Profile of injuries arising from the 2005 Kashmir earthquake: the first 72 h

Multiple injuries after earthquakes: a retrospective analysis on 1,871 injured patients from the 2008 Wenchuan earthquake

Introduction

Multiple injuries have been highlighted as an important clinical dimension of the injury profile following earthquakes, but studies are scarce. We investigated the pattern and combination of injuries among patients with two injuries following the 2008 Wenchuan earthquake. We also described the general injury profile, causes of injury and socio-demographic characteristics of the injured patients.

Methods

A retrospective hospital-based analysis of 1,871 earthquake injured patients, totaling 3,177 injuries, admitted between 12 and 31 May 2008 to the People's Hospital of Deyang city (PHDC). An electronic, webserver-based database with International Classification of Diseases (ICD)-10-based classification of earthquake-related injury diagnoses (IDs), anatomical sites and additional background variables of the inpatients was used. We analyzed this dataset for injury profile and number of injuries per patient. We then included all patients (856) with two injuries for more in-depth analysis. Possible spatial anatomical associations were determined a priori. Cross-tabulation and more complex frequency matrices for combination analyses were used to investigate the injury profile.

Results

Out of the 1,871 injured patients, 810 (43.3%) presented with a single injury. The rest had multiple injuries; 856 (45.8%) had two, 169 (9.0%) patients had three, 32 (1.7%) presented with four injuries, while only 4 (0.2%) were diagnosed with five injuries. The injury diagnoses of patients presenting with two-injuries showed important anatomical intra-site or neighboring clustering, which explained 49.1% of the combinations. For fractures, the result was even more marked as spatial clustering explained 57.9% of the association pattern. The most frequent combination of IDs was a double-fracture, affecting 20.7% of the two-injury patients (n = 177). Another 108 patients (12.6%) presented with fractures associated with crush injury and organ-soft tissue injury. Of the 3,177 injuries, 1,476 (46.5%) were fractures. Most injuries were located in the head (22.9%) and lower extremities (30.8%).

Conclusions

Multiple injuries are put forward as an important component of the injury profile after this earthquake. A pattern of injury combinations and spatial aggregation of injuries was also found. Clinical diagnosis and treatment should be adapted to care of these patients. More studies are needed to generalize these findings.

Medical complications associated with earthquakes

Major earthquakes are some of the most devastating natural disasters. The epidemiology of earthquake-related injuries and mortality is unique for these disasters. Because earthquakes frequently affect populous urban areas with poor structural standards, they often result in high death rates and mass casualties with many traumatic injuries. These injuries are highly mechanical and often multisystem, requiring intensive curative medical and surgical care at a time when the local and regional medical response capacities have been at least partly disrupted. Many patients surviving blunt and penetrating trauma and crush injuries have subsequent complications that lead to additional morbidity and mortality. Here, we review and summarise earthquake-induced injuries and medical complications affecting major organ systems.

Earthquake-related injuries: evaluation with multidetector computed tomography and digital radiography of 1491 patients

PURPOSE

The aim of this study was to evaluate the common features of earthquake-related injuries using radiography and computed tomography.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We retrospectively reviewed the radiography and multidetector computed tomography features of 1491 patients injured in 2008 Sichuan earthquake. We categorized patients by age group (<35, 35-64, and ≥ 65 years) and time to imaging. Injuries were categorized by anatomical distribution.

RESULTS

We detected earthquake-related trauma in 1197 patients (80.28%), including head injuries, facial fractures, thoracic injuries, abdominal injuries, pelvic fractures, spinal injuries, and extremity fractures in 91, 41, 354, 30, 204, 299, and 732 (61.15%) patients, respectively (χ(2) = 1844.747, P < .001). Injuries in 2 or more anatomical locations occurred in 384 cases. We discovered significant difference in the anatomical distribution of injuries among the 3 age groups (χ(2) = 104.113, P < .001) and among the time-to-imaging categories (χ(2) = 64.420, P < .001). Twenty-two patients (1.48%) eventually died. Abdominal injuries (B = 2.285, P = .004), head injuries (B = 2.194, P < .001), thoracic injuries (B = 1.989, P < .001), and age (B = 1.539, P < .001) were all associated with patient death.

CONCLUSIONS

The Sichuan earthquake most commonly resulted in extremity fractures, but there was a high incidence of injuries to multiple body areas. Head, abdominal, and thoracic injuries and age older than 64 years all were significant risk factors for earthquake mortality.

Using robotic telecommunications to triage pediatric disaster victims

PURPOSE

During a disaster, hospitals may be overwhelmed and have an insufficient number of pediatric specialists available to care for injured children. The aim of this study was to determine the feasibility of remotely providing pediatric expertise via a robot to treat pediatric victims.

METHODS

In 2008, Los Angeles County held 2 drills involving telemedicine. The first was the Tri-Hospital drill in which 3 Los Angeles County hospitals, one being a pediatric hospital, participated. The disaster scenario involved a Metrolink train crash, resulting in a large surge of traumatic injuries. The second drill involved multiple agencies and was called the Great California Shakeout, a simulated earthquake exercise. The telemedicine equipment installed is an InTouch Health, Inc, Santa Barbara, CA robotic telecommunications system. We used mixed-methods to evaluate the use of telemedicine during these drills.

RESULTS

Pediatric specialists successfully provided remote triage and treatment consults of victims via the robot. The robot proved to be a useful means to extend resources and provide expert consult if pediatric specialists were unable to physically be at the site.

CONCLUSION

Telemedicine can be used in the delayed treatment areas as well as for training first receivers to collaborate with specialists in remote locations to triage and treat seriously injured pediatric victims.

Orthopaedic management in a mega mass casualty situation. The Israel Defence Forces Field Hospital in Haiti following the January 2010 earthquake

Following the January 2010 earthquake in Haiti, the Israel Defence Forces (IDF) established a field hospital in Port au Prince. The hospital started operating 89 h after the earthquake. We describe the experience of the orthopaedic department in a field hospital operating in an extreme mass casualty situation. The hospital contained 4 operating table and 72 hospitalization beds. The orthopaedic department included 8 orthopaedic surgeons and 3 residents. 1111 patients were treated in the hospital, 1041 of them had adequate records for inclusion. 684 patients were admitted due to trauma with a total of 841 injuries. 320 patients sustained 360 fractures, 18 had joint dislocations and 22 patients were admitted after amputations. 207 patients suffered 315 soft tissue injuries. 221 patients were operated on under general or regional anaesthesia. External fixation was used for stabilization of 48 adult femoral shaft fractures, 24 open tibial fractures and 1 open humeral fracture. All none femoral closed fractures were treated non-operatively. 18 joint reductions and 23 amputations were performed. Appropriate planning, training, operational versatility, and adjustment of therapeutic guidelines according to a constantly changing situation, enabled us to deliver optimal care to the maximal number of patients, in an overwhelming mass trauma situation.

Abdominal crush injury in the Sichuan earthquake evaluated by multidetector computed tomography

AIM: To investigate the features of abdominal crush injuries resulting from an earthquake using multidetector computed tomography (MDCT).

METHODS: Fifty-one survivors with abdominal crush injuries due to the 2008 Sichuan earthquake underwent emergency non-enhanced scans with 16-row MDCT. Data were reviewed focusing on anatomic regions including lumbar vertebrae, abdominal wall soft tissue, retroperitoneum and intraperitoneal space; and types of traumatic lesions.

RESULTS: Fractures of lumbar vertebrae and abdominal wall soft tissue injuries were more common than retro- and intraperitoneal injuries (P < 0.05). With regard to the 49 lumbar vertebral fractures in 24 patients, these occurred predominantly in the transverse process (P < 0.05), and 66.67% of patients (16/24) had fractures of multiple vertebrae, predominantly two vertebrae in 62.5% of patients (10/16), mainly in L1-3 vertebrae in 81.63% of the vertebrae (40/49). Retroperitoneal injuries occurred more frequently than intraperitoneal injuries (P < 0.05), and renal and liver injuries were most often seen in the retroperitoneum and in the intraperitoneal space, respectively (all P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION: Transverse process fractures in two vertebrae among L1-3 vertebrae, injury of abdominal wall soft tissue, and renal injury might be features of earthquake-related crush abdominal injury.

Management of musculoskeletal injuries after the 2009 western Sumatra earthquake

PURPOSE

To report injury patterns and management of musculoskeletal injuries after an earthquake.

METHODS

94 male and 161 female patients aged 17 to 90 (mean, 53) years underwent surgery for musculoskeletal injuries. Their injury patterns, anaesthesia administered, surgeries undertaken, and development of postoperative complications were reviewed.

RESULTS

Of the 255 patients, 155 sustained superficial lacerations with minor soft-tissue contusion, whereas 100 sustained injuries that necessitated surgery under anaesthesia. The injuries involved the tibia/ankle (n=90), the hand (n=48), the pelvis/femur (n=41), the radius/ulnar (n=36), the foot (n=20), the humerus (n=10), and the spine (n=10). 30 (12%) of the patients had multiple injuries. The most common procedure performed was debridement (n=58), followed by open reduction and internal fixation with plates and screws for closed fractures (n=20), Kirschner wiring (n=11), external fixation (n=8), and general surgery and others (n=6). Repeated debridements were performed for 19 open fractures; 10 involved the distal tibia. 63 procedures were carried out under anaesthesia or sedation. General anaesthesia involved 2 patients; one had a right hemi-colectomy for an ischaemic bowel and another had an appendicectomy. Regional anaesthesia included sub-arachnoid block for lowerlimb surgeries (n=21), axillary brachial plexus block for upper-limb surgeries (n=11), and femoral and sciatic nerve blocks for a lower-limb surgery (n=1). The remaining 28 procedures involved conscious sedation. The mean number of debridements for open fractures was 2.8 (range, 2-5). The mean followup duration was 10.4 (range, 7-14) days. Only one patient developed a postoperative wound infection.

CONCLUSION

Our team was effective in managing orthopaedic injuries after an earthquake. The postoperative complication rate was low. Regional and spinal anaesthesia are relatively safe alternatives to general anaesthesia when carried out under such austere circumstances. The success of the mission depended on collaboration with the local health care workers and external agencies.

Genitourinary system trauma after 2003 Bam earthquake in Kerman, Iran

Background:

Natural disasters, especially earthquakes, result in many health problems all over the world, of which urological injuries should not be underestimated. Car accidents and falling from a height are the most common causes of genitourinary system injury. The lack of specific data in the literature regarding the outcome of earthquake-related genitourinary system trauma prompted us to undertake this study.

Methods:

We retrospectively evaluated the genitourinary system injury in patients who had survived the Bam earthquake. In this study, all patients admitted to two main back-up hospitals of Kerman were included. Of 256 patients who had been referred to Kerman hospitals, 28 cases were found to have urologic damage on physical examination, intravenous pyelography, abdominopelvic X-ray, and ultrasonography.

Results:

Of 28 patients with urologic damage, 22 (78.5%) were male and six (21.5%) were female. Their age ranged from 18 to 65 years. The injures included urethral disruption in 21 cases (75.5%), vesicovaginal fistula in four cases (14%), kidney rupture in two cases (7%) and bladder neck disruption accompanied with total right ureteral disruption and vesicovaginal fistula in a female patient (3.5%).

Conclusion:

We have evaluated the incidence of genitourinary injuries after an earthquake disaster for the first time. The most and least common urologic injury in our patients was urethral disruption and ureteral injury, respectively.

The Motor Function and Activities of Daily Living Capacity of Seismic Wounded Patients in Intensive Care Unit Ward in 5.12 Wenchuan Earthquake of China

Objective

To describe the motor function and activities of daily living (ADL) functional status of the seismic wounded patients treated in the intensive care unit (ICU) ward, and to provide insight to the planning on their clinical rehabilitation program.

Method

A prospective study. Trained assessor applied different common testing methods to measure the motor functions of seismic wounded patients treated in ICU: (1) Manual Muscle Testing (MMT) method to evaluate muscle strength; (2) joint angle ruler to assess joint range of motion (ROM); (3) passive joint activities to assess the muscle tension; (4) Modified Ashworth Score (MAS) to assess spasm; (5) balanced response to assess sitting balance and standing balance; (6) international generic Barthel Index Scale to evaluate ADL. Complications as related to rehabilitation were also recorded. Descriptive statistics were employed to describe the epidemiology, pattern of motor function loss and type of injuries.

Results

The most common types of injuries in our sample of seismic wounded treated in ICU were: fracture (70%), nervous system injuries (20%), squeezing syndrome (5%) and pulmonary contusion (5%). The fracture proportion was higher in female than male (about 2:1). Amputation and paralysis occurred more in male than female (about 7:1 and 3:1 respectively). Lung infection as a complication in ICU stay was more common in female than male (4:1). We reported that most of the seismic wounded patient had early loss of motor function during the stay in ICU. Conclusion: Limited ROM, declined muscle strength, abnormal muscle tension, balance dysfunction, alteration of ADL capacity and lung infection are the main dysfunctions occurring among the seismic wounded in ICU ward. Loss of motor function can occur early and therefore active physiotherapy should start even during the stay in ICU.

Earthquake-related crush injury versus non-earthquake injury in abdominal trauma patients on emergency multidetector computed tomography: a comparative study

The aim of this study was to investigate features of abdominal earthquake-related crush traumas in comparison with non-earthquake injury. A cross sectional survey was conducted with 51 survivors with abdominal crush injury in the 2008 Sichuan earthquake, and 41 with abdominal non-earthquake injury, undergoing non-enhanced computed tomography (CT) scans, serving as earthquake trauma and control group, respectively. Data were analyzed between groups focusing on CT appearance. We found that injury of abdominal-wall soft tissue and fractures of lumbar vertebrae were more common in earthquake trauma group than in control group (28 vs 13 victims, and 24 vs 9, respectively; all P < 0.05); and fractures were predominantly in transverse process of 1-2 vertebrae among L1-3 vertebrae. Retroperitoneal injury in the kidney occurred more frequently in earthquake trauma group than in control group (29 vs 14 victims, P < 0.05). Abdominal injury in combination with thoracic and pelvic injury occurred more frequently in earthquake trauma group than in control group (43 vs 29 victims, P < 0.05). In conclusion, abdominal earthquake-related crush injury might be characteristic of high incidence in injury of abdominal-wall soft tissue, fractures of lumbar vertebrae in transverse process of 1-2 vertebrae among L1-3 vertebrae, retroperitoneal injury in the kidney, and in combination with injury in the thorax and pelvis.

[Trauma surgery catastrophe aid following the earthquake in Haiti 2010--a report on experiences: injury patterns, special challenges, prospects]

The earthquake in Haiti in January 2010 resulted in more than 220,000 deaths and over 300,000 injured and was one of the greatest mass casualties in recent history. "Doctors Without Borders" started a medical relief response immediately after the earthquake, building up to the biggest disaster relief activity in the organization's history. Roughly 173,000 medical consultations and more than 11,700 surgical interventions were performed in 26 medical facilities during the first 4 months. A particular challenge was the sheer number of patients in a situation with a completely destroyed medical infrastructure. While the initial phase mainly focused on life saving surgery, the second phase concentrated on reconstructive surgery of the extremities. Crucial for effective patient care is an ability to act early and employ surgical techniques which are adapted to the overall situation. The following article is a personal report of the early emergency response from the viewpoint of two orthopedic trauma surgeons, who have surgical careers in Germany and also frequently volunteer for "Doctors Without Borders".

Anaesthetic management under field conditions after the 12 May 2008 earthquake in Wenchuan, China

OBJECTIVE

To summarise our experiences of anaesthetic management under field conditions after the Wenchuan earthquake, China, on 12 May 2008.

METHODS

Medical records of earthquake victims who received emergency operations under anaesthetic techniques in our field hospital were retrospectively analysed, including patient's demographic data, injury types, surgical procedures, anaesthetic techniques and perioperative care.

RESULTS

Among the 111 patients who required anaesthesia, the eldest was 81 years old, and the youngest was 5 months old. The methods of anaesthesia included general anaesthesia (19 cases), intrathecal anaesthesia (40 cases), monitored anaesthesia care (41 cases) and brachial plexus block (11 cases). Most of the patients were stable and safe during intra- and postoperative period, including successful resuscitation of two newborns, no major complications occurred.

CONCLUSIONS

Earthquake-related injuries are complex. In view of dehydration, hypovolaemia and crush injury are common in earthquake victims, it is essential to perform adequate fluid therapy preoperatively, to ensure safety and reduce complications. Monitored anaesthesia care and regional anaesthesia are highly suitable for anaesthesia under field conditions, they are safe and efficacious. General anaesthesia also can be performed to avail the prompt treatment for the severe injuries in a well-equipped deployable field hospital nowadays. Appropriate anaesthetic management can improve the outcomes to a great extent and is an important component of medical assistance after disasters.

The October 2005 earthquake in Northern Pakistan: patterns of injuries in victims brought to the Emergency Relief Hospital, Doraha, Mansehra

OBJECTIVE

Knowledge of injuries of earthquake victims is important to plan relief efforts. This cross-sectional study was conducted following the 08 October 2005 earthquake in Northern Pakistan to determine the pattern of injuries sustained and their relationship with age and gender in order to identify the medical needs in an earthquake-affected zone.

METHODS

The study was conducted between 13 October and 23 October 2005 at the Emergency Relief Hospital, Doraha, Mansehra. From the 1,700 patients registered in the hospital, 310 were sampled randomly for the study. Demography and details of the patients' injuries were noted by history and physical examination. Twelve cases were omitted due to incomplete data.

RESULTS

Of the cases, 54% were female. Children less than or equal to 10 years old formed the largest age group. Isolated bone injuries were present in 41%, soft tissue injuries in 36%, and mixed injuries in 23% of the patients. The most common bone injury was lower limb fracture (52%), while the most common non-bone injury was non-infected, soft tissue wounds on the limbs (33%). Among patients with soft tissue injuries, gangrenous wounds were present in 9%, and grossly infected wounds in 30% (20% on limbs and 10% on rest of the body).

CONCLUSIONS

The population injured during the earthquake showed a higher proportion of females and children less than or equal to 10 years old, and lower limb bone injuries. The data highlight the need to address orthopedic, pediatric, and women's health issues, and for logistic arrangement of relevant diagnostic and therapeutic facilities at the initial stages of relief activities after earthquakes.

Crush extremity fractures associated with the 2008 Sichuan earthquake: anatomic sites, numbers and statuses evaluated with digital radiography and multidetector computed tomography

OBJECTIVE

To investigate features of crush extremity fractures associated with massive earthquake on digital radiography (DR) and multidetector computed tomography (MDCT).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Six hundred and twenty-three consecutive patients with clinically confirmed crush extremity fractures arising from the 2008 Sichuan earthquake were enrolled into our study. Six hundred and eleven patients with suggested extremity fractures underwent DR, and 12 patients with possible knee fractures underwent MDCT. Image data were retrospectively reviewed, with the focus on anatomic sites, numbers, and status of the fractures.

RESULTS

Extremity fractures occurred in lower extremities in 428 patients, upper extremities in 151, and both lower and upper extremities in 44. Lower extremity fractures were more common than upper extremity fractures (P < 0.05), and the commonly involved bones were the tibia and fibula in 141 patients, femur in 102, tibia in 52, and fibula in 40. According to the numbers of bones involved, multiple bone fractures occurred in 336 patients and included lower extremity fractures in 231, upper extremity fractures in 61, and both lower and upper fractures in 44. Multiple fractures in lower extremities were seen more often than in upper extremities (P < 0.05). As for status of the extremity fractures, comminuted fractures occurred in 324 patients and included lower extremity fractures in 248, upper extremity fractures in 51, and both lower and upper extremity fractures in 25. Comminuted fractures were more common in lower extremities than in upper extremities (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Multiple and comminuted fractures, predominantly in the lower extremities, could be considered as features of crush extremity fractures associated with the massive Sichuan earthquake.

Dentists' role in treating facial injuries sustained in the 2008 earthquake in China: how dental professionals can contribute to emergency response

BACKGROUND

A major earthquake struck Sichuan province, China, on May 12, 2008, and the authors were involved in the medical response to the disaster in Jiangyou City, an area hard-hit by the quake. In this article, they analyze data about the earthquake-related facial injuries and assess dentistry's role in treating them.

METHODS

This descriptive study included review of medical records for 4,582 patients with earthquake-related trauma at eight hospitals in Jiangyou, a city severely affected by the earthquake, for the day of the disaster and the 14 days immediately afterward.

RESULTS

Of the 4,582 patients, 408 (8.9 percent) sustained a total of 482 facial injuries. The dental team treated patients with facial injuries and others who needed care.

CONCLUSIONS

Facial injuries constitute a significant portion of earthquake-related trauma, and dentists therefore are an important part of the medical team that deals with such trauma. Dentists are a reliable force in the medical response to earthquakes and other disasters.

CLINICAL IMPLICATIONS

The dental team should play an important role in disaster response. Establishing oral and maxillofacial surgeon (OMS)/dentist reserves and active leagues that use OMSs' and general dentists' offices as bases can help improve disaster response.

Role of Selective Management of Penetrating Injuries in Mass Casualty Incidents

Terrorist violence has emerged as an increasingly common cause of mass casualty incidents (MCI) due to the sequelae of explosive devices and shooting massacres. A proper emergency medical system disaster plan for dealing with an MCI is of paramount importance to salvage lives. Because the number of casualties following a MCI is likely to exceed the medical resources of the receiving health care facilities, patients must be appropriately sorted to establish treatment priorities. By necessity, clinical signs are likely to prove cornerstones of triage during MCI. An appropriate and effective application of experiences learned from the use of selective nonoperative management (SNOM) techniques may prove essential in this triage process. The present appraisal of the available literature strongly supports that the appropriate utilization of these clinical indicators to identify patients appropriate for SNOM is essential, critical, and readily applicable. We also review the initial emergent triage priorities for penetrating injuries to the head, neck, torso, and extremities in a mass casualty setting.

The Needs of Children in Natural or Manmade Disasters

Disasters have been described as “events of sufficient scale, asset depletion, or numbers of victims to overwhelm medical resources” [1] or as “a serious disruption of the functioning of a community or a society causing widespread human, material, economic or environmental losses that exceed the ability of the affected community or society to cope using its own resources” [2]. Importantly, that definition goes on to state: “A disaster is a function of the risk process. It results from the combination of hazards, conditions of vulnerability and insufficient capacity or measures to reduce the potential negative consequences of risk.”