Role of thyrotropin measurements in the diagnosis and management of thyroid disease

This article reviews the role of thyrotropin assays in clinical medicine and illustrates the advantages and limitations of assays that can measure subnormal concentrations. Analytic considerations that can significantly alter the performance of these assays are outlined. The concept of assay generations is defined, and the potential roles of third and fourth generation assays are postulated. In addition, a diagnostic strategy is presented for using TSH and other procedures in the diagnosis and management of thyroid disease.

Thyroid cancer diagnosis and management

This article provides an overview of the classification of thyroid carcinoma into well-differentiated forms (papillary and follicular) as well as the rare Hurthle cell, medullary, and anaplastic forms. The characteristics, relative frequency, and mortality rates of each form of thyroid cancer are summarized. The roles of history, physical examination, blood tests, such as thyroid function test, thyroglobulin (htg), calcitonin and CEA, radionuclide and ultrasound imaging, and fine-needle aspirates are outlined for the diagnosis and management of thyroid cancer. An algorithmic diagram of the monitoring procedures for long-term management of various forms of thyroid cancer is presented.

Linking medical needs and performance goals: clinical and laboratory perspectives on thyroid disease

Diagnosis and management of thyroid disease benefit substantially from close interactions between clinicians and laboratorians. Clinicians desire reliable tests for diagnosis and management of both hypothyroidism and thyrotoxicosis. Traditionally, multitiered testing has been used, beginning with an index of free thyroxine concentration, which, if abnormal, has been followed by basal thyrotropin (TSH) measurements (for hypothyroidism) or thyrotropin-releasing hormone-stimulated TSH measurements (for thyrotoxicosis). Improvements in analytical methods for TSH have made it practical to use basal TSH measurements in serum as the first-line test for thyroid disease. However, performance guidelines are needed, because not all TSH assays work well in this role. The performance guidelines developed by the American Thyroid Association are reviewed to illustrate how they help to assure consistent analytical testing. Further improvements in TSH assays (third- and fourth-generation assays), which support measurements down to 0.01 mlU/L and 0.001 mIU/L, may provide additional advantages for classifying thyrotoxic patients and monitoring thyroxine-suppressive therapy in patients with thyroid cancer. The potential advantages of these newer assays are illustrated with case examples. Additional analytical performance monitors are proposed to help ensure that these next-generation TSH assays meet the expanded clinical needs.

Linking medical needs and performance goals: clinical and laboratory perspectives on thyroid disease

Diagnosis and management of thyroid disease benefit substantially from close interactions between clinicians and laboratorians. Clinicians desire reliable tests for diagnosis and management of both hypothyroidism and thyrotoxicosis. Traditionally, multitiered testing has been used, beginning with an index of free thyroxine concentration, which, if abnormal, has been followed by basal thyrotropin (TSH) measurements (for hypothyroidism) or thyrotropin-releasing hormone-stimulated TSH measurements (for thyrotoxicosis). Improvements in analytical methods for TSH have made it practical to use basal TSH measurements in serum as the first-line test for thyroid disease. However, performance guidelines are needed, because not all TSH assays work well in this role. The performance guidelines developed by the American Thyroid Association are reviewed to illustrate how they help to assure consistent analytical testing. Further improvements in TSH assays (third- and fourth-generation assays), which support measurements down to 0.01 mlU/L and 0.001 mIU/L, may provide additional advantages for classifying thyrotoxic patients and monitoring thyroxine-suppressive therapy in patients with thyroid cancer. The potential advantages of these newer assays are illustrated with case examples. Additional analytical performance monitors are proposed to help ensure that these next-generation TSH assays meet the expanded clinical needs.

Papillary thyroid microcarcinoma: a study of 535 cases observed in a 50-year period

BACKGROUND

The study aims were to characterize patients with papillary thyroid microcarcinoma and to provide data on outcome after surgical therapy.

METHODS

Five hundred thirty-five patients with papillary microcarcinoma had initial treatment at Mayo Clinic from 1940 to 1989. Follow-up extended to 48 years. Median follow-up time for 400 survivors was 16 years. Recurrence and mortality details were derived from a computerized cancer database.

RESULTS

Median tumor size was 8 mm. Ninety-nine percent of tumors were histologic grade 1; 98% were not locally invasive. Thirty-two percent of patients had nodal metastases at examination. TNM stages were I in 485 patients (91%), III in 49 patients (9%), and IV in one patient (0.2%). Ninety-one percent of patients underwent bilateral lobar resection. Tumor resection was incomplete in three cases (0.6%). Radioiodine remnant ablation was performed in 55 patients (10%). All-causes survival did not differ from expected; two patients (0.4%) died of papillary microcarcinoma. Twenty-year tumor recurrence rate was 6%. Higher recurrence rates were seen either with node-positive patients (p < 0.0001) or after unilateral lobectomy (p < 0.0001). Recurrence rates did not appear to be significantly altered by total thyroidectomy (p = 0.44) or radioiodine remnant ablation in node-positive patients (p = 0.99).

CONCLUSIONS

These results reaffirm that papillary microcarcinoma has an excellent prognosis if managed initially by bilateral lobar resection. Routine radioiodine remnant ablation is not indicated.

Follicular thyroid carcinoma with capsular invasion alone: a nonthreatening malignancy

BACKGROUND

The study was designed to determine whether invasion of the tumor capsule, in the absence of vascular invasion (VI), was significant in predicting cause-specific mortality in follicular thyroid carcinoma (FTC).

METHODS

Seventy-two patients with FTC were treated by us during 1971 through 1985. In 65 cases the tumors could be classified as either showing capsular invasion (CI) alone (20) or VI, with or without CI, (45). Median follow-up of 45 survivors was 11 years; 12 patients died of FTC.

RESULTS

The 10-year occurrence rates for cause-specific mortality and distant metastases were 28% and 19%, respectively, for patients with VI. Comparable rates for the patients with CI were 0% (p = 0.019) and 0% (p = 0.052), respectively. By univariate analysis, higher rates of cause-specific mortality were significantly associated with distant metastases at diagnosis (p < 0.0001), the presence of VI (p = 0.019), and moderate or marked microinvasion (p = 0.019). In stepwise multivariate analyses, only distant metastases at diagnosis had independent prognostic significance (p < 0.0001) in the prediction of cause-specific mortality. In a Cox model, adjusting for distant metastases at diagnosis, the presence of VI was of borderline significance (p = 0.06) in predicting cause-specific mortality.

CONCLUSIONS

FTC, diagnosed on the basis of CI alone, did not result in either distant metastases or cancer-related death. The dominant determinant of cause-specific mortality was the presence of distant metastases at diagnosis.

Medullary thyroid carcinoma: clinicopathologic features and long-term follow-up of 65 patients treated during 1946 through 1970

We retrospectively reviewed the medical records of 65 consecutive patients with medullary thyroid carcinoma, who had had their primary surgical treatment at the Mayo Clinic during the years 1946 through 1970. Of these patients, 58 had sporadic and 7 had familial medullary thyroid carcinoma. Thyroid nodules were the most common initial manifestation. Near-total thyroidectomy was the most frequent initial operation. Survival was affected by the following factors: male sex, familial inheritance, size of the tumor, stage of the tumor (American Joint Committee on Cancer), and completeness of initial resection of the tumor. The mean duration of follow-up was 23.5 years, and the maximal follow-up was 36 years. Among 52 patients without initial distant metastatic involvement and with complete resection of the tumor, 20-year survival free of distant metastatic lesions was 81%. Overall 10- and 20-year survival rates were 63% and 44%, respectively. Because of the substantial morbidity and mortality associated with medullary thyroid carcinoma, early diagnosis and thorough initial resection of the tumor are important.

Non-Hodgkin's lymphoma of the thyroid: is more than biopsy necessary?

Whereas excisional surgery and radiotherapy have resulted in a favorable outcome when non-Hodgkin's lymphoma of the thyroid (NHLT) is confined to the thyroid gland, controversy persists over the potential advantage of aggressive debulking in favor of diagnostic biopsy alone when disease cannot be completely resected. Our aims in this study were to delineate the present role of surgery in NHLT in pre-operative staging, the impact of the extent of resection on achieving complete remission and cause-specific survival, and patterns of failure. All 62 patients who underwent primary surgery for NHLT at the Mayo Clinic between 1965 and 1989 were analyzed. By postoperative staging, 50 patients were stage IE or IIE. Overall survival was 53% and 46% at 5 and 10 years; 80% for stage IE confined to the thyroid, 58% for stage IE-extrathyroid, 50% for stage IIE, and 36% for stages IIIE and IVE. Complete remission was achieved in 88% of patients who underwent diagnostic biopsy plus adjuvant therapy alone compared to 85% for patients in whom debulking plus adjuvant therapy was used. There was no difference in cause-specific survival in these two groups or in cause-specific survival in two subgroups who achieved complete remission. Relapse after complete remission occurred in 12 (26%) of 46 patients, only 2 of whom survived long-term after salvage therapy. The role of surgery in NHLT is diminishing and advances that will increase complete remission and relapse-free survival will not likely involve more aggressive surgical resections.

Hürthle cell (oxyphilic) papillary thyroid carcinoma: a variant with more aggressive biologic behavior

The latest World Health Organization International Classification defines papillary thyroid carcinoma by its "follicular cell differentiation...as well as characteristic nuclear changes". However the oxyphilic (Hürthle cell) papillary carcinoma have nuclei which generally resemble the nuclei seen in oxyphilic follicular carcinomas, and such oxyphilic papillary tumors may behave more aggressively than typical papillary cancers. To further characterize these rare tumors, we identified during a 32-year period 22 patients with oxyphilic papillary cancer and compared them with 1,084 patients with typical papillary cancers and 57 patients with oxyphilic follicular cancers treated by the Mayo surgical group during the same time period. Although typical papillary and oxyphilic papillary cancers were comparable with regards to patient age, tumor size and extent, TNM stage, and prognostic score (AGES), there were significant differences. Compared to typical papillary tumors, oxyphilic papillary cancers had fewer neck nodal metastases at primary diagnosis (5% vs 40%, p less than 0.0001), were more often DNA non-diploid (71% vs 21%, p less than 0.001), and after 10 postoperative years had higher rates of both tumor recurrence (28% vs 11%, p less than 0.0001) and cause-specific mortality (1.7% vs 4%, p less than 0.0005). In these four important respects the oxyphilic papillary cancers more resembled the oxyphilic follicular cancers. For oxyphilic follicular cancers, the frequency of initial neck nodal metastases was 7% (cf 5%); 83% of the oxyphilic follicular tumors were non-diploid (cf 71%), and at 10 years postoperatively the tumor recurrence and cause-specific mortality rates were 28% and 18%, insignificantly different from 28% and 17% seen with the oxyphilic papillary cancers.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Ret oncogene activation in human thyroid neoplasms is restricted to the papillary cancer subtype

We have recently reported the activation of a new oncogene in human papillary thyroid carcinomas. This oncogene, papillary thyroid carcinoma (PTC), is a novel rearranged version of the ret tyrosine-kinase protooncogene. Thyroid neoplasms include a broad spectrum of malignant tumors, ranging from well-differentiated tumors to undifferentiated anaplastic carcinomas. To determine the frequency of ret oncogene activation, we analyzed 286 cases of human thyroid tumors of diverse histologic types. We found the presence of an activated form of the ret oncogene in 33 (19%) of 177 papillary carcinomas. By contrast, none of the other 109 thyroid tumors, which included 37 follicular, 15 anaplastic, and 18 medullary carcinomas, and 34 benign lesions, showed ret activation.

Prognostic significance of calcitonin immunoreactivity, amyloid staining, and flow cytometric DNA measurements in medullary thyroid carcinoma

The proven power of DNA ploidy to predict mortality risk in medullary thyroid carcinoma (MTC) may be weakened when analyzed in conjunction with calcitonin immunoreactivity (CI) and amyloid staining (AS) of tumors. In this study 12 prognostic variables, including DNA ploidy, CI, and AS, were studied in 65 patients with MTC (57 sporadic; mean age 51 years) treated during 1946 through 1970. Cause-specific mortality rates at 10 and 15 years were 15% and 26%, respectively. By univariate analysis, TNM stages III or IV (p less than 0.0001), tumor unresectability (p less than 0.0001), male sex (p = 0.019), negative AS (p = 0.032), and low CI (p = 0.033) were significant predictors of increased mortality rates. DNA ploidy (p = 0.058) and inheritance pattern (p = 0.25) were nonsignificant. By multivariate analysis, only TNM stage, tumor resectability, and AS were independently significant (p less than 0.005). A prognostic model was created, based on presence or absence of these independent risk factors, and four risk groups were defined, capable of predictably defining mortality rates in MTC (p less than 0.0001). The model requires validation in larger series and independent verification by others. However, we believe that a risk-group scheme for MTC based on AS, disease stage, and completeness of tumor resection may have wide applicability and prove relevant to clinicians treating this disease.

The association between Alzheimer's disease and thyroid disease in Rochester, Minnesota

To determine whether an association exists between Alzheimer's disease (AD) and thyroid disease, we carried out two studies in the population of Rochester, Minnesota. We reviewed medical records of a cohort of 198 women with histologically confirmed Hashimoto's thyroiditis (1935 to 1974) for evidence of subsequent dementia, applying the criteria used for dementia in a previous determination of incidence and prevalence rates in this population. From a total of 4,197 person-years of follow-up, eight cases of AD were diagnosed, whereas the expected number was 5.8. The standardized morbidity ratio was 1.37, which failed to reach statistical significance. The second study was a retrospective case-control comparison that sought any relationship between AD and all thyroid disorders, using a previously identified (1960 to 1979) AD cohort (N = 646) and their age- and sex-matched controls. For myxedema there was a positive association for AD without significance, whereas in Graves' disease there was a significant negative association for AD.

Cytogenetic and molecular genetic studies of follicular and papillary thyroid cancers

Cytogenetic studies have shown frequent clonal abnormalities in papillary carcinoma (PTC) and follicular carcinoma (FTC). Loss of heterozygosity (LOH) may suggest the presence of tumor suppressor genes and has not been reported in these neoplasms. These studies were undertaken to determine if consistent chromosomal abnormalities are associated with thyroid cancer, to determine likely regions for molecular genetic investigations, and to determine if there is allelic loss in thyroid tumors. Cytogenetic analysis of 26 PTC and 5 FTC showed clonal abnormalities in 9 and included -Y, +5, or inv(10)(q11.2q21.2) in PTC, and -Y or near haploidy in FTC. Using DNA probes specific for chromosomes 1, 3, 10, 16, and 17, we carried out restriction fragment length polymorphism analysis on 6 FTC, 3 follicular adenomas (FA), and 12 PTC. LOH of all informative loci on chromosome 3p was observed in all 6 FTC, but not in FA or PTC. No LOH was observed for loci mapped to chromosome 10 in PTC. Our results suggest: cytogenetic abnormalities of chromosome 10q are associated with PTC; cytogenetic and molecular abnormalities of chromosome 3 are associated with FTC; and a tumor suppressor gene may be present on the short arm of chromosome 3 important for the development or progression of FTC.

Cytogenetics of six follicular thyroid adenomas including a case report of an oxyphil variant with t(8;14)(q13;q24.1)

Cytogenetic analyses were performed on six follicular thyroid adenomas. Five had normal karyotypes and one, an oxyphil adenoma, had a t(8;14)(q13;q24.1). This patient also had a history of pleomorphic adenoma of the parotid gland. This clonal abnormality may suggest a primary genetic lesion in this patient who had two different benign neoplasms.

Loss of heterozygosity suggests multiple genetic alterations in pheochromocytomas and medullary thyroid carcinomas

Loss of heterozygosity (LOH) at specific loci may help localize tumor suppressor genes involved in the formation of various familial and sporadic tumors. In addition, the genetic loci for a number of familial tumor syndromes have been mapped by linkage analysis. To explore the possible role of tumor suppressor genes in endocrine tumors, we tested 41 pheochromocytomas (34 sporadic and 7 familial) and 11 medullary thyroid cancers (MTC) (10 sporadic and 1 familial) for LOH near a variety of potentially important genetic loci: (a) the multiple endocrine neoplasia type 2A (MEN 2A) locus on chromosome 10; (b) the von Hippel-Lindau locus on 3p; and (c) the p53 and neurofibromatosis 1 loci on 17. We also examined chromosomes 1p and 22q because previous studies in a small number of pheochromocytomas and MTCs suggested LOH in these regions. Background rates for LOH were assessed using several "random" probes. Finally, we examined a number of clinical and histologic characteristics of these tumors for possible correlations with specific genetic alterations. LOH in the region of the MEN 2A locus was uncommon (0% for MTCs, 5% for pheochromocytomas). However, we found significant allelic losses in pheochromocytomas on chromosomes 1p (42%), 3p (16%), 17p (24%), and 22q (31%). We also noted a correlation between LOH on 1p and urinary excretion of metanephrine by these patients (P = 0.02). LOH on 1p, 3p, and 17p also appeared to be associated with increased tumor volume. Analysis of the smaller number of MTCs demonstrated allelic losses on chromosomes 1p and 22q. Our results suggest that tumor formation and/or progression in pheochromocytomas and MTCs involves multiple genes, analogous with the model proposed for colon carcinoma.

Prognostic significance of nondiploid DNA determined by flow cytometry in sporadic and familial medullary thyroid carcinoma

To clarify the role of DNA measurements in predicting outcome after surgical treatment of medullary thyroid carcinoma (MTC), we performed flow cytometric analysis in nuclear suspensions of 119 MTC tumors. Of the 119 patients, 63 (53%) patients had sporadic tumors and 56 (47%) patients had familial tumors; survivors were followed for a mean of 13 years. DNA content was normal in 92 (77%) patients and abnormal (nondiploid) in 27 (23%) patients. Ten-year cause-specific mortality rates were 12%, 42%, and 49% with diploid, tetraploid/polyploid, or aneuploid tumors (p = 0.0009) and were greater with nondiploid tumors both in the sporadic (p = 0.012) and multiple endocrine neoplasia (familial) cases (p = 0.114). None of 27 patients with TNM stage I disease died of MTC. In patients with TNM stages II, III, and IV disease, DNA nondiploid tumors were associated with increased deaths from MTC. In a Cox proportional hazards model involving all 119 patients and adjusted for disease stage and inheritance pattern, nondiploid DNA was independently associated with increased deaths from MTC (p = 0.008). In an identical Cox model restricted to the 92 DNA diploid tumors, an S-phase fraction of 15.0% or more remained a significant variable (p = 0.034) after adjustment for stage and inheritance pattern. We therefore conclude that DNA measurements do have a role to play in predicting outcome after surgical treatment of MTC.

Long-term course of patients with persistent hypercalcitoninemia after apparent curative primary surgery for medullary thyroid carcinoma

Thirty-one patients with persistent hypercalcitoninemia after seemingly adequate primary operation for medullary thyroid carcinoma (MTC) were followed for a mean period of 11.9 years after operation. Ten patients had sporadic MTC and the remaining patients were members of families with multiple endocrine neoplasia (MEN)--either MEN 2A (15 patients) or MEN 2B (six patients). Overall 5- and 10-year survival rates were 90% and 86%, respectively. Only four patients died at the completion of the study: two of MTC and two of unrelated causes. Eleven patients (35.5%) underwent surgical re-exploration after demonstration of recurrent disease clinically or radiologically. In no patient did the calcitonin level return to normal after re-exploration. The presence of more than three metastatic nodes at the time of initial operation was a statistically significant (p = 0.003) predictor for disease recurrence. Factors approaching statistical significance were patients younger than age 35 (p = 0.06) and the percentage of cells in the S phase of cell division (0.07). This data supports a conservative surgical philosophy in the management of the patient with persistent hypercalcitoninemia after resection of MTC.

Frequent occurrence of cytogenetic abnormalities in sporadic nonmedullary thyroid carcinoma

Cytogenetic studies may provide important clues to the molecular pathogenesis of thyroid neoplasia. Thus, the authors attempted cytogenetic studies on 12 thyroid carcinomas: seven papillary, three follicular, and two anaplastic. Successful cytogenetic results were obtained on all 12 tumors; nine (75%) had one or more chromosomally abnormal clones. Four of the papillary carcinomas had a simple clonal karyotype, and three had no apparent chromosome abnormality. All four abnormal papillary tumors contained an anomaly of a chromosome 10q arm. In one instance, an inv(10)(q11.2q21.2) was observed in a Grade 2 papillary carcinoma as the sole acquired abnormality. In another case, an inversion or insertion involving 10q21.2 was found in a Grade 1 papillary tumor. The karyotype of a third tumor, a Grade 1 papillary carcinoma, was 46,XX,der(5)t(5;10)(p15.3;q11),der(9)t(9;?)(q11;?). A fourth abnormal papillary carcinoma, a Grade 1 tumor, had a t(6;10)(q21;q26.1) as the sole abnormality. Each of the five follicular or anaplastic carcinomas had a complex clonal karyotype. The three follicular carcinomas contained an abnormality of 3p25-p21, along with several other chromosome abnormalities.

Papillary thyroid carcinoma

Multiple prognostic factors for outcome in papillary thyroid carcinoma are identified. For a cohort of 1500 consecutive patients followed an average of 16 years, survival rates for tumor recurrence and cause-specific mortality are described. Risk groups derived from novel prognostic scoring or staging systems and the role of DNA ploidy testing are discussed specifically. Lastly, controversies are reviewed regarding the extent of primary surgical resection and the efficacy of postoperative radioiodine remnant ablation in papillary thyroid cancer.

Diagnostic and prognostic utility of flow cytometric DNA measurements in follicular thyroid tumors

Distinguishing cellular follicular adenomas (FA) from minimally invasive follicular carcinomas (FC) continues to plague even experienced thyroid pathologists. DNA ploidy analysis has been promoted as a means of making this differentiation; however, the finding of DNA aneuploidy in FA has caused concern that they may demonstrate potential for malignant behavior or should even be reclassified as low-grade noninvasive cancers. In histologically-proven FC, nuclear DNA content has been claimed to have predictive power equivalent to that of all other prognostic factors combined. The aims of the present study, therefore, were to define the DNA ploidy characteristics of FA and FC, to assess the diagnostic potential of cell-cycle parameters, and, in FC, to investigate the prognostic role of such measurements. We measured DNA content of 124 tumors (60 FA, 64 FC). DNA pattern was normal (diploid) in 75% of FA and 45% of FC, tetraploid/polyploid (T/P) in 13% of FA and 25% of FC, and aneuploid in 12% of FA and 30% of FC. FC was histologically verified in 39% of DNA normal, 67% of T/P, and 73% of aneuploid tumors. DNA index, S-phase, G2M, and S-phase plus G2M were analyzed and were not helpful in differentiating between FA and FC. No patient with FA developed tumor recurrence. In FC (excluding the Hürthle cell variant), no significant differences were found among the 3 DNA ploidy groups with respect to either cancer death or tumor recurrence; however, combining the Hürthle cell variant of follicular carcinomas with pure follicular carcinomas, the presence of distant metastases, DNA aneuploidy, and patient age were the only independently significant prognostic variables.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Practical management of hyperthyroidism

There are several causes of hyperthyroidism, and correct diagnosis is essential for management. Graves' disease is most commonly managed with radioactive iodine therapy (131I), antithyroid drugs or surgery. Toxic adenomas (single or multiple) may be treated with 131I or surgery. Most types of thyroiditis are managed expectantly. Pregnant women, children and the elderly deserve special consideration. Follow-up is vital to identify the later development of hypothyroidism.