and copy number variation are being developed for version two of CIViC, expected to be released in 1-2 years, which will enable curation of a new class of structural variants often encountered in pediatric cancer. A novel standard operating procedure for childhood cancer curation in CIViC is being developed by PCT experts, curators and the CIViC team. This SOP will cover topics including curation of structural variants, as well as pediatric-specific variant tiering guidelines which take into account the sparse nature of evidence in pediatric cases. A companion resource, CIViCmine (http://bionlp.bcgsc.ca/civicmine/), will be further developed to incorporate pediatric data. These and other joint efforts of the PCT and CIViC will significantly enhance pediatric variant representation for public use, to support the care of children with cancer.

Citation Format: Arpad Danos, Wan-Hsin Lin, Jason Saliba, Angshumoy Roy, Alanna J. Church, Shruti Rao, Deborah Ritter, Kilannin Krysiak, Alex Wagner, Erica Barnell, Lana Sheta, Adam Coffman, Susanna Kiwala, Joshua F. McMichael, Laura Corson, Kevin Fisher, Heather E. Williams, Matthew Hiemenz, Katherine A. Janeway, Jianling Ji, Kesserwan A. Chimene, Laura Fuqua, Lisa Dyer, Huiling Xu, Jeffrey Jean, Laveniya Satgunaseelan, Liying Zhang, Ted W. Laetsch, Donald W. Parsons, Ryan Schmidt, Lynn M. Schriml, Kristen L. Sund, Shashikant Kulkarni, Subha Madhavan, Xinjie Xu, Rashmi Kanagal-Shamana, Marian Harris, Yasmine Akkari, Nurit Paz Yacov, Panieh Terraf, Malachi Griffith, Obi L. Griffith, Gordana Raca. Advancing knowledgebase representation of pediatric cancer variants through ClinGen/CIViC collaboration [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2021; 2021 Apr 10-15 and May 17-21. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2021;81(13_Suppl):Abstract nr 210.

Clinical impact of molecular tumor profiling in pediatric, adolescent, and young adult patients with extra-cranial solid malignancies: An interim report from the GAIN/iCat2 study

10005

Background: Next generation sequencing (NGS) assays are now a standard part of clinical care for many adult solid cancers. The significance of molecular tumor profiling for the care of children with cancer is not well understood.We aimed to determine the clinical impact of identifying genomic alterations by NGS for young patients with relapsed, refractory, or high-risk extracranial solid tumors. Methods: We report on the first 389 participants in a prospective cohort study enrolling patients at 12 institutions with extracranial solid tumors diagnosed at age 30 years or less. Targeted DNA NGS was performed on one or more tumor samples from each patient. Selected patients also had tumors subjected to RNA sequencing. Test results were returned to the treating oncologist and follow-up treatment and response data were collected.Identified genomic alterations were classified according to evidence of impact on diagnosis, prognosis or response to targeted therapy matched to an identified alteration (matched targeted therapy, MTT) using established guidelines. Response to MTT was determined and reported as a response if either there was radiographic response according to RECIST or the duration of therapy was > 4 months. Results: Molecular tumor profiling (MTP) was successful in 345 (89%) patients (mean age 11 years at diagnosis; 65% with sarcoma). Two hundred and ninety-nine patients with MTP results (87%) had one or more alterations of clinical significance. Genomic alterations with diagnostic, prognostic or therapeutic significance were present in 208 (60%), 51 (15%) and 240 (70%) patients, respectively. Of the 240 patients with tumors harboring genomic alterations designated as having therapeutic impact, 23 (11%) had Tier 1 molecular findings. 205 patients were eligible to receive MTT based on having a molecular alteration with therapeutic significance and sufficient follow-up; 31 of these patients (15%) received MTT. Seven patients (23%) receiving MTT responded, 6 of these were kinase fusions. All of the responders received targeted therapy matched to a fusion and 78% of diagnostically significant alterations were fusions. Conclusions: Molecular tumor profiling has a significant impact on diagnosis and treatment recommendations for young patients with extracranial solid tumors. These results emphasize the importance of fusion detection for patients with sarcomas and rare tumors. Clinical trial information: NCT02520713.

Natural History of Thyroid Disease in Children with PTEN Hamartoma Tumor Syndrome

CONTEXT

Thyroid ultrasound screening is recommended in children with PTEN hamartoma tumor syndrome (PHTS) due to increased risk of thyroid neoplasia, but the natural history of thyroid disease in children with PHTS is unclear.

OBJECTIVE

Determine the prevalence and natural history of thyroid disease in children with PHTS.

METHODS

Retrospective cohort study (1998-2019) in an academic pediatric hospital of individuals with genetically confirmed PHTS diagnosed before age 19 years. Clinical, thyroid ultrasound, and laboratory characteristics are described. Primary outcomes were the prevalence of thyroid nodules ≥10 mm diameter and time course and risk factors for nodule development assessed by Cox regression analysis. Secondary outcomes included thyroid nodule requiring biopsy, other ultrasound findings, and prevalence of autoimmune thyroid disease.

RESULTS

Among 64 subjects with PHTS, 50 underwent thyroid ultrasound. A thyroid nodule ≥10 mm was diagnosed in 22/50 (44%) subjects at median (range) age 13.3 (7.0-22.9) years. Nodules were diagnosed earlier in females than in males (10.8 [7.0-17.9] vs 14.2 [9.9-22.9] years, P = .009). In multivariate analysis, risk of thyroid nodules was significantly associated with female sex (hazard ratio 2.90, 95% CI 1.16-7.27, P = .02) and inversely associated with the presence of neurologic findings of PHTS (HR 0.27, 95% CI 0.10-0.69, P = .007). Abnormal-appearing lymph nodes with echogenic foci were observed by ultrasound in 20% of subjects, but these were not associated with malignancy. Autoimmune thyroid disease was present in 10/33 (30.3%) of subjects in whom it was assessed.

CONCLUSION

Thyroid disease is common in children with PHTS. This study supports current consensus recommendations for ultrasound screening.

Clinical Pan-Cancer Assessment of Mismatch Repair Deficiency Using Tumor-Only, Targeted Next-Generation Sequencing

PURPOSE

Given regulatory approval of immune checkpoint inhibitors in patients with mismatch repair-deficient (MMR-D) cancers agnostic to tumor type, it has become important to characterize occurrence of MMR-D and develop cost-effective screening approaches. Using a next-generation sequencing (NGS) panel (OncoPanel), we developed an algorithm to identify MMR-D frequency in tumor samples and applied it in a clinical setting with pathologist review.

METHODS

To predict MMR-D, we adapted methods described previously for use in NGS panels, which assess patterns of single base-pair insertion or deletion events occurring in homopolymer regions. Tumors assayed with OncoPanel between July 2013 and July 2018 were included. For tumors tested after June 2017, sequencing results were presented to pathologists in real time for clinical MMR determination, in the context of tumor mutation burden, other mutational signatures, and clinical data.

RESULTS

Of 20,301 tumors sequenced, 2.7% (553) were retrospectively classified as MMR-D by the algorithm. Of 4,404 samples with pathologist sign-out of MMR status, the algorithm classified 147 (3.3%) as MMR-D: in 116 cases, MMR-D was confirmed by a pathologist, five cases were overruled by the pathologist, and 26 were assessed as indeterminate. Overall, the highest frequencies of OncoPanel-inferred MMR-D were in endometrial (21%; 152/723), colorectal (9.7%; 169/1,744), and small bowel (9.3%; 9/97) cancers. When algorithm predictions were compared with historical MMR immunohistochemistry or polymerase chain reaction results in a set of 325 tumors sequenced before initiation of pathologist assessment, the overall sensitivity and specificity of the algorithm were 91.1% and 98.2%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

We show that targeted, tumor-only NGS can be leveraged to determine MMR signatures across tumor types, suggesting that broader biomarker screening approaches may have clinical value.

DICER1-associated central nervous system sarcoma in children: comprehensive clinicopathologic and genetic analysis of a newly described rare tumor

The spectrum of neoplasms associated with DICER1 variants continues to expand, with the recent addition of primary "DICER1-associated central nervous system sarcoma" (DCS). DCS is a high-grade malignancy predominantly affecting pediatric patients. Six pediatric DCS were identified through a combination of clinical diagnostic studies, archival inquiry, and interinstitutional collaboration. Clinical, histologic, immunohistologic, and molecular features were examined. Genomic findings in the 6 DCS were compared with those in 14 additional DICER1-associated tumors sequenced with the same assay. The six patients presented at ages 3-15 years with CNS tumors located in the temporal (n = 2), parietal (n = 1), fronto-parietal (n = 1), and frontal (n = 2) lobes. All underwent surgical resection. Histologic examination demonstrated high-grade malignant spindle cell tumors with pleuropulmonary blastoma-like embryonic "organoid" features and focal rhabdomyoblastic differentiation; immature cartilage was seen in one case. Immunohistochemically, there was patchy desmin and myogenin staining, and patchy loss of H3K27me3, and within eosinophilic cytoplasmic globules, alfa-fetoprotein staining. Biallelic DICER1 variants were identified in all cases, with germline variants in two of five patients tested. DCS demonstrated genomic alterations enriched for Ras pathway activation and TP53 inactivation. Tumor mutational burden was significantly higher in the 6 DCS tumors than in 14 other DICER1-associated tumors examined (mean 12.9 vs. 6.8 mutations/Mb, p = 0.035). Postoperative care included radiation (n = 5) and chemotherapy (n = 3); at the last follow-up, three patients were alive without DCS, and three had died of disease. Our analysis expands the clinical, histologic, immunohistological, and molecular spectrum of DCS, identifying distinctive features that can aid in the diagnosis, multidisciplinary evaluation, and treatment of DCS.

Making the most of small samples: Optimization of tissue allocation of pediatric solid tumors for clinical and research use

INTRODUCTION

Tissue from pediatric solid tumors is in high demand for use in high-impact research studies, making the allocation of tissue from an anatomic pathology laboratory challenging. We designed, implemented, and assessed an interdepartmental process to optimize tissue allocation of pediatric solid tumors for both clinical care and research.

METHODS

Oncologists, pathologists, surgeons, interventional radiologists, pathology technical staff, and clinical research coordinators participated in the workflow design. Procedures were created to address patient identification and consent, prioritization of protocols, electronic communication of requests, tissue preparation, and distribution. Pathologists were surveyed about the value of the new workflow.

RESULTS

Over a 5-year period, 644 pediatric solid tumor patients consented to one or more studies requesting archival or fresh tissue. Patients had a variety of tumor types, with many rare and singular diagnoses. Sixty-seven percent of 1768 research requests were fulfilled. Requests for archival tissue were fulfilled at a significantly higher rate than those for fresh tissue (P > .001), and requests from resection specimens were fulfilled at a significantly higher rate than those from biopsies (P > .0001). In an anonymous survey, seven of seven pathologists reported that the process had improved since the introduction of the electronic communication model.

CONCLUSIONS

A collaborative and informed model for tissue allocation is successful in distributing archival and fresh tissue for clinical research studies. Our workflows and policies have gained pathologists' approval and streamlined our processes. As clinical and research programs evolve, a thoughtful tissue allocation process will facilitate ongoing research.

New molecular insights into the pathogenesis of lipoblastomas: clinicopathologic, immunohistochemical, and molecular analysis in pediatric cases

Lipoblastomas can occasionally require further molecular confirmation when occurring outside of the usual age groups or demonstrating unusual morphology. We reviewed 28 lipoblastomas with 16 controls. Lipoblastomas were subdivided into myxoid (n = 7), classic (n = 9), or lipoma-like (n = 12) subtypes. PLAG1 immunohistochemistry, PLAG1 fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH), and targeted RNA sequencing were performed on formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded tissue. Karyotypes were available in a subset of lipoblastomas (n = 9). Gene rearrangements were identified in 17/25 (68%) lipoblastomas, including PLAG1 (15/25, 60%) and HMGA2 (2/25, 8%). Five novel fusion partners (DDX6, KLF10, and KANSL1L with PLAG1 and EP400 and FGD6 with HMGA2) were found. PLAG1 immunohistochemistry was positive (nuclear, moderate/strong) in myxoid and classic subtypes lipoblastomas with preferential expression in mesenchymal cells within myxoid stroma and fibrous septa and negative in all controls. When comparing PLAG1 immunohistochemistry with molecular testing (FISH and/or RNA sequencing and/or karyotype), concordant results were noted in 13/25 (52%) cases, increasing to 15/25 (60%) after slight adjustment of the PLAG1 FISH positive threshold. In myxoid and classic lipoblastomas, PLAG1 immunohistochemistry seems to be a better surrogate marker for PLAG1 rearrangement, as compared with lipoma-like subtypes. In lipoma-like subtypes, targeted RNA sequencing appears to detect PLAG1 fusions better than FISH and immunohistochemistry. The preferential expression of PLAG1 in the mesenchymal and fibroblast-like cells deserves further investigation as the putative cell of origin in lipoblastoma.

Abstract A58: Curation of pediatric cancer variants within the Clinical Genome Resource (ClinGen)

Introduction: The Clinical Genome Resource (ClinGen) Somatic Working Group (sWG) is a multi-institution team engaged in developing processes, resources, and standards to support accurate classification of somatic variants in cancer. Existing decision support resources in cancer knowledgebases are heavily skewed towards genes and variants relevant in adult cancers; however, information to support variant interpretation in childhood cancers is limited. Here we report on the goals and progress of the Pediatric Cancer Taskforce, created within the ClinGen sWG, to lead curation efforts of actionable alterations in childhood cancers.

Methods: The ClinGen sWG Pediatric Cancer Taskforce (PCT) consists of a core group of twelve members comprising geneticists, pathologists, and oncologists with expertise in different pediatric cancers and with representation from 9 leading pediatric institutions. The taskforce has a total of 35 members including volunteer-curators who work under guidance of the expert members. Curation of childhood cancer variants is conducted in collaboration with the Clinical Interpretation of Variants in Cancer (CIViC) team at Washington University in Saint Louis, using the CIViC knowledgebase (civicdb.org) and the ClinVar database as open-access curation and data-sharing platforms. Diagnostic, prognostic, and therapeutic evidence is tiered according to the AMP/ASCO/CAP guidelines for the clinical interpretation of somatic variants. PCT members are assigned specific genetic variant-tumor type associations for curation, which are then reviewed in monthly conferences to finalize assertions in CIViC.

Results: The PCT has prioritized 40 genetic alterations relevant to pediatric cancer for curation based on their clinical relevance and the lack of sufficient existing curated evidence in clinical knowledgebases. To date, 4 assertions have been created and added to the database: HEY1-NCOA2 fusion in mesenchymal chondrosarcoma, KIAA1549-BRAF fusion and ACVR1 p.G328V variant in pediatric glioma, and EBF1-PDGFRB fusion in pediatric B-cell precursor acute lymphoblastic leukemia. Active curation has been initiated for NTRK fusions agnostic of tissue histology, targetable kinase fusions in Ph-like B-lymphoblastic leukemia, and common variants in selected pediatric sarcomas and brain tumors, focusing heavily on driver gene fusions in childhood cancers. 119 evidence items have been created in CIViC by the members. The PCT also works to implement more standardized and accurate classification of pediatric cancers in CIViC and other cancer resources, and to enhance search for pediatric-specific data through appropriate tagging of evidence using ontology terms.

Conclusions: As molecular alterations are increasingly relevant to the care of children with cancer, the ClinGen PCT will work to develop standards, processes, and resources for efficient and accurate determination of clinical relevance of pediatric cancer variants.

Citation Format: Alanna J. Church, Shruti Rao, Deborah Ritter, Arpad Danos, Kilann Krysiak, Laura B. Corson, Kevin E. Fisher, Matthew Hiemenz, Katherine A. Janeway, Jianling Ji, Chimene A. Kesserwan, Theodore W. Laetsch, Donald W. Parsons, Ryan J. Schmidt, Kristen L. Sund, Wan-Hsin Lin, Malachi Griffith, Obi L. Griffith, Shashikant Kulkarni, Subha Madhavan, Angshumoy Roy, Gordana Raca. Curation of pediatric cancer variants within the Clinical Genome Resource (ClinGen) [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the AACR Special Conference on the Advances in Pediatric Cancer Research; 2019 Sep 17-20; Montreal, QC, Canada. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2020;80(14 Suppl):Abstract nr A58.

Abstract A06: The added value of examining germline variants in a precision cancer therapy study

Introduction: Tumor profiling is becoming a more routine part of clinical care. Many academic centers and commercial entities offer tumor sequencing of cancer-related genes without matched germline profiling. We hypothesize that tumor-only sequencing may limit full clinical interpretation and have decreased sensitivity to identify significant germline variants.

Methods: The Genomic Assessment Improves Novel Therapy (GAIN) Consortium is a clinical cancer genomics study for patients with high-risk solid malignancies. Patients in this study were selected for subanalysis if panel sequencing of 447 genes was performed on a tumor and interpreted by an expert panel prior to the availability of matched germline sequencing. Interpretation of tumor sequencing included both therapeutic recommendations and a curation of cancer-related variants of potential clinical significance if present in the germline. Germline sequencing was separately performed targeting 147 genes (a subset of the somatic panel) and analyzed with a germline-specific pipeline to identify and filter variants. We examined clinical recommendations in the somatic reports that were based on single-nucleotide variants identified from the 147 overlapping genes. We compared these interpretations with results from the matched germline data.

Results: We identified 159 participants with somatic and germline sequencing reports meeting the eligibility criteria. Germline sequencing identified 38 pathogenic or likely pathogenic (P/LP) germline variants in 35 of 159 patients (22%). Of those 35 patients, 17 (49%) had a P/LP variant in an autosomal dominant cancer predisposition gene, 19 (54%) in an autosomal recessive gene, and 1 (2.9%) in a noncancer gene. Of the 38 total variants, 21 (55%) were identified by the analytic pipeline used for somatic sequencing and noted as potential germline variants in the somatic reports. Forty treatment recommendations were made from the somatic data within the overlapping genes. Ten (25%) treatment recommendations were based on variants that were later determined to be germline. These included variants in TP53, SDHA, SMARCA4, TSC2, FAM175A, CHEK2, and AKT1, many of which were noted in the somatic reports to be variants of uncertain significance or possibly germline.

Conclusions: In this study, we found that clinically actionable germline variants were under-reported when relying on analytical pipelines and clinical interpretations developed for the analysis of tumor samples. In the absence of germline sequencing, we also found that cancer treatment recommendations can be made based on mutations identified from tumor sequencing that are germline variants. In many cases, these recommendations remain appropriate (e.g., PARP inhibitors for BRCA1/2) while in other cases germline data facilitated a more nuanced interpretation of actionability. These findings support the use of germline genetic testing and paired tumor-germline analysis in precision cancer medicine studies.

Citation Format: Jaclyn Schienda, Catherine M. Clinton, Laura B. Corson, Alma Imamovic-Tuco, Navin Pinto, Luke Maese, Theodore W. Laetsch, AeRang Kim, Susan I. Vear, Margaret E. Macy, Mark A. Applebaum, Rochelle Bagatell, Amit J. Sabnis, Daniel A. Weiser, Julia L. Glade-Bender, Samuel L. Volchenboum, Wenjun Kang, Danielle Manning, Jonathan Nowak, Joshua Schiffman, Neal I. Lindeman, Alanna J. Church, Katherine A. Janeway, Brian D. Crompton, Junne Kamihara. The added value of examining germline variants in a precision cancer therapy study [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the AACR Special Conference on the Advances in Pediatric Cancer Research; 2019 Sep 17-20; Montreal, QC, Canada. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2020;80(14 Suppl):Abstract nr A06.

Abstract B13: Leveraging cloud-based computational resources for gene fusion discovery with potential clinical implications for pediatric solid tumor patients

Introduction: Gene fusions are important oncogenic drivers with significant clinical impact in some cancer types. This is particularly true in pediatric cancers that often have low mutational burden and lack other diagnostic markers and therapeutic targets. Many gene fusions are rare or private to the individual patient and can be difficult to detect with methods optimized for common fusions. Unbiased sequencing methods and expansive computational resources are needed for expanding our ability to characterize fusions. Building a comprehensive catalog of oncogenic gene fusions will improve our understanding of their diversity and fully harness their potential for clinical impact.

Methods: Patients are eligible for the GAIN/iCat2 study if they have been diagnosed with high-risk or recurrent/refractory extracranial solid tumor at age 30 or less and have a sample available for sequencing. Enrolled patients with an unclear diagnosis after standard clinical testing are nominated for transcriptome sequencing by the study investigators. We developed a computational pipeline in Google Cloud for gene fusion discovery utilizing paired end Illumina RNA-Seq data, multiple fusion callers, and a custom algorithm for integrative data analysis. The multicaller fusion detection approach enables us to address the high false-positive rate typical for gene fusion calling in transcriptomic data while improving the sensitivity to detect the more challenging fusions. After filtering, the fusions are annotated using the databases of known fusions and cancer genes. The predicted fusion transcripts are inspected visually, and the fusions are selected based on relevance to diagnostic classification or therapy to be validated by an orthogonal method.

Results: 41 tumor samples were sequenced and analyzed for gene fusions. A total of 203 candidate fusions were detected by two or more fusion callers. Based on functional annotations and potential impact on diagnosis or therapeutic approaches, 12 fusion transcripts of interest were identified, 10 of which were validated by either pre-enrollment testing or an orthogonal method. Of 16 mesenchymal cases, 6 validated fusions had diagnostic relevance and 3 validated fusions had therapeutic implications (ERC1-BRAF, RBPMS-NTRK2, and VCAN-IL23R). Two patients responded to matched targeted therapy. In one case, diagnostic classification was revised.

Conclusions: Whole-transcriptome sequencing in this selected patient population identified some fusion transcripts with clinical relevance. Determining the biologic significance of previously unreported fusions will require orthogonal sequencing such as whole genome, functional studies, and analysis of larger patient populations. Improved accuracy and scalability of methods for large-scale gene fusion analysis in the growing public datasets are likely to expand the landscape of gene fusions in cancer.

Citation Format: Alma Imamovic, Alanna J. Church, Laura B. Corson, Deirdre Reidy, Navin Pinto, Luke Maese, Theodore W. Laetsch, AeRang Kim, Susan I. Vear, Margaret E. Macy, Mark A. Applebaum, Rochelle Bagatell, Amit J. Sabnis, Daniel A. Weiser, Julia L. Glade-Bender, Gianna R. Strand, Lobin A. Lee, R. Seth Pinches, Catherine M. Clinton, Brian D. Crompton, Neal I. Lindeman, Steven G. DuBois, Katherine A. Janeway, Eliezer M. Van Allen. Leveraging cloud-based computational resources for gene fusion discovery with potential clinical implications for pediatric solid tumor patients [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the AACR Special Conference on the Advances in Pediatric Cancer Research; 2019 Sep 17-20; Montreal, QC, Canada. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2020;80(14 Suppl):Abstract nr B13.

Abstract A59: Sequencing identifies diagnostically relevant alterations in pediatric solid tumor patients

Introduction: Molecular techniques have been incorporated into the diagnostic algorithms for many specific tumors, but the diagnostic role of next-generation sequencing has not been described at a population level. We report diagnostically relevant alterations identified by large-scale sequencing in a prospective cohort of pediatric solid tumors.

Methods and Objectives: Patients are eligible for the GAIN / iCat2 study if they have a high-risk, recurrent, or refractory extracranial solid tumor diagnosed at age 30 or less and have an adequate sample for sequencing available. After informed consent, tumor was sequenced using a next-generation sequencing assay that evaluates 447 genes and includes data about sequence variants, copy number alterations, and, in selected genes, translocations. Some cases received additional sequencing via RNASeq or targeted RNA sequencing for further evaluation of fusions. Diagnostic relevance was determined according to AMP/ASCO/CAP standards and guidelines for the reporting of sequence variants in cancer.

Results: 349 patients were enrolled as of December 31, 2018, and had tumor tissue successfully sequenced. These patients represent 60 unique diagnoses according to the WHO ICD-O classification. The most common single diagnoses were osteosarcoma (n=64), Ewing sarcoma (n=44), and alveolar rhabdomyosarcoma (n=32). For 349 patients, 184 (53%) had one or more genetic alterations that were diagnostically relevant, of which 159 (86%) were structural variants, 16 (8%) were sequence variants, and 9 (5%) were copy number variations. Alterations of high diagnostic relevance include CIC-DUX4 fusions in sarcoma (n=8), TP53 intron 1 rearrangements in osteosarcoma (n=26), DICER1 sequence variants in various tumors (n=7), and BCOR internal tandem duplications in clear-cell sarcoma of kidney and primitive myxoid mesenchymal tumor of infancy (n=3).

Conclusions: Diagnostically relevant alterations were identified in over half of pediatric solid tumor patients evaluated. Gene fusions are particularly prevalent. These results support a role for sequencing that includes robust fusion assessment to inform diagnosis in patients with pediatric solid tumors.

Citation Format: Alanna J. Church, Laura B. Corson, Alma Imamovic-Tuco, Gianna R. Strand, Dierdre Reidy, Duong Doan, Robert S. Pinches, Mark A. Applebaum, Rochelle Bagatell, Brian D. Crompton, Steven G. DuBois, Julia L. Glade Bender, Theodore W. Laetsch, Lobin A. Lee, Neal I. Lindeman, Marian H. Harris, Margaret E. Macy, Luke Maese, Navin Pinto, Amit J. Sabnis, Eliezer M. Van Allen, Susan I. Vear, Daniel A. Weiser, Catherine M. Clinton, Katherine A. Janeway. Sequencing identifies diagnostically relevant alterations in pediatric solid tumor patients [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the AACR Special Conference on the Advances in Pediatric Cancer Research; 2019 Sep 17-20; Montreal, QC, Canada. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2020;80(14 Suppl):Abstract nr A59.

Abstract A28: Targeted sequencing in 388 patients with high-risk or recurrent/refractory pediatric extracranial solid malignancies: An interim report from the GAIN Consortium/iCat2 Study

Background: Gene variants with potential therapeutic significance have been reported in 30-60% of childhood malignancies. The 12-institution Genomic Assessment Informs Novel therapy (GAIN) consortium is conducting the individualized cancer therapy 2 (iCat2) study (NCT02520713) with the objective of evaluating the impact of tumor profiling on outcome. We provide an interim report on patients enrolled on the ongoing GAIN/iCat2 study.

Methods and Objectives: Patients are eligible if they have a high-risk, recurrent/refractory (RR), or difficult-to-diagnose extracranial solid tumor diagnosed at ≤30 years and adequate sample available for sequencing. A next-generation targeted panel assay is performed. Results are returned with a GAIN report containing clinical interpretation, including an individualized cancer therapy (iCat) recommendation if there is evidence supporting a link between an identified variant and response to molecularly targeted therapy. iCat recommendations are tiered from 1 to 5 based on the level of clinical and preclinical support, with tier 1 being the highest and tier 5 the lowest. Potential extraordinary responders are selected for further review based on having treatment duration of ≥1 year for chemotherapy or ≥4 months or a partial response for targeted therapy.

Results: 388 eligible patients were enrolled by 1/1/2019 with the most common diagnoses being osteosarcoma, Ewing sarcoma, and rhabdomyosarcoma. 366 patients (94%) have had at least one successful sequencing result, with 349 having molecular and GAIN reports suitable for inclusion in this analysis. 68% of patients (237/349) have received iCat recommendations, with 41% (143/349) having the highest tier of 1-2 and 27% (94/349) having a highest tier of 3-5. Common genes for which tier 1-2 iCat recommendations were made include TP53 (15%), SMARCB1 (4%), PIK3CA (3%), CDK4 (2%), and KRAS (2%). Common alterations for which tier 3-5 recommendations were made include EWSR1 fusions (12%), MYC/MYCN amplifications (8%), and CDKN2A deletions (7%). Of 170 RR patients with treatment follow-up data entered as of June 2019, 15% (25/170) have received matched targeted therapy. Six of these (24%) are considered extraordinary responders. Of note, extraordinary responses were also seen with some second-line chemotherapy and multitargeted kinase inhibitors.

Conclusions: The proportion of patients with clinically significant gene variants is higher in this study than in some previous reports. Providing an iCat recommendation for alterations in genes such as TP53 where evidence is mixed, increased availability of molecularly targeted therapy trials, and more evidence may all be responsible for this increased rate. Reassessment of iCat recommendation tiers based on current evidence is ongoing. Extraordinary responses occur in a subset of children with extracranial solid malignancies who receive matched targeted therapy. Study enrollment is ongoing with further assessments of the impact of tumor profiling on outcome planned.

Citation Format: Laura B. Corson, Alanna J. Church, Deirdre Reidy, Pei-Chi Kao, Wenjun Kang, Navin Pinto, Luke Maese, Theodore W. Laetsch, AeRang Kim, Susan I. Vear, Margaret E. Macy, Mark A. Applebaum, Lobin A. Lee, Duong Doan, R. Seth Pinches, Seong Choi, Suzanne J. Forrest, Catherine M. Clinton, Brian D. Crompton, Laura E. MacConaill, Samuel L. Volchenboum, Neal I. Lindeman, Steven G. DuBois, Wendy B. London, Katherine A. Janeway. Targeted sequencing in 388 patients with high-risk or recurrent/refractory pediatric extracranial solid malignancies: An interim report from the GAIN Consortium/iCat2 Study [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the AACR Special Conference on the Advances in Pediatric Cancer Research; 2019 Sep 17-20; Montreal, QC, Canada. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2020;80(14 Suppl):Abstract nr A28.

Genomic and Immunologic Characterization of INI1-Deficient Pediatric Cancers

PURPOSE

Several aggressive pediatric cancers harbor alterations in SMARCB1, including rhabdoid tumors, epithelioid sarcoma, and chordoma. As tumor profiling has become more routine in clinical care, we investigated the relationship between SMARCB1 genetic variants identified by next-generation sequencing (NGS) and INI1 protein expression. Therapeutic approaches for INI1-deficient tumors are limited. Early reports suggest a potential role for immune checkpoint inhibition in these patients. Thus, we also investigated PD-L1 and CD8 expression in INI1-negative pediatric brain and solid tumors.

EXPERIMENTAL DESIGN

We performed immunohistochemistry (IHC) for INI1 and immune markers (PD-L1, CD8, and CD163) and NGS on tumor samples from 43 pediatric patients who had tumors with INI1 loss on previous IHC or SMARCB1 genomic alterations on prior somatic sequencing.

RESULTS

SMARCB1 two-copy deletions and inactivating mutations on NGS were associated with loss of INI1 protein expression. Single-copy deletion of SMARCB1 was not predictive of INI1 loss in tumor histologies not known to be INI1-deficient. In the 27 cases with INI1 loss and successful tumor sequencing, 24 (89%) had a SMARCB1 alteration detected. In addition, 47% (14/30) of the patients with INI1-negative tumors had a tumor specimen that was PD-L1 positive and 60% (18/30) had positive or rare CD8 staining. We report on 3 patients with INI1-negative tumors with evidence of disease control on immune checkpoint inhibitors.

CONCLUSIONS

A significant proportion of the INI1-negative tumors express PD-L1, and PD-L1 positivity was associated with extracranial tumor site. These results suggest that clinical trials of immune checkpoint inhibitors are warranted in INI1-negative pediatric cancers.

A phase II study of larotrectinib for children with newly diagnosed solid tumors and relapsed acute leukemias harboring TRK fusions: Children’s Oncology Group study ADVL1823

TPS10560

Background: In children, fusions of the NTRK1/2/3 genes (TRK fusions) occur in soft tissue sarcomas, including infantile fibrosarcoma (IFS), congenital mesoblastic nephroma, high- and low-grade gliomas, secretory breast carcinoma, and papillary thyroid cancer. Rarely, TRK fusions also occur in Ph-like acute lymphoblastic leukemia and acute myeloid leukemia. Larotrectinib is a selective TRK inhibitor FDA-approved for the treatment of TRK fusion solid tumors in patients with no satisfactory alternative treatments or whose cancer has progressed following initial treatment. In children, larotrectinib demonstrated a 94% overall response rate (ORR) with a 12-month progression free survival rate of 75% (1). Methods: Patients <30 years with any newly diagnosed unresectable solid tumor or relapsed/refractory acute leukemia with TRK fusions are eligible. TRK fusions must be locally identified in a CLIA/CAP laboratory and are confirmed centrally using a targeted RNA sequencing panel. Patients with high-grade gliomas are excluded. Patients receive larotrectinib 100 mg/m2/dose BID (max of 100 mg/dose) continuously in 28-day cycles. Patients with solid tumors who achieve CR will discontinue larotrectinib at the completion of at least 12 total cycles of therapy and 6 cycles after achieving CR. Those whose tumors become surgically resectable may undergo on study resection and discontinue therapy if an R0/R1 (IFS) or R0 (other tumors) resection is obtained. All other patients will receive 26 cycles in the absence of unacceptable toxicity or progressive disease. The primary endpoint is the ORR to larotrectinib according to RECIST 1.1 in children with IFS. The study uses a Simon 2-stage minimax design, and the regimen will be considered of sufficient interest if 16 of 21 (76%) patients with IFS demonstrate response. Patients with other solid tumors and leukemias will be analyzed in separate cohorts as secondary objectives. Correlative studies include serial sampling of circulating tumor DNA and neurocognitive assessments. This is the first Children’s Oncology Group study to assign frontline therapy based on the presence of a molecular marker independent of histology, and the first clinical trial to evaluate larotrectinib for the treatment of leukemia. Enrollment began in October 2019 (NCT03834961). 1. Tilburg CMv, DuBois SG, Albert CM, et al: Larotrectinib efficacy and safety in pediatric TRK fusion cancer patients. Journal of Clinical Oncology 37:10010-10010, 2019 Clinical trial information: NCT03834961.

Recurrent and novel USP6 fusions in cranial fasciitis identified by targeted RNA sequencing

Cranial fasciitis is a benign myofibroproliferative lesion of the scalp and underlying bones typically occurring in the pediatric population. Histologically, it is characterized by loose fascicles of stellate cells in a fibromyxoid background, findings similar to those described in the closely related variant nodular fasciitis. Previously characterized as a reactive process, the identification of USP6 translocations in over 90% of nodular fasciitis cases prompted their reclassification as a clonal neoplastic process. Unlike nodular fasciitis, the molecular underpinnings of cranial fasciitis are less clear. While a subset of cranial fasciitis has been associated with Wnt/β-catenin pathway dysregulation, recent case reports suggest that this entity may also harbor USP6 fusions, a finding we sought to further investigate. We identified fifteen archival cases of cranial fasciitis, five females and ten males ranging in age from 3 months to 9 years (median 11 months), composed of formalin-fixed paraffin-embedded and fresh frozen tissues (11 and 4 cases respectively). Samples were evaluated on an RNA-based targeted sequencing panel targeting genes recurrently rearranged in neoplasia, including USP6. Five of fifteen cases (33%) were positive for USP6 rearrangements predicted to result in the fusion of the entire USP6 coding region to the promoter of the 5' partner, (three of which were novel):  two SERPINH1-USP6 (novel) and one each of COL3A1-USP6 (novel), SPARC-USP6, and MYH9-USP6. These results demonstrate the recurrent nature of USP6 rearrangements in cranial fasciitis, and highlight the success of targeted RNA sequencing in identifying known and novel fusion partners. The identification of USP6 promoter-swapping rearrangements is helpful in understanding the underlying biology of cranial fasciitis, and reinforces its biologic relationship to nodular fasciitis. Targeted RNA sequencing is a helpful tool in diagnosing this pseudosarcomatous lesion.

A Distinctive Genomic and Immunohistochemical Profile for NOTCH3 and PDGFRB in Myofibroma With Diagnostic and Therapeutic Implications

Introduction. Myofibromas are rare tumors of pericytic lineage, typically affecting children, and are sometimes aggressive. A subset of sporadic and familial myofibromas have activating variants in PDGFRB. The relationship of myofibroma and PDGFRB to the NOTCH pathway has not yet been described. Methods. Ten myofibroma cases were sequenced with a targeted panel of 447 genes, including copy number variation and selected fusions. Immunohistochemical analysis of total NOTCH3 and activated NOTCH3 was assessed for all 10 myofibroma cases, and a series of histologic mimics (n = 20). Results. Alterations identified by next-generation sequencing included PDGFRB sequence variants in 8/10 cases (80%), a NOTCH3 variant in 1/10 cases (10%), and a NOTCH2 variant in 1/10 cases (10%). All 10 cases also showed a pattern of low-amplitude (1.5- to 2-fold) copy number alterations including gains in PDGFRB and NOTCH3. Ten of 10 myofibromas (100%) showed cytoplasmic staining for total NOTCH3 and 9 of 10 cases (90%) showed nuclear staining for activated NOTCH3. Within the control cohort of histologic mimics, 3 of 3 nodular fasciitis cases (100%) were positive for activated and total NOTCH3, and the remaining 17 cases were negative for pan NOTCH3, while 3 of 3 desmoid-type fibromatosis cases (100%) showed patchy weak nuclear staining for activated NOTCH3. Discussion. Our findings suggest a common pathway of PDGFRB/NOTCH3 activation in myofibromas, even in cases that lack PDGFRB sequence variants. These results support the pericytic lineage of myofibroma. Identification of the characteristic genomic alterations or immunohistochemical staining pattern may facilitate a difficult pathologic diagnosis, and support the use of targeted treatments.

Abstract 3104: A high prevalence of chromosomal translocations as drivers in high-risk pediatric solid cancers

The GAIN iCat2 Project is a collaboration between Dana-Farber/Boston Children's Cancer and Blood Disorder Center and eleven pediatric oncology centers across the United States to sequence relapsed, metastatic, difficult-to-diagnose, and high-risk extracranial solid tumors from 825 patients. The goals are to gain a better understanding of the genomic events in pediatric cancers and determine the clinical impact of matched targeted therapy. Tumor samples are sequenced on one of four gene panels performed in CLIA certified, CAP accredited laboratories, most often utilizing OncoPanel at the Center for Advanced Molecular Diagnostics, Brigham Women’s Hospital. This panel assesses SNVs and CNVs in 447 cancer-associated genes and interrogates intronic regions of 60 genes frequently involved in oncogenic translocation. For undifferentiated sarcomas and tumors in which oncogenic drivers are not identified by the gene panel, whole exome sequencing or RNA sequencing for fusion detection may be done. Interpretation of genomic results, including potential implications for diagnosis and hereditary risks, as well as assessment of possible matched targeted therapies and suitable trials are summarized in a report to the primary oncology provider.

An interim analysis of tumors from the first 275 patients enrolled who have OncoPanel results was performed to assess genomic alterations most prevalent in this group of pediatric cancers. 50% (137/275) have structural alterations in their tumors with over half of these (74/137) harboring an oncogenic fusion that is the main, or only identified, driver of the cancer. These include fusions pathognomonic for diseases such as Ewing sarcoma, alveolar rhabdomyosarcoma, synovial sarcoma, desmoplastic small round cell tumors, mesenchymal chondrosarcoma, low grade fibromyxoid sarcoma, and NUT midline carcinoma. Other cases showed recurrent disruption of key tumor suppressors, such as TP53 intron 1 translocations in osteosarcoma. Lastly, more generalized, key, cancer-driving fusions were seen with rearrangements involving BRAF, NOTCH, and NTRK. In addition to aiding in diagnosis, identification of fusions has led to targeted therapy recommendations for many patients. SNVs and CNVs also helped clarify diagnoses, especially in the case of DICER1 and SMARCB1 alterations, and identified potential targeted therapies to consider for relapsed patients. Although patient recruitment is ongoing, this study shows promise for advancing our understanding and treatment of pediatric cancers and highlights the critical importance of incorporating techniques for fusion detection in tumor profiling.

Citation Format: Laura B. Corson, Alma Imamovic-Tuco, Gianna R. Strand, Deirdre Reidy, Duong Doan, Mark A. Applebaum, Rochelle Bagatell, Brian D. Crompton, Steven G. DuBois, Julia L. Glade Bender, AeRang Kim, Theodore W. Laetsch, Lobin A. Lee, Neal I. Lindeman, Laura E. MacConaill, Margaret E. Macy, Luke Maese, Seth Pinches, Navin Pinto, Amit J. Sabnis, Eliezer M. Van Allen, Susan I. Vear, Daniel A. Weiser, Catherine M. Clinton, Katherine A. Janeway, Alanna J. Church. A high prevalence of chromosomal translocations as drivers in high-risk pediatric solid cancers [abstract]. In: Proceedings of the American Association for Cancer Research Annual Meeting 2019; 2019 Mar 29-Apr 3; Atlanta, GA. Philadelphia (PA): AACR; Cancer Res 2019;79(13 Suppl):Abstract nr 3104.

Renal medullary carcinomas depend upon SMARCB1 loss and are sensitive to proteasome inhibition

Renal medullary carcinoma (RMC) is a rare and deadly kidney cancer in patients of African descent with sickle cell trait. We have developed faithful patient-derived RMC models and using whole-genome sequencing, we identified loss-of-function intronic fusion events in one SMARCB1 allele with concurrent loss of the other allele. Biochemical and functional characterization of these models revealed that RMC requires the loss of SMARCB1 for survival. Through integration of RNAi and CRISPR-Cas9 loss-of-function genetic screens and a small-molecule screen, we found that the ubiquitin-proteasome system (UPS) was essential in RMC. Inhibition of the UPS caused a G2/M arrest due to constitutive accumulation of cyclin B1. These observations extend across cancers that harbor SMARCB1 loss, which also require expression of the E2 ubiquitin-conjugating enzyme, UBE2C. Our studies identify a synthetic lethal relationship between SMARCB1-deficient cancers and reliance on the UPS which provides the foundation for a mechanism-informed clinical trial with proteasome inhibitors.

Renal medullary carcinoma (RMC for short) is a rare type of kidney cancer that affects teenagers and young adults. These patients are usually of African descent and carry one of the two genetic changes that cause sickle cell anemia. RMC is an aggressive disease without effective treatments and patients survive, on average, for only six to eight months after their diagnosis.

Recent genetic studies found that most RMC cells have mutations that prevent them from producing a protein called SMARCB1. SMARCB1 normally acts as a so-called tumor suppressor, preventing cells from becoming cancerous. However, it was not clear whether RMCs always have to lose SMARCB1 if they are to survive and grow.

Often, diseases are studied using laboratory-grown cells and tissues that have certain features of the disease. No such models had been created for RMC, which has slowed efforts to understand how the disease develops and find new treatments for it. Hong et al. therefore worked with patients to develop new lines of cells that can be used to study RMC in the laboratory. These RMC cells started dying when they were given copies of the SMARCB1 gene, which supports the theory that RMCs have to lose SMARCB1 in order to grow.

Hong et al. then used a set of genetic reagents that can suppress or delete genes that are targeted by drugs, and followed this by testing a range of drugs on the RMC cells. Drugs and genetic reagents that reduced the activity of the proteasome – the structure inside cells that gets rid of old or unwanted proteins – caused the RMC cells to die. These proteasome inhibitor drugs also killed other kinds of cancer cells with SMARCB1 mutations.

Proteasome inhibitors are already used to treat different types of cancer. Potentially, a clinical trial could be run to see if they will treat patients whose cancers lack SMARCB1. Further work is also needed to determine the exact link between SMARCB1 and the proteasome.