Liver transplantation for polycystic liver disease

Polycystic liver disease (PLD) may provoke massive hepatomegaly and severe physical and social handicaps. Data on orthotopic liver transplantation (OLT) for PLD are rare and conflicting. Conservative surgery (resection or fenestration) is indicated for large single cysts, but its value for small diffuse cysts is questionable. In addition, conservative surgery is not devoid of morbidity and mortality. OLT offers the prospect of a fully curative treatment, but controversy remains because those patients usually have preserved liver function. Thus, we reviewed our experience with OLT for PLD. Sixteen adult women underwent OLT for small diffuse PLD between 1990 and 1999. Mean age was 45 years (range, 34 to 56 years). Fourteen patients had combined liver and kidney cystic disease, but only 1 patient required combined liver and kidney transplantation, whereas 13 patients underwent OLT alone. Two patients had isolated PLD. Indications for transplantation were massive hepatomegaly causing physical handicaps (n = 16), social handicaps (n = 16), malnutrition (n = 4), and cholestasis and/or portal hypertension (n = 5). OLT caused no technical difficulty in 15 of 16 patients (surgery duration, 6.8 hours; range, 5 to 8 hours), with blood transfusions of 7.9 units (range, 0 to 22 units). One patient who underwent attempted liver-mass reduction pre-OLT died of bleeding and pulmonary emboli. Native liver weight was 10 to 20 kg. Posttransplantation immunosuppression consisted of cyclosporine or FK506, azathioprine, and steroids (discontinued at 3 months). Morbidity included biliary stricture (2 patients), revision for bleeding and hepatitis (1 patient), pneumothorax and subphrenic collection (1 patient), and tracheostomy (1 patient). One patient died of lung cancer 6 years posttransplantation. Both patient and graft survival rates are 87.5% (follow-up, 3 months to 9 years). Of 15 patients who underwent OLT alone, only 1 patient needed a kidney transplant 4 years after OLT. Kidney function has remained satisfactory in the other patients despite the use of cyclosporine or FK506 (last follow-up creatinine level, 1.55 mg/dL; range, 0.80 to 2.85 mg/dL). OLT had a dramatic impact on daily quality of life, enabling these patients to go back to a fully active life style. OLT offers the chance of a definitive treatment in patients with extensive, small, diffuse PLD that has evolved into severely handicapping hepatomegaly. In contrast to previous studies, combined liver and kidney transplantation is rarely needed. Patient symptoms and chances of definitive palliation offered by OLT must be balanced against the risks of transplantation and lifelong commitment to immunosuppression.

An improved model of acute liver failure based on transient ischemia of the liver

HYPOTHESIS

A reproducible and potentially reversible model of acute liver failure in the pig is feasible based on transient ischemia of the liver.

DESIGN

To determine the shortest period of liver ischemia sufficient to cause 100% mortality, ischemia of the liver was induced for different lengths of time, starting with 6 hours. If the pig survived, ischemia time was prolonged for 2 hours in the next animal. In the first group, the common bile duct was not tightened. In the second group, the common bile duct was tightened.

SETTING

The Laboratory for Hepatopathophysiology, Catholic University, Leuven, Belgium.

PARTICIPANTS

Female stress-negative Belgian Landrace pigs weighing 18 to 22 kg.

INTERVENTIONS

During preparatory surgery, all ligaments around the liver and connective tissue around the liver hilum were transected and an end-to-side portacaval shunt was made. Vessel loops were placed around the branches of the hepatic artery and bile duct. Three days later, in fully awake pigs, the loops were tightened.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Mortality. Development of acute liver failure was determined based on neurologic, biochemical, and pathological variables.

RESULTS

When occluded for 10 hours, all pigs in group 2 (n = 5) [corrected] died between 12 and 17 hours after the induction of ischemia. All pigs developed typical acute liver failure. Tissue specimens showed 90% necrosis of the liver parenchyma.

CONCLUSION

A highly reproducible and potentially reversible model of acute liver failure in the large animal has been established.

Portal vein thrombosis in adults undergoing liver transplantation: risk factors, screening, management, and outcome

BACKGROUND

Portal vein thrombosis (PVT) has been seen as an obstacle to liver transplantation (LTx). Recent data suggest that favorable results may be achieved in this group of patients but only limited information from small size series is available. The present study was conducted in an effort to review the surgical options in patients with PVT and to assess the impact of PVT on LTx outcome. Risk factors for PVT and the value of screening tools are also analyzed.

METHODS

Adult LTx performed from 1987 through 1996 were reviewed. PVT was retrospectively graded according to the operative findings: grade 1: <50% PVT +/- minimal obstruction of the superior mesenteric vein (SMV); grade 2: grade 1 but >50% PVT; grade 3: complete PV and proximal SMV thrombosis; grade 4: complete PV and entire SMV thrombosis.

RESULTS

Of 779 LTx, 63 had operatively confirmed PVT (8.1%): 24 had grade 1, 23 grade 2, 6 grade 3, and 10 grade 4 PVT. Being male, treatment for portal hypertension, Child-Pugh class C, and alcoholic liver disease were associated with PVT. Sensitivity of ultrasound (US) in detecting PVT increased with PVT grade and was 100% in grades 3-4. In patients with US-diagnosed PVT, an angiogram was performed and ruled out a false positive US diagnosis in 13%. In contrast with US, angiograms differentiated grade 1 from grade 2, and grade 3 from grade 4 PVT. Grade 1 and 2 PVT were managed by low dissection and/or a thrombectomy; in grade 3 the distal SMV was directly used as an inflow vessel, usually through an interposition donor iliac vein; in grade 4 a splanchnic tributary was used or a thrombectomy was attempted. Transfusion requirements in PVT patients (10 U) were higher than in non-PVT patients (5 U) (P<0.01). In-hospital mortality for PVT patients was 30% versus 12.4% in controls (P<0.01). Patients with PVT had more postoperative complications, renal failure, primary nonfunction, and PV rethrombosis. The overall actuarial 5-year patient survival rate in PVT patients (65.6%) was lower than in controls (76.3%; P=0.04). Patients with grade 1 PVT, however, had a 5-year survival rate (86%) identical to that of controls, whereas patients with grades 2, 3, and 4 PVT had reduced survival rates. The 5-year patient survival rate improved from the 1st to the 2nd era in non-PVT patients (from 72% to 83%; P<0.01), in grade 1 PVT (from 53% to 100%; P<0.01), and in grades 2 to 4 PVT (from 38% to 62%; P=0.11).

CONCLUSIONS

The value of US diagnosis in patients with PVT depends on the PVT grade, and false negative diagnoses occur only in incomplete forms of PVT (grades 1-2). The degree of PVT dictates the surgical strategy to be used, thrombectomy/low dissection in grade 1-2, mesoportal jump graft in grade 3, and a splanchnic tributary in grade 4. Taken altogether, PVT patients undergo more difficult surgery, have more postoperative complications, have higher in-hospital mortality rates, and have reduced 5-year survival rates. Analysis by PVT grade, however, reveals that grade 1 PVT patients do as well as controls; only grades 2 to 4 PVT patients have poorer outcomes. With increased experience, results of LTx in PVT patients have improved and, even in severe forms of PVT, a 5-year survival rate >60% can now be achieved.

[Liver transplantation with a graft taken from a heart transplant patient who was brain-dead]

The shortage of organ donors has led to progressive softening of selection criteria for organ donation. We report on hepatic transplantation in a 55-year-old woman with primary biliary cirrhosis, whose donor was a 50-year-old heart transplant recipient who became brain stem dead, due to cerebral bleeding 8 months after transplantation. An orthotopic liver transplantation was performed. The postoperative course was uneventful and the recipient was alive and had normal liver function after a 42-month follow-up. Analysis of the literature included ethical consideration, potential hepatotoxic effects of immunosuppressive drugs and modification of the graft immunogenicity. It confirms that transplanted patients should not be a priori excluded from organ donation.

Present status and future prospects in liver transplantation

Results of liver transplantation (LTx) have largely improved over the last few years and a one year patient survival rate of around 90% for elective transplants can now be reached. This is mostly the consequence of better patient selection and preparation, improved surgical techniques, improved intra- and postoperative care, reduced incidence of primary non function (< or =5%) and hepatic artery thrombosis (< or =5%), the understanding that the liver induces a tolerogenic response and the development of more judicious immunosuppressive protocols. Because patient and graft survival have dramatically improved, other problems become more overt and need to be addressed: side effects of long-term exposure to immunosuppression, recurrent disease, development of biliary strictures. LTx for acute liver failure continues to bring special difficulties. Strategies need to be urgently developed to augment the number of donor grafts and to combat the profound organ shortage - currently the only limiting factor to wider application of LTx.

Poor outcome in patients with diabetes mellitus undergoing liver transplantation

BACKGROUND

Relatively few studies have examined the influence of pretransplant diabetes on survival after an orthotopic liver transplant (OLT), and those published to date show only minor increases in infection rates among diabetics and no increase in mortality.

METHODS

We examined the effect of diabetes mellitus on survival after OLT. 1005 adults underwent OLT between 1982 and May 1997. Seventy-eight patients with pretransplant diabetes mellitus (7.8% of all OLT, 38 insulin treated, 25 tablet treated, 15 diet controlled) were identified and compared with controls matched for age, sex, and date of first transplant and also with all nondiabetic adult liver recipients undergoing OLT during the same period.

RESULTS

In patients undergoing OLT survival was worse in diabetics than in the comparison group (P=0.002) and vs. all adult nondiabetics undergoing (n=927) (P=0.004); in diabetics with alcoholic liver disease (ALD) vs. all nondiabetics with alcoholic liver disease (P= <0.0001); and in insulin-treated compared with non-insulin-treated diabetics (P=0.05). Multivariate analysis showed type of diabetes (P=0.001) and ALD (P=0.024) to be the most significant independent variables adversely affecting survival. Survival in diabetics undergoing OLT could be further stratified according to whether diabetics were insulin treated.

CONCLUSIONS

Poorer outcome in the diabetics undergoing OLT, particularly in those with ALD, suggests the need for a more detailed pre-OLT assessment of these patients, particularly those with insulin and tablet controlled diabetes.

Clostridium difficile colitis after kidney and kidney-pancreas transplantation

OBJECTIVE

To determine the timing and risk factors involved in the development of Clostridium difficile (CD) colitis in kidney and kidney-pancreas transplant recipients.

BACKGROUND DATA

The incidence of CD colitis after kidney and kidney-pancreas transplantation has not been studied in detail. The question of whether the immunosuppressed transplant recipient is more prone to CD colitis and its complications (i.e., megacolon, perforations) and the risk factors involved have not been determined.

METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed our experience in kidney and kidney-pancreas recipients who received transplants between January 1, 1985 and December 31, 1994. We divided these recipients into three groups: pediatric kidney recipients, adult kidney recipients, and kidney-pancreas recipients. For each group, we assessed the timing of infection, primary disease, colitis treatment, and any concurrent complications or risk factors.

RESULTS

Of 1932 transplants, 159 recipients developed post-transplant CD colitis. 132 charts were available for review. Forty-three pediatric kidney recipients developed CD colitis. Their mean age was 3.2 yr; 74% (n = 37) of them developed their colitis during their initial hospital stay, with the mean timing of infection being 33 d. Forty-one (95%) had undergone intra-abdominal placement of the graft, with renal artery anastomoses to the aorta. Fifty adult kidney recipients developed CD colitis. Thirteen (26%) developed colitis during their initial hospital stay, with the mean timing of infection (for all adult kidney recipients) being 15 months. Thirty-nine kidney-pancreas recipients developed CD colitis. Mean timing of infection was 6 months. The overall incidence of CD colitis was 8%, with 16% in the pediatric kidney group, 15.5% in the kidney-pancreas group, and 3.5% in the adult kidney group. The difference in mean timing of infection was significant between the three groups (p < 0.001 for pediatric versus adult kidney recipients, p = 0.002 for pediatric kidney versus kidney-pancreas recipients, and p = 0.2846 for adult kidney versus kidney-pancreas recipients).

CONCLUSION

The incidence of CD colitis is increased in pediatric kidney and kidney-pancreas recipients. Young recipient age ( < 5 yr), female gender, treatment of rejection with monoclonal antibodies, antibiotic use, and intra-abdominal graft placement have been shown to increase the incidence of this disease. Further studies concerning prevention in the high-risk groups are needed.

Use of grafts procured from organ transplant recipients

BACKGROUND

Massive intracerebral bleeding may cause brain stem death in transplant (Tx) recipients early or late postTx. We addressed the question as to whether Tx recipients may safely be used as organ donors. In particular, it is feared that exposure to immunosuppressive drugs may render those organs unsuitable for Tx.

METHODS

We reviewed two case reports of liver grafts procured from Tx patients. In addition, we conducted a survey within United Kingdom Transplant Support Service Authority (UKTSSA) to delineate the UK experience in that area.

RESULTS

Donor 1 was an 50-year-old heart Tx recipient who became brain stem dead due to cerebral bleeding 8 months postTx. His liver was used in an 55-year-old patient with PBC who is alive and well more than 22 months postTx. Donor 2 was a 22-year-old kidney Tx patient who developed cerebral bleeding 4 years postTx. His liver was used in a 65-year-old patient with PBC who is doing well more than 27 months postTx. During the study period of 1989-1995, 13 organs (9 kidneys, 3 hearts, 1 liver) were procured from 6 brain stem dead Tx patients (3 long, 2 heart, and 1 kidney Tx patients). Seven recipients are enjoying satisfactory graft function 1 to 7 years postTx; one kidney Tx recipient was relisted 4 years postTx due to chronic rejection; five functionning grafts were lost to patient death; primary nonfunction was seen in one heart Tx recipient.

CONCLUSIONS

Tx patients can be successfully used as organ donors. In particular, chronic exposure to immunosuppression is not per se a contraindication to donation. Tx physicians confronted with the rare and tragic event of brain stem death in a Tx patient should not a priori exclude these patients from donation.

Contribution of large animal models to the development of clinical intestinal transplantation

The intestine has long been seen as a "forbidden" organ to transplant and even nowadays it remains the most challenging abdominal organ to transplant. Large animal experiments have been pivotal, first in developing reproducible and clinically applicable surgical techniques for transplanting the intestine and second, in revealing the unique physiological, immunological, and microbiological challenge that intestinal transplantation (ITx) represents. More recently, large animal models have been used to test new immunosuppressive drugs (FK 506) that have been then successfully used clinically. ITx is no more an experimental endeavor and survival figures of about 70% can be reached at one year, justifying routine application of ITx to patients who do not tolerate total parenteral nutrition. However, ITx remains in 1999 an "unfinished product" and further research will need to be done to allow wider application of ITx to patients without total parenteral nutrition (TPN) related complications. Further research will focus on the following aspects: (1) refined understanding of the factors accounting for the high immunogenicity of the intestine; (2) development of immunomodulatory strategies to reduce graft immunogenicity and to induce specific hyporesponsiveness; (3) development of new immunosuppressants, and their usage in combination, to act more specifically on the immune response, and at the price of less toxicity; (4) development of surgical alternatives to alleviate the organ shortage: graft size reduction, live related ITx. Importantly these questions will need to be addressed in clinically relevant animal models before they are applied to man.

Inferior outcome of cadaveric kidneys preserved for more than 24 hr in histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate solution. Leuven Collaborative Group for Transplantation

BACKGROUND

During recent years, an increasing number of transplant centers within the Eurotransplant organization have used histidine-tryptophan-ketoglutarate (HTK) solution instead of University of Wisconsin (UW) solution as their preferred cold storage solution for abdominal organ preservation. We report on our single-center experience on the outcome of imported kidneys preserved with either HTK or UW solution in relation to the duration of cold ischemia time (CIT).

METHODS

Between July 1989 and July 1997, 323 cadaveric kidneys preserved with UW or HTK and imported as a result of an exchange within the Eurotransplant organization were transplanted at our institution. CIT was <24 hr in 216 kidneys (UW: n=174, HTK: n=42) and > or =24 hr in 107 kidneys (UW: n=67, HTK: n=40). Renal functional outcome was evaluated by comparing delayed graft function and initial non-function rates, daily urinary output, the evolution of serum creatinine, and creatinine clearance at 1, 3, 5, 7, and 14 days and at 1, 3, 6 and 12 months, and graft survival at 1 year after transplantation in relation to the type of cold storage solution and CIT < or > or =24 hr.

RESULTS

Whereas the incidence of delayed graft function did not differ significantly between kidneys preserved for less than 24 hr in UW (18.6%) or HTK (26.2%), this rate increased to 50% in HTK kidneys compared to 23.9% in UW kidneys when CIT exceeded 24 hr (P=0.006). Mean serum creatinine and creatinine clearance values were better at 1 and 5 days postoperatively in kidneys preserved <24 hr with UW as compared to HTK (P<0.05). After 24 hr of CIT, HTK-preserved kidneys showed an impaired renal function, not only in the immediate postoperative phase but also at 1, 3, 6, and 12 months after transplantation (P<0.05). Graft survival at 1 year was 92.9% in UW vs. 87.5% in HTK kidneys preserved for <24 hr (NS), and 91% vs. 77.4% when CIT exceeded 24 hr (P=0.059).

CONCLUSIONS

From these single-center findings, it can be concluded that UW is superior to HTK in kidney preservation, particularly when CIT exceeds 24 hr.