Optimizing the exercise test for pharmacological investigations

Exercise trials in cardiology are often hindered by inconsistent approaches to exercise testing. These inconsistencies include the choice of exercise protocol, exercise end points, points of analysis, and absence or misuse of gas exchange data. Gas exchange techniques greatly enhance the accuracy with which cardiopulmonary function is assessed by exercise. Commonly used protocols are not always appropriate for all patients or all studies. Both cardiovascular disease and the exercise protocol can have an important impact on the relation between changes in work rate and oxygen uptake. Ramp protocols appear to offer the greatest promise for assessing cardiopulmonary function. Analyzing hemodynamic and gas exchange responses at several points submaximally, in addition to those at peak exercise, can add important information concerning the efficacy of a drug. A great deal of confusion continues to hinder the application of the gas exchange anaerobic threshold, and many of the commonly used testing end points are not reliable.

Comparison of ST segment/heart rate index to standard ST criteria for analysis of exercise electrocardiogram

The objective of our study was to compare the discriminating power of a proposed ST segment/heart rate index with that of a standard method of assessing exercise-induced ST segment depression for diagnosing coronary artery disease. We used a cross-sectional retrospective analysis of exercise test and coronary angiographic data. The study took place in a 1,200-bed Veterans Affairs Medical Center; participants were 328 male patients who had undergone both a sign and symptom-limited treadmill test and coronary angiography. The sensitivity of the ST segment/heart rate index was 54% at a cut point of 0.021 mm/(beats/min), corresponding to a specificity of 73%. The standard visual ST segment analysis had a sensitivity of 58% at this same specificity, which corresponded to an ST segment cut point of 1-mm depression relative to rest (p = NS). Similarly, for diagnosing three-vessel or left main coronary disease, no significant difference was found between the sensitivities or the two measurements at cut points of equivalent specificity. In this consecutive series of patients presenting for routine clinical testing, the ST segment/heart rate index did not improve the diagnostic accuracy of the exercise test for identifying the presence or severity of coronary artery disease relative to standard visual criteria.

"Recovery only" ST-segment depression and the predictive accuracy of the exercise test

STUDY OBJECTIVE

To clarify the predictive value of exercise-induced ST-segment depression occurring in recovery only, and to determine whether the addition of recovery data improves the interpretation of the exercise test.

DESIGN

Retrospective analysis of data collected during exercise testing and coronary angiography.

SETTING

A 1000-bed Veterans Affairs Medical Center.

PARTICIPANTS

The study included 328 male patients who had had both a sign- or symptom-limited treadmill test and coronary angiography.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Of the 168 patients who had abnormal ST-segment responses, 26 had such responses only during recovery. The positive predictive value of this pattern for significant angiographic disease (84%) was not statistically different from the predictive value of ST depression occurring during exercise (87%). Inclusion of ST depression during recovery significantly increased the sensitivity of the exercise test from 50% to 59% (P = 0.01) without a change in predictive value. In addition, ST-segment depression occurring only during exercise is usually associated with less-severe angiographic coronary artery disease.

CONCLUSION

The occurrence of ST-segment depression during the recovery period only, does not generally represent a "false-positive" response. The inclusion of findings from this period increases the diagnostic yield of the exercise test. Previously proposed exercise test scores, as well as exercise electrocardiography (ECG) analysis done in conjunction with scintigraphy, have a falsely lowered sensitivity that could be increased by considering ST-segment changes occurring in recovery.

Can maximal cardiopulmonary capacity be recognized by a plateau in oxygen uptake?

The failure of oxygen uptake to increase with increasing work has been considered a marker of the limits of the cardiopulmonary system for many years. However, the concept has suffered from inconsistencies in definition, criteria, and data sampling, all of which affect the interpretation of the relation between changes in work and oxygen uptake. To evaluate the response and reproducibility of the slope in oxygen uptake at peak exercise, six subjects (mean age, 33 +/- 6 years) performed two individualized ramp treadmill tests on separate days. During exercise, oxygen uptake (for a given sample of 30 eight-breath running averages) was regressed with time and the slope was calculated. Maximal oxygen uptake, maximal heart rate and maximal perceived exertion were reproducible from day 1 to day 2 (mean difference, 0.4 ml/kg/min, 1.0 beats per minute, and 0.2 for maximal oxygen uptake, heart rate, and maximal perceived exertion, respectively [not significant]). Considerable variability in the slopes was observed during each test and from day to day. This occurred despite the use of large gas exchange samples, averaging techniques, and constant, consistent changes in external work. A plateau, defined as the slope of an oxygen uptake sample at peak exercise that did not differ significantly from a slope of zero, was not a consistent finding within subjects between days. We conclude that marked variability in the slope of the change in oxygen uptake occurs throughout progressive exercise, despite the use of large samples and a linear change in external work. These findings appear to preclude the determination of a plateau by common definitions.

Exercise-induced silent ischemia: age, diabetes mellitus, previous myocardial infarction and prognosis

The purposes of this study were 1) to determine the prognosis of silent ischemia in an unselected group of patients referred for exercise testing, and 2) to assess whether age or the presence of myocardial infarction or diabetes mellitus influences the prevalence of silent myocardial ischemia during exercise testing. The design was retrospective, with a 2 year mean follow-up period. The study group consisted of 1,747 predominantly male in-patients and outpatients referred for exercise testing at a 1,200 bed Veterans Administration hospital. The main result was that the mortality rate was significantly greater (p = 0.02) among patients with abnormal ST segment depression than in patients without ST depression. The presence or absence of angina pectoris during exercise testing was not significantly related to death. The prevalence of silent ischemia was not significantly different among patients categorized according to myocardial infarction or diabetes mellitus status, but was directly related to age. It is concluded that, in patients with an ischemic ST response to exercise testing, the presence or absence of angina pectoris during the test does not alter the risk of death. The prevalence of silent ischemia during exercise testing is not statistically different among patients with recent, past or no myocardial infarction or with insulin-dependent or noninsulin-dependent diabetes mellitus.

Does the rest electrocardiogram after myocardial infarction determine the predictive value of exercise-induced ST depression? A 2 year follow-up study in a veteran population

The failure of exercise-induced ST segment depression to consistently predict prognosis in patients after myocardial infarction could be a result of population differences and the rest electrocardiogram (ECG). These hypotheses were tested by studying 198 veterans who survived a myocardial infarction, underwent a submaximal predischarge treadmill exercise test and were followed up for cardiac events for 2 years. During the 2 years, 29 deaths, 19 reinfarctions and 28 revascularization procedures were documented. The prevalence of death or reinfarction was two times higher in patients who had exercise-induced ST depression than in patients who did not. However, in the 55 patients without Q waves, the risk increased to 11 times for an abnormal ST response. These findings suggest that exercise-induced ST depression only predicts high risk in patients after myocardial infarction whose ECG at rest does not exhibit Q waves and that differences in the prevalence of rest ECG patterns are the most likely explanation for the failure of agreement among prior studies.

Altered ventricular repolarization in central sympathetic dysfunction associated with spinal cord injury

Complete injury to the cervical spinal cord results in total disruption of central sympathetic outflow. Although ventricular repolarization can be significantly influenced by disorders of autonomic function, the effects of cervical sympathectomy are unknown. Therefore, 40 subjects with complete chronic spinal cord injury were prospectively divided into 2 groups, half with total disruption of central sympathetic outflow (level of injury C5 to C8) known as the high level injury group, and half with nearly intact sympathetic innervation (T10 to L1) serving as controls. The completeness of autonomic dysfunction was verified by the cold pressor response. ST-segment analysis of the resting surface electrocardiogram revealed multilead ST elevation in the high level injury group, with maximum ST height significantly higher than the control group (131 +/- 21 [standard error] vs 47 +/- 8 microV; p = 0.0005). Unlike the control subjects, maximal arm ergometry exercise in the high level injury subjects failed to decrease ST-segment height (delta ST = -3 +/- 6 vs -43 +/- 14 microV in controls; p = 0.02). This difference persisted even after matching for exercise capacity. However, during exogenous stimulation with the sympathomimetic amine isoproterenol, ST-segment height in the high level injury group markedly decreased (mean delta ST = -84 +/- 26 vs -17 +/- 18 microV in controls; p = 0.04). Thus, central sympathetic dysfunction regularly results in multilead ST-segment elevation that decreases to or below isoelectric baseline during low dose isoproterenol infusion. Unlike normal subjects and individuals with normal variant ST-segment elevation, ST height is not altered by exercise. These findings document that ST-segment height in man is greatly influenced by central sympathetic nervous activity both at baseline and during physiologic and pharmacologic stress.

Cardiac rehabilitation for heart failure patients

Exercise tolerance in patients with normal cardiac function can improve with an exercise program. Controversy exists whether this is also true for patients with congestive heart failure (CHF). The limiting symptoms in patients with CHF are shortness of breath and fatigue. Hemodynamic parameters do not correlate well with exercise capacity in patients with CHF. These symptoms may be more related to factors that cause fatigue during exercise than to hemodynamic parameters or even to changes in pulmonary capillary pressure. The factors that cause symptoms include an increased lactate production and metabolic and blood flow abnormalities in the skeletal muscle. Exercise training can improve vasodilation and oxidation capacity, thereby reducing lactate production. Exercise programs may improve exercise capacity in the majority of patients with CHF due to coronary artery disease or idiopathic cardiomyopathy. However, certain patients with ischemia and with anterior infarctions may experience a detrimental effect on their cardiac function. Further studies are needed to better enable recognition of these patients but until this is possible, good clinical judgement must suffice.

Exercise-induced hypotension in a male population. Criteria, causes, and prognosis

The objective of this study was to demonstrate the causes, optimal definition, and predictive value of exercise-induced hypotension occurring during treadmill testing. This study included all patients referred for clinical reasons to the Long Beach Veterans Administration Medical Center treadmill laboratory and then followed for a 2-year period for cardiac events. The population consisted of 2,036 patients who underwent testing from April 4, 1984, to May 7, 1987, 131 of whom exhibited exercise-induced hypotension (6.4%). We found that exercise-induced hypotension is usually related to myocardial ischemia or myocardial infarction, is best defined as a drop in systolic blood pressure during exercise below the standing preexercise value, and indicates a significantly increased risk for cardiac events (3.2-fold, p less than 0.005). This increased risk was not found in those having no previous myocardial infarction or no signs or symptoms of ischemia during the exercise test, and the increased risk was also not found in those undergoing a treadmill test within 3 weeks after a myocardial infarction. Exercise-induced hypotension appeared to be reversed by revascularization procedures, but confirmation of a beneficial effect on survival requires a randomized trial. The clinical importance of this study is that we have demonstrated that a drop in systolic blood pressure below standing preexercise values during treadmill testing indicates an increased risk for cardiac events except in certain subsets of patients.

Exercise testing: uses and limitations considering recent studies

Accurate use and interpretation of exercise test results depend on an understanding of physiologic principles, meticulous attention to proper methodology, and realization of the appropriate applications and limitations of testing. Understanding the relationship between myocardial and ventilatory oxygen consumption and exercise test variables will aid in the diagnosis and prognostic evaluation. Use of proper methodology in preparing the patient, performing the examination, and interpreting the results is critical to obtaining the maximum information with maximum safety for each individual patient. Improvements in methodology including the use of the Borg scale to estimate individual effort, abandonment of the predicted maximum heart rate, and the increased use of ventilatory oxygen uptake measurements should be applied. Exercise capacity should not be reported in total time but rather as the VO2 or MET equivalent of the workload achieved. This permits the comparison of the results of many different exercise testing protocols. The most useful exercise ECG variable for the diagnosis of coronary artery disease remains the ST segment shift. Unfortunately, it is not as helpful in localizing myocardial ischemia. Diagnostic accuracy can be improved by adjusting ST depressions for exercise-induced heart rate increase. Accuracy can be further increased by combining ECG, clinical, and radionuclide variables in probabilistic formulas that retain the independent diagnostic information from each variable and accurately predict disease probability. To avoid errors in clinical decision making, care must be used to insure that the mathematical formula used was derived from a population of patients that is similar to those being tested. The clinical applications for exercise testing include diagnosis of patients with chest pain syndromes, determination of disease severity, and prognosis in patients with known coronary artery disease, evaluation of arrhythmias, screening of asymptomatic patients, and evaluation of medical, surgical, and angioplastic therapy for coronary disease. In spite of studies involving thousands of patients, controversy exists regarding the diagnostic power of exercise testing. The large differences in reported accuracies are largely due to methodologic problems that have been encountered by various investigators. Clinicians should be made aware of these problems when reading the literature on ECG and radionuclide exercise testing. Such awareness will help them understand the limitations of these noninvasive procedures.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

The prognostic value of the exercise test

Numerous investigators have demonstrated that responses to exercise testing enable prediction of the severity of underlying coronary disease and the patient's prognosis. However, exercise testing cannot predict angiographic findings or a poor prognosis with absolute certainty. Because survival can only be improved in specific clinical subsets of patients, it is important to carefully select for catheterization those in whom intervention can improve both quality and quantity of life. To deliver cost-effective health care, an effort has been made to use decision analysis to select those who should undergo cardiac catheterization. Decision analysis depends on reliable information regarding the predictive accuracy of the exercise test. Thus, this review is timely. Recent studies investigating the prognostic value of the exercise test are reviewed in this monograph. Patients include those recovering from a recent myocardial infarction (MI), those with stable coronary heart disease (including studies that have considered coronary angiographic findings, cardiac end points, and/or improved survival with coronary artery bypass surgery), and apparently healthy individuals. From this review, we conclude that silent ischemia induced by exercise testing in apparently healthy men is not as predictive of a poor outcome as once thought. Also, the use of the exercise test for screening is even more misleading than previously appreciated because of the higher rate of false positive results. Review of the 24 available studies of exercise testing in post-MI patients demonstrates that clinical judgment can be used to identify the high-risk patients, and that ST-segment shifts are not as predictive of high risk as an abnormal systolic blood pressure response or a poor exercise capacity. In patients with stable coronary heart disease, studies considering angiographic findings, cardiac events, and the differential outcome of coronary artery bypass surgery as compared with medical therapy have shown the exercise test to have prognostic power. From this perspective, it is obvious that there is much information supporting the use of exercise testing as the first noninvasive step after the history, physical examination, and resting electrocardiogram in the prognostic evaluation of patients with coronary artery disease. It accomplishes both purposes of prognostic testing: to provide information regarding the patient's status, and to help make recommendations for optimal management. The exercise test results help us make reasonable decisions for selection of patients who should undergo coronary angiography-including quality-of-life issues.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)

High-frequency electrocardiography: an evaluation of lead placement and measurements

Before there is widespread clinical application of the high-frequency ECG, differences resulting from the leads used and the measurement criteria for late potentials must be resolved. Therefore 113 consecutive patients without resting QRS conduction abnormalities referred for Holter monitoring were studied. Four different lead systems were used: a standard bipolar orthogonal lead system and three bipolar lead systems mapping the left ventricle. Measurements made of late potentials included normal and high-frequency QRS duration, their difference, the duration of low-amplitude signals (less than 40 uV) in the terminal QRS, and the root mean square of the last 40 msec of the high-frequency QRS duration. We found that the left ventricular leads tended to give more abnormal measurements than the orthogonal system and that the various measurements failed to agree with each other. In addition, even in this population in which abnormalities of QRS conduction were excluded, the late potential measurements tended to be more abnormal as QRS duration lengthened. These differences in lead systems and measurement criteria must be considered when clinically applying information regarding late potentials measured from the high-frequency ECG.

Application of probability analysis in the diagnosis of coronary artery disease

The accuracy and applicability of probability analysis to the diagnosis of coronary artery disease is still an open question. Although earlier criticisms are well taken, much of the resistance to the application of probability analysis is based on tradition, rather than logic. Probabilistic algorithms, like any new technology, must be researched and developed and then withstand the test of time. They should not be dismissed simply because they are not traditional. On the other hand, probability analysis in the diagnosis of coronary artery disease must not be accepted just because it is attractive or because it appears to simplify clinical decisions. Application of probabilistic approaches should depend on their accuracy. There is evidence that results of tests and clinical data are not statistically independent. There is also evidence that sensitivities and specificities derived from pooled literature cannot be appropriately applied to just any patient in a particular institution. This is due to variability in the population of patients, a lack of standardization of testing methods, and methodologic problems in reporting results of sensitivities and specificities. In a large institution, where probabilistic formulae can be derived with some degree of confidence, probability analysis has an application today. Discriminant functions will be more accurate than Bayesian formulas, but whatever method one chooses, one must be certain that the parameters used are appropriate. Where the institution is not large enough to generate such a data base, there is presently no accurate approach to the estimation of the probability of coronary disease.

Methodologic problems in exercise testing research. Are we solving them?

To evaluate the comparative effects of methodologic factors on the reported accuracies of two standard exercise tests, 56 publications comparing the exercise thallium scintigram with the coronary angiogram were analyzed for conformation to five methodologic standards. Analyzed were adequate definition of study group, avoidance of a limited challenge group, avoidance of workup bias, and blinded analysis of the coronary angiogram and myocardial scintigram. Study group characteristics and technical factors were also reviewed. Better conformation with methodologic standards was found than has been reported previously for treadmill exercise testing. Furthermore, study group characteristics and technical factors were better predictors of sensitivity and specificity than were methodologic deficiencies. Only workup bias and test blinding were significantly associated with test accuracy. The percentage of patients with previous myocardial infarction had the highest correlation and was independently and directly related to sensitivity and inversely related to specificity.