Combination versus sequential single-agent chemotherapy in the treatment of patients with advanced non-small cell lung cancer

We have carried out a randomized phase III study in 105 patients with advanced non-small cell lung cancer, comparing a four-drug cisplatin-mitomycin-based combination chemotherapy regimen to sequential single-agent therapy. The combination chemotherapy regimen consisted of mitomycin C (10 mg/m2), vinblastine (5 mg/m2), methotrexate (40 mg/m2), and cisplatin (40 mg/m2) given every 28 days. Sequential single-agent chemotherapy consisted of mitomycin C (10 mg/m2) monthly until progression followed by vinblastine (5 mg/m2) every 2 weeks until progression followed by methotrexate (40 mg/m2) weekly until relapse. Patients failing either regimen were followed with supportive care. The objective response rate for the sequential single-agent therapy was 19% versus 25% for the combination chemotherapy group (P greater than .5). The median survival for the single-agent group was 166 days and 191 days for the combination chemotherapy group. Overall survival was not statistically different between the two groups (P greater than .5). Leucopenia, anemia, and prolonged anorexia with nausea and vomiting were more common in the combination chemotherapy group compared to the single-agent group. This study failed to demonstrate a sufficient therapeutic benefit in the face of the added toxicity for the combination chemotherapy regimen compared to sequential single-agent therapy.

Six-Drug Sequential Chemotherapy in Non Small Cell Lung Cancer. A North Milan Group Study

Forty-five patients with inoperable non small cell lung carcinoma were treated according to a sequential polychemotherapeutic regimen with cisplatin-vinblastine (A), cyclophosphamide-etoposide (B), and adriamycin-vincristine (C). Patients were evaluated every two cycles. Ten patients (22.2 %) showed a partial response with a mean duration of 20 weeks, and mean survival of 50.8 weeks. It is remarkable that, among them, 6 patients (13.3 %) lived over 12 months and three (6.6 %) over 18 months. The mean survival for all patients was 35.7 weeks. Toxicity was acceptable and reversible.

Thoracic irradiation with or without levamisole (NSC #177023) in unresectable non-small cell carcinoma of the lung: a phase III randomized trial of the RTOG

A total of 285 patients with medically inoperable (RTOG Stage T1-2, N0-1) or unresectable (RTOG Stage T3, N0-1) non-small cell carcinoma of the lung were randomized by the Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) to receive radiation therapy (6000 cGy total dose/6 weeks) plus levamisole (2.5 mg/kg twice weekly for 2 years or until tumor progression) or a placebo. One hundred twenty-nine evaluable patients were assigned to placebo and 131 to levamisole. This report is based on 260 (91%) eligible patients who started treatment and have adequate follow-up. Fifty percent of the patients in both treatment groups had Karnofsky scores of 90-100; 72% had squamous cell carcinoma, 12% adenocarcinoma, and 16% large cell undifferentiated carcinoma; 60% had RTOG Stage I or II primary tumors and 40% had Stage III (T3, N0-1) tumors. Complete regression of tumor was reported in 20% of the patients treated with levamisole and 36% of those receiving placebo. An additional 33% and 19%, respectively, had a partial response (trend test p = 0.08). Median survival was 9 months for patients treated with levamisole and 12 months for those on placebo (two-sided p less than 0.01); at 2 years, patients treated with levamisole had a 15% survival rate as compared to 24% in those receiving placebo. The cumulative proportion failing within the irradiated field with or without other sites of progression at 2 years was 30% in the levamisole group and 34% in the placebo patients. Median progression-free survival was 6 months for patients on levamisole and 7 months for those on placebo (overall two-sided p = 0.014); the estimated proportions progression-free at 2 years were 11% and 18%, respectively. The study showed no significant prolongation of survival, progression-free survival, or differences in patterns of failure in irradiated patients treated with levamisole compared with a placebo. Toxicity related to this immunoadjuvant was, in general, of moderate clinical importance. This study confirms a report by the Southeastern Cancer Study Group concluding that levamisole combined with definitive irradiation has no benefit in the treatment of unresectable non-small cell carcinoma of the lung.

Non small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). A prospective randomized trial with alternating chemotherapy CEP/MEC' versus no treatment

From April 1985 to September 1987, 92 patients with advanced NSCLC were randomized to receive cytotoxic chemotherapy, Arm A (treated), or supportive care, Arm B (control). Chemotherapy consisted of the CEP combination (cyclophosphamide 500 mg/m2 i.v. day 1; epirubicin 50 mg/m2 i.v. day 1; cisplatin 80 mg/m2 i.v. day 1) alternated every 4 weeks with the MEC' combination (methotrexate 30 mg/m2 i.v. day 1; etoposide 200 mg/m2 i.v. day 1; CCNU 70 mg/m2 per os, day 1) until progression. Eight-nine patients (44 treated and 45 controls) were eligible for survival and 77 evaluable for response (38 treated and 39 controls). Response rate was: in Arm A, 8/38 (21%) partial response, 20/38 (53%) stable disease and 10/38 (26%) progressive disease; in Arm B, 18/39 (46%) stable disease and 21/39 (54%) progressive disease. Median time to progression was 4 months (range = 1-14) for treated and 2 months (range = 1-9) for controls (P = 0.001). Median survival was 8.5 months (range = 1+ to 25) for Arm A versus 5 months (range = 1+ to 28+) for Arm B; this difference was not statistically significant (Breslow test: chi-square = 2.75, P = 0.097; Mantel-Cox: chi-square = 0.32, P = 0.56). Treatment related toxicity was gastrointestinal WHO grade 3 in 22/102 (22%) CEP courses and in 10/91 (11%) MEC' courses respectively. Other observed side-effects were not clinically important. From these data our treatment was not clearly superior to supportive care in prolonging survival. This suggests the need for the inclusion of a control group in future chemotherapeutic trials of NSCLC.

[Combination chemotherapy of CDDP and etoposide in advanced non-small cell carcinoma of the lung]

Twenty-seven patients with advanced and previously untreated non-small cell carcinoma of the lung received combination chemotherapy with CDDP (100 mg/m2 iv on day 1) and etoposide (100 mg/m2 iv on day 2, 4 and 6). Eleven partial responses were observed (response rate of 40.7%), and the median survival of patients was 44.4 weeks. Toxicity was tolerable with moderate myelosuppression. This combination chemotherapy should be recommended for further clinical trials.

The importance of surgery to non-small cell carcinoma of lung with mediastinal lymph node metastasis

In the past 25 years, 1,654 patients with non-small cell cancer underwent resection at National Cancer Center Hospital, Tokyo. A comparative study has been made of 5-year survival of patients who had pulmonary resection with and without mediastinal lymph node dissection. There were 426 patients (25.8% of the total) with N2 M0 disease. Of these, 345 underwent pulmonary resection with mediastinal lymph node dissection. The 5-year survival in this group was 15.9% (T1 N2 M0, 30.0%; T2 N2 M0, 14.5%; and T3 N2 M0, 12.9%). In the remaining 81 patients, who did not have mediastinal lymph node dissection, 5-year survival was 6.7%. Of the 426 patients with N2 M0 disease, 242 were select patients who underwent a curative operation with an overall 5-year survival of 19.2%. Sixty-six of them had squamous cell carcinoma and a 5-year survival of 30.8%; 153 had adenocarcinoma and a survival of 16.0%; 14 had large cell carcinoma and a survival of 12.8%; and 9 had adenosquamous cell carcinoma, and none survived 5 years. To improve the end results, it is important to perform as many curative operations with mediastinal lymph node dissection as possible. Histological cell type and tumor status must be taken into consideration.

Combination chemotherapy confers modest survival advantage in patients with advanced non-small cell lung cancer: report of a Canadian multicenter randomized trial

Between February 1983 and January 1986, the National Cancer Institute of Canada conducted a prospective randomized trial comparing best supportive care (BSC) with two chemotherapy regimens: Vindesine and cisplatin (Platinol) (VP) and cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, and cisplatin (CAP). Twenty-three centers across Canada entered 251 patients on the basis of measurable or evaluable disease, with either distant metastases or bulky limited disease considered inoperable and unsuitable for radical radiation therapy; 233 patients were eligible for evaluation. The overall response rates on the chemotherapy arms were: VP, 25.3%; CAP, 15.3%. The median survival rates were: VP, 32.6 weeks; CAP, 24.7 weeks; BSC, 17 weeks. Toxicity on the chemotherapy arms was significant. Although better therapies are required, the data in this study clearly indicate that VP and CAP combination chemotherapy confers a modest survival advantage over BSC in advanced non-small cell lung cancer.

[Clinical application of multiple fractions per day in lung and esophageal cancer]

We applied MFD to the treatment of forty-nine patients with lung and esophageal cancer. In lung cancer tumor response, tumor regression rate and local recurrence-free survival rate were higher in the MFD group. Although the actuarial survival rates in the two group were similar, the frequency of radiation pneumonitis was much lower in the MFD group. In esophageal cancer, the actuarial survival rate in the MFD group (49.8%) was significantly higher than that in the control group. (14.6%). However, the late effects of radiation were stricture in the 3.2 Gy/2f/day group. Further studies are needed to establish the optimal dose fractionation and indications for MFD therapy.

Radiotherapy as an alternative to surgery in elderly patients with resectable lung cancer

From 1978 to 1983, 50 patients with a peripherally located non-small cell tumor of the lung were irradiated with curative intent. These patients were not operated upon because of poor cardiac or pulmonary condition, old age or refusal to operate. Mean age was 74 years, 40 patients being over 70 years of age. All patients had T1-2 N0M0 tumors according to the AJC classification and received 60 Gy to the primary tumor only. The overall response rate was 90%, with 50% complete responses in tumors smaller than 4 cm. The crude overall survival rates were 56% at 2 years and 16% at 5 years, with a median survival of 27 months. Age did not influence survival. There was a strong correlation of survival to tumor size, with 5-year survival rates of 38, 22, 5 and 0% in tumors with diameters of less than or equal to 2, 2-3, 3-4 and greater than 4 cm respectively. Only 5 out of 20 complete responders had a local recurrence, the 5-year survival in this group was 42%. These results compared favorably to a group of 86 patients over 70 years of age who were selected for operation in the same hospital. The 2- and 5-year survival rates in these patients were 48 and 26% respectively, median survival being 23 months. We conclude that in patients over 70 years of age with resectable lung cancer, radiotherapy with curative intent should be offered as an alternative to operation, especially if the tumor is not larger than 4 cm.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Mitomycin, ifosfamide and cis-platin in non-small cell lung cancer: treatment good enough to compare

Mitomycin, ifosfamide and cis-platin are three of the most active single agents in the chemotherapy of non-small cell lung cancer. We have combined them for a phase 2 study in patients with inoperable non-small cell lung cancer. The regimen ('MIC') comprised: mitomycin 6 mg m-2, ifosfamide 3 g m-2 and cis-platin 50 mg m-2, with routine use of lorazepam, dexamethasone and high dose metoclopramide for anti-emesis. Seventy-four ambulatory patients with untreated, limited (LD) or extensive (ED) disease have entered this study, and 66 are evaluable for response. Thirty patients (45%) have achieved partial remission and 7 (11%) complete remission, as assessed radiologically. The overall response rate is thus 56% (95% confidence interval 44%-68%). There have been 29/43 responses in LD (67%, 95% CI 53%-81%) and 8/23 in ED (35%, 95% CI 15%-55%). The median response duration, measured from the start of treatment is 8.75 months. The median survival for the whole group is 9.2 months. The principal toxicity was nausea and vomiting which was severe or prolonged (greater than 48 h) for one or more courses, in 9% of patients. Performance status (PS) and weight were assessed before, and 3 weeks after the last course of chemotherapy. Fifteen (of 31 evaluable) responders improved their PS and only 1 responder deteriorated. Twenty-one of the 28 evaluable non-responders had no change in PS. The difference in PS change between responders and non-responders is highly significant (P = 0.002). Thirty evaluable responders experienced a mean increase in weight of 2.9% with treatment, whereas 24 evaluable non-responders had a mean weight loss of 3.8%. This change is also highly significant (P = 0.0013). MIC is clearly a well tolerated regime and among the most active combinations in non-small cell lung cancer. It will now be tested in a randomized trial against no chemotherapy.

Results of surgical treatment of patients with T3 non-small cell lung cancer

Sixty-one patients with T3 non-small cell lung cancer were surgically treated in our department from February, 1974, through April, 1986. The overall 5-year survival, excluding patients with pleurisy, was 23%, and the 5-year survival for patients undergoing complete resection and incomplete resection was 42% and 10%, respectively (p less than 0.01). Survival in patients with T3 N0 and T3 N1 or N2 disease was 33% and 0 at 5 years, respectively. The prognosis for patients with pleurisy was poor, and all died within 3 years. Therefore, complete lung resection should be done in patients with T3 N0 non-small cell lung cancer if complete resection is expected. Long-term survival is less likely for patients with lymph node metastases if complete resection cannot be performed.

Phase I-II study of cisplatin, VP-16, MGBG, mitomycin, and vinblastine with radiation therapy for non-small-cell lung cancer

Nineteen patients with locoregional non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) were treated with two courses of cisplatin/VP-16/MGBG, followed by involved field radiotherapy and, subsequently, the same chemotherapy alternating with mitomycin-C/vinblastine. Five of 17 patients obtained a response (CR + PR) after induction chemotherapy. Following radiotherapy, an additional two patients responded. The median survival was 7.5 months, with the two longest survivors at 30 and 32 months. Hematologic toxicity was severe, with two deaths from severe neutropenia. Renal and gastrointestinal toxicities were moderate. This program of aggressive therapy did not increase the response rate or median survival compared with those of comparable patients treated in recent trials using radiotherapy alone or combined radiotherapy plus chemotherapy.

Multimodality treatment of non-small cell lung cancer: response to cisplatin, VP-16, and 5-FU chemotherapy and to surgery and radiation therapy

Twenty-one patients with unresectable non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), 11 with stage III M0, five with malignant pleural effusion, and five with a single resectable metastasis were treated with multimodality therapy. All received two to three cycles of preoperative chemotherapy with a new sequential combination of cisplatin (50 mg/m2 IV X 1) followed by 5-FU infusion (40 mg/m2/hr X 72) and etoposide (80 mg/m2/day X 3). Thirteen of 21 (62%) had a partial response, and three (14%) had a minor response to chemotherapy. Of the 19 who underwent surgical exploration, 17 were confirmed to have NSCLC. Ten patients with NSCLC and one with choriocarcinoma were rendered disease free by resection of the primary tumor and lymph nodes. Six received intra- and/or perioperative interstitial therapy with 125I and/or 192Ir. Another patient was treated with 32P. Postoperative external radiotherapy was administered in 15 patients, and adjuvant chemotherapy was administered in ten. This multimodality therapy was well tolerated, safe, and highly effective, resulting in excellent palliation even in patients with pleural effusion and metastasis. The most promising results were in unresectable stage III M0 with a partial response rate of 82% following neoadjuvant chemotherapy and a complete response rate of 73% after surgery. In this group, median survival has not yet been reached and will exceed 12 months.

[Prognostic factors in unresectable lung cancer]

Seventy-seven prognostic factors influencing survival time in patients with unresectable lung cancer treated from 1964 to 1983 at Aichi Cancer Center Hospital were analyzed using univariate analysis by log rank test and multivariate analysis by proportional hazard model of Cox. Statistical significance using univariate analysis was identified in 19 factors in small cell lung cancer patients, and in 40 factors in non-small cell lung cancer patients. The string prognostic factors determined by multivariate analysis were, in the order of importance, serum LDH level, chest pain, peripheral lymphocyte count, bone marrow metastasis, brain metastasis, age, and performance status in small cell lung cancer patients. These 7 factors had a p value of less than 0.01. On the other hand, they were the number of metastatic sites, performance status, serum albumin level, serum LDH level, sex, BUN level, N category according to TNM staging system in non-small cell lung cancer patients, with a p value of less than 0.001. The most important prognostic factors were serum LDH level in small cell lung cancer, and the number of metastatic sites and performance status in non-small cell lung cancer. A metastasis to bone marrow or brain was a more important prognostic factor than overall M category in small cell lung cancer patients, and the number of metastatic sites rather than clinical stage classification or TNM staging system in non-small cell lung cancer patients with respect to staging system. Accurate evaluation of the treatment results in unresectable lung cancer patients must take the strong prognostic factors into account.

Enhancement of the clinical activity of melphalan by the hypoxic cell sensitizer misonidazole

One hundred patients with non-small cell lung cancer were entered by members of the Northern California Oncology Group into a randomized Phase II trial of i.v. melphalan versus i.v. melphalan with concomitant oral misonidazole. The patients had not received prior chemotherapy. Eighty-five patients were evaluable for assessment of response and 89 were evaluable for toxicity analysis. The melphalan/misonidazole group had a superior response rate (two complete and four partial responses among 42 patients or 14%) compared to the melphalan group in which there were no responses among 43 patients (p = 0.024, two-sided Fisher exact test). Since hematological toxicity was equivalent in the two groups, there was an improvement in therapeutic index. Data from 12 patients undergoing pharmacological studies demonstrated that the plasma concentration of melphalan was 25% higher in the misonidazole group, a difference that is not statistically significant. Although the mechanism of interaction has not been fully established, this randomized trial demonstrates that a chemosensitizer can enhance the clinical antitumor activity of an alkylating agent and suggests that chemosensitizers in combination with alkylating agents should be investigated in further clinical trials.

Synchronous brain metastasis from lung cancer. Result of surgical treatment in combined resection

The results of combined surgical resection of brain metastasis and primary lung cancer from January 1976 to April 1986 were evaluated. In all cases the brain metastasis was single and synchronous and was resected first. There were 20 men and one woman, with an average age of 53 years. All patients initially had neurologic symptoms related to an intracranial mass. In 19 patients the primary lung cancer was roentgenologically visible, but in two the lesion was recognizable only by bronchoscopy. There were no operative deaths. Nine of 21 patients had a poor postoperative course and died during the first 6 months. The combined surgical approach improved the short-term survival rate in four patients, who died 11, 12, 18, and 21 months after the thoracic operation. In six patients (28.5%) survival for more than 2 years was obtained (three died after 27, 30, and 40 months, three are alive after 25, 28, and 48 months). Two others patients are alive and well 4 and 16 months after the thoracic operation. Synchronous onset of brain metastasis from lung cancer does not necessarily contraindicate combined operations, which can provide long-term survival in selected patients. The absence of mediastinal node metastasis is a favorable prognostic factor. Computed tomographic screening of the brain improves patient selection.

Surgical adjuvant chemotherapy in non-small cell lung cancer

In two different controlled prospective randomized trials the Lung Cancer Study Group has shown that adjuvant CAP chemotherapy is effective in prolonging the disease-free survival. These studies indicate that the adjuvant chemotherapy has its effect by way of diminishing systemic recurrences and that the adjuvant therapy is more effective in non-squamous than in squamous disease. In addition, the benefit of the treatment is more apparent in patients with more advanced, though resectable, disease. It is also becoming clear that chemotherapy either alone or in combination with radiation therapy can result in relatively high response rates in patients with disease localized to the thorax. Indeed, many of these individuals can then undergo surgical resection. It remains to be determined, however, whether or not this preoperative therapy will be effective in prolonging survival. In the future it is quite likely that optimum therapy will involve the use of preoperative treatment either with chemotherapy alone or a combination of chemotherapy and radiation therapy, followed postoperatively with adjuvant chemotherapy with a non-cross resistant regimen. In addition, a major problem is brain recurrences. Indeed the brain was the most frequent site of first recurrence systemically in many of these studies. Thus, more effective therapy directed at CNS disease will have to be developed before major breakthroughs can be anticipated in the surgical adjuvant therapy of lung cancer.

Neoadjuvant mitomycin C, cisplatin, and infusion vinblastine in locally and regionally advanced non-small cell lung cancer: problems and progress from the perspective of long-term follow-up

Thirty-one patients with inoperable, locally and regionally advanced non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) were treated with mitomycin C, cisplatin, and continuous-infusion vinblastine (M-PV) in combination with thoracic irradiation (26 patients) or attempted surgical resection following M-PV (five patients). The total response rate to primary M-PV was 73%, and four of five patients undergoing thoracotomy following M-PV were completely resected. With a median follow-up in excess of 4 years, the median survival with neoadjuvant M-PV is 19 months, and the 4 and 6 year actuarial survivals are 31% and 26%, respectively. In contrast, in 42 individuals with equivalent prognostic factors concurrently treated with irradiation alone, the median survival is 8 months, the 4 and 6 year survivals are 6% and 3%, respectively. Although lung injury was the major toxicity encountered with neoadjuvant therapy, the incidence and severity of that complication could be significantly reduced with administration of dexamethasone, 10 to 12 mg IV X 1, before each dose of mitomycin C; a maximum of three courses of primary M-PV before consolidation with radiation therapy (RT) or surgery; and serial diffusion capacity (DLCO) measurement as a potential gauge of impending toxicity with further therapy.

Five-year follow-up study of independent clinical and flow cytometric prognostic factors for the survival of patients with non-small cell lung carcinoma

Fresh surgical specimens of tumors of 187 patients with previously untreated non-small cell lung carcinomas were investigated by means of flow cytometry. The aim of the study was to look for cellular prognostic indicators for survival times of these patients in addition to the well-known clinical prognostic factors. All patients had a minimum of 5 years follow-up. Patients with aneuploid tumors had significantly shorter survival times than did those with diploid tumors (P less than or equal to 0.001). Identical results are obtained when the analysis is restricted to just those patients with T3 tumors or to patients with metastatic tumors at time of surgery or who were classified as Stage III (P less than or equal to 0.01). These data indicate that DNA ploidy is a strong and independent prognostic factor in patients with non-small cell lung carcinoma. Patients having tumors with a high proliferative activity died significantly (P less than 0.05) earlier than patients having tumors with lower proliferative activity. As with tumor ploidy, survival time in patients with high or low proliferative tumor activities was independent of whether the patients had T3-tumors, metastases, or were in Stage III. Univariate and multivariate analyses of the data in this study demonstrate two groups of independent prognostic factors for the survival of patients with non-small cell lung carcinoma: a group of clinical factors and a group of flow cytometric factors.

Should subcarinal lymph nodes be routinely examined in patients with non-small cell lung cancer? The Lung Cancer Study Group

This study is based on a retrospective analysis of 163 patients with stage III non-small cell lung cancer randomized to one of three Lung Cancer Study Group postoperative resection-adjuvant treatment protocols. All patients underwent rigorous surgical/pathologic staging including required removal and examination of bronchopulmonary, hilar, subcarinal, and paratracheal lymph nodes. Patients were grouped as follows: group I, only subcarinal nodes diseased (N = 40); group II, only high paratracheal nodes diseases (N = 32); group III, only mid-mediastinal nodes diseased (N = 48); and group IV, subcarinal nodes plus nodes from any other site diseased (N = 43). Patient deaths and tumor recurrences were recorded. The death rate was highest for patients with metastases to subcarinal nodes plus nodes in another site (group IV). Pairwise comparisons of the survival rates of patients in each group disclosed a significant difference between group III and IV (p less than 0.02). In view of this observation, the Lung Cancer Study Group recommends that all patients have rigorous mediastinal lymph node staging done at the time of pulmonary resection to establish prognosis and criteria for study of adjuvant treatment interventions.

Overall survival results of non-small cell lung cancer patients: chemotherapy alone versus chemotherapy with combined immunomodulation

The effect on long-term survival of immunomodulation adjuvant to various cytotoxic chemotherapy regimens in non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC) was evaluated in 669 patients followed up between 1974 and 1987. Four hundred seventeen patients were treated only by cytotoxic chemotherapy and served as controls. Two hundred fifty-two patients received warfarin (W), levamisole (L) and tranexamic acid (T) for adjuvant immunomodulation. These drugs, especially when given in combination (W + L + T), led to a significant (p less than 0.05) enhancement of survival in patients with advanced NSCLC, independent of the cytotoxic regimen used.

Diameter, cell type, and survival in stage I primary non-small-cell lung cancer

We analyzed 384 veterans who had "curative" (sometimes conservative) resection from 1966 through 1986 for stage I, non-small-cell primary lung cancer to identify significant variables influencing survival. Operative mortality was 3.1%, mainly from heart attacks. Most patients were asymptomatic, presenting with other diseases of smoking. Five-year survival was 43%; deaths from lung cancer only, 63% (T1, 73%; T2, 49%). Two hundred fourteen (57.5%) of the 372 operative survivors had T1 and 158 (42.5%) had T2 disease. Sixty-five percent had peripheral nodules (84%, T1; 38% T2). Pure squamous cell predominated, in 63% overall (T1, 55%; T2, 74%). Systemic metastases caused most cancer deaths. Within T1, diameter was highly significant. Cell type and time of operation (before or after Dec 31, 1980) were also significant. Under T2, only scarring and differentiation were significant. Veterans in this group live longer if they have small squamous cell tumors.

The effects of preoperative chemotherapy on the resectability of non-small cell lung carcinoma with mediastinal lymph node metastases (N2 M0)

We have defined "clinical N2" disease in non-small cell lung cancer to mean the presence of enlarged metastatic mediastinal nodes evident on plain chest roentgenograms or widening of the carina at bronchoscopy. Forty-one patients with non-small cell carcinoma of the lung and clinical N2 M0 disease presumed operable received 2 to 3 cycles of high-dose cisplatin with vindesine (or vinblastine sulfate) with or without mitomycin-C. Following chemotherapy, 30 patients (73%) had a major radiographic response. Of these patients, 28 had thoracotomy, and 21 (75%) of them had complete resection of the disease, 8 of whom had total sterilization of the tumor proven histologically. An additional 4 patients had limited microscopic foci of residual tumor either in lung or lymph nodes. Survival at 3 years from diagnosis was 34% for all patients, 40% for those who completed the combined treatment (chemotherapy and surgery), and 54% for those who had complete resection with a median follow-up of 44 months and a median survival not yet attained.

[Combined radiotherapy and chemotherapy modalities in the treatment of lung cancer]

The aim of combined modality treatment of lung cancer is to improve control of both local and metastatic disease. Retrospective reviews of the combined RT and CT modality in limited-stage small cell lung cancer (SCLC) showed an improvement of median survival and long term survival compared with CT alone. Among reports of 7 prospective trials in which patients were randomized so as to receive CT alone or CT with chest irradiation, combined modality treatment significantly increased the CR rate in 3/3, and the overall survival was significantly prolonged in 3/7. Concurrently combined modality treatment has a modest survival benefit in limited stage SCLC. Our phase 2 study combining RT with cisplatin-containing CT showed better improvement of response and survival than CT alone in non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC). Four reports of prospective randomized studies have been performed to determine whether combined RT and combination chemotherapy might be better than RT alone in limited-stage NSCLC. Two of these studies demonstrated a survival and response advantage for the combined modality treatment. However, this approach for NSCLC reported so far has been disappointing, because of relative lack of effectiveness of the present CT.

Inoperable non-small cell lung cancer: radiation with or without chemotherapy

We report a randomized multicentre study of split-course radiotherapy (RT), with or without combination chemotherapy (CT), in 238 patients with inoperable non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), previously untreated, confined to one hemithorax and the mediastinal nodes. In both treatment groups RT consisted of 55 Gy in 20 F given over 7 weeks with a 3-week rest interval. CT consisted of the 3-drug regimen CAP: C = cyclophosphamide 400 mg/m2, A = adriamycin 40 mg/m2, P = cisplatin 40 mg/m2; 2 cycles of CAP given before RT, one during the rest interval and six after RT. Seventy per cent in the RT arm and 67% in the RT-CT arm had epidermoid carcinoma. No significant difference was apparent between the RT and the RT-CT arms with respect to objective response rates (CR + PR) (44 and 49%, respectively), median duration of response (278 and 320 days), local failure (31 and 20%), distant progression (23 and 20%) or median survival (311 and 322 days). The survival figures showed an almost significant (P = 0.05) therapeutic advantage of the combined regimen with stage IIIM0 disease. Progressive disease was the cause of death in 92% and 88%. We conclude that chemotherapy did not contribute significantly to either local control or survival as compared to radiotherapy alone.

Non-small-cell lung cancer: should unresectable stage III patients routinely receive high-dose radiation therapy?

Non-small-cell lung cancer patients who have unresectable mediastinal disease have a poor prognosis regardless of therapy administered. The various rationales for high-dose radiation therapy with curative intent are reviewed in the context of treatment results reported in the literature. The case for a dose-cure relationship in a clinically practical dose range must be considered unproven. On the other hand, the evidence for dose-response effects suggests that higher dosages could result in improved quality of life. There is a need to further refine reproducible criteria, both anatomic (such as mediastinal involvement) and non-anatomic (such as performance status), to permit more appropriate selection of patients for high-dose treatment. Studies involving less rather than more treatment with appropriate endpoints might be both ethical and appropriate.

Flow cytometric analysis of DNA ploidy level in paraffin-embedded tissue of non-small-cell lung cancer

Investigations regarding the prognostic value of DNA content (ploidy) and proliferative characteristics [percentage of cells in S-phase or S-phase fraction (SPF)] have been greatly facilitated by the application of flow cytometry (FCM) using nuclei isolated from paraffin-embedded tissue. We have applied this technique to tumor sections from patients presenting with non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) in 1980 and 1981. From 67 out of 115 patients material of sufficient quantity and quality was obtained to perform DNA-FCM. A multivariate analysis including stage of disease (UICC), age, tumor histology and treatment modality was performed to examine the prognostic significance of DNA-FCM in NSCLC. Aneuploidy was found in 65% of cases. In our study, the DNA content was not related to histology, stage of disease or treatment modality, nor to the length of survival (log rank test P = 0.62). Calculation of SPF was possible in 49/67 cases. The SPF was not related to histology, stage of disease or treatment modality, but a significant prognostic value was found for survival; patients with a high SPF died earlier (P = 0.04) and this was especially true for squamous cell carcinoma (P = 0.02). This study demonstrates the prognostic importance of DNA-FCM-derived information in NSCLC using a multivariate analysis; however further prospective studies in larger patient populations are needed.

[Phase II studies of a single agent and a cis-platinum-based two-drug combination in patients with non-small cell lung cancer]

Phase II studies of single agent and CDDP-based two drug combination were performed in 189 patients with inoperable non-small cell lung cancer. Six drug regimens were performed: CDDP alone, VDS alone, Epi-ADM alone, CDDP + VDS, CDDP + CPA, CDDP + ADM. The response rates were 15.4% (6/39) with CDDP alone, 8.0% (2/25) with VDS alone, 6.1% (2/33) with Epi-ADM alone, 26.7% (8/30) with CDDP + VDS, 14.3% (4/28) with CDDP + CPA, 17.6% (6/34) with CDDP + ADM and one CR was performed with CDDP + ADM. In patients with no prior chemotherapy, the response rates were 20.0% (6/30), 11.8% (2/17), 12.5% (2/16), 26.7% (8/30), 16.0% (4/25) and 25.0% (3/12), respectively. The median survival times were 25, 27, 23, 33, 25, and 45 weeks, respectively. The efficacy of CDDP in non-small cell lung cancer patients was re-confirmed, and that of CDDP + VDS, CDDP + ADM was suggested. No death due to toxicity occurred and toxicity was generally tolerable.

Surgical therapy in lung cancer with single brain metastasis

From January 1975 to April 1987, 27 patients underwent surgical resection of non oat cell lung cancer and a single brain metastasis. There were 25 men and 2 women ranging in age from 37 to 70 years. In 21 cases the brain metastasis was synchronous while in 6 cases the onset was metachronous. In 17 cases, the site of the brain metastasis was supratentorial and in 10 cases it was located in the posterior fossa. The chest X-ray confirmed the primary lung tumour in 24 cases. In 3 cases, only bronchoscopy and cytology revealed the primary focus of the tumour. The lung cancer was located in the upper lobe in 25 patients. Upper lobectomy was performed in 23 patients, pneumonectomy in 3, and lower lobectomy in 1. There were no operative deaths. The cell type was adenocarcinoma in 19 cases, squamous cell carcinoma in 4 patients and large cell carcinoma in 4. Only the tumour and nodes were used for staging at thoracotomy. The classification was: 12 patients in stage I, 2 in stage II, and 13 in stage III. At conclusion of the study the longest survival was 68 months after thoracotomy. There was no significant difference in the duration of survival in patients over or under 50 years old. Better results were obtained in patients without node metastases at thoracotomy (median survival of 30 months and an overall 5-year survival of 35%), and in patients with supratentorial metastases (median survival of 22 months and an overall 5-year survival of 23.4%). Our experience confirms that combined surgery prolongs survival and improves the quality of life.

Results of radical treatment of stage IIIa non-small-cell carcinoma of the lung

From 1979 to 1987, 907 patients with non-oat cell carcinoma of the lung were subjected to thoracotomy: of these, 685 (75.5%) underwent radical resection of the lung tumour. The 230 stage IIIa patients were studied in this paper. These were divided into three groups. First group: 93 patients with only local parietal or mediastinal spread without involvement of the mediastinal lymph nodes (T3N0-1M0); the 5-year survival of this group was 35% (44.1% when the ribs and muscles were not affected). A second group of 118 patients had tumour spreading to the mediastinal lymph nodes, but without local involvement (T1-2N2M0): this group had a 5-year survival of 22.3%. The 5-year survival was better in patients without metastases in the subcarinal lymph nodes than in patients with them (23.76% versus 12.89%). Skipping of lymphatic levels was frequent: 37% of patients with metastasis to mediastinal lymph nodes did not have metastases in the lymph nodes of the lung; 10% of tumours removed by lobectomy had metastases in the lymph nodes of the residual lobe. The third group with parietal and lymphatic mediastinal invasion (T3N2M0) had a poor survival (13.5% at 5 years). The author concludes that it is possible to achieve an acceptable 5-year survival in selected cases with metastasis to mediastinal lymph nodes: when the CT scan demonstrated mediastinal lymph nodes larger than 1.5 cm, mediastinoscopy was carried out and, if positive, the patient was judged inoperable.

A randomized comparative trial of sequential versus alternating cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, and cisplatin and mitomycin, lomustine, and methotrexate in metastatic non-small-cell lung cancer

One hundred eight eligible patients with advanced, metastatic non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) were randomized to treatment with either cyclophosphamide, doxorubicin, and cisplatin (CAP) followed by mitomycin, lomustine, and methotrexate (MCM) on progression (sequential, 54 patients) or to CAP alternating with MCM (alternating, 54 patients). The regression rate (30%) was identical for both treatments. In addition, there were no statistically significant differences noted between treatments for regression duration (6.9 months v 7.6 months), time to progression (2.1 months v 4.4 months), or overall survival (5.5 months v 6.9 months). The lack of advantage for the theoretically superior alternating approach was probably due to a combination of relative ineffectiveness of each treatment and lack of complete non-cross resistance.

Flow cytometry as a tool for the prognostic assessment of patients with lung and ovarian carcinomas

In two cooperative studies surgical specimens of 187 tumors of patients with non-small cell lung carcinomas (NSCLC) and 37 tumors of patients with ovarian carcinomas (OC) were investigated by means of flow cytometry (ICP-22). From NSCLC30 cases were classified as tumors with DNA diploidy, 119 as tumors with DNA aneuploidy containing one abnormal DNA stemline, and 38 as tumors with DNA aneuploidy containing more than one abnormal DNA stemline. Seven tumors of patients with OC were classified as tumors with DNA diploidy, and 31 as tumors with DNA aneuploidy (three cases had more than one abnormal DNA stemline). The DNA index values of NSCLC range from 0.7 to 4.5 and the values of OC from 0.8 to 2.7 (DNA diploid = 1). A relationship between DNA content and distribution of the cell cycle phases was observed. The results of DNA content analysis have prognostic importance with regard to the length of survival time. Patients with aneuploid and high proliferative tumors had shorter survival times than did those with diploid or near diploid tumors and tumors with low proliferative activity.

Combined treatment with chemotherapy and neutron irradiation for limited non-small-cell lung cancer: a Southwest Oncology Group Study

Seventy-three patients with regional, inoperable non-small-cell lung cancer received treatment with initial chemotherapy for two cycles (vinblastine-mitomycin followed in 3 weeks by vinblastine-cisplatin), with planned subsequent neutron irradiation to the primary site and concurrent, elective whole-brain irradiation using photons, followed by two more cycles of identical chemotherapy. Histology was reported as adenocarcinoma or large cell in 75%, and 60% had Radiation Therapy Oncology Group (RTOG) stage 3 disease; the remainder had stage 4. The response rate to chemotherapy induction was 51%. There were 58 patients in a second phase of the study who were potentially eligible for treatment with a medically dedicated cyclotron having more favorable characteristics with regard to treatment planning and dose delivery (neutrons "B"). The overall response rate in this group was 79%. Chemotherapy toxicity included four fatalities (5%), with three related to mitomycin C induced bilateral pneumonitis, and an additional five patients (7%) with life-threatening events that required hospitalization. Two fatalities were attributed to combined effects of chemotherapy and radiation, and six more to chest radiation therapy, for an overall treatment-related death incidence of 12 of 73 (16%). Four of the six deaths related to chest irradiation occurred after treatment with a "physics-based" neutron generator (neutrons "A"). Among the 45 who received neutrons in the B group, two (4%) had radiation-related deaths, and another four (10%) had clinically evident radiation pneumonitis. Pretreatment performance status (PS) and response to chemotherapy, but not RTOG stage or weight loss, were significantly associated with survival. Among patients who actually received chest irradiation, only initial response to chemotherapy remained as a significant predictor of survival in univariate analysis, with a median survival of 20 months in responders v 9 months in chemotherapy nonresponders. The patterns of first relapse observed in B group patients revealed that 28% were distant, while 64% were locoregional. This represents a reversal of the usual pattern in studies of chest irradiation alone. It probably reflects elimination of brain relapse by the use of elective whole-brain irradiation, impact of systemic chemotherapy on micrometastases elsewhere, and conservative treatment volumes employed for the chest irradiation in an attempt to minimize its toxicity. Further exploration of combined modality therapy is indicated for regional non-small-cell disease, with a real potential for survival impact if the therapeutic index can be improved.

High-dose cisplatin and vinblastine infusion with or without radiation therapy in patients with advanced non-small-cell lung cancer

Non-small-cell lung cancer (NSCLC) patients with locally advanced or metastatic measurable disease were given a combination of cisplatin, 200 mg/m2 divided in five daily doses, and simultaneously, vinblastine, 7.5 mg/m2 as a continuous intravenous (IV) infusion over five days. Five courses of chemotherapy were planned. Afterwards or on progression, patients were randomized to receive maximally tolerated radiation to all sites of disease v observation only. Forty males and seven females were entered. Median age was 60 years (range, 37 to 74), median Karnofsky performance status was 70 (range, 30 to 90). Five patients had previous brain radiation therapy for metastatic disease, all others were previously untreated. Side effects in the 87 courses of chemotherapy administered included leukopenia (WBC less than 1,000/microL following nine courses) and thrombocytopenia (platelets less than 20,000/microL following four courses). Ten patients became septic, nine of them while leukopenic. Elevations of serum creatinine followed eight courses; in all cases the level was less than 3.0 mg/dL. Nausea and vomiting were mild to moderate. Five patients experienced mild hypoacusis and six had sensory polyneuropathy. The deaths of three patients were considered drug-related. The response rate was 28%. The median survival for the group was 22 weeks, 63.2 weeks for responders and 17.9 weeks for nonresponders. Twenty-six patients received radiation therapy, 16 randomized to this arm as planned, ten to palliate symptoms. Median survival of all irradiated patients was 24.8 weeks. Seven responders to chemotherapy were randomized to receive radiotherapy; their median survival was 25 weeks. In six responders randomized not to receive radiation, the median survival was 77.8 weeks (P greater than .3). Among nonresponding patients, the median survival of those radiated was 22.2 weeks, while that of nonradiated patients was 11 weeks. This regimen is cumbersome and toxic. It has offered no major survival benefits, or improvement in response rates, therefore, we do not recommend it for the standard treatment of NSCLC.

Importance of biologic status to the postoperative prognosis of patients with stage III nonsmall cell lung cancer

The prognosis of patients with stage III nonsmall cell lung cancer was studied, with special attention to their biologic status prior to lung resection. The biologic status was estimated from the neutrophil/lymphocyte ratio in the peripheral blood, serum albumin level, and erythrocyte sedimentation rate. Among 46 patients who underwent potentially curative operations, 31 cases of biologic status A or B (more than two parameters normal) revealed 37.6% of a 5-year survival rate, whereas there was no 5-year survivor in 15 cases of biologic status C or D (more than two parameters abnormal). Of the 5-year survival rate in T3N0 disease of biologic status A or B, the 60% surviving (of 10 cases) was in marked contrast to the same stage disease of biologic status C or D where only 1 patient (of 10 cases) was still surviving at more than 30 months. In 30 patients with T3N0, T3N1, and T2N2 diseases of biologic status A or B, where long-term survivors were derived, the 5-year survival rate in 30 patients of biologic status A or B was 36.6% in contrast to no long-term survivor in the same stage diseases of biologic status C or D (n = 25). We conclude that surgical results in stage III nonsmall cell lung cancer will be beneficial in patients of biologic status A or B, but nonbeneficial in patients with the same stage of biologic status C or D.

A randomized trial comparing vindesine and cisplatinum to vindesine and methotrexate in advanced non small cell lung carcinoma

Combination chemotherapy using vindesine and cisplatinum has been reported to be active in non-small cell lung carcinoma (NSCLC). In an attempt to reduce the potential neurotoxicity of this combination, and to assess the role of cisplatinum, a randomized trial has compared vindesine and cisplatinum to vindesine and methotrexate in 48 patients with advanced symptomatic NSCLC. Patient characteristics were similar in the two treatment arms. Objective tumour response and survival were similar for both treatments. No complete response occurred. Four patients receiving vindesine/cisplatinum (16%) and three patients receiving vindesine/methotrexate (13%) had a partial response. All responses occurred in patients with a performance status of 70% or more and no response was seen in patients with squamous cell carcinoma. Median survival for both regimens was 16 weeks. Toxicity was considerable and only six patients (12.5%) felt better on treatment. Nausea and vomiting were more frequent in the vindesine/cisplatinum arm, but mild neurotoxicity was more common in the vindesine/methotrexate arm. The low response rates, short survival and significant toxicity suggest that the role of combination chemotherapy in NSCLC remains to be established.

Gallium-67 scintigraphy and non-small-cell bronchogenic carcinoma: a quantitative in-vivo predictive assay?

Gallium-67 scintigraphy has been of limited use in detecting lung cancers and micrometastases. To study its potential for determining the aggressiveness of a cancer, we reviewed the charts of 44 patients with non-small-cell bronchogenic carcinoma who had not been receiving treatment when 67Ga scintigraphy was performed. The mean length of survival for the 18 patients with low or little uptake of the tracer, corrected for tumour size, was 19.7 months, and for the 26 with high uptake 9.4 months (p less than 0.01). Such in-vivo predictive assays may be a rational goal for tumour scintigraphy.

Limited resection of bronchogenic carcinoma in the patient with marked impairment of pulmonary function

Surgical resection is the treatment of choice for non-small cell bronchogenic carcinoma, and it is the only method providing prolonged arrest and chance for cure. From 1974 through 1984, 32 patients with marked impairment of pulmonary function had a limited resection for carcinoma of the lung. Marked impairment is defined as a maximum breathing capacity less than 35 to 40% of predicted, forced expiratory volume in one second less than or equal to 1 liter, and forced expiratory flow (FEV25-75) of less than or equal to 0.6 liter. Limited resection is defined as an operation that is less than a lobectomy, generally a wide wedge or segmental resection. The pathological stage of disease was Stage I in 31 patients and Stage II in 1 patient. Ten patients were treated by segmental resection and 22 by wide wedge resection. Two-year and three-year survival is 84 and 78%, respectively, and 10 patients (31%) have survived for five years. Recurrent disease developed in 8 patients, 5 of whom died. Recurrence was highest when the lesion crossed an intersegmental plane. In 1978, postoperative radiation therapy was added to the treatment of all patients whose lesion crossed an intersegmental plane. Since then, 18 patients have undergone wedge resection and postoperative irradiation with only 2 local recurrences at two years.

Results of surgical treatment of stage III lung cancer invading the mediastinum

From 1974 to 1984, 225 patients underwent thoracotomy at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center for primary non-small cell lung cancer invading only the mediastinum (T3). The perioperative mortality was 2.7 per cent, and the nonfatal complication rate 13 per cent. Forty-nine patients underwent complete resection of all intrathoracic disease, with a median survival of 17 months, 3-year survival of 21 per cent, and 5-year survival of 9 per cent. Thirty-three patients underwent pulmonary resection with simultaneous iodine-125 interstitial implantation or iridium-192 delayed afterloading to areas of unresectable primary or nodal disease, with a median survival of 12 months, 3-year survival of 22 per cent, and 5-year survival of 22 per cent. One hundred and one patients underwent interstitial implantation without resection, with a median survival of 11 months, 3-year survival of 9 per cent, and no 5-year survivors. Forty-two patients had incomplete resection without intraoperative radiation therapy and fared no better than a cohort group of 44 unoperated patients with clinical evidence of mediastinal invasion--both groups had a median survival of 8 months and no 3-year survivors. An aggressive surgical approach with pulmonary resection and/or brachytherapy appears to offer some survival advantage to this group of patients. In particular, 5-year survival rates ranging from 7 to 15 per cent were observed in subsets of intraoperatively treated patients with invasion of pulmonary vein, phrenic nerve, esophagus, or pericardium and in those with clinically occult T3 disease.

[A randomized trial comparing vindesine plus cisplatin with mitomycin C, vindesine plus cisplatin in patients with advanced non-small cell lung cancer]

Thirty-six evaluable patients with advanced non-small cell lung cancer were randomized to treatments involving vindesine (3 mg/m2 X 3) plus cisplatin (80-120 mg/m2) versus mitomycin C (8 mg/m2) plus vindesine (2 mg/m2 X 3) plus cisplatin (80-120 mg/m2). The response rate for the vindesine and cisplatin combination was 29%, versus 47% for the mitomycin C, vindesine and cisplatin combination. There was no evidence of improved duration of response in patients given mitomycin C, vindesine and cisplatin. The median survival for patients given mitomycin C, vindesine and cisplatin was 11.4 months, compared with 10.3 months for those given vindesine and cisplatin. Toxicity was almost comparable for the two treatments. The utility of addition of mitomycin C to vindesine and cisplatin should be evaluated in further investigations.

Prognosis after resection of non-small cell lung cancer of the right middle lobe

In a previous study at Roswell Park Memorial Institute, it was noted that in patients whose resected non-small-cell lung cancer had originated in the right middle lobe, the prognosis was much worse than when it had originated in any other lobe. A review of a longer period and exclusion of patients who might introduce a bias resulted in a group of 18 patients whose fate was compared to the findings reported in other comparable series. Three out of those are alive at 8-96 months after operation. Five-year survival was 22% (30% counting only survivors of the operations). These findings indicate that the results of surgery for non-small-cell carcinoma of the right middle lobe fall within the lower range of lung cancer generally.

Postoperative radiation therapy in the management of lung cancer

Postoperative radiation therapy for lung cancer is still controversial. In a 9-year period, 69 patients with non-oat-cell carcinoma of the lung (16% stage I, 26% stage II, and 58% stage III) received such therapy. The radiation dose was less than 5,000 cGy in 42 patients, 5,000-5,900 cGy in 16, and 6,000 cGy or more in 11; follow-up ranged from 24 to 64 months. Actuarial survival at 2 and 4 years was 50% and 16%, respectively, for squamous cell carcinoma, and 40% and 26% for adenocarcinoma. The 5-year survival for stages I, II, and III cancer was 29%, 17%, and 19%, respectively. Histologic findings and type of surgery did not affect survival, but the radiation dose apparently did. The 3-year survival for patients who received less than 6,000 cGy was 35%, compared with 73% for patients who received higher doses. In eight patients, treatment failed within the irradiated volume: all had received doses of less than 6,000 cGy, and the volume in three was judged to be inadequate.

Lung cancer classification: the relationship of disease extent and cell type to survival in a clinical trials population

The staging and histologic cell type of patients in the Lung Cancer Study Group (LCSG) clinical trials program are reviewed and confirmed or resolved at the reference center for anatomic and pathologic classification of lung cancer. A high level of consistency in classification has been achieved through the use of criteria that minimize intraobserver variability. The data obtained from the review project have been used to characterize the relationship of disease extent and cell type to survival in the clinical trials population. Survival characteristics were generated for 1,121 patients who underwent apparent complete resection of nonsmall cell lung cancer and were subsequently entered into various protocols to receive either adjuvant treatment or no further therapy. The end results study provides some insight regarding the biological behavior of squamous cell carcinoma and adenocarcinoma of the lung in terms of the anatomic extent of disease at the time of apparent complete resection. Patients with squamous cell carcinoma had an outcome superior to that of patients with adenocarcinoma in every TNM subset. The differences in survival according to these major cell types were significant overall and in the T1 N0, T1 N1, and T2 N1 subsets but not in the TNM subsets in stage III disease. Histologic cell type and extent of disease are important factors in survival expectations; thus the accuracy and reproducibility of these classifications plays a significant role in the evaluation of differing modalities of treatment.

A randomized study comparing platinum, doxorubicin, and VP-16 with platinum, 4'-epidoxorubicin, and VP-16 in patients with non-small-cell lung cancer

Forty-four previously untreated patients with advanced non-small-cell lung cancer were treated in a randomized trial comparing platinum (60 mg/m2), doxorubicin (40 mg/m2), and VP-16 (150 mg/m2) (PAV) with platinum (60 mg/m2), 4'-epidoxorubicin (50 mg/m2), and VP-16 (150 mg/m2) (PEV). The overall response rate was 10%. Major response rates were quite similar for the 21 patients treated with PAV (5%) and the 23 patients treated with PEV (18%) (p = 0.2). Of the 23 patients with assigned to PEV, two (9%) achieved complete responses for a median duration of 20 weeks and 44+ weeks. There was no significant difference (p = 0.75) in the median survival among patients treated with PAV (24 weeks) and those treated with PEV (20 weeks). Toxicity was generally mild and tolerable. The lack of response found in both arms of treatment caused the study to be terminated early. Some benefit could be appreciated in patients with limited disease and good Karnofsky performance status.