Retinoids are endogenous to the porcine blastocyst and secreted by trophectoderm cells at functionally-active levels

Retinoic acid and its isomers are the major morphogens in vertebrate development. For mammals, it was previously considered that circulating retinoic acid was recruited from the uterine environment, to influence embryonic differentiation, morphogenesis and development. Here we report that retinoic acid is endogenous to the blastocyst of the domestic pig, Sus scrofa, as detected by high pressure liquid chromatography. Furthermore, using a continuous, normal line of porcine trophectoderm cells, TE1, we have identified the trophoblast as a major source of retinoids. Endogenous retinoic acid was found at a concentration of approximately 35 nM in extracts of entire blastocysts, and at a similar concentration in extracts of TE1 cells. Retinoids in explants of blastocysts and in conditioned medium from the TE1 cell line were found to be functionally-active, inducing gene expression from a retinoic-acid-responsive enhancer element in an in vitro assay system. In conclusion, we propose that there is a morphogenetic role for endogenous, and trophoblast-derived, retinoids in the early development of the pre-gastrulation porcine embryo; and that the TE1 cell line therefore provides a useful in vitro system for the study of retinoid metabolism. Furthermore, an implication of this study is that endogenous retinoids may play an active role in the pre-implantation embryology of other species, such as the human.

The role of vitamin A in the development of the central nervous system

We describe here the defects that arise in the central nervous system (CNS) of quail embryos when they develop in the absence of vitamin A. It has been assumed that because of the effects of excess vitamin A and its metabolites, particularly retinoic acid (RA), on the CNS they are involved in various aspects of CNS development. We show that this is indeed the case, because these deficient quail embryos have three defects in their CNS. First, the posterior hindbrain fails to develop because the cells fated to form this part of the CNS in the very early embryo die by apoptosis. Second, the neural tube fails to extend neurites into the periphery both in vivo and in vitro. Third, the neural crest cells throughout the embryo die by apoptosis. These results demonstrate a crucial requirement for vitamin A in CNS development.

Hoxb-8 has a role in establishing early anterior-posterior polarity in chick forelimb but not hindlimb

The distribution of Hoxb-8 transcripts through the chick flank and early forelimb mirrors the distribution of polarizing activity in the flank at these early stages. Polarizing activity displayed by Hoxb-8-expressing tissue is only realised when placed adjacent to the AER and appears to be mediated through Shh induction, suggesting that Hoxb-8 may lie genetically upstream of Shh. Accordingly, Hoxb-8 expression is rapidly induced by retinoic acid (RA) treatment in the anterior of the forelimb in a spatial and temporal manner that is consistent with the induction of Shh and formation of the ZPA. Furthermore, inhibition of RA synthesis in the flank downregulates the expression of endogenous Hoxb-8 and results in the loss of Shh expression. However, once the ZPA has become established the posterior limb mesoderm displays resistance to the induction of Hoxb-8 expression. Grafting of ZPA cells to the anterior of a host limb renders the host anterior tissue resistant to RA-induced Hoxb-8 expression. These results indicate that Hoxb-8 expression may be regulated by the established ZPA through a negative feedback loop. The anterior AER also secretes an inhibitory factor, preventing RA-induced or already established Hoxb-8 expression in the cells immediately underneath the AER. Consistent with a role for Hoxb-8 in positioning of the forelimb ZPA, Hoxb-8 expression is not seen in RA-induced duplications at the anterior of the hindlimb. However, grafting of Hoxb-8-expressing tissue to the hindlimb can lead to Shh expression and similar duplications, suggesting that factors mediating ZPA formation are very similar in both wing and leg.

Retinoic acid and its receptors in limb regeneration

The effects of retinoids on the regenerating amphibian limb are described: the mesenchymal cells of the blastema can be proximalized, posteriorized and ventralized. Ectopic limbs are also induced after retinoid treatment of regenerating tails, but not during limb development unless the limb bud is damaged. The cellular and molecular alterations induced by retinoids are reported as well as experiments which have revealed the importance of endogenous retinoids for normal limb regeneration. Various retinoic acid receptors are expressed in the regeneration blastema and the experiments which have revealed functions for individual isoforms are described. These experiments reveal that retinoids are a crucial component of the normal, regenerating limb and demonstrate the value of the regenerating limb as an experimental system for providing functional data on individual retinoic acid receptors.

Positional apoptosis during vertebrate CNS development in the absence of endogenous retinoids

We have previously shown that quail embryos that develop in the absence of vitamin A have severe defects in their central nervous system. One defect is a completely missing posterior hindbrain. Here we have studied how this comes about by examining cell death using a wholemount technique. In these A- embryos we observe two narrow bands of ectopic apoptosis. One is in the mesenchyme in the region of the first somite and occurs at the 4–6 somite stage, before neural tube closure. The second band follows immediately afterwards and occurs in the neuroepithelium of the presumptive posterior hindbrain at the 6–8 somite stage. Electron microscopy shows that the dying neuroepithelial cells exhibit the characteristics of apoptosis. Rescuing the embryos by injecting retinol before gastrulation completely prevents these apoptotic events. In an effort to identify some of the genes that may be involved in the apoptotic pathway we show that Msx-2 is upregulated in the apoptotic neuroepithelium and thus may be involved, whereas Bmp-4 is not altered and thus presumably not involved. Since these apoptotic event take place at the time of specification of axial identity and segmentation in the mesenchyme and neuroepithelium we conclude that these cells die because they are wrongly specified in terms of their rostrocaudal position, a novel phenomenon which we refer to as positional apoptosis.

Retinoic acid is required for the initiation of outgrowth in the chick limb bud

BACKGROUND

Retinoic acid (RA) is present in the chick limb bud, and excess RA induces limb duplications. Here, we have investigated the role of endogenous RA during chick limb development by preventing the synthesis of RA and testing the effect on various genes expressed during limb initiation and outgrowth.

RESULTS

We demonstrate that the stage 20/21 limb bud synthesizes didehydroretinoic acid (ddRA), and that the posterior half of the limb bud synthesizes ddRA at a higher rate than the anterior half. Disulphiram inhibits this synthesis at micromolar concentrations. Administering disulphiram to embryos prior to limb bud outgrowth (stages 12-18) abolishes outgrowth, and no limb develops in the majority of cases. Disulphiram treatment also prevents the expression of Sonic hedgehog (Shh), but the expression of the fibroblast growth factor-8 gene (Fgf-8) appears as normal in the ectoderm over the prospective limb bud. The application of a bead soaked in RA can rescue Shh expression. Disulphiram treatment of later limb buds (stages 20-23) similarly down-regulates Shh, and also Fgf-4, expression, whereas the expression of Fgf-8, as at earlier stages, is initially unaffected. Again, RA can rescue the expression of Shh in these limb buds.

CONCLUSIONS

RA, in conjunction with Fgf-8, may be needed for the induction of the chick limb bud and the induction of Shh and Fgf-4 expression. The expression of Shh and Fgf-4 remains dependent upon the continued synthesis of RA within the limb bud. Didehydroretinoic acid is the major active retinoid in the stage 20 chick limb bud.

Retinoids in patterning: chimeras win by a knockout

Recent studies on the regenerating newt limb, using cells transfected with chimeric retinoic acid receptors that can be activated by thyroid hormone, have provided unique insights into the function of specific retinoic acid receptor isoforms.

Vitamin A-deficient quail embryos have half a hindbrain and other neural defects

BACKGROUND

Retinoic acid (RA) is a morphogenetically active signalling molecule thought to be involved in the development of severely embryonic systems (based on its effect when applied in excess and the fact that it can be detected endogenously in embryos). Here, we adopt a novel approach and use the vitamin A-deficient (A-) quail embryo to ask what defects these embryos show when they develop in the absence of RA, with particular reference to the nervous system.

RESULTS

We have examined the anatomy, the expression domains of a variety of genes and the immunoreactivity to several antibodies in these A- embryos. In addition to the previously documented cardiovascular abnormalities, we find that the somites are smaller in A- embryos, otic vesicle development is abnormal and the somites continue up to and underneath the otic vesicle. In the central nervous system, we find that neural crest cells need RA for normal development and survival, and the neural tube fails to extend any neurites into the periphery. Using general hindbrain morphology and the expression patterns of Hoxa-2, Hoxb-1, Hoxb-4, Krox-20 and FGF-3 as markers, we conclude that segmentation in the myelencephalon (rhombomeres 4-8) is disrupted. In contrast, the dorsoventral axis of the neural tube using Shh, islet-1 and Pax-3 as markers is normal.

CONCLUSIONS

These results demonstrate at least three roles for RA in central nervous system development: neural crest survival, neurite outgrowth and hindbrain patterning.

Late effects of retinoic acid on neural crest and aspects of rhombomere

We exposed st.10 chicks to retinoic acid (RA), both globally, and locally to individual rhombomeres, to look at its role in specification of various aspects of hindbrain derived morphology. Previous studies have looked at RA exposure at earlier stages, during axial specification. Stage 10 is the time of morphological segmentation of the hindbrain and is just prior to neural crest migration. Rhombomere 4 localised RA injections result in specific alterations of pathways some crest cells that normally migrate to sites of differentiation of neurogenic derivatives. The r4 crest cells that give rise to mesenchymal derivatives are unaffected. In addition, r4 gene expression is also partially altered by RA; within 6 hours of r4 exposure to RA, ectopic expression of Krox-20 is seen in r4 and Hoxb-1 expression is lost while Hoxa-2 expression continues normally. When we examined these RA-treated animals later in development, they showed an anterior displacement of the facial ganglion in addition to a mis-direction of the extensions of its distal axons and a dramatic decrease in the number of contralateral vestibuloacoustic neurons normally seen in r4. Only this r4-specific neuronal type is affected in r4; the motor neuron projections seem normal in experimental animals. The specificity of this result, combined with the loss of Hoxb-1 expression in r4 and the work by Krumlauf and co-workers showing gain of contralateral neurons co-localised with ectopic Hoxb-1 expression, indicates a role for Hoxb-1 and RA in the specification of this cell type in normal development. These results suggest that RA, at st.10, is able to affect some aspects of segment identity while leaving others unchanged.

Endogenous retinoids in the zebrafish embryo and adult

Retinoic acid and its isoforms are considered to be endogenous compounds which regulate embryonic development. In the work reported here we have determined which retinoids are present in zebrafish embryos and how their levels change throughout development and into adulthood. All-trans-RA is present and its level does not change significantly during embryogenesis. We failed to detect other retinoic acid isomers such as 9-cis-RA and 4-oxo-RA, but we did observe a rapid rise in the level of didehydroretinol after gastrulation. The most striking result is that the zebrafish embryo, like Xenopus and tunicates, contains a vast excess of t-retinal whereas the embryos of higher vertebrates have an excess of t-retinol. However, as the zebrafish grows, the levels of t-retinol rise so that by adulthood t-retinol and t-retinal concentrations are more equivalent, indicating a changing pattern of retinoid metabolism with growth. To examine the significance of the use of t-retinal as a precursor of t-RA we treated embryos with disulphiram, an inhibitor of retinaldehyde dehydrogenase. This resulted in embryos with an undulating notochord and correspondingly abnormal somites and ventral floor plate. In contrast to this effect, 4-methylpyrazole, which inhibits alcohol dehydrogenases, had no effect on development. This effect of disulphiram suggests that t-RA may be involved in the establishment of the anteroposterior axis of the embryo.

Role of thyroid hormone and retinoid receptors in the homeotic transformation of tails into limbs in frogs

We provide here further data on the dramatic homeotic transformation of tails into limbs which is induced by retinoids during frog tadpole tail regeneration. The effect can still be produced up to nine days after tail amputation by which time tail regeneration has essentially been completed. Complete tail amputation is needed for the effects to be manifest, partial damage of various sorts to the tail is not enough. We show that as well as retinyl palmitate, other retinoids such as all-trans-retinoic acid and TTNPB, which is a RAR specific retinoid, can induce the homeotic transformation. TTNPB has a 300 x greater potency than retinoic acid. Prolactin, which inhibits thyroid hormone production, prevents the appearance of limbs on the tail from which we conclude that thyroid hormone is needed. We present preliminary evidence from RT-PCR that all six retinoid receptors, the three retinoic acid receptors (RARs), and the three retinoid X receptors (RXRs), are present in the normal tail blastema and that after retinoid treatment RAR alpha, RXR alpha, and RXR beta may be up-regulated. Finally, we show that when RA synthesis is inhibited, normal tail regeneration is inhibited. We conclude that tail regeneration depends upon a particular endogenous level of RA, but that when this level is raised by external administration and thyroid hormone receptors are present the up-regulation of certain retinoid receptors allows novel nuclear receptor interactions which results in the induction of limb-specific genes leading to the appearance of limbs on the tail.

[The participation of retinoic acid in embryonic and postembryonic development]

Retinoids are low molecular weight, lipophilic derivatives of vitamin A which have profound effects upon the development of various embryonic systems. Here I review the these effects on developing and regenerating limbs, regenerating amphibian tails and the developing central nervous system (CNS). In the regenerating amphibian limb, retinoids can proximalise, posteriorise and ventralise the axes. In the chick limb bud retinoids can only posteriorise the tissue. In the regenerating amphibian tail retinoids can homoetically transform tail tissue into hindlimb tissue. In the developing and regenerating limb retinoic acid has been detected endogenously, confirming that this molecule plays a role in the generation of pattern and limbs cannot develop in the absence of retinoic acid. In the developing CNS retinoic acid specifically affects the hindbrain where it causes a transformation of anterior rhombomeres into more posterior ones. Again, endogenous retinoic acid has been detected in the CNS and in the absence of retinoids the posterior hindbrain has been found to be affected. The effects of retinoids on the CNS are most likely to be mediated via the Hox genes acting in the mesoderm after gastrulation. It has also been proposed that the establishment of the head-to-tail axis in the mesoderm is established by retinoic acid. These data show that retinoids play an important role in both the development and regeneration of various systems in the embryo and post-embryonically.

Synthesis and release of 9-cis retinoic acid by the urodele wound epidermis

The wound epidermis is a transient secretory epithelium that apposes the mesenchymal blastema of a regenerating urodele limb, and is required for regeneration. Previous studies have shown that the positional identity of the blastema is respecified by retinoic acid (RA; Maden, M. (1982) Nature 295, 672–675), that the blastema contains RA (Scadding, S. R. and Maden, M. (1994) Dev. Biol. 162, 608- 617), and that an RA-reporter gene introduced into the blastema is differentially activated along the proximo-distal axis (Brockes, J. P. (1992) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 89, 11386–11390). The newt limb wound epidermis has been explanted with minimal mesenchymal contamination and cultured under conditions where it retains expression and inducibility of marker antigens. We have assayed for the release of retinoids from the wound epidermis by co-culture with cells transfected with an RA- responsive reporter gene. The reporter was activated to a level corresponding to stimulation by 0.1-1 nM RA, and this activation was substantially conferred by medium conditioned by the wound epidermis. No significant activation was observed for cells transfected with mutated reporter plasmids and analysed in parallel co-cultures. Wound epidermis from contralateral proximal and distal blastemas were compared for reporter activation, and gave a P/D activation ratio significantly greater than 1. Wound epidermis explants were cultured in the presence of tritiated retinol, and extracts were analysed by HPLC on three different columns. Radioactivity was detected in peaks corresponding to didehydroretinol, 9-cis RA and other unidentified metabolites. Analysis of conditioned media samples, some after pulse chase experiments, detected significant release of retinol, 9-cis RA and other metabolites. Although all-trans RA was detectable, the predominant acidic metabolite was 9-cis RA. These experiments establish the wound epidermis as a source of RA for local cellular interactions in the blastema.

Anteriorization of CRABP-I expression by retinoic acid in the developing mouse central nervous system and its relationship to teratogenesis

We have investigated the role that cellular retinoic acid binding protein I (CRABP-I) may play in the development of the murine hindbrain. Since the central nervous system (CNS) represents a major site of the teratogenic action of retinoic acid (RA), we have also determined the effects of exposure of high levels of RA on CRABP-I expression within the CNS. Expression of CRABP-I can first be detected within the presumptive hindbrain of presomitic mouse embryos and later also appears in neural crest cells and neural crest derivatives; it is thus tissue specific at these early stages. Exposure of 7.75-day mouse embryos to RA induces two phenotypes: one is externally normal and the other is exencephalic. In the exencephalic embryos we show that there is abnormal crest migration, a fusion of the trigeminal and facial-acoustic ganglia, a rostral and lateral shift of the otic vesicle, and a loss of hindbrain rhombomeres. Furthermore, and in contrast to in vitro studies, we demonstrate that CRABP-I appears to be up-regulated in both phenotypes of mouse embryos treated with RA and that this up-regulation is accompanied by an anteriorization of its expression within the nervous system. This new CRABP-I expression domain thus retains its tissue specificity. The role that CRABP-I may play in normal development of the hindbrain and in teratogenesis and the similarity of these results to those obtained with various Hox genes are discussed.

Endogenous distribution of retinoids during normal development and teratogenesis in the mouse embryo

We have analysed the endogenous retinoids present in whole mouse embryos from day 9 to day 14 of development and in individual components of the embryo at two stages, day 10.5 and day 13, by HPLC. We can only detect two retinoids, all-trans-RA (tRA) and all-trans-retinol (t-retinol), and t-retinol is 5-10-fold in excess over tRA. We cannot detect 9-cis-RA or any didehydroretinoids; thus mammalian embryos seem to differ in their retinoid content from other embryos such as chick, Xenopus, and fish. The levels of tRA do not change significantly over the 6 days of development analysed, whereas t-retinol rises sharply as the liver develops. Within the embryo, tRA is present at high levels in the developing spinal cord and at very low levels in the forebrain; indeed there is a gradient of endogenous tRA from the forebrain to the spinal cord. Other parts of the embryo had intermediate levels of tRA. When a teratogenic dose of RA was administered to day 10.5 embryos, the levels of tRA present in individual tissues of the embryo rose dramatically--from 175-fold to 1,400-fold--and the levels rose in all tissues not in any exclusive areas. We then determined which areas of the embryo were malformed by such a teratogenic dose. The lower jaw, palate, vertebrae, tail, and limbs were consistently abnormal, and since these areas received a dose of tRA no higher than any other it was concluded that cell-specific factors must determine the teratogenic response of these tissues. We then considered whether cellular retinoic acid-binding protein I or II (CRABP I or II) played any role in this response by determining their relative levels in each of the tissues analysed. There was no correlation between the presence of CRABP I and II and the distribution of administered RA. Neither was there a clear correlation in detail between the presence of CRABP I and II and the sites of teratogenesis. We therefore conclude that other factors, for example, nuclear factors, must be responsible for the teratogenic response to RA.

The distribution of cellular retinoic acid-binding protein I (CRABPI) and cellular retinol-binding protein I (CRBPI) during molar tooth development and eruption in the rat

The distribution of cellular retinoic acid-binding protein (CRABPI) and cellular retinol binding protein (CRBPI) was studied in a series of prenatal and early postnatal rats, covering the main stages of development and eruption of the molar teeth. CRABPI positive cells were found in the mesenchymal cells of the dental follicle from the cap stage and in the dental papilla from the early bell stage. In the dental papilla, CRABPI positive cells were situated adjacent to the enamel organ in the cervical loop region and in the subodontoblastic region. Newly formed odontoblasts were CRABPI positive for a short period of time. The enamel organ was CRBPI and CRABPI negative, except for the presence of CRABPI positive cells in the internal enamel epithelium over the tip of cusps and in parts of the stratum intermedium. During root formation, CRABPI positive cells were found in the developing periodontal ligament, in the dental papilla adjacent to the epithelial root sheath and in the subodontoblastic zone. During crown formation, CRBPI positive cells were mainly localized to the mesenchymal cells of the dental papilla during the cap stage of crown development. The periosteum of the developing mandible contained CRABPI positive cells while some osteoclasts appeared to show a weak but positive reaction to CRBPI. The findings were considered in terms of the possible significance of retinoid-binding proteins during tooth and bone development.

Distribution of cellular retinoic acid-binding proteins I and II in the chick embryo and their relationship to teratogenesis

The distribution of cellular retinoic acid-binding proteins I and II (CRABP I and II) during the first 6 days of chick development has been investigated using immunoblotting. Since retinoic acid (RA) is teratogenic to some parts of the embryo, stimulatory to other parts, and has no effect on others it may be that the distribution of cytoplasmic proteins such as CRABP I and II plays some role in this differential activity. Neither protein is expressed in the day 2 embryo, but from day 3 onwards both proteins are expressed and CRABP I is in considerable excess over CRABP II. Within the day 4 embryo there is some significant variation in the distribution according to tissue type. Neural tissues, neural crest derivatives, and limb buds most strongly express CRABP I whilst other tissues contain only moderate levels, and heart and epidermis do not express CRABP I at all. CRABP II has a widespread distribution, although at a lower level than CRABP I, with the exception of somites and ectoderm which do not express it at all. In the limb buds, there is a significant variation in CRABP I levels across the anteroposterior axis which suggests that these two CRABPs may have different functions during development. The relationship of these distributions in the embryo to the role of endogenous RA and the teratogenic effects of RA is discussed.

The kreisler mouse: a hindbrain segmentation mutant that lacks two rhombomeres

kreisler is a recessive mutation resulting in gross malformation of the inner ear of homozygous mice. The defects in the inner ear are related to abnormalities in the hindbrain of the embryo, adjacent to the ear rudiments. At E9.5, the neural tube posterior to the boundary between the third and fourth rhombomeres, r3 and r4, appears unsegmented, and the region that would normally correspond to r4 is unusually thick-walled and contains many dying cells. The absence of morphological segmentation in the posterior hindbrain corresponds to an altered pattern of gene expression in that region, with major abnormalities posterior to the r4/5 boundary and minor abnormalities anterior to it. From the expression patterns at E9.5 of Krox-20, Hoxb-1 (Hox 2.9), Hoxb-2 (Hox 2.8), Hoxa-3 (Hox 1.5), Hoxd-4 (Hox 4.2) and cellular retinoic-acid binding protein I (CRABP I), it appears that the fundamental defect is a loss of r5 and r6. Correspondingly, the glossopharyngeal ganglion and nerve, associated with r6 are missing and the abducens nerve, which originates from r5 and r6, is also absent. Examination of Krox-20 expression at stages as early as E8.5 indicates that Krox-20 fails ever to be expressed in its r5 domain in the homozygous kreisler mutant. The abnormal amount of cell death is seen only later. An interpretation is that the cells that would normally become specified at an early stage as r5 and r6 adopt an r4 character instead, producing an excess of r4 cells that is disposed of subsequently by cell death.

Retinoic acid gradients during limb regeneration

Retinoids have been implicated in pattern formation processes in both developing chick limbs and in the regenerating limbs of urodele amphibians as well as in other aspects of embryonic development. Since chick wing buds have been shown to have a higher concentration of all-trans-retinoic acid (RA) in the posterior region than in the anterior region, we set out to look for a gradient of RA in the regenerating limb of the axolotl, Ambystoma mexicanum. We used high-performance liquid chromatography to separate, identify, and measure the concentration of retinoids present in the tissues. Our results show that the concentration of RA is about five times higher in posterior quarters of the limb regeneration blastema compared to anterior quarters. In addition, levels of RA are about two and a half times higher in blastemas from the radius-ulna level of the limb compared to those from the humerus level. By contrast, the limb regenerates of the African clawed frog, Xenopus laevis (which produce a regenerative outgrowth which is pattern-deficient), do not exhibit an anteroposterior gradient of any of the retinoids investigated. This paper also reports on the levels of retinoids in a number of other tissues as well. This anteroposterior gradient of RA in the axolotl limb regeneration blastema has significant implications for pattern formation during limb development and regeneration.

Biolistics. The retinoic acid supergun affair

By using biolistics to transfect the regenerating amphibian limb with cDNAs encoding chimeric receptors, the functions of individual retinoic acid receptors have been pinpointed.

The effect of vitamin A (retinoids) on pattern formation implies a uniformity of developmental mechanisms throughout the animal kingdom

Retinoids are low molecular weight, lipophilic derivatives of vitamin A which have a profound effect upon the development of a diverse array of animals. Here, I review these effects on Invertebrates: a colonial hydroid, a colonial ascidian, and Vertebrates: the regenerating amphibian limb, the developing chick limb bud, the regenerating amphibian tail, the anteroposterior axis of the early embryo, the developing chick embryo skin. There is a striking uniformity of effect of retinoids on pattern formation when applied to these diverse organisms. The majority react by being posteriorized in their development, although additional effects can also be seen. Several hypotheses which can explain these results are discussed along with the deduction that they lead to: retinoids may be components of a universal developmental mechanism or they may simply act in a similar way to alter a universal developmental mechanism. In either case the experimental analysis of retinoid effects on development has important implications for the evolution of developmental mechanisms.

The distribution of cellular retinoic acid-binding protein I during odontogenesis in the rat incisor

Retinoids are important molecules in various aspects of embryological development. Here the distribution of cellular retinoic acid-binding protein I (CRABPI) was studied in the continuously growing incisor of adult rats using an affinity-purified rabbit polyclonal antibody. CRABPI was present throughout the presecretory and secretory ameloblast layer. The protein disappeared from that layer during its maturation phase. The adjacent dental mesenchyme of the developing pulp stained positively for CRABPI, especially in the layer immediately beneath the fully differentiated odontoblasts. Little CRABPI was present in the odontoblast layer itself. The distribution of CRABPI, both in the undifferentiated basal region of the incisor tooth and associated with the cells during hard-tissue formation, suggests a role for this molecule during differentiation and hard-tissue genesis.

The homeotic transformation of tails into limbs in Rana temporaria by retinoids

The most remarkable of all the effects of retinoids on embryonic systems is the homeotic transformation of tails into legs which was recently reported using an Indian species of frog. Since then several attempts have been made to repeat these results on other species, notably Xenopus, with no success. Here I report the successful repetition of this homeotic transformation using Rana temporaria tadpoles treated with retinyl palmitate. The phenomenon is concentration-dependent, time-dependent, and stage-dependent. There is some difference in effect according to the tail amputation level. The limbs induced are always hindlimbs and there can be between 1 and 9 of them. There is a tendency to induce limbs in pairs so that even numbered groups are produced in considerable excess over odd numbered groups. As assessed by cartilage staining the majority of the limbs are normal in the proximodistal and anteroposterior axes. The other types of outgrowths induced are double-posterior limbs, posterior half-limbs (usually defective in the proximodistal axis), and spikes. As assessed by the anatomy of the muscle patterns some of these apparently normal limbs are duplicated in the dorsoventral axis. The stage and species dependencies of this phenomenon suggest that it may involve thyroid hormone receptors whose levels rise leading up to metamorphosis and whose interactions with retinoic acid receptors have recently been described.