Effects of balance and proprioceptive training on total hip and knee replacement rehabilitation: A systematic review and meta-analysis

The effects of preoperative balance training on balance and functional outcome after total knee replacement: a randomized controlled trial

Objective:

To assess the effects of preoperative balance training on the early postoperative balance and functional outcomes after total knee replacement surgery and to test whether an outpatient intervention may be as effective as a domiciliary intervention.

Design:

This is a three-arm randomized controlled trial.

Setting:

University hospital.

Subjects:

Eighty-six individuals were recruited. Seventy-seven were analysed, aged 72.1 (SD 7.6) years, of which 68% were women.

Outcome measures:

Overall state of balance, as measured with the Berg Balance Scale, and patient-perceived functionality, as measured with the Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score Function in Activities in Daily Living (KOOS-ADL) questionnaire, were the primary outcomes. Secondary assessments targeted knee function, balance and mobility, quality of life, and self-reported outcomes. The primary end-point was six weeks after surgery.

Intervention:

The hospital group implemented a four-week preoperative outpatient balance-oriented intervention. The home group implemented similar training, but this was domiciliary. The control group was instructed to keep performing their normal activities.

Results:

Home and hospital groups presented a moderate effect against the control group ( dhospital-control = 0.54; dhome-control = 0.63), both being similarly effective in improving the overall state of balance at six weeks after surgery ( P = 0.013). KOOS-ADL scores showed no between-group differences and a small effect size ( d < 0.5; P = 0.937). Secondary assessments suggested non-significant between-group differences.

Conclusion:

Preoperative balance training, conducted either as domiciliary or as an outpatient, is an effective approach to enhance early postoperative balance outcome but not the perceived functionality of individuals undergoing total knee replacement.

Effects of total hip arthroplasty for primary hip osteoarthritis on postural balance: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Hip osteoarthritis is one of the major causes of disability worldwide, and although total hip arthroplasty is considered effective in the management of this condition, its effects on postural balance remain unclear.

RESEARCH QUESTION

What are the effects of total hip arthroplasty for primary hip osteoarthritis on the postural balance compared to preoperative status and/or to healthy controls?.

METHOD

A systematic review was conducted, and the Embase, Latin American and Caribbean Health Sciences (LILACS), PubMed, Scopus, The Cochrane Library, and Web of Science databases were searched. Randomized and non-randomized studies were considered eligible for inclusion. The risk of bias of included studies was assessed using the Joanna Briggs Institute critical appraisal tools.

RESULTS

Among the 41 potentially eligible studies, 13 studies were included for qualitative synthesis-8 studies had low risk of bias and 5 had moderate risk of bias. Ten studies compared the effects of total hip arthroplasty on the postural balance in healthy controls. Meanwhile, the remaining 3 studies compared such effects to the preoperative status only. Comparable results on the postural balance between the intervention and control groups were observed in 5 studies, whereas 3 studies showed better scores among healthy controls. The other 2 studies reported that postural balance could still be impaired at 6 months to 3 years postoperatively. All 3 studies with no healthy controls reported an improvement in the postural balance compared to the preoperative status.

CONCLUSIONS

Major post-surgical improvements were consistently observed compared to preoperative status, although postural balance impairment was still noted compared to healthy controls.

SIGNIFICANCE

The results of this study might be a useful guide for clinicians on the extent of the therapeutic effects of hip arthroplasty on postural balance. Furthermore, the standardization of balance assessment tools could strengthen the certainty of cumulative evidence in future studies.

Functional and postural recovery after bilateral or unilateral total hip arthroplasty

One-stage bilateral total hip arthroplasty (THA) implies similar complication rate and hospitalization time to unilateral THA, but no studies have evaluated the functional and postural recovery in these patients. The aim of this study was to assess short-term functional and postural recovery in patients after one-stage bilateral or unilateral THA. Forty patients undergoing bilateral (n = 20) or unilateral (n = 20) THA were assessed by Timed Up and Go (TUG), Numeric Rating Scale (NRS), Tampa Scale of Kinesiophobia (TSK) and Body Weight Distribution Symmetry Index (BWDSI) during stand-to-sit (STS). Centre of Pressure (CoP) parameters and BWDSI during standing with eyes open (EO) and closed (EC) were also assessed. Data were collected one day before surgery, at three and seven days. No between-group differences were found for TUG, NRS and TSK at any time-point, showing similar mobility, pain and fear of movement in both groups. BWDSI during STS (P = 0.001) and standing (OE P = 0.007; CE P = 0.012) revealed differences over time in favor of patients with bilateral THA, who showed better symmetry in weight distribution. Shorter CoP path length was observed during standing in patients with unilateral THA (OE P = 0.023; CE P = 0.018), who mainly used their non-affected limb to maintain balance.

The efficacy of virtual reality tools for total knee replacement rehabilitation: A systematic review

Purpose. To assess the effects of training with virtual reality tools (VRT) during rehabilitation of patients after total knee replacement (TKR). Methods. Systematic review. Six databases were queried. Search criteria included studies in which participants underwent TKR, took part in a rehabilitation protocol with VRT, and clinical outcomes of rehabilitation were considered. Available demographic, interventional and outcome data, along with functional, balance, and pain outcome measures were extracted. Patient satisfaction was also summarized. Results. Six trials were included. Available information shows that multi-modal intervention with VRT is used primarily to augment conventional rehabilitation. The Wii Balance Board is the most frequently used device. Conclusions. Findings suggest that an augmented VRT physical therapy intervention that is specifically-oriented to enhance balance could be more effective for overcoming balance limitations than standard physical therapy. However, rehabilitation with VRT has no advantage over conventional training for enhancing function, resolving pain, or increasing patient satisfaction after TKR. Future studies are needed to confirm the findings, particularly regarding the feasibility of preoperative and continued in-home intervention. Registration: CRD42017057087.

Comparison of total hip arthroplasty surgical approaches by Statistical Parametric Mapping

BACKGROUND

The most common surgical approaches in use for total hip arthroplasty are the lateral and posterior. When comparing these approaches in terms of gait biomechanics, studies usually rely on pre-defined discrete variables related to the events of gait cycle. However, this analysis may miss differences in other parts of the movement pattern that are not explored. We applied Statistical Parametric Mapping to compare hip kinematics between patients who underwent arthroplasty using either a lateral or posterior approach, contrasting these results with discrete variable analysis.

METHODS

Twenty-two participants (11 lateral, 11 posterior; age between 50 and 80 years) underwent gait analysis before, 3 weeks and 12 weeks after hip arthroplasty. One-dimensional (e.g. time-varying) trajectories and zero-dimensional (e.g. peak extension) discrete variables were used to assess differences between groups in each plane of hip movement (sagittal, frontal, and transverse).

FINDINGS

One-dimensional and zero-dimensional analyses found no significant differences between groups. Statistical Parametric Mapping revealed that both groups presented significant changes over time in hip adduction at 11-43% of the gait cycle. Zero-dimensional analysis seems to overstate sagittal plane changes over time since no such changes were found by Statistical Parametric Mapping.

INTERPRETATION

Our results agreed with previous studies suggesting that surgical approach do not affect hip kinematics at the early post-operative stage after arthroplasty. However, Statistical Parametric Mapping revealed changes in frontal plane kinematics over time that were underestimated by the zero-dimensional variables. These findings suggest hip adduction impairment up to 12 weeks after arthroplasty.