Engineering aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases for use in synthetic biology

Within the broad field of synthetic biology, genetic code expansion (GCE) techniques enable creation of proteins with an expanded set of amino acids. This may be invaluable for applications in therapeutics, bioremediation, and biocatalysis. Central to GCE are aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs) as they link a non-canonical amino acid (ncAA) to their cognate tRNA, allowing ncAA incorporation into proteins on the ribosome. The ncAA-acylating aaRSs and their tRNAs should not cross-react with 20 natural aaRSs and tRNAs in the host, i.e., they need to function as an orthogonal translating system. All current orthogonal aaRS•tRNA pairs have been engineered from naturally occurring molecules to change the aaRS's amino acid specificity or assign the tRNA to a liberated codon of choice. Here we discuss the importance of orthogonality in GCE, laboratory techniques employed to create designer aaRSs and tRNAs, and provide an overview of orthogonal aaRS•tRNA pairs for GCE purposes.

Exploiting evolutionary trade-offs for posttreatment management of drug-resistant populations

Antibiotic resistance frequently evolves through fitness trade-offs in which the genetic alterations that confer resistance to a drug can also cause growth defects in resistant cells. Here, through experimental evolution in a microfluidics-based turbidostat, we demonstrate that antibiotic-resistant cells can be efficiently inhibited by amplifying the fitness costs associated with drug-resistance evolution. Using tavaborole-resistant Escherichia coli as a model, we show that genetic mutations in leucyl-tRNA synthetase (that underlie tavaborole resistance) make resistant cells intolerant to norvaline, a chemical analog of leucine that is mistakenly used by tavaborole-resistant cells for protein synthesis. We then show that tavaborole-sensitive cells quickly outcompete tavaborole-resistant cells in the presence of norvaline due to the amplified cost of the molecular defect of tavaborole resistance. This finding illustrates that understanding molecular mechanisms of drug resistance allows us to effectively amplify even small evolutionary vulnerabilities of resistant cells to potentially enhance or enable adaptive therapies by accelerating posttreatment competition between resistant and susceptible cells.

Hijacking Translation Initiation for Synthetic Biology

Genetic code expansion (GCE) has revolutionized the field of protein chemistry. Over the past several decades more than 150 different noncanonical amino acids (ncAAs) have been co-translationally installed into proteins within various host organisms. The vast majority of these ncAAs have been incorporated between the start and stop codons within an open reading frame. This requires that the ncAA be able to form a peptide bond at the α-amine, limiting the types of molecules that can be genetically encoded. In contrast, the α-amine of the initiating amino acid is not required for peptide bond formation. Therefore, including the initiator position in GCE allows for co-translational insertion of more diverse molecules that are modified, or completely lacking an α-amine. This review explores various methods which have been used to initiate protein synthesis with diverse molecules both in vitro and in vivo.

Archaeal Ribosomal Proteins Possess Nuclear Localization Signal-Type Motifs: Implications for the Origin of the Cell Nucleus

Eukaryotic cells are divided into the nucleus and the cytosol, and, to enter the nucleus, proteins typically possess short signal sequences, known as nuclear localization signals (NLSs). Although NLSs have long been considered as features unique to eukaryotic proteins, we show here that similar or identical protein segments are present in ribosomal proteins from the Archaea. Specifically, the ribosomal proteins uL3, uL15, uL18, and uS12 possess NLS-type motifs that are conserved across all major branches of the Archaea, including the most ancient groups Microarchaeota and Diapherotrites, pointing to the ancient origin of NLS-type motifs in the Archaea. Furthermore, by using fluorescence microscopy, we show that the archaeal NLS-type motifs can functionally substitute eukaryotic NLSs and direct the transport of ribosomal proteins into the nuclei of human cells. Collectively, these findings illustrate that the origin of NLSs preceded the origin of the cell nucleus, suggesting that the initial function of NLSs was not related to intracellular trafficking, but possibly was to improve recognition of nucleic acids by cellular proteins. Overall, our study reveals rare evolutionary intermediates among archaeal cells that can help elucidate the sequence of events that led to the origin of the eukaryotic cell.

Initiation of Protein Synthesis with Non-Canonical Amino Acids In Vivo

By transplanting identity elements into E. coli tRNA^fMet , we have engineered an orthogonal initiator tRNA (itRNA^Ty2 ) that is a substrate for Methanocaldococcus jannaschii TyrRS. We demonstrate that itRNA^Ty2 can initiate translation in vivo with aromatic non-canonical amino acids (ncAAs) bearing diverse sidechains. Although the initial system suffered from low yields, deleting redundant copies of tRNA^fMet from the genome afforded an E. coli strain in which the efficiency of non-canonical initiation equals elongation. With this improved system we produced a protein containing two distinct ncAAs at the first and second positions, an initial step towards producing completely unnatural polypeptides in vivo. This work provides a valuable tool to synthetic biology and demonstrates remarkable versatility of the E. coli translational machinery for initiation with ncAAs in vivo.

The Nbp35/ApbC homolog acts as a nonessential [4Fe-4S] transfer protein in methanogenic archaea

The nucleotide binding protein 35 (Nbp35)/cytosolic Fe-S cluster deficient 1 (Cfd1)/alternative pyrimidine biosynthetic protein C (ApbC) protein homologs have been identified in all three domains of life. In eukaryotes, the Nbp35/Cfd1 heterocomplex is an essential Fe-S cluster assembly scaffold required for the maturation of Fe-S proteins in the cytosol and nucleus, whereas the bacterial ApbC is an Fe-S cluster transfer protein only involved in the maturation of a specific target protein. Here, we show that the Nbp35/ApbC homolog MMP0704 purified from its native archaeal host Methanococcus maripaludis contains a [4Fe-4S] cluster that can be transferred to a [4Fe-4S] apoprotein. Deletion of mmp0704 from M. maripaludis does not cause growth deficiency under our tested conditions. Our data indicate that Nbp35/ApbC is a nonessential [4Fe-4S] cluster transfer protein in methanogenic archaea.

Translation of Diverse Aramid- and 1,3-Dicarbonyl-peptides by Wild Type Ribosomes in Vitro

Here, we report that wild type Escherichia coli ribosomes accept and elongate precharged initiator tRNAs acylated with multiple benzoic acids, including aramid precursors, as well as malonyl (1,3-dicarbonyl) substrates to generate a diverse set of aramid-peptide and polyketide-peptide hybrid molecules. This work expands the scope of ribozyme- and ribosome-catalyzed chemical transformations, provides a starting point for in vivo translation engineering efforts, and offers an alternative strategy for the biosynthesis of polyketide-peptide natural products.

A cysteinyl-tRNA synthetase variant confers resistance against selenite toxicity and decreases selenocysteine misincorporation

Selenocysteine (Sec) is the 21st genetically encoded amino acid in organisms across all domains of life. Although structurally similar to cysteine (Cys), the Sec selenol group has unique properties that are attractive for protein engineering and biotechnology applications. Production of designer proteins with Sec (selenoproteins) at desired positions is now possible with engineered translation systems in Escherichia coli However, obtaining pure selenoproteins at high yields is limited by the accumulation of free Sec in cells, causing undesired incorporation of Sec at Cys codons due to the inability of cysteinyl-tRNA synthetase (CysRS) to discriminate against Sec. Sec misincorporation is toxic to cells and causes protein aggregation in yeast. To overcome this limitation, here we investigated a CysRS from the selenium accumulator plant Astragalus bisulcatus that is reported to reject Sec in vitro Sequence analysis revealed a rare His → Asn variation adjacent to the CysRS catalytic pocket. Introducing this variation into E. coli and Saccharomyces cerevisiae CysRS increased resistance to the toxic effects of selenite and selenomethionine (SeMet), respectively. Although the CysRS variant could still use Sec as a substrate in vitro, we observed a reduction in the frequency of Sec misincorporation at Cys codons in vivo We surmise that the His → Asn variation can be introduced into any CysRS to provide a fitness advantage for strains burdened by Sec misincorporation and selenium toxicity. Our results also support the notion that the CysRS variant provides higher specificity for Cys as a mechanism for plants to grow in selenium-rich soils.

Plasticity and Constraints of tRNA Aminoacylation Define Directed Evolution of Aminoacyl-tRNA Synthetases

Genetic incorporation of noncanonical amino acids (ncAAs) has become a powerful tool to enhance existing functions or introduce new ones into proteins through expanded chemistry. This technology relies on the process of nonsense suppression, which is made possible by directing aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs) to attach an ncAA onto a cognate suppressor tRNA. However, different mechanisms govern aaRS specificity toward its natural amino acid (AA) substrate and hinder the engineering of aaRSs for applications beyond the incorporation of a single l-α-AA. Directed evolution of aaRSs therefore faces two interlinked challenges: the removal of the affinity for cognate AA and improvement of ncAA acylation. Here we review aspects of AA recognition that directly influence the feasibility and success of aaRS engineering toward d- and β-AAs incorporation into proteins in vivo. Emerging directed evolution methods are described and evaluated on the basis of aaRS active site plasticity and its inherent constraints.

Engineered Aminoacyl-tRNA Synthetases with Improved Selectivity toward Noncanonical Amino Acids

A wide range of noncanonical amino acids (ncAAs) can be incorporated into proteins in living cells by using engineered aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase/tRNA pairs. However, most engineered tRNA synthetases are polyspecific; that is, they can recognize multiple rather than one ncAA. Polyspecificity of engineered tRNA synthetases imposes a limit to the use of genetic code expansion because it prevents specific incorporation of a desired ncAA when multiple ncAAs are present in the growth media. In this study, we employed directed evolution to improve substrate selectivity of polyspecific tRNA synthetases by developing substrate-selective readouts for flow-cytometry-based screening with the simultaneous presence of multiple ncAAs. We applied this method to improve the selectivity of two commonly used tRNA synthetases, p-cyano-l-phenylalanyl aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase ( pCNFRS) and N^ε-acetyl-lysyl aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase (AcKRS), with broad specificity. Evolved pCNFRS and AcKRS variants exhibit significantly improved selectivity for ncAAs p-azido-l-phenylalanine ( pAzF) and m-iodo-l-phenylalanine ( mIF), respectively. To demonstrate the utility of our approach, we used the newly evolved tRNA synthetase variant to produce highly pure proteins containing the ncAA mIF, in the presence of multiple ncAAs present in the growth media. In summary, our new approach opens up a new avenue for engineering the next generation of tRNA synthetases with improved selectivity toward a desired ncAA.

Mechanistic insights into the slow peptide bond formation with D-amino acids in the ribosomal active site

During protein synthesis, ribosomes discriminate chirality of amino acids and prevent incorporation of D-amino acids into nascent proteins by slowing down the rate of peptide bond formation. Despite this phenomenon being known for nearly forty years, no structures have ever been reported that would explain the poor reactivity of D-amino acids. Here we report a 3.7Å-resolution crystal structure of a bacterial ribosome in complex with a D-aminoacyl-tRNA analog bound to the A site. Although at this resolution we could not observe individual chemical groups, we could unambiguously define the positions of the D-amino acid side chain and the amino group based on chemical restraints. The structure reveals that similarly to L-amino acids, the D-amino acid binds the ribosome by inserting its side chain into the ribosomal A-site cleft. This binding mode does not allow optimal nucleophilic attack of the peptidyl-tRNA by the reactive α-amino group of a D-amino acid. Also, our structure suggests that the D-amino acid cannot participate in hydrogen-bonding with the P-site tRNA that is required for the efficient proton transfer during peptide bond formation. Overall, our work provides the first mechanistic insight into the ancient mechanism that helps living cells ensure the stereochemistry of protein synthesis.

Muller's Ratchet and Ribosome Degeneration in the Obligate Intracellular Parasites Microsporidia

Microsporidia are fungi-like parasites that have the smallest known eukaryotic genome, and for that reason they are used as a model to study the phenomenon of genome decay in parasitic forms of life. Similar to other intracellular parasites that reproduce asexually in an environment with alleviated natural selection, Microsporidia experience continuous genome decay that is driven by Muller's ratchet-an evolutionary process of irreversible accumulation of deleterious mutations that lead to gene loss and the miniaturization of cellular components. Particularly, Microsporidia have remarkably small ribosomes in which the rRNA is reduced to the minimal enzymatic core. In this study, we analyzed microsporidian ribosomes to study an apparent impact of Muller's ratchet on structure of RNA and protein molecules in parasitic forms of life. Through mass spectrometry of microsporidian proteome and analysis of microsporidian genomes, we found that massive rRNA reduction in microsporidian ribosomes appears to annihilate the binding sites for ribosomal proteins eL8, eL27, and eS31, suggesting that these proteins are no longer bound to the ribosome in microsporidian species. We then provided an evidence that protein eS31 is retained in Microsporidia due to its non-ribosomal function in ubiquitin biogenesis. Our study illustrates that, while Microsporidia carry the same set of ribosomal proteins as non-parasitic eukaryotes, some ribosomal proteins are no longer participating in protein synthesis in Microsporidia and they are preserved from genome decay by having extra-ribosomal functions. More generally, our study shows that many components of parasitic cells, which are identified by automated annotation of pathogenic genomes, may lack part of their biological functions due to continuous genome decay.

Loss of protein synthesis quality control in host-restricted organisms

Intracellular organisms, such as obligate parasites and endosymbionts, typically possess small genomes due to continuous genome decay caused by an environment with alleviated natural selection. Previously, a few species with highly reduced genomes, including the intracellular pathogens Mycoplasma and Microsporidia, have been shown to carry degenerated editing domains in aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases. These defects in the protein synthesis machinery cause inaccurate translation of the genetic code, resulting in significant statistical errors in protein sequences that are thought to help parasites to escape immune response of a host. In this study we analyzed 10,423 complete bacterial genomes to assess conservation of the editing domains in tRNA synthetases, including LeuRS, IleRS, ValRS, ThrRS, AlaRS, and PheRS. We found that, while the editing domains remain intact in free-living species, they are degenerated in the overwhelming majority of host-restricted bacteria. Our work illustrates that massive genome erosion triggered by an intracellular lifestyle eradicates one of the most fundamental components of a living cell: the system responsible for proofreading of amino acid selection for protein synthesis. This finding suggests that inaccurate translation of the genetic code might be a general phenomenon among intercellular organisms with reduced genomes.

Designing seryl-tRNA synthetase for improved serylation of selenocysteine tRNAs

Selenocysteine (Sec) lacks a cognate aminoacyl-tRNA synthetase. Instead, seryl-tRNA synthetase (SerRS) produces Ser-tRNASec , which is subsequently converted by selenocysteine synthase to Sec-tRNASec . Escherichia coli SerRS serylates tRNASec poorly; this may hinder efficient production of designer selenoproteins in vivo. Guided by structural modelling and selection for chloramphenicol acetyltransferase activity, we evolved three SerRS variants capable of improved Ser-tRNASec synthesis. They display 10-, 8-, and 4-fold increased kcat /KM values compared to wild-type SerRS using synthetic tRNASec species as substrates. The enzyme variants also facilitate in vivo read-through of a UAG codon in the position of the critical serine146 of chloramphenicol acetyltransferase. These results indicate that the naturally evolved SerRS is capable of further evolution for increased recognition of a specific tRNA isoacceptor.

Upgrading aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases for genetic code expansion

Synthesis of proteins with non-canonical amino acids via genetic code expansion is at the forefront of synthetic biology. Progress in this field has enabled site-specific incorporation of over 200 chemically and structurally diverse amino acids into proteins in an increasing number of organisms. This has been facilitated by our ability to repurpose aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases to attach non-canonical amino acids to engineered tRNAs. Current efforts in the field focus on overcoming existing limitations to the simultaneous incorporation of multiple non-canonical amino acids or amino acids that differ from the l-α-amino acid structure (e.g. d-amino acid or β-amino acid). Here, we summarize the progress and challenges in developing more selective and efficient aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases for genetic code expansion.

Lysine Acetylation Regulates Alanyl-tRNA Synthetase Activity in Escherichia coli

Protein lysine acetylation is a widely conserved posttranslational modification in all three domains of life. Lysine acetylation frequently occurs in aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs) from many organisms. In this study, we determined the impact of the naturally occurring acetylation at lysine-73 (K73) in Escherichia coli class II alanyl-tRNA synthetase (AlaRS) on its alanylation activity. We prepared an AlaRS K73Ac variant in which N^ε-acetyl-l-lysine was incorporated at position 73 using an expanded genetic code system in E. coli. The AlaRS K73Ac variant showed low activity compared to the AlaRS wild type (WT). Nicotinamide treatment or CobB-deletion in an E. coli led to elevated acetylation levels of AlaRS K73Ac and strongly reduced alanylation activities. We assumed that alanylation by AlaRS is affected by K73 acetylation, and the modification is sensitive to CobB deacetylase in vivo. We also showed that E. coli expresses two CobB isoforms (CobB-L and CobB-S) in vivo. CobB-S displayed the deacetylase activity of the AlaRS K73Ac variant in vitro. Our results imply a potential regulatory role for lysine acetylation in controlling the activity of aaRSs and protein synthesis.

Revising the Structural Diversity of Ribosomal Proteins Across the Three Domains of Life

Ribosomal proteins are indispensable components of a living cell, and yet their structures are remarkably diverse in different species. Here we use manually curated structural alignments to provide a comprehensive catalog of structural variations in homologous ribosomal proteins from bacteria, archaea, eukaryotes, and eukaryotic organelles. By resolving numerous ambiguities and errors of automated structural and sequence alignments, we uncover a whole new class of structural variations that reside within seemingly conserved segments of ribosomal proteins. We then illustrate that these variations reflect an apparent adaptation of ribosomal proteins to the specific environments and lifestyles of living species. Finally, we show that most of these structural variations reside within nonglobular extensions of ribosomal proteins-protein segments that are thought to promote ribosome biogenesis by stabilizing the proper folding of ribosomal RNA. We show that although the extensions are thought to be the most ancient peptides on our planet, they are in fact the most rapidly evolving and most structurally and functionally diverse segments of ribosomal proteins. Overall, our work illustrates that, despite being long considered as slowly evolving and highly conserved, ribosomal proteins are more complex and more specialized than is generally recognized.

Recoding of the selenocysteine UGA codon by cysteine in the presence of a non-canonical tRNACys and elongation factor SelB

In many organisms, the UGA stop codon is recoded to insert selenocysteine (Sec) into proteins. Sec incorporation in bacteria is directed by an mRNA element, known as the Sec-insertion sequence (SECIS), located downstream of the Sec codon. Unlike other aminoacyl-tRNAs, Sec-tRNASec is delivered to the ribosome by a dedicated elongation factor, SelB. We recently identified a series of tRNASec-like tRNA genes distributed across Bacteria that also encode a canonical tRNASec. These tRNAs contain sequence elements generally recognized by cysteinyl-tRNA synthetase (CysRS). While some of these tRNAs contain a UCA Sec anticodon, most have a GCA Cys anticodon. tRNASec with GCA anticodons are known to recode UGA codons. Here we investigate the clostridial Desulfotomaculum nigrificans tRNASec-like tRNACys, and show that this tRNA is acylated by CysRS, recognized by SelB, and capable of UGA recoding with Cys in Escherichia coli. We named this non-canonical group of tRNACys as 'tRNAReC' (Recoding with Cys). We performed a comprehensive survey of tRNAReC genes to establish their phylogenetic distribution, and found that, in a particular lineage of clostridial Pelotomaculum, the Cys identity elements of tRNAReC had mutated. This novel tRNA, which contains a UCA anticodon, is capable of Sec incorporation in E. coli, albeit with lower efficiency relative to Pelotomaculum tRNASec. We renamed this unusual tRNASec derived from tRNAReC as 'tRNAReU' (Recoding with Sec). Together, our results suggest that tRNAReC and tRNAReU may serve as safeguards in the production of selenoproteins and - to our knowledge - they provide the first example of programmed codon-anticodon mispairing in bacteria.

[A facile method for producing selenocysteine-containing proteins]

Ein einfacher Ansatz nutzt einen erweiterten genetischen Code von Escherichia coli zur Biosynthese von Selenoproteinen mit zahlreichen Sec-Resten. Kürzlich wurden so genannte allo-tRNAs entdeckt. Diese verfügen über eine ungewöhnliche Struktur, sind genauso effiziente Serinakzeptoren wie die normale tRNASer aus E. coli und werden von der Aeromonas-salmonicida-Selenocysteinsynthase (SelA) von Ser-allo-tRNA zu Sec-allo-tRNA umgesetzt. Anschließend ermöglicht es Sec-allo-tRNA, fünf UAG-Stop-Codons auf der fdhF-mRNA für E.-coli-Formatdehydrogenase H als Sec zu translatieren und katalytisch aktive E.-coli-Formatdehydrogenase mit fünf Sec-Resten in E. coli zu produzieren. Weiterhin konnte gezeigt werden, dass sich in E. coli durch Kombination genetischer Varianten von allo-tRNA und SelA mit einem modifizierten Selenstoffwechsel das humane Selenoenzym GPx1 mit über 80% Sec-Einbaurate rekombinant produzieren lässt. Beide Beispiele belegen den Wert von allo-tRNAUTu als molekulare Plattform zur Entwicklung neuartiger Selenoproteine.

A Facile Method for Producing Selenocysteine-Containing Proteins

Selenocysteine (Sec, U) confers new chemical properties on proteins. Improved tools are thus required that enable Sec insertion into any desired position of a protein. We report a facile method for synthesizing selenoproteins with multiple Sec residues by expanding the genetic code of Escherichia coli. We recently discovered allo-tRNAs, tRNA species with unusual structure, that are as efficient serine acceptors as E. coli tRNA^Ser . Ser-allo-tRNA was converted into Sec-allo-tRNA by Aeromonas salmonicida selenocysteine synthase (SelA). Sec-allo-tRNA variants were able to read through five UAG codons in the fdhF mRNA coding for E. coli formate dehydrogenase H, and produced active FDH_H with five Sec residues in E. coli. Engineering of the E. coli selenium metabolism along with mutational changes in allo-tRNA and SelA improved the yield and purity of recombinant human glutathione peroxidase 1 (to over 80 %). Thus, our allo-tRNA^UTu system offers a new selenoprotein engineering platform.

Challenges of site-specific selenocysteine incorporation into proteins by Escherichia coli

Selenocysteine (Sec), a rare genetically encoded amino acid with unusual chemical properties, is of great interest for protein engineering. Sec is synthesized on its cognate tRNA (tRNA^Sec) by the concerted action of several enzymes. While all other aminoacyl-tRNAs are delivered to the ribosome by the elongation factor Tu (EF-Tu), Sec-tRNA^Sec requires a dedicated factor, SelB. Incorporation of Sec into protein requires recoding of the stop codon UGA aided by a specific mRNA structure, the SECIS element. This unusual biogenesis restricts the use of Sec in recombinant proteins, limiting our ability to study the properties of selenoproteins. Several methods are currently available for the synthesis selenoproteins. Here we focus on strategies for in vivo Sec insertion at any position(s) within a recombinant protein in a SECIS-independent manner: (i) engineering of tRNA^Sec for use by EF-Tu without the SECIS requirement, and (ii) design of a SECIS-independent SelB route.

Drugging tRNA aminoacylation

Inhibition of tRNA aminoacylation has proven to be an effective antimicrobial strategy, impeding an essential step of protein synthesis. Mupirocin, the well-known selective inhibitor of bacterial isoleucyl-tRNA synthetase, is one of three aminoacylation inhibitors now approved for human or animal use. However, design of novel aminoacylation inhibitors is complicated by the steadfast requirement to avoid off-target inhibition of protein synthesis in human cells. Here we review available data regarding known aminoacylation inhibitors as well as key amino-acid residues in aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases (aaRSs) and nucleotides in tRNA that determine the specificity and strength of the aaRS-tRNA interaction. Unlike most ligand-protein interactions, the aaRS-tRNA recognition interaction represents coevolution of both the tRNA and aaRS structures to conserve the specificity of aminoacylation. This property means that many determinants of tRNA recognition in pathogens have diverged from those of humans-a phenomenon that provides a valuable source of data for antimicrobial drug development.