Strategies to improve long-term outcomes after renal transplantation

Elevated numbers of circulating endothelial cells in renal transplant recipients

BACKGROUND

Damage of microvascular endothelial cells is a salient feature of acute vascular rejection and chronic allograft nephropathy, yet specific blood markers of ongoing endothelial injury are currently unavailable. Circulating endothelial cells have recently been established as a novel marker of endothelial damage in a variety of vascular disorders.

METHODS

We studied 129 renal transplant recipients who underwent percutaneous graft biopsy. Circulating endothelial cells were isolated with immunomagnetic anti-CD146-coated Dynabeads. Cells were stained with acridine and counted. To verify their endothelial origin, staining for Ulex europaeus lectin 1 (UEA-1) was performed in parallel. Twenty-one healthy controls were also studied.

RESULTS

On biopsy, seven patients had acute vascular rejection, 15 patients had acute tubulointerstitial rejection, 14 patients had borderline rejection, and 93 patients had no rejection. Patients with acute vascular rejection had the highest cell numbers (72+/-39 cells/mL) when compared with all other patients (P<0.02). Regardless of their biopsy findings, however, all other renal transplant recipients had significantly higher numbers of circulating endothelial cells (25+/-20 cells/mL) than healthy controls (7+/-5 cells/mL, P<0.001). Finally, there was a significant correlation of cell numbers and serum cyclosporine A trough levels. By contrast, there was no correlation with serum creatinine, age, or the number of immunosuppressive drugs.

CONCLUSIONS

The number of circulating endothelial cells is a novel marker of endothelial damage in renal transplant recipients. Further studies must now evaluate the origin of these cells, corroborate the clinical significance of our findings, and delineate the influence of calcineurin inhibitors.

Predictive value of urinary retinol binding protein for graft dysfunction after kidney transplantation

High concentrations of retinol binding protein (RBP) are found in the urine of patients with tubulointerstitial injury. We evaluated the predictive value of urinary RBP (RBPu) for development graft dysfunction after kidney transplantation.

METHODS

Serum creatinine and RBPu were prospectively measured at months 3, 6, and 12 in 221 kidney transplant patients. Baseline graft function was defined as the lowest serum creatinine value during the first 3 months after transplantation. Graft dysfunction was assessed at 1 year as a >-20% or >-30% change in the inverse creatinine ((Delta)1/Cr) compared to baseline value at month 3.

RESULTS

Among 183 patients with normal graft function (Cr </= 1.6 mg/dL) the mean (Delta)1/Cr from month 3 to 12 was -17 +/- 22% (-80% to + 44%). Using a receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis, concentrations higher than 0.6 mg/L showed the best predictive value for diagnosis of graft dysfunction at 1 year. Mean (Delta)1/Cr from month 3 to 12 was -13 +/- 20% for those with RBP < 0.6 mg/L vs -20 +/- 23% in those with RBPu > 0.6 mg/L (95% CI = -13% to -1.3%, P =.018). The percentage of patients with >-20% or >-30% (Delta)1/Cr was higher among patients with RBPu > 0.6 mg/L (34% vs 47%, P =.042; 21% vs 34%, P =.035). RBPu > 0.6 mg/L was the only variable independently associated with >-30% (Delta)1/Cr at 1 year, with an odds ratio (OR) of 1.95 (95% CI 0.99 to 3.80, P =.05).

CONCLUSIONS

RBPu may serve as a surrogate marker for graft dysfunction early after transplantation for patients with normal graft function, allowing early institution of intervention therapies to prolong allograft survival.

Regulatory CD25+ T cells in human kidney transplant recipients

Recent evidence suggests that a population of professional regulatory cells, which limit immune responsiveness, exist in rodents and healthy human subjects. However, their role in disease states remains unclear. A proportion of renal transplant recipients do not demonstrate in vitro reactivity toward their mismatched donor-derived HLA-DR antigens; it was therefore hypothesized that this may be due to such regulatory cells. A cohort of 23 renal transplant recipients was studied at a single institution. In patients with no history of acute rejection, 6 (40%) of 15 demonstrated regulation toward the mismatched HLA-DR allopeptides by CD25(+) cells. By contrast, only one (12.5%) in eight of those with a history of acute rejection demonstrated regulation. Interestingly, if the patient assays were stratified according to initial in vitro immune responsiveness toward the mismatched allopeptides, 8 (47.1%) of 17 of patient assays with low allopeptide responsiveness (alloreactive T cell frequencies less than 60/million) demonstrated regulation of indirect pathway alloresponses by CD25(+) cells, whereas 0 of 8 with higher responses (frequencies greater than 60/million) demonstrated no such regulation (P < 0.05 by chi(2) test). The regulatory cells are present in the circulation as early as 3 mo after transplantation and persist for a number of years, despite conventional immunosuppression. Furthermore, induction treatment with anti-IL-2R mAb did not prevent the development of these regulatory CD25(+) cells. Data from two patients suggest that these cells may also play a role in preventing epitope shifting, implicated in the ongoing immune activation contributing to chronic rejection, and that loss of regulation in a given patient may precede an episode of rejection.

Increased expression of p16(INK4a) and p27(Kip1) cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor genes in aging human kidney and chronic allograft nephropathy

BACKGROUND

The goal of the current study was to examine the potential value of p16(INK4a) and p27(Kip1) cyclin-dependent kinase inhibitor (CDKI) genes in the process of human kidney aging in vivo, and in the development of chronic allograft nephropathy (CAN).

METHODS

Expression of p16(INK4a) and p27(Kip1) CDKI genes was evaluated and compared in 20 normal human kidney tissues of different ages (range, 21 to 80 years) and in 9 chronically rejected kidney grafts. Age dependency of marker expression was analyzed by the Pearson correlation and linear regression.

RESULTS

Expression of p16 in cortical tubular (CTS) and interstitial (CIS) cells of normal kidney was age dependent (correlation coefficients: 0.608 and 0.726, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.227 to 0.828 and 0.417 to 0.884, respectively). Cortical tubular expression of p27 was also correlated with increasing age (0.672, 95% CI: 0.327 to 0.859). Linear regression analyses confirmed the linearity of marker relationship with age (coefficient of determination R(2):0.370, 0.452, and 0.527 for CIS p16, CTS p27, and CTS p16, respectively). The mean chronological and predicted graft ages (53 +/- 21 and 76 +/- 8.9 years, respectively) were significantly different (P = 0.0126). The glomeruli, tubules, and interstitial cells of rejected grafts expressed significantly higher levels of p16 and p27 than normal kidneys. Expression of p16 in glomerular and cortical interstitial cells was higher in grade 3 of CAN than in grade 2 (P = 0.013 and 0.004, respectively).

CONCLUSION

The results of the current study show that expression of p16(INK4a) and p27(Kip1) CDKI genes is increased in cortical cells of the aging human kidney and in chronic allograft rejection, supporting the senescence theory of CAN.

Prevention of chronic deterioration of heart allograft by recombinant adeno-associated virus-mediated heme oxygenase-1 gene transfer

BACKGROUND

Allograft deterioration is the major obstacle to organ transplantation as a long-term treatment of end-stage heart failure. In this study, we transduced the antioxidant gene, heme oxygenase-1 (HO-1), to heart grafts using a recombinant adeno-associated viral vector (rAAV) in a rat heart transplantation model and investigated its potentiality in prevention of chronic graft deterioration.

METHODS AND RESULTS

rAAV/HO-1 was administered to heart grafts through the coronary arteries during cold preservation. We investigated the expression patterns and activities of transgene, graft survival, graft histomorphology, and relevance of HO-1 expression on graft survival and chronic graft deterioration by itself. Long-term allograft survival can be achieved by rAAV/HO-1-mediated stable transgene expression. The development of graft arteriosclerosis and interstitial fibrosis was prevented in rAAV/HO-1-transduced allografts on day 100. rAAV/HO-1-mediated long-term graft protection was accompanied by remarkable downregulation of the intragraft mRNA level of macrophage migration inhibitory factor, tumor necrosis factor-alpha, and transforming growth factor-beta1. Blockage of HO activities by zinc protoporphyrin IX at different posttransplant phases showed that the stable expression of HO-1 is a prerequisite for both survival of grafts and prevention of graft arteriosclerosis.

CONCLUSIONS

rAAV/HO-1 gene transfer represents a novel therapeutic approach to prevent chronic allograft deterioration in clinical heart transplantation.

A prospective, randomized clinical trial of cyclosporine reduction in stable patients greater than 12 months after renal transplantation

BACKGROUND

For stable kidney-transplant recipients receiving triple drug therapy with cyclosporine (CsA), prednisone, and mycophenolate mofetil (MMF), it remains unclear what is the optimal dose of CsA beyond the first 6 to 12 months after transplantation. Complete CsA withdrawal has been associated with a significant incidence of acute rejection and, in some studies, chronic rejection as well.

METHODS

We performed an open, prospectively randomized, controlled clinical trial to determine whether CsA could be safely reduced by 50%. At 1 year or more posttransplant, 64 patients were randomized to either continue their stable-maintenance CsA dose (control group, n=32) or to lower their CsA dose by 50% over a 2 month period (CsA reduction group, n=32). All patients had stable renal-allograft function at the time of enrollment.

RESULTS

Within 6 months of randomization, no episode of acute rejection or graft loss occurred in either group. Patients in the CsA reduction group had a slight but significant increase in their glomerular filtration rate and a trend towards lower serum creatinine. There was also a significant decrease in mean systolic blood pressure, triglycerides, and serum uric acid levels in the CsA reduction group. No significant changes in any of these parameters were observed in the control group.

CONCLUSIONS

This study suggests that a strategy consisting of a 50% CsA reduction is safe and is not associated with the increased risk of acute rejection observed in CsA withdrawal studies. It also has the potential to improve short-term allograft function and appears to reduce cardiovascular risk factors such as hypertension and hyperlipidemia.

Outcomes in kidney transplantation

It is estimated that there are greater than 100000 kidney transplant recipients with a functioning graft in the United States. Recent advances in immunosuppression have improved short-term graft survival rates and decreased early mortality by decreasing the incidence and therapy for acute rejection episodes. For those accepted on the waiting list, transplant prolongs patient survival compared with remaining on dialysis. During the 1990s, 3 new immunosuppressive drugs were introduced in clinical kidney transplantation. All were approved for use by the Food and Drug Administration after large, controlled, randomized trials. Mycophenolate mofetil (MMF), when combined with cyclosporine (CSA) and prednisone, lowered acute rejection rates by nearly 50% compared with control. Tacrolimus compared with CSA also significantly reduced acute rejection rates in kidney transplant recipients, but was associated with a significant increase in posttransplant diabetes mellitus (PTDM) in the early trials. When evaluated in combination with MMF, the incidence of PTDM was much lower. At the end of the decade, sirolimus was shown in several randomized trials to lower acute rejection rates and is believed to be less nephrotoxic compared with calcineurin inhibitors. All of the randomized trials were not statistically powered to assess long-term superiority. Registry analyses have been performed that appear to show some long-term benefit of immunosuppressive therapy with MMF. Other outcome assessments in kidney transplant recipients include risk factors for chronic allograft nephropathy, hypertension, hyperlipidemia, and bone disease. Although there are few randomized trials, understanding of the significance of these common complications has progressed and strategies for therapy and intervention have been developed. This article focuses on the randomized trials of immunosuppressive therapy and complications associated with use of these drugs. In addition, we review the current management and intervention for the comorbidities associated with the long-term clinical management of the kidney transplant recipient.

Islet transplantation: where do we stand now?

After many years of limited success in islet transplantation, researchers developing this procedure have made great strides, and several centers have now reported that islet transplantation can result in long-term insulin independence for patients with type 1 diabetes mellitus. The improved quality of life achieved in some islet allograft recipients suggests that this important line of investigation should proceed. Yet, several factors limit the technique and these hurdles must be overcome before it can be considered a practical treatment for the millions of individuals with diabetes, be it type 1 or type 2. Most obvious is the gross disparity between the number of islets available for clinical transplantation and the number of patients with diabetes who might benefit. Other important limitations, too often lost in the discussion, include complications associated with the technique itself, the toxicity of currently available immunosuppressive drugs, and the imperfect glycemia control achieved in most patients. In fact, our ongoing analysis as to whether transplantation-based therapy improves survival for patients with type 1 diabetes suggests that, for many at least, the opposite may be true. Two variables, as yet undefined, also need to be considered: (1) can the procedure, when done well, prevent or reverse diabetes-associated complications and (2) what are the long-term consequences of intrahepatic islets?

Health-related quality-of-life outcomes of sirolimus-treated kidney transplant patients after elimination of cyclosporine A: results of a 2-year randomized clinical trial

BACKGROUND

This study compared 2-year health-related quality-of-life (HRQL) outcomes of sirolimus (SRL)-treated kidney transplant patients after elimination of cyclosporine A (CsA) to patients continuing on a combined CsA and SRL regimen.

METHODS

A randomized, open-label, clinical trial was performed in Europe, Australia, and Canada. Four hundred thirty kidney transplant patients were randomly assigned to sirolimus plus steroids (ST) (n=215) or SRL and CsA+ST (n=215) therapy after 3 months of combined SRL+CsA+ST treatment. HRQL was measured using the Kidney Transplant Questionnaire (KTQ) and the SF-36 Health Survey at month 3 (time of randomization) and months 12 and 24 after transplantation. Repeated-measures analysis of covariance was used to evaluate treatment differences in HRQL scores over the 2-year period.

RESULTS

HRQL scores were available for 361 (86%) eligible study patients. Statistically significant treatment-by-assessment time interactions, favoring SRL+ST, were found on KTQ Fatigue (P=0.0158) and Appearance scores (P=0.0007). No treatment differences were observed in KTQ Physical Symptom, Uncertainty-Fear, and Emotion scores. Statistically significant treatment-by-assessment time interactions were observed for SF-36 Vitality scores (P=0.0203) but not other SF-36 scores (P>0.05). For Vitality scores, the SRL+ST group remained stable (mean, 0.4-point change) from month 3 to month 24 compared with decreases in the SRL+CsA+ST group (mean, -6.5-point change).

CONCLUSIONS

SRL-based therapy with early elimination of CsA results in fewer appearance-related problems, less fatigue, and better vitality compared with continuous treatment with SRL, CsA, and ST.

FTY720, an immunosuppressant that alters lymphocyte trafficking, abrogates chronic rejection in combination with cyclosporine A

BACKGROUND

Chronic rejection remains the leading cause of failure after transplantation (Tx). FTY720, a new immunosuppressant altering lymphocyte trafficking, is effective against acute rejection, but its activity against chronic rejection is not known.

METHODS

A valid model of chronic rejection was produced. Heart transplantation (HTx) was performed using fully mismatched RA (RT1p) and PVG (RT1c) rats. Administration of donor-specific blood transfusion 12 days before HTx prolongs graft survival, but features of chronic rejection including intimal hyperplasia and vascular obliteration (VO) develop with time only in allogeneic Tx. This is therefore a valid model of chronic rejection. VO was assessed on post-Tx day 90 in six groups differing according to the maintenance immunosuppressive regimen administered. group 1, donor-specific blood transfusion only and no other treatment; group 2, FTY720 (0.3 mg/kg/day orally) for 90 days; group 3, cyclosporine A (CsA) (1 mg/kg/day orally) for 90 days; group 4, combined administration of FTY720 and CsA for 90 days; group 5, transient administration of combined FTY720 and CsA for 7 days; and group 6, syngeneic HTx (RA to RA). Graft infiltrate, endothelial immunoglobulin (Ig) G deposition, and complement binding were also examined on post-Tx day 90.

RESULTS

In control group 1, severe VO was observed, compared with syngeneic HTx (group 6). Monotherapy with FTY720 (group 2) or with CsA (group 3) significantly but partially reduced VO. On the contrary, combined administration of FTY720 and CsA (group 4) abrogated VO. A 1-week treatment with combined FTY720 and CsA (group 5) reduced VO but only partially. In group 1, arteriosclerosis was accompanied by graft infiltrate, endothelial IgG deposition, and complement binding. In groups 2, 3, and 5, graft infiltrating scores were partially decreased compared with group 1 but remained higher than in syngeneic controls; endothelial IgG deposition and complement binding were still present. In group 4, continuous administration of combined FTY720 and CsA reduced graft infiltrate to the level of syngeneic control and abrogated both endothelial IgG deposition and complement binding.

CONCLUSIONS

Maintenance treatment with either FTY720 or CsA monotherapy partially prevents chronic rejection; short-term treatment with combined FTY720 and CsA reduces chronic rejection only partially; and continuous treatment with combined FTY720 and CsA abrogates chronic rejection, and this is accompanied by dramatic reduction of graft infiltrating cells, endothelial IgG deposition, and complement binding. Prevention of chronic rejection by maintenance treatment with FTY720 and CsA represents indirect evidence that normal lymphocyte trafficking and function are mandatory for development of chronic rejection.

Renal transplantation: can we reduce calcineurin inhibitor/stop steroids? Evidence based on protocol biopsy findings

How to combine antirejection drugs and which is the optimal dose of steroids and calcineurin inhibitors beyond the first year after kidney transplantation to maintain adequate immunosuppression without major side effects are far from clear. Kidney transplant patients on steroid, cyclosporine (CsA), and azathioprine were randomized to per-protocol biopsy (n = 30) or no-biopsy (n = 29) 1 to 2 yr posttransplant. Steroid or CsA were discontinued or reduced on the basis of biopsy to establish effects on drug-related complications, acute rejection, and graft function over 3 yr of follow-up. Serum creatinine, GFR (plasma clearance of iohexol), RPF (renal clearance of p-aminohippurate), CsA pharmacokinetics, and adverse events were monitored yearly. At the end, patients underwent a second biopsy. Per-protocol biopsy histology revealed no lesions (n = 5, steroid withdrawal), CsA nephropathy (n = 13, CsA discontinuation/reduction), or chronic rejection (n = 12, standard therapy). Reducing the drug regimen led to overall fewer side effects related to immunosuppression as compared with standard therapy or no-biopsy. Steroids were safely stopped with no acute rejection or graft loss. Complete CsA discontinuation was associated with acute rejection in the first four patients. Lowering CsA to low target CsA trough (30 to 70 ng/ml) never led to acute rejection or major renal function deterioration. Biopsy patients on conventional regimen had no acute rejection, one graft loss, no significant change in GFR, and significant RPF decline. No-biopsy controls: no acute rejection, one graft loss, significant decline of GFR and RPF. By serial biopsy analysis, severe lesions did not develop in patients with steroid discontinuation in contrast to patients on standard therapy over follow-up. CsA reduction did not adversely affect histology. Per-protocol biopsy more than 1 yr after kidney transplantation is a safe procedure to guide change of drug regimen and to lower the risk of major side effects.

Permanent acceptance of both cardiac and skin allografts using a mild conditioning regimen for the induction of stable mixed chimerism in mice

Patients who are receiving an organ transplant nowadays are sentenced to the life-long administration of immunosuppressive drugs, which have serious side effects. The reliable induction of donor-specific tolerance therefore remains a major goal in organ transplantation. Previously, we have developed a sublethal, non-myeloablative murine model in which permanent mixed, multilineage chimerism and donor-specific tolerance are established. Our model involves engraftment of fully allogeneic T cell depleted donor bone marrow cells in low dose irradiated and anti-CD3 treated major histocompatibility complex (MHC)-disparate recipient mice. To investigate whether vascularized organ grafts are accepted in our model, we performed heterotopic heart transplantations in our mixed chimeric mice. Chimeric mice permanently accepted hearts from the bone marrow donor (>130 days) and rapidly rejected third party-type allografts (median survival time 9 days). Untreated control recipient mice rejected both donor- and third party-type allografts. In addition, mice that accepted their cardiac grafts, donor-specific acceptance of skin grafts was observed. In conclusion, the establishment of stable mixed chimerism with this low-toxicity regimen resulted in permanent donor-specific acceptance of vascularized organ as well as skin grafts across a full MHC barrier.

Humoral rejection in kidney transplantation: new concepts in diagnosis and treatment

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

Evidence from several transplant centers indicates that a substantial proportion of acute and chronic renal allograft rejection is caused by antibodies to donor antigens. Antibody-mediated injury arises despite potent anti-T cell pharmacological agents, and probably requires different therapy.

RECENT FINDINGS

Acute humoral rejection occurs in 20-30% of acute rejection cases, has a poorer prognosis than cellular rejection, and is refractory to conventional immunosuppressive therapy. C4d deposition in peritubular capillaries of renal allografts has been demonstrated to be a sensitive and diagnostic in-situ marker of acute humoral rejection that correlates strongly with the presence of circulating donor-specific antibodies. Biopsies with chronic allograft arteriopathy or glomerulopathy also have a high frequency of C4d deposition and donor-specific antibodies. The vessels of other organs, notably the heart, can also be targets of humoral rejection. New polyclonal C4d antibodies work in paraffin sections. Pitfalls in C4d staining have been identified and must be considered in the valid interpretation of results.

SUMMARY

As the histology is variable, the current diagnosis of humoral rejection in biopsies relies on the demonstration of C4d, a component of the classical complement pathway, in peritubular capillaries. The new classification of renal allograft rejection incorporates humoral and cellular mechanisms of injury, with the diagnostic criteria of each. This should prove useful in guiding clinical treatment, and stratifying drug trials, replacing obsolete terms such as 'vascular rejection'. Specific therapeutic strategies for humoral rejection with controlled trials targeting the humoral limb of immunosuppression are needed.