Chlorambucil in indolent chronic lymphocytic leukemia. French Cooperative Group on Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia

BACKGROUND

To determine whether chlorambucil treatment benefits patients with indolent chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL), we conducted two randomized trials in 1535 patients with previously untreated stage A CLL.

METHODS

In the first trial, 609 patients were randomly assigned to receive either daily chlorambucil or no treatment; in the second trial, 926 patients were randomly assigned to receive either intermittent chlorambucil plus prednisone or no treatment. Median follow-up for the first and second trials exceeded 11 and 6 years, respectively. The end points were overall survival, response to treatment, and disease progression.

RESULTS

Treatment of indolent CLL did not increase survival in either trial. In the treated group, as compared with the untreated group, the relative risk of death was 1.14 (95 percent confidence interval, 0.92 to 1.41; P=0.23) in the first trial and 0.96 (95 percent confidence interval, 0.75 to 1.23; P=0.74) in the second trial, with 76 percent and 69 percent of patients, respectively, having a response to therapy. Although chlorambucil slowed disease progression, there was no effect on overall survival. In the untreated group in the first trial, 49 percent of patients did not have progression to more advanced disease and did not need therapy after follow-up of more than 11 years; however, 27 percent of patients with stage A CLL died of causes related to the disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Chlorambucil does not prolong survival in patients with stage A CLL. Since deferring therapy until the disease progresses to stage B or C does not compromise survival, treatment of indolent CLL is unnecessary.

VH gene expression in hairy cell leukaemia

Hairy cells are characterized by their typical morphology and expression of specific surface antigens. Although their B-cell origin is now confirmed, their exact position in B-cell development remains unclear. To better define the origin of hairy cells, we analysed the immunophenotype and the Ig VH nucleotide sequence of seven cases of hairy cell leukaemia (HCL). Six of them were typical HCL and the remaining case corresponded to a variant HCL. Analysis of sequenced VH genes revealed that the VH1 family was used in one case, VH2 in one, VH3 in two, VH4 in two and VH5 in one. No preferential usage of VH genes was observed in this small series. In five cases high rates of somatic mutations were observed, with a predominance of mutations and replacements in CDR regions for three. indicating that these cells originate from cells that have been exposed to the hypermutation mechanism. The distribution of mutations in our small series provides some evidence of a selective mutational process.

Basic biology of autoimmune phenomena in chronic lymphocytic leukemia

There is evidence indicating that autoreactive B cells constitute a substantial part of the B cell repertoire. This autoreactive repertoire secretes the so-called natural autoantibodies characterized by their broad reactivity mainly directed against well-conserved public epitopes. Their germinal origin is suggested by their early appearance during ontogeny, their expression of cross-reactive idiotopes, and structural studies of their sequence. As for the physiological role of the repertoire, it may play a major role as a first barrier of defense. It is presently unknown whether these polyreactive B cells could constitute a pre-immune template which, through an antigen-driven process, may be involved in the production of immune high-affinity antibodies. This autoreactive B cell repertoire frequently undergoes malignant transformation, although there is controversy concerning the reasons accounting for this. It has been postulated that the continuous challenge of this autoreactive repertoire by self-antigens could create propitious conditions for malignant transformation to occur. However, this hypothesis still needs to be substantiated. Chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL), the most frequent form of leukemia in western countries, is characterized by constant expression of the CD5 marker and low expression of surface membrane immunoglobulin (Ig) in B lymphocytes. CLL B lymphocyte is frequently committed for natural autoantibody secretion. Despite expressing the Epstein-Barr virus (EBV) receptor CLL B cells cannot be infected by the EBV virus, they overexpress the bcl-2 protein and they are unable to adequately respond when stimulated through the B cell receptor pathway. Autoimmune-associated phenomena are frequently observed in B-cell CLL. These autotoxic manifestations are mainly directed against hematopoietic cells. In most cases, autoantibodies against red blood cells are warm reactive polyclonal IgG. Immune thrombocytopenia is observed in about 2% of cases, but higher frequencies of increased platelet associated Igs have been reported. Pure red cell aplasia and autoantibodies against neutrophils are only rarely observed. This pattern is similar to that observed in primary immunodeficiency syndromes, in which immune thrombocytopenia, autoimmune hemolytic anemia, and pure red cell aplasia are frequently observed. The potential role of T cell defects in inducing autoimmune complications in B-cell CLL has been stressed by recent publications showing increased frequency of autoimmune hemolytic anemia in patients treated with purine nucleoside analogues. However, evidence is presently scarce concerning a functional impairment of T cells after administration of these drugs.

Minimal residual disease detection in B-cell malignancies by assessing IgH rearrangement

In B-cell malignancies, the uniqueness of the immunoglobulin heavy chain locus (IgH) clonal rearrangement provides a useful marker for the detection of minimal residual disease (MRD) after treatment. During the last decade, several techniques have been proposed and used for detecting MRD. In this review, we report the current PCR based techniques dealing with amplification of the VDJ segment since the CDR3 region is unique to each IgH rearrangement. The sensitivity of these techniques varies considerably with a detection level of one tumoral cell in 10(-2) to 10(-6) normal cells. Accurate and sensitive assessment of MRD may have profound impact in the clinical management of patients with hematologic malignancies. Although, a majority of studies have shown a good correlation between the rapidity or extent of the reduction in the number of tumoral cells and the subsequent relapse, other studies demonstrated substained positivity of PCR in patients in long term remission. Thus, current clinical studies of MRD should establish whether MRD predicts relapse uniformly and, therefore, justifies intensification of therapy in positive cases, or whether it simply detects leukemic cell populations whose proliferative potential has been altered by chemotherapy.

VH gene expression in CD5 positive and CD5 negative B cell chronic lymphoid malignancies

In this review, we report analyses of VH genes in mature B cell malignancies generally or occasionally bearing CD5 antigen such as B CLL, MCL, SLVL and PLL. In the majority of cases, B CLL and MCL use VH genes in germline configuration. However in some cases a higher rate of random mutations is observed. These differences are not related to CD5 expression but are accounted by Ig phenotype, since less mutations are observed in CLL cases expressing membrane mu delta, when compared to forms exclusively expressing membrane mu. PLL and SLVL cases display mutated V genes independently of CD5 expression. Although there is some evidence that CD5+ B cells constitute a separate lineage, the possibility that CD5 constitutes an activation marker cannot be ruled out. Indeed, CD5- B cells can be induced to differentiate into CD5+ B cells and VH gene analyses showed no significative differences between CD5+ and CD5- B cell lymphoproliferative disorders. In this review we have tried to examine B cell chronic malignancies on the basis of phenotype and VH gene usage. Thus we propose a tentative classification where these disorders are allocated according to these characteristics.

High frequency of somatic mutations in the VH genes expressed in prolymphocytic leukemia

Prolymphocytic leukemia (PLL) is a chronic lymphoproliferative disorder, characterized by prominent splenomegaly, prolymphocytes accounting for more than 55% of circulating lymphocytes, and short-term survival. To better characterize the nature of the cellular origin in this disease, we analyzed lg heavy chain variable region (VH) genes in eleven cases of de novo PLL Leukemic cells expressed a skewed repertoire characterized by predominant use of the V3 family members (73%), with preferential use of the V3-23 gene (50% of the VH3 genes). All sequences from expressed VH genes diverged from their putative germline counterpart, and in eight cases the divergence was greater than 5%. In seven cases, which expressed the V3-23 gene and VH4 family members, nucleotide substitutions could be confidently attributed to somatic mutations. The type and distribution of these mutations clearly indicated that in three cases the cells had been subjected to an antigen selection process. Taken together, these results suggest that B-PLL cells display a skewed repertoire of lg VH regions and probably represent, at least in some instances, expansion of postgerminal center cells that have undergone antigen driven selection.

Analysis of VH gene expression in CD5+ and CD5- B-cell chronic lymphocytic leukemia

In contrast to highly mutated follicular lymphomas and multiple myelomas, chronic lymphocytic leukemias (CLLs) frequently express VH genes in germline configuration. It is currently unclear whether this difference is related to the expression of CD5 or to the differentiation stage of the B cell when malignant transformation occurs. We have studied the VH sequence of 11 cases of CD5- B-CLL to address the question whether CD5- B-CLL are derived from naive pregerminal B cells (low mutation pattern) or from germinal center-derived memory B cells (high mutation pattern). Among the 12 detected rearrangements (2 distinct rearrangements in 1 case) VH1 family was found in 2, VH2 in 2, VH3 in 4, and VH4 in 4. Nine different VH genes were detected among the 12 rearrangements, including 2 cases expressing V1-69 (51p1) and 1 case expressing V4-39 (VH4.18), previously reported to be overexpressed in CD5+ B-CLL. A higher mutation pattern, following a random distribution, was observed when compared with classical CD5+ B-CLL. However, as reported in normal B cells, these results appeared to be related to membrane Ig phenotype (less mutations in membrane mu delta-expressing forms in leukemias expressing exclusively membrane mu). Overall, the differences found when comparing the mutational profile with classical CD5+ B-CLL were not clearcut and might be explained more by the membrane isotype (mu v mu delta) than by CD5 expression.

Skewed rearrangement of the VH4-21 gene during pre-B acute lymphoblastic leukemia

Thirty-six pre-B acute lymphoblastic leukemias (ALL) were studied for VH family expression. Among the 35 detected rearrangements, VH1 family genes were expressed in 7, VH2 in 1, VH3 in 18, VH4 in 6 and VH6 in 3. This expression is close to that expected according to the complexity of the system. The complete sequence of the 6 VH4 genes was examined in order to determine whether there is a skewed rearrangement of individual genes in this family. Our results indicate rearrangement of VH4-21 in 3 cases, 71-4 in one, 58P2 in one case and probably of a new germinal VH4 gene for the sixth case. All the genes were displaying an almost complete homology with their germinal VH counterparts. The 6 sequenced genes associated with 6 different D gene segments displaying a close homology with their germinal counterpart. JH4 segment was expressed in 3 cases and JH6 in the remaining 3. These results associated with previous results obtained by others indicate that there is skewed rearrangement of the VH4-21 gene in pre-B ALL. It is presently unknown whether this phenomenon is the consequence of a selective process or whether it reflects what normally occurs in the normal human functional repertoire, which could be more limited than the germline repertoire.