[Specialised palliative home care (SAPV) in an urban setting--a first year experience]

PROJECT DESCRIPTION

The Palliative Home Care Team of the InterdisciplinaryCenterfor Palliative Medicine at Munich University Hospital has been providing Specialized Home Palliative Care (German abbreviation: SAPV) according to the new German regulations since October 2009.

RESULTS

Out of 267 requests, 178 patients were accepted for SAPV, 33 thereof at the level of care coordination and 140 as partial or total home palliative care including 24-h, 7/7 on-call duty. Of the latter group, 90 died at home, 19 in a palliative care unit or hospice and one on a hospital ward.The place of death corresponded to the patients' wishes in 98% of cases. Altogether, emergency medical services other than the SAPV team were called upon in 7 cases, and 12 patients were admitted to a general hospital ward. More than a quarter of our patients had non-oncological diagnoses.The proportion of work dealing with family members (21%) was higher than the patient-related one (19%). The highest percentage (37%) represented office work.

CONCLUSIONS

The requirement for SAPV in the urban setting is high, in spite of the intensive primary care, with an increasing proportion of non-oncological patients. A key aspect concerns the work with family members. SAPV can minimize the number of hospital admissions and emergency calls. The patient's wishes concerning the place of death can be fulfilled. Feed-back from patients and family members indicates that SAPV makes an important contribution towards removing the taboo associated with death and dying.

Medical errors and patient safety in palliative care: a review of current literature

BACKGROUND

Recently, the discussion about medical errors and patient safety has gained scientific as well as public attention. Errors in medicine have been proven to be frequent and to carry enormous financial costs and moral consequences. We aimed to review the research on medical errors in palliative care and to screen relevant literature to appreciate the relevance of safety studies to the field.

METHODS

We performed a literature search using the database PubMed that cross-matched terms for palliative care with the words "errors" and "patient safety." Publications were classified according to type of study and kind of error, and empiric research results were extracted and critically assessed.

RESULTS

We found 44 articles concerning medical errors in palliative care, most of which were case studies. Of these 44 articles, 16 deal with palliative care errors as a key issue, referring mostly to symptom control (n = 13). Other examples are errors in communication, prognostication, and advance care planning. There are very few empirical studies, which are mostly retrospective observational studies.

DISCUSSION

Although patients in palliative care are more vulnerable to errors and their consequences, there is little theoretical or empirical research on the subject. We propose a specific definition for errors in palliative care and analyze the challenges of delineating, identifying and preventing errors in such key areas as prognostication, advance care planning and end-of-life decision-making.

Palliative care in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis: a review of current international guidelines and initiatives

BACKGROUND

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is a relentlessly progressive neurodegenerative condition. Optimal management requires a palliative approach from diagnosis with emphasis on patient autonomy, dignity and quality of life.

OBJECTIVE

To conduct a systematic analysis of the type, level and timing of specialist palliative care intervention in ALS.

RESULTS

Despite an international consensus that ALS management should adopt a multidisciplinary approach, integration of palliative care into ALS management varies considerably across health care systems. Late referral to palliative services in ALS is not uncommon and may impact negatively on the quality of life of ALS patients and their caregivers. However, common themes and principles of engagement can be identified across different jurisdictions, and measurement systems have been established that can assess the impact of palliative care intervention.

CONCLUSIONS

There is considerable evidence that palliative care intervention improves quality of life in patients and carers. International consensus guidelines would assist in the development of a framework for active palliative care engagement in ALS and other neurodegenerative diseases.

A new law on advance directives in Germany

This article presents the new German law on advance directives from 1 September 2009. The history of the parliamentary process of this law is described, the present regulations are explained, their relevance for medical practice discussed and shortcomings are identified. Finally, the new law is compared with other regulations in the international context. Previously established legal practice in Germany has now become largely confirmed by the new law: An advanced directive must be respected in any decision concerning medical treatment, regardless of the stage of the illness. It can be informally revoked at any time, even with limited decision-making capacity. Nobody may be obliged to issue a directive in any way. Advance directives do not need notarisation or routine updating after certain time intervals. Provided that the patient, who is no longer mentally competent, has issued a lasting power of attorney (Bevollmächtiger), or provided that the patient has been appointed a healthcare proxy by the courts (Betreuer), this authorized surrogate must assert the patient's will. The role of the guardianship court is clarified: it only needs to be involved in cases of disagreement as to the patient's will. The new German law thus combines more legal certainty with a liberal emphasis on patient autonomy and flexible, adaptable regulations.

Meaning in life in palliative care patients

CONTEXT

The construct "meaning in life" (MiL) has recently raised the interest of clinicians working in psycho-oncology and end-of-life care and has become a topic of scientific investigation.

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to compare MiL in palliative care (PC) patients with a representative sample of the German population.

METHODS

In this cross-sectional study, all PC patients treated in the PC inpatient unit and through the PC consult service at Ludwig-Maximilians-University Hospital, Munich, from May 2005 to July 2007 were eligible to participate. Patients were interviewed by a doctoral student, psychologist, or physician, all previously trained to administer the Schedule for Meaning in Life Evaluation (SMiLE) in a standardized way. In the SMiLE, respondents first list individual areas that provide meaning to their life before rating their current level of importance and satisfaction with each area. Overall indices of weighting (IoW, range 20-100), satisfaction (IoS, range 0-100), and weighted satisfaction (IoWS, range 0-100) are calculated.

RESULTS

One hundred PC patients completed the SMiLE: the IoS was 70.2 ± 19.7, the IoW was 84.7 ± 11.5, and the IoWS was 72.0 ± 19.4. The representative sample (n=977) scored significantly higher in the IoS (82.8 ± 14.7) and IoWS (83.3 ± 14.8) but not in the IoW (85.6 ± 12.3). Compared with healthy individuals, PC patients are more likely to list partner, friends, leisure, spirituality, well-being, nature/animals, and pleasure as meaningful areas. Examining the satisfaction ratings, it is noteworthy that PC patients' satisfaction scores are fairly high (and not lower than their healthy counterparts') in a number of domains: family, partner, home/garden, spirituality, and finances. On the other hand, they score significantly lower in nature/animals, leisure, friends, well-being, altruism, work, pleasure, and health.

CONCLUSION

These findings underscore the potential of the SMiLE for identifying areas that are particularly important to individuals, and that can be targeted by the PC team to improve overall life satisfaction at the end of life.

Nonconvulsive status epilepticus in palliative care patients

Altered mental status and reduced level of consciousness are common among patients admitted to palliative care units. However, nonconvulsive status epilepticus (NCSE) has rarely been considered as a possible cause, and electroencephalographic confirmation of the epileptic status is sparse. The clinical presentation of patients with NCSE varies from altered mental status to coma, with no or only minimal convulsions. We report a prospective evaluation of patients with altered mental status on admission to our palliative care unit in the year 2007. Of 290 patients admitted in 2007, 49 patients showed signs of confusion or delirium and/or a reduction in their level of consciousness. NCSE was suspected clinically in 22 of these patients, and epileptic activity could be confirmed in 15 (5.2%) of 290 patients. Nine of 15 patients could be effectively treated with anticonvulsants and regained communication ability before death. NCSE appears to be an important, often unrecognized, and potentially treatable cause of altered mental status in palliative care patients. Pharmacological treatment might restore communicative abilities even in severely ill patients.

Breaking the news in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis

Diagnosis communication is a mainstay of the patient-physician relationship and in ALS represents the beginning of the treatment. In Europe, the diagnosis is now communicated to most patients, but with some differences from north to south. Communication is the basis of the patient's autonomy. When adequately informed, patients are able to consider their preferences about life-extending interventions. However, this discussion is sometimes entertained too late. Both the style and the context of this discussion have profound impact on patient satisfaction. The content of the communication should include all relevant information about the disease and should be performed honestly while preserving hope. Collusion with relatives can create difficulties in the relationship with a patient and isolate them from their family. Diagnostic communication is an ongoing process and should form part of every follow-up visit. Communication with the dying patient is often reinforced by non-verbal messages, acknowledgements of patients' emotions, and by listening. Written material may increase satisfaction of patients and their relatives, but should never substitute for face-to-face discussion.

Promoting excellence in end‐of‐life care in ALS

The type and quality of end-of-life care varies greatly in ALS; the time to initiate end-of-life care is not defined, and decision making is hampered by logistical and financial barriers. There has been no systematic review of these issues in ALS. The goals of this initiative are to: 1) improve end-of-life care for patients with ALS and families based on what limited evidence is available; 2) increase awareness, interest, and debate on the end-of-life care in ALS; and 3) identify areas needed for new prospective clinical research. The ALS Peer Workgroup reviewed the literature and 1) identified the current state of knowledge, 2) analysed the gaps in care, and 3) provided recommendations for standard of care and future research. It was shown that areas of investigation are needed on the incorporation of an interdisciplinary approach to care in ALS that includes: psychosocial evaluation and spiritual care; the use of validated instruments to assess patient and caregiver quality of life; and the establishment of proactive caregiver programs. Several public policy changes that will improve coverage for medical care, hospice, and caregiver costs are also reviewed. More clinical evidence is needed on how to provide optimal end-of-life care specifically in ALS.

[End-of-life decisions, powers of attorney, and advance directives]

In modern medicine, decisions about the kind of treatment at life's end are often inevitable. According to German law, powers of attorney and advance directives can be of help in these decisions. When a patient in a state of competence has issued a lasting power of attorney, there is no need for courts to appoint a proxy, and physicians immediately have a legally empowered decision-maker they can address. According to current German law, advance directives are legally valid and binding expressions of a patient's will. They are, however, more powerful when issued after consultation with a physician. If treatment at life's end no longer complies with the patient's will or loses its medical indication, the goal of treatment should be redirected towards palliation. This implies that life-sustaining treatment may be withdrawn or withheld, which is best accomplished with sensitivity to the needs of patients, relatives, and health care professionals.

Nonconvulsive status epilepticus in terminally ill patients-a diagnostic and therapeutic challenge

Nonconvulsive status epilepticus (NCSE) is rarely considered as a cause of confusion in terminally ill patients. The clinical presentation varies from altered mental status to coma, without visible convulsions. Electroencephalogram is the most important diagnostic tool to identify epileptiform activity. Treatment should be initiated following a stepwise model, avoiding intubation and transfer to the intensive care unit. Although mortality rates are high, in some patients NCSE can be reversed by treatment. NCSE should be considered in a differential diagnosis of all terminally ill patients with sudden mental status changes. We present two cases and discuss treatment options and the borders of therapy.

[Changes in therapy aims and palliative treatment for severe stroke]

Recent years have seen considerable advances in acute stroke treatment. Patients who survive the acute phase following major stroke often retain severe limitations of motor, cognitive, and communicative functions. In such patients whose death is imminent, curative therapies should be avoided. Instead, the goal of any therapy should shift to palliative treatment and concentrate on reducing causes of suffering. Palliative methodologies and concepts are already well established in neurology, e.g. for amytrophic lateral sclerosis. Particularly those stroke patients who remain stable for a long period with massive neurological deficits require interdisciplinary palliative care that goes beyond mere reduction of symptoms and seeks a response to possible complications and the question of maintaining life-preserving measures. Not only medical indications but also the expressed or presumed will of the patient must be included in such considerations. This article describes and elucidates basic questions of palliative medicine and symptomatic palliative treatment concepts for stroke patients.