Structural and functional analysis of the C-terminal cytoplasmic domain of FlhA, an integral membrane component of the type III flagellar protein export apparatus in Salmonella

Role of a conserved prolyl residue (Pro173) of MotA in the mechanochemical reaction cycle of the proton-driven flagellar motor of Salmonella

The MotA/B complex acts as the stator of the proton-driven bacterial flagellar motor. Proton translocation through the stator complex is efficiently coupled with torque generation by the stator-rotor interactions. In Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium, the highly conserved Pro173 residue of MotA is close to the absolutely conserved Asp33 residue of MotB, which is believed to be a proton-binding site. Pro173 is postulated to be involved in coupling proton influx to torque generation. However, it remains unknown what critical function Pro173 carries out. Here, we characterize the motility and the torque-speed relation of the flagellar motor of the slow motile motA(P173A) mutant of Salmonella. Stall torque produced by the mutant motor was at the wild-type level, indicating that neither the number of stators in the motor nor the rotor-stator interaction is affected by the P173A substitution. In agreement with this, the motA(P173A) allele exerted a strong dominant-negative effect on wild-type motility. In contrast, high-speed rotation at low load was significantly impaired by the mutation, suggesting that the maximum rate of torque generation cycle is severely limited. Simulation of the torque-speed curve by a simple kinetic model indicated that the mutation reduces the rate of conformational changes of the MotA/B complex that switches the exposure of Asp33 to the outside and the inside of the cell, thereby slowing down the mechanochemical reaction cycle. Based on these results, we propose that Pro173 plays an important role in facilitating the conformational dynamics of the stator complex for rapid proton translocation and torque generation cycle.

ATP-induced FliI hexamerization facilitates bacterial flagellar protein export

FliI ATPase forms a homo-hexamer to fully exert its ATPase activity, facilitating bacterial flagellar protein export. However, it remains unknown how FliI hexamerization is linked to protein export. Here, we analyzed the capability of ring formation by FliI and its catalytic mutant variants. Compared to ATP a non-hydrolysable ATP analog increased the probability of FliI hexamerization. In contrast, FliI(E221Q), which retained the affinity for ATP but has lost ATPase activity, efficiently formed the hexamer even in the presence of ATP. The mutations, which reduced the binding affinity for ATP, significantly abolished the ring formation. These results indicate that ATP-binding induces FliI hexamerization and that the release of ADP and Pi destabilizes the ring structure. FliI(E221Q) facilitated flagellar protein export in the absence of the FliH regulator of the export apparatus although not at the wild-type FliI level while the other did not. We propose that FliI couples ATP binding and hydrolysis to its assembly-disassembly cycle to efficiently initiate the flagellar protein export cycle.

Mutations in flk, flgG, flhA, and flhE that affect the flagellar type III secretion specificity switch in Salmonella enterica

Upon completion of the flagellar hook-basal body (HBB) structure, the flagellar type III secretion system switches from secreting rod/hook-type to filament-type substrates. The secretion specificity switch has been reported to occur prematurely (prior to HBB completion) in flk-null mutants (P. Aldridge, J. E. Karlinsey, E. Becker, F. F. Chevance, and K. T. Hughes, Mol. Microbiol. 60:630-643, 2006) and in distal rod gene gain-of-function mutants (flgG* mutants) that produce filamentous rod structures (F. F. Chevance, N. Takahashi, J. E. Karlinsey, J. Gnerer, T. Hirano, R. Samudrala, S. Aizawa, and K. T. Hughes, Genes Dev. 21:2326-2335, 2007). A fusion of beta-lactamase (Bla) to the C terminus of the filament-type secretion substrate FlgM was used to select for mutants that would secrete FlgM-Bla into the periplasmic space and show ampicillin resistance (Ap(r)). Ap(r) resulted from null mutations in the flhE gene, C-terminal truncation mutations in the flhA gene, null and dominant mutations in the flk gene, and flgG* mutations. All mutant classes required the hook length control protein (FliK) and the rod cap protein (FlgJ) for the secretion specificity switch to occur. However, neither the hook (FlgE) nor the hook cap (FlgD) protein was required for premature FlgM-Bla secretion in the flgG* and flk mutant strains, but it was in the flhE mutants. Unexpectedly, when deletions of either flgE or flgD were introduced into flgG* mutant strains, filaments were able to grow directly on the filamentous rod structures.

Mechanisms of type III protein export for bacterial flagellar assembly

Flagellar type III protein export is highly organized and well controlled in a timely manner by dynamic, specific and cooperative interactions among components of the export apparatus, allowing the huge and complex macromolecular assembly to be built efficiently. The bacterial flagellum, which is required for motility, consists of a rotary motor, a universal joint and a helical propeller. Most of the flagellar components are translocated to the distal, growing end of the flagellum for assembly through the central channel of the flagellum itself by the flagellar type III protein export apparatus, which is postulated to be located on the cytoplasmic side of the flagellar basal body. The export specificity switching machinery, which consists of at least two proteins that function as a molecular ruler and an export switch, respectively, monitors the state of hook-basal body assembly in the cell exterior and switches export specificity, thereby coupling sequential flagellar gene expression with the flagellar assembly process. The export ATPase complex composed of an ATPase and its regulator acts as a pilot to deliver its export substrate to the export gate and helps initial entry of the substrate N-terminal chain into a narrow pore of the export gate. The energy of ATP hydrolysis appears to be used to disassemble and release the ATPase complex from the protein about to be exported, and the rest of the successive unfolding/translocation process of the long polypeptide chain is driven solely by proton motive force (PMF), perhaps through biased one-dimensional Brownian diffusion. Interestingly, the subunits of the ATPase complex have significant sequence similarities to subunits of F(0)F(1)-ATP synthase, a rotary motor that drives the chemical reaction of ATP synthesis using PMF, and the entire crystal structure of the export ATPase is extremely similar to the alpha/beta subunits of F(0)F(1)-ATP synthase, suggesting that the flagellar export apparatus and F(0)F(1)-ATP synthase share the mechanism for their two distinct functions.

Suppressor analysis of the MotB(D33E) mutation to probe bacterial flagellar motor dynamics coupled with proton translocation

MotA and MotB form the stator of the proton-driven bacterial flagellar motor, which conducts protons and couples proton flow with motor rotation. Asp-33 of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium MotB, which is a putative proton-binding site, is critical for torque generation. However, the mechanism of energy coupling remains unknown. Here, we carried out genetic and motility analysis of a slowly motile motB(D33E) mutant and its pseudorevertants. We first confirmed that the poor motility of the motB(D33E) mutant is due to neither protein instability, mislocalization, nor impaired interaction with MotA. We isolated 17 pseudorevertants and identified the suppressor mutations in the transmembrane helices TM2 and TM3 of MotA and in TM and the periplasmic domain of MotB. The stall torque produced by the motB(D33E) mutant motor was about half of the wild-type level, while those for the pseudorevertants were recovered nearly to the wild-type levels. However, the high-speed rotations of the motors under low-load conditions were still significantly impaired, suggesting that the rate of proton translocation is still severely limited at high speed. These results suggest that the second-site mutations recover a torque generation step involving stator-rotor interactions coupled with protonation/deprotonation of Glu-33 but not maximum proton conductivity.

Coordinating assembly of a bacterial macromolecular machine

The assembly of large and complex organelles, such as the bacterial flagellum, poses the formidable problem of coupling temporal gene expression to specific stages of the organelle-assembly process. The discovery that levels of the bacterial flagellar regulatory protein FlgM are controlled by its secretion from the cell in response to the completion of an intermediate flagellar structure (the hook-basal body) was only the first of several discoveries of unique mechanisms that coordinate flagellar gene expression with assembly. In this Review, we discuss this mechanism, together with others that also coordinate gene regulation and flagellar assembly in Gram-negative bacteria.

Coordinating assembly of a bacterial macromolecular machine

The assembly of large and complex organelles, such as the bacterial flagellum, poses the formidable problem of coupling temporal gene expression to specific stages of the organelle-assembly process. The discovery that levels of the bacterial flagellar regulatory protein FlgM are controlled by its secretion from the cell in response to the completion of an intermediate flagellar structure (the hook-basal body) was only the first of several discoveries of unique mechanisms that coordinate flagellar gene expression with assembly. In this Review, we discuss this mechanism, together with others that also coordinate gene regulation and flagellar assembly in Gram-negative bacteria.

Characterization of the periplasmic domain of MotB and implications for its role in the stator assembly of the bacterial flagellar motor

MotA and MotB are integral membrane proteins that form the stator complex of the proton-driven bacterial flagellar motor. The stator complex functions as a proton channel and couples proton flow with torque generation. The stator must be anchored to an appropriate place on the motor, and this is believed to occur through a putative peptidoglycan-binding (PGB) motif within the C-terminal periplasmic domain of MotB. In this study, we constructed and characterized an N-terminally truncated variant of Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium MotB consisting of residues 78 through 309 (MotB(C)). MotB(C) significantly inhibited the motility of wild-type cells when exported into the periplasm. Some point mutations in the PGB motif enhanced the motility inhibition, while an in-frame deletion variant, MotB(C)(Delta197-210), showed a significantly reduced inhibitory effect. Wild-type MotB(C) and its point mutant variants formed a stable homodimer, while the deletion variant was monomeric. A small amount of MotB was coisolated only with the secreted form of MotB(C)-His(6) by Ni-nitrilotriacetic acid affinity chromatography, suggesting that the motility inhibition results from MotB-MotB(C) heterodimer formation in the periplasm. However, the monomeric mutant variant MotB(C)(Delta197-210) did not bind to MotB, suggesting that MotB(C) is directly involved in stator assembly. We propose that the MotB(C) dimer domain plays an important role in targeting and stable anchoring of the MotA/MotB complex to putative stator-binding sites of the motor.

From The Origin of Species to the origin of bacterial flagella

In the recent Dover trial, and elsewhere, the 'Intelligent Design' movement has championed the bacterial flagellum as an irreducibly complex system that, it is claimed, could not have evolved through natural selection. Here we explore the arguments in favour of viewing bacterial flagella as evolved, rather than designed, entities. We dismiss the need for any great conceptual leaps in creating a model of flagellar evolution and speculate as to how an experimental programme focused on this topic might look.

Oligomerization of the bacterial flagellar ATPase FliI is controlled by its extreme N-terminal region

Salmonella FliI is the flagellar ATPase which converts the energy of ATP hydrolysis into the export of flagellar proteins. It forms a ring-shaped oligomer in the presence of ATP, its analogs, or phospholipids. The extreme N-terminal region of FliI has an unstable conformation and is responsible for the interaction with other components of the export apparatus and for regulation of the catalytic mechanism. To understand the role of this N-terminal region in more detail, we used multi-angle light-scattering, analytical ultracentrifugation, far-UV CD and biochemical methods to characterize a partially functional variant of FliI, missing its first seven amino acid residues (His-FliI(Delta1-7)), whose ATPase activity is about ten times lower than that of wild-type FliI. His-FliI(Delta1-7) is monomeric in solution. The deletion increased the content of alpha-helix, suggesting that the deletion stabilizes the unstable N-terminal region into an alpha-helical conformation. The deletion did not influence the K(m) value for ATP. However, unlike the wild-type, ATP and acidic phospholipids did not induce oligomerization of His-FliI(Delta1-7) or increase its ATPase activity. These results suggest that the deletion suppresses the oligomerization of FliI, and that a conformational change in the unstable N-terminal region is required for FliI oligomerization to effectively couple the energy of ATP hydrolysis to the translocation of flagellar proteins.

Crystallization and preliminary X-ray analysis of the C-terminal cytoplasmic domain of FlhA, a membrane-protein subunit of the bacterial flagellar type III protein-export apparatus

The axial components of the bacterial flagellum and the scaffolding proteins for its assembly are exported through the flagellar-specific type III protein-export apparatus, which is believed to be located on the cytoplasmic surface of the basal body. FlhA is an essential component of the type III export apparatus of Salmonella and consists of two major portions: an N-terminal transmembrane domain and a C-terminal cytoplasmic domain (FlhAC). FlhAC and a 38 kDa fragment of FlhAC (FlhAC38K) were purified and crystallized. The crystals were obtained by the sitting-drop vapour-diffusion technique with PEG 8000 as a precipitant. FlhAC crystals grew in the tetragonal space group I4(1)/I4(3), with unit-cell parameters a = b = 216.6, c = 65.0 A. FlhAC38K was crystallized in an orthorhombic form, with unit-cell parameters a = 53.0, b = 93.1, c = 186.5 A. X-ray diffraction data from crystals of FlhAC and the SeMet derivative of FlhAC were collected to 2.9 and 3.2 A, respectively.

Analysis of the cytoplasmic domains of Salmonella FlhA and interactions with components of the flagellar export machinery

Most flagellar proteins are exported via a type III export apparatus which, in part, consists of the membrane proteins FlhA, FlhB, FliO, FliP, FliQ, and FliR and is housed within the membrane-supramembrane ring formed by FliF subunits. Salmonella FlhA is a 692-residue integral membrane protein with eight predicted transmembrane spans. Its function is not understood, but it is necessary for flagellar export. We have created mutants in which potentially important sequences were deleted. FlhA lacking the amino-terminal sequence prior to the first transmembrane span failed to complement and was dominant negative, suggesting that the sequence is required for function. Similar effects were seen in a variant lacking a highly conserved domain (FHIPEP) within a putative cytoplasmic loop. Scanning deletion analysis of the cytoplasmic domain (FlhAc) demonstrated that substantially all of FlhAc is required for efficient function. Affinity blotting showed that FlhA interacts with several other export apparatus membrane proteins. The implications of these findings are discussed, and a model of FlhA within the export apparatus is presented.