Reproducibility, and sensitivity to motor unit loss in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis, of a novel MUNE method: MScanFit MUNE

Biomarkers in Motor Neuron Disease: A State of the Art Review

Motor neuron disease can be viewed as an umbrella term describing a heterogeneous group of conditions, all of which are relentlessly progressive and ultimately fatal. The average life expectancy is 2 years, but with a broad range of months to decades. Biomarker research deepens disease understanding through exploration of pathophysiological mechanisms which, in turn, highlights targets for novel therapies. It also allows differentiation of the disease population into sub-groups, which serves two general purposes: (a) provides clinicians with information to better guide their patients in terms of disease progression, and (b) guides clinical trial design so that an intervention may be shown to be effective if population variation is controlled for. Biomarkers also have the potential to provide monitoring during clinical trials to ensure target engagement. This review highlights biomarkers that have emerged from the fields of systemic measurements including biochemistry (blood, cerebrospinal fluid, and urine analysis); imaging and electrophysiology, and gives examples of how a combinatorial approach may yield the best results. We emphasize the importance of systematic sample collection and analysis, and the need to correlate biomarker findings with detailed phenotype and genotype data.

Multiple Point Stimulation MUNE in ALS: Toward a Faster Modification

PURPOSE

Multiple point stimulation is a well-established motor unit number estimate method that can be used in all EMG machines, but it is time-consuming. We investigated whether a faster modification of multiple point stimulation using five surface motor unit action potentials (sMUAP) had similar reproducibility, sensitivity, and specificity as 10.

METHODS

Twenty-two motor neuron disease patients and 20 healthy controls were prospectively examined by two physicians twice in the thenar muscles.

RESULTS

A total of 168 multiple point stimulation motor unit number estimate recordings were obtained. Mean motor unit number estimate was significantly lower in patients in contrast to the controls, whether using 5 (53 ± 55 [1-170] vs. 150 ± 64 (51-325), P < 0.001] or 10 sMUAP [52 ± 51 (1-162) vs. 151 ± 50 (75-274), P < 0.001]. No significant differences (P > 0.05) were found between mean motor unit number estimate obtained from 5 or 10 sMUAP in both patients and controls. Intra-rater coefficient of variation (CV) for patients (17% vs. 15%) and controls (16% vs. 13%) and inter-rater coefficient of variation for patients (25% vs. 24%) did not differ between five and 10 sMUAP (P > 0.05), whereas interrater coefficient of variation was higher for five sMUAP in controls (21% vs. 16%, P = 0.004). An excellent intraclass correlation coefficient (≥0.78) was found, sampling either 5 or 10 sMUAP, for both groups. Receiver operating characteristic curves collecting 5 or 10 sMUAP showed excellent accuracy in distinguishing between patients and controls.

CONCLUSIONS

The faster modification of Multiple point stimulation by sampling five sMUAP had similar reproducibility, sensitivity, and specificity as 10 and may be suggested in future research and clinical practice.

A review of electrophysiological studies of lower motor neuron involvement in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is a neurodegenerative disease involving both the upper and lower motor neuron diseases. In this review, we studied and compared different articles regarding the electrodiagnostic criteria for diagnosis of lower motor neuron pathology in ALS. We reviewed the most recent articles and metaanalysis regarding various lower motor neuron electrodiagnostic methods for ALS and their sensitivities. We concluded that Awaji Shima criteria is by far the most sensitive criteria for diagnosis of ALS.

In vivo evidence for reduced ion channel expression in motor axons of patients with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis

KEY POINTS

The progressive loss of motor units in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is initially compensated for by the reinnervation of denervated muscle fibres by surviving motor axons. A disruption in protein homeostasis is thought to play a critical role in the pathogenesis of ALS. The changes in surviving motor neurons were studied by comparing the nerve excitability properties of moderately and severely affected single motor axons from patients with ALS with those from single motor axons in control subjects. A mathematical model indicated that approximately 99% of the differences between the ALS and control units could be explained by a non-selective reduction in the expression of all ion channels. These changes in ALS patients are best explained by a failure in the supply of ion channel and other membrane proteins from the diseased motor neuron.

ABSTRACT

Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) is characterised by a progressive loss of motor units and the reinnervation of denervated muscle fibres by surviving motor axons. This reinnervation preserves muscle function until symptom onset, when some 60-80% of motor units have been lost. We have studied the changes in surviving motor neurons by comparing the nerve excitability properties of 31 single motor axons from patients with ALS with those from 21 single motor axons in control subjects. ALS motor axons were classified as coming from moderately or severely affected muscles according to the compound muscle action potential amplitude of the parent muscle. Compared with control units, thresholds were increased, and there was reduced inward and outward rectification and greater superexcitability following a conditioning impulse. These abnormalities were greater in axons from severely affected muscles, and were correlated with loss of fine motor skills. A mathematical model indicated that 99.1% of the differences between the moderately affected ALS and control units could be explained by a reduction in the expression of all ion channels. For the severely affected units, modelling required, in addition, an increase in the current leak through and under the myelin sheath. This might be expected if the anchoring proteins responsible for the paranodal seal were reduced. We conclude that changes in axonal excitability identified in ALS patients are best explained by a failure in the supply of ion channel and other membrane proteins from the diseased motor neuron, a conclusion consistent with recent animal and in vitro human data.

Motor unit number estimation of human abductor hallucis from a compound muscle action potential scan

INTRODUCTION

This study performed motor unit number estimation (MUNE) of the abductor hallucis (AH) muscle from 16 healthy control participants on the basis of the compound muscle action potential (CMAP) scan.

METHODS

Muscle responses to electrical stimuli ranging from subthreshold to supramaximal intensity were recorded, and MUNE was determined from a model of the responses (MScanFit program).

RESULTS

The average CMAP amplitude and MUNE of the AH for the right and left sides combined were 19.6 ± 0.75 mV and 127 ± 5 (mean ± SE), respectively.

DISCUSSION

Findings of the study provide useful information about the motor unit number of the AH. Muscle Nerve 58: 735-737, 2018.

The utility of motor unit number index: A systematic review

The need for a valid biomarker for assessing disease progression and for use in clinical trials on amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) has stimulated the study of methods that could measure the number of motor units. Motor unit number index (MUNIX) is a newly developed neurophysiological technique that was demonstrated to have a good correlation with the number of motor units in a given muscle, even though it does not necessarily accurately express the actual number of viable motor neurons. Several studies demonstrated the technique is reproducible and capable of following motor neuron loss in patients with ALS and peripheral polyneuropathies. The main goal of this review was to conduct an extensive review of the literature using MUNIX. We conducted a systematic search in English medical literature published in two databases (PubMed and SCOPUS). In this review, we aimed to answer the following queries: Comparison of MUNIX with other MUNE techniques; the reproducibility of MUNIX; the utility of MUNIX in ALS and preclinical muscles, peripheral neuropathies, and other neurological disorders.

Reproducibility of motor unit number index and multiple point stimulation motor unit number estimation in controls

INTRODUCTION

Reproducibility of the multiple point stimulation motor unit number estimation (MPS-MUNE) technique was compared with the recently developed motor unit number index (MUNIX) technique.

METHODS

MPS-MUNE and MUNIX were performed on 15 healthy subjects at 3 different time-points by the same examiner. Reproducibility was analyzed using intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) and coefficient of variation (CV).

RESULTS

ICC values for MUNIX and MPS-MUNE were excellent across 3 tests (0.80 and 0.77, respectively), although CV values were significantly lower for MUNIX than MPS-MUNE (P < 0.01). In addition, test-retest reproducibility was better for MUNIX, a finding largely attributable to poor reproducibility of the single motor unit action potential area. MUNIX (R = -0.48, P < 0.05) and MPS-MUNE (R = -0.53, P < 0.05) were significantly correlated with age.

DISCUSSION

MUNIX demonstrated better intrarater reproducibility and may be a more reliable neurophysiological biomarker than MPS-MUNE. Muscle Nerve 58: 660-664, 2018.

CMAP Scan MUNE (MScan) - A Novel Motor Unit Number Estimation (MUNE) Method

Like other methods for motor unit number estimation (MUNE), compound muscle action potential (CMAP) scan MUNE (MScan) is a non-invasive electrophysiologic method to estimate the number of functioning motor units in a muscle. MUNE is an important tool for the assessment of neuropathies and neuronopathies. Unlike most MUNE methods in use, MScan assesses all the motor units in a muscle, by fitting a model to a detailed stimulus-response curve, or CMAP scan. It thereby avoids the bias inherent in all MUNE methods based on extrapolating from a small sample of units. Like 'Bayesian MUNE,' MScan analysis works by fitting a model, made up of motor units with different amplitudes, thresholds, and threshold variabilities, but the fitting method is quite different, and completed within five minutes, rather than several hours. The MScan off-line analysis works in two stages: first, a preliminary model is generated based on the slope and variance of the points in the scan, and second, this model is then refined by adjusting all the parameters to improve the fit between the original scan and scans generated by the model. This new method has been tested for reproducibility and recording time on 22 amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS) patients and 20 healthy controls, with each test repeated twice by two blinded physicians. MScan showed excellent intra- and inter-rater reproducibility with ICC values of >0.98 and a coefficient of variation averaging 12.3 ± 1.6%. There was no difference in the intra-rater reproducibility between the two observers. Average recording time was 6.27 ± 0.27 min. This protocol describes how to record a CMAP scan and how to use the MScan software to derive an estimate of the number and sizes of the functioning motor units. MScan is a fast, convenient, and reproducible method, which may be helpful in diagnoses and monitoring disease progression in neuromuscular disorders.

Excitability of sensory axons in amyotrophic lateral sclerosis

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the excitability of sensory axons in patients with amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS).

METHODS

Comprehensive sensory nerve excitability studies were prospectively performed on 28 sporadic ALS patients, compared to age-matched controls. Sensory nerve action potentials were recorded from digit 2 following median nerve stimulation at the wrist. Disease severity was measured using motor unit number estimation (MUNE), the revised ALS Functional Rating Scale (ALSFRS-R) and the MRC scale.

RESULTS

There were no significant differences in standard and extended measures of nerve excitability between ALS patients and controls. These unchanged excitability measures included accommodation to long-lasting hyperpolarization and the threshold changes after two supramaximal stimuli during the recovery cycle. Excitability parameters did not correlate with MUNE, ALSFRS-R, APB MRC scale or disease duration.

CONCLUSIONS

This cross-sectional study has identified normal axonal membrane properties in myelinated sensory axons of ALS patients. Previously described sensory abnormalities could be the result of axonal fallout, possibly due to a ganglionopathy, or to involvement of central sensory pathways rostral to gracile and cuneate nuclei.

SIGNIFICANCE

These results demonstrate the absence of generalized dysfunction of the membrane properties of sensory axons in ALS in the face of substantial deficits in motor function.