Are there Clinical Ways to Assess Inflammation in Dry Eye Disease?

In the diagnostic process of dry eye disease, the detection of inflammatory activity is critical in order to evaluate the risk of progression and immunologic shift of the disease, to predict patient response to treatment, and to design an efficient therapeutic strategy, including artificial tear replacement, punctal occlusion or anti-inflammatory therapy.Even if it is difficult to quantify, some indicators of the presence of inflammation are collectible during the examination of the ocular surface in a first-line clinical setting. This review presents and critically discusses the assessment of inflammation in dry eye disease in clinical practice.

Efficacy of Lifitegrast Ophthalmic Solution, 5.0%, in Patients With Moderate to Severe Dry Eye Disease: A Post Hoc Analysis of 2 Randomized Clinical Trials

Question

What are post hoc treatment outcomes of lifitegrast by severity of dry eye disease (DED)?

Findings

In this post hoc analysis of 2 randomized clinical trials including 1429 patients, treatment with lifitegrast in the subgroup with an inferior corneal staining score of greater than 1.5 and eye dryness score of at least 60 at baseline (ie, moderate to severe DED) showed lifitegrast-treated participants had higher odds of achieving simultaneous improvement in clinical signs and symptoms than placebo-treated participants.

Meaning

The results of this post hoc analysis suggest that lifitegrast treatment may be associated with a response in the signs and symptoms of moderate to severe DED.

Importance

An investigation of the treatment effect of lifitegrast ophthalmic solution, 5.0%, in different subgroups by severity of dry eye disease (DED) seems warranted.

Objective

To explore the heterogeneity across different subgroups of DED and identify which participants were most likely to achieve clinically meaningful benefit with lifitegrast treatment.

Design, Setting, and Participants

This post hoc responder analysis was performed using the data from the phase 3 OPUS-2 and OPUS-3 studies, which were 12-week, prospective, double-masked, multicenter, placebo-controlled, randomized, parallel-arm clinical trials that previously demonstrated the efficacy of lifitegrast in DED. Pooled data were stratified into 4 subgroups based on severity of inferior corneal staining score (ICSS; ≤1.5 vs >1.5) and eye dryness score (EDS; <60 or ≥60) at baseline. Data were collected from December 7, 2012, to October 5, 2015, and post hoc analysis was performed from April 14, 2020, to July 30, 2021.

Interventions

Lifitegrast or placebo twice daily for 84 days.

Main Outcomes and Measures

Proportion of participants with (1) a clinically meaningful improvement in signs (ICSS or total corneal staining score [TCSS]) and symptoms (EDS or global visual analog scale [VAS]) and (2) a composite response for a given sign and symptom end point pair at day 84 were measured. Clinically meaningful improvement was defined as at least 30% improvement in symptoms (EDS or global VAS) and either at least a 1-point improvement in ICSS or at least a 3-point improvement in TCSS. For the composite responder analysis, the end point pairs were defined as at least a 30% reduction in EDS and at least a 1-point improvement in ICSS; at least a 30% reduction in EDS and at least a 3-point improvement in TCSS; at least a 30% improvement in global VAS and at least a 1-point improvement in ICSS; and at least a 30% improvement in global VAS and at least a 3-point improvement in TCSS.

Results

In total, 1429 participants (716 in the placebo group and 713 in the lifitegrast group) were analyzed (1087 women [76.1%]; mean [SD] age, 58.7 [14.3] years). For the overall pooled population, responder and composite responder rates favored lifitegrast vs placebo (odds ratio range, 1.29 [95% CI, 1.05-1.59] to 2.10 [95% CI, 1.68-2.61]; P ≤ .02). In the composite analysis, the subgroup with ICSS of greater than 1.5 and EDS of at least 60 at baseline (ie, moderate to severe DED) demonstrated a 1.70- to 2.11-fold higher odds of achieving clinically meaningful improvement with lifitegrast across all sign and symptom end point pairs (P ≤ .001).

Conclusions and Relevance

These post hoc findings suggest that lifitegrast ophthalmic solution, 5.0%, treatment may be associated with a response in participants with moderate to severe signs and symptoms of DED.

Trial Registration

ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT02284516

Ocular surface response of two preservative-free cylcosporine A emulsion eye drops in a mouse model of dry eye

PURPOSE/AIM

Dry eye (DE) disease is a multifactorial disease in which uncontrolled inflammation can lead to corneal epithelium lesions and symptoms of discomfort. The aim of the present study was to evaluate the efficacy of two cyclosporine emulsions in a mouse model of DE with corneal epithelium lesions.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Six- to 9-week-old female C57BL/6 N mice were housed in a controlled-environment room to induce DE. Following DE development, mice were instilled with: QD 0.1%CsA cationic emulsion (CaEm), BID 0.05%CsA anionic emulsion (AEm), or left untreated. Aqueous tear production and corneal epithelium lesions were assessed throughout the experiment. At the end of the treatment period, left eyes were sampled, fixed, and stained for histology, while the cornea, conjunctiva, and lacrimal gland of right eyes were sampled for transcriptomic analysis.

RESULTS

Corneal lesion scores were reduced by 10.4%, 18.4%, and 10.9% at day 6, 10, and 14, respectively, with CaEm (QD), and by 2.6%, 3.0%, and 5.5% at day 6, 10, and 14, respectively, with AEm (BID). Histology demonstrated that 7 out of 10 DE mice presented moderate to severe ocular lesions, while only 2 and 5 out of 10 mice presented slight to moderate ocular lesions when treated with the CaEm (QD) and AEm (BID), respectively. The transcriptomic profile analysis suggests that a different set of inflammatory genes are modulated in the cornea, conjunctiva, and lacrimal gland upon DE development. In addition, the two emulsions distinctively modulate the gene expression profile.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates that both emulsions were effective at reducing corneal lesions, with the CaEm (QD) being slightly better than the AEm (BID). Interestingly, this study suggests that ocular tissues may not respond similarly to a dry environment and that a different set of genes is modulated by the two formulations in the ocular tissues.

Is there a role for tapered topical dose steroidal treatment for dry eye disease? A randomized, pilot study

PURPOSE

To evaluate the effect of tapered doses of loteprednol-etabonate in dry eye disease patients.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Dry eye and treatment outcomes were assessed by Schirmer I test, tear BUT, lissamine green conjunctival staining, fluorescein corneal staining, and HLA-DR expression on conjunctival cells. Patients received either loteprednol-etabonate 0.5% twice daily for 14 days tapered to once daily for 14 days, and then twice weekly for 28 days (n = 10), or NaCl 0.9%.

RESULTS

A significant decrease of ocular surface inflammation and improvement of symptoms was recorded in the study group compared with controls at days 14 and 56. Change from baseline in HLA-DR expression in CD45+ conjunctival cells was significantly higher in treated patients at day 14. Intraocular pressure and best corrected visual acuity were preserved in all treated eyes.

CONCLUSIONS

Tapered doses of loteprednol etabonate 0.5% suspension controlled ocular surface inflammation, improving dry eye symptoms.

Long-Term Activity and Safety of a Low-Dose Hydrocortisone Tear Substitute in Patients with Dry Eye Disease

PURPOSE

A clinical trial was conducted to evaluate the activity of a new artificial tear containing hyaluronic acid (HA) and low-dose hydrocortisone to control dry-eye disease (DED) symptoms.

METHODS

a randomized, controlled, double-masked study was carried out at the Ocular Surface and Dry Eye Center, "Luigi Sacco" University Hospital (Milan, Italy), between June 2020 and June 2021. The study involved patients with DED for at least 6 months. After an initial 7-day treatment with corticosteroid, the treatment with the new artificial tear (four-times a day for 6 months) was compared with a control HA solution.

RESULTS

A total of 40 patients were considered. We observed a significant improvement in the frequency and intensity of DED symptoms in both groups. After corticosteroid discontinuation, the maintenance of the therapeutic advantage was observed only in the treatment group, which also showed a significant improvement of the tear film break-up time (p ≤ 0.05) and infiltrated macrophages (p < 0.05). A significant reduction in fluorescein and Lissamine staining (p < 0.05) was observed in the treatment group, suggesting damage reduction at both corneal and conjunctival levels. Intraocular pressure did not change at the end of the treatment period and was maintained within the normal range, sustaining the product's safety.

CONCLUSIONS

Our findings support the prolonged use of the new eye drop with low-dose hydrocortisone, also in the DED initial stages, to prevent the degenerating towards a chronic condition (http://www.isrctn.com/ISRCTN16288419).

Development of a Novel In Vitro Immuno-Competent Model of Dry Eye Disease and Its Use to Evaluate the Efficacy of an Ocular Surface Modulator

PURPOSE

To develop an in vitro model of severe immunocompetent-dry eye disease (ic-DED) and to investigate the mechanism of action of a T-lysial ocular surface modulator.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The reconstructed human corneal epithelium (HCE) was exposed to dryness stimuli. THP-1 cell infiltration into HCE was monitored at 4 h and 24 h from T-lysial application by immunohistochemistry (CD14, CD86, AQP3) and molecular biology (AQP3, TLR4 and TNF-α).

RESULTS

A reduction of CD14, CD86 and AQP3 was observed after T-lysial treatment at 24 h. TLR4 was overexpressed in ic-DED model and downregulated by T-Lysial after 24 h. TNF-α expression was not modified.

CONCLUSION

The ic-DED model can be used to monitor the migration and differentiation of THP-1 into HCE. T-lysial was found to exert anti-inflammatory activity. This experimental model is a promising tool to study the crosstalk between epithelial and immune cells, providing new insights on the mechanisms of DED onset.

Review of Preclinical Outcomes of a Topical Cationic Emulsion of Cyclosporine A for the Treatment of Ocular Surface Diseases

BACKGROUND

Cyclosporine A (CsA) has been used as a topical treatment for various ocular surface diseases including dry eye disease (DED). Several CsA formulations are available as solutions or emulsions.

PURPOSE

This review describes the development and the preclinical testing of a cationic oil-in-water emulsion of CsA (CE-CsA) in terms of pharmacodynamics, pharmacokinetics, and ocular tolerance. Due to the cationic charge, CE electrostatically interacts with the negatively-charged ocular surface, improving its residence time. Compared to other CsA formulations, CE-CsA and CE itself were found to reduce the signs and symptoms of DED, by restoring tear film stability and properties, and inhibiting the expression and secretion of pro-inflammatory factors. No delay in wound healing nor ocular toxicity were observed using CE formulations.

CONCLUSION

these findings indicate that the type of vehicle can significantly affect the performance of eye drops and play an ancillary role in DED treatment. CE appears as a promising strategy to deliver drugs to the ocular surface while maintaining its homeostasis.

Phenotypic Spectrum of Granular Corneal Dystrophy Type II in Two Italian Families Presenting an Unusual Granular Corneal Dystrophy Type I Clinical Appearance

Clinical, instrumental, and genetic findings are reported in Italian families with Type II Granular Corneal Dystrophies (GCD2) presenting an initial unusual presentation of a Granular Corneal Dystrophy Type I (GCD1) phenotypic spectrum in female descendants. Slit-lamp examinations showed the typical phenotypic features of GCD2 in both mothers and a phenotypic appearance of GCD1 in both daughters. Despite the different phenotypic onset, the genetic diagnostic testing revealed the presence of a mutation in the TGFB-I gene, typical of GCD2 in both cases, excluding GCD1. Patients who were clinically suspected of corneal dystrophy need a genetic confirmatory testing for certain diagnosis. Genetic test may help to find the specific mutation distinguishing between different phenotypic spectra with relative diagnostic and prognostic implications. The study demonstrates that the phenotypic spectrum of genetically confirmed granular corneal dystrophies in patients may change over time. Since the R124H mutation has also been described in clinically asymptomatic individuals prior to LASIK, who then develop dramatic deposition, suggesting that this particular mutation and phenotype may be sensitive to, precipitated, or modified by central cornea trauma, a careful familial anamnesis excluding cornel dystrophies and specific preoperative genetic test are recommended prior to LASIK.

The Management of Dry Eye Disease: Proceedings of Italian Dry Eye Consensus Group Using the Delphi Method

Dry eye disease (DED) is a highly prevalent, chronic and progressive condition that affects 5-33% of the world's adult population [...].

Dry eye disease pathogenesis and clinical signs: searching for correspondence in the clinical practice

BACKGROUND

Ocular surface alterations causing dry eye disease (DED) can be described as a vicious circle consisting of different consecutive stages. Among the factors involved, the ocular surface immune-inflammatory response has been established as a key player in the pathogenesis of the vicious circle of DED. Thus, the prompt recognition of the disruption of the immunoregulatory mechanisms is crucial for properly managing the ocular surface alterations. To increase awareness and knowledge of the identification and clinical interpretation of immunological mechanisms of dry eye in clinical practice, we present two clinical cases related to DED patients to provide a practical example of clinical examination application and interpretation of diagnostic parameters in daily practice. Moreover, a literature overview of the available clinical examinations to assess the immunological involvement in DED patients, with a particular focus on the correlation between diagnostic parameters and pathogenesis of clinical signs, is provided with an educational intent.

CASE PRESENTATION

The presented clinical experiences suggested that in ocular surface pathologies, knowledge of the immune-inflammatory pathogenetic mechanisms underlying the observed clinical sign is of great help for understanding what is being observed in the patient and, consequently, for the choice of appropriate therapy. Literature evidence suggests that many different clinical examinations can be used to assess inflammation in DED patients, such as the assessment of hyperemia, staining of the ocular surface and measurement of hyperosmolarity and MMP-9 levels. The combination of impression cytology and flow cytometry to assess for markers of inflammation is considered the best technique to quantify the level of inflammation on the ocular surface, even if not always applicable in clinical practice.

CONCLUSIONS

Literature evidence and clinical experiences suggest that basic diagnostic approaches (assessment of hyperemia, MMP-9 levels, and staining of the ocular surface with Lissamine green or fluorescein) represent useful tools to assess the inflammatory component of DED in everyday practice, providing a guide to establish the correct therapeutic strategy.

How Eyelid Changes May Impact on Tears

This article examines the impact of eyelid margin diseases on tear film composition and associated ocular surface disorders. It highlights the prevalence of blepharitis and meibomian gland dysfunction, discussing risk factors and diagnostic considerations. Various therapeutic approaches, including eyelid hygiene, antibiotics, and innovative treatments, are explored. Emphasizing the chronic nature of these conditions, the article underscores the need for patient compliance. Overall, it provides a concise overview of eyelid-related issues and potential management strategies.

One Soul and Several Faces of Evaporative Dry Eye Disease

The ocular surface system interacts with, reacts with, and adapts to the daily continuous insults, trauma, and stimuli caused by direct exposure to the atmosphere and environment. Several tissue and para-inflammatory mechanisms interact to guarantee such an ultimate function, hence maintaining its healthy homeostatic equilibrium. Evaporation seriously affects the homeostasis of the system, thereby becoming a critical trigger in the pathogenesis of the vicious cycle of dry eye disease (DED). Tear film lipid composition, distribution, spreading, and efficiency are crucial factors in controlling water evaporation, and are involved in the onset of the hyperosmolar and inflammatory cascades of DED. The structure of tear film lipids, and subsequently the tear film, have a considerable impact on tears' properties and main functions, leading to a peculiar clinical picture and specific management.

Dry eye in mind: Exploring the relationship between sleep and ocular surface diseases

PURPOSE

Dry Eye Disease (DED) is regarded as the most common ocular surface disease worldwide, entailing symptoms that have a major impact on the physical and psychological well-being of DED patients. In this context, the impact of sleep quality on DED has recently attracted attention. Indeed, although little is known about the mechanisms underlying the relationship between sleep and ocular surface diseases, recent evidence suggests that a reciprocal relationship exists between sleep quality and DED. Aim of the study was to investigate such relationship by means of both survey-based and instrumental analysis in a large population.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

The present cross-sectional study included 1182 DED patients who completed the Insomnia Severity Index (ISI) and the Ocular Surface Disease Index (OSDI) questionnaires. Moreover, tear break-up time (TBUT) and ocular surface staining (OSS) data of included patients were collected by physicians.

RESULTS

According to the findings of this study, in DED patients, the severity of dry eye symptoms and signs, assessed by OSDI score, TBUT, and ocular surface staining, is associated with more severe insomnia symptoms. Furthermore, higher severity of DED symptoms seems to be associated with the occurrence of nocturnal awakenings rather than with problems in falling asleep.

CONCLUSIONS

Present work contributes to the understanding of the complex relationship between DED and insomnia by showing that in a large population of DED patients, the more severe the insomnia, the more severe the DED symptoms and signs.