Reflections on the cost-effectiveness of recombinant FSH in assisted reproduction. The clinician's perspective

PURPOSE

To analyze the relative cost-effectiveness of recombinant FSH (rFSH) and urinary FSH (uFSH) in assisted reproduction techniques (ART).

METHODS

Calculation of the average cost-effectiveness ratio and the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio to compare costs and effects (pregnancy rates) of the two therapeutic options (rFSH and uFSH).

RESULTS

Assuming that the cost of the procedure per ART cycle is between 100,000 pesetas (601 euro) and 150,000 pesetas (901.52 euro), and pricing the GnRH analogues used for pituitary suppression at 35,000 pesetas (210.3 euro), the cost-effectiveness ratio is better for rFSH than for uFSH, implying that the cost per pregnancy is lower when the recombinant preparation is used.

CONCLUSIONS

In ART, the use of rFSH is more cost-effective than uFSH.

Human chorionic gonadotropin and intravaginal natural progesterone are equally effective for luteal phase support in IVF

This prospective randomized study compared human chorionic gonadotropin (hCG) and micronized transvaginal progesterone for luteal support in 310 in vitro fertilization (IVF) patients treated with leuprolide acetate and gonadotropins in a long protocol, and showing normal ovarian response. Both treatment groups were homogeneous for age, BMI, stimulation treatment and ovarian response. Pregnancy rates per embryo transfer were not significantly different (33.1% for the hCG group versus 38.7% for the progesterone group). For IVF patients with a normal response to stimulation under pituitary suppression, the use of hCG or progesterone for luteal support does not seem to have any effect on pregnancy rate. The choice of luteal treatment must balance medical hazard and patient convenience, as both therapeutic regimens seem equally effective.

Stimulation protocols for poor responders and aged women

There is a general consensus on the clinical fact that the more embryos replaced the higher pregnancy rates are achieved. For this reason those IVF cycles with a low response and a reduced number of oocytes and embryos will have very few chances of producing a pregnancy. It is very important to diagnose, by means of the anamnesis and hormonal tests which patients are most likely to present a poor response to conventional ovarian stimulation protocols. It is mandatory to know the patient's plasmatic levels of FSH and estradiol together with personal data such as the age and the previous history of the patient. Only young poor responders with a normal basal hormonal profile will have some chances that by applying new protocols and combining new drugs, improve their response and have higher pregnancy rates. For the old poor responders who have already failed to alternative protocols including natural cycles, oocyte donation is the last and best hope.

Increased incidence of meiotic anomalies in oligoasthenozoospermic males preselected for intracytoplasmic sperm injection

PURPOSE

Based on data from the literature, to detect the possible presence of an increased frequency of meiotic anomalies in oligoasthenozoospermic (OA) patients preselected for intracytoplasmic sperm injection.

METHODS

Meiotic studies in as many successive patients with a clinical indication for a diagnostic testicular biopsy as needed to complete at least 100 cases with a severe OA (motile sperm concentration < or = 1.5 x 10(6)/ml).

RESULTS

An increased incidence of meiotic anomalies was found in 102 patients with a severe OA (17.6%) compared to the mean for 105 patients with other etiologies in the series (5.7%) or the mean for patients reviewed in the literature (6.5%).

CONCLUSIONS

Patients with a severe OA have a higher incidence of synaptic anomalies. This may result in the malsegregation of chromosomes at meiosis I, producing abnormal sperm, and could explain the high incidence of sterility and some cases of abortion (in two thirds of the couples with abortions the husband had meiotic anomalies) in this group.

Embryo transfer under ultrasound guidance improves pregnancy rates after in-vitro fertilization

Between October 1998 and January 1999, we examined the influence of ultrasound guidance in embryo transfer on pregnancy rate in 362 patients from our in-vitro fertilization (IVF)-embryo transfer programme. These patients were prospectively randomized into two groups: 182 had ultrasound-guided embryo replacement, and 180 had clinical touch embryo transfer. There were no statistically significant differences between the two groups with respect to age, cause of infertility and in the characteristics of the IVF cycle. The pregnancy rate was significantly higher among the ultrasound-guided embryo transfer group (50%) compared with the clinical touch group (33.7%) (P < 0.002). Furthermore, there was also a significant increase in the implantation rate: 25.3% in the ultrasound group compared with 18.1% in the clinical touch group (P < 0.05). In conclusion, ultrasound assistance in embryo transfer significantly improved pregnancy and implantation rates in IVF.

Human male infertility: chromosome anomalies, meiotic disorders, abnormal spermatozoa and recurrent abortion

Human male infertility is often related to chromosome abnormalities. In chromosomally normal infertile males, the rates of chromosome 21 and sex chromosome disomy in spermatozoa are increased. Higher incidences of trisomy 21 (seldom of paternal origin) and sex chromosome aneuploidy are also found. XXY and XYY patients produce increased numbers of XY, XX and YY spermatozoa, indicating an increased risk of production of XXY, XYY and XXX individuals. Since XXYs can reproduce using intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI), this could explain the slight increase of sex chromosome anomalies in ICSI series. Carriers of structural reorganizations produce unbalanced spermatozoa, and risk having children with duplications and/or deficiencies. In some cases, this risk is considerably lower or higher than average. These patients also show increased diploidy, and a higher risk of producing diandric triploids. Meiotic disorders are frequent in infertile males, and increase with severe oligoasthenozoospemia (OA) and/or high follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) concentrations. These patients produce spermatozoa with autosomal and sex chromosome disomies, and diploid spermatozoa. Their contribution to recurrent abortion depends on the production of trisomies, monosomies and of triploids. The most frequent sperm chromosome anomaly in infertile males is diploidy, originated by either meiotic mutations or by a compromised testicular environment.

Use of co-culture of human embryos on Vero cells to improve clinical implantation rate

Co-culture of human embryos (n = 384 cycles) to the blastocyst stage using Vero cell monolayers was carried out between August 1995 and December 1997. A total of 2868 zygotes were co-cultured and 1027 embryos reached the blastocyst stage (blastocyst formation rate 35.8%). The blastocysts were frozen in 43.7% of patients. A mean of 1.8 blastocysts was transferred per patient and 95 pregnancies were obtained (pregnancy rate/cycle 24.7%). The blastocyst implantation rate was 23.6%. Miscarriage occurred in 15 patients (15.7%) and ectopic pregnancy in three (3.1%) patients. The multiple pregnancy rate was 32.6%. No differences were observed in the blastocyst rate between poor, normal or high response patients. Blastocyst formation was significantly lower when frozen donor spermatozoa were used. Significantly higher pregnancy rates per transfer and blastocyst implantation rates were attained when embryos were transferred on days 5 or 6 compared with day 7. No advantage was observed when co-culture was used in first cycle IVF patients, in comparison with conventional day 2 replacements. The use of blastocysts for preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) increases the diagnostic reliability and widens diagnostic possibilities. A total of 215 cycles with frozen-thawed co-cultured blastocysts were carried out, with a pregnancy rate of 22.7% per replacement.

Confirmation of diagnosis in preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) through blastocyst culture: preliminary experience

Three cases of preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) (two for sexing and one for aneuploidy screening) are presented. Embryo biopsy was performed at day 3 and diagnosis was established with fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH). Embryos not used for replacement were cultured in sequential media for blastocyst development. Blastocyst rate was 39.3 per cent. Confirmations of diagnosis were established with FISH in blastocysts and arrested embryos. Mosaicism was observed in 7/8 blastocysts (mean number of cells analysed: 55.5) and 5/8 arrested embryos. The percentage of abnormal cells was 17.1 per cent for blastocysts and 54 per cent for arrested embryos. Polypoid cells were observed in 4/8 blastocysts. Confirmation of diagnosis at the blastocyst stage is a useful tool in PGD.

Screening for abnormalities of chromosomes X, Y, and 18 and for diploidy in spermatozoa from infertile men participating in an in vitro fertilization-intracytoplasmic sperm injection program

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the frequency of disomy (for chromosomes X, Y, and 18) and of diploidy in the spermatozoa of infertile men undergoing intracytoplasmic sperm injection (ICSI).

DESIGN

Prospective analysis of sperm nuclei by fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH).

SETTING

University-affiliated IVF-ICSI program.

PATIENT(S)

Semen samples from 19 patients participating in an IVF-ICSI program.

INTERVENTION(S)

Semen samples were analyzed and prepared for FISH.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE(S)

Semen parameters were evaluated. The frequency of disomy for chromosomes X, Y, and 18 and the frequency of diploidy were analyzed by FISH.

RESULT(S)

A total of 9,373 spermatozoa from 19 infertile patients were analyzed and compared with spermatozoa from a control group of 5 healthy men. No differences in the frequency of disomy 18 were found, but statistically significant differences in the incidence of sex chromosome disomy and of diploidy were observed.

CONCLUSION(S)

The study of sperm nuclei by FISH is useful to improve genetic counseling in infertile patients selected for ICSI.

Meiotic abnormalities and spermatogenic parameters in severe oligoasthenozoospermia

The incidence of meiotic abnormalities and their relationship with different spermatogenic parameters was assessed in 103 male patients with presumably idiopathic severe oligoasthenozoospermia (motile sperm concentration < or = 1.5 x 10(6)/ml). Meiosis on testicular biopsies was independently evaluated by two observers. Meiotic patterns included normal meiosis and two meiotic abnormalities, i.e. severe arrest and synaptic anomalies. A normal pattern was found in 64 (62.1%), severe arrest in 21 (20.4%) and synaptic anomalies in 18 (17.5%). The overall rate of meiotic abnormalities was 37.9%. Most (66.7%) meiotic abnormalities occurred in patients with a sperm concentration < or = 1 x 10(6)/ml. In this group, total meiotic abnormalities were found in 57.8% of the patients; of these, 26.7% had synaptic anomalies. When the sperm concentration was < or = 0.5 x 10(6)/ml, synaptic anomalies were detected in 40% of the patients. In patients with increased follicle stimulating hormone (FSH) concentrations, total meiotic abnormalities occurred in 54.8% (synaptic anomalies in 22.6%). There were statistically significant differences among the three meiotic patterns in relation to sperm concentration (P < 0.001) and serum FSH concentration (P < 0.05). In the multivariate analysis, sperm concentration < or = 1 x 10(6)/ml and/or FSH concentration > 10 IU/l were the only predictors of meiotic abnormalities.

Hyperprolactinemia: an inductor of neoplastic changes in endometrium? A report of two cases

Estrogen-dependent endometrial carcinomas habitually arise through a precursor lesion such as endometrial hyperplasia. The hormonal environment of these patients remains unclear. Two cases of neoplastic changes in the endometrium of patients with a chronic hyperprolactinemia are presented. Despite the treatment with bromocriptine both patients developed endometrial adenocarcinomas. Possible mechanisms involved in the pathogenesis of these tumors are discussed.

[Pre-implantation genetic diagnosis: indications, techniques, and results]

The combination of the technique of In Vitro Fertilization (IVF) and molecular genetics has led to the development of Preimplantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD). Oocyte and embryo biopsy, Fluorescent in situ Hybridization (FISH) and Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) allow diagnostic procedures in couples with high risk and also certain IVF couples. We present a review of PGD indications, techniques and results.

Psychiatric morbidity in couples attending a fertility service

The structured clinical interview for diagnosis (axis 1) according to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual for Mental Disorders (DSM-III-R) was used to assess psychiatric morbidity in 110 infertile patients. They were divided into two groups according to whether referral to the service of psychosomatic medicine was deemed advisable by the physician in charge. Psychiatric disorders were diagnosed in 39 of 56 (69.6%) patients in the referred group and in 13 of 54 (24.1%) in the non-referred group. Psychiatric morbidity was found in 61.1% of females and 21% of males. Adjustment disorders were found in 59.6% (31/52) of all patients, in 59% (24/39) of patients among the referred group and in 61.5% (8/13) of patients among the non-referred group. Fourteen (67%) of 21 women in the referred group with adjustment disorders suffered from anxiety. In addition, 33.3% of patients in the non-referred group showed important psychological dysfunction, although DSM-III-R criteria were not met. Psychiatric morbidity was significantly associated with the number of treatment cycles and female gender in the whole study population, as well as with the type and length of infertility in the non-referred group. Psychological services in an infertility clinic help to identify at an early stage those individuals who are more likely to be vulnerable. This would enable psychological interventions to be targeted towards those in greater need.

Successful use of a laser for human embryo biopsy in preimplantation genetic diagnosis: report of two cases

PURPOSE

The use of Tyrode's acid to drill the zona pellucida for embryo biopsy is the most widely used methodology in preimplantation genetic diagnosis. Instead of this, we propose the use of a 1.48-micron diode noncontact laser, which is quicker, simpler, and safer.

METHODS

The laser beam was tangentially guided to the zona pellucida of the embryo. Depending on zona pellucida measurement, two to four consecutive shots of 8-22 msec were necessary to drill the zona pellucida of the 13 embryos biopsied for two patients (hemophilia carriers).

RESULTS

Female embryos were replaced into the uterus of the patients (1.5 embryos/replacement). One single pregnancy was established (33.3% implantation rate). Coculture of untransferable embryos showed a blastocyst rate of 66.7% (4/6) for male embryos and 25% (1/4) for abnormal ones.

CONCLUSIONS

These results demonstrate the safety and usefulness of laser methodology in preimplantation genetic diagnosis.

Parental human leukocyte antigens and implantation failure after in-vitro fertilization

At present, it is well accepted that maternal recognition of paternally derived fetal antigens occurs during normal pregnancy and may be beneficial for implantation and maintenance of gestation. Thus, we have investigated the compatibility of human leukocyte antigens (HLA) in couples with successive failed in-vitro fertilization (IVF) cycles. Study group 1 included 50 couples with prior primary infertility who had not achieved a pregnancy after > or = 3 (range 3-7, mean 3.7) IVF cycles where at least two embryos (mean 3.3, range 2-4) were transferred in each attempt. An infertile control group (group 2) included 50 infertile couples undergoing IVF with the same indications as couples in group 1, who achieved a viable pregnancy with their first IVF attempt. The results were compared with those found in a population sample including 100 men and 100 women from the local population (group 3). We found a statistically significant (P < 0.05) excess of HLA sharing (> or = 2 antigens) between partners in group 1 as compared to groups 2. There was a trend toward increased HLA sharing in group 1 when groups 1 and 3 were compared. We conclude that some cases of implantation failure after IVF and embryo transfer might be caused by underlying close histocompatibility between partners.

Laser blastocyst biopsy for preimplantation diagnosis in the human

A new methodology for blastocyst biopsy that uses a 1.48 microm diode laser is described. Trophectoderm cells are biopsied after laster zona drilling and culture, fixed and processed for fluorescent in situ hybridisation (FISH) analysis. Preliminary results on the efficiency of the procedure and blastocyst recovery rate are promising. Blastocyst laser biopsy is a useful tool in preimplantation genetic diagnosis (PGD) as it allows a more reliable diagnosis and widens the diagnostic possibilities on account of the higher number of cells obtained in the biopsy.

Ureteral lesion secondary to vaginal ultrasound follicular puncture for oocyte recovery in in-vitro fertilization

Techniques of oocyte retrieval have progressed from laparoscopy to transvaginal follicular aspiration under ultrasonographic control. This highly efficient method, routinely used nowadays, is not free of complications. We present a case of a ureteral lesion secondary to vaginal ultrasound follicular puncture for oocyte recovery in in-vitro fertilization. Despite the surgical procedure to reimplant the ureter, the patient achieved a twin pregnancy which is ongoing uneventfully.

Comparison of the role of cervical and intrauterine insemination techniques on the incidence of multiple pregnancy after artificial insemination with donor sperm

PURPOSE

Our purpose was to investigate the role of the insemination technique used in an artificial insemination program with donor sperm (AID) in multiple pregnancy rates.

METHODS

We carried out a retrospective nonrandom analysis of 300 pregnancies corresponding to 300 cycles in women from our Artificial Insemination Donor Sperm Program. All cycles were stimulated with gonadotropins. Single and multiple pregnancy cycles and intracervical and intrauterine pregnant cycles were compared.

RESULTS

Intracervical insemination was performed in 173 cycles (58%), and intrauterine insemination in 127 (42%). Two hundred twenty-three pregnancies were single (74%), and 77 multiple (26%). In multiple pregnancy cycles, initial dose and mean total daily dose of gonadotropins, plasma estradiol levels, and number of follicles > or = 14 mm were significantly higher compared to those in single pregnancy cycles. Multiple pregnancy rte was significantly higher among pregnancies after intrauterine insemination (32%) than after intracervical insemination (21%).

CONCLUSIONS

The intrauterine technique of insemination in AID-stimulated cycles with gonadotropins is related to multiple pregnancy risk.

Treatment of polycystic ovary patients undergoing IVF

We believe that PCO patients can achieve good results in IVF cycles, provided that stimulation protocols appropriate to their hormonal profiles are used.

The dose of gonadotropin used seems to be more important than the type of gonadotropin. If there is a risk of ovarian hyperstimulation, it is useful to employ one of the strategies recommended to prevent development of genuine OHS, which may endanger the patient’s health.

Optimization of implantation in the in-vitro fertilization laboratory

Implantation failure rates after in-vitro fertilization (IVF) can be reduced in the IVF laboratory using two different techniques: assisted hatching and embryo co-culture on monolayer feeder cells. A review of the different methodologies and the results gained using these techniques is reported. Preliminary results obtained in the Reproductive Medicine Service of the Institut Universitari Dexeus, Barcelona, Spain using these techniques are also presented.

Evaluation of cytogenetic analysis for clinical preimplantation diagnosis

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the feasibility of using cytogenetic analysis in preimplantation diagnosis.

DESIGN

Two different biopsy protocols (chemical drilling and zona cutting) and two fixation methods were tested in a mouse model. Afterwards, the efficiency of obtaining chromosome preparations from untransferable human embryos depending on the method used to obtain the blastomeres (embryos biopsy or removal of the zona pellucida and blastomere disaggregation) was determined. The chances of obtaining chromosome preparations depending on the type of embryo (haploid, diploid, triploid, and apparently unfertilized) were also evaluated.

RESULTS

Results from the mouse model showed that chemical drilling yields better results than cutting in terms of metaphases per biopsied embryo and surviving rate after biopsy. In human embryos, biopsy of diploid embryos produced 46.6% chromosome preparations, while 29% were obtained after blastomere disaggregation and 20.4% when biopsying triploid embryos.

CONCLUSIONS

These results suggest that the disaggregating procedure and triploid embryos cannot be considered as good models to assess the feasibility of cytogenetic analysis in preimplantation diagnosis. Poor chromosome quality and loss during fixation are the main problems to use cytogenetics in preimplantation diagnosis; a combination of cytogenetics and other techniques is suggested in cases of balanced translocations.

Further characterization of the luteal phase inadequacy after gonadotrophin-releasing hormone agonist-induced ovulation in gonadotrophin-stimulated cycles

To characterize further the luteal phase ensuing gonadotrophin-releasing hormone agonist (GnRHa)-induced ovulation in exogenous gonadotrophin-stimulated cycles, plasma progesterone concentrations on luteal days +2 and +8 were determined in 20 patients (group 1) receiving one s.c. 0.5 mg injection of the GnRHa leuprolide acetate and in 10 patients (group 2) receiving two doses 12 h apart in multifollicular cycles stimulated with highly purified follicle-stimulating hormone (FSH). The patients received luteal support with micronized vaginal progesterone from day +2 (after sampling for plasma progesterone determination) until the onset of menses. The duration of the luteal phase was also assessed. As a control group, we included five fertile women who underwent plasma progesterone determinations on days +2 and +8 according to the luteinizing hormone peak in their spontaneous ovulatory cycles. On day +2, plasma progesterone concentrations were significantly higher in groups 1 and 2 than in the controls. However, on day +8, the mean plasma progesterone concentration and the average progesterone concentration per pre-ovulatory follicle were significantly higher in the control women than in groups 1 and 2. Furthermore, 13 patients (65%) in group 1 and seven patients (70%) in group 2 had plasma progesterone concentrations < 2 SD below the mean value obtained in the controls on that post-ovulatory day. Percentage increments in the plasma progesterone concentration from day +2 to day +8 were significantly lower in groups 1 and 2 than in the control group of spontaneous ovulatory cycles.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)