Evaluating clinical librarian services: a systematic review

BACKGROUND

  Previous systematic reviews have indicated limited evidence and poor quality evaluations of clinical librarian (CL) services. Rigorous evaluations should demonstrate the value of CL services, but guidance is needed before this can be achieved.

OBJECTIVES

  To undertake a systematic review which examines models of CL services, quality, methods and perspectives of clinical librarian service evaluations.

METHODS

  Systematic review methodology and synthesis of evidence, undertaken collaboratively by a group of 8 librarians to develop research and critical appraisal skills.

RESULTS

  There are four clear models of clinical library service provision. Clinical librarians are effective in saving health professionals time, providing relevant, useful information and high quality services. Clinical librarians have a positive effect on clinical decision making by contributing to better informed decisions, diagnosis and choice of drug or therapy. The quality of CL studies is improving, but more work is needed on reducing bias and providing evidence of specific impacts on patient care. The Critical Incident Technique as part of a mixed method approach appears to offer a useful approach to demonstrating impact.

CONCLUSIONS

  This systematic review provides practical guidance regarding the evaluation of CL services. It also provides updated evidence regarding the effectiveness and impact of CL services. The approach used was successful in developing research and critical appraisal skills in a group of librarians.

Ultrawide-Angle Retinal Imaging and Retinal Detachment

PURPOSE

To illustrate the utility of ultrawide-angle fundus imaging in documenting the clinical course of a retinal detachment.

DESIGN

Observational case report.

METHOD

A 20-year-old man with high myopia and a blind fellow eye noted symptoms of retinal detachment and was imaged with an ultrawide-angle fundus imaging device (Optos P200). Imaging was performed after scleral buckling and before and after additional vitreoretinal surgery.

RESULTS

Ultrawide-angle images were useful in delineating the extent of retinal detachment even in the presence of intraocular gas.

CONCLUSION

The ability to rapidly image the ocular fundus well anterior to the equator facilitates clinical management and may prove particularly useful in electronic record keeping.

Environmental health risks and vulnerability in post-conflict regions

The importance of environmental factors during and after conflict has often not received adequate attention, and is of particular importance when assessing those groups most vulnerable to changing conditions. Post-war reconstruction and aid policies must take note of which groups are most susceptible to environmental health risks, and how the conflict itself often created new vulnerabilities through deliberate destruction of the natural and built environments. The environmental security and public health fields have a good deal to offer in understanding these dynamics, and must work more closely together in the future to identify potential vulnerabilities in advance of conflicts and disasters.

Surveillance results of depleted uranium-exposed Gulf War I veterans: sixteen years of follow-up

As part of a longitudinal surveillance program, 35 members of a larger cohort of 77 Gulf War I veterans who were victims of depleted uranium (DU) "friendly fire" during combat underwent a 3-day clinical assessment at the Baltimore Veterans Administration Medical Center (VAMC). The assessment included a detailed medical history, exposure history, physical examination, and laboratory studies. Spot and 24-h urine collections were obtained for renal function parameters and for urine uranium (U) measures. Blood U measures were also performed. Urine U excretion was significantly associated with DU retained shrapnel burden (8.821 mug U/g creatinine [creat.] vs. 0.005 mug U/g creat., p = .04). Blood as a U sampling matrix revealed satisfactory results for measures of total U with a high correlation with urine U results (r = .84) when urine U concentrations were >/=0.1 mug/g creatinine. However, isotopic results in blood detected DU in only half of the subcohort who had isotopic signatures for DU detectable in urine. After stratifying the cohort based on urine U concentration, the high-U group showed a trend toward higher concentrations of urine beta(2) microglobulin compared to the low-U group (81.7 v. 69.0 mug/g creat.; p = .11 respectively) and retinol binding protein (48.1 vs. 31.0 mug/g creat.; p = .07 respectively). Bone metabolism parameters showed only subtle differences between groups. Sixteen years after first exposure, this cohort continues to excrete elevated concentrations of urine U as a function of DU shrapnel burden. Although subtle trends emerge in renal proximal tubular function and bone formation, the cohort exhibits few clinically significant U-related health effects.

Contractual obligations and the sharing of confidential health information in sport

As an employee, a sports doctor has obligations to their employer, but also professional and widely accepted obligations of a doctor to the patient (in this case the individual team member). The conflict is evident when sports doctors are asked by an athlete to keep personal health information confidential from the coach and team management, and yet both doctor and athlete have employment contracts specifying that such information shall be shared. Recent research in New Zealand shows that despite the presence of an employment contract, there appears to be a wide range of behaviours among sports doctors when an athlete requests that information about them be kept from team management. Many seem willing to honour requests to keep health information about the athlete confidential, thereby being in breach of the employment contract, while others insist on informing team management against the wishes of the athlete. There are a number of potential solutions to this dilemma from forcing doctors to meet their contractual obligations, to limiting the expectations of the employment contract. This paper suggests that at times it may be appropriate to do both, making the position of the doctor clearer and supporting the ability of this group to resist pressure by coaches and management through having a robust code of ethics.

Does orally administered doxycycline reach the tear film?

BACKGROUND/AIMS

Orally administered doxycycline, a broad-spectrum antibiotic, is an established treatment for ocular surface diseases, particularly rosacea, meibomian gland dysfunction and recurrent epithelial cell erosion. In recent times, its efficacy in treating these diseases has been ascribed to an ability to inhibit matrix metalloproteinase (MMP) activity and both MMP and interleukin-1 (IL-1) synthesis. Since these functions are concentration-dependent, the aim of this project was to determine whether sufficient doxycycline reached the tear film to fulfil these roles in vivo.

METHODS

Doxycycline was extracted with 1-butanol from tear and blood plasma samples obtained from patients with ocular surface disease and healthy individuals and quantified spectrophotometrically. The MMPs present in the patients tear films before and during doxycycline treatment were analysed zymographically.

RESULTS

The quantity of doxycycline detected in the blood plasma samples of patients undergoing treatment ranged from 1.83 to 13.18 microM. Although doxycycline was not detected in their tear samples, the treatment caused the disappearance of the MMPs symptomatic of disease progression.

CONCLUSION

The inability to detect doxycycline in the tear film of patients undergoing treatment indicates that doxycycline does not directly inhibit MMP activity or the synthesis/secretion of these proteases and IL-1 from corneal epithelial cells.

Evaluating the adequacy of disease control in patients with rheumatoid arthritis: a RAND appropriateness panel

OBJECTIVES

There is a lack of agreement on assessing disease activity in patients with RA and determining when the RA treatment should be changed or continued. A panel of rheumatologists was convened to develop guidelines to assess adequacy of disease control, focusing on the use of disease-modifying anti-rheumatic drugs.

METHODS

The Research and Development/University of California in Los Angeles (RAND/UCLA) Appropriateness Method was used to evaluate disease control adequacy. After a literature review, 108 scenarios were developed to simulate situations most likely to be encountered in clinical practice and rated on a 9-point scale by a 10-member expert panel.

RESULTS

Final appropriateness rankings for the scenarios were as follows: 37% 'appropriate', 48% 'inappropriate', and 16% 'neutral'. The panelists felt that patients with disease control in the 'appropriate' range have adequate control with their current therapy, whereas those in the 'inappropriate' range should be considered for a change in therapy. Those in 'neutral' areas should have their therapy reviewed carefully. The panelists recommended that the clinically active joint count should be considered the most important decision factor. In patients with no clinically active joints, regardless of other factors no change in therapy was felt to be warranted. Patients with five or more active joints should be considered inadequately treated, and in patients with one to four active joints other variables must be considered in the decision to change therapy.

CONCLUSION

These preliminary guidelines will assist the clinician in determining when a patient's clinical situation warrants therapy escalation and when continuing the current regimen would be appropriate.