Consensus statement of the Movement Disorder Society on Tremor. Ad Hoc Scientific Committee

Tremor in Parkinson's disease

Rest tremor is a common feature of Parkinson's disease, but its underlying pathophysiology remains unknown. This review hypothesizes that tremor is related to selective loss of components of the substantia nigra. The relative scarcity of tremor in related Parkinsonian conditions may indicate a dissociation associated with different pathological involvement of the substantia nigra and its connections. Connections of the subthalamic nucleus with the pallidum, modified by cortical and nigral inputs, allow for the transfer of tremorogenic activity to the thalamus. Thalamo-cortical interactions, tempered by cerebellar input, generate the final common pathway for tremor production.

Electrophysiological confirmation of the zona incerta as a target for surgical treatment of disabling involuntary arm movements in multiple sclerosis: use of local field potentials

Lesioning or chronic deep brain stimulation (DBS) of the nucleus ventralis intermedius results in abolition of tremor in the contralateral limbs in Parkinson's disease (PD) and also in essential tremor. Recently, chronic DBS of the subthalamic nucleus has also proved to be very effective in reducing contralateral limb tremor in PD. These targets have been less effective in controlling the complex limb tremor often seen in multiple sclerosis (MS). Consequently, other targets have been sought in cases of MS with tremor. We describe a patient with MS with disabling proximal and distal involuntary arm movements in whom we were able to obtain sustained control of contralateral arm tremor and achieve functional improvement of the affected arm by chronic DBS of the region of the zona incerta. We also highlight the important role played by local field potentials recorded from the brain, with simultaneous recording of corresponding EMGs, in target localisation.

Holmes' tremor following midbrain Toxoplasma abscess: clinical features and treatment of a case

The label Holmes' tremor defines a rare symptomatic movement disorder frequently occurring with midbrain damage. It appears at rest and worsens adopting a posture and on attempting movements. We describe the case of a patient with Holmes' tremor due to a presumed Toxoplasma abscess of the midbrain. The positive response to a combined therapy with levodopa and isoniazid is also reported.

Loss of reflex inhibition following muscle tendon stimulation in essential tremor

Electrical stimulation of human upper limb muscle tendons produces a reflex inhibition (I(1)) in the same muscles. This inhibition is reduced in Parkinson's disease (PD), prompting a similar study of essential tremor (ET). In essential tremor, two of eight subjects had no discernible inhibition, even following supramaximal stimulation (< 80 mA) of the tendons from extensor digitorum communis and extensor pollicis brevis. In the remaining six subjects, the mean thresholds for I(1) in these muscles were increased by 270 and 320%, respectively, relative to controls. The maximal amplitude of the inhibition was significantly reduced in the ET group, as was the following excitation (E(1)). The latency and duration of I(1) were not different in ET subjects and controls. The maximal duration of I(1) was correlated with tremor frequency in individuals, and tendon stimulation was effective in initiating ongoing tremor cycles. These results disclose a peripheral reflex abnormality in ET that is mediated by tendon afferents and can be linked to the coexistent tremor. The response in ET was distinguished from that in PD by its different time-course and by failure of the response to appear in the antagonist muscle. The abnormality may prove a useful marker for ET, which currently lacks a definitive pathological or neurophysiological marker to support objective clinical diagnosis.

Influence of proprioceptive input on parkinsonian tremor

Previous studies have shown a modification of parkinsonian tremor (PT) by proprioceptive input induced by passive joint movements. The authors investigated the impact of electrically evoked proprioceptive input on PT. In eight patients with PT they recorded surface EMG from the opponens pollicis muscle, and forearm extensors and flexors. Rhythmic electrical stimulation was applied to the ipsilateral median nerve at the wrist using a submaximal stimulus intensity and stimulus frequencies between two stimuli per second and five stimuli per second. The tremor frequency did not adapt to the stimulus frequency. Tremor frequency of parkinsonian resting tremor increased significantly in the directly stimulated opponens pollicis muscle (mean +/- standard deviation, 4.35 +/- 0.64 Hz without stimulation versus 4.53 +/- 0.68 Hz with stimulation; P < 0.05, paired t-test), the not directly stimulated forearm muscles (4.90 +/- 0.72 Hz versus 5.18 +/- 0.73 Hz, P < 0.001), and the upper arm muscles (5.13 +/- 0.61 Hz versus 5.36 +/- 0.68 Hz, P < 0.01). Furthermore, the parkinsonian postural tremor accelerated significantly during ipsilateral median nerve stimulation (5.31 +/- 0.99 Hz versus 5.44 +/- 1.03 Hz, P < 0.05). Parkinsonian resting tremor in the forearm muscles also accelerated significantly during ipsilateral ulnar nerve stimulation (4.85 +/- 0.57 Hz versus 5.05 +/- 0.65 Hz, P < 0.05). Contralateral median nerve stimulation had no significant effect. These results suggest a close interaction between proprioceptive input and PT generation.

Measurement of ataxic symptoms with a graphic tablet: standard values in controls and validity in Multiple Sclerosis patients

Aim of our study was to find a specific measure for the intensity of upper limb tremor and other ataxic symptoms in Multiple Sclerosis (MS) patients, and to establish standard values and test quality parameters. Three hundred and forty-two consecutive patients with different symptoms in the upper limbs (upper motor neuron symptoms, cerebellar upper limb ataxia, and/or sensory deficits in the upper limbs) and 140 healthy controls took part in the study. All patients and controls had to trace over a 25 cm high figure '8' on a graphic tablet, to tap with the stylus on the tablet and to perform the nine-hole-peg test (9HPT). Patients were additionally examined using clinical standard scales to classify motor dysfunctions of the upper limbs. One hundred and eighty-nine patients and 27 controls were tested twice to investigate the test reliability. Kinematic analysis of the tablet data was performed by kernel estimators, oscillatory activity by spectral analysis. Total power in the 2--10 Hz band was very specific for ataxia versus other motor symptoms. Tapping and 9HPT could well distinguish patients from controls, and patients with predominant motor neuron or cerebellar symptoms from patients with predominant sensory dysfunctions. Mean drawing error did not differ between motor and sensory dysfunctions. The test--retest reliability was similarly high for both spectral analysis and 9HPT.

The pathophysiology of tremor

Tremor is defined as rhythmic oscillatory activity of body parts. Four physiological basic mechanisms for such oscillatory activity have been described: mechanical oscillations; oscillations based on reflexes; oscillations due to central neuronal pacemakers; and oscillations because of disturbed feedforward or feedback loops. New methodological approaches with animal models, positron emission tomography, and mathematical analysis of electromyographic and electroencephalographic signals have provided new insights into the mechanisms underlying specific forms of tremor. Physiological tremor is due to mechanical and central components. Psychogenic tremor is considered to depend on a clonus mechanism and is thus believed to be mediated by reflex mechanisms. Symptomatic palatal tremor is most likely due to rhythmic activity of the inferior olive, and there is much evidence that essential tremor is also generated within the olivocerebellar circuits. Orthostatic tremor is likely to originate in hitherto unidentified brainstem nuclei. Rest tremor of Parkinson's disease is probably generated in the basal ganglia loop, and dystonic tremor may also originate within the basal ganglia. Cerebellar tremor is at least in part caused by a disturbance of the cerebellar feedforward control of voluntary movements, and Holmes' tremor is due to the combination of the mechanisms producing parkinsonian and cerebellar tremor. Neuropathic tremor is believed to be caused by abnormally functioning reflex pathways and a wide variety of causes underlies toxic and drug-induced tremors. The understanding of the pathophysiology of tremor has made significant progress but many hypotheses are not yet based on sufficient data. Modern neurology needs to develop and test such hypotheses, because this is the only way to develop rational medical and surgical therapies.

Risk of tremor and impairment from tremor in relatives of patients with essential tremor: a community-based family study

Essential tremor (ET) is a common condition that is present in as many as 23% of elderly individuals. Our objective was to determine the risk of ET and to study the impairment resulting from ET among relatives of ET cases compared to relatives of controls. ET cases and matched controls from the Washington Heights-Inwood community, New York, and their first- and second-degree relatives underwent a standardized tremor examination. The risk of having ET in relatives of cases vs relatives of controls was compared using Cox proportional hazards models. Five hundred ninety-one subjects were examined (59 ET cases, 72 controls, 234 case relatives, and 226 control relatives). ET was present in 25 (22.5%) of the 111 first-degree relatives of cases compared to 6 (5.6%) of 107 first-degree relatives of controls [relative risk (RR) = 4.67, 95% confidence interval (CI) = 1.90-11.49, p = 0.0008]. RRs were higher in relatives of cases with onset < or =50 years than in those with later onset (RR = 10.38 vs 4.82). Sixteen (64%) of twenty-five affected first-degree case relatives exhibited moderate tremor while performing tasks such as writing, drinking, or pouring. Relatives of ET patients are five times more likely to develop the disease than are members of the population and ten times more likely if the proband's tremor began at an early age. The majority of the affected relatives can expect to experience impairment resulting from tremor.

Firing patterns and correlations of spontaneous discharge of pallidal neurons in the normal and the tremulous 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine vervet model of parkinsonism

To investigate the role of the basal ganglia in parkinsonian tremor, we recorded hand tremor and simultaneous activity of several neurons in the external and internal segments of the globus pallidus (GPe and GPi) in two vervet monkeys, before and after systemic treatment with 1-methyl-4-phenyl-1,2,3,6-tetrahydropyridine (MPTP) and development of parkinsonism with tremor of 5 and 11 Hz. In healthy monkeys, only 11% (20/174) of the GPe cells and 3% (1/29) of the GPi cells displayed significant 3-19 Hz oscillations. After MPTP treatment, 39% (107/271) of the GPe cells and 43% (26/61) of the GPi cells developed significant oscillations. Oscillation frequencies of single cells after MPTP treatment were bimodally distributed around 7 and 13 Hz. For 10% of the oscillatory cells that were recorded during tremor periods, there was a significant tendency for the tremor and neuronal oscillations to appear simultaneously. Cross-correlation analysis revealed a very low level of correlated activity between pallidal neurons in the normal state; 95.6% (477/499) of the pairs were not correlated, and oscillatory cross-correlograms were found in only 1% (5/499) of the pairs. After MPTP treatment, the correlations increased dramatically, and 40% (432/1080) of the cross-correlograms had significant oscillations, centered around 13-14 Hz. Phase shifts of the cross-correlograms of GPe pairs, but not of GPi, were clustered around 0 degrees. The results illustrate that MPTP treatment changes the pattern of activity and synchronization in the GPe and GPi. These changes are related to the symptoms of Parkinson's disease and especially to the parkinsonian tremor.

Treatment of tremor and dystonia

Treatment of movement disorders has expanded beyond traditional therapies with oral medications to include injection of drugs like botulinum toxin and the use of surgical interventions in cases that do not respond to medical therapy. This article provides an overview to the diagnosis and treatment of tremor and dystonia. The distinguishing features of rest, postural, and kinectic tremor are detailed with medical and surgical modalities for treatment. A discussion of idiopathic and secondary dystonia with focus on diagnosis and medical and surgical treatments encompasses the second part of the article.

Cerebral activation pattern in primary writing tremor

OBJECTIVE

To compare the cerebral activation pattern during writing of patients with writing tremor with healthy controls using functional MRI METHODS: Three patients with writing tremor and 10 healthy controls were examined using a 1.5 Tesla scanner. All subjects performed a paradigm of alternating 30 second periods of rest or writing. For functional imaging 60 EPI multislice data sets were acquired. All images were analyzed using SPM96 software. Data were analyzed for the group of patients with writing tremor and compared with those of the control group.

RESULTS

Both patients with writing tremor and controls showed a significant activation of the contralateral primary sensorimotor cortex, SMA, and area 44. By contrast, motor cortex activation in writing tremor also included the contralateral premotor area (area 6) and ipsilateral prefrontal area (inferior frontal gyrus; areas 10, 44, and 47). Only patients with writing tremor showed a bilateral activation of the parietal lobule (area 40) with a more pronounced activation on the contralateral side. Furthermore, there was a bilateral activation of the cerebellum with a more pronounced area of activation on the ipsilateral side.

CONCLUSIONS

Brain areas activated in writing tremor included activation patterns otherwise typical for both essential tremor and writer's cramp. Therefore a distinct category for writing tremor integrating hallmarks of essential tremor and writer's cramp is proposed.

Kinetic tremor in a reach-to-grasp movement in Parkinson's disease

The aim of this study was to quantify the tremor of the hand during a natural movement (kinetic tremor) in tremor-dominant parkinsonian patients (n = 13). We used a three-dimensional camera system to kinematically analyze rest and kinetic tremors in an unrestrained reach-to-grasp movement, and additional tremor recordings were performed under standard postural and rest conditions using electromyography and accelerometry. The standard analysis showed a highly synchronized tremor with similar frequencies at rest and in sustained postural tasks, with and without loading. A kinematic recording was used to compare rest and action conditions. A strong inhibition of the resting tremor was present at the onset of the movement and reached its peak during deceleration. A kinetic tremor of low amplitude was present in most of the parkinsonian patients, but its occurrence was confined mainly to the terminal periods of the movement. The frequency of kinetic tremor was significantly higher than that at rest, before the onset of the movement in Parkinson's disease, as determined by the kinematic analysis (mean, 5.5 Hz vs 6.5 Hz; p <0.01). Our results confirm similarities between the tremor at rest and the oscillations during a sustained postural task in classic parkinsonian tremor. In contrast to this stable tremor, which seems to be generated by basal ganglia oscillators, a different pathophysiology of oscillations during motion must be considered. The kinetic tremor is most likely related to an enhancement of the physiologic tremor in the terminal phase of the reach-to-grasp movement.

Clinical and electromyographic examinations of Parkinsonian tremor

Background: The clinical presentations of postural Parkinsonian tremor are variable and different types of tremors have been described. The aim of this study was to re-evaluate the clinical and electromyographic (EMG) pattern of different tremors in Parkinsonian patients.Methods: One hundred and ten patients with Parkinsonian tremor were included in the study. Patients were subdivided into four groups according to the presence or absence of postural tremor, in addition to a resting tremor and its EMG pattern. The first group consisted of patients without postural tremor. The second group consisted of patients with fast postural tremor (>7Hz). The third group consisted of patients with slow postural tremor with alternating EMG activity. Patients with slow postural tremor with synchronous EMG activity were included in the fourth group. In each limb position, the tremor of the most involved body part was graded on the Webster Tremor Scale. Surface EMG recordings of the most involved limb in all positions were performed.Results: Postural tremor in addition to the rest one was found in 84% of the patients. The postural tremor was with lower amplitude than the rest one. The frequencies and EMG patterns of the postural tremors were different and correlated with some specific clinical symptoms. Patients with alternating postural tremor had a kinetic and intention tremor in addition.Conclusions: Four different subtypes of Parkinsonian tremor were found according to the presence and type of postural tremor. These subtypes had some differing clinical characteristics and probably different relationships to essential tremor.

Nonparkinsonian tremors

Tremors other than those associated with Parkinson's disease are commonly encountered in clinical practice. The differentiation of tremor subtypes depends primarily on the presence of distinct clinical characteristics and is facilitated by the use of consistent nomenclature. Such differentiation can be helpful in determining the etiology of the tremor and assist in its management. In this review, the authors outline recently proposed changes to classification and review the clinical features, differential diagnosis, and current therapy for nonparkinsonian tremors.

Tremor

Tremor research during the past year has focused on clinical differential diagnosis, and a new clinical classification has been developed. The origin of tremor is thought to depend on unstable central loops, and new coherence data suggest that these often involve the motor cortex. Gabapentine has been assessed for efficacy in some tremors, and deep brain stimulation of the ventrolateral thalamus has been shown to be safer and more effective for severe essential and parkinsonian tremor than thalamotomy.

A novel quantitative method for 3D measurement of Parkinsonian tremor

OBJECTIVE

To demonstrate the usefulness of a three dimensional (3D) motion analysis system for the quantitative measurement of tremor in patients with Parkinson's disease (PD).

METHODS

Six PD patients with hand tremors were studied using a system that employed 3D electromagnetic position sensors to measure the actual, cumulative displacement of the tremoring finger. Patients were studied in different hand positions and activating conditions before and 30, 60, 90 and 120 min after intake of Pramipexole, a dopamine agonist known to reduce tremor. Tremor amplitude and frequency, before and after drug intake, were compared using Mann-Whitney U test and Wilcoxon rank test, respectively.

RESULTS

The motion analysis system allowed discrimination of tremor related events from movement artifact and allowed the calculation of real world movement of the finger tremor despite altered hand positions and orientation. Average 3D tremor frequency ranged from 3.71 to 4.34 Hz. Median tremor amplitude (total distance traveled per 5 s interval) decreased with drug from 4.9 to 1.6 cm for resting tremor, 4.5 to 3.7 cm for postural tremor, 3.4 to 3.3 cm for precision tremor, 10.2 to 3.3 cm for tapping activation and 108.6 to 5.7 cm for counting activation.

CONCLUSIONS

Our method of 3D analysis provides a robust, single quantitative measure of tremor amplitude that is intuitive and likely to reflect the functional impact of tremor. This methodology should be useful in comparing tremor across patients and in measuring the efficacy of therapeutic interventions.

Electrophysiological observations in hereditary parkinsonism-dementia with Lewy body pathology

We studied the only two living affected individuals who are part of a previously reported kindred that expresses a hereditary parkinsonism-dementia syndrome with Lewy body pathology. The electrophysiological characteristics of the hyperkinetic movement disorders in these patients were examined to provide physiological insights into the clinical phenotype of this syndrome. Evaluation of both patients showed 7-9 Hz electromyographic discharges in upper extremity muscles during postural activation, and one patient showed a 4-5 Hz discharge pattern correlating to a rest tremor. Brief (<50 ms) myoclonic electromyographic discharges were seen in both patients, and a time-locked relationship to a focal cortical premovement electroencephalographic potential was elicited in one patient. Somatosensory evoked potentials were not enlarged and long latency reflexes were not enhanced. Electroencephalography was normal in one patient but showed pathologic slow frequencies in the other. The electrophysiological findings show evolution which correlates with an apparent characteristic evolution of hyperkinetic movement disorders that accompanies the severe progression of parkinsonism-dementia in this kindred. These results have implications for the future study of this and similar syndromes.

Multiple oscillators are causing parkinsonian and essential tremor

The tremors of Parkinson's disease (PD) and essential tremor (ET) are traditionally considered to depend on a central oscillator producing rhythmic activation of the motoneurones of all extremities. To test this hypothesis, we have compared electromyographic tremor activity in different muscles of the affected limbs using cross spectral analysis, including coherence and phase. Surface electromyographic recordings from both arms, legs, and the neck were analyzed in 22 patients with PD and 28 patients with ET. Volume conduction between neighboring muscles producing artificial "coherence" has been found to be an important methodologic problem. We have developed a mathematical test to exclude data that could distort the results. According to this test, 10% or 25% of muscle combinations from the same limb had to be excluded from further analysis in PD or ET, respectively. In both, patients with PD and ET, we found a considerable number of muscle combinations oscillating at virtually the same frequency (delta frequency <0.4 Hz) without showing a significant coherence. Thus, the frequency difference between different muscles is not sufficient to measure the correlation between two muscles. Significant coherencies between muscles within the same arm or leg were found in 70% or 90% of patients with PD or ET, respectively, whereas only one patient with PD and not a single patient with ET showed significant coherencies between muscles from different limbs. The phase between coherent muscles of the same arm of patients with PD showed a preference of either a reciprocal alternating pattern for antagonistic muscles in forearm flexor and upper arm extensor as opposed to a co-contraction pattern between the hand flexors and the triceps brachii. In patients with ET such clear differences were lacking. We conclude that multiple oscillators are responsible for the tremor in different extremities of patients with PD and ET. Differences between PD and ET concerning the phase relation within the arm may either be related to the topography within the basal ganglia or to differently involved-spinal pathways.

Voluntary motor reactions: does stimulus appearance prolong the actual tremor period?

Entrainment of voluntary motor responses by ongoing tremors demonstrates the interaction of motor actions simultaneously performed by the same muscle. In the case of physiological tremor, based on experimental data, Kogan (Determining the influence of a bright stimulus on the ultramicrostructure of the movement control process in highly qualified wrestlers, Tesisi 7, Nautschnometoditscheskoi konferenzii respublik Pribaltiki i Belorussi po woprosam sportivnoi trenirovki, Riga, 1978:56-57) postulated a direct and immediate impact of a 'go' stimulus on the actual tremor cycle. This paper represents a critical replication of this investigation, showing that the effect reported can be simply explained as an inherent statistical consequence of the experimental paradigm.

Animal models of tremor

Animal models of tremor have been widely used in experimental neurology, because they are an indispensable requirement for understanding the pathophysiology of human tremor disorders and the development of new therapeutic agents. This review focuses on three approaches to produce tremor in animals (application of tremorgenic drugs, experimental central nervous system lesions, study of genetic mutants) and their use in simulating tremor syndromes of humans. Whereas harmaline induces a postural/kinetic tremor in animals that shares some features with human essential tremor/enhanced physiological tremor, MPTP tremor is the best model available for rest tremor in people. The tremor following experimental lesion of the ventromedial tegmentum in primates closely resembles Holmes tremor in humans, whereas cerebellar intention tremor is mimicked by cooling of the lateral cerebellar nuclei. The "campus syndrome," discovered in a breed of Pietrain pigs, might be a useful model of human orthostatic tremor. However, no animal model has yet been generated that exactly recreates all features of any of the known tremor disorders in humans. Problems encountered when comparing tremor in animals and humans include differing tremor frequencies and the uncertainty, if specific transmitter abnormalities/central nervous system lesions seen in animal tremor models are characteristic for their human counterparts. The search for adequate tremor models continues.

Function of the cerebellum in Parkinsonian rest tremor and Holmes' tremor

We describe a patient who developed Parkinson's disease (PD) 17 years after resection of his right cerebellum because of a Lindau tumor. He showed a classic 4.3-Hz resting tremor on the left side but a 3.1-Hz resting, postural, and intention tremor on the right side compatible with midbrain tremor (Holmes' tremor). We conclude that the generator of the tremor in PD cannot be located within the olivocerebellar loop. The cerebellum, however, seems to modulate the tremor frequency of parkinsonian rest tremor and may prevent the rest tremor from transforming into a postural and goal-directed tremor.

Validity of family history data on essential tremor

BACKGROUND

In family studies of essential tremor (ET), valid data on the presence of ET in relatives of probands with ET is important. The family history method uses information obtained by interviewing probands with ET to identify ET in their relatives. The validation of this method by direct examination of the relatives has not been performed.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the validity of family history data on ET in families in which the proband has ET.

METHODS

ET cases (probands) and their respective relatives were enrolled in a genetic study of ET in Washington Heights-Inwood, New York. Each underwent a tremor interview and videotaped examination. Two neurologists rated the severity of tremor and assigned diagnoses (ET versus normal). Probands were asked to identify their relatives who had ET. The validity of the probands' responses was tested against the neurologists' diagnoses.

RESULTS

There were 206 subjects: 46 ET cases and 160 relatives. Twelve (7.5%) of 160 relatives were diagnosed with ET (four definite ET and eight probable ET). Probands with ET reported that two of these 12 had tremor (sensitivity of probands' report = 16.7%). Six of the 12 affected relatives (50.0%) reported their own tremor. The probands reported that one of 136 of their unaffected relatives had tremor (specificity of probands' report = 99.3%).

CONCLUSIONS

For family studies of ET, information on reportedly unaffected relatives is of limited use given the low sensitivity of family history data. The neurologic examination remains the only valid means of ascertaining cases of ET among relatives.