Switch from conventional to distributed kinetics in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle

Below 195 K, the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle could not be adequately described with exponential kinetics [Dioumaev, A. K., and Lanyi, J. K. (2007) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 104, 9621-9626] but required distributed kinetics, previously found in hemoglobin and myoglobin at temperatures below the vitrification point of the surrounding solvent. The aim of this study is to determine which factors cause the switch from this low-temperature regime to the conventional kinetics observed at ambient temperature. The photocycle was monitored by time-resolved FTIR between 180 and 280 K, using the D96N mutant. Depending on the temperature, decay and temporal redistribution of two or three intermediates (L, M, and N) were observed. Above approximately 245 K, an abrupt change in the kinetic behavior of the photocycle takes place. It does not affect the intermediates present but greatly accelerates their decay. Below approximately 240 K, a kinetic pattern with partial decay that cannot be explained by conventional kinetics, but suggesting distributed kinetics, was dominant, while above approximately 250 K, there were no significant deviations from exponential behavior. The approximately 245 K critical point is >/=10 K below the freezing point of interbilayer water, and we were unable to correlate it with any FTIR-detectable transition of the lipids. Therefore, we attribute the change from distributed to conventional kinetics to a thermodynamic phase transition in the protein. Most probably, it is related to the freezing and thawing of internal fluctuations of the protein, known as the dynamic phase transition, although in bacteriorhodopsin the latter is usually believed to take place at least 15 K below the observed critical temperature of approximately 245 K.

Xanthorhodopsin: a bacteriorhodopsin-like proton pump with a carotenoid antenna

Xanthorhodopsin is a light-driven proton pump like bacteriorhodopsin, but made more effective for collecting light by its second chromophore, salinixanthin, a carotenoid. Action spectra for transport and fluorescence of the retinal upon excitation of the carotenoid indicate that the carotenoid functions as an antenna to the retinal. The calculated center-to-center distance and angle of the transition moments of the two chromophores are 11 A and 56 degrees , respectively. As expected from their proximity, the carotenoid and the retinal closely interact: tight binding of the carotenoid, as indicated by its sharpened vibration bands and intense induced circular dichroism in the visible, is removed by hydrolysis of the retinal Schiff base, and restored upon reconstitution with retinal. This antenna system, simpler than photosynthetic complexes, is well-suited to study features of excited-state energy migration.

Chromophore interaction in xanthorhodopsin--retinal dependence of salinixanthin binding

Xanthorhodopsin is a light-driven proton pump in the extremely halophilic bacterium Salinibacter ruber. Its unique feature is that besides retinal it has a carotenoid, salinixanthin, with a light harvesting function. Tight and specific binding of the carotenoid antenna is controlled by binding of the retinal. Addition of all-trans retinal to xanthorhodopsin bleached with hydroxylamine restores not only the retinal chromophore absorption band, but causes sharpening of the salinixanthin bands reflecting its rigid binding by the protein. In this report we examine the correlation of the changes in the two chromophores during bleaching and reconstitution with native all-trans retinal, artificial retinal analogs and retinol. Bleaching and reconstitution both appear to be multistage processes. The carotenoid absorption changes during bleaching occurred not only upon hydrolysis of the Schiff base but continued while the retinal was leaving its binding site. In the case of reconstitution, the 13-desmethyl analog formed the protonated Schiff base slower than retinal, and provided the opportunity to observe changes in carotenoid binding at various stages. The characteristic sharpening of the carotenoid bands, indicative of its reduced conformational heterogeneity in the binding site, occurs when the retinal occupies the binding site but the covalent bond to Lys-240 via a Schiff base is not yet formed. This is confirmed by the results for retinol reconstitution, where the Schiff base does not form but the carotenoid exhibits its characteristic spectral change from the binding.

Xanthorhodopsin: Proton pump with a carotenoid antenna

Retinal proteins function as photoreceptors and ion pumps. Xanthorhodopsin of Salinibacter ruber is a recent addition to this diverse family. Its novel and distinctive feature is a second chromophore, a carotenoid, which serves as light-harvesting antenna. Here we discuss the properties of this carotenoid/retinal complex most relevant to its function (such as the specific binding site controlled by the retinal) and its relationship to other retinal proteins (bacteriorhodopsin, archaerhodopsin, proteorhodopsin and retinal photoreceptors of archaea and eukaryotes). Antenna addition to a retinal protein has not been observed among the archaea and emerged in bacteria apparently in response to environmental conditions where light-harvesting becomes a limiting factor in retinal protein functioning.

A priori resolution of the intermediate spectra in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle: the time evolution of the L spectrum revealed

Resolution of the spectra of the intermediates in the photocycle of wild-type bacteriorhodopsin (BR) was achieved by singular value decomposition with exponential-fit-assisted self-modeling (SVD-EFASM) treatment of multichannel difference spectra measured at 5 degrees C during the course of the photocycle. New is the finding that two spectrally distinct L intermediates, L(1) and L(2), form sequentially. Our conclusion is that the photocycle is more complex than most published schemes. The dissection of the spectrally different L forms eliminates stoichiometric discrepancies usually appearing as systematically varying total intermediate concentrations before the onset of BR recovery. In addition, our analysis reveals that the red tails in the spectra of K and L(1) are more substantial than those of L(2) and BR. We suggest that these subtle differences in the shapes of the spectra reflect torsional and/or environmental differences in the retinyl chromophore.

Withdrawn: Role of Lipids in Dynamic Phase Transition: FTIR Spectroscopy of Retinal-Protein Containing Membranes

Withdrawn.

Studies of the Bacteriorhodopsin Photocycle without the Use of Light: Clues to Proton Transfer Coupled Reactions

In the photochemical cycle of bacteriorhodopsin, the light-driven proton pump of halobacteria, only the first step, the isomerization of the all-trans retinal to 13-cis, is dependent on illumination. Because the steps that accomplish the translocation of a proton during the ensuing reaction sequence of intermediate states are thermal reactions, they have direct analogies with such steps in other ion pumps. In a surprisingly large number of cases, the reactions of the photocycle could be studied without using light. This review recounts experiments of this kind, and what they contribute to understanding the transport mechanism of this pump, and perhaps indirectly other ion pumps as well.

Bacteriorhodopsin photocycle at cryogenic temperatures reveals distributed barriers of conformational substates

The time course of thermal reactions after illumination of 100% humidified bacteriorhodopsin films was followed with FTIR spectroscopy between 125 and 195 K. We monitored the conversion of the initial photoproduct, K, to the next, L intermediate, and a shunt reaction of the L state directly back to the initial BR state. Both reactions can be described by either multiexponential kinetics, which would lead to apparent end-state mixtures that contain increasing amounts of the product, i.e., L or BR, with increasing temperature, or distributed kinetics. Conventional kinetic schemes that could account for the partial conversion require reversible reactions, branching, or parallel cycles. These possibilities were tested by producing K or L and monitoring their interconversion at a single temperature and by shifting the temperature upward or downward after an initial incubation and after their redistribution. The results are inconsistent with any conventional scheme. Instead, we attribute the partial conversions to the other alternative, distributed kinetics, observed previously in myoglobin, which arise from an ensemble of frozen conformational substates at the cryogenic temperatures. In this case, the time course of the reactions reflects the progressive depletion of distinct microscopic substates in the order of their increasing activation barriers, with a distribution width for K to L reaction of approximately 7 kJ/mol.

pH-dependent transitions in xanthorhodopsin

Xanthorhodopsin (XR), the light-driven proton pump of the halophilic eubacterium Salinibacter ruber, exhibits substantial homology to bacteriorhodopsin (BR) of archaea and proteorhodopsin (PR) of marine bacteria, but unlike them contains a light-harvesting carotenoid antenna, salinixanthin, as well as retinal. We report here the pH-dependent properties of XR. The pKa of the retinal Schiff base is as high as in BR, i.e. > or =12.4. Deprotonation of the Schiff base and the ensuing alkaline denaturation cause large changes in the absorption bands of the carotenoid antenna, which lose intensity and become broader, making the spectrum similar to that of salinixanthin not bound to XR. A small redshift of the retinal chromophore band and increase of its extinction, as well as the pH-dependent amplitude of the M intermediate indicate that in detergent-solubilized XR the pKa of the Schiff base counterion and proton acceptor is about 6 (compared to 2.6 in BR, and 7.5 in PR). The protonation of the counterion is accompanied by a small blueshift of the carotenoid absorption bands. The pigment is stable in the dark upon acidification to pH 2. At pH < 2 a transition to a blueshifted species absorbing around 440 nm occurs, accompanied by loss of resolution of the carotenoid absorption bands. At pH < 3 illumination of XR with continuous light causes accumulation of long-lived photoproduct(s) with an absorption maximum around 400 nm. The photocycle of XR was examined between pH 4 and 10 in solubilized samples. The pH dependence of recovery of the initial state slows at both acid and alkaline pH, with pKas of 6.0 and 9.3. The decrease in the rates with pKa 6.0 is apparently caused by protonation of the counterion and proton acceptor, and that at high pH reflects the pKa of the internal proton donor, Glu94, at the times in the photocycle when this group equilibrates with the bulk.

Electron paramagnetic resonance study of structural changes in the O photointermediate of bacteriorhodopsin

The structural changes of bacteriorhodopsin during its photochemical cycle, as revealed by crystal structures of trapped intermediates, have provided insights to the proton translocation mechanism. Because accumulation of the last photointermediate, O, appears to be hindered by lattice forces in the crystals, the only information about the structure of this state is from suggested analogies with the determined structures of the non-illuminated D85S mutant and wild-type bacteriorhodopsin at low pH. We used electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy of site-directed spin labels at the extracellular protein surface in membranes to test these models. Spin-spin dipolar interactions in the authentic O state compared to the non-illuminated state revealed that the distance between helices C and F increases by ca 4 Angstroms, there is no distance change between helices D and F, and the distance between helix D and helix B of the adjacent monomer increases. Further, the mobility changes of single labels indicate that helices E and F move outward from the proton channel at the center of the protein, and helix D tilts inward. The overall pattern of movements suggests that the model at acid pH is a better representation of the O state than D85S. However, the mobility analysis of spin-labels on the B-C interhelical loop indicates that the antiparallel beta-sheet maintains its ordered secondary structure in O, instead of the predicted disorder in the two structural models. During decay of the O state, the last step of the photocycle, a proton is transferred from Asp85 to proton release complex in the extracellular proton channel. The structural changes in O suggest the need of large conformational changes to drive the Arg82 side-chain back to its initial orientation towards Asp85, and to rearrange the numerous water molecules in this region in order to conduct the proton away from Asp85.

Functions of carotenoids in xanthorhodopsin and archaerhodopsin, from action spectra of photoinhibition of cell respiration

The recent discovery of a carotenoid light-harvesting antenna in xanthorhodopsin, a retinal-based proton pump in Salinibacter ruber, made use of photoinhibition of respiration in whole cells to obtain action spectra [Balashov et al. Science 309, (2005) 2061-2064]. Here we provide further details of this phenomenon, and compare action spectra in three different systems where carotenoids have different functions or efficiencies of light-harvesting. The kinetics of light-induced inhibition of respiration in Salinibacter ruber was determined with single short flashes, and the photochemical cross section of the photoreaction was estimated. These measurements confirm that the xanthorhodopsin complex includes no more than a few, and most likely only one, carotenoid molecule, which is far less than the core complex antenna of photosynthetic bacteria. Although the total cross-section of light absorption in the purple bacterium Rhodospirillum rubrum greatly exceeds that in Salinibacter, the cross-sections are roughly equivalent in the shared wavelength range. We show further that despite interaction of bacterioruberin with archaerhodopsin, another retinal-based proton pump, there is no significant energy transfer from this carotenoid. This emphasizes the uniqueness of the salinixanthin-retinal interaction in xanthorhodopsin, and indicates that bacterioruberin in Halorubrum species has a structural or photoprotective rather than energetic role.

Structural changes in the L photointermediate of bacteriorhodopsin

The L to M reaction of the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle includes the crucial proton transfer from the retinal Schiff base to Asp85. In spite of the importance of the L state in deciding central issues of the transport mechanism in this pump, the serious disagreements among the three published crystallographic structures of L have remained unresolved. Here, we report on the X-ray diffraction structure of the L state, to 1.53-1.73 A resolutions, from replicate data sets collected from six independent crystals. Unlike earlier studies, the partial occupancy refinement uses diffraction intensities from the same crystals before and after the illumination to produce the trapped L state. The high reproducibility of inter-atomic distances, and bond angles and torsions of the retinal, lends credibility to the structural model. The photoisomerized 13-cis retinal in L is twisted at the C(13)=C(14) and C(15)=NZ double-bonds, and the Schiff base does not lose its connection to Wat402 and, therefore, to the proton acceptor Asp85. The protonation of Asp85 by the Schiff base in the L-->M reaction is likely to occur, therefore, via Wat402. It is evident from the structure of the L state that various conformational changes involving hydrogen-bonding residues and bound water molecules begin to propagate from the retinal to the protein at this stage already, and in both extracellular and cytoplasmic directions. Their rationales in the transport can be deduced from the way their amplitudes increase in the intermediates that follow L in the reaction cycle, and from the proton transfer reactions with which they are associated.

Propagating structural perturbation inside bacteriorhodopsin: crystal structures of the M state and the D96A and T46V mutants

The X-ray diffraction structure of the non-illuminated D96A bacteriorhodopsin mutant reveals structural changes as far away as 15 A from residue 96, at the retinal, Trp-182, Ala-215, and waters 501, 402, and 401. The Asp-to-Ala side-chain replacement breaks its hydrogen bond with Thr-46, and the resulting separation of the cytoplasmic ends of helices B and C is communicated to the retinal region through a chain of covalent and hydrogen bonds. The unexpected long-range consequences of the D96A mutation include breaking the hydrogen bond between O of Ala-215 and water 501 and the formation of a new hydrogen bond between water molecules 401 and 402 in the extracellular region. Because in the T46V mutant a new water molecule appears at Asp-96 and its hydrogen-bond to Ile-45 replaces Thr-46 as its link to helix B, the separation of helices B and C is smaller than that in D96A, and there are no atomic displacements elsewhere in the protein. Propagation of conformational changes along the chain between the retinal and Thr-46 had been observed earlier in the crystal structures of the D96N and E204Q mutants but in the trapped M state. Consistent with the perturbation of the retinal region in D96A, little change of the Thr-46 region occurs between the non-illuminated and M states of this mutant. It appears that a local perturbation can propagate along a track in both directions between the retinal and the Asp-96/Thr-46 pair, either from photoisomerization of the retinal in the wild-type protein in one case or from the D96A mutation in the other.

Induced chirality of the light-harvesting carotenoid salinixanthin and its interaction with the retinal of xanthorhodopsin

In xanthorhodopsin, a retinal protein-carotenoid complex of Salinibacter ruber, the carotenoid salinixanthin functions as a light-harvesting antenna in supplying additional excitation energy for retinal isomerization and proton transport. Another retinal protein, archaerhodopsin, has been shown to contain a carotenoid, bacterioruberin, but without an antenna function. We report here that the binding site confers a chiral geometry on salinixanthin in xanthorhodopsin and confirm that the same is true for bacterioruberin in archaerhodopsin. Cell membranes containing these rhodopsins exhibit CD spectra with sharp positive bands in the visible region where the carotenoids absorb, and in the case of xanthorhodopsin a negative band at 536 nm, as well as bands in the UV region. The carotenoid in ethanol has very weak optical activity in the visible region of the spectrum. Denaturation of the opsin upon deprotonation of the Schiff base at pH 12.5 eliminates the induced CD bands in both proteins. In one of these proteins, but not in the other, the carotenoid binding site depends entirely on the retinal. Hydrolysis of the retinal Schiff base of xanthorhodopsin with hydroxylamine eliminates the induced CD bands of salinixanthin. In contrast, hydrolysis of the Schiff base in archaerhodopsin does not abolish the CD bands of bacterioruberin. Thus, consistent with its antenna function, the carotenoid binding site interacts closely with the retinal only in xanthorhodopsin, and this interaction is the major source of the CD bands. In this protein, protonation of the counterion with a decrease in pH from 8 to 5 causes significant changes in the CD spectrum. The observed spectral features suggest that binding of salinixanthin in xanthorhodopsin involves the cyclohexenone ring of the carotenoid and its conformational heterogeneity is restricted.

Proton transfers in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle

The steps in the mechanism of proton transport in bacteriorhodopsin include examples for most kinds of proton transfer reactions that might occur in a transmembrane pump: proton transfer via a bridging water molecule, coupled protonation/deprotonation of two buried groups separated by a considerable distance, long-range proton migration over a hydrogen-bonded aqueous chain, and capture as well as release of protons at the membrane-water interface. The conceptual and technical advantages of this system have allowed close examination of many of these model reactions, some at an atomic level.

Xanthorhodopsin: a proton pump with a light-harvesting carotenoid antenna

Energy transfer from light-harvesting carotenoids to chlorophyll is common in photosynthesis, but such antenna pigments have not been observed in retinal-based ion pumps and photoreceptors. Here we describe xanthorhodopsin, a proton-pumping retinal protein/carotenoid complex in the eubacterium Salinibacter ruber. The wavelength dependence of the rate of pumping and difference absorption spectra measured under a variety of conditions indicate that this protein contains two chromophores, retinal and the carotenoid salinixanthin, in a molar ratio of about 1:1. The two chromophores interact strongly, and light energy absorbed by the carotenoid is transferred to the retinal with a quantum efficiency of approximately 40%. The antenna carotenoid extends the wavelength range of the collection of light for uphill transmembrane proton transport.

Formation of a Long-Lived Photoproduct with a Deprotonated Schiff Base in Proteorhodopsin, and Its Enhancement by Mutation of Asp227

Proteorhodopsin, a retinal protein of marine proteobacteria similar to bacteriorhodopsin of the archaea, is a light-driven proton pump. Absorption of a light quantum initiates a reaction cycle (turnover time of ca. 50 ms), which includes photoisomerization of the retinal from the all-trans to the 13-cis form and transient deprotonation of the retinal Schiff base, followed by recovery of the initial state. We report here that in addition to this fast cyclic conversion, illumination at high pH results in accumulation of a long-lived photoproduct absorbing at 362 nm. This photoconversion is much more efficient in the D227N mutant in which the anionic Asp227, which together with Asp97 constitutes the Schiff base counterion, is replaced with a neutral residue. Upon illumination at pH 8.5, most of the D227N pigment is converted to the 362 nm species, with a quantum efficiency of ca. 0.2. The pK(a) for this transition in the wild type is 9.6, but decreased to 7.5 after mutation of Asp227. The short wavelength of the absorption maximum of the photoproduct indicates that it has a deprotonated Schiff base. In the dark, this photoproduct is converted back to the initial pigment with a time constant of 30 min (in D227N, at pH 8.5), but it can be reconverted more rapidly by illumination with near-UV light. Experiments with "locked" retinal analogues which selectively exclude rotation around either the C9=C10, C11=C12, or C13=C14 bond show that formation of the 362 nm species involves isomerization around the C13=C14 bond. In agreement with this, retinal extraction indicates that the 362 nm photoproduct is 13-cis whereas the initial state is predominantly all-trans. A rapid shift of the pH from 8.5 to 4 greatly accelerates thermal reconversion of the 362 nm species to the initial pigment, suggesting that its recovery involving the thermal isomerization of the chromophore is controlled by ionizable residues, primarily the Schiff base and Asp97. The transformation to the long-lived 362 nm photoproduct is apparently a side reaction of the photocycle, a response to high pH, caused by alteration of the normal reprotonation and reisomerization pathway of the Schiff base.

Proton binding within a membrane protein by a protonated water cluster

Proton transfer is crucial for many enzyme reactions. Here, we show that in addition to protonatable amino acid side chains, water networks could constitute proton-binding sites in proteins. A broad IR continuum absorbance change during the proton pumping photocycle of bacteriorhodopsin (bR) indicates most likely deprotonation of a protonated water cluster at the proton release site close to the surface. We investigate the influence of several mutations on the proton release network and the continuum change, to gain information about the location and extent of the protonated water network and to reveal the participating residues necessary for its stabilization. We identify a protonated water cluster consisting in total of one proton and about five water molecules surrounded by six side chains and three backbone groups (Tyr-57, Arg-82, Tyr-83, Glu-204, Glu-194, Ser-193, Pro-77, Tyr-79, and Thr-205). The observed perturbation of proton release by many single-residue mutations is now explained by the influence of numerous side chains on the protonated H bonded network. In situ hydrogen/deuterium exchange Fourier transform IR measurements of the bR ground state, show that the proton of the release group becomes localized on Glu-204 and Asp-204 in the ground state of the mutants E194D and E204D, respectively, even though it is delocalized in the ground state of wild-type bR. Thus, the release mechanism switches between the wild-type and mutated proteins from a delocalized to a localized proton-binding site.

What is the real crystallographic structure of the L photointermediate of bacteriorhodopsin?

In the last few years, three laboratories have reported three entirely different crystallographic models for the L photointermediate of bacteriorhodopsin. All are from X-ray diffraction of illuminated crystals that contain L in photostationary states created at similar cryogenic temperatures. This article compares the models and their implications, the crystallographic statistics and the methods used to derive them, as well as their agreement with non-crystallographic information.

The nitrate transporting photochemical reaction cycle of the pharaonis halorhodopsin

Time-resolved spectroscopy, absorption kinetic and electric signal measurement techniques were used to study the nitrate transporting photocycle of the pharaonis halorhodopsin. The spectral titration reveals two nitrate-binding constants, assigned to two independent binding sites. The high-affinity binding site (K(a) = 11 mM) contributes to the appearance of the nitrate transporting photocycle, whereas the low-affinity constant (having a K(a) of approximately 7 M) slows the last decay process in the photocycle. Although the spectra of the intermediates are not the same as those found in the chloride transporting photocycle, the sequence of the intermediates and the energy diagrams are similar. The differences in spectra and energy levels can be attributed to the difference in the size of the transported chloride or nitrate. Electric signal measurements show that a charge is transferred across the membrane during the photocycle, as expected. A new observation is an apparent release and rebinding of a small fraction of the retinal, inside the retinal pocket, during the photocycle. The release occurs during the N-to-O transition, whereas the rebinding happens in several seconds, well after the other steps of the photocycle are over.

Local-global conformational coupling in a heptahelical membrane protein: transport mechanism from crystal structures of the nine states in the bacteriorhodopsin photocycle

Proton pumps utilize a chemical or photochemical reaction to create pH and electrical gradients between the interior and the exterior of cells and organelles that energize ATP synthesis and the accumulation and extrusion of solutes and ions. G-protein coupled receptors bind agonists and assume signaling states that communicate with the coupled transducers. How these two kinds of proteins convert chemical potential to a proton transmembrane electrochemical potential or a signal are the great questions in structural membrane biology, and they may have a common answer. Bacteriorhodopsin, a particularly simple integral membrane protein, functions as a proton pump but has a heptahelical structure like membrane receptors. Crystallographic structures are now available for all of the intermediates of the bacteriorhodopsin transport cycle, and they describe the proton translocation mechanism, step by step and in atomic detail. The results show how local conformational changes propagate upon the gradual relaxation of the initially twisted photoisomerized retinal toward the two membrane surfaces. Such local-global conformational coupling between the ligand-binding site and the distant regions of the protein may be the shared mechanism of ion pumps and G-protein related receptors.

Bacteriorhodopsin

Fourier transform infrared and Raman spectroscopy, solid-state NMR, and X-ray crystallography have contributed detailed information about the structural changes in the proton transport cycle of the light-driven pump, bacteriorhodopsin. The results over the past few years add up to a step-by-step description of the configurational changes of the photoisomerized retinal, how these changes result in internal proton transfers and the release of a proton to the extracellular surface and uptake on the other side, as well as the conservation and transformation of excess free energy during the cycle.

Selectivity of Retinal Photoisomerization in Proteorhodopsin Is Controlled by Aspartic Acid 227

Similarly to bacteriorhodopsin, proteorhodopsin that normally contains all-trans and 13-cis retinal is transformed at low pH to a species containing 9-cis retinal under continuous illumination at lambda > 530 nm. This species, absorbing around 430 nm, returns thermally in tens of minutes to initial pigment and can be reconverted also with blue-light illumination. The yield of the 9-cis species is negligibly small at neutral pH but increases manyfold (>100) at acid pH with a pK(a) of 2.6. This indicates that protonation of acidic group(s) alters the photoreaction pathway that leads normally to all-trans --> 13-cis isomerization. In the D97N mutant, in which one of the two acidic groups in the vicinity of the retinal Schiff base is not ionizable, the yield of 9-cis species at low pH shows a pH dependence similar to that in the wild-type but with a somewhat increased pK(a) of 3.3. In contrast to this relatively minor effect, replacement of the other acidic group, Asp227, with Asn results in a remarkable, more than 50-fold, increase in the yield of the light-induced formation of 9-cis species in the pH range 4-6. It appears that protonation of Asp227 at low pH is what causes the dramatic increase in the yield of the 9-cis species in wild-type proteorhodopsin. We conclude that the photoisomerization pathways in proteorhodopsin to 13-cis or 9-cis photoproducts are controlled by the charge state of Asp227.