Stability of refraction and visual acuity during 5 years in eyes with simple myopia. The PERK Study Group

BACKGROUND

Normal ranges of variability of refraction and visual acuity in adult myopic eyes are needed as a reference standard for assessing the stability of refractive corneal surgery.

METHODS

We measured the changes in spectacle-corrected visual acuity and cycloplegic refraction during 5 years for the unoperated eye of 82 patients aged 21 to 57 years in the Prospective Evaluation of Radial Keratotomy Study. The changes were compared for contact lens and non-contact lens wearers. We also compared the 5-year cycloplegic and manifest refractions for these unoperated eyes.

RESULTS

Of 77 eyes, 44% gained or lost one Snellen line and 48% experienced no change in spectacle-corrected visual acuity between baseline and 5 years. Only one eye (1%) lost two lines, and 7% gained two lines. The refractive change was less than 1.00 D for 84% of the 37 non-contact lens wearing eyes. Only 13% became more myopic by at least 1.00 D (maximum increase in myopia, 2.00 D), and 3% became less myopic by 1.00 D. Of 45 contact lens wearing eyes, 38% became more myopic by at least 1.00 D. The 5-year manifest refraction was 0.50 D to 1.50 D more myopic than the cycloplegic refraction for 37% of eyes.

CONCLUSIONS

We recommend using two or more Snellen lines as the standard for a meaningful change in spectacle-corrected visual acuity in operated eyes, and 1.00 D as a meaningful cutoff for stability of refraction. The wearing of contact lenses can confound the results of stability studies. The difference between the cycloplegic and manifest refractions suggests that the cycloplegic refraction should be used in planning for refractive surgery.

A granny-style slip knot for use in eye surgery

An adjustable knot for use in ocular surgery is described herein. The first part of the knot is a granny knot, which allows tension to be adjusted. The advantages of this knot are: 1) ease of tying; 2) adjustability; and 3) small size of the knot.

Corneal wound healing in monkeys after repeated excimer laser photorefractive keratectomy

Five rhesus monkey eyes underwent repeated argon fluoride (193 nm) excimer laser myopic photorefractive keratectomy 3 months following an initial ablation that had produced mild subepithelial haze. At 3 months all eyes had development of a dense subepithelial opacity and a thickened epithelium (12 cells, 80 microns) with vacuolization of basal cells, fragmented basement membrane, and a layer of subepithelial fibrosis containing activated fibroblasts. By 6 months the opacity was clearing; epithelium was thinner (50 microns); subepithelial fibrosis was more lamellar. By 15 months only mild haze persisted clinically; epithelium was 30 microns thick, with persistent basal vacuolization and focal basement membrane disruption; subepithelial fibrous tissue was more organized. Early repeated excimer laser ablation of the monkey cornea apparently induces vigorous stromal wound healing. Use of shallower ablations, corticosteroids, or a longer delay between ablations may be necessary for repeated laser surgery to be practical clinically.

Complications of Mersilene sutures in penetrating keratoplasty

BACKGROUND

After penetrating keratoplasty, many corneal surgeons adjust sutures to reduce astigmatism and then leave the sutures in place indefinitely. Nylon sutures can hydrolyze and break years after surgery. In a series of human penetrating keratoplasties, we studied the use of polyester (Mersilene) sutures that do not hydrolyze.

METHODS

We performed two prospective studies of polyester (Mersilene) sutures in human penetrating keratoplasty done by one surgeon. Study I was a randomized comparison of combined running and interrupted Mersilene and nylon sutures in 45 consecutive eyes. Study II was a case series of single running Mersilene suture with postoperative adjustment of suture tension to manage astigmatism in 23 consecutive eyes. We evaluated the performance of the suture and the control of astigmatism.

RESULTS

The interrupted running suture study demonstrated that interrupted Mersilene sutures were 5.5 times more likely to have handling-related complications than nylon interrupted sutures (p = .01); in addition, they were three times as likely to have tissue-related complications as nylon (p = .16). The running suture study demonstrated an unacceptable complication rate of 69% when Mersilene was used as a single adjustable running suture. At 6 months postoperatively, the median refractive astigmatism for the adjustable cases was 3.37 diopters (mean, 4.03 +/- 2.37 D). Eyes with significant suture-related complications were 2.85 times more likely to have greater than 4.00 D of refractive astigmatism than were eyes without suture-related complications.

CONCLUSIONS

Mersilene is an undesirable suture for use in penetrating keratoplasty.

Penetrating keratoplasty in patients with rheumatoid arthritis

The authors reviewed in a retrospective manner 47 penetrating keratoplasties performed on 23 eyes of 21 patients with rheumatoid arthritis. The indications for the first penetrating keratoplasty were corneal melt in 19 eyes (83%), infectious keratitis in 2 eyes (9%), and corneal scarring after ulceration in 2 eyes (9%). Twelve of the 23 eyes required 24 repeat penetrating keratoplasties. Seventeen of the 23 eyes (74%) had clear grafts at the last follow-up visit, a median of 13.7 months after the last penetrating keratoplasty. The final best corrected visual acuity was greater than or equal to 20/60 in 4 eyes (17%), 20/70 to 20/100 in 1 eye (4%), 20/200 to 20/400 in 7 eyes (30%), counting fingers in 4 eyes (17%), hand motions in 2 eyes (9%), and light perception in 4 eyes (17%). One eye (4%) was enucleated. Anatomic success (absence of phthisis bulbi, enucleation, or conjunctival flap) was achieved in 20 eyes (87%). The survival probability for the 21 patients was only 48% 5 years after the first penetrating keratoplasty. The authors conclude that penetrating keratoplasty is often anatomically successful in patients with rheumatoid arthritis; however, the prognosis is poor for both vision and survival of the patient.

Computer simulation of arcuate keratotomy for astigmatism

BACKGROUND

The development of refractive corneal surgery involves numerous attempts to isolate the effect of individual factors on surgical outcome. Computer simulation of refractive keratotomy allows the surgeon to alter variables of the technique and to isolate the effect of specific factors independent of other factors, something that cannot easily be done in any of the currently available experimental models.

METHODS

We used the finite element numerical method to construct a mathematical model of the eye. The model analyzed stress-strain relationships in the normal corneoscleral shell and after astigmatic surgery. The model made the following assumptions: an axisymmetric eye, an idealized aspheric anterior corneal surface, transversal isotropy of the cornea, nonlinear strain tensor for large displacements, and near incompressibility of the corneoscleral shell. The eye was assumed to be fixed at the level of the optic nerve. The model described the acute elastic response of the eye to corneal surgery.

RESULTS

We analyzed the effect of paired transverse arcuate corneal incisions for the correction of astigmatism. We evaluated the following incision variables and their effect on change in curvature of the incised and unincised meridians: length (longer, more steepening of unincised meridian), distance from the center of the cornea (farther, less flattening of incised meridian), depth (deeper, more effect), and the initial amount of astigmatism (small effect).

CONCLUSIONS

Our finite element computer model gives reasonably accurate information about the relative effects of different surgical variables, and demonstrates the feasibility of using nonlinear, anisotropic assumptions in the construction of such a computer model. Comparison of these computer-generated results to clinically achieved results may help refine the computer model.

Subepithelial fibrosis after myopic epikeratoplasty. Report of a case

A 29-year-old man with a -22.00-diopter myopia in the right eye underwent a planar, nonfreeze myopic epikeratoplasty and postoperatively developed a central subepithelial opacity. The opacity recurred after two superficial keratectomies; finally, another epikeratoplasty was performed. Light microscopic examination of the original button showed that the epithelium was thickened, collagenous subepithelial fibrocellular tissue was present, and Bowman's layer was focally disrupted. The stroma was edematous and peripherally scarred with scattered keratocytes. Examination by transmission electron microscopy revealed keratocytes lying anterior and posterior to Bowman's layer. The subepithelial fibrocellular tissue corresponded to an area of a break in Bowman's layer and probably originated from the donor stroma. The break in Bowman's layer may have been caused by the microkeratome cuts, but its origin is not certain.

Mycobacterium gordonae keratitis

A 20-year-old man was evaluated for an indolent corneal ulcer. Tissue and cultures from a penetrating keratoplasty indicated that the causative agent was Mycobacterium gordonae. This is the third patient reported with M. gordonae keratitis, although there have been numerous reports of nontuberculous mycobacterial keratitis. Nontuberculous mycobacterial keratitis is typically associated with previous trauma. The patient reported here had no known predisposing factor.

Trapezoidal keratotomy for the correction of naturally occurring astigmatism

We performed trapezoidal keratotomy, consisting of combined nonintersecting semiradial and transverse incisions, in 64 eyes of 45 consecutive patients with naturally occurring astigmatism. The central clear zone diameter and number and length of transverse incisions were determined by the refractive error. Mean preoperative refractive astigmatism was 3.18 +/- 1.16 diopters (D) (range, 2.25 to 7.00 D). At the 1-year follow-up examination, the mean surgically corrected astigmatism determined by vector analysis was 3.70 +/- 1.50 D (range, 0.75 to 8.5 D), and the mean residual refractive astigmatism was 0.85 +/- 0.72 D (range, 0 to 4.0 D), with 64% of eyes having 1.00 D or less. The smaller the clear zone diameter, the greater the astigmatic correction. Longer transverse incisions produced more steepening of the secondary meridian. The operative complications included microperforation (5%), misalignment of surgical meridian (6%), encroachment on clear zone (5%), and inadvertent crossed incisions (11%). Trapezoidal keratotomy reduced naturally occurring astigmatism, but with only fair predictability and with some irregular astigmatism due to irregular wound healing.

Results of the Prospective Evaluation of Radial Keratotomy (PERK) Study five years after surgery. The Perk Study Group

In the Prospective Evaluation of Radial Keratotomy (PERK) Study, 793 eyes of 435 patients with 2 to 8 diopters (D) of myopia received a standardized surgery consisting of 8 incisions with a diamond-bladed knife set at 100% of the thinnest paracentral ultrasonic corneal thickness measurement and a diameter of the clear zone of 3.0 to 4.5 mm; 97 eyes (12%) received an additional 8 incisions. There were 757 eyes (95%) followed for 3 to 6.3 years. After surgery, uncorrected visual acuity was 20/40 or better in 88% of eyes. The refractive error was within 1 D of emmetropia for 64% of eyes; 19% were myopic and 17% were hyperopic by more than 1 D. Between 6 months and 5 years after surgery, 22% of the eyes had a refractive change of 1 D or more in the hyperopic direction. For 25 eyes (3%) there was a loss of 2 or more lines of best spectacle-corrected visual acuity.

Corneal topography as a predictor of refractive change in the prospective evaluation of radial keratotomy (PERK) study

The first operated eyes of 435 patients undergoing radial keratotomy in the Prospective Evaluation of Radial Keratotomy (PERK) study were evaluated by photokeratography to document the preoperative and postoperative corneal shape. We determined by regression analysis and analysis of variance that the corneal shape preoperatively improved the prediction of the corneal shape 6 months postoperatively in the 3-mm-clear-zone population. The reduction of myopia in all 435 eyes ranged from 1.25 to 9.75 diopters. We studied the effect of the preoperative corneal shape on this variability in the outcome of the surgery using rings 2 and 7 on photokeratography and corneal diameter. In the 3-mm-clear-zone group, eyes with flat prolate corneas had a greater reduction in myopia (4.65 D); those with steeper, more spherical corneas had less reduction in myopia (3.48 D). In addition, eyes with a 3-mm clear zone and flat central corneas alone (8.0 mm = 42.19 D) flattened approximately 0.75 D more than those with steep central corneas (7.0 mm = 48.21 D). In the 3.5-mm and 4.0-mm clear zone groups, the change in corneal curvature was not related to the preoperative curvature. A stepwise regression analysis of the 151 eyes in the 3.0-mm-clear-zone population demonstrated the following predictive equation for radial keratotomy; change in cycloplegic refraction = -14.55 + [-2.097 x average ring-2 radius] + [3.605 x average ring-7 radius] + [0.69 x horizontal corneal diameter] + [0.079 x age] + [-0.379 x spherical equivalent cycloplegic refraction]. There was a 1.17-D observed difference in the effect of radial keratotomy between those eyes with a steep/steep corneal topography (7.2% of the 3.0-mm-clear-zone population) and the flat/flat topography (29% of the 3.0-mm-clear-zone PERK population). A knowledge of corneal topography provides an additional tool for understanding the operative variability of radial keratotomy.

Computer-assisted videokeratography of corneal topography after radial keratotomy

We used computer-assisted videokeratography to compare the topographies of 32 corneas from 23 subjects after radial keratotomy with those of 47 normal corneas from 47 subjects controlled for age and preoperative keratometric and refractive power. Three ophthalmologists independently classified color-coded videokeratographs based on the color-coded pattern of dioptric power distribution and the cross-sectional shape. Corneas that had radial keratotomy exhibited a polygonal pattern not seen in normal eyes; this occurred in 59% of corneas. All normal corneas demonstrated a cross-sectional shape configuration that was steeper centrally than peripherally; 79% of corneas after radial keratotomy had a shape that was flatter centrally than peripherally. After radial keratotomy, the dioptric power increased from the center to the periphery (radius of approximately 4.6 mm) by 2.8 +/- 2.2 diopters (mean +/- SD), with a sharp inflection zone ("paracentral knee") 2.7 mm from the center; normal corneas showed a smooth decrease in power from the center to the periphery of 1.9 +/- 0.5 diopters.

Current status of synthetic epikeratoplasty

Many of the deficiencies with human tissue epikeratoplasty might be improved by the use of a suitable synthetic lenticule. Potential biomaterials for epikeratoplasty include collagen (types I, III, or IV), collagen-hydrogel copolymers, bioactive synthetics, and coated hydrogels. The biomaterial must be engineered to achieve strict specifications of optical clarity, support of epithelial migration and adhesion, permeability to solutes, and stability to corneal proteases. Attaching synthetic lenticules to the cornea without cutting Bowman's layer by adhesives, laser welding, or direct adhesion may also improve the efficacy of synthetic epikeratoplasty.

Stability of refraction during four years after radial keratotomy in the prospective evaluation of radial keratotomy study

The Prospective Evaluation of Radial Keratotomy Study is a nine-center clinical trial of a standardized technique of radial keratotomy in 435 patients who had simple myopia with a preoperative refraction between -2.00 and -8.00 diopters. We studied the stability of the refractive error during four years after surgery for each of 341 eyes first operated on that had a single surgical procedure. Between baseline and two weeks after surgery, all eyes became less myopic; between two weeks and three months, 161 eyes (59%) lost 1.00 D or more of the initial effect; and between three and six months, 266 eyes (95%) had a stable refraction with less than 1.00 D change. The change from six months to four years was less than 1.00 D for 246 eyes (72%). There was 1.00 D or more decrease in surgical effect (increased minus power) for 13 eyes (4%), and 1.00 D or more increase in surgical effect (decreased minus power) for 82 eyes (24%). Eyes with larger amounts of preoperative myopia and smaller diameter of the clear zone were more likely to have an increasing effect of the surgery. The duration of this continued increasing effect of the surgery is unknown.

Lack of association between keratoconus, mitral valve prolapse, and joint hypermobility

The authors enrolled 95 patients with keratoconus and 96 matched controls in a cross-sectional study to determine if mitral valve prolapse and hypermobile joints occur with greater frequency in individuals with keratoconus than in individuals without keratoconus. The hypothesis that keratoconus may not be a distinct eye disease, but a nonspecific sign representing a more generalized systemic disorder, possibly a mild collagen tissue abnormality, was considered. M-mode and two dimensional echocardiography and cardiac auscultation detected no statistically significant difference in the prevalence of mitral valve prolapse in patients with keratoconus compared with controls. Formal, systematic examination of five joints also failed to detect a statistically significant difference in the prevalence of hypermobile joints in keratoconus patients and controls. However, as an ancillary finding, a significantly higher proportion of patients with keratoconus was found to have a history of hay fever than was the case with controls.

The relationship of visual acuity, refractive error, and pupil size after radial keratotomy

To better define the relationship between residual refractive error, uncorrected visual acuity, and pupil diameter, we compared 42 eyes that had an eight-incision radial keratotomy according to the Prospective Evaluation of Radial Keratotomy Study protocol with 42 matched control eyes. The parameters measured were best corrected visual acuity, uncorrected visual acuity, and the change in cycloplegic refraction with enlarging pupil diameter. The best corrected visual acuity was 20/16 in both the radial keratotomy and control groups, but the variability (SD) was higher in the radial keratotomy group. The average uncorrected visual acuity was 0.35 (35%) better in the radial keratotomy group, but the variability was 1.77 times higher. Change in refraction with dilation occurred in 9% of the controls and 36% of the radial keratotomy patients, indicating a significant difference (P = .002). The change in refraction with dilation in the eyes with radial keratotomy was almost equally split between a hyperopic change (17%) and a myopic change (18%), which was much different than in the control eyes, only 2% of which changed in a hyperopic direction and 7% in a myopic direction. The radial keratotomy patients with a myopic change had the best uncorrected visual acuity, indicating that positive spherical aberration yielded the best aspherical surface for uncorrected visual acuity.

Solid state ultraviolet laser (213 nm) ablation of the cornea and synthetic collagen lenticules

We used a Q-switched Nd:YAG laser with non-linear optical crystals to produce the 5th (213 nm) and the 4th (266 nm) harmonic frequencies. Using these two wavelengths, we ablated fresh porcine corneas and type I collagen synthetic epikeratoplasty lenticules. For the 213-nm ablation, radiant exposure was 1.3 J/cm2. The ablation rate was 0.23 micron per pulse for the epikeratoplasty lenticules. We examined all tissues with light microscopy, transmission electron microscopy, and scanning electron microscopy. Histology for the 213-nm ablation showed a clean ablation crater with minimal collagen lamellae disruption and a damage zone less than 1 micron. In comparison, the 266 nm radiation showed more charring at the edges with a damage zone approximately 25 microns deep with disruption of the stromal lamella. Our results show that this solid state UV laser is a potential alternative to the excimer laser for cornea surgery.