From autoantibody research to standardized diagnostic assays in the management of human diseases – report of the 12th Dresden Symposium on Autoantibodies

Testing for autoantibodies (AABs) is becoming more and more relevant, not only for diagnosing autoimmune diseases (AIDs) but also for the differentiation of defined AID subtypes with different clinical manifestations, course and prognosis as well as the very early diagnosis for adequate management in the context of personalized medicine. A major challenge to improve diagnostic accuracy is to harmonize or even standardize AAB analyses. This review presents the results of the 12th Dresden Symposium on Autoantibodies that focused on several aspects of improving autoimmune diagnostics. Topics that are addressed include the International Consensus on ANA Patterns (ICAP) and the International Autoantibody Standardization (IAS) initiatives, the optimization of diagnostic algorithms, the description and evaluation of novel disease-specific AABs as well as the development and introduction of novel assays into routine diagnostics. This review also highlights important developments of recent years, most notably the improvement in diagnosing and predicting the course of rheumatoid arthritis, systemic sclerosis, idiopathic inflammatory myopathies, and of autoimmune neurological, gastrointestinal and liver diseases; the potential diagnostic role of anti-DFS70 antibodies and tumor-associated AABs. Furthermore, some hot topics in autoimmunity regarding disease pathogenesis and management are described.

Patient preference: a comparison of electronic patient-completed questionnaires with paper among cancer patients

In this study, we compared cancer patients preference for computerised (tablet/web-based) surveys versus paper. We also assessed whether the understanding of a cancer-related topic, pharmacogenomics is affected by the survey format, and examined differences in demographic and medical characteristics which may affect patient preference and understanding. Three hundred and four cancer patients completed a tablet-administered survey and another 153 patients completed a paper-based survey. Patients who participated in the tablet survey were questioned regarding their preference for survey format administration (paper, tablet and web-based). Understanding was assessed with a 'direct' method, by asking patients to assess their understanding of genetic testing, and with a 'composite' score. Patients preferred administration with tablet (71%) compared with web-based (12%) and paper (17%). Patients <65 years old, non-Caucasians and white-collar professionals significantly preferred the computerised format following multivariate analysis. There was no significant difference in understanding between the paper and tablet survey with direct questioning or composite score. Age (<65 years) and white-collar professionals were associated with increased understanding (both P = 0.03). There was no significant difference in understanding between the tablet and print survey in a multivariate analysis. Patients overwhelmingly preferred computerised surveys and understanding of pharmacogenomics was not affected by survey format.

Highlights on novel technologies for the detection of antibodies to Ro60, Ro52, and SS-B

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to compare a chemiluminescent immunoassay (CIA, QUANTA Flash) on BIO-FLASH with a multiplex flow immunoassay (MFI) on BioPlex 2200 for the detection of antibodies to Ro60, Ro52, and SS-B.

METHODS

The study included 241 samples, from patients suffering from systemic autoimmune diseases (n = 108) as well as disease controls (n = 133). All samples were tested for anti-Ro52, anti-Ro60, and anti-SS-B (La) antibodies on QUANTA Flash (INOVA Diagnostics, San Diego, USA) and BioPlex 2200 (Bio-Rad Laboratories Inc., Hercules, USA). Discrepant samples were tested by two independent methods: BlueDot/ANA and QUANTRIX Microarray (both D-tek, Belgium).

RESULTS

The overall qualitative agreements were 95.4% (95% confidence interval, CI 92.0-97.7%) for anti-Ro52, 98.8% (95% CI 96.4-99.7%) for anti-Ro60, and 91.7% (95% CI 87.5-94.9%) for anti-SS-B antibodies. There were 34 discrepant samples among all assays (20 anti-SS-B, 11 anti-Ro52, 3 anti-Ro60). 30/33 of retested samples (by D-tek dot blot) agreed with the QUANTA Flash results. Similar findings were obtained with QUANTRIX Microarray kit.

CONCLUSION

QUANTA Flash and BioPlex 2200 show good qualitative agreement. The clinical performances were similar for anti-Ro52 and anti-Ro60 autoantibodies while differences were observed for anti-SS-B (La) antibodies.

Severe hepatocellular dysfunction in obstetric cholestasis related to combined genetic variation in hepatobiliary transporters

Obstetric cholestasis (OC) is a cholestatic disorder with a prominent genetic background including variation in diverse hepatobiliary lipid transporters, such as ABCB4 (phospholipids) and ABCB11 (bile salts). Given a marked hepatocellular dysfunction in an OC patient indicated by > 40-fold rise in alanine aminotransferase activity and minor gamma-glutamyl transpeptidase increases, we performed genotyping of candidate gene variants associated with adult cholestatic phenotypes. Genetic analysis revealed the heterozygous ABCB4 mutation p.R590Q, the ABCB11 variant p.V444A and the lithogenic ABCG8 variant p.D19H. Aggregation of multiple hepatobiliary transporter variants is rare in OC, and may cooperate to negatively modulate hepatobiliary transport capacities.

The common adiponutrin variant p.I148M does not confer gallstone risk but affects fasting glucose and triglyceride levels

Recently the common adiponutrin (PNPLA3) polymorphism p.I148M has been identified as a genetic determinant of severe forms of non-alcoholic fatty liver disease and alcoholic liver disease. Additionally, insulin resistance - linked to the development of non-alcoholic steatohepatitis - increases the risk of developing gallstones. Here we assessed whether the PNPLA3 p.I148M (c.444 C-G) polymorphism affects glucose and lipid levels and increases gallstone risk. We analysed 229 individuals with gallstones from 108 families (age 24-80 years, BMI 17-55 kg/m(2)) and 258 gallstone-free controls (age 20-70 years, BMI 14-43 kg/m(2)). Fasting glucose, triglyceride and cholesterol serum levels were determined. The p.I148M polymorphism was genotyped using a PCR-based assay with 5'-nuclease and fluorescence detection. Case-control association tests and nonparametric linkage (NPL) analysis in sib-pairs were performed. Individuals carrying the [GG] genotype had significantly (P<0.0001) higher median fasting glucose levels as compared to [GC] and [CC] carriers. After adjustment for multiple testing, we detected a trend for an association between triglyceride levels and variant adiponutrin in gallstone patients (P=0.032), and gallstone cases carrying the genotype [CC] presented with significantly higher triglyceride levels than the corresponding controls (P<0.003). No significant effects on cholesterol metabolism were detected. Neither genotype distributions nor NPL scores provided evidence for association or linkage between the PNPLA3 variant and gallstones. In conclusion, homozygous carriers of the PNPLA3 risk allele display higher fasting glucose. Although this adiponutrin variant may affect triglyceride homeostasis, it does not increase the risk of cholelithiasis.

Novel diagnostic and clinical aspects of anti-PCNA antibodies detected by novel detection methods

Autoantibodies targeting the proliferating cell nuclear antigen have been considered as a specific biomarker for systemic lupus erythematosus, and were historically identified by indirect immunofluorescence and then confirmed by other more specific immunoassays. Our objective was to investigate the anti-PCNA immune response in various disease conditions. Unselected sera referred to a clinical diagnostic laboratory and other sera from various diseases cohorts and controls were tested for anti-PCNA antibodies by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), line immunoassay (LIA) and an addressable laser bead assay (ALBIA) using full-length human proliferating cell nuclear antigen. Two out of 2500 sequential, unselected sera (0.07%) referred to a diagnostic laboratory for autoantibody analysis showed a proliferating cell nuclear antigen-like staining pattern. Good agreement was found between ELISA, ALBIA and LIA. At cut-off values resulting in 100% specificity, 52.5% (ELISA), 42.5% (ALBIA) and 35% (LIA) of samples with a proliferating cell nuclear antigen-like indirect immunofluorescence staining pattern were positive. In the indirect immunofluorescence proliferating cell nuclear antigen immunoblot (IB)-positive group, anti-PCNA antibodies were frequently accompanied by anti-Ro52, and in the indirect immunofluorescence PCNA-negative but LIA PCNA-positive group by various other autoantibodies. The prevalence of anti-PCNA antibodies was highest in Sjögren’s syndrome (5.0%). In conclusion, the proliferating cell nuclear antigen-like staining pattern was rarely found (0.07%) in sequential, unselected sera. Further, indirect immunofluorescence is not an accurate screening method to identify anti-PCNA antibodies as their presence may be masked by other autoantibodies. The specific association of anti-PCNA antibodies with systemic lupus erythematosus was not confirmed in our study. Lupus (2010) 19, 1527—1533.

Diverse humoral autoimmunity to the ribosomal P proteins in systemic lupus erythematosus and hepatitis C virus infection

Autoantibodies to the three ribosomal P proteins (Rib-P) are specifically found in 10% to 40% of systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) patients. Most anti-Rib-P autoantibodies bind to a C-terminal epitope shared by all three Rib-P proteins P0, P1 and P2. In the present study, we shed more light on the humoral autoimmune response to the Rib-P antigen as it occurs in autoimmunity and infectious disease. In a mutational analysis of the major C-terminal epitope, we verified the key role of phenylalanine residues Phe ( 111 ) and Phe ( 114 ) for binding of most anti-Rib-P serum autoantibodies present in SLE sera (n = 28). By nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) investigation of a peptide comprising the C-terminal 22 amino acids, we observed hallmarks for alpha-helical secondary structure of the Rib-P epitope core (GFGLFD). Based on NMR data and on SPOT epitope analysis, we propose a structural model of the Rib-P major epitope, which displays Phe ( 111 ) and Phe ( 114 ) on one side of the helix. Apart from that, two sera from the hepatitis C virus (HCV) control group (n = 68) were found to contain antibodies specific for P2, but not for the other Rib-P proteins. Using a SPOT peptide array scanning the P2 amino acid sequence, we identified reactivity with two distinct epitopes (residues 21-35 and 41-55 of Rib-P2) shared by both HCV sera. We conclude that anti-Rib-P autoreactivity occurs in SLE, Chagas' disease (CD) and-as firstly described here-during HCV infection. Anti-Rib-P reactivity in SLE sera primarily depends on Phe ( 111 ) and Phe ( 114 ) of the alpha-helical C-terminal epitope. In contrast, anti-Rib-P autoantibodies in HCV infection mainly recognize epitopes within the N-terminal half of ribosomal P2.

Serological and Clinical Characterization of Anti-dsDNA and Anti-PM/Scl Double-Positive Patients

Antibodies to double-stranded desoxyribonucleic acid (dsDNA) and to the polymyositis/scleroderma (PM/Scl) complex are regarded as serological markers for systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) and PM/Scl overlap syndrome, respectively. In a previous study, serum samples were identified that contained antibodies specific for both dsDNA and PM/Scl. Fourteen of these sera were available for more detailed investigation including the autoantibody profile as determined by several methods including an addressable laser bead assay, Crithidia luciliae indirect immunofluorescence test (CLIFT) and a PM1-Alpha ELISA. Moreover, 300 samples from connective tissue disease patients and 30 PM/Scl positive samples were screened for anti-dsDNA(+)/PM/Scl(+) specimens by CLIFT, dsDNA ELISA, and PM1-Alpha ELISA. We confirmed anti-dsDNA and anti-PM/Scl reactivity in 2/7 samples from the previous study. One sample had also anti-chromatin and anti-SS-A reactivity and the second sample was oligoreactive. In addition, 2/300 (0.7%) unselected samples from connective tissue disease patients were identified with anti-dsDNA and anti-PM/Scl reactivity. In a panel of PM1-Alpha positive samples (n = 30) collected regardless of the diagnosis of the patients, no anti-dsDNA reactivity was found. All anti-dsDNA(+)/anti-PM/Scl(+) patients identified fulfilled sufficient criteria to be classified as definite SLE and also had at least one feature of systemic sclerosis (i.e., sclerodactyly and/or Raynaud's phenomenon). Only 1/4 patients had clinical evidence of dermatomyositis. The combination of anti-dsDNA(+)/anti-PM/Scl(+) in patients suffering from connective tissue disease is less frequently found than previously described when newer assays are used. Clinically, anti-dsDNA(+)/anti-PM/Scl(+) patients may define a small subgroup of SLE patients with additional features of systemic sclerosis.

Environment as a Critical Factor for the Pathogenesis and Outcome of Gastrointestinal Disease: Experimental and Human Inflammatory Bowel Disease and Helicobacter-Induced Gastritis

Environmental factors play an important role in the manifestation, course, and prognosis of diseases of the gastrointestinal tract such as inflammatory bowel disease (IBD) and Helicobacter pylori-induced gastritis. These two disease complexes were chosen for a discussion of the contribution of environmental factors to the disease outcome in humans and animal models. Dissecting complex diseases like IBD and Helicobacter-induced gastritis has shown that the outcome of disease depends on the allelic constellation of a host and the microbial and physical environments. Host alleles predisposing to a disease in one genomic and/or environmental milieu may not be deleterious in other constellations; on the other hand, microbes can have different effects in different hosts and under different environmental conditions. The impact of the complex interaction between host genetics and environmental factors, particularly microflora, also underlines the importance of a defined genetic background and defined environments in animal studies and is indicative of the difficulties in analyzing complex diseases in humans.

Improved serological differentiation between systemic lupus erythematosus and mixed connective tissue disease by use of an SmD3 peptide-based immunoassay

Autoantibodies to the Sm antigens are specifically found in 5 to 30% of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus (SLE) depending on the detection system and the patient group. Several immunoassays designed for research and diagnostic laboratory use have been developed. The autoantigens employed in these tests include purified native proteins, recombinant polypeptides, and synthetic peptides. In the present study, we compared the clinical accuracy of anti-Sm autoantibody assays from commercial suppliers including different conventional enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) systems based on purified Sm antigens, an addressable laser bead assay and a newly developed anti-Sm peptide assay. Although the clinical sensitivity of all assays under investigation was comparable, relatively poor correlations and significant differences in specificity were found with a patient cohort of 150 patients. The sensitivity and specificity were 10 and 94%, respectively, for the anti-Sm ELISA from Euroimmun, 10 and 90%, respectively, for the QuantaLite Sm (INOVA), 12 and 88%, respectively, for the Sm assay in the Varelisa ReCombi ANA profile (Pharmacia Diagnostics), 10 and 94%, respectively, for the QuantaPlex Sm (INOVA), and 12 and 100%, respectively, for the new SmD3 peptide-based ELISA (Varelisa Sm Antibodies). The majority of positive test results within the control groups were found in patients with mixed connective tissue disease. Based on the results, we conclude that the detection of anti-Sm antibodies strongly depends both on the nature of the antigen and on the detection system. Finally, we conclude that the recently identified SmD peptide containing a symmetrical dimethylarginine at position 112 of D3 represents a promising tool for the detection of a highly specific subpopulation of anti-Sm antibodies.

Technical and clinical evaluation of anti-ribosomal P protein immunoassays

Autoantibodies to the three ribosomal phospho (-P) proteins P0, P1, P2, referred to as Rib-P, are specifically found in 10-40% of patients with systemic lupus erythematosus. The variations in the observed frequency of these autoantibodies is related to a number of factors such as the test system used to detect the antibodies. Several immunoassays that were designed for research and diagnostic laboratory use have been developed. The autoantigens employed in these tests include native proteins, recombinant polypeptides, and synthetic peptides. In this study, we compared the technical and clinical accuracy of anti-Rib-P antibody assays from different commercial suppliers including ELISA systems and a novel addressable laser bead assay (from Euroimmun, MBL, Pharmacia Diagnostics, INOVA). Although the assays from all suppliers used in this study performed well in the technical part of the study, relatively poor correlations and significant differences in the clinical accuracy were found. Based on the results, we conclude that the detection of anti-Rib-P antibodies strongly depends on both the nature of the antigen and the detection system. We recommend that anti-Rib-P assays should be standardized on an international level. The Varelisa Rib-P profile and the addressable laser bead Rib-P assays represent promising tools and platforms for the detection of anti-Rib-P antibodies in the future.