Surgical treatment of craniopharyngiomas: experience with 168 patients

Craniopharyngioma in adults and children: a study of 122 surgical cases

OBJECT

This work is devoted to a 25-year retrospective study of 122 cases of craniopharyngiomas in adults and children treated and followed by the same neurosurgeon (R.V.E.). In this homogeneous series, the aim was total microsurgical removal of the tumor, without postoperative radiotherapy.

METHODS

The operation was performed via a frontopterional approach in 112 cases and a transsphenoidal approach in 10 cases. The tumor removal was considered total in 59%, subtotal in 29%, and partial in 12%. The surgical mortality rate was 2.5%. Even when tumor removal was not complete, radiotherapy was not systematically administered; it was reserved for cases of recurrence. The authors have studied clinical signs, operative characteristics, and ophthalmological, endocrinological, and functional outcomes, as well as recurrence risk and long-term patient survival. The mean follow-up period was 7 years. The functional results in these patients were excellent in 85%, good in 9%, fair in 5% (usually because of ophthalmological sequelae), and poor in 1%. Tumors recurred in 29 patients, but the salvage treatment, by operation or radiotherapy, was successful in 83%. The actuarial patient survival rate was 92% after 5 years and 85% after 10 years.

CONCLUSIONS

These results compared favorably with the data reported in the literature, suggesting that radical surgery of craniopharyngiomas allows good outcome in terms of survival, full recovery, and quality of life for both adults and children.

Intracranial aneurysm and vasculopathy after surgery and radiation therapy for craniopharyngioma: case report

OBJECTIVE AND IMPORTANCE

This case report illustrates the possible occurrence of intracranial aneurysms after surgery and radiation-induced vasculopathy.

CLINICAL PRESENTATION

An internal carotid bifurcation aneurysm was diagnosed in a 19-year-old woman in a routine follow-up examination by magnetic resonance imaging 5 years after subtotal removal of a giant cystic craniopharyngioma treated by postoperative external radiotherapy. The presence of the aneurysm was confirmed by angiography.

INTERVENTION

It was decided to treat the aneurysm by embolization with Guglielmi detachable coiling. However, at the beginning of the procedure, a few weeks after the diagnosis, a dramatic reduction in the carotid artery blood flow was observed, along with signs of thrombosis inside the aneurysm. In light of these findings, the procedure was aborted. Four months later, another angiographic examination confirmed the exclusion of the aneurysm and compensatory flow through the external carotid artery.

CONCLUSION

During the assessment of patients who have undergone postoperative radiotherapy, the potential for the development of aneurysms and radiation-induced vasculopathy exists and should be kept in mind. Considering the potential for spontaneous thrombosis of these aneurysms, cautious judgment is recommended before making a decision to treat them.

Surgical outcomes in 31 patients with craniopharyngiomas extending outside the suprasellar cistern: an evaluation of the frontobasal interhemispheric approach

OBJECT

Craniopharyngiomas frequently grow from remnants of the Rathke pouch, which is located on the cisternal surface of the hypothalamic region. These lesions can also extend elsewhere in the infundibulohypophyseal axis. The aim of this study was to establish the usefulness of the frontobasal approach made through a relatively small craniotomy window for the removal of tumors protruding from the sellar-suprasellar region into the third and basal cistern.

METHODS

Thirty-one patients who were surgically treated for craniopharyngiomas extending outside the sellar-suprasellar region were evaluated. The diagnoses were established in all cases by using magnetic resonance and computerized tomography imaging. The initial symptoms and signs were increased intracranial pressure in eight, vision impairment or visual field defect in 16, hypopituitarism in 17, and psychological disturbances in three cases. All patients underwent surgery via the frontobasal interhemispheric approach, and the average follow-up period was 30 months. Total removal of the lesion was achieved in 22 cases, six patients underwent subtotal resection, and three underwent partial removal due to tumor recurrence after previous surgeries performed with or without adjunctive radiotherapy. Major complications, including impairment of the cranial nerves, were not observed in the immediate postoperative period. One patient exhibited transient memory disturbance due to infarction of the perforating vessels; after 3 months this symptom was ameliorated. None of the patients died during long-term follow up; however, four of the 22 who underwent total removal and six of the nine patients who underwent subtotal or partial removal suffered recurrence. Of the 10 patients with recurrence, six experienced a small recurrence of the lesion (average 3 months postsurgery); after gamma knife surgery (GKS), the size of two of the lesions was unchanged and in four reoperation was performed due to tumor enlargement during the follow-up period. Ultimately, a total of eight patients (four with recurrence and four who had been treated with GKS) underwent reoperation, with gross-total removal via the same approach or combined with the orbitozygomatic approach in patients with very short optic nerves. In no patient was deterioration of visual acuity and visual field observed after surgery. Although all patients except four children and one adult were receiving some form of hormone replacement therapy, their endocrine status was stably controllable.

CONCLUSIONS

In the authors' experience, the frontobasal interhemispheric approach, even made through a small craniotomy window, is a valid choice for the removal of craniopharyngiomas extending outside the sellar-suprasellar region. Via this approach, tumors can be removed without significant sequelae related to the surgical method, due to ease of preservation of the pituitary stalk, hypothalamic structures, and perforating vessels. This approach offers a safe and minimally invasive means of treating craniopharyngiomas.

Microsurgical anatomic features of the lamina terminalis

OBJECTIVE

The lamina terminalis (LT) is a structure of considerable interest for microneurosurgery, and precise knowledge regarding its normal anatomic features and the variations thereof is required. The purpose of this study, which was based on microanatomic dissection of human cadaveric specimens, was to review the microsurgical anatomic features of the LT and its neurovascular relationships. The surgical implications of the morphometric data are discussed.

METHODS

The region of the LT was examined in 10 human cadaveric heads, obtained from 8 fresh adult cadavers and 2 formalin-fixed adult cadavers, and in 10 formalin-fixed, isolated, adult brains. An operating microscope was used for all dissections and measurements.

RESULTS

Assuming the LT to be a triangular structure, we performed measurements of the distance between the midportion of the upper edge of the chiasm and the lower edge of the anterior commissure (height), which averaged 8.25 mm. The distance between the medial edges of the optic tracts (base) averaged 12.81 mm. The area averaged 52.84 mm(2). A minimal amount of retraction was needed to fully expose the LT, and generally there was no need to mobilize the anterior cerebral artery-anterior communicating artery complex. Perforating branches to the hypothalamus and optic apparatus are laterally located and do not interfere with LT incision and/or fenestration.

CONCLUSION

The LT constitutes a clearly identifiable microsurgical target. The allowable extent of LT opening is sufficient to provide wide access into and free cerebrospinal fluid flow from the third ventricle. Fenestration of the LT is a safe procedure, provided that the relevant anatomic landmarks are identified and respected.

Initial clinical results of stereotactic radiotherapy for the treatment of craniopharyngiomas

The efficacy and toxicity of stereotactic radiotherapy (SRT) for the treatment of craniopharyngioma has been retrospectively evaluated in 16 patients. The median tumor diameter was 2.8 cm (range 1.5-6.1) and the median tumor volume was 7.7 cc (range 0.7-62.8). SRT was delivered to a single isocenter using a dedicated 6 MV linear accelerator to patients immobilized with a relocatable stereotactic head frame. The three-year actuarial overall survival was 93% and the rate of survival free of any imaging evidence of progressive disease was 75%. The three-year actuarial survival rates free of solid tumor growth or cyst enlargement were 94% and 81% respectively. Our results suggest that SRT is a safe and effective treatment approach for patients with craniopharyngioma. Long-term follow-up is required to determine whether the normal tissue-sparing inherent with SRT results in reduction of the neurocognitive effects of conventional radiotherapy for craniopharyngioma. SRT can be delivered to craniopharyngioma that may be difficult to treat with stereotactic radiosurgery due to proximity of the optic chiasm. Further clinical experience is necessary to determine the clinical utility of beam shaping in the setting of SRT.

Management of recurrent pituitary cysts with pituitary-nasal drain

Pituitary cysts are usually craniopharyngiomas or remnants of Rathke's cleft. Histologically craniopharyngiomas are lined by stratified squamous epithelium whereas Rathke's cleft cysts are lined by cuboidal or columnar epithelium. The management of pituitary cysts remains difficult because of the risks associated with attempts at complete removal and the chances of recurrence after inadequate resection. We describe 3 cases of cystic craniopharyngiomas and one case of Rathke's cleft cyst which recurred after surgery and were subsequently managed successfully with pituitary-nasal drains.

Growth patterns of craniopharyngioma in children: role of the diaphragm sellae and its surgical implication

BACKGROUND

Most craniopharyngiomas can be classified as either "prechiasmatic" or "retrochiasmatic" according to their growth patterns. The purpose of our study was to investigate the factors determining these growth patterns.

METHODS

The radiological, operative, and pathological findings of 25 consecutive cases were reviewed.

RESULTS

In cases with prechiasmatic growth (n = 14), most tumors were easily separated from the undersurface of the third ventricular floor with the exception of a small area at the top of the tumor where tumor-glial interfaces occurred. Pathological examination of the tough tumor surface demonstrated well-organized collagen tissue, which is compatible with diaphragm sellae. All tumors of this type had intrasellar components, suggesting a subdiaphragmatic origin for this tumor type. On the other hand, tumors with retrochiasmatic growth (n = 11) demonstrated a prefixed chiasm, and most of the surface excluding areas exposed to ventricular cerebrospinal fluid showed tumor-glial interfaces. With the exception of three, all tumors of this type lacked intrasellar components, and the diaphragm sellae was depressed and free of tumor, suggestive of a supradiaphragmatic infundibular origin of the tumor.

CONCLUSION

Growth pattern is closely correlated to the origin of the tumor, whether it is above or below the diaphragm sellae. In craniopharyngiomas with prechiasmatic growth, the major portion of the tumor could be resected by traction. These tumors are candidates for the transsphenoidal approach if the sphenoid sinus is pneumatized. Tumors with retrochiasmatic growth, which are not covered by diaphragm sellae and contact brain tissue directly, are easily torn by traction and the tumor-glial interface should be carefully dissected under direct vision.

The utility of external beam radiation and intracystic 32P radiation in the treatment of craniopharyngiomas

BACKGROUND

The management of craniopharyngiomas has historically been controversial in terms of the extent of initial surgical resection and the use of additional treatments. Various options include radical excision versus a more conservative surgical approach followed by external beam radiation; most recently, intracystic 32P radiation has been used in selected patients.

METHODS

We reviewed our experience with 25 patients with craniopharyngiomas treated between 1984 and 1999 to assess the effectiveness of external beam radiation and intracystic 32P radiation therapy in preventing progression and recurrence of local disease.

RESULTS

All patients underwent surgery as a component of initial therapy for their histologically-proven craniopharyngiomas. Fifteen patients additionally received external beam radiation. Forty-five percent of patients who underwent incomplete resections followed by external beam radiation required additional therapy. In contrast, 80% of patients who had incomplete resections without post-operative external beam radiation required further treatment. Seven patients had intracystic 32P colloid injections. Neither of the two patients receiving 32P intracystic radiation as part of their initial therapy needed further treatment. Only one of the five patients receiving 32P intracavitary radiation for disease progression following initial therapy required further intervention. Of the remaining four patients, three enjoyed responses to treatment and one had stable disease.

CONCLUSIONS

Our observations support the use of external beam radiation for prevention of tumor progression in adults unable to receive a complete surgical resection. Our results additionally suggest that intracystic 32P radiation results in control of cystic components of craniopharyngiomas in the majority of cases.

Transsphenoidal Approaches for the Extracapsular Resection of Midline Suprasellar and Anterior Cranial Base Lesions

OBJECTIVE

The transsphenoidal approach is an effective method for treating tumors contained within the sella or extending into the suprasellar cistern. The technique of tumor dissection is predicated on preservation of the integrity of the diaphragma, i.e., intracapsular removal. Gross total extracapsular dissection may, however, be accomplished either by using a standard approach to the pituitary fossa or by extending the exposure to include removal of a portion of the planum sphenoidale and division of the superior intercavernous sinus.

METHODS

Included in this series were 14 patients with parasellar or sellar tumors with extension into the anterior fossa and/or suprasellar cistern. For 4 of 14 patients (29%), extracapsular access was gained by broaching the tumor capsule from within the pituitary fossa. For the remaining 10 of 14 patients (71%), the dura of the floor of the sella and the planum sphenoidale was exposed, using neuronavigation to verify the limits of bony dissection; extracapsular tumor resection was performed using the operating microscope and endoscopy as indicated. The dural defect was repaired with abdominal fat, the sellar floor and planum sphenoidale were reconstructed, and in selected cases a lumbar drain was placed.

RESULTS

Seven of 14 tumors (50%) were craniopharyngiomas, 3 of 14 (21%) were pituitary adenomas, and 2 of 14 (14%) were meningiomas. There was one case of lymphocytic hypophysitis and one yolk sac tumor. Gross total resection was possible in 11 of 14 cases (79%). Immediate postoperative visual function worsened in 2 of 14 cases (14%), improved in 3 of 14 cases (21%), and was stable in the remainder of cases. Postoperatively, 2 of 14 patients (14%) developed bacterial meningitis. Overt postoperative cerebrospinal fluid rhinorrhea was not observed.

CONCLUSION

Gross total extracapsular resection of midline suprasellar tumors via a transsphenoidal approach is possible but is associated with a higher risk of complications than is standard transsphenoidal surgery.

Extended transsphenoidal approach with submucosal posterior ethmoidectomy for parasellar tumors. Technical note

The authors have developed an extended transsphenoidal approach with submucosal posterior ethmoidectomy for resection of tumors located in the cavernous sinus or the suprasellar region that are difficult to remove via the conventional transsphenoidal approach. Surgery was performed using this approach in 14 patients with large pituitary adenomas, three patients with craniopharyngiomas, and one patient with a meningioma of the tuberculum sellae. The submucosal dissection of the nasal septum used in the conventional transsphenoidal approach was extended to the superior lateral wall of the nasal cavity to expose the bony surface of the superior turbinate lying under the nasal mucosa. Submucosal posterior ethmoidectomy widened the area visualized through the conventional transsphenoidal approach both superiorly and laterally. This provided a safer and less invasive access to lesions in the cavernous sinus or the suprasellar region through the sphenoid sinus. Using this approach the authors encountered no postoperative complications, such as olfactory disturbance, cranial nerve palsy, or arterial injury. In this article the authors present the surgical methods used in this approach.

Craniopharyngioma

Current management for craniopharyngioma, a low-grade developmental neoplasm of the sellar region, is complicated by the tumor's proximity to critical neuroanatomical structures, including the optic chiasm and hypothalamus. Recommended preoperative investigations include MRI with and without gadolinium infusion, a neuro-ophthalmologic examination and a complete endocrine evaluation. Strict management of fluids and electrolytes, the judicious use of desmopressin (DDAVP), and the provision of "stress" doses of gluocorticoids will help guide the patient through the perioperative period. Although radical resection has a role as the sole therapeutic modality in some instances, the majority of patients can be appropriately managed by a subtotal resection followed by adjuvant external beam radiotherapy to the involved field using three dimensional treatment planning. The use of external ventricular drains may obviate the requirement for an indwelling cerebrospinal fluid shunt device. Patients with recurrent or progressive disease, in particular those with cystic tumors, may benefit from other therapies, including stereotactic radiosurgery (gamma knife) or intracavitary irradiation. Currently, stereotactic radiotherapy, intracavitary bleomycin, and systemic chemotherapy remain investigational treatment modalities for this challenging disorder.

Cystic lesions of the pituitary: clinicopathological features distinguishing craniopharyngioma, Rathke's cleft cyst, and arachnoid cyst

The distinction among craniopharyngioma (CR), Rathke's cleft cyst (RCC), and intrasellar arachnoid cyst (AC) remains a difficult preoperative problem. Accurate diagnosis of these rare pituitary lesions is important to determine the type of treatment and predict prognostic outcome. The majority of the literature describes the clinical manifestations and management of only one of CR, RCC, or AC, rendering comparisons difficult. We conducted a study to 1) investigate distinguishing preoperative clinical, biochemical, and radiographic features of patients with CR, RCC, and AC; and 2) identify clinicopathological features that independently predict recurrence in CR and RCC in adults. Fifty-two adult patients included 21 patients with CR (mean age at initial surgery, 35 +/- 14 yr), 26 patients with RCC (mean age, 37 +/- 14 yr), and 5 patients with AC (mean age, 53 +/- 12 yr). Mean follow-up duration was 70 +/- 13 months. Patients with CR presented with hypopituitarism in 95% of cases and hyperprolactinemia in 38%. These patients also had more preoperative neurological deficits (67%), ophthalmological complaints (67%), and significantly higher psychiatric manifestations (33%; P = 0.003) than those with RCC or AC. Patients with AC presented with headaches (60%), visual field deficits (60%), or impotence (50%) in the absence of other specific endocrine dysfunction symptoms. Using biochemical criteria, the percentage of patients with two or more pituitary hormonal axes impaired preoperatively was 67% for CR and 62% for RCC, significantly greater (P = 0.03) than that for the AC patients who had pituitary dysfunction of only one axis. The composition of CR lesions was cystic (38%), solid (10%), or mixed solid and cystic (43%). Patients with RCC or AC groups had a significantly greater proportion (P = 0.006) of purely cystic lesions (88% and 100%, respectively). Calcification detectable on computed tomographic scanning was present in 87% of patients with CR, a significantly greater proportion (P < 0.001) compared to those with RCC (13%) or AC (0%). No significant differences were found between the groups based on computed tomography density, the presence of postcontrast enhancement, or magnetic resonance imaging. Recurrence rate was 62% for CR, 19% for RCC, and 20% for AC. Surgical intervention statistically improved most neurological, ophthalmological, and psychiatric manifestations; in contrast, galactorrhea, menstrual dysfunction, and diabetes insipidus (52% CR; 31% RCC) did not improve or became worse postoperatively. A significantly higher percentage of patients with CR required postoperative hormone replacement. Similarly, there was a biochemical trend suggesting that a smaller proportion of patients with CR improved in at least one pituitary axis after surgery (P = 0.08) compared to those with RCC or AC. There was a positive correlation between cyst size and recurrence rate (r = 0.689; P < 0.01) and between cyst size and time to recurrence (r = 0.582; P = 0.037) for all three groups. We describe the largest clinical, biochemical, radiographic, and histological series of adult patients with cystic disease of the sella turcica. Patients with AC tended to be older at initial diagnosis than CR or RCC patients. Mass effects, such as visual problems and headaches, are common symptoms of all three cystic lesions, but psychiatric deficits favor a diagnosis of CR. Calcification or solid components on neuroimaging characterize CR. Endocrinological deficits, especially diabetes insipidus, had the worst prognosis after surgery. Low recurrence rates can be expected for RCC and AC. These data have direct implications for the management and monitoring of patients with cystic lesions of the sella turcica.