[Cardiac arrest in dental offices. Report of six cases]

The extreme medical emergency situation in the dental setting is cardiac arrest. The need to provide dental treatment to the medically compromised patients, suffering from very high risk heart diseases at special oral medicine hospital dentistry units, expose the dental and medical teams to the possibility of patients' death. Cardiac and cardiorespiratory arrest in these units faces the dentists with the need to perform basic and/or advanced cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR). Various etiologies are responsible for cardiac arrests. This article describes our experience and the outcome of six patients who have suffered cardiac arrests pre, during or post dental treatment in two special oral medicine centers. Two patients, suffering from severe congestive heart failure experienced fatal ventricular arrhythmia, both of them underwent CPR with early cardiac defibrillation, following which one patient completely recovered, and the other one expired. Two young and healthy patients experienced severe neurocardiogenic syncope with heart standstill for more than 40 seconds followed by spontaneous uneventful recovery. The fifth patient, who suffered from ventricular fibrillation as a result of an acute coronary ischemia, was resuscitated successfully. The last patient, a young woman, suffered from a severe status epilepticus causing bradycardia, which led to cardiac arrest, but recovered following CPR. All patients who did not recover spontaneously underwent methodical advanced CPR with early defibrillation. Only one patient out of the six died.

The Utstein template and the effect of in-hospital decisions: the impact of do-not-attempt resuscitation status on survival to discharge statistics

BACKGROUND

Variables for reporting outcome of pre-hospital cardiac arrest have been delineated in the Utstein style template. The primary outcome statistic is survival to hospital discharge (SHD). The template allows comparisons of pre-hospital care systems and has been used to determine the benefit of pre-hospital interventions. Post-resuscitation care has not been standardized and in-hospital events that affect SHD are not considered in the template.

STUDY PURPOSE

To determine the frequency and timing with which do-not-attempt resuscitation (DNAR) status is conferred following resuscitation from pre-hospital cardiac arrest and to assess the impact of this action on SHD.

METHODS

A 4-year retrospective, observational cohort study of all adult patients successfully resuscitated from nontraumatic pre-hospital cardiac arrest and admitted to a single municipal teaching hospital. Study variables included age, witnessed arrest, bystander cardiopulmonary resuscitation (CPR), initial rhythm documented by paramedics, hospital admission rate, frequency and time at which DNAR status was conferred, and SHD.

RESULTS

Four hundred and eighteen adult patients experienced pre-hospital arrest and received standard advanced cardiac life support interventions during the study period. Seventy-nine patients (19%; 95% confidence interval (CI), 15-23%) survived to be admitted to the hospital. Fifty-four of these patients (68%; 96% CI, 57-78%) were subsequently placed in DNAR status. Only one of these patients had a living will or advanced directive prior to cardiopulmonary arrest. In 37 DNAR patients (68%; 95% CI, 54-81%), DNAR status was conferred within 24 h of hospital admission. For patients made DNAR within 24 h of admission, 38% had a witnessed arrest, 22% had ventricular fibrillation as the first documented arrest rhythm, and 29% received bystander CPR. When patients made DNAR are included in the calculation of SHD rate, the SHD rate for the study period was 5.3% (95% CI, 3.3-7.8%). If DNAR patients are excluded, the SHD was 6.1% (95% CI, 3.8-9.0%), representing a 15% increase in SHD rate.

CONCLUSION

In-hospital care and medical decision making are not considered in the Utstein template and can have a significant effect on reported survival statistics. When assessing the benefit of pre-hospital interventions, it may be preferable to consider survival to hospital admission as the primary outcome statistic until such time as post-resuscitation care after hospital admission is rigidly standardized.

The death of a Princess and the formulation of medical competence

This study outlines a genealogy of the French and United States' Emergency Medical Service (EMS) systems. This is done to contextualise claims that Princess Diana could have survived had her crash taken place in the USA, and to enrich the EMS debate regarding field-treatment vs. rapid hospital admission for trauma victims. A historical analysis is offered for the disproportionate amount of available data on penetrating trauma, and proportionate deficit of data on blunt trauma with respect to total North American and Western European trauma epidemiology. The impact of US biomedical knowledge and culture on French medical practice is evaluated and used to understand how foreign knowledge is negotiated in local medical practice. The paper concludes by showing how, in response to a challenge by American biomedical standards of practice and formulation of competence, French pre-hospital Emergency Physicians have contextualised the origins of these standards as well as their local relevance in order to preserve an integrated notion of competence.

Use of a cardiocerebral-protective drug cocktail prior to countershock in a porcine model of prolonged ventricular fibrillation

OBJECTIVES

This was the third study in a series exploring whether the use of combination pharmacotherapy with delayed countershock would produce higher rates of return of spontaneous circulation (ROSC) and one-hour survival when compared with standard advanced cardiac life support (ACLS) therapy in prolonged ventricular fibrillation (VF).

METHODS

Twenty-four female, mixed-breed, domestic swine (ranging in mass from 22 to 25 kg) were used in this prospective, blinded, randomized, experimental trial. Animals were sedated (ketamine/xylazine), anesthetized (alpha-chloralose), paralyzed (pancuronium), mechanically ventilated with room air, and monitored with electrocardiography, arterial pressure, and Swan-Ganz catheters. VF was induced with a 3 s, 60 Hz, 100 mA transthoracic shock, and remained untreated for 8 min. One minute of basic life support followed (standardized by use of a mechanical device). At 9 min, animals were treated with one of three regimes: Group 1, cardiocerebral-protective cocktail (antioxidant U-74389G (3.0 mg/kg), epinephrine (0.2 mg/kg), lidocaine (1.0 mg/kg), bretylium (5.0 mg/kg), magnesium (2.0 g), and propranolol (1.0 mg)); Group 2, magnesium (2.0 g); and Group 3, standard ACLS. Groups 1 and 2 received drugs at minute nine (first countershock at minute 11), while Group 3 received first countershock at minute nine. Data were analyzed with two-tailed Fisher's exact tests.

RESULTS

ROSC was achieved in Group 1, 7/7 (100%); Group 2, 3/9 (33%, P versus Group 1=0.01); and Group 3, 3/8 (38%; P versus Group 1=0.02). One-hour survival was attained in Group 1, 7/7 (100%); Group 2, 3/9 (33%; P versus Group 1=0.01), and Group 3, 1/8 (13%; P versus Group 1=0.001).

CONCLUSIONS

Combination pharmacotherapy with a cardiocerebral-protective drug cocktail prior to countershock produced superior rates of ROSC and one-hour survival when compared with singular drug therapy (Group 2) and standard ACLS (Group 3) in this porcine model of prolonged VF.

Vasopressin and shock

Vasopressin (antidiuretic hormone) is emerging as a potentially major advance in the treatment of a variety of shock states. Increasing interest in the clinical use of vasopressin has resulted from the recognition of its importance in the endogenous response to shock and from advances in understanding of its mechanism of action. From animal models of shock, vasopressin has been shown to produce greater blood flow diversion from non-vital to vital organ beds (particularly the brain) than does adrenaline. Although vasopressin has similar direct actions to the catecholamines, it may uniquely also inhibit some of the pathologic vasodilator processes that occur in shock states. There is current interest in the use of vasopressin in the treatment of shock due to ventricular fibrillation, hypovolaemia, sepsis and cardiopulmonary bypass. This article reviews the physiology and pharmacology of vasopressin and all of the relevant animal and human clinical literature on its use in the treatment of shock following a MEDLINE (1966-2000) search.

An evidence base for adult resuscitation

New international guidelines on resuscitation are now agreed. This article examines in detail the adult advanced life support guidelines, highlighting where the new document differs from existing practice. Core resuscitation points are also reviewed.

[CPR--guidelines 2000. New international guidelines for cardiopulmonary resuscitation]

The "Guidelines 2000 for Cardiopulmonary Resuscitation and Emergency Cardiovascular Care. An International Consensus an Science" are the first true international CPR guidelines in the history of resuscitation medicine. Experts from major international resuscitation organizations (International Liaison Committee on Resuscitation, ILCOR) achieved a consensus of recommendations which had to pass a rigorous review procedure applying the tools of evidence-based medicine: all proposed guidelines or guideline changes had to be based on critically appraised pieces of evidence which had to be integrated into a final class of recommendations. The most important changes compared to previous recommendations from either the European Resuscitation Council or the American Heart Association are presented and commented upon.

Child with absent vital signs

The outcome of cardiopulmonary resuscitation in the child with absent vital signs is dismal. Best outcomes therefore should rely on early recognition and aggressive management of critical illness to interrupt deterioration to cardiorespiratory arrest. Moreover, resuscitation entails a spectrum of care starting with cardiopulmonary resuscitation at the site of injury through critical care and post resuscitation rehabilitation. The resources required to provide this level of care is not available in many parts of the world. Therefore, resuscitation skills should be taught to caregivers at a level which is congruent to their role in the continuum of care and the use of aggressive resuscitation needs to be tailored based on geography, risk to medical personnel, preservation of resources, transplantation issues and expected outcomes. In some cases, the most prudent decision may be not to attempt resuscitation of the child with absent vital signs.

Diversion of ALS ambulances: characteristics, causes, and effects in a large urban system

OBJECTIVE

To characterize the reasons for and effects of diversions of advanced life support (ALS) ambulances in a large urban area with a high concentration of receiving hospitals.

METHODS

A retrospective study was performed in a large urban region during a consecutive three-month period. Diversion was defined as the ALS transport of a patient to an emergency department (ED) other than the designated primary receiving facility. Case-matched concurrent cohorts of patients who were and were not diverted were studied to establish emergency medical services (EMS) time intervals, including total prehospital interval (TPI), on-scene interval (OSI), and patient transfer interval (PTI); age; gender; Glasgow Coma Score (GCS); ALS interventions; and insurance status. The reasons for diversion and the chief complaints of diverted patients were also studied.

RESULTS

During the study period, 2,534 ALS runs occurred, of which 147 (5.8%) were diverted. Twenty-four (16.3%) diversions had incomplete run times, leaving 123 (83.7%) for analysis. The most common chief complaints of diverted patients were shortness of breath (SOB), chest pain (CP), and altered mental status (AMS). The most common reason for diversion was special consideration (SC), defined as a diversion requested by a patient, family member, law enforcement officer, or private medical doctor. Diverted ambulances had significant increases in TPI, 36.4 [95% confidence interval (95% CI) 35.1-37.7] vs. 33.4 [95% CI 32.13-34.7], and PTI, 10.3 [95% CI 9.4-11.2] vs. 7.9 [95% CI 7.2-8.6], compared with nondiverted ambulances. Further analysis demonstrated that SC diversions accounted for all of the increases in TPI (p<0.001) and PTI (p<0.001) when compared with other types of diversions and nondiverted transports.

CONCLUSION

"Special consideration" was the most common reason for diversion in this study. Special consideration diversions increased TPI and PTI, causing delays in arrival to the ED and decreased ALS ambulance availability.

['Advanced trauma life support' in Netherlands]

Introduction of the principles of advanced trauma life support (ATLS) in the management of accident victims has been in progress in the Netherlands since 1995. The main ATLS principles are that the aid giver treats the most dangerous disorder first and does no further damage. After assessment and, if necessary, treatment of the airways, the respiration, the circulation and any craniocerebral injury, an exploratory examination is carried out. Physicians receive theoretical and practical instructions in this form of management during an intensive two-day course, counselled by a coordinating organization in the USA. Most of those attending are interns in general surgery, traumatology and orthopaedics, gatekeeper doctors of emergency rooms and army medical officers. The standardized way of thinking improves the communication and understanding between the various disciplines involved in trauma care, in part because there exist comparable programmes for ambulance care and emergency care. Other measures improving the quality of trauma care are regionalization of the trauma care, medical helicopter teams and evaluation of the effects of ATLS as an operating procedure.

Cancellation of responding ALS units by BLS providers: a national survey

OBJECTIVE

In many emergency medical services (EMS) systems, personnel without advanced life support (ALS) training are authorized to cancel responding ALS units before the ALS personnel arrive and examine the patient. This study was conducted to examine these cancellations in major U.S. cities.

METHODS

A survey was mailed to the physician medical directors of the EMS services of the 125 largest U.S. cities, with telephone follow-up of nonresponders. The survey requested information on system structure, and on policies governing cancellation of responding ALS units by non-ALS personnel.

RESULTS

Ninety-four cities responded (75%), from 35 states. Nineteen systems (20%) are all-ALS with no basic life support (BLS) tier, and these were eliminated. Of the remaining 75 systems, eight (11%) use BLS ambulances (BLS-A), 35 (47%) use BLS first responders (BLS-FR), and 32 (43%) use both. Of these 75 systems, 60 (80%) allow cancellation of responding ALS units by BLS personnel. Only 24 of these (40%) have written protocols for such cancellations, and only 12 of those (50%) involve specific medical criteria, with two (8%) relying on the best judgment of the BLS personnel with no medical criteria, and another eight (33%) allowing cancellation only for logistic reasons. Of the 60 systems that permit cancellation, 13 (22%) perform some type of medical oversight review of all such calls, 26 (43%) review some such calls (median 10%, range 2-80% for the 19 systems specifying a percentage), 15 (25%) do not review any, and six did not specify.

CONCLUSIONS

Fewer than half of the surveyed EMS systems that permit non-ALS personnel to cancel responding ALS units use written protocols to guide these decisions, and only half of those protocols utilize specific medical criteria. Medical oversight review of these calls is highly variable, with many systems reviewing few or none of these cancellations.