Alleged malpractice in orthopaedics. Analysis of a series of medmal insurance claims

Background

Medical malpractice is an important topic worldwide, and orthopedics is a clinical branch that is considered to be at a high risk for claims. The analysis of a series of medmal insurance claims allows forensic pathologists, clinicians, and insurance companies to probe the risk of a specific clinical branch for medical malpractice claims and highlights areas where care may be improved. We investigated the main features of a major Italian insurance broker’s archive in order to identify recurrent pitfalls in this field.

Materials and methods

A retrospective study was carried out on orthopedics claims. The archive covered claims from 2002 to 2013 that targeted 1980 orthopedists.

Results

635 claims were found and analyzed with a focus on the clinical activity invocked in the claim, the presence of alleged team malpractice, the clinical outcome of the case, and the final forensic decision regarding the claim. 299 orthopedists had at least one malpractice claim made against them during the available period; 146 orthopedists were subject to more than one malpractice claim. Most of the claims regarded perioperative and operative cases, usually originating from civil litigation. The anatomical sites most commonly involved were the hip or knees, and sciatic nerve lesions were the main contributor.

Conclusions

Orthopedics is a medical specialty with a high risk for malpractice claims. In our study, medical malpractice was observed in nearly 50% of the cases—typically in surgery-linked cases resulting in permanent impairment of the patient. Death from orthopedics malpractice seemed to be rare.

Level of Evidence

IV.

Predictors of hospitalization length of stay among re-admitted treatment-resistant Bipolar Disorder inpatients

BACKGROUND

Hospitalization accounts for significant health care resource utilization for treatment-resistant Bipolar Disorder (BD), especially among frequent users of acute inpatient psychiatric units. Appraisal of the clinical features and predictive role of selected variables is therefore crucial in such population, representing the aim of the present research.

METHODS

A hundred and nineteen BD inpatients with an established history of pharmacological treatment resistance for either mania or bipolar depression were classified as long hospitalization cases (LOS⁺) and their controls and compared against each other for a number of demographic, clinical, and psychopathological features.

RESULTS

Overall, female sex, current second-generation atypical antipsychotic (SGA)/mood stabilizer other than lithium as well as antidepressant treatment at the admission occurred statistically more frequently among LOS⁺ cases, concordant with higher scores at the Hamilton scales for depression and anxiety. Lithium utilization at the time of hospitalization did not differ between cases and controls (LOS^-, n = 81/119), as predominant affective temperament and other psychopathological rating did not. Overall, the time of admission, use of SGA, anticonvulsant (other than lithium), antidepressant, lifetime alcohol dependence, and BD Type (-I or -II), but not current mood polarity at the time of hospitalization, correctly predicted LOS⁺ grouping 68.2% of the times: Exp(B) = 3.151, p042.

LIMITATIONS

Post-hoc, cross-sectional study, relatively small sample size, recall and selection bias on some diagnoses.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, LOS⁺ treatment-resistant BD inpatients characterize for higher severity and greater pharmaco-utilization use, which warrants replication studies to include additional predictors to shed further light on the matter.

Anti-Parkinsonian and anti-dyskinetic profiles of two novel potent and selective nociceptin/orphanin FQ receptor agonists

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

We previously showed that nociceptin/orphanin FQ opioid peptide (NOP) receptor agonists attenuate the expression of levodopa-induced dyskinesia in animal models of Parkinson's disease. We now investigate the efficacy of two novel, potent and chemically distinct NOP receptor agonists, AT-390 and AT-403, to improve Parkinsonian disabilities and attenuate dyskinesia development and expression.

EXPERIMENTAL APPROACH

Binding affinity and functional efficacy of AT-390 and AT-403 at the opioid receptors were determined in radioligand displacement assays and in GTPγS binding assays respectively, conducted in CHO cells. Their anti-Parkinsonian activity was evaluated in 6-hydroxydopamine hemi-lesioned rats whereas the anti-dyskinetic properties were assessed in 6-hydroxydopamine hemi-lesioned rats chronically treated with levodopa. The ability of AT-403 to inhibit the D₁ receptor-induced phosphorylation of striatal ERK was investigated.

KEY RESULTS

AT-390 and AT-403 selectively improved akinesia at low doses and disrupted global motor activity at higher doses. AT-403 palliated dyskinesia expression without causing sedation in a narrow therapeutic window, whereas AT-390 delayed the appearance of abnormal involuntary movements and increased their duration at doses causing sedation. AT-403 did not prevent the priming to levodopa, although it significantly inhibited dyskinesia on the first day of administration. AT-403 reduced the ERK phosphorylation induced by SKF38393 in vitro and by levodopa in vivo.

CONCLUSIONS AND IMPLICATIONS

NOP receptor stimulation can provide significant albeit mild anti-dyskinetic effect at doses not causing sedation. The therapeutic window, however, varies across compounds. AT-403 could be a potent and selective tool to investigate the role of NOP receptors in vivo.