The validation of a 7-locus multiplex STR test for use in forensic casework. (II), Artefacts, casework studies and success rates

Analysis and interpretation of mixed forensic stains using DNA STR profiling

The use of multiplex PCR and fluorescent dye technology in the automated detection and analysis of short tandem repeat loci provides not only qualitative information about the profile--i.e. which alleles are present--but can also provide quantitative information on the relative intensities of the bands, and is therefore a measure of the amount of amplified DNA. The availability of this quantitative information allows for the interpretation of mixtures in a detailed way which has not been previously possible with many other human identification systems. In this paper we present a simple approach to the resolution and analysis of mixed STR profiles resulting from the testing of mixed biological stains in forensic casework and highlight factors which can affect it. This approach requires a detailed knowledge--gained through a mixture of experiments and validation studies--of the behaviour of each locus within the multiplex systems described. We summarise the available data from previously published experimental work and validation studies to examine the general principles underlying this approach.

Development of guidelines to designate alleles using an STR multiplex system

We have carried out extensive validation of a multiplex system of 6 STR loci and the Amelogenin sex test to investigate the following characteristics: relative peak areas of heterozygote peaks; non-specific artefacts; stutters caused by slippage of the Taq enzyme; pull-up (an electronic artefact often associated with software). The purpose of this paper is to demonstrate how interpretation guidelines can be formulated by experimentation and analysis using casework samples. Automation allows data relating to band position (in base pairs), peak area and peak height to be easily collected and manipulated in spreadsheets or computer programs. This paves the way to designing expert systems to carry out the interpretative process.

Detection and quantitative characterization of artificial extra peaks following polymerase chain reaction amplification of 14 short tandem repeat systems used in forensic investigations

Detection on automated DNA sequencers of polymerase chain reaction (PCR) products of tetra- and penta-nucleotide short tandem repeat (STR) loci frequently reveals one or more extra peaks along with the true, major allele peak. The most frequent extra peak pattern is a single smaller peak which is one repeat unit shorter than the true allele peak. The existence of such artificial peaks is of special importance when the methods are used for forensic investigations because the artificial extra peaks may simulate true alleles when samples containing mixtures of DNA from different individuals are analyzed. We have investigated the relative levels of formation of extra peaks in 14 STR marker systems. We found that not only the parameters of the PCR but also factors determining the stringency during the post-PCR and pre-electrophoresis handling of samples were of importance for the formation of extra peaks. In our hands, the amounts of extra peaks were reduced (i) if the samples were effectively denatured immediately before loading, (ii) if they contained substantial amounts of formamide (i.e. > or = 50%), and (iii) if the temperature of the electrophoresis gel was above a certain level (i.e. > or = 43 degrees C). The results suggest that extra peaks may in part be due to re-annealing of the PCR product under suboptimal conditions. When efforts had been made to reduce the post-PCR formation of extra peaks, the relative peak areas of the extra peaks ranged from 1% to 17% of those of the true alleles. Similar results were obtained when the PCR products were analyzed under native conditions. Low-copy genome analysis excluded that somatic heterogeneity of the STR regions caused the extra peaks. The systems HumVWA31A, HumFibra/FGA, and D21S11 were especially affected by low-stringency conditions, while Hum-TH01, HumCD4, and D12S391 were virtually unaffected by low-stringency conditions. Replacement of the Taq DNA polymerase with DNA polymerases with lower processivity resulted in higher levels of extra peaks. Our results support the hypothesis that extra peaks are produced due to slipped-strand mispairing.

The validation of a 7-locus multiplex STR test for use in forensic casework. (I). Mixtures, ageing, degradation and species studies

We have evaluated a multiplex STR system for routine forensic use, which co-amplifies six short tandem repeat (STR) loci; HUMTH01, D21S11, D18S51, D8S1179, HUMVWF31/A and HUMFIBRA (FGA), in conjunction with the X-Y homologous gene Amelogenin. Analysis of PCR products employs denaturing polyacrylamide gels coupled with fluorescent labelled primers and detection is undertaken on ABD 373A automated sequencers. The technique was shown to be robust and reproducible when samples were analysed under conditions consistent with those encountered in a forensic environment. The system was demonstrated to be human specific and is suitable for use with both aged and degraded material. Somatic stability was proven with a wide range of tissue types and we were able to detect mixtures at ratios between 1:10 and 10:1. During this study no incidence of sample mis-typing due to allelic or locus drop-out was observed. Furthermore, although additional artefact bands were occasionally encountered these did not interfere with the interpretation of results. The performance of the system with poor quality samples demonstrated its suitability as a powerful tool in forensic investigation.

The validation of a 7-locus multiplex STR test for use in forensic casework. (II), Artefacts, casework studies and success rates

PCR-based DNA typing of biological evidence is now widely used in forensic analyses due to the obvious advantages of enhanced sensitivity, the ability to distinguish discrete alleles and efficacy with degraded samples. A multiplex short tandem repeat (STR) system has been previously developed which successfully co-amplifies six STR loci HUMTH01, D21S11, D18S51, D8S1179, HUMVWF31/A and HUMFIBRA (FGA) in conjunction with the X-Y homologous gene Amelogenin. This is known as the second generation multiplex system (SGM). Detection of the PCR products is undertaken on ABD 373A or 377 automated sequencers using denaturing polyacrylamide gels coupled with fluorescent-based technology. We have evaluated this system for routine forensic use and demonstrated that the technique is robust and reproducible under conditions consistent with those encountered in a forensic environment. A total of 132 stains from simulated and actual casework were analysed, together with relevant control areas and reference samples. The success rate was high with 76% of stains giving full profiles; we were also able to successfully detect and interpret mixtures. No mistyping was observed. A detailed examination of each of these profiles has assisted in the development of guidelines for casework interpretation. Although artefacts, stutter peaks and undenatured DNA were occasionally observed, these did not interfere with the accuracy of interpretation. In addition 38 samples, previously examined using the quadruplex system, were analysed with the SGM to enable a direct comparison to be made between the systems. The performance of the system with poor quality samples demonstrated its use as a rapid and powerful technique for individual identification.