Estimates of protein surface areas in solution by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

The extent of multiple charging of protein ions in electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectra depends on the solvent-exposed surface area, but it may also be influenced by a variety of other extrinsic and intrinsic factors. Gas-phase ion chemistry (charge-transfer and charge-partitioning reactions) appears to be the major extrinsic factor influencing the extent of protonation as detected by ESI MS. In this work, we demonstrate that under carefully controlled conditions, which limit the occurrence of the charge-transfer reactions in the gas phase, charge-state distributions of protein ions can be used to assess the solvent-exposed surface area in solution. A set of proteins ranging from 5-kDa insulin to 500-kDa ferritin shows a clear correlation between the average charge in ESI mass spectra acquired under native conditions and their surface areas calculated based on the available crystal structures. An increase of the extent of charge-transfer reactions in the ESI interface results in a noticeable decrease of the average charge of protein ions across the entire range of tested proteins, while the charge-surface correlation is maintained. On the other hand, the intrinsic factors (e.g., a limited number of basic residues) do not appear to play a significant role in determining the protein ion charge. Based on these results, it is now possible to obtain estimates of the surface areas of proteins and protein complexes, for which crystal structures are not available. We also demonstrate how the ESI MS measurements can be used to characterize protein-protein interaction in solution by providing quantitative information on the subunit interfaces formed in protein associations.

Estimates of Protein Surface Areas in Solution by Electrospray Ionization Mass Spectrometry

The extent of multiple charging of protein ions in electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectra depends on the solvent-exposed surface area, but it may also be influenced by a variety of other extrinsic and intrinsic factors. Gas-phase ion chemistry (charge-transfer and charge-partitioning reactions) appears to be the major extrinsic factor influencing the extent of protonation as detected by ESI MS. In this work, we demonstrate that under carefully controlled conditions, which limit the occurrence of the charge-transfer reactions in the gas phase, charge-state distributions of protein ions can be used to assess the solvent-exposed surface area in solution. A set of proteins ranging from 5-kDa insulin to 500-kDa ferritin shows a clear correlation between the average charge in ESI mass spectra acquired under native conditions and their surface areas calculated based on the available crystal structures. An increase of the extent of charge-transfer reactions in the ESI interface results in a noticeable decrease of the average charge of protein ions across the entire range of tested proteins, while the charge-surface correlation is maintained. On the other hand, the intrinsic factors (e.g., a limited number of basic residues) do not appear to play a significant role in determining the protein ion charge. Based on these results, it is now possible to obtain estimates of the surface areas of proteins and protein complexes, for which crystal structures are not available. We also demonstrate how the ESI MS measurements can be used to characterize protein-protein interaction in solution by providing quantitative information on the subunit interfaces formed in protein associations.

Mapping protein energy landscapes with amide hydrogen exchange and mass spectrometry: I. A generalized model for a two-state protein and comparison with experiment

Protein amide hydrogen exchange (HDX) is a convoluted process, whose kinetics is determined by both dynamics of the protein and the intrinsic exchange rate of labile hydrogen atoms fully exposed to solvent. Both processes are influenced by a variety of intrinsic and extrinsic factors. A mathematical formalism initially developed to rationalize exchange kinetics of individual amide hydrogen atoms is now often used to interpret global exchange kinetics (e.g., as measured in HDX MS experiments). One particularly important advantage of HDX MS is direct visualization of various protein states by observing distinct protein ion populations with different levels of isotope labeling under conditions favoring correlated exchange (the so-called EX1 exchange mechanism). However, mildly denaturing conditions often lead to a situation where the overall HDX kinetics cannot be clearly classified as either EX1 or EX2. The goal of this work is to develop a framework for a generalized exchange model that takes into account multiple processes leading to amide hydrogen exchange, and does not require that the exchange proceed strictly via EX1 or EX2 kinetics. To achieve this goal, we use a probabilistic approach that assigns a transition probability and a residual protection to each equilibrium state of the protein. When applied to a small protein chymotrypsin inhibitor 2, the algorithm allows complex HDX patterns observed experimentally to be modeled with remarkably good fidelity. On the basis of the model we are now in a position to begin to extract quantitative dynamic information from convoluted exchange kinetics.

Transient structural disorder as a facilitator of protein-ligand binding: native H/D exchange-mass spectrometry study of cellular retinoic acid binding protein I

Binding of all-trans Retinoic Acid (RA) to Cellular Retinoic Acid Binding Protein I (CRABP I) does not result in significant changes of the protein tertiary structure, even though the binding site is inaccessible in a static apo-protein conformation. One of the proposed scenarios for the protein-ligand binding process invokes the notion of a flexible portal region adjacent to the binding site, while another model suggests that the requisite dynamic events are induced by dimerization of the apo-protein in solution. In this work, RA binding to CRABP I is studied in dilute solutions (low micro-molar range), where no dimer and/or oligomer formation occurs. Modulation of backbone dynamics within various segments of the protein by its ligand is assessed using a combination of hydrogen exchange, electrospray ionization mass spectrometry, and collision-induced dissociation of protein ions in the gas phase. Consistent with the portal model of ligand entry, several protein segments (most of them containing residues making hydrophobic contacts to RA in the holo-form of the protein) are flexible in the absence of the ligand. At the same time, the two segments containing arginine residues forming a salt bridge with RA form the least flexible region in the apo-form of the protein. Although the presence of RA in solution reduces flexibility of all protein segments, the largest effect is observed within four strands that form one of the two beta-sheets enveloping a cavity which houses the ligand-binding site. These results are consistent with a model in which ligand binding occurs through a partially unstructured state of the protein with unobstructed access to the ligand-binding site. This intermediate (whose core is formed by the two stable arginine-containing strands) corresponds to a relatively low-energy local minimum on the apo-protein energy surface and is frequently sampled under native conditions.

Methods to study protein dynamics and folding by mass spectrometry

It is clear that merely knowing the structure of a protein alone is not sufficient to fully understand its behavior: knowledge also of the dynamic events that occur within proteins is vital to elucidate their function and folding. In recent years, mass spectrometry has come to the forefront as a powerful biophysical method, which can shed light both on the structure and dynamics of proteins. Hydrogen exchange monitored by mass spectrometry is a highly sensitive marker of the backbone dynamics in solution that, combined with gas phase dissociation techniques, can provide a high resolution tool to locate the dynamic regions of a protein. Additionally, charge state distributions in electrospray mass spectra yield insight into the nature and population of alternate structural states present at equilibrium. In this paper, we describe several applications of these methodologies to probe the dynamic events key to the structure, folding, and biological functions of proteins.

Indirect detection of protein-metal binding: interaction of serum transferrin with In3+ and Bi3+

Transferrins comprise a class of monomeric glycoproteins found in all vertebrates, whose function is iron sequestration and transport. In addition to iron, serum transferrin also binds a variety of other metals and is believed to provide a route for the in vivo delivery of such metals to cells. In the present study, ESI MS is used to investigate interactions between human serum transferrin and two nonferrous metals, indium (a commonly used imaging agent) and bismuth (a component of many antiulcer drugs). While the UV-Vis absorption spectroscopy measurements clearly indicate that both metals bind strongly to transferrin in solution, the metal-protein complex can be detected by ESI MS only for indium, but not for bismuth. Despite the apparently low stability of the transferrin-bismuth complex in the gas phase, presence of such complex in solution can be established by ESI MS indirectly. This is done by monitoring the evolution of charge state distributions of transferrin ions upon acid-induced protein unfolding in the presence and in the absence of the metal in solution. The anomalous instability of the transferrin-bismuth complex in the gas phase is rationalized in terms of conformational differences between this form of transferrin and the holo-forms of this protein produced by binding of metals with smaller ionic radii (e.g., Fe3+ and In3+). The large size of Bi3+ ion is likely to prevent formation of a closed conformation (canonical structure of the holo-protein), resulting in a non-native metal coordination. It is suggested that transferrin retains the open conformation (characteristic of the apo-form) upon binding Bi3+, with only two ligands in the metal coordination sphere provided by the protein itself. This suggestion is corroborated by the results of circular dichroism measurements in the near-UV range. Since the cellular consumption of metals in the transferrin cycle critically depends upon recognition of the holo-protein complex by the transferrin receptor, the noncanonical conformation of the transferrin-bismuth complex may explain very inefficient delivery of bismuth to cells even when a high dosage of bismuth-containing drugs is administered for prolonged periods of time.

Is there hydrogen scrambling in the gas phase? Energetic and structural determinants of proton mobility within protein ions

The extent of internal hydrogen exchange (scrambling) within multiply charged solvent-free protein ions was investigated using a small model protein. The site-specific backbone amide protection data were obtained using protein ion fragmentation in the gas phase and compared with the available NMR data. Only minimal scrambling was detected when relatively high-energy collisional activation was used to fragment intact protein ions, while low-energy fragmentation resulted in more significant but not random internal exchange. Increased conformational flexibility of protein ions in the gas phase did not have any effect on the extent of hydrogen scrambling under the conditions of higher-energy collisional activation but resulted in totally random redistribution of labile hydrogen atoms when the protein ion fragmentation was induced by multiple low-energy collisions.

Highly asymmetric interactions between globin chains during hemoglobin assembly revealed by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

Dynamics of bovine hemoglobin assembly was investigated by monitoring monomers/oligomers equilibria in solution with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry and circular dichroism spectroscopy. Intensities of ionic signals corresponding to various protein species (tetramers, dimers, heme-deficient dimers, as well as apo- and holo-monomers) were used to estimate relative fractions of these species in solution as a function of pH. The fraction of folded protein for each observed species was estimated based on charge-state distributions of corresponding ionic species in the mass spectra. The cumulative numbers (averaged across the entire protein population) were in good agreement with circular dichroism data at the Soret band and in the far-UV region, respectively. The mass spectral data confirm that hemoglobin dissociation involves a step where heme is first lost from the beta-chain of the alpha beta-dimer to form a heme-deficient dimeric species. This dimer dissociates further to produce a holo-alpha-chain and an apo-beta-chain. The former is tightly folded into a comparatively compact structure at neutral pH, while the latter always exhibits significant backbone disorder. Acidification of the protein solution to pH 4 leads to partial heme dissociation and significant increase of the backbone flexibility in the alpha-chains as well. Complete dissociation of the heme from the alpha-chains at a pH below 4 coincides with the total disappearance of the dimeric and tetrameric hemoglobin species from the mass spectra. The experimental data provide strong evidence that binding of a partially unstructured apo-beta-chain to a tightly folded holo-alpha-chain to form a heme-deficient dimer is the initial step of hemoglobin assembly. Such binding locks the beta-chain in a highly ordered conformation, which allows for an efficient heme acquisition, followed by docking of two hemoglobin dimers to form a tetrameric form of the protein. The asymmetry of the roles of the two chains in the assembly process is surprising, given a rather high sequence homology (ca. 43%) and highlights functional importance of intrinsic protein disorder. The study also demonstrates a tremendous potential of mass spectrometry as an analytical tool capable of elucidating protein interaction mechanisms in highly heterogeneous systems.

A Chemometric Approach to Detection and Characterization of Multiple Protein Conformers in Solution Using Electrospray Ionization Mass Spectrometry

Protein ion charge state distributions in electrospray ionization mass spectra have a potential to provide a wealth of information on protein dynamics, because they contain contributions from all protein conformers present in solution. Such ionic contributions often overlap, limiting the amount of useful information that can be extracted from the spectra. This difficulty is overcome in the present work by using a chemometric approach, which allows spectral deconvolution to be carried out and information on individual protein conformers to be extracted. Experiments are carried out by acquiring a series of spectra over a range of near-native and denaturing conditions to ensure significant changes in the conformers' populations. A total number of protein conformers sampled in the course of the experiments is determined by subjecting the set of collected spectra to singular value decomposition. Ionic contributions of each conformer to the total signal are then determined using a supervised optimization routine. Validation of the method has been carried out by monitoring acid- and alcohol-induced equilibrium states of well-characterized model proteins, chymotrypsin inhibitor 2 (two states), ubiquitin (three states) and apo-myoglobin (four states). For each of the model proteins, a new chemometric procedure yielded a picture of protein dynamics that was in excellent agreement with their documented behavior (as studied with other biophysical tools). The new method appears to be well-suited for monitoring protein dynamics in highly heterogeneous systems consisting of multiple proteins sampling a range of conformational states.

Interlobe communication in human serum transferrin: metal binding and conformational dynamics investigated by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

Human serum transferrin (hTF) is an iron transport protein, comprising two lobes (N and C), each containing a single metal-binding center. Despite substantial structural similarity between the two lobes, studies have demonstrated the existence of significant differences in their metal-binding properties. The nature of these differences has been elucidated through the use of electrospray ionization mass spectrometry to study both metal retention and conformational properties of hTF under a variety of conditions. In the absence of chelating agents or nonsynergistic anions, the diferric form of hTF remains intact until the pH is lowered to 4.5. The monoferric form of hTF retains the compact conformation until the pH is lowered to 4.0, whereas the apoprotein becomes partially unfolded at pH as high as 5.5. Selective (lobe-specific) modulation of the iron-binding properties of hTF using recombinant forms of the protein (in which the pH-sensitive elements in each lobe were mutated) verifies that the N-lobe of the protein has a lower affinity for ferric ion. Surprisingly, the apo-N-lobe is significantly less flexible compared to the apo-C-lobe. Furthermore, the conformation of the iron-free N-lobe is stabilized when the C-lobe contains iron, confirming the existence of an interlobe interaction within the protein. The experimental results provide strong support for the earlier suggestion that hTF interacts with its receptor (TFR) primarily through the C-lobe both at the cell surface and inside the endosome.

Indirect assessment of small hydrophobic ligand binding to a model protein using a combination of ESI MS and HDX/ESI MS

Direct mass spectrometric characterization of interactions between proteins and small hydrophobic ligands often poses a serious problem due to the complex instability in the gas phase. We have developed a method that probes the efficacy of ligand-protein interactions indirectly by monitoring changes in protein flexibility. The latter is assessed quantitatively using a combination of charge state distribution analysis and amide hydrogen exchange under both native and mildly denaturing conditions. The method was used to evaluate binding of a model protein cellular retinoic acid binding protein I to its natural ligand all-trans retinoic acid (RA), isomers 13-cis- and 9-cis-RA, and retinol, yielding the following order of ligand affinities: All-trans RA > 9-cis RA > 13-cis RA, with no detectable binding of retinol. This order is in agreement with the results of earlier fluorimetric titration studies. Furthermore, binding energy of the protein to each of retinoic acid isomers was determined based on the measured hydrogen exchange kinetics data acquired under native conditions.

Influence of Polyether Copolymer Configuration on Polyurethane Reaction: A Mass Spectrometry Analysis

Matrix Assisted Laser Desorption Ionization Time-of-Flight mass spectrometry has been applied to obtain the molecular weight distribution of two polyether copolymers containing ethylene oxide and propylene oxide units. The measured molecular weights and their distributions were surprisingly different from the expected. Based upon the natural isotopic abundance, it was possible to provide a quantitative description of the number of ethylene oxide and propylene oxide units as a function of molecular weight. Important information on composition drift and heterogeneity can be obtained from the 3-D bivariate deconvolution of the mass spectra. As the molecular weight of a random copolymer increased, the ethylene oxide content also increased. A copolymer system with a narrow molecular weight distribution did not necessarily have a narrow composition distribution. These results provide information at the molecular level regarding the hydrophilicity of these copolymers used in polyurethane formulations.

Differential effect of a his tag at the N- and C-termini: functional studies with recombinant human serum transferrin

Attachment of a cleavable hexa His tag is a common strategy for the production of recombinant proteins. Production of two recombinant nonglycosylated human serum transferrins (hTF-NG), containing a factor Xa cleavage site and a hexa His tag at the carboxyl terminus, has been described [Mason et al. (2001) Prot. Exp. Purif 23, 142-150]. More recently, hTF-NG with an amino-terminal His tag and a factor Xa cleavage site has been expressed (>30 mg/L) in baby hamster kidney cells and purified from the tissue culture medium. Although it is frequently assumed that addition of a His tag has little or no effect on function, this is not always confirmed experimentally. In the present study, in vitro quantitative data clearly shows that the presence of the C-terminal His tag has an effect on the release of iron from recombinant hTF at pH 7.4 and 5.6. Measurement of the rate of release from both the N- and C-lobes is reduced 2-4-fold. These findings provide further compelling evidence that the two lobes communicate with each other and highlight the importance of the C-terminal portion of the C-terminal lobe in this interaction. In contrast to these results, we demonstrate that the presence of a His tag at the N-terminus of hTF has no effect on the rate of iron release from either lobe. In a competition experiment, both unlabeled N- and C-terminal His-tagged constructs were equally effective at inhibiting the binding of radio-iodinated diferric glycosylated hTF from a commercial source to receptors on HeLa cells as the unlabeled recombinant diferric hTF-NG control. Thus, the presence of a His tag at either the N- or C-terminus of hTF-NG has no apparent effect on the ability of these hTF species to bind to transferrin receptors.

Crossing the phase boundary to study protein dynamics and function: combination of amide hydrogen exchange in solution and ion fragmentation in the gas phase

Protein dynamics are the key to understanding their behavior. The static protein structure alone in most cases is insufficient to describe the vast array of complex functions they perform in vivo. Until recently there were relatively few techniques available to investigate the dynamic nature of these proteins. Mass spectrometry has recently emerged as a powerful biophysical method, capable of providing both structural and dynamic information. By utilizing the labile nature of amide hydrogens as a marker of the backbone dynamics in solution, combined with gas-phase dissociation techniques, we now have a high-resolution tool to locate these exchanging hydrogens within the sequence of the protein and to probe the functional importance of its structural elements. In this paper we describe several applications of these methodologies to illustrate the importance of dynamics to the biological functions of proteins.

Studies of biomolecular conformations and conformational dynamics by mass spectrometry

In the post-genomic era, a wealth of structural information has been amassed for proteins from NMR and crystallography. However, static protein structures alone are not a sufficient description: knowledge of the dynamic nature of proteins is essential to understand their wide range of functions and behavior during the life cycle from synthesis to degradation. Furthermore, few proteins have the ability to act alone in the crowded cellular environment. Assemblies of multiple proteins governed by complex signaling pathways are often required for the tasks of target recognition, binding, transport, and function. Mass spectrometry has emerged over the past several years as a powerful tool to address many of these questions. Recent improvements in "soft" ionization techniques have enabled researchers to study proteins and biomolecular complexes, both directly and indirectly. Likewise, continuous improvements in instrumental design in recent years have resulted in a dramatic expansion of the m/z range and resolution, enabling observation of large multi-protein assemblies whose structures are retained in the gas phase. In this article, we discuss some of the mass spectrometric techniques applied to investigate the nature of the conformations and dynamical properties that govern protein function.

Detection of multiple protein conformational ensembles in solution via deconvolution of charge-state distributions in ESI MS

Monitoring the changes in charge-state distributions of protein ions in electrospray ionization (ESI) mass spectra has become one of the commonly accepted tools to detect large-scale conformational changes of proteins in solution. However, these experiments produce only qualitative, low-resolution information. Our goal is to develop a procedure that would produce quantitative data on protein conformational isomers coexisting in solution at equilibrium. To that end, we have examined the evolution of positive ion charge-state distributions in the

Expression, purification, and characterization of recombinant nonglycosylated human serum transferrin containing a C-terminal hexahistidine tag

Attachment of a hexa-His tag is a common strategy in recombinant protein production. The use of such a tag greatly simplifies the purification of the protein from the complex mixture of other proteins in the media or cell extract. We describe the production of two recombinant nonglycosylated human serum transferrins (hTF-NG), containing a factor Xa cleavage site and a hexa-His tag at their carboxyl-terminal ends. One of the constructs comprises the entire coding region for hTF (residues 1-679), while the other lacks the final three carboxyl-terminal amino acids. After insertion of the His-tagged hTFs into the pNUT vector, transfection into baby hamster kidney (BHK) cells, and selection with methotrexate, the secreted recombinant proteins were isolated from the tissue culture medium. Average maximum expression levels of the His-tagged hTFs were about 40 mg/L compared to an average maximum of 50 mg/L for hTF-NG. The first step of purification involved an anion exchange column. The second step utilized a Poros metal chelate column preloaded with copper from which the His-tagged sample was eluted with a linear imidazole gradient. The His-tagged hTFs were characterized and compared to both recombinant hTF-NG and glycosylated hTF from human serum. The identity of each of the His-tagged hTFs constructs was verified by electrospray mass spectroscopy. In summary, the His-tagged hTF constructs simplify the purification of these metal-binding proteins with minimal effects on many of their physical properties. The His-tagged hTFs share many features common to hTF, including reversible iron binding, reactivity with a monoclonal antibody, and presence as a monomer in solution.

Dynamics of iron release from transferrin N-lobe studied by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

Transferrins constitute a class of metalloproteins that are involved in circulatory iron transport in a variety of species. The metal ion-binding properties of these proteins have been the focus of extensive research efforts in the past decade due to their extreme importance in a variety of biological and healthcare-related fields. The large size of these proteins, as well as the presence of high-spin metal ions (e.g., Fe3+), limits the use of NMR. In this work, we report on the use of electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI MS) to study dynamics of the transferrin system in vitro under conditions that are designed to mimic the endosomal environment. ESI MS is shown to provide valuable insights into the mechanistic aspects of metal ion-binding/release by transferrins and is complementary to other spectroscopic techniques. Conformational stability of the complex is evaluated based on the appearance of the charge-state distribution of protein ions, while the composition of the protein-ligand complex is determined based on the mass of the protein ions. In the absence of iron chelators, a stepwise dissociation of the ternary complex (protein-metal ion-synergistic anion) is observed as the solution pH is gradually decreased. Although the release of synergistic anion from the complex is initiated at typical endosomal pH levels (i.e., 5.5), metal ion remains largely bound to the protein until the pH is lowered to a level of approximately 4.5. Under these conditions, a significant fraction of the protein populates unfolded conformations. In stark contrast to this behavior, addition of an iron chelating agent (citrate) to the protein solution results in facile iron release at typical endosomal pH levels without any detectable unfolding of the protein. The mass spectral data lends further credibility to the notion that the holoprotein samples conformations that are specific to the apo form (e.g., "open conformation"), from which iron dissociation most likely occurs. The results of the present study demonstrate that ESI MS can be used to model metal ion release from transferrin under conditions that are designed to mimic the physiological environment.

Unfolding dynamics of a beta-sheet protein studied by mass spectrometry

The unfolding dynamics of cellular retinoic acid-binding protein I (CRABP I), an 18 kDa predominantly beta-sheet protein, were studied by monitoring the hydrogen-deuterium (H-D) exchange reaction under various solution conditions. A bimodal charge state distribution was observed when a denaturing agent was added to the protein aqueous solution. These two populations exhibit different kinetics of H-D exchange, with the high charge state ions undergoing very rapid isotope exchange, while the low charge state protein ions exchange cooperatively but at much slower rates. Transiently populated intermediate states were detected indirectly using hydrogen exchange measurement in aqueous solution at various pHs. At pH 2.5 and room temperature, three distinct populations of CRABP I ions exist over an extended period of time, each corresponding to a specific degree of backbone amide hydrogen atom protection. Mass spectral data are complementary to hydrogen exchange measurements by NMR, since the former samples a much faster time-scale of dynamic events in solution.

Stability of secondary structural elements in a solvent-free environment. II: the beta-pleated sheets

The stability of single beta-strands and multistrand beta-pleated sheets as elements of secondary structure is examined in the absence of intermolecular interactions. Such experimental conditions (e.g., complete removal of solvent molecules and counterions) are achieved by placing the peptide ions in the gas phase. The metastable multiply- charged peptide ions produced by electrospray ionization undergo unimolecular dissociation. Intercharge repulsion within the precursor ions gives rise to the elevated kinetic energy of fragment ions, which is measured using Mass-analyzed Ion Kinetic Energy (MIKE) spectrometry. Intercharge distances calculated based on these measurements are compared to the numbers derived from molecular mechanics calculations with charge site assignments based on relative proton affinities. Evidence is presented suggesting that single beta-strands form collapsed structures in the absence of solvents, while multistrand beta-pleated sheets are likely to retain "native-like" secondary structures under the same conditions. These results indicate that intramolecular hydrogen bonds are the major factor determining the three-dimensional arrangements of polypeptides in the gas phase, compensating both long- and short-range electrostatic repulsions. This is in good agreement with our earlier findings (Proteins 27:165170, 1997) concerning stability of helical conformation of melittin in the absence of solvent.