Intraoperative consultation of central nervous system lesions. Frozen section, cytology or both?

OBJECTIVE

Frozen section is the traditional method of assessing central nervous system (CNS) lesions intraoperatively. Our aim is to determine the diagnostic accuracy of frozen section and/or cytological evaluation of CNS lesions in our center.

STUDY DESIGN

A total of 157 patients with CNS lesions underwent open surgical biopsy or excision in our center during a period of 2 years (2012-2013). All specimens were studied cytologically; of these specimens, 146 cases were also examined by frozen section. Cytology and frozen section slides were studied separately by two general pathologists who were blind to final diagnoses. The final diagnoses were based on permanent sections and IHC studies.

RESULTS

The accuracy rates of frozen section analysis and cytological evaluation were 87% and 86%, respectively. If the two methods were considered together, the accuracy rate improved to about 95%.

CONCLUSIONS

Cytological evaluation is an acceptable alternative to frozen section analysis and also a great supplement to the diagnosis of CNS lesions.

Evaluating the accuracy of fine needle aspiration and frozen section based on permanent histology in patients with follicular lesions

BACKGROUND

Fine needle aspiration (FNA) has led to a decrease in unnecessary surgeries for thyroid nodules. This study was designed to compare diagnostic value of FNA and frozen section methods in the follicular lesions.

METHODS

This is a cross-sectional study based on the medical records of 42 patients who were referred to surgery clinic of Rasool-e-Akram hospital in Tehran with complaint of thyroid nodules. All FNAs were diagnosed as follicular lesions in pathologic evaluation. All the patients underwent thyroid surgery and their frozen section results were also assessed. Finally, diagnostic value of the two tests was compared based on final permanent histologic report.

RESULTS

Forty two patients with follicular thyroid nodules diagnosed with FNA were included. During the operation, using frozen sections, diagnosis of papillary carcinoma, non-papillary malignancies, benign lesion and intermediate cytology was made in 13 (31%), 3 (7%), 25 (59.5%), 1 (2.5%) patients, respectively. RESULTS of permanent histology showed that follicular adenoma is the most prevalent lesion which appeared in 25 (59.5%) cases. Papillary and follicular carcinomas were detected in 10 (23.8%) and 4 (9.5%) cases, respectively.

CONCLUSION

RESULTS of the study demonstrate a 73% reduction in second surgery in patients with follicular thyroid lesions based on intraoperative frozen section results.

Intraoperative pathology consultation for pulmonary lesions: errors and deferrals

The accuracy rate of frozen section constitutes an important step of quality assessment step in pathology practice. This study aimed to investigate pulmonary lesions that were incorrectly diagnosed or postponed for routine examination by pathologists at frozen section examination; it also aimed to discuss the reasons for difficult diagnoses and the various clues enabling the correct diagnosis to be made when such lesions are encountered. This study retrospectively reviewed the medical data of the thoracic surgery cases that underwent frozen section examination between 2009 and 2014. Frozen section errors and deferrals were identified in 25 cases. Fourteen (56%) lesions were of pulmonary parenchymal origin and 11 (44%) were of pleural origin. The number of cases in which the pathologists postponed the diagnosis without making any approach was 14. Of these, 9 (64%) were benign lesions such as bronchiectasis, fibrosis anthracosis, chronic inflammatory cell infiltration, chronic pleuritis, and mesothelial proliferation. The number of misdiagnosed cases was 11. Of these, 7 (64%) were of pulmonary and 4 (36%) were of pleural origin. Because the examination techniques of each pathology department may differ from one another, the comparative examination of frozen sections and routine sections would aid in becoming familiar with various pathologies and would be beneficial for pathologists in minimizing their diagnostic errors.

Assessing the histological type and grade of primary parotid carcinoma by fine-needle aspiration and frozen section

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study is to compare preoperative fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC) and intraoperative frozen section (FS) for the correct identification of malignancy, histological grade, and histological type.

METHODS

FNAC was performed on all 105 patients and FS on 71 patients with parotid carcinoma.

RESULTS

The rate of correctly determining the histological grade by FNAC and FS was 32% and 73%, respectively. The correct diagnosis rate for both the histological type and grade by FNAC and FS was 20% and 48%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

The correct grading of both high and low/intermediate grade carcinoma is possible in 70-80% of patients by FS. If the histological grade is identified correctly, the extent of resection can usually be decided appropriately. Therefore, we should put emphasis on determining the histological grade.

Reliability of Frozen Section Pathology in Transoral Laser Laryngectomy

Objective

To evaluate the reliability of frozen section analysis in transoral laser laryngectomy (TOLL).

Methods

A retrospective analysis was conducted for patients who underwent TOLL in a university hospital between January 2012 and February 2014. The grade of the tumor and the histopathological diagnosis were noted. The results of frozen section pathologies and routine histological examinations were compared.

Results

A total number of 84 sections from 21 patients with a mean age of 57.3 years were included in the study. All the patients were operated with superpulse continuous mode carbon dioxide laser with a power of 5-8 watts. Squamous cell carcinoma was histologically diagnosed in all patients. The tumor was grade 1 in 80.95% of the patients, grade 2 in 9.52%, and grade 3 in 9.52%. A routine histopathological examination confirmed the frozen section in 94.04% of the patients.

Conclusion

Laser surgery is a commonly preferred treatment modality in early-stage laryngeal carcinomas, in particular. However, a safe surgical margin is a debate in transoral laser surgery. In light of our results, we can conclude that frozen section pathology is a reliable method to achieve safe surgical margins in TOLL.

A novel approach emphasising intra-operative superficial margin enhancement of head-neck tumours with narrow-band imaging in transoral robotic surgery

The primary goal of surgical oncology is to obtain a tumour resection with disease-free margins. Transoral robotic surgery (TORS) for surgical treatment of head-neck cancer is commensurate with standard treatments. However, the likelihood of positive margins after TORS is up to 20.2% in a recent US survey. The aim of this study is to evaluate the efficacy and the feasibility of narrow-band imaging (NBI) during TORS in order to improve the ability to achieve disease-free margins during tumour excision. The present study was conducted at the ENT, Head- Neck Surgery and Oral Surgery Unit, Department of Special Surgery, Morgagni Pierantoni Hospital, Azienda USL Romagna. From March 2008 to January 2015, 333 TORS were carried out for malignant and benign diseases. For the present study, we retrospectively evaluated 58 biopsy-proven squamous cell carcinoma patients who underwent TORS procedures. Patients were divided into 2 groups: (1) 32 who underwent TORS and intra-operative NBI evaluation (NBI-TORS); (2) 21 who underwent TORS with standard intra-operative white-light imaging (WLITORS). Frozen section analysis of margins on surgical specimens showed a higher rate of negative superficial lateral margins in the NBI-TORS group compared with the WLI-TORS group (87.9% vs. 57.9%, respectively, p = 0.02). The sensitivity and specificity of intra-operative use of NBI, respectively, were 72.5% and 66.7% with a negative predictive value of 87.9%. Tumour margin enhancement provided by NBI associated with magnification and 3-dimensional view of the surgical field might increase the capability to achieve an oncologically-safe resection in challenging anatomical areas where minimal curative resection is strongly recommended for function preservation.

Establishing an accurate diagnosis of a parotid lump: evaluation of the current biopsy methods - fine needle aspiration cytology, ultrasound-guided core biopsy, and intraoperative frozen section

The optimum technique for histological confirmation of the nature of a parotid mass remains controversial. Fine needle aspiration cytology (FNAC), which has traditionally been used, is associated with high non-diagnostic and false negative rates, and ultrasound (US)-guided core biopsy and frozen section have been explored as alternatives. US-guided core biopsy is more invasive than FNAC, but is safe, well-tolerated, and associated with improved diagnostic performance. Although frozen section offers better specificity than FNAC, it has a number of important drawbacks and cannot be considered as a primary diagnostic tool. US-guided core biopsy should be considered as the initial diagnostic technique of choice, and in units where the accuracy of FNAC is good it can be used when FNAC is equivocal or non-diagnostic.

The basics of intraoperative diagnosis in neuropathology

Intraoperative pathologic consultation continues to be an essential tool during neurosurgical procedures, helping to ensure adequacy of material for achieving a pathologic diagnosis and to guide surgeons. For pathologists, successful consultation with central nervous system lesions involves not only a basic familiarity with the pathologic features of such lesions but also an understanding of their clinical and radiologic context. This review discusses a basic approach to intraoperative diagnosis for practicing pathologists, including preparation for, performance of, and interpretation of an intraoperative neuropathologic evaluation. The cytologic and frozen section features of select examples of common pathologic entities are described.

Fourteen-year experience with the intraoperative frozen section examination of testicular lesion in a tertiary university center

Most testicular tumors are germ cell neoplasias. The number of incidentally detected small-sized, nonpalpable testicular lesions is increasing with the use of high-frequency ultrasound for infertility or trauma. These lesions are benign in 80% of cases and can be treated by organ-sparing surgery on the basis of frozen section examination (FSE). We assess the reliability of FSE in testicular and paratesticular lesions and its possible impact on surgical management. We performed a retrospective review of intraoperative FSE in testicular/paratesticular lesions at Geneva University Hospital during a 14-year period. A total of 170 cases were identified, with 159 testicular and 11 paratesticular lesions. The FSE results, permanent sections, and orchiectomy slides were reviewed and compared. Frozen section examinations were reported to be benign in 9 paratesticular and in 43 testicular lesions, and malignant in 2 paratesticular and 105 testicular lesions. Comparing FSE and final diagnosis, FSE correctly identified all nontumor lesions. There was a failure rate of 3.5% to identify tumor. Specificity was 100%, sensitivity was 95%, positive predictive value was 100%, and negative predictive value was 89%. Frozen section examination is a highly sensitive and specific intraoperative procedure, which allows to differentiate between benign and malignant testicular and paratesticular lesions, with a possibility of organ-sparing surgery when they are benign.

A new method of surgical margin assuring for abdominal radical trachelectomy in frozen section

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to introduce a new method of assuring surgical margins for abdominal radical trachelectomy (ART) and report our experience using the method.

METHODS

We combined transverse and perpendicular sections to assess surgical margins of specimens from RT. All surgeries from 1st August 2012 to 1st October 2013 were performed by one surgeon. The frozen section (FS) was consistently performed by a group of gynaecologic pathologists according to the detailed protocol described in this article. All cases were prepared by the same pathologist, and the slides were reviewed by two pathologists.

RESULTS

There were 53 patients treated using the new method in our institution. The patient ages ranged from 20 to 41 years old (median 32). The surgeries were performed for clinical stage IA (n = 11) with LVSI and IB (n = 42) tumours (40 squamous cell carcinoma, 11 adenocarcinoma, two adenosquamous and two others). In 20 (37.74%) cases, no residual tumour of the ART specimen on frozen section was observed in the specimens as it was cleared by the preceding loop electrical excision procedure (LEEP) or conization. The margins were initially reported as negative in 45 cases and positive in nine cases. In those nine cases, a second slice of cervix was removed and negative in six cases and positive again in two cases, the other one with positive nodes. The results of frozen sections were concordant with the final paraffin-embedded sections. There were no false negative intraoperative assessments. There were no recurrences after a median follow-up of 15.4 months (range, 6-21 months).

CONCLUSIONS

Combining transverse and perpendicular sections to assess surgical margins of specimens from RT makes the protocol simple, reliable and produces accurate results.

[What size of surgical margins for carcinoma of the eyelid?]

Traditional surgical treatment of non-melanoma skin cancer includes excision with adjacent surgical margins, such "safety" margins theoretically leading to lower recurrence rates. Thus, some authors favor a clinical excision margin of 4mm for basal cell carcinoma and 6mm for squamous cell carcinoma. However, such "safety" margins cannot be applied in all cases of eyelids tumors for anatomic and functional reasons, because such recommendations may lead to severe ocular complications, even loss of the globe. Thus, in order to mitigate these issues in oculoplastic surgery, excision with reduced margins is proposed, either with frozen sections or with traditional pathologic analysis and secondary reconstructive surgery several days later. The purpose of this article is to demonstrate that it is possible to reduce surgical margins while respecting "safety" from tumor recurrence, in order to preserve ocular integrity. The most appealing technique is frozen section of the margins, corresponding to "slow-Mohs" micrographic surgery.

Is intraoperative frozen section analysis of reexcision specimens of value in preventing reoperation in breast-conserving therapy?

OBJECTIVES

A prior study at our institution showed a marked reduction in reoperation for margin reexcision following the development of an intraoperative frozen section evaluation of margins (FSM) practice on lumpectomy specimens from patients undergoing breast-conserving therapy (BCT). This study aimed to examine the frequency of FSM utilization, FSM pathology performance, and outcomes for BCT patients undergoing margin reexcision only.

METHODS

Consecutive reexcision-only specimens were reviewed from a 40-month period following the development of the FSM practice. Clinicopathologic features and patient outcomes were assessed.

RESULTS

FSM was performed in 46 (30.7%) of 150 reexcision-only operations. Of the 46 operations with FSM, there were 28 (60.9%) true-negative, 12 (26.1%) true-positive, six (13.0%) false-negative, and no false-positive cases. There was no difference in further reexcision, total operations, or conversion to mastectomy among patients with and without FSM. Need for further reexcision was significantly associated with tumor multifocality (P = .008).

CONCLUSIONS

Despite overall good pathology performance for FSM in reexcision-only specimens, use of FSM did not affect patient outcome. Rather, underlying disease biology appeared most significant in predicting whether adequate surgical margins could be attained.

Prognostic value of frozen section in t1, t2 carcinoma of oral cavity

Complex anatomy of oral cavity makes it difficult for a surgeon to assess margins of oral cancer accurately and positive margins compromise loco regional disease control, thus surgeon may rely on frozen section assessment for marginal status. We discussed the prognostic value of frozen section in early carcinoma of oral cavity. 90 patients with pT1 and pT2 oral cavity cancer operated from January 2010 to December 2011 under single consultant surgeon were retrospectively evaluated. Log rank test and multivariate cox regression model was used for testing frozen section against the survival and recurrence free status. Survival of patients with positive or negative frozen section was significant (p = 0.037), Survival of patients with positive or negative histology report was significant (p = 0.004), however; prognosis of patients with positive margins despite revision under frozen control was poorer to the patients with negative margin. Frozen section assessment is accurate but their use in the surgery of oral cavity cancer might not improve loco regional disease control or survival when used routinely.

Evaluation of frozen section margins in high-risk cutaneous squamous cell carcinomas of the head and neck

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

To identify histopathologic features associated with poor correlation of frozen and permanent pathology margins following wide local excision for advanced cutaneous squamous cell carcinomas of the head and neck.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective review.

METHODS

A retrospective review of patients undergoing excision of advanced head and neck squamous cell carcinomas between the years 2010 AND 2013 was performed. Demographic, operative, and pathology data were collected. Overall correlation between frozen section margins and final margins on permanent section results was calculated. Positive and negative predictive values of several histopathologic features were determined.

RESULTS

Forty-one cases were identified from the database. Perineural invasion, lymphovascular invasion, and a component of poorly differentiated carcinoma were identified in 61.3%, 34.5%, and 17.1% of cases, respectively. Discrepancy between frozen section margins and permanent margins was identified in eight cases (19.5%). The false-negative rate for poorly differentiated carcinoma, lymphovascular invasion, and perineural invasion was 14%, 36%, 26%, respectively. The positive and negative predictive value of poorly differentiated carcinoma, lymphovascular invasion, and perineural invasion in predicting discrepancy between frozen and permanent margins was 14% and 80%, 36% and 84%, and 26% and 92%, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrated a moderate rate of discrepancy between frozen and permanent section analysis of operative margins from high-risk cutaneous squamous cell carcinomas of the head and neck. The presence or absence of certain histopathologic features appears to be associated with a higher rate of frozen section discrepancy. Evaluation of these features in a preoperative biopsy or staging excision may be useful in planning definitive excision and reconstruction.

Measuring the impact of the American College of Surgeons Oncology Group Z0011 trial on breast cancer surgery in a community health system

BACKGROUND

The American College of Surgeons Oncology Group Z0011 trial has been lauded as practice changing. We sought to identify its impact on breast cancer surgery in the community hospital setting.

METHODS

A retrospective review was performed from 8 community hospitals identifying patients with invasive breast cancer meeting the Z0011 criteria. The primary outcome measures were the rate of completion axillary lymph node dissection (ALND) and performance of intraoperative sentinel lymph node (SLN) analysis over time.

RESULTS

A total of 1,125 lumpectomies with SLN biopsies were performed with 180 subjects meeting inclusion criteria. Performance of ALND (P < .0001) and intraoperative SLN analysis (P < .0001) declined during each time period. Patients more likely to undergo ALND included those with extracapsular extension (odds ratio [OR] 12.8, 95% confidence interval [CI] 2.5 to 67.1) and those who underwent reoperative surgery (OR 10.8, 95% CI 2.6 to 44.4) or intraoperative SLN analysis (OR 5.1, 95% CI 1.2 to 21.9).

CONCLUSION

American College of Surgeons Oncology Group Z0011 trial has been rapidly practice changing in the community hospital setting.

Sentinel lymph node localization using 1 % isosulfan blue dye in cases of early oral cavity and oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma

To study the use of 1 % isosulfan blue dye in identifying sentinel node, sensitivity and specificity of frozen section and predictive value of sentinel node in predicting other nodal status in the cases of oral cavity and oropharyngeal squamous cell carcinoma. 15 patients of oral cavity and oropharyngeal SCC with clinically N0 neck, who required WLE of the primary lesion as well as neck dissection as per recommended treatment protocol, were selected from OPD. 1 % Isosulfan dye was injected peritumorally intraoperatively after the induction of general anaesthesia. Neck dissection was performed and first node taking up the blue dye was identified, dissected, removed and was sent for frozen section. In two of the 15 cases a sentinel node was identified (sensitivity of the technique-13 %). Both the sentinel nodes were positive for presence of metastasis on final histopathology (specificity-100 %). However, five cases had nodal metastasis on final histopathological examination of the neck dissection specimen (sensitivity of sentinel lymph node biopsy-40 %). Frozen section examination had a sensitivity and specificity of 100 %. All data was analyzed using SPSS 16 software. Use of 1 % Isosulfan Dye for identification of sentinel node is a simple and cheap technique, however, it has low sensitivity as compared to the use of triple diagnostic procedure consisting of lymphoscintigraphy, per op gamma probe localization and using isosulfan dye for sentinel node identification. Sentinel lymph node is representative of nodal status and correlates well with the final histopathological examination of the dissected neck nodes.

Frozen section of placental membranes and umbilical cord: an aid to early postpartum diagnosis of intra-amniotic infection

OBJECTIVES

We devised a rapid frozen section (FS) assessment technique of placental tissues and performed the first rigorous assessment of FS relative to conventional workup.

METHODS

We evaluated 49 placentas with clinical/gross suspicion of intra-amniotic infection by FS. Relative to formalin-fixed and paraffin-embedded tissues, we compared the grading, staging, and interobserver variability.

RESULTS

FS assessment demonstrated a sensitivity of 0.91 (95% CI, 0.77-0.97) and a specificity of 0.60 (95% CI, 0.36-0.80) for the presence of chorioamnionitis and a sensitivity of 0.89 (95% CI, 0.75-0.96) and a specificity of 0.69 (95% CI, 0.42-0.87) for the presence of funisitis. The χ2 goodness of fit for grade and stage in both placental membrane and umbilical cord sections was significant (P<.001). There was no significant difference in interobserver variability in comparison with permanent section results (P=0.06).

CONCLUSIONS

We conclude that FS is a reasonably sensitive screening technique, correlating well with conventional assessment, without significantly different interobserver variability.

Therapeutic surgery without a definitive diagnosis can be an option in selected patients with suspected lung cancer

OBJECTIVES

With the recent improvements in the diagnostic accuracy of radiographic modalities, it might be an option to perform therapeutic surgery without a definitive diagnosis for selected patients with suspected lung cancer based on the findings of diagnostic imaging.

METHODS

Between April 2008 and December 2012, all nodules without a definitive diagnosis were classified into five categories according to the probability of lung cancer based on the diagnostic imaging: Category 1 (Benign), Category 2 (Probably benign), Category 3 (Intermediate), Category 4 (Suspected malignancy) and Category 5 (Highly suggestive of malignancy). In this study, the 232 surgical candidates for suspected clinical stage I lung cancer without a preoperative definitive diagnosis were considered to be Category 3 (n = 29), Category 4 (n = 46) and Category 5 (n = 157). Eighty-two patients (72% of Category 3, 46% of Category 4 and 25% of Category 5) had an intraoperative diagnosis during surgery, whereas the remaining 150 patients did not. The final pathological diagnosis and surgical outcomes were analysed.

RESULTS

The final pathological diagnosis of the 232 suspicious nodules revealed 214 lung cancers (52% of Category 3, 93% of Category 4 and 99% of Category 5). Wedge resection was performed for all seven benign tumours. In the multiple regression analysis, intraoperative diagnosis was a significant factor for the length of the operation. In the multivariate logistic regression analysis, the length of the operation was a significant factor predicting both the postoperative morbidity and a prolonged hospital stay.

CONCLUSIONS

Based on a careful clinical decision made using the current diagnostic imaging strategies, patients with a high probability of lung cancer are good candidates for therapeutic surgery, even without a preoperative or intraoperative definitive diagnosis.

Role of frozen section in intraoperative assessment of ovarian masses: a tertiary oncology center experience

Surgical management of ovarian lesions vary considerably depending on the nature of the lesion. As the preoperative imaging and serum tumor marker levels are of limited value in the proper categorization of ovarian lesions, intraoperative pathological assessment is commonly requested for a primary diagnosis. Aim of the study is to assess the accuracy of the frozen section in the diagnosis of ovarian masses in our center and to analyze the causes of diagnostic discrepancies. In this retrospective study, frozen section diagnosis of 233 cases of ovarian masses was compared with the permanent section diagnosis. The overall accuracy of frozen section was 91.85 %. The sensitivity of frozen section diagnosis for benign, borderline and malignant tumors was 99.2, 88.46 and 82.95 % respectively. The corresponding specificity was 96.5, 93.23 and 99.3 %. There were 19 discordant cases including 18 false negative cases and one false positive case. Frozen section is an important diagnostic tool to determine the nature of ovarian masses. Careful macroscopic examination, evaluation of multiple sections along with clinical and radiological findings helps to reduce false positive and false negative results. Frozen section examination has limitations especially in cases of borderline tumors. This modality is most effective when the pathologist and surgeon are aware of the advantages and limitations.

Sertoli-leydig cell tumor of ovary- a diagnostic dilemma

Sertoli Leydig Cell Tumours (SLCTs) are rare, unilateral, sex cord stromal tumours of ovary, which constitute less than 1% of all the ovarian neoplasms. These tumours can be functionally diverse and they may have heterologous elements. We aim to report a case of a 25-year- old woman who presented with suprapubic pain of 5 days duration, a unilateral adnexal mass, hypertestosteronism without virilization. Intraoperative frozen section of the unilateral salpingo-oophorectomy specimen was suggestive of granulosa cell tumour. Histopathological examination, supplemented with alpha-inhibin immunohistochemistry, was diagnostic of Meyer's type II SLCT. Clinical presentation, pathology and the diagnostic pitfalls in the present case have been presented with a brief review of literature.

Intraoperative parathyroid hormone assay-cutting the Gordian knot

BACKGROUND

Hyperparathyroidism is treated by surgical excision of the hyperfunctioning parathyroid gland. In case of adenoma the single abnormal gland is removed, while in hyperplasias, a subtotal excision, that is, three-and-a-half of the four glands are removed. This therapeutic decision is made intraoperatively through frozen section evaluation and is sometimes problematic, due to a histological overlap between hyperplasia and the adenoma. The intraoperative parathyroid hormone (IOPTH) assay, propogated in recent years, offers an elegant solution, with a high success rate, due to its ability to identify the removal of all hyperfunctioning parathyroid tissue.

AIM

To study the feasibility of using IOPTH in our setting.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Seven patients undergoing surgery for primary hyperparathyroidism had their IOPTH levels evaluated, along with the routine frozen and paraffin sections.

RESULTS

All seven patients showed more than a 50% intraoperative fall in serum PTH after excision of the abnormal gland. This was indicative of an adenoma and was confirmed by histopathological examination and normalization of serum calcium postoperatively.

CONCLUSION

The intraoperative parathyroid hormone is a sensitive and specific guide to a complete removal of the abnormal parathyroid tissue. It can be incorporated without difficulty as an intraoperative guide and is superior to frozen section diagnosis in parathyroid surgery.

A reliable frozen section technique for basal cell carcinomas of the head and neck

Basal cell carcinomas (BCCs) of the head and neck treated by conventional techniques of surgical excision, curettage, cryotherapy and radiation therapy have recurrence rates of up to 42%. Mohs micrographic surgery (MMS) decreases the recurrence rate but can be expensive, delay definitive reconstruction and is limited in its availability. The authors report a series of 50 patients with head and neck BCCs treated by a surgeon-directed 'en face' frozen section technique that immediately evaluates the entire peripheral and deep margins during BCC resection, and potentially offers a more efficient and equally effective alternative to MMS. Patient demographics, pathology results, operative time, technique and outcomes are all reported. With a mean follow-up of three years, there was only one recurrence (1.7%). Mean total operative time was 1 h 47 min. The authors conclude that this surgeon-directed 'en face' frozen section technique does not require any specialized training, enables more rapid and reliable results than standard frozen section techniques that are currently used, and provides outcomes equivalent to MMS in the surgical treatment of head and neck BCCs.

How well do we communicate?: a comparison of intraoperative diagnoses listed in pathology reports and operative notes

OBJECTIVES

To compare surgeons' interpretations of intraoperative diagnoses with those rendered by the pathologist.

METHODS

Consecutive intraoperative diagnoses over a nine-month period were retrospectively reviewed. For each case, operative notes were obtained from the hospital information system. The intraoperative diagnoses listed in the final pathology reports were compared with those dictated by the surgeon. Discrepancies were stratified by potential clinical impact: category A, overall correct diagnosis with minor unimportant differences; category B, discrepant diagnosis with both either benign or malignant; and category C, intraoperative diagnoses differing between benign and malignant. The method of communication of each discrepant intraoperative diagnoses (in person vs telephone) was also examined.

RESULTS

There was no record of the intraoperative diagnoses in 20% of operative notes. Comparison of intraoperative diagnoses was possible in 1,131 cases. Category A errors were noted in 94 (8.3%) cases, B in 11 (1%), and C in 4 (0.3%). The most frequent means of communication in A and B cases was the telephone, with more C cases being relayed in person.

CONCLUSIONS

A subset of verbally reported intraoperative diagnoses is misinterpreted by surgeons. While rare events, miscommunication can lead to inappropriate intraoperative management. Communicating diagnoses by phone may increase the risk of perception errors.

[Diagnostic validity of the intraoperative analysis in frozen section of the sentinel lymph node in the surgical management of breast cancer]

OBJECTIVE

The method for intraoperative sentinel lymph node (SLN) evaluation has still not been established in breast cancer staging. This study has evaluated the diagnostic validity and impact of intraoperative analysis using the frozen section (FS) of SLN.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

We performed a descriptive study of the diagnostic validity of the FS of the SLN in patients with breast cancer and selective sentinel node biopsy (SSNB) from October-2006 to October-2012. The diagnostic validity indexes were evaluated using sensitivity, specificity, positive and negative predictive values and global value. Gold standard was considered as the final histopathological results of the biopsies.

RESULTS

A total of 370 patients were studied. Sensitivity and specificity for detection of metastasis by FS in the SLN were 67% and 100%, respectively. Global diagnostic validity was 95%. There was a correlation between detection of metastasis and tumor size (p<0.05). Twelve of the 15 patients with SLN micro-metastases underwent axillary lymph node dissection (ALND). Metastatic lymph nodes were not found in any of them.

CONCLUSIONS

Intraoperative FS examination of the SLN is a useful and reliable predictor of axillary lymph node staging in patients with initial stages of breast cancer. FS reduces the need for second interventions, at least for most patients who have breast cancer with identifiable positive SLN and unequivocal evidence of positive lymph node disease.

Frozen section diagnosis: is there discordance between what pathologists say and what surgeons hear?

OBJECTIVES

Communication in various medical settings is subject to misinterpretation. The frozen section (FS) diagnosis in patient care is dependent on successful communication between pathologists and surgeons. However, very few studies looking at FS errors analyzed postanalytic communication issues.

METHODS

A total of 300 consecutive cases, in which an FS was performed and corresponding surgical note was available, were studied. The FS diagnosis and surgeon's interpretation were recorded for all cases. Discrepancies were classified as major (clinical impact) or minor (no clinical impact).

RESULTS

We found 8 (2.7%) miscommunications, all with only minor clinical impact. These were attributed mainly to the surgeon's misinterpretation of a deferred diagnosis. Also contributing to miscommunication was the pathologist's use of nonspecific terminology such as "favor" or "scattered."

CONCLUSIONS

We found that the rate of miscommunicated FS diagnoses was low at our institution during the period of our study. However, the rate of miscommunication was similar to the much more widely recognized problem of sampling error.