Advanced multiple beam equalization radiography (AMBER) combined with computed radiography. Preliminary evaluation

The combined use of AMBER (Advanced Multiple Beam Equalization Radiography) and a digital storage phosphor (SP) radiography system was evaluated for chest radiography in a pilot study with 4 patients. Four image modes with different dose levels were compared: the SP in combination with an AMBER equalized exposure (SP/AMBER) and 3 nonequalized exposures with dose levels corresponding to the respective calculated AMBER lung dose (SP/lung field dose), the calculated AMBER mediastinal dose (SP/mediastinal dose) and the calculated AMBER average dose (SP/average dose). All image modes were matched for Hurter and Driffield characteristics and subjectively rated according to visibility of details. The improved signal-to-noise (S/N) ratio of SP/AMBER resulted in a better visualization of structures in the mediastinum and the basal lung where SP/lung field dose scored lowest. For the central lung no quality differences were seen between techniques. The compressed dynamic range of the SP/AMBER images was more easily displayed on the hard-copy film. The combination of AMBER with SP radiography promises to overcome the dynamic range limitations of digital displays while, at moderate doses, giving better S/N and image quality than standard SP technique.

Improved parameters for unsharp mask filtering of digital chest radiographs

Observer performance with four unsharp mask filtering algorithms for storage phosphor chest radiographs was compared with that with conventional screen-film radiographs in the detection of three types of simulated lung disease: nodules, fine lines, and micronodule clusters. Previously studied parameter sets (small [1.4-mm] and medium [5-mm] filter masks) and two new parameter sets (large [2.5-cm] and ultralarge [7-cm] masks) were compared by means of receiver operating characteristic analysis. With medium and small masks, nodule detection was inferior to that achieved with other modes. Use of ultralarge masks decreased the detection of lines compared with detection with conventional screen-film radiographs. Although detection of micronodule clusters was worse with digital images than with conventional screen-film radiographs, results with large and ultralarge masks were better than with small masks. Overall, filtering with large masks was best suited for simultaneously matching linear, nodular, and micronodular structures. These results suggest that lesion-specific processing of digital chest images is not necessary.

Visualization of basal pleural space and lung with advanced multiple beam equalization radiography (AMBER)

During clinical use of AMBER (Advanced Multiple Beam Equalization Radiography) it was frequently felt that the basal lung and pleural space were better appreciated than with standard chest radiography. We aimed to quantify the amount of additional relevant anatomy seen in this part region and to review the normal radiographic anatomy. Four hundred patients without known chest disease were evaluated. Two groups of 200 patients (50% female) were studied with either AMBER or standard chest radiography (140 kVp, 180 cm FFD, Kodak Tmat G film, Lanex regular screen; for both techniques). Visualization of the pleural sinuses (in percent of the transverse thoracic diameter) and the basal pulmonary vessels (4-point scale) was evaluated by a panel of 3 radiologists. The shape of the sinus was traced if sufficiently visible and subjectively evaluated. A significantly (P < 0.05) larger segment of the dorsal (41 +/- 34%) and ventral (14 +/- 15%) sinuses was seen with the AMBER technique than with the standard technique (16 +/- 21% and 9 +/- 11%, respectively). Vessel visibility was also significantly (P < 0.001) better with AMBER (3.2 +/- 0.6) than with the standard technique (1.9 +/- 0.6). The dorsal sinus showed alternatively a curved or pointed configuration.

Chest "gestalt" and detectability of lung lesions

Image perception in chest radiography is thought to occur on two levels, (a) a fast global response based on learned templates ("gestalt") and, (b) a slower systematic scan process. The relative importance of "gestalt" on the detection of nodular lung cancers was studied by disturbing the "gestalt" through rotation of the radiograph but not actually diminishing the image content available for viewing. Sixty chest radiographs (20 normals, 21 with subtle lung cancers, 19 with obvious lung cancers) were presented to three readers in normal and abnormal (rotated randomly in 90 degree increments) orientation for varying durations (0.25 s, 1 s, 4 s and unlimited viewing time). The results indicate that the detectability of obvious and subtle lung lesions was degraded by the disturbed "gestalt" for both short and long viewing times. The readers did not significantly increase their unlimited viewing time when faced with rotated images (4.4 +/- 3.4 s) as opposed to non-rotated images (4.0 +/- 3.2 s). We conclude that the detection of lung lesions relies heavily on the chest "gestalt" and that systematic scanning cannot fully compensate for an impaired global response due to a disturbed "gestalt."

Impact of hard-copy size on observer performance in digital chest radiography

To determine the impact of reduced hard-copy size on diagnostic performance of digital radiography, screen-film chest radiographs were compared with isodose digital storage phosphor radiographs in the detection of simulated nodules, fine pulmonary lines, and micronodular opacities superimposed on the chests of 10 healthy volunteers. Digital radiographs were laser-printed in a full-size conventional format and in image lengths of two-thirds, one-half, and five-elevenths of the conventional format. Eighteen thousand observations by eight radiologists were analyzed by use of receiver operating characteristics. The detectability of lines and micronodular opacities decreased with declining image format size. In the detection of micronodular opacities, only the nearly full-size digital images were equivalent to conventional images. In the detection of linear opacities, reduction of image length by one-half or more reduced performance (analysis of variance, P less than .05). Only for the detection of nodules was no major difference found.

Comparison between high-field-strength MR imaging and CT for screening of hepatic metastases: a receiver operating characteristic analysis

The diagnostic performance of high-field-strength magnetic resonance (MR) imaging (1.5 T) for detection of liver metastases was compared with that of computed tomography (CT). All patients (n = 52) underwent preoperative screening for metastases by means of MR imaging with T1-weighted, proton-density-weighted, and T2-weighted pulse sequences and CT scanning with unenhanced, incremental dynamic bolus-enhanced, and delayed contrast medium-enhanced techniques. Diagnostic performance was evaluated by means of receiver operating characteristic analysis in which 800 images (400 with and 400 without lesions) and five readers (4,000 observations) were used; images were obtained from patients (n = 39) in whom the same anatomic levels were available for all MR imaging and CT studies. Direct comparison between the best MR imaging technique (T2-weighted spin-echo imaging [repetition time, 2,000 msec; echo time, 70 msec]) and the best CT technique (incremental dynamic bolus CT) showed a strong trend of superiority of T2-weighted MR imaging over incremental dynamic bolus CT. No highly statistically significant difference (P greater than or equal to .01), however, was found between these two techniques.

[The visibility of a central venous catheter using digital luminescence radiography in intensive care radiology]

The aim of the following study was to assess the impact of dose alterations on the detection of catheters. We compared the performance of well-exposed conventional and digital portable chest radiographs in the detection of thin catheters and tested the influences of dose alterations. Portable chest radiographs of 20 patients were obtained with conventional film/screen (FR) and with storage phosphors at 50% (SRL), 100% (SRN), and 250% (SRH) of the conventionally required exposure dose. The region of the mediastinum was subdivided into an average of 18 fields, 50% of which were superimposed with thin catheter segments. ROC analysis of 11,600 observations by 8 readers found only SRH equivalent to FR in catheter visualisation. Performance decreased significantly with SRN and SRL. Detection of low contrast catheters was found to be significantly decreased in storage phosphor radiographs obtained with standard exposure dose. A dose reduction is not feasible with current equipment if performance equivalent to conventional radiography is to be achieved.

Hardware and software artifacts in storage phosphor radiography

Hardware and software artifacts in digital radiographs acquired with storage phosphor systems can seriously impair image quality and imitate or mask abnormalities. These artifacts are caused by image plate, image reader, and laser printer defects; faulty image readout; processing errors; and unsharp masking. The artifacts can simulate calcifications and pneumothoraces or conceal low-contrast ill-defined lesions and subtle lesions along opacity interfaces. Hardware artifacts need to be recognized and properly traced to repair the system or improve its maintenance. Artifacts due to software characteristics and image post-processing must also be identified to ensure adequate system handling and adjustment of postprocessing algorithms.

[Digital radiography: optimization of chest radiographs using a modified exposure control]

Phototiming over the lung fields frequently compromises the signal-to-noise ratio available in the mediastinal and diaphragmatic regions of the chest. A moderate dose increase would be justified if a significant improvement in diagnostic performance could be achieved. We compared the impact of mediastinal phototiming (150 kVp, 150 cm FFD, 1.0 mm focus, 12:1 grid [higher kVp chosen to minimize dose increase]) to standard lungfield phototiming (125 kVp, 150 cm FFD, 1.0 mm focus, 12:1 grid) on the detectability of simulated pulmonary nodules (wax, 0.5-2.5 cm in diameter) superimposed on human volunteers in storage phosphor radiographs (1744 x 2144 pixels, 10 bit). ROC analysis of 1920 observations by 8 readers showed a significantly higher (p less than 0.03) detectability of simulated pulmonary nodules with mediastinal phototiming (ROC area = 0.89) than standard lungfield phototiming (ROC area = 0.84).

[Digital projection radiography]

Several hundred storage phosphor digital projection radiography (DR) systems are in operation in many parts of the world in experimental and clinical settings. They are used clinically for almost all projection radiographic studies except mammography. An overview is given of the experimental and clinical results achieved so far. Image post-processing has yet to meet the initial expectations. The average image quality will certainly improve with automatic brightness control. Edge enhancement should be performed in selected applications only. A true increase in diagnostic information probably cannot be expected except with dual energy techniques. Dose reductions are possible only in those studies in which the specific imaging task permits a decrease in signal-to-noise ratio.

Storage phosphor versus screen-film radiography: effect of varying exposure parameters and unsharp mask filtering on the detectability of cortical bone defects

Diagnostic performance with storage phosphor radiography is influenced by exposure parameters and digital filtering algorithms. The authors compared the detectability of cortical lesions in excised human femoral shafts on state-of-the-art screen-film radiographs and storage phosphor digital radiographs. For the digital system, the effect of varying exposure parameters (photon flux and tube voltage) and unsharp mask filtering (kernel size and enhancement factor) was tested. Analysis of receiver operating characteristics was performed for 10,560 observations made by eight radiologists. Under identical exposure conditions, storage phosphor imaging yielded no significant advantages over conventional screen-film radiography. Although large variations in exposure dose are possible with storage phosphors, the potential for dose reduction was limited even by means of an increase in tube voltage. The performance with unsharp masked images declined with decreasing kernel size and pronounced enhancement.

[Preliminary results with digital luminescence radiography in radiotherapy]

Port films in radiation therapy suffer from low image contrast und exposure errors. We examined the potential of computed radiography with a storage phosphor system (FCR-901/Siemens Digiscan) to overcome these drawbacks. Port films of various treatment sites were obtained for both, conventional films and digital storage phosphor screens with a DuPont cassette and steel intensifier screens under identical exposure settings. We examined port films from a linear accelerator and from a 60Co source. We found a superior contrast in the digital images and an almost total elimination of exposure errors. The differences between digital and conventional images, however, were less pronounced with films from the 60Co source. Unsharp mask filtering (medium kernel size, moderate enhancement) further improved image quality. Several sources of artefacts in the digital images could be described.

Digital storage phosphor imaging versus conventional film radiography in CT-documented chest disease

The advantages of imaging the chest with digital storage phosphor radiography (SR) may be nullified by its spatial resolution, which is lower than that of conventional film radiography (FR). To test the reader detection performance with the two modalities under clinical conditions, the authors compared 140-kVp isoexposure SR (system resolution: 0.2 mm, 10 bits) and FR images of a variety of chest abnormalities proved by computed tomography (CT) (157 patients, 244 abnormalities, 5,652 observations, six readers). In all tests, SR was as good as or better than FR (P less than .05). In overall detection, indicated by the average area of receiver operating characteristics, SR and FR were equivalent. SR was superior for mediastinal lesions and for pulmonary opacities greater than 2 cm in diameter. For all other types of pulmonary lesions and pleural abnormalities, SR and FR were equivalent. Currently available commercial SR systems can replace film radiographic systems in the detection of a wide variety of chest lesions. SR is likely to enable better visualization than FR in the detection of mediastinal and large pulmonary abnormalities.

Improved control of image optical density with low-dose digital and conventional radiography in bedside imaging

The technical and diagnostic performance of simultaneously acquired low-dose (44% of standard dose) storage-phosphor digital radiographs (system resolution = 0.2 mm, 10 bits) were compared with those of standard-dose conventional bedside radiographs of the chest in 32 patients. The mean optical density (OD) of the lungs (800 measurements) was closer to the ideal density with digital radiography (1.45 OD +/- 0.20 [standard deviation] vs 1.75 OD +/- 0.53) and was less often outside the usable range (2.5% vs 42.5%). Receiver operating characteristic analysis for detection of simulated nodules and monitoring devices (nine readers, 4,608 observations) showed that digital radiography was superior to conventional radiography (P less than .05) for four of the nine readers and equivalent to conventional radiography for five readers. The authors concluded that digital radiography produces more consistent and ideal image density and performs at least as well as conventional radiography under phantom test conditions.

High frequency edge enhancement in the detection of fine pulmonary lines. Parity between storage phosphor digital images and conventional chest radiography

Fine linear structures represent a severe test of the minimum spatial resolution that is needed for digital chest imaging. We studied the comparative observer performance of storage phosphor digital imaging (1760 X 2140 pixel matrix, 10 bits deep), and conventional radiography (Lanex medium screen, Ortho C film) in the detection of simulated fine pulmonary lines superimposed on the normal chest when exposure factors were identical (20mR skin entrance dose at 141 kVp). Receiver operating characteristics analysis of 2160 observations by six readers found that high frequency edge-enhanced digital images (ROC area: 0.78 +/- 0.06) performed better than unenhanced digital images (ROC area: 0.70 +/- 0.07) (P less than 0.01 for paired t-test), and that edge enhanced digital images performed on a par with conventional radiography (ROC area: 0.78 +/- 0.09). We conclude that for the detection of fine linear structures, storage phosphor digital images can perform on a par with higher resolution conventional chest radiographs when a high frequency edge-enhancement algorithm is employed.

[ROC: a method for comparing the diagnostic performance of imaging procedures]

ROC analysis permits an evaluation of the diagnostic performance of imaging systems by incorporating the individual decision threshold of the diagnostician that determines the relation between sensitivity and specificity of a tested system. It therefore facilitates the comparison between different imaging systems and observers. A thorough knowledge and sophistication of this methodology is of special importance in the comparison of digital and conventional projection radiography because the images in question may have a very similar character. The method is explained and special points of interest (standard of "truth", size of sample, lesion conspicuity and localisation, viewing time and determination of significance) are emphasised.

"Single-exposure" dual energy digital radiography in the detection of pulmonary nodules and calcifications

We studied the detectability of mineralized and non-mineralized simulated pulmonary nodules with dual energy digital radiography. "Soft tissue" and "bone" images (pixel size = 0.2 mm, 10 bits deep) were obtained with subtraction image processing after a single simultaneous exposure (100 kVp, 8 mAs, 17 mR skin exposure dose) of two storage phosphors with an interleaved 0.9 mm copper wafer. Three classes of paraffin-based nodules (0.5 to 3.0 cm) of varying mineral concentration (0, 120 and 190 mg/cm3 K2HPO4) were randomly positioned on the chest wall of two healthy volunteers to simulate calcified and non-calcified nodules. The average receiver operating characteristics (ROC) area of six readers (n = 2880 observations) showed that digital "bone" images (ROC area: 0.77 +/- 0.03) were significantly better (P less than 0.04) than conventional radiographs (OC Film, Lanex medium screens, 141 kVp, 19 mR skin exposure dose) (ROC area: 0.71 +/- 0.05) in detecting calcification in nodules. The unsubtracted digital images of lower kilovoltage were not superior to the 141 kVp conventional radiographs in a subgroup of two readers (ROC area: 0.73 +/- 0.02). Digital "soft tissue" images were equivalent to conventional chest radiographs in detecting soft tissue pulmonary nodules (ROC areas: 0.92 +/- 0.04 and 0.92 +/- 0.05, respectively.

Impact of postprocessing on the detection of simulated pulmonary nodules with digital radiography

The authors compared the impact of five postprocessing algorithms on diagnostic performance in the detection of simulated pulmonary nodules on storage phosphor-based digital chest radiographs. Tissue equivalent paraffin nodules (0.5-2.5 cm diameter) were randomly positioned over the chest of a normal volunteer. Receiver operating characteristics (ROC) analysis of a total of 2500 observations by five readers indicated that the default unenhanced image having the appearance of a conventional chest radiograph (ROC area = 0.87 +/- 0.05) was as good as an image with moderate enhancement of medium frequencies (ROC area = 0.85 +/- 0.03), an image with reversed gray scale polarity (ROC area = 0.84 +/- 0.02), an image with reversed gray scale and moderate enhancement of medium frequencies (ROC area = 0.87 +/- 0.03), and an image with a linear rather than a sigmoid gradation curve and incorporating moderate enhancement of medium frequencies (ROC area = 0.87 +/- 0.03). The authors conclude that the specific algorithms they tested had no effect on the detection of pulmonary nodules.

[Digital radiography in thoracic diagnosis]

Technologies and performance of digital projection radiography are reviewed. Storage phosphor imaging plates can be used in existing diagnostic equipment and the resulting digital images permit the recognition of fine interstitial changes, if a high frequency edge enhancement is performed. While a generalized enhancement of low and medium spatial frequencies and a grey scale reversal do not improve the detectability of pulmonary nodules, selective enhancement of low frequencies in the mediastinal and retro-diaphragmatic areas may well improve diagnostic performance. Dose can be reduced if the resulting signal-to-noise ratio is adequate for diagnosis. Further dose savings can be achieved by the reduced number of retakes. Dual energy techniques improve the detectability and differential diagnosis of pulmonary nodules. The further development of picture archiving and communication systems (PACS) will turn the digital projection radiography into the method of choice for the diagnosis of chest disease.

Use of a modified needle in antegrade transfemoral arterial approach for diagnostic and interventional procedures

A modified needle for the antegrade transfemoral approach in diagnostic and interventional procedures is described that simplifies access to the superficial femoral artery, and that can easily be manufactured from standard puncture needles.

Single exposure simultaneous acquisition of digital and conventional radiographs utilizing unaltered dose

We describe the simultaneous acquisition of digital and conventional radiographs with a single standard radiographic exposure. A digitizable storage phosphor (ST Imaging Plate, FujiTM) is sandwiched into a radiographic cassette (X-Omatic, KodakTM) behind a conventional radiographic film-screen combination (Lanex medium screens, OC film, KodakTM). The barium fluorohalide storage phosphor is digitized with a helium-neon laser scanner (TCR 201, ToshibaTM), and the conventional radiograph is processed in the standard fashion (M7B, KodakTM). The storage phosphor is exposed by the "wasted" radiation normally exiting the back of the film-screen combination (32% of the cassette entrance dose at 141 kVp). At a standard exposure (6.3 mAs), the conventional radiograph is of unaltered quality, and the digital image appears to have an adequate signal-to-noise ratio for chest studies despite the lower exposure dose. This technique produces twin images of identical spatial and temporal registration and avoids the added radiation exposure normally required to carry out comparative studies.

A comparison of digitized storage phosphors and conventional mammography in the detection of malignant microcalcifications

The detectability of malignant tumor-derived microcalcifications with conventional mammography was compared to that with digital images (2000 X 2510 pixels by 10 bits) derived from a storage phosphor-based digital radiography system capable of 5 line pair/mm resolution at identical exposure factors (30 kVp, 250 mAs, 65 cm film-focus distance). Microcalcifications (50-800 microns in diameter) were randomly superimposed on a preserved human breast specimen. ROC analysis based on 480 observations made by four readers indicated that the ability to detect the calcifications with digital images (ROC area = 0.871 +/- 0.066) was equivalent to conventional mammography (ROC area = 0.866 +/- 0.075) despite lower spatial resolution. With digital mammography, 62% of all clusters were correctly localized, but only 23.6% of the individual calcifications were counted. With conventional mammography 61% of all clusters were correctly localized, but significantly more of the individual calcifications (31.5%) were counted.

Comparison of two screen-film combinations in contact and magnification mammography: detectability of microcalcifications

A new dual-screen, dual-emulsion-film combination that allows a decrease in radiation dose of approximately 66% was compared with a widely used single-screen, single-emulsion-film system in contact and magnification mammography. Clustered microcalcifications randomly superimposed on a breast phantom were detected, and the location and number of individual calcifications were determined by four observers. The detectability of calcifications, determined with a receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis area, was 0.92 for magnification and 0.82 for contact mammography with the single-emulsion-film system, compared with 0.84 and 0.72, respectively, with the dual-emulsion-film system. More clusters were correctly located and more individual calcifications were counted with magnification than with contact mammography. The dual-emulsion-film system with the magnification technique performs as well as the single-emulsion-film system with the contact technique, while retaining a decrease in required dose of approximately 40%.