Homing behavior of hippocampus and parahippocampus lesioned pigeons following short-distance releases

Spatial memory and hippocampal pallium through vertebrate evolution: insights from reptiles and teleost fish

The forebrain of vertebrates shows great morphological variation and specialized adaptations. However, an increasing amount of neuroanatomical and functional data reveal that the evolution of the vertebrate forebrain could have been more conservative than previously realized. For example, the pallial region of the teleost telencephalon contains subdivisions presumably homologous with various pallial areas in amniotes, including possibly a homologue of the medial pallium or hippocampus. In mammals and birds, the hippocampus is critical for encoding complex spatial information to form map-like cognitive representations of the environment. Here, we present data showing that the pallial areas of reptiles and fish, previously proposed as homologous to the hippocampus of mammals and birds on an anatomical basis, are similarly involved in spatial memory and navigation by map-like or relational representations of the allocentric space. These data suggest that early in vertebrate evolution, the medial pallium of an ancestral fish group that gave rise to the extant vertebrates became specialized for processing and encoding complex spatial information, and that this functional trait has been retained through the evolution of each independent vertebrate lineage.

Hippocampus and homing in pigeons: left and right hemispheric differences in navigational map learning

One-month-old, inexperienced homing pigeons, prior to any opportunity to learn a navigational map, were subjected to either right or left unilateral ablation of the hippocampal formation (HF). These pigeons were then held together with a group of age-matched control birds in an outdoor aviary, where they were kept for about 3 months with the opportunity to learn a navigational map. When subsequently tested for navigational map learning at about 4 months of age posthatching, control and right HF-ablated pigeons were equally good at orienting homeward from distant, unfamiliar locations, indicating successful navigational map learning. By contrast, left HF-ablated pigeons were impaired in orienting homeward, indicating a failure to learn a navigational map. Interestingly, both right and left HF-ablated pigeons displayed impaired homing performance relative to controls. These results suggest that different aspects of homing pigeon navigation may be lateralized to different hemispheres, and in particular, the HF of the different hemispheres. The left HF appears critical for navigational map learning, i.e. determining an approximate direction home from distant, unfamiliar locations. The right HF, and possibly the left HF as well, appear to play an important role in local navigation near the loft, which is likely based on familiar landmarks.

Dissociation of place and cue learning by telencephalic ablation in goldfish

This study examined the spatial strategies used by goldfish (Carassius auratus) to find a goal in a 4-arm maze and the involvement of the telencephalon in this spatial learning. Intact and telencephalon-ablated goldfish were trained to find food in an arm placed in a constant room location and signaled by a local visual cue (mixed place-cue procedure). Both groups learned the task, but they used different learning strategies. Telencephalon-ablated goldfish learned the task more quickly and made fewer errors to criterion than controls. Probe trials revealed that intact goldfish could use either a place or a cue strategy, whereas telencephalon-ablated goldfish learned only a cue strategy. The results offer additional evidence that place and cue learning in fish are subserved by different neural substrates and that the telencephalon of the teleost fish, or some unspecified structure within it, is important for spatial learning and memory in a manner similar to the hippocampus of mammals and birds.

Is the avian hippocampus a functional homologue of the mammalian hippocampus?

The effects of hippocampal lesions on the processing and retention of visual and spatial information in birds and mammals is reviewed. Both birds and mammals with damage to the hippocampus are severely impaired on a variety of spatial tasks, such as navigation, maze learning, and the retention of spatial information. In contrast, both birds and mammals with damage to the hippocampus are not impaired on a variety of visual tasks, such as delayed matching-to-sample, concurrent discrimination, or retention of a visual discrimination. In addition, both birds and mammals with hippocampal damage display impairments in the acquisition of an autoshaped response, as well as alterations in response suppression. These findings suggest that the avian hippocampus is a functional homologue of the mammalian hippocampus, and that in both birds and mammals the hippocampus is important for the processing and retention of spatial, rather than purely visual information.

The neuroanatomical correlates of route learning impairment

Recent functional imaging studies of topographical learning point to the participation of a large network of cortical and subcortical regions. Nevertheless, areas which are crucial remain poorly specified due to the absence of group studies of subjects with focal lesions distributed throughout the brain. We assessed the ability of 127 subjects with stable, focal lesions to learn a complex real-life route, a critical aspect of topographical functioning. Results indicated that impairment in route learning was highly associated with damage to medial occipital and posterior parahippocampal cortices in either hemisphere, the right hippocampus, and the right inferotemporal region. Impairment was seen among 86% of the subjects with damage to any these regions, in contrast to impairment among 31% of subjects with lesions in other regions. The importance of medial occipitotemporal cortices bilaterally and right inferotemporal cortex likely reflects the critical role of the ability to quickly and accurately perceive and learn multiple topographical scenes. The importance of the right (and probably left) posterior parahippocampal gyrus and of the right hippocampus likely reflects their critical, distinctive roles forming an integrated representation of the extended topographical environment (i.e., the appearance of places and spatial relationships between specific places), and consolidating that representation into multifaceted contextual knowledge of the environment.

Spatial learning-induced increase in the argyrophilic nucleolar organizer region of dorsolateral telencephalic neurons in goldfish

Spatial learning and memory related morphological changes in the argyrophilic nucleolar organizer region (AgNOR) of telencephalic neurons in goldfish were quantitatively evaluated by means of AgNOR neurohistochemical stain. The AgNORs and nuclei of nerve cells of two different telencephalic regions of goldfish trained in a spatial task or submitted to a similar non-contingent behavioral procedure (control group) were morphometrically evaluated. Results show that the area of AgNORs in goldfish dorsolateral telencephalic neurons increased significantly in the spatial learning group but not in control group. This effect seems to be highly specific as it did not appear in the dorsolateral area of the control group neither in the dorsomedial area of both groups. As the size of AgNORs in the nerve cell nuclei reflect the level of transcriptive activity, these morphological changes could be revealing increased protein synthesis in goldfish dorsolateral telencephalic neurons related with learning and memory. These findings could contribute to determining the subregions of the teleost telencephalon implicated in spatial learning and could indicate that the AgNOR staining technique would be a useful tool in assesing learning and memory related neuronal activity.

Reversal learning deficit in a spatial task but not in a cued one after telencephalic ablation in goldfish

The fish telencephalon seems to be involved in spatial learning and memory in a similar manner to the hippocampus of the land vertebrates. For instance, telencephalon ablated goldfish are impaired in the post-operative retention of a 'spatial constancy' task, which requires the use of mapping strategies, but not in a directly cued task in which responses are based in a guidance strategy. In this regard, previous experiments showed that intact goldfish trained in the spatial constancy task presented considerable behavioral flexibility, as they showed fast reversal learning, that is, they required less training compared with animals trained in the directly cued task and made a lower number of errors to master the reversal than in acquisition. The purpose of the present work was to investigate if the goldfish telencephalon is involved in the faster reversal learning of the animals trained in the spatial constancy task. Goldfish with bilateral telencephalic ablation, sham operated or intact, were trained in the spatial constancy task or in the directly cued task. Telencephalic ablation selectively impaired reversal learning in the animals trained in the spatial constancy procedure. Ablated animals in this procedure reversed more slowly than control animals. By contrast, telencephalic ablation did not produce any significant deficit during reversal in the animals trained in the directly cued task. These results provide additional evidence that the fish telencephalon, as the land vertebrate hippocampus, plays a crucial role in the use of flexible spatial representations.

Hippocampal participation in navigational map learning in young homing pigeons is dependent on training experience

The homing pigeon navigational map is perhaps one of the most striking examples of a naturally occurring spatial representation of the environment used to guide navigation. In a previous study, it was found that hippocampal lesions thoroughly disrupt the ability of young homing pigeons held in an outdoor aviary to learn a navigational map. However, since that study an accumulation of anecdotal data has hinted that hippocampal-lesioned young pigeons allowed to fly during their first summer could learn a navigational map. In the present study, young control and hippocampal-lesioned homing pigeons were either held in an outdoor aviary or allowed to fly during the time of navigational map learning. At the end of their first summer, the birds were experimentally released to test for navigational map learning. Independent of training experience, control pigeons oriented homeward during the experimental releases demonstrating that they learned a navigational map. Surprisingly, while the aviary-held hippocampal-lesioned pigeons failed to learn a navigational map as reported previously, hippocampal-lesioned birds allowed flight experience learned a navigational map indistinguishable from the two control groups. A subsequent experiment revealed that the navigational map learned by the three groups was based on atmospheric odours. The results demonstrate that hippocampal participation in navigational map learning depends on the type of experience a young bird pigeon has, and presumably, the type of navigational map learned.

Homing in pigeons: the role of the hippocampal formation in the representation of landmarks used for navigation

When given repeated training from a location, homing pigeons acquire the ability to use familiar landmarks to navigate home. Both control and hippocampal-lesioned pigeons succeed in learning to use familiar landmarks for homing. However, the landmark representations that guide navigation are strikingly different. Control and hippocampal-lesioned pigeons were initially given repeated training flights from two locations. On subsequent test days from the two training locations, all pigeons were rendered anosmic to eliminate use of their navigational map and were phase- or clock-shifted to examine the extent to which their learned landmark representations were dependent on the use of the sun as a compass. We show that control pigeons acquire a landmark representation that allows them to directly use landmarks without reference to the sun to guide their flight home, called "pilotage". Hippocampal-lesioned birds only learn to use familiar landmarks at the training location to recall the compass direction home, based on the sun, flown during training, called "site-specific compass orientation." The results demonstrate that for navigation of 20 km or more in a natural field setting, the hippocampal formation is necessary if homing pigeons are to learn a spatial representation based on numerous independent landmark elements that can be used to directly guide their return home.

Hippocampal lesion effects on learning strategies in homing pigeons

Several studies have shown that birds have a directional view of space and tend to use the sun compass over landmark beacons when both are available. Intact homing pigeons can use either the sun compass or colour beacons to locate a food reward, whereas pigeons with hippocampal lesions are unable to use the sun compass, but quickly learn to use colour beacons. We trained hippocampal ablated and intact pigeons to find a reward in an outdoor octagonal arena when both sun compass information (directional cues) and intramaze landmark beacons (colour cues) were available. The intact control pigeons learned the task by preferentially relying on directional cues while effectively ignoring the colour beacons. The behaviour of the hippocampal ablated birds, based on a clock-shift manipulation and after the rotation of the colour beacons, showed that they learned to locate the food reward in the arena only on the basis of the landmark beacons, ignoring the sun compass directional information.

Hippocampal participation in the sun compass orientation of phase-shifted homing pigeons

The orientation of phase-shifted control and hippocampal lesioned homing pigeons with previous homing experience was examined to investigate the possible participation of the hippocampal formation in sun compass orientation. Hippocampal lesioned pigeons displayed appropriate shifts in orientation indicating that such birds possess a functional sun compass that is used for orientation. However, their shift in orientation was consistently larger than in control pigeons revealing a difference in orientation never observed in pigeons that have not undergone a phase shift. Although alternative interpretations exist, the data suggest the intriguing possibility that following a change in the light-dark cycle, the hippocampal formation participates in the re-entrainment of a circadian rhythm that regulates sun compass orientation.

Hippocampal volume in migratory and non-migratory warblers: effects of age and experience

We tested the hypothesis that experience of migration from Europe to tropical Africa by Garden Warblers is associated with changes in the relative volume of the hippocampus, a brain region thought to be involved in processing spatial information, including that used in navigation. Relative hippocampal volume was larger in birds at least one year old that had migrated to and from Africa, than in naive birds approx. 3 months old. Further comparisons between groups of differing age and experience of migration suggested that both experience and age during the first year have an effect of relative hippocampal volume. The increase in relative hippocampal volume was mainly due to a decrease in the size of the telencephalon; however, the comparison between young, naive birds and older, experienced birds also suggests a possible increase in absolute hippocampal volume. The latter is associated with an increase in number and density of neurons, whilst the former is associated with an increase in density but no change in total number of neurons. In a non-migratory close relative of the garden warbler, the Sardinian warbler, older birds had a smaller telencephalon but there was no change in hippocampal volume, which supports the view that changes in the hippocampus may be associated with migratory experience, whilst changes in the telencephalon are not.

The muscarinic acetylcholine antagonist scopolamine impairs short-distance homing pigeon navigation

The present study employed intramuscular (i.m.) injections of the acetylcholine (ACh) receptor antagonist scopolamine hydrobromide (0.10 mg/kg) to investigate the possible involvement of ACh in naturally occurring spatial navigation in homing pigeons (Columba livia). Control pigeons receiving injections of saline or scopolamine methylbromide, an ACh antagonist that does not cross the blood-brain barrier, were oriented in a homeward direction when released from a location 8 km from home. In contrast, pigeons injected with scopolamine hydrobromide (0.10 mg/kg, i.m.) were less well oriented and took more time to return home from the same location. These results suggest that homing pigeon navigation is regulated, in part, by central cholinergic mechanisms.

Telencephalic ablation in goldfish impairs performance in a 'spatial constancy' problem but not in a cued one

This work was aimed to study if goldfish telencephalon is involved differentially in spatial and cue learning. With this purpose, animals were assigned to two learning conditions, 'spatial constancy' and 'directly cued', and their performance was recorded before and after ablation of the telencephalon. During the presurgical acquisition period, animals of both groups learned to solve the task with accuracy, and reached the goal in transfer tests, even though they were released from new starting positions and the response requirements were changed. Ablation impaired selectively the solution of the spatial constancy problem, but had no significant effects on the cued condition. However, with additional training, performance of the ablated animals in the spatial constancy condition improved to control levels. The above data suggest that fishes can implement multiple spatial learning strategies which have different neural substrata. These results are discussed in relation to the possible nature of the representation underlying each task.

Dopaminergic innervation of the telencephalon of the pigeon (Columba livia): a study with antibodies against tyrosine hydroxylase and dopamine

The dopaminergic structures in the telencephalon of the pigeon were investigated with antisera against glutaraldehyde-conjugated dopamine (DA) and tyrosine hydroxylase (TH). Our goal was to describe the morphological patterns of the labelled axons and to provide a detailed map of the density and regional distribution of the dopaminergic innervation in relation to cytoarchitectonic areas. DA- and TH-like fibers reached their highest density in the paleostriatum augmentatum and the lobus parolfactorius of the basal ganglia. The paleostriatum primitivum was characterized by a dichotomous DA-positive innervation with a diffuse fiber network contacting enpassant granular cells and a more specific input that completely wrapped up large cells, which probably represent relay neurons. Two distinct DA-positive pathways could be followed back from the forebrain leading to the dopaminergic cell groups of the nucleus tegmenti pedunuculopontinus pars lateralis and the area ventralis tegmentalis. The primary sensory areas of the visual, auditory, somatosensory, and trigeminal systems within the forebrain of the pigeon were virtually devoid of DA-like fibers and demonstrated only TH-positive axons, probably of a noradrenergic nature. Among the limbic structures, the neostriatum caudolaterale (a possible equivalent of the mammalian prefrontal cortex), the septum, the nucleus accumbens, and parts of the archistriatum were heavily labelled by DA-like axons. A highly characteristic morphological feature of the catecholaminergic innervation was the presence of "baskets," which are constituted by TH- and DA-positive fibers coiled up around large perikarya, so that the surrounded somata were virtually visible by the presence of labelled axons. The density of basket and nonbasket type innervations seemed to be independently regulated, so that each forebrain structure could be characterized by a mixture consisting of the individual degrees of these two features. Our results demonstrate that the dopaminergic innervation of the forebrain of the pigeon is widespread but shows important regional variations. Similar to mammals, associative and motor structures are heavily innervated by dopaminergic fibers, whereas sensory areas are dominated by their noradrenergic input. The basket and nonbasket type innervations observed in virtually all of these subdivisions of the telencephalon may indicate the presence of two main classes of catecholaminergic afferents with different mechanisms of modulation of forebrain activity patterns.

Organization of the avian "corticostriatal" projection system: a retrograde and anterograde pathway tracing study in pigeons

Birds have well-developed basal ganglia within the telencephalon, including a striatum consisting of the medially located lobus parolfactorius (LPO) and the laterally located paleostriatum augmentatum (PA). Relatively little is known, however, about the extent and organization of the telencephalic "cortical" input to the avian basal ganglia (i.e., the avian "corticostriatal" projection system). Using retrograde and anterograde neuroanatomical pathway tracers to address this issue, we found that a large continuous expanse of the outer pallium projects to the striatum of the basal ganglia in pigeons. This expanse includes the Wulst and archistriatum as well as the entire outer rind of the pallium intervening between Wulst and archistriatum, termed by us the pallium externum (PE). In addition, the caudolateral neostriatum (NCL), pyriform cortex, and hippocampal complex also give rise to striatal projections in pigeon. A restricted number of these pallial regions (such as the "limbic" NCL, pyriform cortex, and ventral/caudal parts of the archistriatum) project to such ventral striatal structures as the olfactory tubercle (TO), nucleus accumbens (Ac), and bed nucleus of the stria terminalis (BNST). Such "limbic" pallial areas also project to medialmost LPO and lateralmost PA, while the hyperstriatum accessorium portion of the Wulst, the PE, and the dorsal parts of the archistriatum were found to project primarily to the remainder of LPO (the lateral two-thirds) and PA (the medial four-fifths). The available evidence indicates that the diverse pallial regions projecting to the striatum in birds, as in mammals, are parts of higher order sensory or motor systems. The extensive corticostriatal system in both birds and mammals appears to include two types of pallial neurons: 1) those that project to both striatum and brainstem (i.e., those in the Wulst and the archistriatum) and 2) those that project to striatum but not to brainstem (i.e., those in the PE). The lack of extensive corticostriatal projections from either type of neuron in anamniotes suggests that the anamniote-amniote evolutionary transition was marked by the emergence of the corticostriatal projection system as a prominent source of sensory and motor information for the striatum, possibly facilitating the role of the basal ganglia in movement control.

Neuroactive substances in the developing dorsomedial telencephalon of the pigeon (Columba livia): differential distribution and time course of maturation

The avian hippocampal formation has previously been shown to contain many of the same neurotransmitters and related enzymes that are found in mammals. In order to determine whether the relatively delayed development of the mammalian hippocampus is typical of other vertebrates, we investigated the maturation of a variety of neuroactive substances in the hippocampal formation of the homing pigeon. The distribution of two transmitter-related enzymes, choline acetyltransferase (ChAT) and tyrosine hydroxylase (TH), the neurotransmitter GABA, and four neuropeptides (substance P, enkephalin, neuropeptide Y, and somatostatin) was studied by immunohistochemistry in the developing hippocampal complex. The pattern and/or the time course of changes in the distribution of immunoreactivity varied among the different neuroactive substances examined. Immunoreactivity to ChAT and TH was found exclusively in fibers and terminal-like processes, whereas GABA and peptide immunoreactivity was seen in cells and neuropil. Quantitative differences in the density, number, and size of stained cells were assessed by a computer-assisted image analyzer. For the majority of the substances, developmental patterns in the distribution of immunoreactivity differ between the hippocampus proper and the area parahippocampalis, the two major areas that together make up the avian hippocampal complex. The adult pattern of immunoreactivity was generally attained by 3 weeks after hatching. For many of the neuroactive substances found in cell bodies, there was a gradual decrease in the density of immunoreactive cells with a concomitant increase in the density of immunoreactive neuropil. The actual number of stained cells usually increased to a peak at 9 days posthatching and then declined until 3 weeks posthatching, when the adult value was reached. These results are discussed in relation to the advantages that the pigeon hippocampal complex may provide in the study of developmental processes. Parallels with the distribution of the same neuroactive substances in the mammalian hippocampus are used to suggest possible functional similarities between the avian and mammalian hippocampal regions.

The NMDA-receptor antagonist MK-801 impairs navigational learning in homing pigeons

The present study employed the N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptor antagonist MK-801 to investigate the possible importance of NMDA receptor activation for naturally occurring spatial learning in birds by exploiting the navigational ability of homing pigeons (Columba livia). Control pigeons released from two unfamiliar release sites displayed vanishing bearings that were poorly oriented. However, when released a second time from the same sites they displayed improved homeward orientation. The control birds apparently learned something about the spatial relationships of stimuli at the release sites on the first releases and used that information to orient better when released a second time from the same locations. Experimental pigeons given the NMDA receptor antagonist MK-801 (0.10 mg/kg) initially behaved as controls, orienting poorly when released for the first time from the two sites. In contrast to controls, the experimental birds failed to show significant improvement in orientation when released again from the same sites without MK-801. A second experiment revealed no state-dependent learning. Results of a position/color discrimination task showed that the impairments observed did not generalize to associative learning in an operant chamber, and together with field observations were not a result of sensory or motor drug effects. The data indicate that blocking NMDA receptors can disrupt navigational learning in homing pigeons. As such, the results are consistent with the hypothesis that NMDA receptor activation plays an important role in spatial learning in birds.

Visual performance of pigeons following hippocampal lesions

The effect of hippocampal lesions on performance in two psychophysical measures of spatial vision (acuity and size-difference threshold) was examined in 7 pigeons. No difference between the preoperative and postoperative thresholds of the experimental birds was found. The visual performance of pigeons in the psychophysical tasks failed to reveal a role of the hippocampal formation in vision. The results argue strongly that the behavioral deficits found in pigeons with hippocampal lesions when tested in a variety of memory-related spatial tasks is not based on a defect in spatial vision but impaired spatial cognition.

The importance of comparative studies and ecological validity for understanding hippocampal structure and cognitive function

Building from the premise that hippocampal cognitive function has been molded by natural selection under natural environmental conditions, it is argued that traditional laboratory studies likely do not reveal the richness and complexity of hippocampal function. Research on the role of the hippocampal formation in the navigational behavior of homing pigeons is offered as an example to illustrate the advantages of using an ecological approach to understand hippocampal function. It is further proposed that dissimilarities in hippocampal anatomy, physiology, and neurochemistry found between species reflect species differences in the range of functions served by the hippocampal formation, as well as possibly the molecular and cellular mechanisms that support such functions. These differences notwithstanding, it is suggested that, from an evolutionary perspective, the primary function of the hippocampal formation is a role in some aspect of spatial cognition. Dissimilarities in hippocampal structure and function among extant species are viewed as resulting from differences in evolutionary selective pressure and evolutionary history.

Food-storing birds: adaptive specialization in brain and behaviour?

Among the passerine birds, species that store food have an enlarged hippocampal region (dorso-medial cortex), relative to brain and body size, when compared with the non-storers. The volume of one of the major afferent-efferent pathways (the septo-hippocampal pathway) is also greater in food storing species. This specialization of brain structure is discussed in relation to behavioural studies in which the spatial memory of storing and non-storing species has been compared.