An RNA pyrophosphohydrolase triggers 5'-exonucleolytic degradation of mRNA in Bacillus subtilis

In Escherichia coli, RNA degradation often begins with conversion of the 5'-terminal triphosphate to a monophosphate, creating a better substrate for internal cleavage by RNase E. Remarkably, no homolog of this key endonuclease is present in many bacterial species, such as Bacillus subtilis and various pathogens. Here, we report that the degradation of primary transcripts in B. subtilis can nevertheless be triggered by an analogous process to generate a short-lived, monophosphorylated intermediate. Like its E. coli counterpart, the B. subtilis RNA pyrophosphohydrolase that catalyzes this event is a Nudix protein that prefers unpaired 5' ends. However, in B. subtilis, this modification exposes transcripts to rapid 5' exonucleolytic degradation by RNase J, which is absent in E. coli but present in most bacteria lacking RNase E. This pathway, which closely resembles the mechanism by which deadenylated mRNA is degraded in eukaryotic cells, explains the stabilizing influence of 5'-terminal stem-loops in such bacteria.

Ribonuclease J: how to lead a double life

New structures of RNase J reported by Dorléans et al. and Newman et al. in this issue of Structure suggest how an enzyme whose identical subunits each contain a single, buried active site can function as both a 5’ exonuclease and an endonuclease.

All things must pass: contrasts and commonalities in eukaryotic and bacterial mRNA decay

Despite its universal importance for controlling gene expression, mRNA degradation was initially thought to occur by disparate mechanisms in eukaryotes and bacteria. This conclusion was based on differences in the structures used by these organisms to protect mRNA termini and in the RNases and modifying enzymes originally implicated in mRNA decay. Subsequent discoveries have identified several striking parallels between the cellular factors and molecular events that govern mRNA degradation in these two kingdoms of life. Nevertheless, some key distinctions remain, the most fundamental of which may be related to the different mechanisms by which eukaryotes and bacteria control translation initiation.

A role for huntington disease protein in dendritic RNA granules

Regulated transport and local translation of mRNA in neurons are critical for modulating synaptic strength, maintaining proper neural circuitry, and establishing long term memory. Neuronal RNA granules are ribonucleoprotein particles that serve to transport mRNA along microtubules and control local protein synthesis in response to synaptic activity. Studies suggest that neuronal RNA granules share similar structures and functions with somatic P-bodies. We recently reported that the Huntington disease protein huntingtin (Htt) associates with Argonaute (Ago) and localizes to cytoplasmic P-bodies, which serve as sites of mRNA storage, degradation, and small RNA-mediated gene silencing. Here we report that wild-type Htt associates with Ago2 and components of neuronal granules and co-traffics with mRNA in dendrites. Htt was found to co-localize with RNA containing the 3'-untranslated region sequence of known dendritically targeted mRNAs. Knockdown of Htt in neurons caused altered localization of mRNA. When tethered to a reporter construct, Htt down-regulated reporter gene expression in a manner dependent on Ago2, suggesting that Htt may function to repress translation of mRNAs during transport in neuronal granules.

RNase E autoregulates its synthesis in Escherichia coli by binding directly to a stem-loop in the rne 5' untranslated region

RNase E autoregulates its production in Escherichia coli by governing the decay rate of rne (RNase E) mRNA. It does so by a mechanism that is dependent in part on hp2, a cis-acting stem-loop within the rne 5' untranslated region. In principle, hp2 could function either as a cleavage site for RNase E or as a binding site for that protein or an ancillary factor. Here we show that the effector region at the top of hp2 is cleaved poorly by RNase E yet binds the catalytic domain of that ribonuclease with a sequence specificity reflecting its efficacy in feedback regulation. These findings suggest that hp2 controls RNase E synthesis by binding to RNase E and expediting cleavage elsewhere within the rne transcript.

A new window onto translational repression by bacterial sRNAs

In this issue of Molecular Cell, Bouvier et al. (2008) show that bacterial sRNAs can repress mRNA translation not only by binding to the Shine-Dalgarno element but also by base pairing anywhere within the first few codons of the protein-coding region.

Importance of translation and nonnucleolytic ago proteins for on-target RNA interference

In animals, both siRNAs and miRNAs are thought to diminish protein synthesis from transcripts that are perfectly complementary by directing endonucleolytic cleavage where they anneal, thereby triggering rapid degradation of the entire message [1-4]. By contrast, partially complementary messages are downregulated by a combination of translational repression and accelerated decay caused by rapid poly(A) tail removal [3, 5-12]. Here we present evidence that translational repression can also make a substantial contribution to the downregulation of fully complementary messages by RNA interference. Unlike mRNA destabilization, this inhibitory effect on translation is greater for perfectly complementary elements located in the 3' untranslated region rather than in the protein-coding region. In addition to known disparities in their endonucleolytic activity [13, 14], the four Ago proteins with which siRNAs associate in humans differ significantly in their capacity to direct translational repression. As a result, the relative effect of siRNA on targets that are fully versus partially complementary is influenced by the comparative abundance of the three nonnucleolytic Ago proteins, causing this on-target/off-target ratio to vary in a cell-type-dependent manner because of the dissimilar tissue distribution of these proteins. These findings have important implications for the efficacy and specificity of RNA interference.

Let me count the ways: mechanisms of gene regulation by miRNAs and siRNAs

The downregulation of gene expression by miRNAs and siRNAs is a complex process involving both translational repression and accelerated mRNA turnover, each of which appears to occur by multiple mechanisms. Moreover, under certain conditions, miRNAs are also capable of activating translation. A variety of cellular proteins have been implicated in these regulatory mechanisms, yet their exact roles remain largely unresolved.

The bacterial enzyme RppH triggers messenger RNA degradation by 5' pyrophosphate removal

The long-standing assumption that messenger RNA (mRNA) degradation in Escherichia coli begins with endonucleolytic cleavage has been challenged by the recent discovery that RNA decay can be triggered by a prior non-nucleolytic event that marks transcripts for rapid turnover: the rate-determining conversion of the 5' terminus from a triphosphate to a monophosphate. This modification creates better substrates for the endonuclease RNase E, whose cleavage activity at internal sites is greatly enhanced when the RNA 5' end is monophosphorylated. Moreover, it suggests an explanation for the influence of 5' termini on the endonucleolytic cleavage of primary transcripts, which are triphosphorylated. However, no enzyme capable of removing pyrophosphate from RNA 5' ends has been identified in any bacterial species. Here we show that the E. coli protein RppH (formerly NudH/YgdP) is the RNA pyrophosphohydrolase that initiates mRNA decay by this 5'-end-dependent pathway. In vitro, RppH efficiently removes pyrophosphate from the 5' end of triphosphorylated RNA, irrespective of the identity of the 5'-terminal nucleotide. In vivo, it accelerates the degradation of hundreds of E. coli transcripts by converting their triphosphorylated 5' ends to a more labile monophosphorylated state that can stimulate subsequent ribonuclease cleavage. That the action of the pyrophosphohydrolase is impeded when the 5' end is structurally sequestered by a stem-loop helps to explain the stabilizing influence of 5'-terminal base pairing on mRNA lifetimes. Together, these findings suggest a possible basis for the effect of RppH and its orthologues on the invasiveness of bacterial pathogens. Interestingly, this master regulator of 5'-end-dependent mRNA degradation in E. coli not only catalyses a process functionally reminiscent of eukaryotic mRNA decapping but also bears an evolutionary relationship to the eukaryotic decapping enzyme Dcp2.

PABLO analysis of RNA: 5'-phosphorylation state and 5'-end mapping

Recent studies have revealed that 5'-end-dependent RNA degradation in prokaryotes is triggered by pyrophosphate removal from the 5'-terminus to generate a monophosphorylated intermediate that is readily degraded. This chapter describes how to examine the 5'-phosphorylation state of any specific bacterial RNA by PABLO analysis. The method is based on the ability of monophosphorylated, but not triphosphorylated, RNA 5'-ends to undergo splinted ligation to a DNA oligonucleotide when juxtaposed by base pairing to a bridging oligonucleotide. PABLO analysis not only makes it possible to quantify the proportion of a particular RNA that is monophosphorylated in bacterial cells but also provides a more reliable method than primer extension for high-resolution mapping of RNA 5'-termini.

Examining the influence of microRNAs on translation efficiency and on mRNA deadenylation and decay

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) utilize multiple posttranscriptional mechanisms to downregulate gene expression in metazoan organisms. These include translation repression and accelerated mRNA decay, the latter being triggered either by deadenylation or, less frequently, by endonucleolytic cleavage, as governed by the degree of complementarity of the targeted message. This chapter describes methods for examining the effect of miRNAs on the translation and turnover of complementary mRNAs in cultured mammalian cells. Among these are procedures for quantifying their influence on the cytoplasmic concentration and translation efficiency of luciferase reporter mRNAs, for monitoring their impact on the deadenylation and decay of beta-globin reporter mRNAs, and for detecting miRNA-directed internal mRNA cleavage.

Initiation of RNA decay in Escherichia coli by 5' pyrophosphate removal

The common belief that endonucleolytic cleavage is the initial, rate-determining step of mRNA decay in Escherichia coli fails to explain the influence of 5' termini on the half-lives of primary transcripts. We have re-examined the initial events of RNA degradation in that organism by devising an assay to probe the 5' phosphorylation state of RNA and by employing a self-cleaving hammerhead ribozyme to investigate the degradative consequences of an unphosphorylated 5' end. These studies have identified a previously unrecognized prior step in decay that triggers subsequent internal cleavage by the endonuclease RNase E and thereby governs RNA longevity: the rate-determining conversion of a triphosphorylated to a monophosphorylated 5' terminus. Our findings redefine the role of RNase E in RNA degradation and explain how unpaired 5'-terminal nucleotides can facilitate access to internal cleavage sites within primary transcripts. Moreover, these results reveal a striking parallel between the mechanisms of mRNA decay in prokaryotic and eukaryotic organisms.

MicroRNAs direct rapid deadenylation of mRNA

MicroRNAs (miRNAs) are ubiquitous regulators of eukaryotic gene expression. In addition to repressing translation, miRNAs can down-regulate the concentration of mRNAs that contain elements to which they are imperfectly complementary. Using miR-125b and let-7 as representative miRNAs, we show that in mammalian cells this reduction in message abundance is a consequence of accelerated deadenylation, which leads to rapid mRNA decay. The ability of miRNAs to expedite poly(A) removal does not result from decreased translation; nor does translational repression by miRNAs require a poly(A) tail, a 3' histone stem-loop being an effective substitute. These findings suggest that miRNAs use two distinct posttranscriptional mechanisms to down-regulate gene expression.

Lost in translation: the influence of ribosomes on bacterial mRNA decay

The lifetimes of bacterial mRNAs are strongly affected by their association with ribosomes. Events occurring at any stage during translation, including ribosome binding, polypeptide elongation, or translation termination, can influence the susceptibility of mRNA to ribonuclease attack. Ribosomes usually act as protective barriers that impede mRNA cleavage, but in some instances they can instead trigger the decay of the mRNA to which they are bound or send a signal that leads to widespread mRNA destabilization within a cell. The influence of translation on mRNA decay provides a quality-control mechanism for minimizing the use of poorly or improperly translated mRNAs as templates for the production of abnormal proteins that might be toxic to bacteria.

Micro-RNA regulation of the mammalian lin-28 gene during neuronal differentiation of embryonal carcinoma cells

Vertebrate genomes each encode hundreds of micro-RNAs (miRNAs), yet for few of these miRNAs is there empirical evidence as to which mRNA(s) they regulate. Here we report the identification of human lin-28 mRNA as a regulatory target of human miR-125b and its homolog miR-125a. Studies of miR-125b function in mouse P19 embryonal carcinoma cells induced to develop into neurons suggest a role for this regulatory miRNA in mammalian neuronal differentiation, since its increased concentration in these cells contributes to lin-28 downregulation. Within the lin-28 3' untranslated region (UTR) are two conserved miRNA responsive elements (miREs) that mediate repression by miR-125b and miR-125a. Simultaneous deletion of both miREs renders the lin-28 3' UTR almost completely insensitive to these miRNAs, indicating that these two miREs are the principal elements in the lin-28 3' UTR that respond to miR-125. At the 3' end of each element is an adenosine residue that makes a significant contribution to function irrespective of its complementarity to the 5'-terminal nucleotide of miR-125. By contrast to most earlier reports of gene repression by other miRNAs that are imperfectly complementary to their targets, lin-28 downregulation by miR-125 involves reductions in both translational efficiency and mRNA abundance. The decrease in the mRNA concentration is achieved by a posttranscriptional mechanism that is independent of the inhibitory effect on translation.

Catalytic activation of multimeric RNase E and RNase G by 5'-monophosphorylated RNA

RNase E is an endonuclease that plays a central role in RNA processing and degradation in Escherichia coli. Like its E. coli homolog RNase G, RNase E shows a marked preference for cleaving RNAs that bear a monophosphate, rather than a triphosphate or hydroxyl, at the 5' end. To investigate the mechanism by which 5'-terminal phosphorylation can influence distant cleavage events, we have developed fluorogenic RNA substrates that allow the activity of RNase E and RNase G to be quantified much more accurately and easily than before. Kinetic analysis of the cleavage of these substrates by RNase E and RNase G has revealed that 5' monophosphorylation accelerates the reaction not by improving substrate binding, but rather by enhancing the catalytic potency of these ribonucleases. Furthermore, the presence of a 5' monophosphate can increase the specificity of cleavage site selection within an RNA. Although monomeric forms of RNase E and RNase G can cut RNA, the ability of these enzymes to discriminate between RNA substrates on the basis of their 5' phosphorylation state requires the formation of protein multimers. Among the molecular mechanisms that could account for these properties are those in which 5'-end binding by one enzyme subunit induces a protein structural change that accelerates RNA cleavage by another subunit.

The function of RNase G in Escherichia coli is constrained by its amino and carboxyl termini

RNase G is a homologue of the essential Escherichia coli ribonuclease RNase E. Whereas RNase E plays a key role in the degradation of mRNA and the processing of tRNA and rRNA in E. coli, the biological functions of RNase G appear more limited. We report here that this difference in function is not merely a consequence of the significantly lower cellular concentration of RNase G, but also reflects differences in the intrinsic properties of these ribonucleases, as overproducing wild-type RNase G at a level up to 20 times the usual cellular concentration of RNase E cannot normally compensate for the absence of RNase E in E. coli. Instead, RNase G can sustain significant growth of RNase E-deficient E. coli cells only when it bears an unnatural extension at its amino terminus (e.g. MRKGINM) or carboxyl terminus (e.g. GHHHHHH). These extensions presumably enable RNase G to cleave critically important cellular RNAs whose efficient processing or degradation ordinarily requires RNase E. That extending the amino terminus of RNase G restores growth to E. coli cells lacking RNase E without detectably improving tRNA processing suggests that RNase E is not essential for tRNA production and is required for cell growth because it plays an indispensable role in the maturation or decay of essential E. coli RNAs other than tRNA.

Two distinct regions on the surface of an RNA-binding domain are crucial for RNase E function

Despite its importance for RNA processing and degradation in Escherichia coli, little is known about the structure of RNase E or its mechanism of action. We have modelled the three-dimensional structure of an essential amino-terminal domain of RNase E on the basis of its sequence homology to the S1 family of RNA-binding domains. Each of the five surface-exposed aromatic residues and most of the 14 basic residues of this RNase E domain were replaced with alanine to determine their importance for RNase E function. All the surface residues essential for cell growth and feedback regulation of RNase E synthesis mapped to one end of the domain. In vitro assays indicate that these essential residues fall into two functionally distinct groups that form discrete clusters on opposite faces of the S1 domain. One group, comprising Phe-57, Phe-67 and Lys-112 [corrected], is of general importance for the ribonuclease activity of RNase E, whereas the other group, comprising Lys-37 and Tyr-60, is entirely dispensable for catalytic activity in vitro. The side-chains of two residues previously identified as sites of temperature-sensitive mutations lie buried directly beneath the surface region defined by Phe-57, Phe-67 and Lys-112 [corrected], which probably enhances RNase E activity by making a crucial contribution to the binding of substrate RNAs. In contrast to the S1 domain, an arginine-rich RNA-binding domain in the carboxyl half of RNase E appears to have a more peripheral role in RNase E function, as it is not required for feedback regulation, cell growth or ribonuclease activity.

Critical features of a conserved RNA stem-loop important for feedback regulation of RNase E synthesis

RNase E is an important regulatory enzyme that governs the principal pathway for mRNA degradation in Escherichia coli. This endonuclease controls its own synthesis via a feedback mechanism in which the longevity of rne (RNase E) mRNA is modulated by a cis-acting sensory element that responds to changes in cellular RNase E activity. Previous research has shown that this element is an RNA stem-loop (hp2) within the 5'-untranslated region of the rne transcript. Here we report studies involving mutational analysis and phylogenetic comparison that have identified the features of rne hp2 important for its function. These comprise an internal loop flanked on one side by a 2-bp stem and a hairpin loop and on the other side by a longer stem whose sequence is inconsequential. A search of bacterial genome sequences suggests that regulation by an hp2-like element may be a unique evolutionary adaptation of the rne transcript that is not shared by other mRNAs.

Comparative analysis of the plant mRNA-destabilizing element, DST, in mammalian and tobacco cells

The labile SAUR transcripts from higher plants contain a conserved DST sequence in their 3'-untranslated regions. Two copies of a DST sequence from soybean are sufficient to destabilize reporter transcripts in cultured tobacco cells whereas variants bearing mutations in the conserved ATAGAT or GTA regions are inactive. To investigate the potential for conserved recognition components in mammalian and plant cells, we examined the function of this instability determinant in mouse NIH3T3 fibroblasts and tobacco BY2 cells. In fibroblasts, a tetrameric DST element from soybean accelerated deadenylation and decay of a reporter transcript. However, a version mutated in the ATAGAT region was equally effective in this regard, and a tetrameric DST element from Arabidopsis was inactive. In contrast, the soybean DST element was more active as an mRNA instability element than the mutant version and the Arabidopsis element, when tested as tetramers in tobacco cells. Hence, the plant DST element is not recognized in animal cells with the same sequence requirements as in plant cells. Therefore, its mode of recognition appears to be plant-specific.

Consequences of RNase E scarcity in Escherichia coli

The endoribonuclease RNase E plays an important role in RNA processing and degradation in Escherichia coli. The construction of an E. coli strain in which the cellular concentration of RNase E can be precisely controlled has made it possible to examine and quantify the effect of RNase E scarcity on RNA decay, gene regulation and cell growth. These studies show that RNase E participates in a step in the degradation of its RNA substrates that is partially or fully rate-determining. Our data also indicate that E. coli growth requires a cellular RNase E concentration at least 10-20% of normal and that the feedback mechanism that limits overproduction of RNase E is also able to increase its synthesis when its concentration drops below normal. The magnitude of the in-crease in RNA longevity under conditions of RNase E scarcity may be limited by an alternative pathway for RNA degradation. Additional experiments show that RNase E is a stable protein in E. coli. No other E. coli gene product, when either mutated or cloned on a multicopy plasmid, seems to be capable of compensating for an inadequate supply of this essential protein.

T7 phage display: a novel genetic selection system for cloning RNA-binding proteins from cDNA libraries

RNA-binding proteins are central to posttranscriptional gene regulation and play an important role in a number of major human diseases. Cloning such proteins is a crucial but often difficult step in elucidating the biological function of RNA regulatory elements. To make it easier to clone proteins that specifically bind RNA elements of interest, we have developed a rapid and broadly applicable in vitro genetic selection method based on T7 phage display. Using hairpin II of U1 small nuclear RNA (U1hpII) or the 3' stem loop of histone mRNA as bait, we could selectively amplify T7 phage that display either the spliceosomal protein U1A or the histone stem loop-binding protein from a lung cDNA phage library containing more than 10(7) independent clones. The use of U1hpII mutants with various affinities for U1A revealed that this method allows the selection even of proteins that bind their cognate RNA targets with relatively weak affinities (K(d) as high as the micromolar range). Experiments with a mixture of recombinant phage displaying U1A or the closely related protein U2B" demonstrated that addition of a competitor RNA can suppress selection of a protein with a higher affinity for a given RNA target, thereby allowing the preferential amplification of a lower affinity protein. Together, these findings suggest that T7 phage display can be used to rapidly and selectively clone virtually any protein that binds a known RNA regulatory element, including those that bind with low affinity or that must compete for binding with other proteins.

Structural model for the cooperative assembly of HIV-1 Rev multimers on the RRE as deduced from analysis of assembly-defective mutants

The functional efficacy of the HIV-1 Rev protein is highly dependent on its ability to assemble onto its HIV-1 RNA target (the RRE) as a multimeric complex. To elucidate the mechanism of multimeric assembly, we have devised two rapid and broadly applicable strategies for examining cooperative interactions between proteins bound to RNA, one based on cooperative translational repression of a two-site reporter and the other on gel shift analysis with crude E. coli extracts. Using these strategies, we have identified two distinct surfaces of Rev (head and tail) that are critical for different steps in multimeric assembly. Our data indicate that Rev assembles cooperatively on the RRE via a series of symmetrical tail-to-tail and head-to-head protein-protein interactions. The insights into molecular architecture suggested by these findings have enabled us to derive a structural model for Rev and its multimerization on the RRE.