Detection of monodisperse aggregates of a recombinant amelogenin by dynamic light scattering

Dynamic light scattering study of an amelogenin gel-like matrix in vitro

Amelogenin self-assembly is critical for the structural organization of apatite crystals during enamel mineralization. The aim of the present study was to investigate the influence of temperature and protein concentration on the aggregation of amelogenin nanospheres at high protein concentrations (>4.4 mg ml-1) in order to obtain an insight into the mechanism of amelogenin self-assembly to form higher-order structures. Amelogenins were extracted from enamel scrapings of unerupted mandibular pig molars. The dynamics of protein solutions were measured using dynamic light scattering (DLS) as a function of temperature and at acidic pH. At pH 4-5.5, three kinds of particles were observed, ranging in size from 3 to 80 nm. At pH 6, heating the solution above approximately 30 degrees C resulted in a drastic change in the solution transparency, from clear to opaque. Low pH showed no aggregation effect, whilst solutions at a slightly acidic pH exhibited diffusion dynamics associated with the onset of aggregation. In addition, at the same temperature range, the hydrodynamic radii of the aggregates increased drastically, by almost one order of magnitude. These observations support the view that hydrophobic interactions are the primary driving force for the pH- and temperature-sensitive self-assembly of amelogenin particles in a 'gel-like' matrix. The trend of self-assembly in a 'gel-like matrix' is similar to that in solution.

Histidine tag fusion increases expression levels of active recombinant amelogenin in Escherichia coli

Amelogenin is a dental enamel matrix protein involved in formation of dental enamel. In this study, we have expressed two different recombinant murine amelogenins in Escherichia coli: the untagged rM179, and the histidine tagged rp(H)M180, identical to rM179 except that it carries the additional N-terminal sequence MRGSHHHHHHGS. The effects of the histidine tag on expression levels, and on growth properties of the amelogenin expressing cells were studied. Purification of a crude protein extract containing rp(H)M180 was also carried out using IMAC and reverse-phase HPLC. The results of this study showed clearly that both growth properties and amelogenin expression levels were improved for E. coli cells expressing the histidine tagged amelogenin rp(H)M180, compared to cells expressing the untagged amelogenin rM179. The positive effect of the histidine tag on amelogenin expression is proposed to be due to the hydrophilic nature of the histidine tag, generating a more hydrophilic amelogenin, which is more compatible with the host cell. Human osteoblasts treated with the purified rp(H)M180 showed increased levels of secreted osteocalcin, compared to untreated cells. This response was similar to cells treated with enamel matrix derivate, mainly composed by amelogenin, suggesting that the recombinant protein is biologically active. Thus, the histidine tag favors expression and purification of biologically active recombinant amelogenin.

Co-operative mineralization and protein self-assembly in amelogenesis: silica mineralization and assembly of recombinant amelogenins in vitro

An amorphous silica mineralization technique was used to produce inorganic/protein composites to elucidate the structure and mechanism of formation of amelogenin assemblies, which may play an important role in regulating enamel structure during the initial stages of amelogenesis. Full-length recombinant amelogenins from mouse (rM179) and pig (rP172) were investigated along with key degradation products (rM166 and native P148) lacking the hydrophilic C terminus found in parent molecules. The resulting products were examined using transmission electron microscopy and/or small-angle X-ray scattering. Using protein concentrations of 0.1-3 mg ml-1, large monodisperse spheres of remarkably similar mean diameters were observed using rM179 (124+/-4 nm) and rP172 (126+/-7 nm). These spheres also exhibited 'internal structure', comprising nearly spherical monodisperse particles of approximately 20 nm in diameter. In the presence of rM166, P148, and bovine serum albumin (control), large unstructured and randomly shaped particles (250-1000 nm) were observed. Without added protein, large dense spherical particles of silica (mean approximately 500 nm) lacking internal structure were produced. These findings demonstrate that full-length amelogenins have the ability to form higher-order structures, whereas amelogenins that lack the hydrophilic C terminus do not. The results also suggest that full-length amelogenin can guide the formation of organized mineralized structures through co-operative interactions between assembling protein and forming mineral.

Expression and characterization of a Rana pipiens amelogenin protein

Amelogenin, the major protein of developing enamel matrix, controls enamel crystal growth via unique supermolecular features. While much has been contributed to our understanding of mammalian amelogenin function, little is known about how amelogenin and its unique physico-chemical features have evolved among vertebrates. Here we report, for the first time, amphibian amelogenin recombinant protein expression and characterization in Rana pipiens. In order to characterize R. pipiens amelogenin, the newly discovered amelogenin coding sequence was amplified, subcloned, and expressed in Eshcerichia coli. Our newly generated R. pipiens amelogenin-specific antisera resolved a major 19-kDa band on western blots of frog tooth extracts and revealed an enamel organ tissue-specific localization pattern using immunohistochemistry. Using mass spectroscopy, a single major compound with a molecular weight of 21.6 kDa was detected, which corresponded to the amino acid sequence-based molecular weight prediction of the His fusion recombinant protein. Dynamic light scattering studies resolved 41-nm radius subunits compared with 14-nm radius subunits from mouse recombinant amelogenin controls. Transmission electron microscopy revealed defined spherical subunits in R. pipiens matrix self-assembly in contrast with a homogeneous 'stippled' matrix in mouse amelogenin matrix self-assembly. Our data suggest that R. pipiens amelogenin is distinguished from mammalian amelogenins by a number of unique physico-chemical properties which may be related to specific modes of crystal formation in frog enamel.

Amelogenin Supra-Molecular Assembly in vitro Compared with the Architecture of the Forming Enamel Matrix

Tooth enamel is formed in the extracellular space within an organic matrix enriched in amelogenin proteins. Amelogenin nanosphere assembly is a key factor in controlling the oriented and organized growth of enamel apatite crystals. Recently, we have reported the formation of higher ordered structures resulting from organized association and self-orientation of amelogenin nanospheres in vitro. This remarkable hierarchical organization includes self-assembly of amelogenin molecules into subunits of 4-6 nm in diameter followed by their assembly to form nanospheres of 15-25 nm in radii. Chains of >100 nm length are then formed as the result of nanosphere association. These linear arrays of nanospheres assemble to form the microribbons that are hundreds of microns in length, tens of microns in width, and a few microns in thickness. Here, we review the step by step process of amelogenin self-assembly during the formation of microribbon structures in vitro. Assembly properties of selected amelogenins lacking the hydrophilic C terminus will then be reviewed. We will consider amelogenin as a template for the organized growth of crystals in vitro. Finally, we will compare the structures formed in vitro with globular and periodic structures observed earlier, in vivo, by different sample preparation conditions. We propose that the alignment of amelogenin nanospheres into long chains is evident in vivo, and is an important indication for the function of this protein in controlling the oriented and elongated growth of apatite crystals during enamel biomineralization.

Protein–Protein Interactions of the Developing Enamel Matrix

Extracellular matrix proteins control the formation of the inorganic component of hard tissues including bone, dentin, and enamel. The structural proteins expressed primarily in the enamel matrix are amelogenin, ameloblastin, enamelin, and amelotin. Other proteins, like biglycan, are also present in the enamel matrix as well as in other mineralizing and nonmineralizing tissues of mammals. In addition, the presence of sulfated enamel proteins, and "tuft" proteins has been examined and discussed in relation to enamel formation. The structural proteins of the enamel matrix must have specific protein-protein interactions to produce a matrix capable of directing the highly ordered structure of the enamel crystallites. Protein-protein interactions are also likely to occur between the secreted enamel proteins and the plasma membrane of the enamel producing cells, the ameloblasts. Such protein-protein interactions are hypothesized to influence the secretion of enamel proteins, establish short-term order of the forming matrix, and to mediate feedback signals to the transcriptional machinery of these cells. Membrane-bound proteins identified in ameloblasts, and which interact with the structural enamel proteins, include Cd63 (cluster of differentiation 63 antigen), annexin A2 (Anxa2), and lysosomal-associated glycoprotein 1 (Lamp1). These and related data help explain the molecular and cellular mechanisms responsible for the removal of the organic enamel matrix during the events of enamel mineralization, and how the enamel matrix influences its own fate through signaling initiated at the cell surface. The knowledge gained from enamel developmental studies may lead to better dental and nondental materials, or materials inspired by Nature. These data will be critical to scientists, engineers, and dentists in their pursuits to regenerate an entire tooth. For tooth regeneration to become a reality, the protein-protein interactions involving the key dental proteins must be identified and understood. The scope of this review is to discuss the current understanding of protein-protein interactions of the developing enamel matrix, and relate this knowledge to enamel biomineralization.

Tooth developmental biology: disruptions to enamel-matrix assembly and its impact on biomineralization

Dental enamel is a composite bioceramic material that is the hardest tissue in the vertebrate body, containing long, thin crystallites of substituted hydroxyapatite (HAP). Over a lifetime of an organism, enamel functions under repeated and immense loads, generally without catastrophic failure. Enamel is a product of ectoderm-derived cells called ameloblasts. Recent investigations on the formation of enamel using cell and molecular approaches are now being coupled to biomechanical investigations at the nanoscale and mesoscale levels. For amelogenin, the principal structural protein for forming enamel, we have identified two domains that are required for its proper self-assembly into supramolecular structures referred to as nanospheres. Nanospheres are believed to control HAP crystal habit. Other structural proteins of the enamel matrix include ameloblastin and enamelin, but little is known about their biological importance. Transgenic animals have been prepared to investigate the effect of overexpression of wild-type or mutated enamel proteins on the developing enamel matrix. Amelogenin transgenes were engineered to contain deletions to either of the two self-assembly domains and these alterations produced significant defects in the enamel. Additional transgenic animal lines have been prepared and studied and each gives additional insights into the mechanisms for enamel biofabrication. This study summarizes the observed enamel phenotypes of recently derived transgenic animals. These data are being used to help define the role of each of the enamel structural proteins in enamel and study how each of these proteins impact on enamel biomineralization.

Amelogenin control over apatite crystal growth is affected by the pH and degree of ionic saturation

OBJECTIVE

To study the mechanisms which promote the interactions of amelogenin proteins with the forming mineral to establish suitable conditions for the biomimetic synthesis of enamel in vitro.

DESIGN

Saturated calcium phosphate solutions were used in conjunction with recombinant amelogenin proteins to induce mineral formation on glass-ceramics substrates containing oriented fluoroapatite crystals (FAP). The height of mineral layers formed on these substrates within 24 h was measured by atomic force microscopy (AFM).

EXPERIMENTAL VARIABLES

The effect of protein concentration, pH and degree of saturation (DS) on the growth of apatite mineral was evaluated. Mineralization experiments were performed at 0, 0.4 and 1.6 mg/ml amelogenin concentrations. Mineralization solutions were used at pH values of 6.5, 7.4, 8.0 and 8.8 and DS of calcium and phosphate between 9 and 13.

OUTCOME MEASURE

Height and morphology of mineralized layer formed on glass-ceramic substrates as determined from AFM measurements.

RESULTS

Homogeneous nucleation and crystal growth of thin layers on the FAP were observed, when calcium and phosphate ions were added. The height of these layers grown on (001) planes of FAP was strongly dependent on the protein concentration and pH. At concentrations of 0 and 0.4 mg/ml crystal grew 5-15 nm on the FAP, while they grew approximately to 200 nm at 1.6 mg/ml. The enhanced crystal growth was observed only at pH 6.5, 7.4 and 8.0, while layers only 20 nm thick were obtained at pH 8.8. An increase in DS resulted in uncontrolled growth of calcium phosphate mineral covering large areas of the substrate.

CONCLUSIONS

Protein concentration, pH and the saturation of the mineralizing solution need to be considered carefully to provide suitable conditions for amelogenin-guided growth of apatite crystals.

Molecular evolution of amelogenin in mammals

An evolutionary analysis of mammalian amelogenin, the major protein of forming enamel, was conducted by comparison of 26 sequences (including 14 new ones) representative of the main mammalian lineages. Amelogenin shows highly conserved residues in the hydrophilic N- and C-terminal regions. The central hydrophobic region (most of exon 6) is more variable, but it has conserved a high amount of proline and glutamine located in triplets, PXQ, indicating that these residues play an important role. This region evolves more rapidly, and is less constrained, than the other well-conserved regions, which are subjected to strong constraints. The comparison of the substitution rates in relation to the CpG richness confirmed that the highly conserved regions are subjected to strong selective pressures. The amino acids located at important sites and the residues known to lead to amelogenesis imperfecta when substituted were present in all sequences examined. Evolutionary analysis of the variable region of exon 6 points to a particular zone, rich in either amino acid insertion or deletion. We consider this region a hot spot of mutation for the mammalian amelogenin. In this region, numerous triplet repeats (PXQ) have been inserted recently and independently in five lineages, while most of the hydrophobic exon 6 region probably had its origin in several rounds of triplet insertions, early in vertebrate evolution. The putative ancestral DNA sequence of the mammalian amelogenin was calculated using a maximum likelihood approach. The putative ancestral protein was composed of 177 residues. It already contained all important amino acid positions known to date, its hydrophobic variable region was rich in proline and glutamine, and it contained triplet repeats PXQ as in the modern sequences.

Supramolecular assembly of amelogenin nanospheres into birefringent microribbons

Although both tooth enamel and bone are composed of organized assemblies of carbonated apatite crystals, enamel is unusual in that it does not contain collagen nor does it remodel. Self-assembly of amelogenin protein into nanospheres has been recognized as a key factor in controlling the oriented and elongated growth of carbonated apatite crystals during dental enamel biomineralization. We report the in vitro formation of birefringent microribbon structures that were generated through the supramolecular assembly of amelogenin nanospheres. These microribbons have diffraction patterns that indicate a periodic structure of crystalline units along the long axis. The growth of apatite crystals orientated along the c axis and parallel to the long axes of the microribbons was observed in vitro. The linear arrays (chains) of nanospheres observed as intermediate states before the microribbon formation give an important indication as to the function of amelogenin in controlling the oriented growth of apatite crystals during enamel mineralization.

Microparticles Shed from Different Antigen-Presenting Cells Display an Individual Pattern of Surface Molecules and a Distinct Potential of Allogeneic T-Cell Activation

Various cells such as platelets, lymphocytes, endothelial cells, red blood cells and monocytes do release surface-derived microparticles (mps). We analysed mp isolated from supernatants of cultured antigen-presenting human cells (APCs) and human cell lines. Particle sizing by dynamic light scattering revealed a characteristic size of the particles ranging from 80 nm to 300 nm in viable cells and from 400 nm to 1200 nm in irradiated cells. Employing flow-cytometry, we observed partly an altered surface protein composition of the mp compared to their cellular source. Mp originating from dendritic cells (DCs) differed in their surface composition from those released from monocytes and monocyte-derived macrophages. In functional assays, these mp stimulated alloreactive T-cells. The treatment of the cells with either UV-B or lipopolysaccharide strongly influenced the quantity, the immunostimulatory features and the surface composition of the mp. Mp from apoptotic macrophages were able to reduce the stimulatory capacity of vital macrophages but not of DC. Apoptotic mps from DC, on the other hand, were always stimulatory. This is the first report regarding the study of mp released from DC and compared with those released from other APC.

Interactions of amelogenins with octacalcium phosphate crystal faces are dose dependent

Amelogenins, the major protein components of the enamel extracellular matrix, are postulated to be involved in controlling the elongated and oriented growth of enamel carbonated apatite crystals. In order to clarify the functional role of amelogenin during the early stage of enamel biomineralization, octacalcium phosphate (OCP) crystals, known to be potent precursors of hydroxyapatite, were grown in 1-10% (w/w) native bovine and two recombinant murine amelogenins. Amelogenins were solution-like at 1% and formed gel at 10%, while 5% amelogenins became gel after reaction and it was inhomogeneous and porous. Morphological changes of OCP crystals were evaluated as the function of amelogenin concentration by analyzing the mean values of length, width, thickness, their reduction ratios (L/Lc, W/Wc, T/Tc) as well as L/W and W/T ratios. Length, width, and thickness decreased in a does-dependent manner. Length decreased almost linearly in 1%-10%, whereas width decreased drastically in 1%-5% while the decrease from 5% to 10% was small. As a result, elongated morphology of OCP crystal was most emphasized in 5% bovine amelogenins and rM166 and 2%-5% rM179. The size reduction was in the order of W/Wc < L/Lc < T/Tc. We therefore concluded that amelogenin interaction with crystal faces was in the order (010) > (001) > (100). At all concentrations, W/ Wc was significantly the smallest. This indicated that the primary role of amelogenin was to decrease the width of OCP by blocking the hydrophobic (010) faces. We suggest that the drastic decrease of crystal width is the result of interaction of the densely packed nanospheres in 5%-10% amelogenin.

Enamel structure properties controlled by engineered proteins in transgenic mice

Amelogenin protein has regulatory effects on enamel biofabrication in mammalian tooth. Using teeth obtained from transgenic mice that express two separate protein-engineered versions of amelogenins, we made structure-nanomechanical properties correlations and showed 21% hardness and 24% elastic modulus degradation compared with the age-matched wildtype littermates. We attribute the inferior properties to the disorganization of the protein matrix resulting in defective mineral formation.

INTRODUCTION

Enamel is a bioceramic initiated by the biosynthesis of a complex mixture of proteins that undergoes self-assembly to produce a super molecular ensemble that controls the nucleation and habit of the crystalline mineral phase. Ultimately, the inorganic crystals grow to almost fully replace the organic phase. This biofabrication process occurs at physiologic conditions of pH, temperature, pressure, and ion concentration and results in the hardest tissue in the vertebrate body, with the largest and longest substituted-hydroxyapatite crystals known to biomineralizing systems. The most abundant protein of forming mammalian enamel, amelogenin, has been shown to have a significant regulatory effect on this complex process.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this work, we present the effect of protein engineering of amelogenin on the mechanical properties of the resultant mouse enamel. We have produced two types of transgenic animals that express separate versions of amelogenin proteins that lack the required self-assembly domains. The resultant matured enamel was extensively characterized for its mechanical properties at the nanoscale by means of nanoindentation and atomic force microscopy (AFM). These techniques have enabled us to probe the mechanical properties that are representative of a single enamel rod.

RESULTS

Our nanoindentation measurements have revealed that the altered amelogenin with dysfunctional self-assembly properties resulted in a degradation by as much as 21% in hardness and 24% in elastic modulus compared with the age-matched wildtype littermates. Furthermore, the enamel formed by these defective proteins is found to display a decrease in indentation surface pile-up volume by up to 32%.

CONCLUSIONS

We attribute these inferior mechanical properties for the enamel grown by the engineered amelogenins to result from the disorganization of the nanospheres formed in the protein matrix starting at the mineral nucleation stage with a consequential alteration to the fully grown mineral component. By engineering the properties of proteins that contribute to the nanoscale level of hierarchy in enamel biomineralization, it is possible to regulate the properties of the resulting bioceramic at the mesoscale level of the tissue.

Photon correlation spectroscopy investigations of proteins

Physical principles of photon correlation spectroscopy (PCS), mathematical treatment of the PCS data (converting autocorrelation functions to distribution functions or average characteristics), and PCS applications to study proteins and other biomacromolecules in aqueous media are described and analysed. The PCS investigations of conformational changes in protein molecules, their aggregation itself or in consequence of interaction with other molecules or organic (polymers) and inorganic (e.g. fumed silica) fine particles as well as the influence of low molecular compounds (surfactants, drugs, salts, metal ions, etc.) reveal unique capability of the PCS techniques for elucidation of important native functions of proteins and other biomacromolecules (DNA, RNA, etc.) or microorganisms (Escherichia coli, Pseudomonas putida, Dunaliella viridis, etc.). Special attention is paid to the interaction of proteins with fumed oxides and the impact of polymers and fine oxide particles on the motion of living flagellar microorganisms analysed by means of PCS.

Analysis of hydroxyapatite surface coverage by amelogenin nanospheres following the Langmuir model for protein adsorption

The assembly of amelogenin protein into nanospheres is postulated to be a key factor in the stability of enamel extracellular matrix framework, which provides the scaffolding for the initial enamel apatite crystals to nucleate and grow. Adsorption isotherms were evaluated in order to investigate the nature of interactions of amelogenin nanospheres with hydroxyapaite crystals in solution, where their assembly status and particle size distribution are defined. We report that the adsorption isotherm of a recombinant mouse amelogenin (rM179) on synthetic hydroxyapatite crystals can be described using a Langmuir model indicating that amelogenin nanospheres adsorb onto the surface of apatite crystals as binding units with defined adsorption sites. The adsorption affinity and the maximum adsorption sites were 19.7 x 10(5) L/mol and 6.09 x 10(-7) mol/m2, respectively, with an r2 value of 0.99. Knowing the composition and particle size distribution of amelogenin nanospheres under the condition of adsorption experiments, we have calculated the number of nanospheres and the crystal surface area covered by each population of nanospheres at their maximum adsorption. It was found that total maximum binding covers 64% of the area unit. This observation supports the speculation that amelogenin binding onto apatite surface is selective and occurs only at certain sites.

Limited proteolysis of amelogenin: toward understanding the proteolytic processes in enamel extracellular matrix

This article is a short review of our recent study on controlled proteolysis of amelogenins by a series of commercially available proteinases as well as the tooth-specific metalloproteinase enamelysin. A limited proteolysis approach and mass spectrometry were applied in order to determine the surface accessibility of conserved domains of amelogenin nanospheres. Furthermore, this study was aimed at exploring the factors that affect the activity of enamel proteases to process amelogenins and at providing insight into the mechanisms of amelogenin degradation during amelogenesis. We found that, under limited conditions, certain amino acid residues at both the C- and N-termini of amelogenin are accessible to proteolytic action by a series of proteinases, suggesting that these regions are exposed on the surface of amelogenin nanospheres. Recombinant enamelysin cleaved amelogenin at the C-terminal region, showing a preference of the enzyme to cleave the S/M and F/S bonds. This result of enamelysin activity on amelogenin explains the abundance of the p148 (20k) pig amelogenin during the secretory stage of amelogenesis.

Pig amelogenin gene expresses a unique exon 4

The pig amelogenin gene was isolated from a Lambda genomic library, and a 6.3 kb SalI/XbaI restriction fragment, inclusive of exons 3 through 7, was subcloned into a plasmid vector. DNA sequencing revealed two putative exon 4 sequences. The derived amino acid sequence of exon 4a, KSGRWGARLTAFVSSVQ, had previously been identified in a 190-amino-acid amelogenin isoform by protein sequencing. Exon 4b encoded the peptide DLYLEAIRIDRTAF, which is homologous to exon 4-encoded segments reported for human, mouse, and rat. Oligonucleotides from both of these exons were used to amplify cDNA generated from developing teeth. Amplification products were analyzed by agarose gel electrophoresis, cloned, and characterized by DNA sequencing. Exon 4a was found in transcripts encoding amelogenin isoforms having 190 and 73 amino acids. Exon 4b was found only in apparent splicing intermediates that retained intron 3, but was not detected in any final mRNA transcripts. Pig amelogenin having apparent molecular mass of 23 kD were isolated from the enamel matrix and characterized by mass spectrometry. Two mass values, 18,512.5, and 18,571.2 Da, were measured that match the values predicted for the 162-amino-acid cleavage product of the 173-amino-acid amelogenin, and the 165-amino-acid cleavage product of the 190-amino-acid amelogenin, which includes 17 amino acids encoded by exon 4a. We conclude that the pig amelogenin gene expresses a unique exon 4 that is not homologous to, or evolved from, the exon 4 segment expressed in humans and rodents.

Modification of calcium-phosphate coatings on titanium by recombinant amelogenin

Amelogenin proteins, the principal components of the developing dental enamel extracellular matrix, have been postulated to facilitate the elongated and oriented growth of the carbonated apatite crystals during enamel formation. We previously reported that amelogenin caused modulation of apatite crystals nucleated on a bioactive glass (Bioglass(R)) in vitro. Here, the effects of amelogenin on the growth morphology of calcium-phosphate crystals nucleated on a titanium surface were investigated in order to gain a better understanding of the role of amelogenins during enamel biomineralization and to explore their potential application in the design and development of novel biomaterials. The dose-dependent effects of a recombinant mouse amelogenin (rM179) were found to be different from those of bovine serum albumin, which significantly inhibited apatite crystal growth and caused the octacalcium phosphate (OCP) crystals to change from a plate-like shape to a curved shape, indicating a general inhibitory effect. The effects of rM179 on the crystal growth of OCP at 12.5-100 microg/mL and of apatite at 50 microg/mL were insignificant while the apatite crystals were remarkably elongated along their c-axes upon the use of 100 microg/mL of rM179. The unique modulation of the calcium-phosphate coatings on titanium by rM179 supports the view that amelogenins have a great potential for applications designed to develop novel biomimetic materials.

Assessment of enamelysin (MMP-20) selectivity to three peptide bonds on amelogenin sequence

Recent studies have highlighted the potential role of the metalloproteinase enamelysin (MMP-20) in controlling some of the most critical stages during enamel development. This study was aimed to assess the selectivity of enamelysin to the three most abundant cleavage sites on the amelogenin sequence, and to gain insight into the factors that control the pattern of amelogenin processing during enamel mineralization. Three deca-peptides with sequences based on pig amelogenin and including the proteolytic cleavage sites W/L, S/M, and P/A were synthesized as substrates. Statistical analysis revealed no significant differences in the rates of cleavage among the three peptides, indicating comparable selectivity of enamelysin for these peptide bonds. Considering the selective appearance of amelogenin proteolytic products, we suggest that amelogenin folding and assembly are the primary factors in controlling the pattern of its proteolysis during the secretory stage of enamel development.

A new frameshift mutation encoding a truncated amelogenin leads to X-linked amelogenesis imperfecta

The amelogenin proteins are the most abundant organic components of developing dental enamel. Their importance for the proper mineralization of enamel is evident from the association between previously identified mutations in the X-chromosomal gene that encodes them and the enamel defect amelogenesis imperfecta. In this investigation, an adult male presenting with a severe hypoplastic enamel phenotype was found to have a single base deletion at the codon for amino acid 110 of the X-chromosomal 175-amino acid amelogenin protein. The proband's mother, who also has affected enamel, carries the identical deletion on one of her X-chromosomes, while the father has both normal enamel and DNA sequence. This frameshift mutation deletes part of the coding region for the repetitive portion of amelogenin as well as the hydrophilic tail, replacing them with a 47-amino acid segment containing nine cysteine residues. While greater than 60% of the protein is predicted to be intact, the severity of this phenotype illustrates the importance of the C-terminal region of the amelogenin protein for the formation of enamel with normal thickness.

Analysis of self-assembly and apatite binding properties of amelogenin proteins lacking the hydrophilic C-terminal

Amelogenins, the major protein component of the mineralizing enamel extracellular matrix, are critical for normal enamel formation as documented in the linkage studies of a group of inherited disorders, with defective enamel formation, called Amelogenesis imperfecta. Recent cases of Amelogenesis imperfecta include mutations that resulted in truncated amelogenin protein lacking the hydrophilic C-terminal amino acids. Current advances in knowledge on amelogenin structure, nanospheres assembly and their effects on crystal growth have supported the hypothesis that amelogenin nanospheres provide the organized microstructure for the initiation and modulated growth of enamel apatite crystals. In order to evaluate the function of the conserved hydrophilic C-terminal telopeptide during enamel biomineralization, the present study was designed to analyze the self-assembly and apatite binding behavior of amelogenin proteins and their isoforms lacking the hydrophilic C-terminal. We applied dynamic light scattering to investigate the size distribution of amelogenin nanospheres formed by a series of native and recombinant proteins. In addition, the apatite binding properties of these amelogenins were examined using commercially available hydroxyapatite crystals. Amelogenins lacking the carboxy-terminal (native P161 and recombinant rM166) formed larger nanospheres than those formed by their full-length precursors: native P173 and recombinant rM179. These data suggest that after removal of the hydrophilic carboxy-terminal segment further association of the nanospheres takes place through hydrophobic interactions. The affinity of amelogenins lacking the carboxy-terminal regions to apatite crystals was significantly lower than their parent amelogenins. These structure-functional analyses suggest that the hydrophilic carboxy-terminal plays critical functional roles in mineralization of enamel and that the lack of this segment causes abnormal mineralization.

Elongated growth of octacalcium phosphate crystals in recombinant amelogenin gels under controlled ionic flow

Amelogenin proteins constitute the primary structural entity of the extracellular protein framework of the developing enamel matrix. Recent data on the interactions of amelogenin with calcium phosphate crystals support the hypothesis that amelogenins control the oriented and elongated growth of enamel carbonate apatite crystals. To exploit further the molecular mechanisms involved in amelogenin-calcium phosphate mineral interactions, we conducted in vitro experiments to examine the effect of amelogenin on synthetic octacalcium phosphate (OCP) crystals. A 10% (wt/vol) recombinant murine amelogenin (rM179, rM166) gel was constructed with nanospheres of about 10- to 20-nm diameter, as observed by atomic force microscopy. The growth of OCP was modulated uniquely in 10% rM179 and rM166 amelogenin gels, regardless of the presence of the hydrophilic C-terminal residues. Fibrous crystals grew with large length-to-width ratio and small width-to-thickness ratio. Both rM179 and rM166 enhanced the growth of elongated OCP crystals, suggesting a relationship to the initial elongated growth of enamel crystals.

Calcium binding of enamel proteins and their derivatives with emphasis on the calcium-binding domain of porcine sheathlin

Dental enamel is believed to form by the transfer of ions from solution, primarily calcium, phosphate, hydroxyl and carbonate, to the surface of solid-state mineral. Such precipitation phenomena can be controlled by regulating the degree of saturation of the solution with respect to the potential solid phases that can form. The concentration of free calcium is the factor that most affects the degree of saturation for calcium hydroxyapatite, and its buffering by calcium-binding proteins has been proposed as the mechanism that determines the enamel mineral structure. In this study, Stains-all staining was used to identify and isolate calcium-binding proteins from the enamel matrix, and determine their structures and association constants for calcium. Proteolytic cleavage fragments derived from the C-terminus of sheathlin, having apparent molecular weights of 13, 15, 27 and 29 kDa, were characterized by amino-terminal protein sequencing, amino acid analysis, and sugar, phosphate and sulphate determinations. Sheathlin C-terminal cleavage products were shown to have no N-linked glycosylations or phosphorylated amino acids, but Pro(350) was hydroxylated, and there was one sulphated O-linked glycosylation at Thr(386), containing galactose and N-acetylgalactosamine. The calcium-binding association constants for enamel proteins ranged from a high of 1.2 x 10(4) M(-1) to a low of 4.4x10(1) M(-1). The relative strengths of binding in order of decreasing affinity were: 13 and 15 kDa calcium-binding domain of sheathlin >27 and 29 kDa calcium-binding proteins >32 kDa enamelin >89 kDa enamelin >6.5 kDa, 25 kDa, 23 kDa, 20 kDa, 13 kDa, 5.3 kDa amelogenins. It is concluded that if enamel proteins have similar calcium-binding properties in vivo as have been measured in vitro, they would tend to buffer the free calcium ion concentration in enamel fluid.

Progressive accretion of amelogenin molecules during nanospheres assembly revealed by atomic force microscopy

Amelogenin proteins, the principal components of the developing dental enamel matrix, self-assemble to form nanosphere structures that are believed to function as structural components directly involved in the matrix mediated enamel biomineralization. The self-assembly behavior of a recombinant murine amelogenin (rM179) was investigated by atomic force microscopy (AFM) for further understanding the roles of amelogenin proteins in dental enamel biomineralization. Recombinant rM179 amelogenin was dissolved in a pH 7.4 Tris-HCl buffer at concentrations ranging from 12.5 to 300 microg/ml. The solutions were adsorbed on mica, fixed with Karnovsky fixative and rinsed thoroughly with water for atomic force microscopy (AFM). At low concentrations (12.5-50 microg/ml), nanospheres with diameters varying from 7 to 53 nm were identified while at concentrations ranging between 100-300 microg/ml the size distribution was significantly narrowed to be steadily between 10 and 25 nm in diameter. These nanospheres were observed to be the basic building blocks of both engineered rM179 gels and of the developing enamel extracellular matrix. The stable 15-20-nm nanosphere structures generated in the presence of high concentrations of amelogenins were postulated to be of great importance in facilitating the highly organized ultrastructural microenvironment required for the formation of initial enamel apatite crystallites.

Regulated gene expression dictates enamel structure and tooth function

Enamel is a complex bioceramic tissue. In its final form, enamel is a reflection of the unique molecular and cellular activities occurring during organogenesis. From the ectodermal origins of ameloblasts, their gene activity and protein expression profiles exist for the sole purpose of producing a mineralized shell, almost entirely devoid of protein, deposited over the 'bone-like' dentine. The interface between enamel and dentine is referred to as the dentine enamel junction and it is also unique in its biology. This review article is narrow in its scope. We restrict our review to selected advances in our understanding of the genetic, molecular and structural aspects of enamel biology. We present a model of enamel formation that relates gene expression to the assembly of an extracellular protein matrix that in turn controls the structural hierarchy and mechanical aspects of enamel and the tooth organ.

Amelogenins: assembly, processing and control of crystal morphology

The remarkable properties of enamel crystals and their arrangements in an extraordinary micro-architecture are clear indications that the processes of crystal nucleation and growth in the extracellular matrix are highly controlled. The major extracellular events involved in enamel formation are: (a) delineation of space by the secretory ameloblasts and the dentino-enamel junction; (b) self-assembly of amelogenin proteins to form the supramolecular structural framework; (c) transportation of calcium and phosphate ions by the ameloblasts resulting in a supersaturated solution; (d) nucleation of apatite crystallites; and (e) elongated growth of the crystallites. Finally, during the 'maturation' step, rapid growth and thickening of the crystallites take place, which is concomitant with progressive degradation and eventual removal of the enamel extracellular matrix components (mainly amelogenins). This latter stage during which physical hardening of enamel occurs is perhaps unique to dental enamel. We have focused our in vitro studies on three major extracellular events: matrix assembly, matrix processing and control of crystal growth. This paper summarizes current knowledge on the assembly, processing and effect on crystal morphology by amelogenin proteins. The correlation between these three events and putative functional roles for amelogenin protein are discussed.

Amelogenin-deficient mice display an amelogenesis imperfecta phenotype

Dental enamel is the hardest tissue in the body and cannot be replaced or repaired, because the enamel secreting cells are lost at tooth eruption. X-linked amelogenesis imperfecta (MIM 301200), a phenotypically diverse hereditary disorder affecting enamel development, is caused by deletions or point mutations in the human X-chromosomal amelogenin gene. Although the precise functions of the amelogenin proteins in enamel formation are not well defined, these proteins constitute 90% of the enamel organic matrix. We have disrupted the amelogenin locus to generate amelogenin null mice, which display distinctly abnormal teeth as early as 2 weeks of age with chalky-white discoloration. Microradiography revealed broken tips of incisors and molars and scanning electron microscopy analysis indicated disorganized hypoplastic enamel. The amelogenin null phenotype reveals that the amelogenins are apparently not required for initiation of mineral crystal formation but rather for the organization of crystal pattern and regulation of enamel thickness. These null mice will be useful for understanding the functions of amelogenin proteins during enamel formation and for developing therapeutic approaches for treating this developmental defect that affects the enamel.

Controlled proteolysis of amelogenins reveals exposure of both carboxy- and amino-terminal regions

The matrix-mediated enamel biomineralization involves secretion of the enamel specific amelogenin proteins that through self-assembly into nanosphere structures provide the framework within which the initial enamel crystallites are formed. During enamel mineralization, amelogenin proteins are processed by tooth-specific proteinases. The aim of this study was to explore the factors that affect the activity of enamel proteases to process amelogenins. Two factors including amelogenin self-assembly and enzyme specificity are considered. We applied a limited proteolysis approach, combined with mass spectrometry, in order to determine the surface accessibility of conserved domains of amelogenin assemblies. A series of commercially available proteinases as well as a recombinant enamelysin were used, and their proteolytic actions on recombinant amelogenin were examined under controlled and limited conditions. The N-terminal region of the recombinant mouse amelogenin rM179 was found to be more accessible to tryptic digest than the C-terminal region. The endoproteinase Glu-C cleaved amelogenin at both the N-terminal (E18/V) and C-terminal (E178/V) sites. Chymotrypsin cleaved amelogenin at both the carboxy- (F151/S) and amino-terminal (W25/Y) regions. Interestingly, the peptide bond F/S152 was also recognized by the action of enamelysin on recombinant mouse amelogenin whereas thermolysin cleaved the S152/M153 peptide bond in addition to T63/L64 and I159/L160 and M29/I30 bonds. It was then concluded that regions at both the carboxy- and amino-terminal were exposed on the surface of amelogenin nanospheres when the N-terminal 17 amino acid residues were proposed to be protected from proteolysis, presumably as the result of their involvement in direct protein-protein interaction. Cleavage around the FSM locus occurred by recombinant enamelysin under limited conditions, in both mouse (F151/S152) and pig amelogenins (S148/M). Our in vitro observations on the limited proteolysis of amelogenin by enamelysin suggest that enamelysin cleaved amelogenin at the C-terminal region showing a preference of the enzyme to cleave the S/M and F/S bonds. The present limited proteolysis studies provided insight into the mechanisms of amelogenin degradation during amelogenesis.

The pH dependent amelogenin solubility and its biological significance

Amelogenins are a group of extracellular enamel matrix proteins which are believed to be involved in the regulation of the size and habit of enamel crystals. The aim of this study was to compare the solubility properties of several amelogenins in various pH (4.0-9.0) solutions with an ionic strength (IS) of 0.15 M using the Micro BCA protein assay at 25 degrees C or 37 degrees C. The solubility of the recombinant amelogenin rM179 was lowest (0.7 mg/ml) close to its isoelectric point and it increased below and above this point. The solubility of the recombinant amelogenin rM166 remained almost the same (1-2 mg/ml) as the pH rose from 6.0 to 9.0 and it increased as the solution became more acidic. Synthetic "tyrosine-rich amelogenin polypeptide" (TRAP) was extremely insoluble (<0.2 mg/ml) in the pH range studied while synthetic "leucine-rich amelogenin polypeptide" (LRAP) was readily soluble (>3.3 mg/ml). The native porcine amelogenin with apparent molecular weight 25 kDa shared similar solubility behavior to rM179. The porcine 23 kDa amelogenin was only sparingly soluble (0.3-0.8 mg/ml) over a wide range of pH. Interestingly, the porcine 20 kDa amelogenin was remarkably soluble in the pH range of 4.0 to 6.0 (approximately 12 mg/ml), but the solubility dropped strikingly to only approximately 0.2 mg/ml at pH larger than approximately 7.0. The strong dependence of amelogenin solubility on solution pH may be involved in the regulation of aggregation, enzymatic degradation and the binding properties of amelogenins, thus playing an important role in enamel biomineralization.

Degradative changes in whole enamel homogenates incubated in vitro in the presence of low calcium ion concentrations

The purpose of this study was to investigate overall degradative changes occurring to enamel matrix proteins in small, freeze-dried pieces of rat incisor enamel homogenized and incubated directly for 0-48 hours in a synthetic enamel fluid solution (165 mM total ionic strength with 0.153 mM calcium chloride) versus other samples homogenized and incubated for the same time intervals in distilled water. The results indicated that many alterations in the apparent molecular weights of enamel matrix proteins took place under both conditions although the rates for many degradative changes over a 48 hour period were often slower in distilled water than in synthetic enamel fluid. Freeze-dried enamel samples homogenized and incubated in 165 mM Tris-HCl buffer at pH 8.0 showed changes comparable to those seen with distilled water. This suggested that differences observed between samples incubated in enamel fluid versus distilled water were unrelated to pH or ionic strength of the solutions and may be the result of a requirement by some enamel proteinases for small amounts of free calcium ions in incubation media. Of interest were findings that some enamel matrix proteins, especially those in strips taken from the first half of the secretory stage of amelogenesis, were degraded much faster in distilled water than in synthetic enamel fluid. The reasons for this effect are unclear although, in this case, calcium ions could be inhibitory to hydrolysis of certain matrix proteins by the enamel proteinases.

Biochemical characterization of recombinant mouse amelogenins: protein quantitation, proton absorption, and relative affinity for enamel crystals

Four recombinant mouse amelogenins, which varied by the presence or absence of the exon 4 encoded segment as well as the carboxyl-terminus were heterologously expressed and purified from bacteria. The rM193 and rM179 contain the carboxyl-terminus, whereas the rM180 and rM166 do not. The rM193 and rM180 contain the polypeptide segment encoded by exon 4 of the amelogenin gene. A precisely weighed sample of purified rM179 was quantified by Lowry, Bicinchoninic Acid and Bradford assays. It was determined that these protein quantification methods characteristically under or overestimate the amount of amelogenin. The calculated correction factors were: Lowry (x 1.35), BCA (x 1.96), and Bradford (x 0.78). Recombinant mouse amelogenin (rM179) was characterized with respect to its hydrogen ion binding properties. The protein absorbs 11.9 +/- 1.7 protons during a pH change from 8.0 to 5.0, suggesting that amelogenins buffer the enamel fluid in vivo. Crystal binding experiments were performed using rM193, rM180, rM179 and rM166. The carboxyl-terminus enhanced the binding of amelogenin to enamel crystals while the exon 4 encoded segment did not appreciably affect crystal binding.

Does amelogenin nanosphere assembly proceed through intermediary-sized structures?

We have proposed that these nanosphere structures are functionally involved in the organization and control of initial enamel biomineralization at the ultrastructural level. Based on the observed nanosphere hydrodynamic radii (18-20 nm diameter) computation suggests these structures to be compounded of some 100 amelogenin monomers, raising the question as to the possible molecular mechanism for the assembly of such structures? Based on recent dynamic light scattering experiments using the recombinant murine amelogenin M179, and employing a newer size distribution algorithm we now report that the size distribution data for M179 are better described by a bimodal distribution model, than the monomodal distribution as previously described. We suggest that amelogenin nanosphere assembly proceeds through intermediate structures (perhaps represented in vivo by "stippled material") of some 4-5 nm hydrodynamic radius, and computed to comprise 4-6 amelogenin monomers. We suggest that such intermediary, sub-unit structures, assemble through inter-molecular hydrophobic interactions to generate the 20 nm diameter nanospheres observed by TEM in the secretory stage enamel matrix.

Evidence for charge domains on developing enamel crystal surfaces

The control of hydroxyapatite crystal initiation and growth during enamel development is thought to be mediated via the proteins of the extracellular matrix. However, the precise nature of these matrix-mineral interactions remains obscure. The aim of the present study was to use a combination of atomic and chemical force microscopy to characterize developing enamel crystal surfaces and to determine their relationship with endogenous enamel matrix protein (amelogenin). The results show regular and discrete domains of various charges or charge densities on the surfaces of hydroxyapatite crystals derived from the maturation stage of enamel development. Binding of amelogenin to individual crystals at physiological pH was seen to be coincident with positively charged surface domains. These domains may therefore provide an instructional template for matrix-mineral interactions. Alternatively, the alternating array of charge on the crystal surfaces may reflect the original relationship with, and influence of, matrix interaction with the crystal surfaces during crystal growth.

Spatially related amelogenin interactions in developing rat enamel as revealed by molecular cross-linking studies

A cleavable cross-linker (dithiobis[succinimidyl propionate], DTSP) was used to investigate the subunit structure of the developing enamel matrix. Intact matrix was cross-linked under conditions chosen to simulate those found in vivo. The cross-linked complexes were isolated by preparative sodium dodecyl sulphate-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (SDS-PAGE) and their subunit composition determined by analytical SDS-PAGE following reductive cleavage of the cross-links. Western blotting using antiamelogenin antibodies was used to confirm the identity of the proteins involved. The results showed that nascent amelogenins tended to be cross-linked to other nascent amelogenins while amelogenin-processing products tended to be cross-linked to other processed molecules at the same stage of processing. The results suggest that nascent amelogenins are in close association after secretion and during extracellular processing, and that processed products are not free to associate with nascent molecules, presumably due to diffusion constraints in the tissue. This conclusion implies that individual amelogenin molecules within supramolecular aggregates (nanospheres) are processed in situ and remain in the same nanosphere while all the individual component amelogenins undergo processing. The biological function of amelogenin processing remains unclear but the fact that amelogenin-amelogenin associations are maintained during processing indicates that matrix stability is an important factor while the enamel layer is being deposited.

Self-assembly properties of recombinant engineered amelogenin proteins analyzed by dynamic light scattering and atomic force microscopy

Dynamic light scattering (DLS) analysis together with atomic force microscopy (AFM) imaging was applied to investigate the supramolecular self-assembly properties of a series of recombinant amelogenins. The overall objective was to ascertain the contribution of certain structural motifs in amelogenin to protein-protein interactions during the self-assembly process. Mouse amelogenins lacking either amino- or carboxy-terminal domains believed to be involved in self-assembly and amelogenins having single or double amino acid mutations identical to those found in cases of amelogenesis imperfecta were analyzed. The polyhistidine-containingfull-length recombinant amelogenin protein [rp(H)M180] generated nanospheres with monodisperse size distribution (hydrodynamic radius of 20.7 +/- 2.9 nm estimated from DLS and 16.1 +/- 3.4 nm estimated from AFM images), comparable to nanospheres formed by full-length amelogenin rM179 without the polyhistidine domain, indicating that this histidine modification did not interfere with the self-assembly process. Deletion of the N-terminal self-assembly domain from amelogenin and their substitution by a FLAG epitope ("A"-domain deletion) resulted in the formation of assemblies with a heterogeneous size distribution with the hydrodynamic radii of particles ranging from 3 to 38 nm. A time-dependent dynamic light scattering analysis of amelogenin molecules lacking amino acids 157 through 173 and containing a hemagglutinin epitope ("B"-domain deletion) resulted in the formation of particles (21.5 +/- 6.8 nm) that fused to form larger particles of 49.3 +/- 4.3 nm within an hour. Single and double point mutations in the N-terminal region resulted in the formation of larger and more heterogeneous nanospheres. The above data suggest that while the N-terminal A-domain is involved in the molecular interactions for the formation of nanospheres, the carboxy-terminal B-domain contributes to the stability and homogeneity of the nanospheres, preventing their fusion to larger assemblies. These in vitro findings support the notion that the proteolytic cleavage of amelogenin at amino- and carboxy-terminii occurring during enamel formation influences amelogenin to amelogenin interactions during self-assembly and hence alters the structural organization of the developing enamel extracellular matrix, thus affecting enamel biomineralization.

Cloning human enamelin cDNA, chromosomal localization, and analysis of expression during tooth development

Enamelin is the largest protein in the enamel matrix of developing teeth. In the pig, enamelin is secreted as 186-kDa phosphorylated glycoprotein, which is rapidly processed by enamel proteinases into smaller cleavage products. During the secretory stage of enamel formation, enamelin is found among the crystallites in the rod and interrod enamel and comprises roughly 5% of total matrix protein. Although the function of enamelin is unknown, it is thought to participate in enamel crystal nucleation and extension, and the regulation of crystal habit. Here we report the results of enamelin in situ hybridization in a day 1 mouse developing incisor that shows that enamelin is expressed by ameloblasts, but not by odontoblasts or other cells in the dental pulp. The restricted pattern of enamelin expression makes the human enamelin gene a prime candidate in the etiology of amelogenesis imperfecta (AI), a genetic disease in which defects of enamel formation occur in the absence of non-dental symptoms. We have cloned and characterized a full-length human enamelin cDNA and determined by radiation hybrid mapping and fluorescent in situ hybridization (FISH) that the gene is located on chromosome 4q near the ameloblastin gene in a region previously linked to local hypoplastic AI in six families. These findings will facilitate the search for specific mutations in the enamelin gene in kindreds suffering from amelogenesis imperfecta.

The structural biology of the developing dental enamel matrix

The biomineralization of the dental enamel matrix with a carbonated hydroxyapatite mineral generates one of the most remarkable examples of a vertebrate mineralized tissue. Recent advances in the molecular biology of ameloblast gene products have now revealed the primary structures of the principal proteins involved in this extracellular mineralizing system, amelogenins, tuftelins, ameloblastins, enamelins, and proteinases, but details of their secondary, tertiary, and quaternary structures, their interactions with other matrix and or cell surface proteins, and their functional role in dental enamel matrix mineralization are still largely unknown. This paper reviews our current knowledge of these molecules, the probable molecular structure of the enamel matrix, and the functional role of these extracellular matrix proteins. Recent studies on the major structural role played by the amelogenin proteins are discussed, and some new data on synthetic amelogenin matrices are reviewed.

Microstructures of an amelogenin gel matrix

The thermo-reversible transition (clear <--> opaque) of the amelogenin gel matrix, which has been known for some three decades, has now been clarified by microstructural investigations. A mixed amelogenin preparation extracted from porcine developing enamel matrix (containing "25K," 7.4%; "23K," 10.7%; "20K," 49.5%; and smaller peptides, 32.4%) was dissolved in dilute formic acid and reprecipitated by adjusting the pH to 6.8 with NaOH solution. Amelogenin gels were formed in vitro by sedimenting the precipitate in microcentrifuge tubes. The gels were fixed with Karnovsky fixative at 4 and 24 degrees C, which was found to preserve their corresponding clear (4 degrees C) and opaque (24 degrees C) states. Scanning electron microscopy, atomic force microscopy, and transmission electron microscopy were employed for the microstructural characterization of the fixed clear and opaque gels. The amelogenin gel matrix was observed to possess a hierarchical structure of quasi-spherical amelogenin nanospheres and their assemblies. The nanospheres of diameters 8-20 nm assemble to form small spherical assemblies of diameters 40-70 nm that further aggregated to form large spherical assemblies of 70-300 nm in diameter. In the clear gel, most of the large assemblies are smaller than 150 nm, and the nanospheres and assemblies are uniformly dispersed, allowing an even fluid distribution among them. In the opaque gel, however, numerous spherical fluid-filled spaces ranging from 0.3 to 7 microm in diameter were observed with the majority of the large assemblies sized 150-200 nm in diameter. These spaces presumably result from enhanced hydrophobic interactions among nanospheres and/or assemblies as the temperature increased. The high opacity of the opaque (24 degrees C) gel apparently arises from the presence of the numerous fluid-filled spaces observed compared to the low-temperature (4 degrees C) preparation. These observations suggest that the hydrophobic interactions among nanospheres and different orders of amelogenin assemblies are important in determining the structural integrity of the dental enamel matrix.

Temperature and pH-dependent supramolecular self-assembly of amelogenin molecules: a dynamic light-scattering analysis

Evidence for the molecular self-assembly of amelogenin proteins to form quasi-spherical particles ("nanospheres") in solution, both in vitro and in vivo, has recently been documented. A particle-size distribution analysis of dynamic light-scattering data was undertaken to investigate the influence of temperature on this molecular self-assembly process at three different pH's. The long-term objective was to correlate these observations to the unusual physiochemical characteristics of the protein, to improve understanding of the molecular mechanisms involved in the generation of amelogenin "nanospheres" and understanding of their putative relation to amelogenin function in vivo. We analyzed data using two different algorithms: Dynamics and DynaLS. It was found that at pH 8, in a temperature range between 5 and 25 degrees C, the size of the recombinant amelogenin nanospheres is monodisperse, giving rise to particles of 15-18 nm in hydrodynamic radius. However, heterogeneous distribution of particle size was observed at temperature ranges between 27 and 35 degrees C, becoming monodisperse again with larger particles (60-70 nm) after the temperature was elevated to 37-40 degrees C. We interpret these results to suggest that amelogenin molecular self-association possesses a second stage assembly process at temperatures of 30-35 degrees C, creating larger entities which apparently are structured and stable at 37-40 degreesC. The effect of pH on the size of amelogenin "aggregates" was much more noticeable at 37 degrees C compared to that at 25 degrees C. This observation suggests that at physiological temperature (i.e., 37 degrees C) amelogenin molecular self-assembly is extremely sensitive to pH changes. This finding supports the notion that local pH changes in the microenvironment of the enamel extracellular matrix may play critical roles in controlling the structural organization of the organic matrix framework.

Interaction of amelogenin with hydroxyapatite crystals: an adherence effect through amelogenin molecular self-association

At the secretory stage of tooth enamel formation the majority of the organic matrix is composed of amelogenin proteins that are believed to provide the scaffolding for the initial carbonated hydroxyapatite crystals to grow. The primary objective of this study was to investigate the interaction between amelogenins and growing apatite crystals. Two in vitro strategies were used: first, we examined the influence of amelogenins as compared to two other macromolecules, on the kinetics of seeded growth of apatite crystals; second, using transmission electron micrographs of the crystal powders, based on a particle size distribution study, we evaluated the effect of the macromolecules on the aggregation of growing apatite crystals. Two recombinant amelogenins (rM179, rM166), the synthetic leucine-rich amelogenin polypeptide (LRAP), poly(L-proline), and phosvitin were used. It was shown that the rM179 amelogenin had some inhibitory effect on the kinetics of calcium hydroxyapatite seeded growth. The inhibitory effect, however, was not as destructive as that of other macromolecules tested. The degree of inhibition of the macromolecules was in the order of phosvitin > LRAP > poly(L-proline) > rM179 > rM166. Analysis of particle size distribution of apatite crystal aggregates indicated that the full-length amelogenin protein (rM179) caused aggregation of the growing apatite crystals more effectively than other macromolecules. We propose that during the formation of hydroxyapatite crystal clusters, the growing apatite crystals adhere to each other through the molecular self-association of interacting amelogenin molecules. The biological implications of this adherence effect with respect to enamel biomineralization are discussed.

Quantitative analysis of amelogenin solubility

Amelogenins are a group of extracellular enamel matrix proteins which are believed to be involved in the regulation of the size and habits of forming enamel crystals. The aim of this study was to compare the solubility properties of several amelogenins at various pH (from 4.0 to 9.0) at constant ionic strength (IS), and to examine the influence of buffer composition, IS, and divalent metal ions (including Ca2+, Mg2+, and Zn2+) on amelogenin solubility. The solubility of the recombinant murine amelogenin ("rM179") was minimum near its isoelectric point and increased rapidly below and above, regardless of buffer composition. A similar trend was observed for the native porcine ("25K") amelogenin. Porcine "23K" amelogenin was only sparingly soluble from pH of 4.0 to 9.0, in contrast to the analogous recombinant "rM166", which was more soluble in acidic solutions. The synthetic amelogenin polypeptide "TRAP" was extremely insoluble, while synthetic LRAP was readily soluble. Porcine "20K" amelogenin solubility increased strikingly as the solution pH was lowered from 7.0 to 6.0. Increasing IS decreased the solubility of rM179. While Zn2+ reduced rM179 solubility, Ca2+ and Mg2+ showed no significant effects. We conclude that the solubility of amelogenin was dependent on the primary structure, solution pH, and IS, and the low solubility of amelogenins under physiological conditions may result from their tendency to form quaternary (aggregate) structures in vivo.

Cellular and chemical events during enamel maturation

This review focuses on the process of enamel maturation, a series of events associated with slow, progressive growth in the width and thickness of apatitic crystals. This developmental step causes gradual physical hardening and transformation of soft, newly formed enamel into one of the most durable mineralized tissues produced biologically. Enamel is the secretory product of specialized epithelial cells, the ameloblasts, which make this covering on the crowns of teeth in two steps. First, they roughly "map out" the location and limits (overall thickness) of the entire extracellular layer as a protein-rich, acellular, and avascular matrix filled with thin, ribbon-like crystals of carbonated hydroxyapatite. These initial crystals are organized spatially into rod and interrod territories as they form, and rod crystals are lengthened by Tomes' processes in tandem with appositional movement of ameloblasts away from the dentin surface. Once the full thickness of enamel has been formed, ameloblasts initiate a series of repetitive morphological changes at the enamel surface in which tight junctions and deep membrane infoldings periodically appear (ruffle-ended), then disappear for short intervals (smooth-ended), from the apical ends of the cells. As this happens, the enamel covered by these cells changes rhythmically in net pH from mildly acidic (ruffle-ended) to near-physiologic (smooth-ended) as mineral crystals slowly expand into the "spaces" (volume) formerly occupied by matrix proteins and water. Matrix proteins are processed and degraded by proteinases throughout amelogenesis, but they undergo more rapid destruction once ameloblast modulation begins. Ruffle-ended ameloblasts appear to function primarily as a regulatory and transport epithelium for controlling the movement of calcium and other ions such as bicarbonate into enamel to maintain buffering capacity and driving forces optimized for surface crystal growth. The reason ruffle-ended ameloblasts become smooth-ended periodically is unknown, although this event seems to be crucial for sustaining long-term crystal growth.

Protein-to-protein interactions: criteria defining the assembly of the enamel organic matrix

Enamel crystallites form in a protein matrix located proximal to the ameloblast cell layer. This unique organic extracellular matrix is constructed from structural protein components biosynthesized and secreted by ameloblasts. To date, three distinct classes of enamel matrix proteins have been cloned. These are the amelogenins, tuftelin, and ameloblastin, with recent data implicating ameloblastin gene expression during cementogenesis. The organic enamel extracellular matrix undergoes assembly to provide a three-dimensional array of protein domains that carry out the physiologic function of guiding enamel hydroxyapatite crystallite formation. Using the yeast two-hybrid system, we have surveyed these three known enamel gene products for their ability to direct self-assembly. We measured the capacity of the enamel gene products to direct protein-to-protein interactions, a characteristic of enamel proteins predicated to be required for self-assembly. We provide additional evidence for the self-assembly nature of amelogenin and tuftelin. Ameloblastin self-assembly could not be demonstrated, nor were protein-to-protein interactions observed between ameloblastin and either amelogenin or tuftelin. Within the limits of the yeast two-hybrid assay, these findings constrain the emerging model of enamel matrix assembly by helping to define the limits of enamel matrix protein-protein interactions that are believed to guide enamel mineral crystallite formation.

Protein interactions during assembly of the enamel organic extracellular matrix

Enamel is the outermost covering of teeth and contains the largest hydroxyapatite crystallites formed in the vertebrate body. Enamel forms extracellularly through the ordered assembly of a protein scaffolding that regulates crystallite dimensions. The two most studied proteins of the enamel extracellular matrix (ECM) are amelogenin and tuftelin. The underlying mechanism for assembly of the proteins within the enamel extracellular matrix and the regulatory role of crystallite-protein interactions have proven elusive. We used the two-hybrid system to identify and define minimal protein domains responsible for supra molecular assembly of the enamel ECM. We show that amelogenin proteins self-assemble, and this self-assembly depends on the amino-terminal 42 residues interacting either directly or indirectly with a 17-residue domain in the carboxyl region. Amelogenin and tuftelin fail to interact with each other. Based upon this data, and advances in the field, a model for amelogenin assemblies that direct enamel biomineralization is presented.

Cloning, characterization, and heterologous expression of exon-4-containing amelogenin mRNAs

The formation of dental enamel is dependent upon amelogenins, a family of proteins constituting most of the developing enamel matrix. Depending upon the species, these enamel proteins are expressed from either one or two copies of the amelogenin gene. Each gene directs the synthesis of a variety of amelogenin isoforms through alternative splicing of their pre-mRNA transcript(s). Before the role of amelogenins in dental enamel formation can be better understood, one must know the isoforms that are secreted and their biochemical properties. Previously, we cloned and characterized 7 mouse amelogenin RNA messages generated by alternative splicing. The largest amelogenin cDNA encoded a 194-residue amelogenin isoform which was the only clone to contain the 42-nucleotide exon 4 segment. Anti-peptide antibodies raised against the derived translation of this exon revealed an unexpectedly diverse assortment of murine amelogenins, suggesting that additional splicing variants could contain the exon 4 coding region. Using exon-4-specific oligonucleotide primers, we have amplified, cloned, and characterized three different amelogenin RNA messages. These messages encode amelogenin polypeptides (exclusive of signal peptides) 194, 170, and 73 amino acids in length. The isotope-averaged molecular weights for the deduced, single-phosphorylated, proteins are 21,897.1, 19,113.9, and 8176.5 Daltons, respectively. Splice-site selection for the generation of these mRNAs was identical to that of the previously characterized messages for the M180, M156, and M59 except for the inclusion of exon 4. The exon-4-containing amelogenin isoforms were heterologously expressed in E. coli by means of the pET11 expression system (Novagen, Madison, WI).

Amelogenin proteins of developing dental enamel

The amelogenins of developing dental enamel are tissue-specific proteins, rich in proline, leucine, histidine and glutamyl residues, and synthesized by the ameloblast cells of the inner enamel epithelium. These proteins comprise the bulk of the extracellular matrix that becomes mineralized with a hydroxyapatite phase to become the mature enamel. Examination of the amino acid sequences of amelogenins from a range of mammals shows a high degree of evolutionary sequence conservation, suggestive of specialized function. Recently it has been shown that multiple amelogenin components, observed in the matrix, arise both by a sequence of post-secretory proteolytic processing and by the expression of alternatively spliced mRNAs generated from the amelogenin gene(s) that are located on the sex chromosomes. Although the function of these amelogenins in enamel biomineralization is unknown, physico-chemical studies of recombinant amelogenins have shown that they undergo a self-assembly process in vitro generating supra-molecular 'nanosphere' structures, and recent observations in vivo point to a functional role for the nanospheres in the ultrastructural organization of the secretory enamel matrix, conducive to the organized development of the earliest mineral crystallites.

Identification of a novel proteinase (ameloprotease-I) responsible for the complete degradation of amelogenin during enamel maturation

During enamel formation the proteins of the extracellular matrix, particularly amelogenins, are removed prior to maturation. In order to investigate this process and to improve our understanding of the function of proteinases during enamel maturation, proteinase fractions were isolated from developing pig enamel and assayed for proteolytic activity in vitro. A recombinant murine amelogenin, M179, was used as a substrate. Two major groups of enamel proteinases were defined as high-molecular-mass ['high-molecular-weight' in Moradian-Oldak, Simmer, Sarte, Zeichner-David and Fincham (1994) Arch. Oral Biol.39, 647-656] and low-molecular-mass proteinases. Here we report the characterization of one of the proteinases present in the low-molecular-mass group. We demonstrate that this proteinase is a serine proteinase capable of degradation of M179 following cleavage of the tyrosine-rich amelogenin polypeptide from the N-terminal region. A partial N-terminal sequence of the proteinase was obtained (LPHVPHRIPPGYGRPXTXNEEGXNPYFXFFXXHG). An anti-peptide antibody directed against a synthetic peptide corresponding to the first 14 amino acids of the above sequence was produced. The presence of the proteinase in the acetic acid extract was confirmed by Western blotting. Searching using the amino acid sequence determined in this study showed it to be also present in the 32 kDa and 89 kDa enamelin proteins reported by Fukae, Tanabe, Murakami and Tohi [(1996) Adv. Dent. Res., in the press]. We therefore identify the 32 kDa enamelin as an enamel proteinase ('ameloprotease-I') which is responsible for amelogenin degradation in maturing enamel. We propose that the 89 kDa enamelin is a precursor of ameloprotease-I, the first enamel protein for which a function has been defined.