Liquid-based cytology can improve efficiency of cervical smear readers: evidence from timing surveys in two NHS cytology laboratories

OBJECTIVE

Cervical screening programmes in England and Wales were advised by the National Institute for Clinical Excellence in 2003 to adopt liquid-based cytology (LBC) in place of conventional Papanicolaou (Pap) cytology to facilitate laboratory efficiency. Pilot evaluations in England and Scotland monitored daily or weekly workloads of smear readers and concluded that LBC could increase hourly throughput rates. This study, instead, used timing surveys to determine screening rates.

METHODS

Two National Health Service cytology laboratories in Manchester and Stockport were partially converted to the LBC ThinPrep process for a cervical screening trial. Three 1-week timing surveys were conducted over 7 months. The surveys covered all LBC-trained staff. The first survey in Manchester also covered staff undertaking conventional Pap screening. The smear readers used timers to record time taken for examining and reporting each slide.

RESULTS

In Manchester, in the first survey, nearly 1 minute per slide was saved by the LBC method during primary microscopy. In both laboratories, the mean microscopy time for primary screening of LBC slides was reduced by almost 1 minute between the first and second surveys. There was no difference between the second and third surveys. Microscopy by cytopathologists was also 1 minute per slide quicker with LBC than conventional Pap. The LBC inadequate rates for both laboratories were <2.0%. Organizational factors impacted on the hourly LBC primary screening rates in the laboratories, the rate for Stockport being higher than the rates in the pilot evaluations.

CONCLUSIONS

The timing surveys confirm that the LBC ThinPrep technology can improve laboratory efficiency. However, decision-makers should also consider the overall costs and benefits of introducing the technology in screening programmes, including the capital investment and workforce implications.

Pre-biopsy PSA and biopsy gleason sum; evaluating the independence of two independent variables

14555

Background: Traditionally PSA, Gleason sum and Clinical Stage are considered independent predictors of outcome for prostate cancer. The purpose of this study is to investigate a codependence between prostate specific antigen (PSA) and Gleason sum and whether this relationship has evolved during the PSA era. Methods: The Columbia Urologic Oncology Database was reviewed and 2,522 patients were identified who underwent radical prostatectomy from 1988 to 2005; a retrospective cohort of 1,786 patients with complete data was included. Patients were stratified by Gleason sum into groups with Gleason sum <7, =7 and >7. PSA was correlated to Gleason sum to examine a possible relationship between the two variables. Two-sample t-tests with 95% confidence intervals were utilized to determine differences between groups and were confirmed by ANOVA techniques. A Cox regression model using an interaction term between PSA and Gleason sum was fit to determine if an interaction exists between the two variables. Patients were further stratified into two cohorts by median year of surgery (1998) and the PSA-Gleason sum relationship was evaluated over time. Results: Median patient age was 61.9 years. 1,081 patients were identified with Gleason sum <7. 540 patients had a Gleason sum =7. 165 patients had a Gleason sum >7. The mean PSA values were 6.05, 6.89 and 8.41 for <7, =7 and >7 groups respectively. Differences between the means were statistically significant and validated by the ANOVA technique (p < 0.001). A Cox regression model validated PSA, Gleason sum and clinical stage as independent predictors of outcome. The addition of an interaction term into the Cox regression model between PSA and Gleason sum demonstrated a significant interaction effect between PSA and Gleason sum (p < 0.001). The relationship remained between PSA and Gleason sum within the pre and post 1998 groups (p < 0.001). Conclusions: PSA and Gleason sum are highly interrelated variables, although they each carry additional information that significantly contributes to the prediction of biochemical failure (PSA ≥0.2 ng/ml). For an individual patient, the higher the initial PSA the higher the risk of having a high Gleason sum on biopsy. This relationship has remained constant over the PSA era.

No significant financial relationships to disclose.

HPV testing in routine cervical screening: cross sectional data from the ARTISTIC trial

To evaluate the effectiveness of human papillomavirus (HPV) testing in primary cervical screening. This was a cross-sectional study from the recruitment phase of a prospective randomised trial. Women were screened for HPV in addition to routine cervical cytology testing. Greater Manchester, attendees at routine NHS Cervical Screening Programme. In all, 24 510 women aged 20–64 screened with liquid-based cytology (LBC) and HPV testing at entry. HPV testing in primary cervical screening. Type-specific HPV prevalence rates are presented in relation to age as well as cytological and histological findings at entry. In all, 24 510 women had adequate cytology and HPV results. Cytology results at entry were: 87% normal, 11% borderline or mild, 1.1% moderate and 0.6% severe dyskaryosis or worse. Prevalence of HPV decreased sharply with age, from 40% at age 20–24 to 12% at 35–39 and 7% or less above age 50. It increased with cytological grade, from 10% of normal cytology and 31% of borderline to 70% mild, 86% moderate, and 96% of severe dyskaryosis or worse. HPV 16 or HPV 18 accounted for 64% of infections in women with severe or worse cytology, and one or both were found in 61% of women with severe dyskaryosis but in only 2.2% of those with normal cytology. The majority of young women in Greater Manchester have been infected with a high-risk HPV by the age of 30. HPV testing is practicable as a primary routine screening test, but in women aged under 30 years, this would lead to a substantial increase in retesting and referral rates. HPV 16 and HPV 18 are more predictive of underlying disease, but other HPV types account for 30% of high-grade disease.

Genetic stability of strains preserved on LENTICULE discs and by freeze-drying: a comparison using fluorescent amplified fragment length polymorphism analysis

Fluorescent amplified fragment length polymorphism (FAFLP) analysis, a high-resolution genome fingerprinting method, was used to ascertain the DNA integrity of bacterial strains during preservation by lenticulation and by traditional freeze-drying into glass ampoules. This was achieved by comparing FAFLP genotypes of a range of paired bacterial isolates recovered from LENTICULE discs (preserved between 1995 and 2004) and from freeze-dried (FD) cultures in glass ampoules (preserved between 1966 and 2000). A choice of two endonuclease combinations EcoRI/MseI or HindIII/HhaI was used for FAFLP analysis of the five different bacterial genera comprising of 10 strains. Each of these 10 strains exhibited unique FAFLP profiles. However, there were no detectable differences between the FAFLP profiles for each of the individual strains, irrespective of their preservation format or their year of preservation. Thus, the FAFLP data suggests that LENTICULE production does not result in any detectable genetic changes during drying onto LENTICULE discs and storage for at least 5 years. The provision of such FD reference cultures on LENTICULE discs rather than FD glass ampoules will provide a cost-effective format that is easier to use.

Elimination of metformin-croscarmellose sodium interaction by competition

During analytical method development and validation, a strong charge interaction between metformin and croscarmellose sodium was observed when the aqueous solution containing metformin was spiked with croscarmellose sodium. The charge interaction resulted in the retention of metformin in croscarmellose sodium and caused a serious drug recovery problem. The percent recovery of metformin in the solution was much lower than its theoretical values, especially in the low metformin concentration range. To overcome the metformin-croscarmellose interaction, arginine was selected as a competitor for the binding sites on croscarmellose sodium. Because of the competition and stronger interaction between arginine and croscarmellose sodium than metformin and croscarmellose sodium, a complete recovery of metformin in presence of arginine in both low and high concentration ranges was achieved. The effect of arginine on the recovery of metformin and the competition mechanism are discussed in this paper.

The comparative diagnostic accuracy of conventional and liquid-based cytology in a colposcopic setting

OBJECTIVE

This study was conducted to compare the performance of liquid-based cytology (LBC) and conventional cytology (CS) in the high prevalence setting of colposcopy clinic.

DESIGN

A split sample of matched ThinPrep (TP) and conventional smear from 563 patients were evaluated blindly. The performance of both techniques was compared with the gold standard of biopsy results or normal colposcopy examination in 441 cases.

SETTING

Colposcopy clinic of an inner city hospital for women and children.

SAMPLE

Five hundred and sixty-three women referred to colposcopy clinic over 14-month period.

METHODS

Cervical smears were taken from 563 women referred for colposcopy. Using the split-sample technique, the material was spread on a conventional (CS) slide and the remaining material rinsed in a PreservCyt solution. A T2000 processor was used to prepare LBC preparations. All women underwent colposcopy/biopsy according to local protocol. Four hundred and forty-one women met the diagnostic standard criteria of the study, which was either a normal colposcopy or histopathology result. Sensitivity, specificity and positive and negative predictive values were calculated for both methods of cytology preparations.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Matched TP and conventional smears, detection of abnormality, matched biopsies, sensitivity, specificity, and positive and negative predictive values.

RESULTS

Inadequate rates for CS and LBC (TP) were 4.3% and 0.68%, respectively. In 73% of cases, the CS and the LBC preparations showed exact agreement, whereas 77% agreement was seen when comparison was made for amalgamated low grade and high grade abnormalities. Low grade cytological abnormalities accounted for 44% of LBC slides versus 37% in CS slides. High grade cytological abnormalities accounted for 22% of LBC versus 17% seen in CS cases (P < 0.001). LBC showed increased sensitivity in the detection of CIN2 or worse than CS (92% and 83%, respectively) and CS showed greater specificity than LBC (82% and 76%, respectively).

CONCLUSIONS

In high prevalence setting, LBC performed at least as well as CS. The inadequate rate was significantly lower with LBC. The numbers are too small, however, to make confident comments about increased sensitivity and negative predictive value with LBC. Larger studies are required to verify these findings.

Transphyseal spread of benign tumors and infections in pediatric patients: a series of six cases

Epiphyseal extension of benign pathology is regarded as an infrequent occurrence. This observation has been attributed to anatomical and biochemical phenomenon unique to physeal cartilage. We report a retrospective series of six patients over a period of 4 years, diagnosed with benign pathologies that showed crossing of an open physeal plate by the disease. Four of these cases were infections and two were benign tumors. The patients were aged between 5 and 11 years, all of them were treated at a tertiary referral centre and followed up for a minimum period of 6 months to evaluate the progress of disease. The findings are more than just a pathological curiosity as they alter the management and surgical procedure that needs to be performed for these conditions. The recognition of the fact that benign tumors may occasionally present with transphyseal spread will prevent unjustified radical procedures that are best reserved for aggressive malignant conditions.

BSCC, Bethesda or other? Terminology in cervical cytology European panel discussion

The European panel agreed that reproducibility and translatability of terminology in cervical cytology were essential, arguing well for harmonization of reporting systems. The majority at this meeting use a modification of the Bethesda system (BS). Local modifications involved reporting subcategories within high grade and low grade lesions, which would not alter the overall translatability of their systems both with each other and BS. The majority agree that low grade lesions with and without koilocytosis should be managed similarly as should high grade lesions (moderate dysplasia/CIN2 or worse). Those systems linking moderate dysplasia with mild rather than severe dysplasia would need to define moderate dysplasia as such, if their results were to be translatable, which would be preferable to their using a different definition of low grade and high grade lesions. Translation between systems might anyway be facilitated by reporting moderate dysplasia as a subcategory within high grade, which was favoured by most of those present. Therefore, there is no need for exact agreement of terminology if broad principles are agreed. This useful discussion adds weight to the British Society for Clinical Cytology recommendation that the new classification should be adopted by the UK National Health Service Cervical Screening Programme. If the new classification is adopted, the UK would join the European consensus opinion on terminology.

Transphyseal spread of benign tumors and infections in pediatric patients: a series of six cases

Epiphyseal extension of benign pathology is regarded as an infrequent occurrence. This observation has been attributed to anatomical and biochemical phenomenon unique to physeal cartilage. We report a retrospective series of six patients over a period of 4 years, diagnosed with benign pathologies that showed crossing of an open physeal plate by the disease. Four of these cases were infections and two were benign tumors. The patients were aged between 5 and 11 years, all of them were treated at a tertiary referral centre and followed up for a minimum period of 6 months to evaluate the progress of disease. The findings are more than just a pathological curiosity as they alter the management and surgical procedure that needs to be performed for these conditions. The recognition of the fact that benign tumors may occasionally present with transphyseal spread will prevent unjustified radical procedures that are best reserved for aggressive malignant conditions.

A forgotten old disease: mediastinal tuberculous lymphadenitis in children

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of the study was two-fold: (1) to highlight the varied presentation of mediastinal tuberculous lymphadenitis (MTL) in children and (2) to identify parameters, that may help in the early diagnosis of this condition.

METHODS

Between January 1995 and December 2002, 13 children with histological diagnosis of MTL were retrospectively assessed for age at presentation, history of exposure to TB, presenting symptoms, investigations, initial diagnosis, surgical treatment and outcome. Stepwise multiple linear regression analysis was used to determine potential risk factors for early diagnosis of MTL.

RESULTS

Thirteen children presented with: (a) fever, night sweats and weight loss (4); (b) acute respiratory distress (2); (c) cough and shortness of breath (SOB) (5); (d) stridor (1); and (e) chest pain (1). TB was suspected only in 6 children (46%) at presentation. In the other 7 cases (54%) the presumed diagnoses were: neuroblastoma (n=1), metastatic malignancy (n=1), bronchial polyp (n=1), bronchogenic cyst (n=2), and presumed foreign body (n=2). Bronchoscopy was diagnostic in identifying cheesy material within the bronchus and organisms on lavage in 4 (30%) and in identifying external compression in 2 (15%). Thoracotomy and excision of the lymph node mass was necessary to treat the mediastinal compression and to ascertain the diagnosis of TB in 3 children (23%). All 13 children had complete resolution of tuberculous lymphadenitis following anti-tuberculous treatment. The diagnostic clues in this cohort of patients were cough and SOB with history of exposure to tuberculosis (P=0.0001) and bronchoscopy and lavage with positive staining for acid-fast bacilli (P=0.0001).

CONCLUSIONS

Tuberculosis was not suspected in 54% of children with MTL, and they posed diagnostic dilemma on admission. Bronchoscopy must be used as a diagnostic tool in children where tuberculosis cannot be excluded by radiology or specific skin tests. Thoracotomy and excision may be necessary to treat the obstructive symptoms.

Five-year follow-up of women with borderline and mildly dyskaryotic cervical smears

This study investigated the 5-year follow-up status of women with cervical smears showing borderline nuclear changes (BNC) or mild dyskaryosis and the effect of koilocytosis on the outcome. Thirteen per cent of women with cervical smears showing BNC had high-grade cervical intraepithelial neoplasia (CIN). In contrast, 28% of women with cervical smears showing mild dyskaryosis had high-grade CIN. The presence of koilocytosis (24% for borderline smears and 34% for mild dyskaryotic smears) did not appear to influence the risk of developing high-grade CIN. Our results suggest that the simultaneous implementation of the British Society for Clinical Cytology proposed terminology and the colposcopy guidelines from the British Society for Colposcopy and Cervical Pathology could have an impact on colposcopy services.

Attitudes to self-sampling for HPV among Indian, Pakistani, African-Caribbean and white British women in Manchester, UK

Objective: To examine attitudes to self-sampling for human papillomavirus (HPV) testing among women from contrasting ethnic groups.

Setting: Manchester, UK.

Methods: Two hundred women of Indian, Pakistani, African-Caribbean and white British origin were recruited from social and community groups to participate in a questionnaire survey. The questionnaire included items on attitudes to self-sampling and intention to use the test.

Results: Willingness to try to use the test was high, and women did not foresee religious or cultural barriers to self-sampling; however, a large proportion of women were concerned about doing the test properly. This concern was greatest in the Indian and African-Caribbean groups.

Conclusions: Although women's willingness to try self-sampling for HPV is encouraging, worries about carrying out the procedure correctly must be addressed if women are to feel confident about the results of self-sampling methods and reassured by a negative result.

Fluorescent amplified fragment length polymorphism subtyping of multiresistant Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium DT104

Fluorescent amplified fragment length polymorphism (FAFLP) subtyping analysis was used to genotype multiresistant Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium definitive phage type 104. Thirteen distinct FAFLP profiles were found among 85 isolates exhibiting identical pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE) profiles. A single FAFLP profile was shared by 93% of outbreak-associated isolates and 82% of sporadic isolates. This study demonstrates the value of FAFLP as a high-resolution tool for epidemiological investigation of Salmonella.

Cervical HPV infection and neoplasia in a large population-based prospective study: the Manchester cohort

Cytology and histology records and cervical samples for HPV assay were obtained from a prospective cohort of 49 655 women attending clinics for routine cervical cytology in or near Manchester between 1988 and 1993. The women were followed up for cytological abnormality and neoplasia through the cytology laboratory's records. HPV at entry was assayed in an age- and period-stratified random sample of 7278 women and in prevalent and incident CIN3 cases. The prevalence of newly diagnosed CIN3 increased with time since last normal smear, indicating that most cases persist for several years. CIN3 prevalence did not increase further for screening intervals exceeding 5 years, however, suggesting that CIN3 eventually regresses cytologically. CIN2 prevalence increased less steeply with screening interval, while the prevalence of lesser abnormality was almost independent of screening interval. The prevalence of oncogenic HPV at entry declined from 19% among women aged under 25 to less than 3% at age 40 or above. Oncogenic HPV infection was strongly predictive of subsequent CIN3 (OR 17.2, 95% CI 10.4–28.4), but only weakly related to CIN2 (OR 2.3, 95% CI 0.5–10.7) and lesser abnormality (OR 1.4, 95% CI 0.8–2.5). At current incidence rates, the lifetime risk of developing CIN3 will be 9% in this population. The cumulative risk of CIN3 diagnosis among cytologically normal women with oncogenic HPV detected at entry was 28% (CI 18–43%) after 14 years. Persistence of oncogenic HPV may be more sensitive and specific than cytology for early detection of CIN3 and invasive cancer.

Carcinomatous meningitis mimicking Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease

We report a case of carcinomatous meningitis diagnosed at autopsy that was clinically diagnosed as a case of Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (CJD) because of rapidly evolving dementia. Pathological study revealed diffusely spreading carcinomatous meningitis, infiltrating into cortex along Virchow Robin space. Immunostaining for Prion protein was negative. Despite advances in clinical diagnosis, tissue diagnosis remains a pre-requisite for confirmation of CJD.

Cough plate versus cough swab in patients with cystic fibrosis; a pilot study

BACKGROUND

Accurate identification of lower respiratory tract pathogens is important in the management of cystic fibrosis patients.

AIM

To evaluate the cough plate as an alternative method of obtaining respiratory samples for microbiological culture.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Using sputum culture as the "gold standard", the cough plate method identified significantly more positive cases than either dry or moistened cough swabs. Of 20 patients who had a positive sputum culture, 16 had a positive culture on cough plate compared to seven positive cultures each on moistened swab and on dry swab respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

In this study cough plates were more sensitive than cough swabs in isolating respiratory pathogens in sputum producers. As patients prefer it, the cough plate merits further evaluation, particularly in non-sputum producers.

Normal tension glaucoma is not associated with the common apolipoprotein E gene polymorphisms

BACKGROUND

/aims: In normal tension glaucoma (NTG) factors other than raised intraocular pressure have a role in the pathogenesis of the optic neuropathy. Because particular apolipoprotein E (ApoE) gene polymorphisms have been associated with cell death and survival in neurological degenerative diseases, the purpose of this study was to determine the ApoE allele frequencies in patients with normal tension glaucoma.

METHODS

The apolipoprotein E genotype of 155 patients with normal tension glaucoma was compared to that of 349 non-affected, control subjects from the same geographical area. A similar comparison was made between 53 patients with normal tension glaucoma who demonstrated progressive visual field loss, and control subjects. The frequencies of genotypes was compared with the chi(2) test and Mantel-Haenszel coefficent.

RESULTS

There was no significant difference in the frequency of ApoE alleles or genotypes in the normal tension glaucoma population compared to the control group. The ApoE alleles and genotypes in NTG patients with progressive disease were not different from the control group.

CONCLUSION

ApoE gene polymorphisms are not linked to normal tension glaucoma, suggesting that this gene does not have a role in the pathogenesis of optic neuropathy in this disease.

The role of ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration biopsy in the previously treated patient with thyroid cancer

The aim of the present study was to evaluate the effectiveness of ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration in detecting locoregional recurrence in previously treated patients with thyroid cancer. A retrospective analysis of ultrasound-guided fine-needle aspiration (FNA) biopsy was carried out for suspected recurrence of thyroid cancer over a 5-year period at a single institution. There were 37 biopsies in 37 patients. Each patient's ultrasound report, cytology report and medical notes were examined to determine the result of the biopsy and the patient's outcome. There were 29 true-positives, 6 true-negatives, 1 false-negative and 1 inadequate biopsy. Ultrasound-guided FNA, therefore, had a sensitivity of 96.7%, specificity of 100% and overall accuracy of 97.2% in detecting recurrence. Ultrasound-guided FNA is an accurate method of identifying suspected recurrence.

Fluorescent amplified fragment length polymorphism genotyping of Campylobacter jejuni and Campylobacter coli strains and its relationship with host specificity, serotyping, and phage typing

Fluorescent amplified fragment length polymorphism (FAFLP) analysis was applied to 276 Campylobacter jejuni strains and 87 Campylobacter coli strains isolated from humans, pigs, cattle, poultry, and retail meats to investigate whether certain FAFLP genotypes of C. jejuni and C. coli are associated with a particular host and to determine the degree of association between FAFLP-defined genotypes and heat-stable serotypes and/or phage types. Within C. coli, the poultry strains clustered separately from those of porcine origin. In contrast, no evidence of host specificity was detected among C. jejuni strains. While C. coli strains show host specificity by FAFLP genotyping, C. jejuni strains that are genotypically similar appear to colonize a range of hosts, rather than being host adapted. Some serotypes and/or phage types (C. jejuni serotype HS18, phage type PT6, and serophage type HS19/PT2 and C. coli HS66, PT2, and HS56/PT2) were the most homogeneous by FAFLP genotyping, while others were more heterogeneous (C. jejuni HS5 and PT39, and C. coli HS24 and PT44) and therefore poor indicators of genetic relatedness between strains. The lack of host specificity in C. jejuni suggests that tracing the source of infection during epidemiological investigations will continue to be difficult. The lack of congruence between some serotypes and/or phage types and FAFLP genotype underlines the need for phenotypic testing to be supplemented by genotyping. This study also demonstrates how, in general, FAFLP generates "anonymous" genetic markers for strain characterization and epidemiological investigation of Campylobacter in the food chain.

Molecular characterisation of an outbreak strain of multiresistant Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium DT104 in the UK

A major national outbreak of multiresistant Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium definitive phage type 104 (MR DT104) occurred in England and Wales in the summer of 2000. Isolates of MR DT104 were characterised by antimicrobial resistance type (R-type), pulsed-field gel electrophoresis (PFGE), plasmid profiling and fluorescent amplified fragment length polymorphism (fAFLP) analysis. Results of R-type, PFGE and fAFLP showed that summer 2000 outbreak-associated isolates were indistinguishable from most MR DT104 isolates collected in England and Wales during the 1980s and 1990s. However, outbreak-associated isolates all had an additional 2-MDa plasmid (PP D), and this distinct profile allowed outbreak cases to be distinguished from background MR DT104 infections, thereby facilitating the epidemiological investigation by improving the specificity of the case definition. The study demonstrated the highly clonal nature of MR DT104 and the importance of a hierarchical approach to molecular subtyping for outbreak investigations.

Pharmacokinetics and QT interval pharmacodynamics of oral haloperidol in poor and extensive metabolizers of CYP2D6

We studied the pharmacokinetics and QT interval pharmacodynamics of a single 10 mg dose of oral haloperidol in a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled, crossover trial of healthy poor (PMs) and extensive (EMs) metabolizers of CYP2D6. There was a statistically significant greater mean QT(c) on haloperidol (421.6+/-20.1 ms) than on placebo (408.4+/-18.5 ms, P=0.0053) occurring 10 h post haloperidol/placebo administration. Men and women had similar ranges of QT(c) changes from placebo. Despite a statistically significant greater mean elimination half-life (19.1+/-3.6 vs 12.9+/-4.0 h, P=0.04) and lower mean apparent oral clearance (12.8+/-4.1 vs 27.0+/-11.3 ml/min/kg, P=0.02) of haloperidol in CYP2D6 PMs than in EMs, this exposure change did not translate into marked QT(c) changes from baseline that could be considered clinically important. Although the magnitude of the mean QT(c) prolongation on haloperidol relative to placebo is relatively small, it may assume significance in the presence of other risk factors for QT prolongation.

A randomised controlled trial of cytological surveillance versus patient choice between surveillance and colposcopy in managing mildly abnormal cervical smears

OBJECTIVE

To determine whether choice of colposcopy or six month cytological surveillance would be beneficial to women with mildly abnormal smears when compared with the national policy of six months surveillance in terms of psychological morbidity.

DESIGN

A randomised trial based on the Zelen design.

SETTING

A hospital-based research clinic.

POPULATION

Four hundred and seventy-six women who had had a recurrent borderline or mildly dyskaryotic smear on routine cervical screening in primary care.

METHODS

Women were randomised either to six months cytological surveillance or to make a choice between that or colposcopy and were followed up for 1 year.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

The primary outcome measure was caseness (score >or=4) on the General Health Questionnaire at 12 months follow up. Other measures were the Spielberger State and Trait scores, default rates and cytology/colposcopy outcomes.

RESULTS

There was no significant difference between the arms for General Health Questionnaire (GHQ) scores and Spielberger State and Trait at 12 months. There was a significant reduction in psychometric morbidity between baseline and 12 months in both arms. Overall rates of default from the protocol were the same in both arms, but default that led to uncertain ascertainment of cervical pathology was greater in the no-choice arm.

CONCLUSIONS

This trial indicates that having choice did not impact favourably or harmfully on anxiety or feelings of wellbeing. If a patient is anxious, allowing the patient to choose immediate colposcopy may be preferable because it will improve ascertainment of underlying disease in a group who are more likely to default.