Utility of stereoelectroencephalography in preoperative assessment of temporal lobe epilepsy

Of 269 consecutive patients entered into a preoperative assessment programme for possible surgical treatment of epilepsy, 33 had intracranial recording (SEEG) with combined subdural and depth electrodes for the purpose of localising a suspected temporal site of seizure onset. The findings in these patients are analysed with particular reference to: 1) the criteria of selection for SEEG and their validity; 2) information on SEEG compared with that obtained by less invasive means, including foramen ovale telemetry; 3) information on the use of intracerebral electrodes compared with subdural placements; 4) possible predictors of failure of localisation by SEEG and of surgical outcome. It was concluded that SEEG had usefully contributed to the management of 69% of the patients in whom it was used, establishing a previously unidentified site of seizure onset in 33%, correcting an erroneous localisation in 15%, and establishing inoperability in 21% of patients. No predictors of failure of SEEG or of surgery emerged; thus there was no evidence of unnecessary use of this procedure. Five patients were found with incorrect lateralisation of seizure onset on foramen ovale recording (of a total of 192 foramen ovale telemetries). Localisation of the ictal onset zone either by the distribution of inter-ictal discharges or by the initial ictal changes at subdural electrodes was unreliable, confirming the need for ictal, depth recordings.

MEG and EEG in epilepsy: is there a difference?

Interictal epileptiform activity recorded by scalp EEG, foramen ovale electrodes and MEG is discussed. Gross differences in waveform between the electric and magnetic records are discussed in the light of intracranial depth recordings.

Effects of transitory cognitive impairment on psychosocial functioning of children with epilepsy: a therapeutic trial

The authors report a trial of the use of anti-epileptic medication to treat possible cognitive deficits due to subclinical epileptiform EEG discharges in 10 children with psychosocial and educational problems associated with epilepsy. Medication intended to suppress the EEG discharges was added to the children's existing drug regime. In all instances, epileptiform activity, assessed by 24-hour periods of ambulatory monitoring, was reduced on active medication compared with placebo. In general, there was improvement of psychosocial function on active treatment: eight children improved, there was no change in one and one deteriorated. No psychosocial deterioration attributable to adverse effects of the medication was detected in those completing the trial. Despite possible confounding factors, the findings are in accordance with the view that subclinical EEG discharges can impair psychosocial function, which may be ameliorated by anti-epileptic medication.

Surgical treatment of epilepsy due to cortical dysplasia: clinical and EEG findings

Seventeen patients with cortical dysplasia who had surgical resection for medically intractable partial epilepsy were studied. Compared with two groups of surgically treated patients with intractable epilepsy due to tumour (n = 20) and mesial temporal sclerosis (n = 40), patients with cortical dysplasia showed significantly more frequent extratemporal lesions, more frequent non-epileptiform EEG abnormalities and less favourable surgical outcome for seizure control. Patients with cortical dysplasia were younger at onset of seizures and had a lower detection rate of CT abnormalities compared with the tumour group, and lower IQ compared with the mesial temporal sclerosis group. MRI was abnormal in five of seven patients. Six patients became seizure-free or almost seizure-free but eight did not experience relief of seizures. Surgical outcome related to the extent of pathology but not to the histological abnormality. Lesions outside the temporal and frontal lobes were correlated with poor surgical outcome, as were generalised interictal EEG abnormalities, which may reflect extensive or multiple lesions. Ictal intracranial recordings were not useful for presurgical evaluation of cortical dysplasia.

Significance and management of transitory cognitive impairment due to subclinical EEG discharges in children

Epileptiform EEG discharges not accompanied by obvious clinical events are generally regarded as subclinical or interictal. However, in many patients suitably sensitive methods of continuous psychological testing demonstrate brief episodes of impaired cognitive function during such discharges. This phenomenon of transitory cognitive impairment (TCI) is found in some 50% of those patients who exhibit discharges during testing. With focal discharges, the effects are material specific, the deficit being demonstrable only with tasks involving that hemisphere in which the discharge occurs. It is probable that TCI contributes to the known cognitive problems of many people with epilepsy, and indeed causes deficits which are not readily recognised. Thus TCI may be found in benign epilepsy of childhood, a condition believed specifically not to be associated with psychological problems. An important practical issue is whether TCI materially impairs day to day psychosocial function and if so whether drug treatment is either desirable or effective. A preliminary controlled trial of antiepileptic treatment of TCI is described: suppression of discharges was associated with significant improvement in psychosocial function.

Brain mapping--a useful tool or a dangerous toy?

Images

Outcome following resective surgery for temporal lobe epilepsy: a prospective follow up study of 102 consecutive cases

The long term outcome has been assessed in a consecutive series of 102 cases undergoing resective temporal lobe surgery because of medically intractable epilepsy. Patients were followed prospectively for a median of 61 months. Actuarial statistics were used to measure the temporal patterns of remission and stability of outcome over prolonged periods of observation. The probability of achieving one year remission was 57% by one year, 70% by two years, and 77% by seven years. Once a patient was in one year remission the probability of remaining seizure free was 90%. This rose to 94% after two consecutive years of being seizure free. The majority of patients who remit following surgery have done so by two years of follow up. Outcome at the end of the second post operative year is a good predictor of long term prognosis.

Predictive value of intraoperative electrocorticograms in resective epilepsy surgery

The preresection and postresection intraoperative electrocorticograms of 76 consecutive patients undergoing resective surgery for intractable epilepsy were analyzed to see if location, configuration, and discharge rate of epileptiform activity correlated with type and location of pathology of the resected specimens and outcome in regard to seizure control. The location of the predominant spike focus did not correlate with either type of location of pathology or with seizure outcome from temporal lobe surgery (n = 58). The presence of spontaneous or activated spikes outside the resected area did not correlate with outcome from any surgery type. Positive spikes recorded from the amygdala and anterior hippocampus (n = 37) were not associated with type or location of pathology, but bursts of fast repetitive spikes on these needle recordings tended to associate with mesiotemporal pathology (p = less than 0.02) and with mesial temporal sclerosis (p = less than 0.04). A preresection spike discharge rate of 1 per 4 minutes or less was associated with a poor outcome in 5 of 6 patients (p = 0.03), whereas a rate of 18 or more per minute was associated with a good outcome in 15 of 18 patients (p less than 0.06). Persistence of 50% or more of the preresection epileptiform activity in the postresection electrocorticogram after temporal lobectomy correlated with poor outcome in 80% (p = less than 0.03), although the absolute amount of epileptiform activity remaining in the postresection electrocorticogram did not correlate with outcome. Further studies are needed to define the role of intraoperative electrocorticograms in resective epilepsy surgery.

Learning disabilities in epilepsy: neurophysiological aspects

Subclinical generalized spike-wave discharges are often accompanied by transitory cognitive impairment, demonstrable by psychological testing during EEG recording. Transitory cognitive impairment is demonstrated most readily by difficult tasks and during generalized regular spike-wave bursts lasting for more than 3 s, but can also be found during briefer and even focal discharges. That this is not simply a consequence of global inattention is shown by the fact that focal discharges exhibit some specificity: left-sided focal spiking is more likely to produce errors on verbal tasks, for instance, whereas right-sided discharges are more often accompanied by impairment in handling nonverbal material. Both learning difficulties in general and specific abnormal patterns of cognitive functioning are well documented in children with epilepsy and are most pronounced in those with frequent interictal discharges. However, there is now evidence that intermittent cognitive impairment due to the discharges themselves contributes significantly to such neurophysiological abnormalities. The significance of transitory cognitive impairment accompanying subclinical EEG discharges for everyday functioning is uncertain, but there is experimental evidence that subclinical discharges may be accompanied by disruption of educational skills in children or by impairment of driving performance in motorists. In some individuals, suppression of discharges by antiepileptic drugs has demonstrably improved psychological function, but further work is required to determine the indications for such treatment.

Combined use of subdural and intracerebral electrodes in preoperative evaluation of epilepsy

For intracranial recording of partial seizures considered to originate from one of the temporal or frontal lobes, the team in the Utrecht Academic Hospital has used subdural, multicontact, flexible electrodes since 1972. These are introduced through bilateral, frontocentral trephine holes and are manipulated under fluoroscopy to cover most of the cerebral convexity. It became evident that in many patients, additional placements to record from intracerebral structures were indispensable. Therefore, using the same trephine holes, an additional 2 to 4 depth electrodes were stereotactically implanted in the mesial temporal and/or frontal structures, as appropriate. An extensive intra- and extracerebral spatial representation of the epileptogenic zone was thus obtained. We report here the methods for manufacturing and applying these electrodes and our clinical experience with 28 patients. The results obtained so far stress the value of combining subdural and depth electroencephalographic monitoring in the presurgical selection of patients suffering from medically refractory complex partial seizures. By miniaturizing the electrodes, extensive areas of the brain can be investigated without craniotomy or multiple burr holes.

Treatment of narcolepsy with L-tyrosine: double-blind placebo-controlled trial

A randomised, double-blind, placebo-controlled study of L-tyrosine was done in ten subjects with narcolepsy and cataplexy. Of twenty-eight visual analogue scales rating mood and arousal, the subjects' ratings in the tyrosine treatment (9 g daily) and placebo periods differed significantly for only three (less tired, less drowsy, more alert). Ratings of daytime drowsiness, cataplexy, sleep paralysis, night-time sleep, overall clinical response, and measurements of multiple sleep latency and tests of speed and attention did not differ significantly between tyrosine and placebo periods. Dietary supplementation with tyrosine 9 g daily for 4 weeks seems to have a mild stimulant action on the central nervous system but this effect is not clinically significant in the treatment of the narcoleptic syndrome.

Distribution of temporal spikes in relation to the sphenoidal electrode

Sphenoidal EEG recordings were performed in 111 patients with epilepsy, who showed antero-mesial temporal epileptiform discharges. In 6, a multipolar sphenoidal electrode showed a shallow potential gradient between the standard sphenoidal site and the surface. In 17 patients a superficial electrode at the site of entry of the sphenoidal wire recorded all discharges seen at the sphenoidal. Out of 165 foci, in only 2 instances were less than 90% of sphenoidal discharges recognisable on the surface. In 39 patients who underwent surgery, lesions confined to mesial temporal structures were found to be associated with inter-ictal discharges maximal at the sphenoidal electrode. A mid-temporal maximum was always associated with diffuse non-specific, or lateral temporal pathology. It is concluded that sphenoidal recording offers no advantage over suitably placed scalp contacts for detecting inter-ictal epileptiform discharges. It may be of some value for differentiating between mesial and lateral temporal foci.

Double-blind crossover trial of lamotrigine (Lamictal) as add-on therapy in intractable epilepsy

A double-blind, placebo-controlled trial is reported of lamotrigine as add-on treatment in therapy-resistant epilepsy. A within-patients serial design was used, with two 3-month treatment periods and an intervening 6-week washout/crossover period. An unblinded investigator adjusted lamotrigine dosage to achieve a plasma concentration within a previously predicted therapeutic range. All patients had therapy-resistant partial seizures, some in combination with other seizure types and were without serious neurological or intellectual deficit. Of 34 patients recruited only one was withdrawn because of an adverse experience (maculo-papular rash) probably related to the experimental drug and 30 completed the trial. The other 3 withdrawals were due to default during baseline, dispensing error and cholecystectomy. There was a modest statistically significant reduction in total and partial seizures on lamotrigine compared to placebo treatment. There was no difference in adverse experiences or abnormal biochemical or haematological findings between the lamotrigine and placebo periods. The plasma concentrations of concomitantly administered antiepileptic drugs were not affected by lamotrigine treatment. It is concluded that lamotrigine shows promise as an antiepileptic drug with low toxicity.

Acute hippocampal recording and pathology at temporal lobe resection and amygdalo-hippocampectomy for epilepsy

An electrocorticographic (ECoG) study is reported of patients undergoing surgery for epilepsy of temporal lobe origin. During 22 en bloc resections and six out of a total of 18 amygdalo-hippocampectomies, the activity of the hippocampus was also recorded by a multipolar strip electrode placed along its axis on the ventricular surface. Patients with mesial temporal pathology, chiefly mesial temporal sclerosis, made up the majority of those selected for amygdalo-hippocampectomy. They showed a characteristic ECoG pattern, with spikes localised to the mid part of the second and third convolutions and inferior aspect of the temporal lobe. Typically, this was associated with hippocampal discharges showing an anterior maximum. Pathology involving lateral temporal neocortex and non-specific findings were associated with more widespread temporal spikes and a maximum discharge amplitude over the mid and posterior parts of the hippocampus. It is suggested that intraoperative recording of the ECoG and hippocampal activity may provide a guide to the choice between en bloc resection and amygdalo-hippocampectomy.

Comparison of the effects of lamotrigine and phenytoin on the EEG power spectrum and cortical and brainstem-evoked responses of normal human volunteers

Phenytoin and lamotrigine (a new antiepileptic drug with an animal experimental profile resembling phenytoin) have closely similar effects on the quantitative pharmaco-electroencephalogram. These characteristics do not provide a basis for the functional classification of antiepileptic drugs nor for prediction of clinical efficacy, but they do give some insight into the probable secondary psychotropic effects which may arise with use of these drugs. Central conduction in cortical (visual) and brainstem (auditory) event-related potentials are not influenced by either drug, but peripheral nerve conduction is delayed with the use of phenytoin as reflected in increased latency wave I in the brainstem auditory-evoked response. The evidence suggests that in equivalent therapeutic dosage, lamotrigine may be less neurotoxic than phenytoin.

Preliminary evaluation of potential anti-epileptic drugs by single dose electrophysiological and pharmacological studies in patients

In phase 1 evaluation of potential anti-epileptic drugs (AEDs), insufficient attention has perhaps been directed to the transition from single, and multi-dose studies in normal volunteers to clinical trials of some weeks duration in patients. Acute single dose studies in epileptic patients already receiving AEDs may reduce avoidable errors in early controlled trials. Acute single dose studies provide the opportunity of obtaining some preliminary evidence of efficacy by observing the effects of the drug on quantified epileptiform EEG discharges, both those occurring spontaneously in long term telemetric recordings and those elicited by standardised photic stimulation in susceptible subjects. The pharmacokinetics of the new drug may be profoundly influenced by the comedication (as illustrated by lamotrigine, the half life of which varies by a factor of 10 depending on comedication). Conversely, the new drug may so influence metabolism of the comedication that the results of add-on trials may be virtually uninterpretable, unless steps are taken to maintain blood levels of the other AEDs. A method of addressing this problem is illustrated in the case of an imidazole, R57720. Adverse experiences may also occur more readily when a new drug is added to comedication than when it is given to normal volunteers and these problems in chronic trials can be anticipated from acute studies.

Psychological effects of subclinical epileptiform EEG discharges. I. Scholastic skills

The possible effects of subclinical epileptiform EEG discharges on educational skills have been studied. Twenty children with proven or suspected epilepsy and known subclinical EEG discharges underwent telemetric EEG and video monitoring during standard tasks of reading, mental arithmetic and manual dexterity, and at rest. The discharge rate was significantly lower at rest than during execution of a task. For both reading and arithmetic, the discharge rate was higher when the child was presented with material appropriate to his own level of ability than when easier or more difficult material was given. High discharge rates were associated with low test performance particularly for arithmetic. Reading speed was significantly increased during the discharges, but overall reading efficiency was significantly reduced with respect to the non-discharge condition. The decrement of reading efficiency was greater for longer than for shorter discharges. The findings confirm that otherwise subclinical EEG discharges may be accompanied by momentary impairment of scholastic skills. The interaction between discharges and cognitive function is, however, complex and the nature and level of difficulty of the task in turn affects the rate of EEG discharge.

Psychological effects of subclinical epileptiform EEG discharges in children. II. General intelligence tests

Twenty-one children with suspected or proven epilepsy and subclinical epileptiform EEG discharges in the waking state were studied. The EEG was telemetered and behaviour recorded by closed-circuit television during performance of a general intelligence test (RAKIT, shortened version) which comprised 6 subtests. Mean total IQ was below that of control populations and the subtests profile was abnormal, due particularly to impaired performance on a subtest concerned with verbal short-term memory. This effect was accounted for by that subgroup of children who exhibited discharges during the test; those who did not show discharges at that time were unimpaired. Performance of 3 of the subtests was impaired when discharges occurred during presentation of the test item or between presentation and response. The findings suggest that cognitive impairment found in people with epilepsy may not only represent a more or less static disability, due to drugs, cerebral pathology, etc., but may in part be an intermittent process related to the occurrence of subclinical epileptiform discharges. These preliminary findings need to be amplified but have implications both for interpretation of neuropsychological studies in persons with epilepsy and also for the drug treatment of those who continue to exhibit subclinical EEG discharges when overt seizures have been controlled.