Residual bacterial detection rates after primary culture as determined by secondary culture and rapid testing in platelet components: A systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Primary culture alone was a bacterial risk control strategy intended to facilitate interdiction of contaminated platelets (PLTs). A September 2019 FDA guidance includes secondary testing options to enhance safety. Our objective was to use meta-analysis to determine residual contamination risk after primary culture using secondary culture and rapid testing.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

A December 2019 literature search identified articles on PLT bacterial detection rates using primary culture and a secondary testing method. We used meta-analysis to estimate secondary testing detection rates after a negative primary culture. We evaluated collection method, sample volume, sample time, and study date as potential sources of heterogeneity.

RESULTS

The search identified 6102 articles; 16 were included for meta-analysis. Of these, 12 used culture and five used rapid testing as a secondary testing method. Meta-analysis was based on a total of 103 968 components tested by secondary culture and 114 697 by rapid testing. The residual detection rate using secondary culture (DR_SC ) was 0.93 (95% CI, 0.24-0.6) per 1000 components, while residual detection rate using rapid testing (DR_RT ) was 0.09 (95% CI, 0.01-0.25) per 1000 components. Primary culture detection rate was the only statistically significant source of heterogeneity.

CONCLUSION

We evaluated bacterial detection rates after primary culture using rapid testing and secondary culture. These results provide a lower and upper bound on real-world residual clinical risk because these methods are designed to detect high-level exposures or any level of exposure, respectively. Rapid testing may miss some harmful exposures and secondary culture may identify some clinically insignificant exposures.

The comparative safety of bacterial risk control strategies for platelet components: a simulation study

BACKGROUND

Bacterial contamination of platelets is a problem that can lead to harmful septic transfusion reactions. The US Food and Drug Administration published a guidance in September 2019 detailing several permissible risk control strategies. Our objective was to compare the safety of each bacterial testing strategy for apheresis platelets.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

We used simulation to compare safety of the nine risk control strategies involving apheresis platelet testing. The primary outcome was the risk of exposure. An exposure event occurred if a patient received platelets exceeding a specific contamination threshold (>0, 10³ , and 10⁵ colony-forming units (CFU/mL). We generated a range of bacterial contamination scenarios (inoculum size, doubling time, lag time) and compared risk of exposure for each policy in each contamination scenario. We then computed the average risk difference over all scenarios.

RESULTS

At the 0 CFU/mL exposure threshold, two-step policies that used secondary culture ranked best (all top three), while single-step 24-hour culture with 3-day expiration ranked last (ninth). This latter policy performed well (median rank of 1) at both the 10³ and 10⁵ CFU/mL thresholds, but 48-hour culture with 7-day expiration performed relatively poorly. At these higher thresholds, median ranks of two-step policies that used secondary culture were again top three. Two-step policies that used rapid testing improved at the higher (10⁵ CFU/mL) harm threshold, with median rankings between 1 and 5.

CONCLUSION

Two-step policies that used secondary culture were generally safer than single-step policies. Performance of two-step policies that used rapid testing depended on the CFU per milliter threshold of exposure used.

Current advances in transfusion medicine: a 2019 review of selected topics from the AABB Clinical Transfusion Medicine Committee

BACKGROUND

The AABB Clinical Transfusion Medicine Committee (CTMC) compiles an annual synopsis of the published literature covering important developments in the field of transfusion medicine (TM) for the board of director's review. This synopsis is now made available as a manuscript published in TRANSFUSION.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

CTMC committee members review original manuscripts including TM-related topics published in different journals between late 2018 and 2019. The selection of topics and manuscripts are discussed at committee meetings and are chosen based on relevance and originality. After the topics and manuscripts are selected, committee members work in pairs to create a synopsis of the topics, which is then reviewed by two committee members. The first and senior authors of this manuscript assembled the final manuscript. Although this synopsis is comprehensive, it is not exhaustive, and some papers may have been excluded or missed.

RESULTS

The following topics are included: infectious risks to the blood supply, iron donor studies, pre-transfusion testing interference and genotyping, cold agglutinin disease (CAD), HLA alloimmunization in platelet transfusions, patient blood management, updates to TACO and TRALI definitions, pediatric TM, and advances in apheresis medicine.

CONCLUSION

This synopsis provides easy access to relevant topics and may be useful as an educational tool.

Bacterial contamination rate of platelet components by primary culture: a systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Platelets have the highest bacterial contamination risk of all blood components, and septic transfusion reactions remain a problem. A good estimate of contamination rates could provide information about residual risk and inform optimal testing strategies. We performed a systematic review and meta-analysis of platelet contamination rates by primary culture.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

A literature search in December 2019 identified articles on platelet contamination rates using primary culture. We used meta-analysis to estimate the overall rate of contamination and meta-regression to identify heterogeneity. We studied the following sources of heterogeneity: collection method, sample volume, positivity criteria, and study date. Contamination rate estimates were obtained for apheresis (AP), platelet rich plasma (PRP), and buffy coat (BC) collection methods.

RESULTS

The search identified 6102 studies, and 22 were included for meta-analysis. Among these 22 studies, there were 21 AP cohorts (4,072,022 components), 4 PRP cohorts (138,869 components), and 15 BC cohorts (1,474,679 components). The overall mean contamination rate per 1000 components was 0.51 (95% CI: 0.38-0.67) including AP (0.23, 95% CI: 0.18-0.28), PRP, (0.38, 95% CI: 0.15-0.70), and BC (1.12, 95% CI: 0.51-1.96). There was considerable variability within each collection method. Sample volume, positivity criteria, and publication year were significant sources of heterogeneity.

CONCLUSION

The bacterial contamination rate of platelets by primary culture is 1 in 1961. AP and PRP components showed a lower contamination rate than BC components. There is clinically significant between-study variability for each method. Larger sample volumes increased sensitivity, and bacterial contamination rates have decreased over time.

The association of inpatient blood utilization and diagnosis-related group weight: implications for risk-adjusted benchmarking

BACKGROUND

Risk-adjusted benchmarking could be useful to compare blood utilization between hospitals or individual groups, such as physicians, while accounting for differences in patient complexity. The aim of this study was to analyze the association of red blood cell (RBC) use and diagnosis-related group (DRG) weights across all inpatient hospital stays to determine the suitability of using DRGs for between-hospital risk-adjusted benchmarking. Specific hierarchical organizational units (surgical vs. nonsurgical patients, departments, and physicians) were also evaluated.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

We studied blood use among all adult inpatients, and within organizational units, over 4 years (May 2014 to March 2018) at an academic center. Number of RBCs transfused, all patient refined (APR)-DRGs, and other variables were captured over entire hospital stays. We used multilevel generalized linear modeling (zero-inflated negative binomial) to study the relationship between RBC utilization and APR-DRG.

RESULTS

A total of 97,955 hospital stays were evaluated and the median APR-DRG weight was 1.2. The association of RBCs transfused and APR-DRG weight was statistically significant at all hierarchical levels (incidence rate ratio = 1.22; p < 0.001). The impact of APR-DRG on blood use, measured by the incidence rate ratio, demonstrated an association at the all-patient and surgical levels, at several department and physician levels, but not at the medical patient level. The relationship between RBCs transfused and APR-DRG varied across organizational units.

CONCLUSION

Number of RBCs transfused was associated with APR-DRG weight at multiple hierarchical levels and could be used for risk-adjusted benchmarking in those contexts. The relationship between RBC use and APR-DRG varied across organizational units.

Response to random apheresis platelets versus HLA-selected platelets versus pooled platelets in HLA-sensitized patients

BACKGROUND

It is unknown how pooled platelets (PPs) compare to random apheresis platelets (RAPs) when HLA-selected platelets (PLTs) are unavailable for HLA-sensitized patients. The aim of this study was to compare patient responses to RAPs, HLA-selected PLTs, and PPs in HLA-sensitized patients.

STUDY DESIGN AND METHODS

This is a single-institution retrospective study of patients from January 2014 to April 2017 with a class I calculated panel-reactive antibody of 60% or more. Response to transfusion was determined by a corrected count increment (CCI) up to 1 hour after completion of transfusion. A CCI of 5 or more was considered successful.

RESULTS

Seventy-seven units of RAPs, 412 units of HLA-selected PLT, and 388 units PPs were transfused. Mean CCIs when transfusing RAPs, HLA-selected PLTs, and PPs were 2.82, 11.44, and 4.77, respectively (p < 0.0001). Posttest comparison between RAPs and PPs revealed no significant difference in mean CCI while there was a significant difference between HLA-selected PLTs versus RAPs and HLA-selected PLTs versus PPs. The success rates of RAPs, HLA-selected PLTs, and PPs were 31%, 80%, and 35% respectively. There was no significant association of type of PLT and success rate when comparing RAPs versus PPs (p = 0.51) while there was a significant association between success rate and type of PLT transfusion when comparing HLA-selected PLTs with RAPs and PPs.

CONCLUSION

HLA-selected PLTs resulted in higher mean CCIs and more successful transfusions. There was no significant difference in mean CCI or success rate when transfusing RAPs versus PPs to HLA-sensitized patients. Future studies should assess clinical outcomes in HLA-sensitized patients receiving each type of PLT product.

A data-driven patient blood management strategy in liver transplantation

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Blood utilization during liver transplant has decreased, but remains highly variable due to many complex surgical and physiologic factors. Previous models attempted to predict utilization using preoperative variables to stratify cases into two usage groups, usually using entire blood units for measurement. We sought to develop a practical predictive model using specific transfusion volumes (in ml) to develop a data-driven patient blood management strategy.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This is a retrospective evaluation of primary liver transplants at a single institution from 2013 to 2015. Multivariable analysis of preoperative recipient and donor factors was used to develop a model predictive of intraoperative red-blood-cell (pRBC) use.

RESULTS

Of 256 adult liver transplants, 207 patients had complete transfusion volume data for analysis. The median intraoperative allogeneic pRBC transfusion volume was 1250 ml, and the average was 1563 ± 1543 ml. Preoperative haemoglobin, spontaneous bacterial peritonitis, preoperative haemodialysis and preoperative international normalized ratio together yielded the strongest model predicting pRBC usage. When it predicted <1250 ml of pRBCs, all cases with 0 ml transfused were captured and only 8·6% of the time >1250 ml were used. This prediction had a sensitivity of 0·91 and a specificity of 0·89. If predicted usage was >2000 ml, 75% of the time blood loss exceeded 2000 ml.

CONCLUSION

Patients likely to require low or high pRBC transfusion volumes were identified with excellent accuracy using this predictive model at our institution. This model may help predict bleeding risk for each patient and facilitate optimized blood ordering.

Quality Improvement After Multiple Fatal Transfusion-Transmitted Bacterial Infections

OBJECTIVES

Transfusion-transmitted bacterial infection (TTBI) from platelet components is likely underrecognized and can be fatal. Twenty-four-hour prospective culture was felt to be insufficiently preventive after multiple TTBIs occurred and strategies to improve safety were sought.

METHODS

Two fatal and one severe TTBIs occurred from a split-apheresis platelet donation contaminated with Klebsiella pneumoniae. Improvement opportunities were identified and corrective and preventive action (CAPA) followed.

RESULTS

To mitigate bacterial contamination and improve detection sensitivity, additional prospective culture 48 hours postcollection was implemented. Since implementation, secondary cultures have caught two true positives (0.01%) missed by 24-hour culture. Bacterial testing at issue and pathogen reduction were later implemented as an added layer of safety.

CONCLUSION

While rare, TTBI is a prominent cause of morbidity and mortality from contaminated platelets. The approach to CAPA presented here may lower the risk of future transfusion-transmitted infections but must be weighed against potential added costs.

Building a New Transfusion Service

OBJECTIVES

For over 60 years, Harborview Medical Center (HMC) in Seattle has received its blood components and pretransfusion testing from a centralized transfusion service operated by the regional blood supplier. In 2011, a hospital-based transfusion service (HBTS) was activated.

METHODS

After 5 years of operation, we evaluated the effects of the HBTS by reviewing records of hospital blood use, quality system events, blood product delivery times, and costs. Furthermore, the effects of in-house expertise on laboratory medicine resident and medical laboratory scientist student training, as well as regulatory and accrediting agency concerns, were reviewed.

RESULTS

Blood use records from 2003 to 2015 demonstrated large reductions in blood component procurement, allocation, transfusion, and wastage with decreases in costs temporally related to the change in service. The turnaround time for thawed plasma for trauma patients decreased from 90 to 3 minutes. Transfusion medicine education metrics for residents and laboratory technology students improved significantly. HMC researchers brought in $2 million in transfusion research funding.

CONCLUSIONS

HMC successfully transitioned to an HBTS, providing world-class primary transfusion support to a level 1 trauma center. Near-term benefits in patient care, education, and research resulted. Blood support became faster, safer, and cheaper.

Transportation Cooler Interventions Reduce Plasma and RBC Product Wastage

OBJECTIVES

The rate of plasma product wastage for the United States in 2011 was approximately 1.8%. The plasma wastage rate at our institution was higher, mainly due to products returned out of temperature range from procedural areas. A process review and intervention to reduce plasma wastage was undertaken, which included modifications to our transport cooler.

METHODS

A new cooler system was designed, and this device was implemented alongside an updated protocol for delivering plasma while also enhancing the previous RBC cooler validation time. We audited plasma and RBC product wastage prior to these interventions, from January 2013 to February 2014, vs after the intervention from April 2014 to March 2015.

RESULTS

After the intervention, the monthly plasma wastage rate declined 60% (12.6 units/100 units transfused preintervention vs 5.0 units/100 units transfused postintervention; P < .0001). The monthly RBC wastage rate also decreased 28% (3.2 units/100 units transfused preintervention vs 2.3 units/100 units transfused postintervention; P < .01).

CONCLUSIONS

Our intervention resulted in significantly decreased plasma and RBC wastage and is broadly applicable, since out-of-temperature product wastage in procedural areas is likely a significant problem at many institutions.

Cyclin D3 coordinates the cell cycle during differentiation to regulate erythrocyte size and number

Genome-wide association studies (GWASs) have identified a genetic variant of moderate effect size at 6p21.1 associated with erythrocyte traits in humans. We show that this variant affects an erythroid-specific enhancer of CCND3. A Ccnd3 knockout mouse phenocopies these erythroid phenotypes, with a dramatic increase in erythrocyte size and a concomitant decrease in erythrocyte number. By examining human and mouse primary erythroid cells, we demonstrate that the CCND3 gene product cyclin D3 regulates the number of cell divisions that erythroid precursors undergo during terminal differentiation, thereby controlling erythrocyte size and number. We illustrate how cell type-specific specialization can occur for general cell cycle components-a finding resulting from the biological follow-up of unbiased human genetic studies.

Cucurbitacins as kairomones for diabroticite beetles

The characteristic bitter substances of the Cucurbitaceae act as kairomones for a large group of diabroticite beetles (Chrysomelidae, Galerucinae, Luperini), promoting host selection and compulsive feeding behavior. These beetles (e.g., Diabrotica undecimpunctata howardi) respond to as little as 1 ng of cucurbitacin (Cuc) B on thin-layer plates by arrest and compulsive feeding. Six species of diabroticite beetles were about 10 times more responsive to Cuc B than to Cuc E and less responsive to Cuc D, I, and L. Chloroform extracts of 18 species of Cucurbita were developed on thin-layer chromatograms and exposed to diabroticite beetles. The feeding patterns showed pronounced beetle responses to three general Cuc distribution patterns: Cuc B and D as in Cucurbita andreana and C. ecuadorensis; Cuc E and I as in C. okeechobeensis and C. martinezii; and Cuc E glycoside in C. texana. All the diabroticites responded in exactly the same feeding patterns. The results demonstrate a coevolutionary association between the Cucurbitaceae and the Luperini, during which the intensely bitter and toxic Cucs that arose to repel herbivores and protect the plants from attack became specific kairomone feeding stimulants for the beetles.

Requirement for increased IL-10 in the development of B-1 lymphoproliferative disease in a murine model of CLL

Malignant B-1 cells derived from NZB mice, a murine model of spontaneous autoimmunity and B cell lymphoproliferative disease, produce significantly higher levels of IL-10 mRNA than normal B-1 or B cells. IL-10 may act as an autocrine growth factor for the expansion of malignant B-1 cells. In order to determine if elevated endogenous production of IL-10 was a required element for the malignant transformation of B-1 cells in NZB mice, backcross animals were studied for the linkage between elevated IL-10 expression and the presence of lymphoid malignancy. The phenotypes of aged (NZB x DBA/2)F1 x NZB animals were determined and a strong correlation was found between the elevated levels of IL-10 mRNA and the development of B-1 malignant clones. In contrast, an increased level of IL-10 message was not associated with elevated serum IgM or the presence of anemia or reticulocytosis which is mainly seen in response to autoantibody production. These results indicate that, at least in NZB, the autoimmunity and lymphoproliferation phenotypes are not linked genetically. IL-10 may enhance proliferation and the development of B-1 cell malignancy rather than antibody production by the B-1 cell subpopulation. Thus, IL-10 plays an important role in B-1 malignancies, and downregulation of IL-10 could be a likely site for intervention in B cell malignancies.

The natural history of a lymphoproliferative disorder in aged NZB mice

The molecular lesions of human familial and common B-CLL remain unknown. As an approach to this problem, aged NZB mice with a B cell lymphoproliferative disorder were chosen as a murine model. Three groups of NZB mice (2 months, 6 months and > 18 months) for a total of nineteen were studied. A complete autopsy including a CBC was performed on each mouse. Spleen cells were immunophenotyped and cell cycle analysis was performed. Spleen weight, peritoneal cell counts and absolute lymphocytes counts were all elevated in the oldest group. All mice showed evidence of extramedulary hematopoiesis and the older group showed lymphocytic infiltrates in the lacrymal glands, kidneys, liver and lungs. Two of the seven aged mice had a malignant lymphoma. One was a marginal zone lymphoma and the other a lymphocytic lymphoma. Splenic immunophenotyping showed a loss of T cells with an increase in B cells as the mice age. Cell cycle analysis revealed hyperdiploidy in all of the aged mice with a decrease in the percentage G0G1 cells. This disease appears to involve an absolute lymphocytosis of the peritoneum and the peripheral blood compartment. This is associated with splenic aneuploidy. The infiltration of the spleen by malignant cells of varying morphology is a late event. The aged NZB mouse continues to be a model for human B-CLL.

p53 mutations in lung cancers from Japanese mustard gas workers

Mustard gas (MG) is a mutagenic and carcinogenic alkylating agent, and is a known risk factor for occupational lung cancer. Our hypothesis is that lung cancers from MG workers contain mutations (G:C to A:T transitions) as the result of MG-produced DNA promutagenic adducts in the p53 tumor suppressor gene. We analyzed 12 primary lung cancers from Japanese MG factory workers and 12 lung cancers from non-exposed individuals. Genomic DNA was isolated from archival paraffin-embedded tissues. Exons 5-8 were amplified by polymerase chain reaction using p53-specific primers, and sequenced by dideoxy termination methods. Six out of 12 lung cancers from MG workers contained a total of eight somatic point mutations: two cases had double G:C to A:T transitions; one had a G:C to T:A transversion; one case had an A:T to G:C transition; and two cases had single base deletions. Four of the six mutated purines occurred on the non-transcribed, DNA-coding strand. Out of 12 unexposed cases, there were six single base mutations in six cancers, and no double mutations. The p53 mutational frequency in the MG-exposed cases is similar to the non-exposed controls and the usual smoking-related lung cancers reported previously. However, the distinctive double mutations (G:C to A:T transition) observed in two cases are unusual and may be related to MG exposure.

p53 protein accumulates frequently in early bronchial neoplasia

p53 mutations are common in human lung cancer and frequently generate levels of p53 protein that are detectable by immunohistochemistry. For this reason, p53 protein accumulation is a candidate biomarker, but little is known about its timing or frequency in multistage bronchial carcinogenesis. We studied human lung tissues containing preinvasive squamous neoplasms from 34 donors with and without lung cancer. Nuclear p53 protein was present in 0% of normal mucosas, 6.7% of squamous metaplasias, 29.5% of mild dysplasias, 26.9% of moderate dysplasias, 59.7% of severe dysplasias, 58.5% of carcinomas in situ, 67.5% of microinvasive carcinomas, and 79.5% of invasive tumors. These data indicate that (a) p53 protein accumulates in about 30% of the earliest recognized neoplastic lesions (i.e., mild dysplasia), (b) there is an increasing frequency of p53 protein accumulation starting with mild dysplasia, and (c) p53 protein accumulates infrequently in normal or metaplastic mucosa. In a subset of six patients whose most advanced lesion was carcinoma in situ without evidence of invasive cancer, p53 protein was detected in 0% of normal mucosas, 8.3% of squamous metaplasias, 37.5% of mild dysplasias, 12.5% of moderate dysplasias, 93.8% of severe dysplasias, and 55% of carcinoma in situ lesions. These data show clearly that p53 alterations can occur before invasion and suggest that the frequency is similar to that observed in the full series. Since two-thirds or more of lung cancers have p53 alterations, the timing and frequency of p53 protein accumulation make the p53 tumor suppressor gene an attractive marker for early diagnosis and evaluation of chemoprevention agents.

p53 gene mutation and integrated hepatitis B viral DNA sequences in human liver cancer cell lines

A G:C-->T:A mutational hotspot at codon 249 of the p53 tumor suppressor gene has previously been identified in hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC) of patients from Qidong, China and southern Africa in which aflatoxin B1 (AFB1) and hepatitis B virus (HBV) are known synergistic risk factors. We have examined p53 mutation patterns of HCC from geographic areas in which the risk factors vary. Nine HCC lines and four hepatoblastoma lines (HB) were examined for p53 gene mutations and the relationship with HBV infection. Five of the nine HCC lines had homozygous mutation or deletion randomly distributed in exons 6-8, whereas none of the four HB cell lines had p53 mutations. One of the four HB lines (HepG2) had an N-ras mutation at codon 61 position 2. The p53 point mutations in the three HCC cell lines from Japan resulted in the amino acid changes of cysteine for tyrosine in cell line HuH 7 at codon 220 (A:T-->G:C), alanine for glycine in cell line HLF at codon 244 (G:C-->C:G), and serine for arginine in cell line HLE at codon 249 (G:C-->C:G). In addition, the deletion of 18 base pairs from codon 264 position 3 to codon 270 position 1 has resulted in the deletion of Leu-Gly-Arg-Asn-Ser-Phe from the amino acids sequences 256-270 in the Japanese cell line HuH 4. The cell line PLC/PRF/5 that showed p53 mutation at codon 249 (G:C-->T:A) with substitution of serine for arginine was derived from a South African patient. Our results indicate that whereas the p53 gene is not mutated in the HB cell lines, the HCC cell lines frequently contain an abnormal p53 gene. In addition, p53 point mutations were not detected in the four Japanese HCC cell lines that were positive for genomic integration of HBV X-gene and surface antigen gene. The three Japanese HCC cell lines with p53 mutations did not contain HBV sequences, indicating that hepatocarcinogenesis associated with p53 mutation does not require the genomic integration of HBV sequences.