A bond path and an attractive Ehrenfest force do not necessarily indicate bonding interactions: case study on M2X2 (M = Li, Na, K; X = H, OH, F, Cl)

Different zeroes of interaction energies as the cause of opposite results on the stabilizing nature of C-H···O intramolecular interactions

The interaction energy of the C-H···O intramolecular interaction is estimated by several methods for a large group of systems possessing a quasi-cyclic six-membered ring. In the case of the geometry corrected method (GCM), the related rotamers method (RRM), and Espinosa's method (EM), the linear correlations between interaction energies and the electron density at the bond critical point have close slopes. The first and the last two methods yield almost systematically opposite results concerning the stabilizing/destabilizing character of the interaction, and their main difference is their zero of the interaction energy. An investigation on the limitations of reference energies has led to the introduction of the geometry corrected related rotamers method (GCRRM), estimating both stabilizing and destabilizing C-H···O interactions. An extension of EM is proposed.

On the physical role of exchange in the formation of an intramolecular bond path between two electronegative atoms

In this paper, we present a detailed energetic decomposition of intramolecular O···X interactions (X being O, S, or a halogen atom) based on the interacting quantum atoms approach of Pendás and co-workers. The nature of these interactions (repulsive or attractive, more or less electrostatic) is discussed in the framework of Bader's atoms in molecules theory, a particular emphasis being put on delocalization (measured by delocalization indexes and in terms of the source function) and on the exchange contributions. Notably, the concept of exchange channels introduced by Pendás and collaborators provides means of rationalizing and predicting the presence of bond critical points, enhancing the physical meaning of bond paths.

Forced bonding and QTAIM deficiencies: a case study of the nature of interactions in He@adamantane and the origin of the high metastability

Calculations within the framework of the interacting quantum atoms (IQA) approach have shown that the interactions of the helium atom with both tertiary, tC, and secondary, sC, carbon atoms in the metastable He@adamantane (He@adam) endohedral complex are bonding in nature, whereas the earlier study performed within the framework of Bader's quantum theory of atoms in molecules (QTAIM) revealed that only He---tC interactions are bonding. The He---tC and He---sC bonding interactions are shown to be forced by the high pressure that the helium and carbon atoms exert upon each other in He@adam. The occurrence of a bonding interaction between the helium and sC atoms, which are not linked by a bond path, clearly shows that the lack of a bond path between two atoms does not necessarily indicate the lack of a bonding interaction, as is asserted by QTAIM. IQA calculations showed that not only the destabilization of the adamantane cage, but also a huge internal destabilization of the helium atom, contribute to the metastability of He@adam, these contributions being roughly equal. This result disproves previous opinions based on QTAIM analysis that only the destabilization of the adamantane cage accounts for the endothermicity of He@adam. Also, it was found that there is no homeomorphism of the ρ(r) and -v(r) fields of He@adam. Comparison of the IQA and QTAIM results on the interactions in He@adam exposes other deficiencies of the QTAIM approach. The reasons for the deficiencies in the QTAIM approach are analyzed.

The Ehrenfest force field: Topology and consequences for the definition of an atom in a molecule

The Ehrenfest force is the force acting on the electrons in a molecule due to the presence of the other electrons and the nuclei. There is an associated force field in three-dimensional space that is obtained by the integration of the corresponding Hermitian quantum force operator over the spin coordinates of all of the electrons and the space coordinates of all of the electrons but one. This paper analyzes the topology induced by this vector field and its consequences for the definition of molecular structure and of an atom in a molecule. Its phase portrait reveals: that the nuclei are attractors of the Ehrenfest force, the existence of separatrices yielding a dense partitioning of three-dimensional space into disjoint regions, and field lines connecting the attractors through these separatrices. From the numerical point of view, when the Ehrenfest force field is obtained as minus the divergence of the kinetic stress tensor, the induced topology was found to be highly sensitive to choice of gaussian basis sets at long range. Even the use of large split valence and highly uncontracted basis sets can yield spurious critical points that may alter the number of attraction basins. Nevertheless, at short distances from the nuclei, in general, the partitioning of three-dimensional space with the Ehrenfest force field coincides with that induced by the gradient field of the electron density. However, exceptions are found in molecules where the electron density yields results in conflict with chemical intuition. In these cases, the molecular graphs of the Ehrenfest force field reveal the expected atomic connectivities. This discrepancy between the definition of an atom in a molecule between the two vector fields casts some doubts on the physical meaning of the integration of Ehrenfest forces over the basins of the electron density.