Unreliability of conventional visual electrocardiographic monitoring for detection of transient ST segment changes in a coronary care unit

Visual monitoring at the central station of coronary care units (CCUs) may not adequately assess the presence and frequency of transient asymptomatic ST segment changes in patients with unstable angina. We have performed continuous 24-h electrocardiographic recordings over a total period of 50 days in 10 patients admitted to our CCU with frequent attacks of angina at rest. Over the corresponding period, at the central monitoring station (6 beds), the nursing-staff detected only 31 transient ischaemic episodes (27 with ST elevation, 4 with depression, 9 of which were asymptomatic). By contrast the retrospective analogue analysis of tapes identified 213 ischaemic episodes: 143 with ST elevation (greater than or equal to 0.2 mV) and 70 with ST depression (greater than or equal to 0.2 mV); usual CCU monitoring failed to report changes during 13 episodes (8 with ST elevation, 5 with depression) accompanied by anginal pain. When the tapes were played back in real time on a CCU monitoring scope, a cardiologist (who had the option of interrupting the play-back whenever tired) recognized 48% of the episodes when presented in groups of 4 and randomly positioned on the screen together with 2 other electrocardiographic tracings not related to the study; he recognized 92% of the episodes when only one ECG was presented on the screen. Thus conventional visual monitoring in a CCU considerably underestimates the incidence of transient ischaemic ST segment changes, some of which were accompanied by pain. This low rate of detection is the result of the presentation on the central monitoring station of several ECGs and of fatigue.

Computer system for analysis of ST segment changes on 24 hour Holter monitor tapes: Comparison with other available systems

The accuracy of a computer system that was developed for the analysis of ST segment changes recorded on Holter ambulatory electrocardiographic monitoring tapes was compared with conventional visual scrutiny, beat by beat analog printouts and a commercial J point trend system. The program calculates and plots multiple electrocardiographically derived variables in a high temporal resolution trend format. Fifty tapes of good recording quality obtained from 19 patients (13 with chronic stable angina and 6 with variant angina) were assessed visually and with the computer system; of these, 20 were analyzed by all four techniques. In the 50 tapes, 629 episodes of diagnostic ST segment changes (all true positive results) were identified by using the computer system. In contrast, only 507 were identified by visual scrutiny; none of these 507 episodes was missed by computer analysis. On the 20 tapes assessed using computer, visual, beat by beat analog and J point trend system analysis, 268, 221, 230 and 178 episodes, respectively, were documented. For the four techniques, false negative and positive results were 0, 47, 38 and 90 and 0, 10, 6 and 24, respectively. The results indicate that, of the systems assessed in this study, the computer program provides the highest accuracy for detection of transient ST segment changes. This is probably accreditable to the compact presentation of multiple electrocardiographically derived variables, allowing a detailed quantitative assessment of 24 hour tapes. It is of particular value for pathophysiologic and pharmacologic studies.