Discriminating small molecule DNA binding modes by single molecule force spectroscopy

Progressing single biomolecule force spectroscopy measurements for the screening of DNA binding agents

Recent studies have indicated that the force-extension properties of single molecules of double stranded (ds) DNA are sensitive to the presence of small molecule DNA binding agents, and also to their mode of binding. These observations raise the possibility of using this approach as a highly sensitive tool for the screening of such agents. However, particularly for studies employing the atomic force microscope (AFM), several non-trivial barriers hinder the progress of this approach to the non-specialist arena and hence also the full realization of this possibility. In this paper, we therefore address a series of key reproducibility and metrological issues associated with this type of measurement. Specifically, we present an improved immobilization method that covalently anchors one end (5' end) of a dual labelled (5'-thiol, 3'-biotin) p53 DNA molecule onto a gold substrate via gold-thiol chemistry, whilst the biotinylated 3' end is available for 'pick-up' using a streptavidin modified AFM tip. We also show that co-surface immobilization of DNA with 6-mercapto-1-hexanol (MCH) can also lead to a further increase the measured contour length. We demonstrate the impact of these improved protocols through the observation of the cooperative transition plateau in a DNA fragment of approximately 118 bp, a significantly smaller fragment than previously investigated. The results of a comparative study of the effects of a model minor groove binder (Hoechst 33258) and an intercalating drug (proflavine), alone, as a mixture and under different buffer conditions, are also presented.

Simultaneous AFM Manipulation and Fluorescence Imaging of Single DNA Strands

We report combined atomic force and far-field fluorescence microscopic experiments which allow the simultaneous atomic force manipulation and optical observation of individual dye-labeled DNA molecules. A detailed understanding of the binding properties of DNA to different transparent surfaces is prerequisite for these investigations. Atomic force spectroscopy and fluorescence microscopy of single DNA strands yielded detailed insight into two different types of DNA binding onto transparent polylysine-coated and silanized glass surfaces. We subsequently demonstrate how the different binding can be exploited to perform two types of nanomanipulation experiments: On polylysine, strong electrostatic interactions over the whole length of the DNA strand enable the writing of micrometer-sized patterns. By contrast, the strong pointwise attachment of DNA to silanized surfaces allows horizontal stretching of single DNA strands to lengths exceeding 1.6 times the contour length of the DNA strand. With this new approach it is possible to directly observe the rupture of the strongly bonded DNA strand.

Single-molecule investigations of RNA dissociation

Given the essential cellular roles for ribonucleic acids (RNAs) it is important to understand the stability of three-dimensional structures formed by these molecules. This study aims to investigate the dissociation energy landscape for simple RNA structures via atomic-force-microscopy-based single-molecule force-spectroscopy measurements. This approach provides details on the locations and relative heights of the energy barriers to dissociation, and thus information upon the relative kinetic stabilities of the formed complexes. Our results indicate that a simple dodecamer RNA helix undergoes a forced dissociation process similar to that previously observed for DNA oligonucleotides. Incorporating a UCU bulge motif is found to introduce an additional energy barrier closer to the bound state, and also to destabilize the duplex. In the absence of magnesium ions a duplex containing this UCU bulge is destabilized and a single, shorter duplex is formed. These results reveal that a bulge motif impacts upon the forced dissociation of RNA and produces an energy landscape sensitive to the presence of magnesium ions. Interestingly, the obtained data compare well with previously reported ensemble measurements, illustrating the potential of this approach to improve our understanding of RNA stability and dissociation kinetics.

Atomic force microscopy imaging and pulling of nucleic acids

Recent advances in atomic force microscopy (AFM) imaging of nucleic acids include the visualization of DNA and RNA incorporated into devices and patterns, and into structures based on their sequences or sequence recognition. AFM imaging of nuclear structures has contributed to advances in telomere research and to our understanding of nucleosome formation. Highlights of force spectroscopy or pulling of nucleic acids include the use of DNA as a programmable force sensor, and the analysis of RNA flexibility and drug binding to DNA.

Molecular mechanisms and kinetics between DNA and DNA binding ligands

Mechanical properties of single double-stranded DNA (dsDNA) in the presence of different binding ligands were analyzed in optical-tweezers experiments with subpiconewton force resolution. The binding of ligands to DNA changes the overall mechanic response of the dsDNA molecule. This fundamental property can be used for discrimination and identification of different binding modes and, furthermore, may be relevant for various processes like nucleosome packing or applications like cancer therapy. We compared the effects of the minor groove binder distamycin-A, a major groove binding alpha-helical peptide, the intercalators ethidium bromide, YO-1, and daunomycin as well as the bisintercalator YOYO-1 on lambda-DNA. Binding of molecules to the minor and major groove of dsDNA induces distinct changes in the molecular elasticity compared to the free dsDNA detectable as a shift of the overstretching transition to higher forces. Intercalating molecules affect the molecular mechanics by a complete disappearance of the B-S transition and an associated increase in molecular contour length. Significant force hysteresis effects occurring during stretching/relaxation cycles with velocities >10 nm/s for YOYO-1 and >1000 nm/s for daunomycin. These indicate structural changes in the timescale of minutes for the YOYO-DNA and of seconds for the daunomycin-DNA complexes, respectively.

Single-Molecule Techniques for Drug Discovery

Single-molecule techniques offer a number of key benefits over conventional in vitro assay methods for drug screening, as they use less material and unlock the ability to observe transient states. By observing such states, it should be possible to screen for chemical compounds that isolate these steps. The benefit of this is twofold: (a) inhibitors can be found that target key phases in biochemical processes, e.g., transcription initiation; and (b) the total number of drug targets increases as many biochemical processes consist of many transient steps, e.g., transcription promoter binding, initiation, elongation, and termination. Although single-molecule methods offer exciting opportunities for new ways of discovering drugs, there are a number of obstacles to their adoption for drug screening. The main hurdle is to develop robust apparatus that will allow many thousands of individual single molecule experiments to be performed in parallel. By using recently developed integrated microfluidics technology, this hurdle may be overcome. Here, a number of potential single-molecule approaches to drug screening are presented along with a discussion of the benefits and technical obstacles that must be overcome.

Single molecule force spectroscopy on ligand–DNA complexes: from molecular binding mechanisms to biosensor applications

Recent developments in single molecule force spectroscopy (SMFS) allow direct observation and measurements of forces that hold protein-DNA complexes together. Furthermore, the mechanics of double-stranded (ds) DNA molecules in the presence of small binding ligands can be detected. The results elucidate molecular binding mechanisms and open the way for ultra sensitive and powerful biosensor applications.

Plastic Tip Arrays for Force Spectroscopy

The mechanical stability and viability of molecules investigated with the atomic force microscope (AFM) continue to be limiting factors in the duration of force spectroscopy measurements. In an effort to circumvent this problem, we have fabricated an all-plastic array of over 30 000 tips with dimensions similar to common AFM probes using silicon micromolding techniques. This approach enables rapid fabrication of tip arrays with improved properties, as compared to tip arrays made entirely of silicon.

Atomic force microscopy studies on DNA structural changes induced by vincristine sulfate and aspirin

We report that atomic force microscopy (AFM) studies on structural variations of a linear plasmid DNA interact with various concentrations of vincristine sulfate and aspirin. The different binding images show that vincrinstine sulfate binding DNA chains caused some loops and cleavages of the DNA fragments, whereas aspirin interaction caused the width changes and conformational transition of the DNA fragments. Two different DNA structural alternations could be explained by the different mechanisms of the interactions with these two components. Our work indicates that the AFM is a powerful tool in studying the interaction between DNA and small molecules.

An overview of the biophysical applications of atomic force microscopy

The potentialities of the atomic force microscopy (AFM) make it a tool of undeniable value for the study of biologically relevant samples. AFM is progressively becoming a usual benchtop technique. In average, more than one paper is published every day on AFM biological applications. This figure overcomes materials science applications, showing that 17 years after its invention, AFM has completely crossed the limits of its traditional areas of application. Its potential to image the structure of biomolecules or bio-surfaces with molecular or even sub-molecular resolution, study samples under physiological conditions (which allows to follow in situ the real time dynamics of some biological events), measure local chemical, physical and mechanical properties of a sample and manipulate single molecules should be emphasized.

Atomic force microscopy and drug discovery

Atomic force microscopy is being used ever more widely in biological imaging, because of its unique ability to provide structural information at the single molecule level and under near-physiological conditions. Detailed topographic images of potential drug targets, such as proteins and DNA, have been produced, and the folding of modular proteins has been studied using single-molecule force spectroscopy. Recently, atomic force microscopy has been used to examine ligand-protein and ligand-DNA interactions, and to begin to determine the architecture of multi-subunit proteins, including a member of the superfamily of ionotropic receptors. Atomic force microscopy is fast becoming a valuable addition to the pharmaceutical industry's toolkit.

Identification of binding mechanisms in single molecule-DNA complexes

Changes in the elastic properties of single deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) molecules in the presence of different DNA-binding agents are identified using atomic force microscope single molecule force spectroscopy. We investigated the binding of poly(dG-dC) dsDNA with the minor groove binder distamycin A, two supposed major groove binders, an alpha-helical and a 3(10)-helical peptide, the intercalants daunomycin, ethidium bromide and YO, and the bis-intercalant YOYO. Characteristic mechanical fingerprints in the overstretching behavior of the studied single DNA-ligand complexes were observed allowing the distinction between different binding modes. Docking of ligands to the minor or major groove of DNA has the effect that the intramolecular B-S transition remains visible as a distinct plateau in the force-extension trace. By contrast, intercalation of small molecules into the double helix is characterized by the vanishing of the B-S plateau. These findings lead to the conclusion that atomic force microscope force spectroscopy can be regarded as a single molecule biosensor and is a potent tool for the characterization of binding motives of small ligands to DNA.

Force spectroscopy of single DNA and RNA molecules

Experiments in which single molecules of RNA and DNA are stretched, and the resulting force as a function of extension is measured have yielded new information about the physical, chemical and biological properties of these important molecules. The behavior of both single-stranded and double-stranded nucleic acids under changing solution conditions, such as ionic strength, pH and temperature, has been studied in detail. There has also been progress in using these techniques to study both the kinetics and equilibrium thermodynamics of DNA-protein interactions. These studies generate unique insights into the functions of these proteins in the cell.