Immunoglobulin light chain class multiplicity and alternative organizational forms in early vertebrate phylogeny

Marsupial Light Chains: Complexity and Conservation of λ in the Opossum Monodelphis domestica

The Igλ chains in the South American opossum, Monodelphis domestica, were analyzed at the expressed cDNA and genomic organization level, the first described for a nonplacental mammal. The Vλ segment repertoire in the opossum was found to be comprised of at least three diverse Vλ families. Each of these families appears to be related to distinct Vλ families present in placental mammals, suggesting the divergence of these genes before the separation of metatherians and eutherians more than 100 million years ago. Based on framework and constant region sequences from full-length cDNAs and intron sequences from genomic clones, it appears that there are multiple functional Jλ-Cλ pairs in the opossum locus. The opossum Jλ-Cλ sequences are phylogenetically clustered, suggesting that these gene duplications are more recent and species specific. Sequence analysis of a large set of functional, expressed Vλ-Jλ recombinations is consistent with an unbiased, highly diverse λ light chain repertoire in the adult opossum. Overall, the complexity of the Igλ locus appears to be greater than that found in the Ig heavy chain locus in the opossum, and light chains are therefore likely to contribute significantly to Ig diversity in this species.

The immunoglobulin light chain in poikilothermic vertebrates

The immunoglobulin light chains are classified as kappa or lambda in mammals and birds (homeothermic vertebrates), but the traditional criteria for this classification are not applicable to the light chains found in poikilothermic vertebrates. Still it is possible to find some relationships between Ig light chain sequences in these animals and in those of the homeothermic animals. It is generally accepted that the Ig light chains contribute to the antigen binding capacity of antibodies and the variability is approximately similar in all studied vertebrate species except the elasmobranchs. This might be explained by the organisation of the Ig light chain locus in these animals and the fact that the variable and joining DNA segments are joined in the genome. These conclusions are limited by the small number of species studied in this respect.

Towards understanding the evolutionary origins and early diversification of rearranging antigen receptors

The rearranging antigen binding receptors, immunoglobulin heavy (IgH) and light (IgL) chains and the four classes of T-cell antigen receptors (TCR) are found in all contemporary species of jawed vertebrates examined thus far. Ig genes have undergone marked changes in organization and mechanisms of diversification during vertebrate phylogeny; whereas TCR genes, which are found in species as phylogenetically removed as man and cartilaginous fishes (e.g. skate), are generally similar in terms of structure, diversification and, presumably, function. The patterns of Ig divergence in cartilaginous fish are informative as to both the potential for genetic variation and the mechanisms that bring about such change. No evidence has been found for homologs of either Ig, TCR, recombination activating gene (RAG)1 or RAG2 in jawless vertebrates or invertebrates. Thus, a phylogenetic demarcation exists in terms of the presence and absence of the rearranging antigen binding receptor genes. It is presumed that the rearranging antigen binding receptors arose from a non-rearranging predecessor. The recent discovery of non-rearranging homologs of antigen binding receptor genes in several species offers insight into alternative forms of recognition, relationships between adaptive and innate mechanisms of immunity, and the origins of antigen recognition.

Lymphocyte development in fish and amphibians

Recently, molecular markers such as recombination activating genes (RAG), terminal deoxynucleotidyl transferase (TdT), stem cell leukemia hematopoietic transcription factor (SCL), Ikaros and gata-binding protein (Gata)-family members have been isolated and characterized from key lower vertebrates, adding to our growing knowledge of lymphopoiesis in ectotherms. In all gnathostomes there appear to be two main embryonic locations derived from the early mesoderm, both intra- and extraembryonic, which contribute to primitive and definitive hematopoiesis based upon their differential expression of SCL, Gata-1, Gata-2 and myeloblastosis oncogene (c-myb). In teleosts, a unique intraembryonic location for hematopoietic stem cells termed the intermediate cell mass (ICM) of Oellacher appears to be responsible for primitive or definitive hematopoiesis depending upon the species being investigated. In Xenopus, elegant grafting studies in combination with specific molecular markers has led to a better definition of the roles that ventral blood islands and dorsal lateral plate play in amphibian hematopoiesis, that of primitive and definitive lymphopoiesis. After the early embryonic contribution to hematopoiesis, specialized tissues must assume the role of providing the proper microenvironment for T and B-lymphocyte development from progenitor stem cells. In all gnathostomes, the thymus is the major site for T-cell maturation as evidenced by strong expression of developmental markers such as Ikaros, Rag and TdT plus expression of T-cell specific markers such as T-cell receptor beta and lck. In this respect, several zebrafish mutants have provided new insights on the development of the thymopoietic environment. On the other hand, the sites for B-cell lymphopoiesis are less clear among the lower vertebrates. In elasmobranchs, the spleen, Leydig's organ and the spiral valve may all contribute to B-cell development, although pre-B cells have yet to be fully addressed in fish. In teleosts, the kidney is undeniably the major source of B-cell development based upon functional, cellular and molecular indices. Amphibians appear to use several different sites (spleen, bone marrow and/or kidney) depending upon the species in question.

Mutation, selection, and memory in B lymphocytes of exothermic vertebrates

Unlike mammals, cold-blooded vertebrates produce antibodies of low heterogeneity that show little increase in binding affinity with time after immunization. In secondary responses, antibody titers and affinities are often little, if any, higher than in primary responses. That is, specificity, diversity, and memory--the hallmarks of the immune system--are rather meager in the humoral immune responses of exothermic vertebrates. As the genetic components of the immunoglobulin (Ig) gene systems in fishes, amphibians or reptiles are not deficient in number or diversity, their responses probably do not stem from restrictions in the primary antibody repertoire. Somatic hypermutation at the Ig locus, which generates diversity and higher affinity antibodies in mammals, is not lacking in the South African frog Xenopus or in the shark. However, the Ig mutants recovered are strongly biased toward alterations at GC pairs, an indication that they have not undergone effective selection. While cells resembling follicular dendritic cells are present in cold-blooded vertebrates, germinal centers do not form. It is suggested that this absence of germinal centers, the site of selection for the mutants with higher affinity receptors and of differentiation into memory B cells in mammals, may explain the principal differences between cold and warm-blooded vertebrates.

The signature of somatic hypermutation appears to be written into the germline IgV segment repertoire

We present here a unifying hypothesis for the molecular mechanism of somatic hypermutation and somatic gene conversion in IgV genes involving reverse transcription using RNA templates from the V-gene loci to produce cDNA which undergoes homologous recombination with chromosomal V(D)J DNA. Experimental evidence produced over the last 20 years is essentially consistent with this hypothesis. We also review evidence suggesting that somatically generated IgV sequences from B lymphocytes have been fed back to germline DNA over evolutionary time.

Evolution by the birth-and-death process in multigene families of the vertebrate immune system

Concerted evolution is often invoked to explain the diversity and evolution of the multigene families of major histocompatibility complex (MHC) genes and immunoglobulin (Ig) genes. However, this hypothesis has been controversial because the member genes of these families from the same species are not necessarily more closely related to one another than to the genes from different species. To resolve this controversy, we conducted phylogenetic analyses of several multigene families of the MHC and Ig systems. The results show that the evolutionary pattern of these families is quite different from that of concerted evolution but is in agreement with the birth-and-death model of evolution in which new genes are created by repeated gene duplication and some duplicate genes are maintained in the genome for a long time but others are deleted or become nonfunctional by deleterious mutations. We found little evidence that interlocus gene conversion plays an important role in the evolution of MHC and Ig multigene families.

alpha, beta, gamma, and delta T cell antigen receptor genes arose early in vertebrate phylogeny

A series of products were amplified using a PCR strategy based on short minimally degenerate primers and R. eglanteria (clearnose skate) spleen cDNA as template. These products were used as probes to select corresponding cDNAs from a spleen cDNA library. The cDNA sequences exhibit significant identity with prototypic (alpha, beta, gamma, and delta T cell antigen receptor (TCR) genes. Characterization of cDNAs reveals extensive variable region diversity, putative diversity segments, and varying degrees of junctional diversification. This demonstrates expression of both alpha/beta and gamma/delta TCR genes at an early level of vertebrate phylogeny and indicates that the three major known classes of rearranging antigen receptors were present in the common ancestor of the present-day jawed vertebrates.

Primordial emergence of the recombination activating gene 1 (RAG1): sequence of the complete shark gene indicates homology to microbial integrases

The rearrangement of antibody and T-cell receptor gene segments is indispensable to the vertebrate immune response. All extant jawed vertebrates can rearrange these gene segments. This ability is conferred by the recombination activating genes I and II (RAG I and RAG II). To elucidate their origin and function, the cDNA encoding RAG I from a member of the most ancient class of extant gnathostomes, the Carcharhine sharks, was characterized. Homology domains identified within shark RAG I prompted sequence comparison analyses that suggested similarity of the RAG I and II genes, respectively, to the integrase family genes and integration host factor genes of the bacterial site-specific recombination system. Thus, the apparent explosive evolution (or "big bang") of the ancestral immune system may have been initiated by a transfer of microbial site-specific recombinases.

A novel "chimeric" antibody class in cartilaginous fish: IgM may not be the primordial immunoglobulin

Using a degenerate oligonucleotide primer specific for immunoglobulin (Ig) constant type 1 (C-1 set) domain genes, products were amplified by the reverse transcriptase-polymerase chain reaction from nurse shark spleen cDNA. The deduced protein sequence of one of these clones reveals a novel Ig class in cartilaginous fish. A complete mRNA could encode a mature protein bearing an amino-terminal variable (V) domain, followed by six C-1 set domains, and ending in a carboxy-terminal tail typical of secreted IgM, IgA, and the new antigen receptor (NAR). The two amino-terminal C domains are orthologous to IgX (or IgR), an Ig heavy (H) chain class in the skate, and the last four domains are homologous to the carboxy-terminal four domains of NAR. We designate this "chimeric" Ig class IgNARC for Ig new antigen receptor from cartilaginous fish. Like NAR, but unlike shark IgM, IgNARC is encoded by very few V and C genes which apparently are not closely linked. The number of bands that hybridize with exon-specific probes varies with genomic DNA from individual sharks, suggestive of different numbers of IgNARC genes in different animals. A protein of approximately 95 kDa, which is likely to be the IgNARC H chain, is immunoprecipitated with both light chain-specific monoclonal antibodies and with antisera generated to a peptide comprising the IgNARC carboxy-terminal tail. We conclude that the arsenal of secreted antigen receptors in cartilaginous fish is greater than previously believed. In addition, our data cast doubt on the dogma that IgM is the primordial Ig isotype.

Rearrangement/hypermutation/gene conversion: when, where and why?

Diversification strategies for immunoglobulins vary widely in different species. Here, Jean-Claude Weill and Claude-Agnès Reynaud argue that V(D)J recombination arose as a means for achieving allelic exclusion rather than diversity, and postulate that the choice of a diversification strategy is selected along with a specific site of B-cell differentiation. They propose that somatic mutation and gene conversion represent analogous molecular strategies occurring in specific chromatin accessibility contexts.

Generation of immunoglobulin light chain gene diversity in Raja erinacea is not associated with somatic rearrangement, an exception to a central paradigm of B cell immunity

In all vertebrate species examined to date, rearrangement and somatic modification of gene segmental elements that encode portions of the antigen-combining sites of immunoglobulins are integral components of the generation of antibody diversity. In the phylogenetically primitive cartilaginous fishes, gene segments encoding immunoglobulin heavy and light chain loci are arranged in multiple clusters, in which segmental elements are separated by only 300-400 bp. In some cases, segmental elements are joined in the germline of nonlymphoid cells (joined genes). Both genomic library screening and direct amplification of genomic DNA have been used to characterize at least 89 different type I light chain gene clusters in the skate, Raja. Analyses of predicted nucleotide sequences and predicted peptide structures are consistent with the distribution of genes into different sequence groups. Predicted amino acid sequence differences are preferentially distributed in complementarity-determining versus framework regions, and replacement-type substitutions exceed neutral substitutions. When specific germline sequences are related to the sequences of individual cDNAs, it is apparent that the joined genes are expressed and are potentially somatically mutated. No evidence was found for the presence of any type I light chain gene in Raja that is not germline joined. The type I light chain gene clusters in Raja appear to represent a novel gene system in which combinatorial and junctional diversity are absent.

Identification and characterization of T-cell antigen receptor-related genes in phylogenetically diverse vertebrate species

Characterization of the structure, multiplicity, organization, and cell lineage-specific expression of T-cell receptor (TCR) genes of nonmammalian vertebrate species is central to the understanding of the evolutionary origins of rearranging genes of the vertebrate immune system. We recently described a polymerase chain reaction (PCR) strategy that relies on short sequence similarities shared by nearly all vertebrate TCR and immunoglobulin (Ig) variable (V) regions and have used this approach to isolate a TCR beta (TCRB) homolog from a cartilaginous fish. Using these short PCR products as probes in spleen cDNA and genomic libraries, we were able to isolate a variety of unique TCR and TCR-like genes. Here we report the identification and characterization of a chicken TCR gamma (TCRG) homolog, apparent Xenopus and pufferfish TCR alpha (TCRA) homologs, and two horned shark TCR delta (TCRD)-like genes. In addition, we have identified what could be a novel representative of the Ig gene superfamily in the pufferfish. This method of using short, minimally degenerate PCR primers should speed progress in the phylogenetic investigations of the TCR and related genes and lend important insights into both the origins and functions of these unique gene systems.

cDNA sequence and organization of the immunoglobulin light chain gene of the duck, Anas platyrhynchos

A cDNA was cloned which encoded an immunoglobulin (Ig) light (L) chain of the White Pekin duck. The organization of the variable (V) and constant (C) domains was analyzed by genomic Southern blotting. The duck L chain gene has a similar chromosomal organization to that of the chicken, with a single lambda-like C region and multiple VL, hybridizing elements. The amino acid sequence of the VL region of the White Pekin duck L chain showed 88% identity with the Muscovy duck and 87% identity with the chicken, the JL region showed 92% identity with these species, and the CL region showed 88% identity with Muscovy duck and 66% with chicken. The constraints imposed by the gene-conversion mechanism of generating antibody diversity might account for the similarities of the avian V region sequences.

T-cell receptor gene homologs are present in the most primitive jawed vertebrates

The phylogenetic origins of T-cell immunity and T-cell antigen receptor (TCR) genes have not been established. A PCR approach using short, minimally degenerate oligodeoxynucleotide primers complementing conserved variable region segments amplifies TCR-like products from the genomic DNA of Heterodontus francisci (horned shark), a representative phylogenetically primitive cartilaginous fish. One of these products has been used as a probe to screen a Heterodontus spleen cDNA library and a clone was identified that is most related at the nucleotide sequence and predicted peptide levels to higher vertebrate TCR beta-chain genes. Genomic analyses of the TCR homologs indicate that recombining variable and joining region segments as well as constant region exons are encoded by extensive gene families, organized in the multicluster form, characteristic of both the immunoglobulin heavy- and light-chain gene loci in the cartilaginous fishes. Greater numbers of homologous products were identified when a probe complementing the putative constant region of the TCR homolog was used to screen the same cDNA library. A high degree of intergenic variation is associated with the putative variable region segments of these isolates. Direct evidence is presented for TCR-like genes, which presumably are associated with T-cell function, at the earliest stages in the phylogenetic emergence of jawed vertebrates.