Safety of Combined Immunotherapy and Thoracic Radiation Therapy: Analysis of 3 Single-Institutional Phase I/II Trials

Toxicity of radiation and immunotherapy combinations

Purpose

Although immunotherapy is a rapidly emerging modality for cancer care, there have been multiple reports of fatal toxicities. There have also been cases of treatment-related deaths with combined non-immunotherapeutic biologic compounds with radiation therapy. Thus, provision of summative information appraising the safety of combinatorial immunotherapy and radiation therapy (iRT) is imperative. Because this has not been well characterized, this review summarizes the available evidence to date.

Methods and materials

Owing to the heterogeneity and relatively low quantity of published reports, this review was conducted in a narrative rather than systematic format.

Results

The results of combined iRT, both concurrent and sequential, are discussed for oncologic therapy of the brain, lung, liver, and prostate. Most evidence is from small samples and shorter follow-up but does consist of multiple prospective publications. Most data exist for ipilimumab, with programmed cell death -1 inhibitors emerging in more recent years. With 2 large phase 3 trials as exceptions, there were no instances of iRT-related deaths across all discussed studies. Altogether, grade 3 to 4 toxicities were relatively low in frequency; of the studies that compared iRT with an “immunotherapy only” or “RT only” cohort, none documented a clear increase in high-grade adverse events with combined-modality management.

Conclusions

Despite the low quantity of data, combined iRT offers encouraging safety profiles. There is no evidence that iRT produces an overt increase in high-grade toxicities. Further data, especially on concurrent iRT, are anticipated from numerous iRT trials that are currently ongoing worldwide.

Combining stereotactic body radiation therapy with immunotherapy: current data and future directions

Stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) offers excellent local control of early-stage non-small cell lung cancer (NSCLC), but there currently is a need for tolerable systemic therapy to address regional and distant disease progression. One potential option is immunotherapy, which in metastatic NSCLC has shown promise for sustained disease control in a subset of patients. There is also growing evidence for a clinical synergy between radiation and immunotherapy, with several ongoing trials studying the abscopal effect. This review summarizes the current data in the fast-changing field of immuno-radiation therapy, highlighting updates from recent clinical trials.